Beef Ban Debate - The Newshour Debate: Beef ban row (7th April 2015)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 29. 08. 2024
  • In a debate moderated by TIMES NOW's Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami, panelists -- Sanjay Jha, Spokesperson, Congress; Rahul Narvekar, Spokesperson & MLC, NCP; Saba Naqvi, Political Editor, Outlook; Dr Sudhanshu Trivedi, National Spokesperson, BJP & Political Advisor to Rajnath Singh; Dr Manisha Kayande, Spokesperson, Shiv Sena; Adv Sanjeev Punalekar, Speaker & Advisor, Sanatan Sanstha; and Asaduddin Owaisi, President & MP, Lok Sabha, AIMIM -- discuss the issue of Maharashtra CM clarifying that slaughter ban is only on cows, and not for other meat, and whether the Fadnavis retracted under pressure.
    Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis today (Apriul 7, 2015) sought to defuse the row over the statement of the state Advocate General on cow slaughter ban, saying the beef ban will not be extended to any other meat. As the purported remarks by Advocate General Sunil Manohar before the Mumbai High Court that the government might consider extending the ban to other animals as well triggered a controversy, Fadnavis said that according to the law officer his statement was "misinterpreted". "I have spoken to Advocate General. He has said that his statement in the court yesterday has been isinterpreted," Fadnavis said in the state Assembly. The Chief Minister's remarks came in the wake of the AG's response to the high court's query to the government as to why there is ban on slaughter of cows, bulls and bullocks only and not to any other animals like goats. Raising the issue in the House, members from BJP ally Shiv Sena, Arjun Khotkar and Sunil Prabhu, sought to know the state's stand on the high court's query to the government. Earlier, Sunil Prabhu (Sena) said the AG's statement had created confusion in the minds of people. The beef ban has already sparked protests from political and cultural groups, alleging it amounted to encroachment on individual choices and eating habits of large sections of people, especially the minority communities. Chaotic scenes were witnessed in the state Legislative Council, as Opposition and Shiv Sena members opposed the AG's statement.
    Subscribe Now To Our Network Channels
    The NewsHour Debate : goo.gl/LfNgFF
    ET Now : goo.gl/5XreUq
    Times Now : goo.gl/U9ibPb
    Social Media Links :-
    Twitter - goo.gl/FzJIpz
    Facebook - goo.gl/CC7rGc
    G+ - goo.gl/O1iEp5
    Also visit our website - goo.gl/XPUXe8

Komentáře • 1,7K

  • @mgtm
    @mgtm Před 8 lety +133

    Thank god the Southern states and North Eastern states are free of such idiotic beef debates. We eat what we want.

    • @rahulkashelkar5493
      @rahulkashelkar5493 Před 5 lety +6

      Goutham M what about dog meat I support people who eat dog meat I am against dog meat ban

    • @tytoalba3333
      @tytoalba3333 Před 5 lety +2

      Same in West Bengal

    • @zawmcarpenter305
      @zawmcarpenter305 Před 5 lety

      That the way to go!😁👍

    • @ritwikraj9
      @ritwikraj9 Před 5 lety +4

      @@rahulkashelkar5493 eat whatever you want to

  • @santasingh7738
    @santasingh7738 Před 9 lety +437

    watching this debate while enjoying a beef sandwich.

    • @madhumk1981
      @madhumk1981 Před 9 lety +7

      Santa Singh please Go thru please One of our reserach scientist shared this Humans are developed & evolved to escape arms race of evolution be a consciously evolved Human. Modern metaphysical science coming to same conclusion as ancient wisdom suggests.Understand Arms race of evolution the depth Science understand science in subjective manner & not objective, disintegrated, commercialized Science understand How and why mutations occur everyone & everything is connected your known or unknown action can harm other or bring good.Nothing goes unaccounted . Barbarians or any race or community say our Law is to eat Human meat now you tell why control them why ban or take their Law, Rights & impose our views on their diet after all food is matter of choice. You are hypocrite you are Anti Human they say. Fact : Did you know there are people who drink human blood esp babies for trying to Stay Young and sacrifice ppl they are and were in every civilization country too. wish they don't visit you .. Good that society is not in hands of careless shudra who says Lets Exploit Eat Live Work and Die . brahmins are brahmins brain trusted Khastriya take care and bring those Ideals into society so that vaishya & careless shudra like millions eat live work die so now Gov knows what to do ‪#BANBEEF. So common people you need not to worry.Let Gov do as per science.The cause of micro evolution of viruses which are rising their arms inside your body and animals body Humans and animals are slaves of those microbes.why virus evolve as ebola H1N1 HIV few to name.Why are they rising their arms . so leave it to science Follow modern Research data stay disease free & let others live & leave disease free.We don't want bacteria's in Cows and viruses to rise their Arms...Eat for necessity Like animals do.Live in symbiotic Earthly condition Food for life & need not for extravaganza & taste.A True brahmin is one who stays 1 meal a day and caste is not by birth.He Lives for others.If Cows Develop Antibiotic viruses Whole world will be in great loss and will face further consequences Organic farming will be collapsed and will push humanity in vicious circle of Fight with drugs to Viruses !!

    • @LambrettaFunk
      @LambrettaFunk Před 9 lety +11

      Santa Singh Eating beef isn't the problem, it's killing a living animal that is.

    • @LambrettaFunk
      @LambrettaFunk Před 9 lety +3

      Indrajeet Patil is type of language is unacceptable, How can we argue for compassion when you say such vile things about somebodies Mother? Please re-think your anger.

    • @santasingh7738
      @santasingh7738 Před 9 lety +25

      LambrettaFunk how are you suppose to eat beef without killing the animal? Look man i respect that you are a vegetarian good for you but don't expect that i will change my eating habits to please other people.

    • @insta_sinista
      @insta_sinista Před 9 lety +7

      Santa Singh omg same here ..... eatinga a stake clubhouse

  • @adithyad2858
    @adithyad2858 Před 8 lety +154

    I wish I could start my own religion and ban most of vegetables.

    • @CS-rw4es
      @CS-rw4es Před 8 lety +3

      Id ban gobi I hate that shit

    • @ankush_chatterjee
      @ankush_chatterjee Před 8 lety

      i would surely ban capsicum 😁

    • @empt12345g
      @empt12345g Před 8 lety

      Its laid down in the constitution not to kill cows and eat beef. Do you believe and follow our constitution or only do so selectively according to your convenience.

    • @adithyad2858
      @adithyad2858 Před 8 lety +7

      Rajeev Sharma​​ I surely have to follow the constitution because I value my freedom and do not want to end up behind bars. But the problem is, here for the State Of Maharashtra even beef consumption was illegal! Which I think is more absurd than the law of no cow slaughter( which I have been a critic of). That means one cannot enjoy a beef brisket at a restaurant which imports their meat. Buffalo and other cattle slaughter also had a ban imposed which is utterly obnoxious and a very cruel move to turn a very secular state into a religious theocracy. I mean why the fuck can't a man have a beef burger, I'm bloody paying for it, keep your culture and religion to yourself. Our constitution deserves an amendment otherwise we turn into a sham religion crazed nation like our neighbor Pakistan, which has fucking blasphemy and apostasy laws and yes pork is forbidden there aswell which could equate to the "mild" beef ban here.
      In India fortunately we have freedom of religion and also freedom from religion, don't ever say such bullshit laws make sense in a democratic country like ours. The cow might be revered as a God, but it's some person's dinner. Hypocrisy should end.
      

    • @vishwasdev7266
      @vishwasdev7266 Před 8 lety +2

      गोहत्या प्रतिबंध, सख्त गाय सुरक्षा ,,प्रकृति को बचाने के लिए ,,शांति की दिशा में एक महत्वपूर्ण कदम है ,एकता ,,पर्यावरण हितैषी ,,सभी प्राणियों और पेड़ मानव के साथ-साथ खुश हैं ,,हर किसी को ,, दुनिया के हर कोने में हर कोई खुश है, तो हम भी खुश हैं,,हम गाय की रक्षा करते हैं।, तो प्रकृति का स्वचालित रूप से सहेजा और सम्मान किया जाएगा,,,गाय पृथ्वी के लिए एक प्रतीक है ...इसका गोबर पौधों के पेड़ के लिए उपयोगी है और दूध सभी प्राणियों के लिए जीवन है।गायों का शरीर भी,,, प्रकृति और सभी प्राणियों के लिए मददगार हैं कि पवित्र तरंगों का उत्सर्जन करता है..,प्रकृति की कम से कम कीमत पर जो जी रहे हैं,,, प्रकृति पर कम से कम वर्चस्व हैं , वे ही एकता और सच का सच्चा मार्ग है ..,, भगवान,, समान रूप से, हर किसी को,, सभी को प्यार करता है,, प्रभु ने हर किसी को आत्म सुरक्षा दे दी है, मानव के लिए दुर्भाग्य से मस्तिष्क दिया, जो, वे व्यावसायिकता या धोखाधड़ी में बर्बाद करते हैं,,वह एकमात्र निर्माता है,भीतर से बनाया है ब्रह्मांडों को.. कहीं न कहीं उनकी उपस्थिति की अनदेखी करना , कहीं भी, पत्थर,,छवि,, मूर्ति,, आकाश,, पानी,, किसी भी जगह,,,यह सबसे बड़ा पाप है,,दुनिया में कुछ भी इतना मजबूत नहीं है जो प्रभु पर प्रतिबंध लगाता है कहीं भी मौजूद होने पर... औम ओम-.., QURAN (पैरा 14 , 7/15)कहते हैं,, गाय 4 पैर वाले जानवरों का नेता है इसलिए गाय का सम्मान करें। दूध, घी (शिफा), गाय का मक्खन अमृत है। इसका मांस सभी रोगों का मुख्य कारण है। अल्लाह नबी ने भी प्रतिबंध लगा दिया है गोमांस खाने में और ज्यादातर,, उन दूध देने जानवरों को मारने में,,, Christian:“For I desire mercy and not sacrifice, and the knowledge of God more than that of your offerings.” Hosea 6:6 (quoted by Jesus in Matthew 9:13, 12:7),,शाकाहारी भोजन भी हलाल है ,,प्रभु ने पहले से ही शाकाहारी जानवरों की आबादी को बनाए रखने के लिए मांसाहारी जानवरों बनाया है,, तो हम विशेष रूप से गैर शाकाहारी बनने की जरूरत नहीं है।इसलिए कोई जरूरत नहीं है किसी भी निर्दोष जानवर को मारने की । यहां तक कि शाकाहारी भोजन मांसाहारी भोजन की तुलना में कहीं,,शुद्ध ,,पौष्टिक होता है,,, गेंडा,,हाथी,, बैल जो गैर शाकाहारी जानवरों की तुलना में कहीं अधिक मजबूत,, गरीब लोगों को आसानी से आसपास की दुकानों से घी दूध प्राप्त करने के लिए कभी भी जरूरत है कि प्राथमिकता पशुधन को बचाने के द्वारा दूध और घी को बढ़ाने के लिए दी जानी चाहिए -- गरीब लोगों को गौशाला,, पशुधन की सेवा में अच्छा रोजगार का अवसर मिल जाएगा ,,यहां तक कि बच्चों शिक्षा के साथ और वृद्ध लोग आसानी से यह काम कर सकते हैं.,,किसानों को गायों की चारा फसल लेने के लिए भी एक भव्य अवसर,, खाद के बिना 2-3 महीने के भीतर होती है चारा फसल,,, जो प्रकृति से प्यार कर सकते हैं वे बिना किसी भेदभाव के सब निर्दोष लोगों से प्यार कर सकते हैं, , है और वे सत्य और शांति प्राप्त कर सकते हैं .. औम ओम,.. देश भर में सभी लाख गौशालाओं सस्ता दूध,, घी और दुनिया भर में सबसे अच्छा स्वास्थ्य अल करने के लिए नेतृत्व करेंगे .. .Antaratma me paramatma to virajmaan hai hi,,sath sath prakriti /maa/nature/cow/srushti ka adar kar parampita aur mata ki bhakti hi purna tatha shuddha karma hai..aum om.... सभी के अंदर ,,सब कुछ के बाहर मैं व्याप्त हूँ, जो हर जगह मुझे देखते हैं,, और मुझ में सब कुछ देखते हैं,,, वह मुझसे दूर नहीं है और मैं उससे दूर नहीं हूँ… Chapter 6 text 30.Bhagwad Geeta .
      सब कुछ मेरे पारे उपस्थिति में, दुनिया में मौजूद है ... सब कुछ के शाश्वत जड़ बीज मैं हूं, Chapter 10 text 39 Bhagwad Geeta
      परमात्मा ,वह एक ही है, सब कुछ के बाहर अंदर,, हर जगह एक ही एक, बराबर बराबर मौजूद है,, आप अपने परम पिता(lord) से प्यार करना चाहते हैं,, तो आप को अपने सर्वोच्च मां को भी प्यार करने की जरूरत है। परमात्मा और मां को प्यार और प्रार्थना करने के लिए हीं जीवन है ,,मां पिता sukhi bhava,,sukhi hai,,namo namaha..-- औम ओम-/

  • @manojkrishna8839
    @manojkrishna8839 Před 7 lety +40

    I do not like eating meat, but if Narendra Modi says Indians must not eat beef, I will force myself to eat it.

  • @comradca7
    @comradca7 Před 3 lety +13

    Once upon a time when Arnab was secular 😂😂

    • @user-ul1zz4cw2b
      @user-ul1zz4cw2b Před 2 lety

      I am astonished to see this

    • @tanwar2514
      @tanwar2514 Před 9 měsíci

      😂😂😂 I will choose loyalty.. he have changed himself so much to be not reliable

  • @susanthomas7659
    @susanthomas7659 Před 7 lety +45

    Why don't they catch criminals and rapists put in jail, instead of beef eaters

    • @pulkitdahiya9406
      @pulkitdahiya9406 Před 5 lety +1

      They don't have minds, fucked up thinking. Can think any thing sanely

    • @samratb9169
      @samratb9169 Před 3 lety

      Catching already

  • @jafarsayyid
    @jafarsayyid Před 9 lety +144

    come to kerala. u can eat anything you like such as beef, pork, veg, etc. nobody kill you

    • @samm6095
      @samm6095 Před 9 lety +9

      +Sayed Jafar K Really...??? Only their hands get chopped off if they ever mention name Mohammed in any books evn by mistake. Yeah true a handicap is still a livin person..lol

    • @SujithDasMyVintageClothing
      @SujithDasMyVintageClothing Před 8 lety +24

      +SAM “Only4Sane” M Fuck off from Kerala, and i am Hindu and my Muslim brothers are safer here , nobody will hurt them ,if so they have to go through us!!! #fuck your facts

    • @khalidsayd5447
      @khalidsayd5447 Před 8 lety +3

      +SAM “Only4Sane” M he said only case of eating..not about religeous intolerance
      .u r true about what u said about religeous intolerance among muslim

    • @Surajkumar0770
      @Surajkumar0770 Před 8 lety +2

      +Sujith Das Hindus are Minority in Kerala and they are treated very bad by majority.

    • @SujithDasMyVintageClothing
      @SujithDasMyVintageClothing Před 8 lety +13

      +Suraj101st from where u got this foolish information?if u are not from Kerala don't talk shit. get your facts right.
      Google it
      Kerala Hindus
      Hinduism (54.73%)
      Islam (26.56%)
      Christianity (18.38%)
      Other or none (0.32%)
      one more thing.here no religious intolerance like North India .

  • @BhaskarBiswasEcon
    @BhaskarBiswasEcon Před 7 lety +54

    Beef ban? I mean seriously?
    I am a vegetarian, and still I find this ridiculous.

    • @Meefacus
      @Meefacus Před 7 lety +4

      I agree. What makes the beef ban ironical is the fact that Vedic Bhramins ate beef. I have no problem if people are vegetarians. But to dictate the food preferences of others is a little too much. In his book “The Myth of the Holy Cow,” Professor D N Jha (a brahmin himself) has made available information from the Vedas, the Sanskrit texts, the epics Ramayana and the Mahabaratha and archaeological digs, to show that the Vedic Brahmins were beef eaters, and cows were regularly sacrificed by them. This has been placed before the literate public through Frontline, Outlook and the Hindu Newspaper just to name just a few publications... In case you have not read them, visit my CZcams channel, where I have displayed the links.

    • @ashleyserrao283
      @ashleyserrao283 Před 7 lety +5

      Bhaskar Biswas this stupidity bothers me alot,personally as a atheist and patriotic Indian see this ban as a security threat to my nation,these right wing fucktards will break my country into peices. India is a secular state not a hindu rashtra.

    • @vedantasutraspersonalityde2759
      @vedantasutraspersonalityde2759 Před 5 lety +2

      @@Meefacus ie fake mahabharat read bhagavad gita as it is

  • @SaintAlphaOmega
    @SaintAlphaOmega Před 9 lety +62

    But i do agree with Mr. Owaisi when he says that BJP is being selective about their bans!

    • @chessmasterfaisal
      @chessmasterfaisal Před 4 lety

      What are your views now. After 5 years.

    • @SaintAlphaOmega
      @SaintAlphaOmega Před 4 lety +1

      Zcode I’m a BJP guy since 2000. It’s just that Owaisi had a good point in this debate. Give the devil it’s due.

    • @chessmasterfaisal
      @chessmasterfaisal Před 4 lety

      @@SaintAlphaOmega I appreciate your views. I have also seen many of his videos.
      He make clear point according to the law, as he is a lawyer.

    • @chessmasterfaisal
      @chessmasterfaisal Před 4 lety

      @@SaintAlphaOmega what are your views on the beef ban across India?

  • @makhack247
    @makhack247 Před 9 lety +45

    Stop beef export and ban beef across the country i challange to BJP govt do it..

    • @indianzionist2012
      @indianzionist2012 Před 9 lety +3

      mohammed azeem khan Try PORK VINDALOO sometime. You will then be like "YUMMY, i want more MUMMY"!

    • @makhack247
      @makhack247 Před 9 lety +8

      No iam a veg

    • @diptanusinha9663
      @diptanusinha9663 Před 9 lety +3

      mohammed azeem khan Kuch saal rook le yeh bhi hoga.

    • @sameerrajgangawane6225
      @sameerrajgangawane6225 Před 9 lety +2

      Diptanu sinha Bhai agar apka bas chale to Aap to Chicken, Fish, Eggs, vegetables ye sab Ban kardo.

    • @diptanusinha9663
      @diptanusinha9663 Před 9 lety

      hay bro gov of maharastra just band beef not chicken, eaggs. Because cow is our main source of milk.

  • @syed.kmmubasheer5592
    @syed.kmmubasheer5592 Před 8 lety +9

    This bjp and rss just playing beef politices and dividing to community's for their vote bank and big question is how can an animal be your mother ... And another question is if you respect cow and treat like mother then why you people exporting your mother meat to other country... So, stop this double standard politices.. But i respect Indian constitution and love to follow even if i go to someother country i won't touch beef because that meat will b of Indian cow which is exported by modi govt...And it's no we're written in any of your book that eating beef is prohibited in hinduism, but your gods asking you people to sacrifice animals... you people who says eating beef or sacrificing cow is against Hindu law please go to your book... Mahabharata Anushasan parva Ch no 88 ....Manusmriti chapter no 5 verse no 30.. Manusmriti chapter no 5 verse no 39 & 40.. Rigveda book no 10 hynm 85 vs 13.. And many more.. if you are a Hindu you should follow your books..

  • @ujan9837
    @ujan9837 Před 9 lety +95

    Watching this debate while having beef burger. lol

    • @ashleyserrao283
      @ashleyserrao283 Před 7 lety +4

      Dipak Basu because of people like you our country will disintegrate to tiny kingdom and fiefdoms,if you want a hindu rashtra go to nepal,this is India a secular state not a hindu state.

    • @kolkatablues8643
      @kolkatablues8643 Před 6 lety

      @dipak Basu, The oriental school that your parent organisation is based on were avid beef eaters. We also have instances of hardcore Hindu sadhus eating beef. So, what are you kiddo? A half pant idiot?

    • @samratb9169
      @samratb9169 Před 3 lety

      These secular people is hell for India

    • @jetflare724
      @jetflare724 Před 3 lety

      @@kolkatablues8643 I think your instances are from whatsapp University please smoke less ganja and then tlk

    • @jetflare724
      @jetflare724 Před 3 lety

      Nobody asked Ujan banerjee asshole

  • @farhanmirza6455
    @farhanmirza6455 Před 8 lety +40

    Ban all political parties who rule in any religious way instead of the constitution of India!

    • @ketankunte8646
      @ketankunte8646 Před 6 lety +3

      Then owaisi's party!

    • @vk5722
      @vk5722 Před 3 lety

      Ban all religions. Religions are made by rich and wealthy to control poor.

    • @powergaming6856
      @powergaming6856 Před 3 lety +1

      Then which party will govern our country? If so is done, then all the parties will be banned!😂

    • @Phoenix-King-ozai
      @Phoenix-King-ozai Před 2 lety

      Then first congress should go

  • @ashwanikhandelwal3729
    @ashwanikhandelwal3729 Před 9 lety +17

    Vehicle leads to pollution... Ban them also

  • @robbinsmathew
    @robbinsmathew Před 7 lety +22

    India is becoming a Joke. Its shameful i don't know wheather i cry or laugh ...i miss my beef fry my fav.. yumee beef pickles. ... n a lot of dishes ..

    • @jetflare724
      @jetflare724 Před 3 lety

      So are people like you and nobody asked

  • @kiliyano
    @kiliyano Před 9 lety +29

    If there is a yelling sport, India should send Arnab

  • @VinylToVideo
    @VinylToVideo Před 9 lety +13

    I should move to India.. it would be so easy to become a politician!

    • @kamakshigarg1289
      @kamakshigarg1289 Před 4 lety +2

      VinylToVideo no it isn’t At least we will not elect a person who has not been Indian since birth. Remember Sonia gandhi

  • @giltonkjose
    @giltonkjose Před 9 lety +16

    Some one please support chicken too....

  • @comradebarry
    @comradebarry Před 9 lety +165

    Eating a big Mac and Ribs while watching this

    • @lakshayrattan4454
      @lakshayrattan4454 Před 9 lety

      👍🏽 good for you, it's not going to affect my in any way but good for you.

    • @nishchaysrivastava7212
      @nishchaysrivastava7212 Před 9 lety +13

      PashtoonKhan ISI sitting in texas having whataburger and being a Hindu lol

    • @natsudragnell4752
      @natsudragnell4752 Před 9 lety +2

      hahaha, I wish I could do that too xD BUT I can't, it's banned my country (at least at some places)

    • @Zachuman
      @Zachuman Před 9 lety +6

      hahahahaha that's the fucking way man. although I'd enjoy that with slices of bacon on the side :P

    • @mr.intellectual4033
      @mr.intellectual4033 Před 9 lety +1

      You are a Muslim and not from India so Indians don't care what you eat in a foreign country.

  • @dunsacc
    @dunsacc Před 8 lety +10

    trivedi got destroyed... he has no argument.

    • @sumit5624
      @sumit5624 Před rokem

      He didn't get chance to speak ...they kept disturbing

  • @jumikaka
    @jumikaka Před 8 lety +15

    Did anybody tried beef biryani ? Its so tasty ?

  • @janvisai8187
    @janvisai8187 Před 8 lety +16

    I watch this show for improving my debating skills and english

    • @bobpgeorge8985
      @bobpgeorge8985 Před 8 lety +8

      wrong show to watch. it's just a shouting match

    • @decayjustice4818
      @decayjustice4818 Před 8 lety +4

      +Janvi Sai They can't even speak decent English too .. lol

    • @krishmistry2608
      @krishmistry2608 Před 6 lety +1

      yeah me too

    • @debojitdeori4837
      @debojitdeori4837 Před 6 lety

      Decay Justice at least better than you...i bet!

    • @krishmistry2608
      @krishmistry2608 Před 6 lety

      Ricky Deori decay justice would copy paste something to prove his/her English skill

  • @abdulla6828
    @abdulla6828 Před 9 lety +44

    watching dis debate while eating a beef biryani...

    • @pramod8838
      @pramod8838 Před 6 lety +2

      Raj singh why not ur biryani instead? What ppl eat is their choice. If u don't like or if u believe cow is god then it's only for u, not for the whole world. U know to fight over such issues only in India bcos u know it rakes up religious sentiment. But try banning or asking rest of the countries to stop eating beef, im sure they'll kick ur ass out.

    • @Maheshgurucom
      @Maheshgurucom Před 5 lety +4

      Abdullah go and eat pork also

    • @piyushyadav2444
      @piyushyadav2444 Před 5 lety

      @@Maheshgurucom tu religion ki baat kyu laa Raha hai beech mei
      Usne bola Kahi ki hindu kharab hai?

    • @mohsin3488
      @mohsin3488 Před 5 lety

      @@Maheshgurucom
      We dont eat pork. Pork is haram. Beef is halal and nutritious. Cow meat is second to none.

  • @bonny27196
    @bonny27196 Před 9 lety +30

    Lol looking at this it seems the bjp is going back to the old age or even stone age.

  • @aayosaathgaaye
    @aayosaathgaaye Před 8 lety +5

    I hate Arnab to the core. He is so impatient & never let anyone speak & always tries to cut others off

    • @pravinpinto9791
      @pravinpinto9791 Před 8 lety

      is there any point of this debate?
      har party ka spokesperson will defend his own party....they are very well versed with twisting and manipulating the law.
      owaisi wants to ban pork/trivedi wants to ban beef/satan oooopppsss sry sanatan sanstha is practically useless.(ss is found guilty behind the murders of 3 social activists....
      whatever the issue the common man suffers because these idiotic creatures.
      trivedi said while cooking beef more cfc is released does that dumb f*** knows he was sitting in an ac/fridge also releases cfc...
      NOW I WOULD VOTE ON BANNING AC/FRIDGE.....(LOL) oops forgot the old tv sets as wel ha ha ha
      he also said cow dung is good ...so the people who want to eat beef should eat cow dung now/milk is good however half a litre of milk is costing 20 rs which is not even sufficient for 1 person to fill his stomach.how will that person fulfill the hunger of entire family.....oh btw do ull know any organisation of rss which give COW milk for free(ill stand in line).
      and coming back to owaisi he dint even utter the word pork...if he was so concerned about the economics he should have kept the religion aside and used that word but he dint.
      and i forgot the main point
      letting other world population eat beef is fyn but we should eat..
      majority of beef exportes are gujratis (ooooohhhh now i understood).
      anyways
      tc(have beef/pork/drink some wine) we've got only 1 life

  • @BY-yb3vs
    @BY-yb3vs Před 7 lety +2

    Arnab was sane till 30:00... After this he forgot that debate was about beef ban... His target shifted on Owaisi

  • @vineethvinu7672
    @vineethvinu7672 Před 6 lety +3

    Just finished eating porotta & beef before watching this

  • @mofaha43
    @mofaha43 Před 9 lety +10

    Bjp is totally runs on the hindu religion and culture and they have double standard i want to ask them a simple question, why dont they ban beef in bjp governed state of goa?

  • @shibinsunnyshibin
    @shibinsunnyshibin Před 9 lety +16

    Beedi is good for health and beef is hazardous for health.. Wooww incredible India.

  • @shashankgogoi5871
    @shashankgogoi5871 Před 8 lety +4

    BJP/Congress should be banned in India. Along with all the religions. WE must put a 2 year tax on Temple/Mosque/Church and seize their assets and distribute in among dalits and BPL people.
    On a more serious note, let's actually pass a bill to ban religion.

  • @vutubeify
    @vutubeify Před 4 lety +4

    I miss this Arnab...today he has become a shadow of his former self

  • @feludaify
    @feludaify Před 9 lety +1

    Thumbs up if you have developed the superpower to listen to 5 different people at the same time due to this show....

  • @TheKailash89
    @TheKailash89 Před 9 lety +4

    i hoped that BJP will bring some change to my society after congress looted country for many years ,but i think these BJP fundamentalist are trying to divert country from ground issues and trying do things which are useless

  • @robertjung9232
    @robertjung9232 Před 8 lety +2

    A random atheist American here. I ate a rare t bone steak and downed it with two beers. I also ate a bacon cheeseburger today. I love meat

  • @juibappaahmed7297
    @juibappaahmed7297 Před 7 lety +5

    if anybody wants eat and drink
    .let them consume what ever they feel like yaar!!! where is the freedom..
    don't plz ......

  • @Surajkumar0770
    @Surajkumar0770 Před 8 lety +2

    In India "Secularism" is a Codename for a "Anti-Hinduism".

  • @MImran-yq8xn
    @MImran-yq8xn Před 8 lety +11

    It's banned to eat in India but in the other hand the exports has been increased to get more profit out of beef,,,,, madness

  • @wasilrazak21
    @wasilrazak21 Před 9 lety +1

    5 years for a burger and 3 for harassment... wow... truly the ache din has come to our nation.. :)

  • @aadviknarainshukla7080
    @aadviknarainshukla7080 Před 7 lety +3

    Haha I'm a Hindu and I love eating cows.do what you like you fanatics

  • @nevillefernandes5521
    @nevillefernandes5521 Před 8 lety +2

    Getting bjp in power was biggest mistake by maharashtra people ....

  • @chomschoms1315
    @chomschoms1315 Před 6 lety +13

    Here in the US we start our day with a nice Beef sandwich.

    • @kamakshigarg1289
      @kamakshigarg1289 Před 4 lety

      CHOMS CHOMS then do that We can pretty well see our country

  • @Jcoke2201
    @Jcoke2201 Před 3 lety +1

    I am pro govt. But this beef ban was wrong. Also, this shows how unbiased Arnab is.

  • @Mr.Mister420
    @Mr.Mister420 Před 4 lety +4

    I am a Muslim I enjoy Pork..

  • @naynikareddy525
    @naynikareddy525 Před 5 lety +1

    All Hindus who are not supporting beef ban shame on their part

  • @kanukuladheerajreddy6710
    @kanukuladheerajreddy6710 Před 6 lety +3

    Iam watching this video while having beef pork and alchol

  • @sharavan91
    @sharavan91 Před 8 lety +1

    Why ban beef ? Why not ban Alcohol ? No one can answer this question. Politician acts for the people with privileged status not for needy one. Shame....

  • @BBQBeerKars
    @BBQBeerKars Před 9 lety +6

    None of those things are scientifically proven by the way. And i guess Carbon Emissions cannot come from living species as long as you have people in Delhi doing their best at increasing pollution.

    • @ajturbo619
      @ajturbo619 Před 9 lety

      shikhar s It's a waste of breath arguing with these morons. The nation will never recover from it's cesspool of shit. It's better for us to find ways out of india & make our lives better! Ayurveda, homeopathy, it's all hogwash. Virat dimwits won't accept all this crap!

    • @BBQBeerKars
      @BBQBeerKars Před 9 lety +1

      AJVonDoom Oh I am settled in Canada for about 12 years now, but my family lives in India whom i visit once every 3 to 4 years. I was born and raised there so I have something to look out for. But then i end up meeting morons who defame India. It just pisses me off.

    • @ajturbo619
      @ajturbo619 Před 9 lety

      shikhar s I'm on my way to Italy. We Shud never forget our roots mate! but sometimes calling myself an indian feels sho shameful. :\

    • @BBQBeerKars
      @BBQBeerKars Před 9 lety

      AJVonDoom yup. It sure does.

    • @justarandomguywithoutaname8719
      @justarandomguywithoutaname8719 Před 3 lety

      Now even oxford university banned beef

  • @subhajitlivewire
    @subhajitlivewire Před 4 lety +2

    This Sudhanshu guy probably exports few tons of cows every year.

  • @Anab7860
    @Anab7860 Před 6 lety +3

    All these beef debates make me hungry. I swear.

  • @truthwillprevail7872
    @truthwillprevail7872 Před 9 lety +2

    Please dont have double standards.......
    One can export cow meat for money but poor people cant eat it..... wha re mera bharat mahan

  • @kumarjain4944
    @kumarjain4944 Před 9 lety +19

    government should not regulate people's dietary habits.

    • @kumarjain4944
      @kumarjain4944 Před 9 lety +7

      I am sorry people be able to eat what the want irrespective of someone belief. That is the definition of a democracy. I am a Jain do not eat meat, but I will not superimpose my views on society. What cruelty, stop using leather products and medicines. They are derived from animals.

    • @kumarjain4944
      @kumarjain4944 Před 9 lety +3

      ARE YOU A DICTATOR PLEASE GO TO PAKISTAN WHERE THEY ABUSE HUMAN FREEDOM. THERE IS NOTHING WRONG WITH BEING VEGAN, BUT DO NOT FORCE IT ON OTHERS. I DO NOT EAT, BUT THAT MY PERSONAL CHOICE WHO AM I TO IMPOSE IT ON SOMEONE ELSE. WE LIVE IN A FREE AND PLURAL INDIA. GOVERNMENT HAS NO RIGHT TO ABRIDGE ANYONE RIGHT TO CONSUME FOOD. DO NOT TALK NONSENSE. JAI HIND

    • @kumarjain4944
      @kumarjain4944 Před 9 lety

      Where did I use curse words are you reading someone else remarks. People dietary habits are not in purview of government, You cannot tell people what to eat. You teach and educate them about it being wrong. If the listen to your advice then great. However, please do not superimpose your views on others. Do you know the population of cattle in India, it will skyrocket. What is the cost of maintaining a cow are you aware of that. I am not a meat eater , but I feel it is up to individual to make that decision. That is a democracy.

    • @kumarjain4944
      @kumarjain4944 Před 9 lety

      In a democracy it is incumbent on the elected government to maintain the fragile balance, between security, morality, and personal freedom. It is not black and white in most cases there are many grey areas. That is why an it is imperative to have an independent judiciary to decide the boundary lines. In this case I believe the government has crossed the boundary line between personal freedom and morality. This is my personal opinion. I am not the court. Jai Hind

    • @kumarjain4944
      @kumarjain4944 Před 9 lety

      Yes, the government has backtracked on its own opinion and shortened the ban.

  • @sylhetiuk2918
    @sylhetiuk2918 Před 4 lety +1

    I used to be e vegetarian, but after the killing of Mohammad Aklaq, I now eat beef whenever possible.

  • @snehamani1859
    @snehamani1859 Před 8 lety +7

    in India anything under the earth can be given religion aspect.

  • @aniketroy657
    @aniketroy657 Před 4 lety +2

    When Arnab was not Modi and BJP slave ❤️

  • @neerajharitwal8611
    @neerajharitwal8611 Před 9 lety +3

    Dear arnab sir,
    Mr shudhanshu is talking abt minor religion's right.... Mentioning Jainism of the minor religion..... Okay.. Bt jains dont eat vegetables which grow underground (eg. Potatos onions) plus they are nt allowed to eat after sunset.... So according to that we should ban all vegetables that grow underground n 5 years of prison for those who eat after sunset....
    (i am a bramhin)

  • @jamalshaikh7896
    @jamalshaikh7896 Před 9 lety +2

    inteligent anchor arnab goswami very good sir

  • @BobbyChauhan-drifter
    @BobbyChauhan-drifter Před 9 lety +29

    politics , politics, politics of their own respective agendas !! sabki apni dafli apna raag !!

    • @ahmedeliasraheal4116
      @ahmedeliasraheal4116 Před 9 lety +5

      We or human civilization always pass through new era, experiences, compulsions, needs and innovations. Majority of Indians are with the faith that cow slaughter is outraging the sensitivity of one religion and they believe it spiritually and I personally believe it must be respected. Indian constitution respects all faiths and religions. Banning Cow slaughter taking consent of majority of Hindus would be right move. It does not harm Muslims or Christians. For better quality protein and calcium one can eat fish, milk and other substitutes. Our temperature does not go to minus degree to need more calories and fats. IF Government TAKES DECISION JUSTIFIED. When our generation develops higher and needs otherwise they may take their own decision. This moment banning right decision.

    • @essay427
      @essay427 Před 9 lety +2

      There is no problem likely to arise, if the government does it in a systematic well planned and well communicated manner. We as Indians should support it.
      Problem arises when so called Managers of Gods come and try to impose what they think is right on all of us using force, coercion and Goondaism.
      Although, i personally feel slaughter will continue even after the ban due to the deep rooted corruption in our country.
      Jo paisa dega wo dhanda karta rahega !! ;)

    • @BobbyChauhan-drifter
      @BobbyChauhan-drifter Před 9 lety +1

      they cant stop it safeer ahmed ! this is also just a bloody sham !

    • @essay427
      @essay427 Před 9 lety

      Bobby Chauhan Zonal Coordinator AAP Sir ji yahi to problem hai humare desh ki. .
      sarkar badalti hai.. mantri badalte hain . .Babu badalte hain...but System Waise ka waisa hi rehta hai !!!

    • @BobbyChauhan-drifter
      @BobbyChauhan-drifter Před 9 lety +3

      nobody is against this fact Mia Satish even our muslim friends support this with us ! :)

  • @sandybhan
    @sandybhan Před 9 lety +1

    Benefits of Cow..!!!
    Cow milk is of two types:-Lesser fatty and, More fatty.These fats are of two types:-
    1. Unsaturated fatty acid and
    2. Saturated fatty acid.
    Much importance is given to unsaturated fat from the mental and physical health point of view. This fat is found in cows eating green pasture. Saturated fat in cow milk increases by feeding it husks grains etc which if drank causes high blood pressure. There are omega 3 and omega 6 in the unsaturated milk. These are called essential fatty acid (EFA). When both these two elements mix in balanced proportion it strengthens the mind of the person who drinks cow milk. Studies have shown that the DHA element is formed with omega 3 which makes mind stronger.
    Properties of cow milk eating greener fodder
    In the milk of cows eating greener fodder, the fatty acid going by the name of conjugated leanolic acid (CLA) is present, which is very vital and which prevents many types of cancer. This CLA destroys the cancerous cells. Drinking cow milk minimises the onset of cancer. From other studies, it has been found that there are less cholesterol in the fat and stems the attack from atherosclerosis. The arteries get thicker by the formation of atheroma on its walls.
    The benefits of cow milk in prevention of diseases
    Cow milk forms the base of all dairy products. This makes bones stronger because, vitamin D, Calcium and other vitamins are found in it. All these elements are considered good for the health of bones. The calcium accruing from cow milk is constitutes a great role in various other body functions. Cow milk prevents clotting of blood and felicitates the smooth functions of veins and arteries. It also prevents contraction of muscles. It regulates enzymes activities. It also improves the smooth functioning of cell membrane. It regulates blood pressure. Iodine is found in ample quantities which regulates the function of thyroids.
    Other benefits of cow milk
    1. The milk safeguards the colon cells from the chemicals responsible for cancer
    2. This prevents the harms arising out of menopause and rheumatoid arthritis.
    3. Prevents the headache of migraine.
    4. It relieves the symptoms arising due to pre-menstrual syndrome during the menstrual cycles.
    5. Prevents body- girth in children and helps lose heftiness.
    6. Helps loose weight around waistlines.
    7. Cow milk and its products minimises the dangers of metabolic syndrome by 62%.
    8. The conjugated leanoleic acid present in cow milk properly regulates insulin secretion minimising the blood glucose levels.
    Cow milk stems osteoporosis
    The vitamins present in cow milk makes bones stronger. Vitamin K1 activates osteocalcin which is the main noncollagen protein found in bones. Osteocalcin give proper directions to calcium in the body. Its levels remain lower when the body lacks adequate vitamins causing shortages of minerals. A cup of cow milk daily covers the whole necessary elements. Leftopherin, which is the protein which binds the iron in cow’s curd or its milk boosts up osteoblast i.e. insulates the cells which is responsible for the formation of bones. This just reverses the processes of osteoporosis.Cow milk cures numerous serious diseases
    Scientific Importance Of Cow Milk .
    Cow milk is of two types:-
    Lesser fatty and, More fatty.
    These fats are of two types:-
    1. Unsaturated fatty acid and 2. Saturated fatty acid.
    Much importance is given to unsaturated fat from the mental and physical health point of view. This fat is found in cows eating green pasture. Saturated fat in cow milk increases by feeding it husks grains etc which if drank causes high blood pressure.
    There are omega 3 and omega 6 in the unsaturated milk. These are called essential fatty acid (EFA). When both these two elements mix in balanced proportion it strengthens the mind of the person who drinks cow milk. Studies have shown that the DHA element is formed with omega 3 which makes mind stronger. Properties of cow milk eating greener fodder In the milk of cows eating greener fodder, the fatty acid going by the name of conjugated leanolic acid (CLA) is present, which is very vital and which prevents many types of cancer. This CLA destroys the cancerous cells.
    Drinking cow milk minimises the onset of cancer. From other studies, it has been found that there are less cholesterol in the fat and stems the attack from atherosclerosis. The arteries get thicker by the formation of atheroma on its walls. The benefits of cow milk in prevention of diseases Cow milk forms the base of all dairy products. This makes bones stronger because, vitamin D, Calcium and other vitamins are found in it. All these elements are considered good for the health of bones.
    The calcium accruing from cow milk is constitutes a great role in various other body functions. Cow milk prevents clotting of blood and felicitates the smooth functions of veins and arteries. It also prevents contraction of muscles. It regulates enzymes activities. It also improves the smooth functioning of cell membrane. It regulates blood pressure. Iodine is found in ample quantities which regulates the function of thyroids. Other benefits of cow milk
    1. The milk safeguards the colon cells from the chemicals responsible for cancer
    2. This prevents the harms arising out of menopause and rheumatoid arthritis.
    3. Prevents the headache of migraine.
    4. It relieves the symptoms arising due to pre-menstrual syndrome during the menstrual cycles.
    5. Prevents body- girth in children and helps lose heftiness.
    6. Helps loose weight around waistlines.
    7. Cow milk and its products minimises the dangers of metabolic syndrome by 62%.
    8. The conjugated leanoleic acid present in cow milk properly regulates insulin secretion minimising the blood glucose levels. Cow milk stems osteoporosis The vitamins present in cow milk makes bones stronger. Vitamin K1 activates osteocalcin which is the main noncollagen protein found in bones. Osteocalcin give proper directions to calcium in the body. Its levels remain lower when the body lacks adequate vitamins causing shortages of minerals.
    A cup of cow milk daily covers the whole necessary elements. Leftopherin, which is the protein which binds the iron in cow’s curd or its milk boosts up osteoblast i.e. insulates the cells which is responsible for the formation of bones. This just reverses the processes of osteoporosis.Cow milk cures numerous serious diseases
    COW - Is one of the most magical things made available to us by nature. He praises gau mootra very highly. It helps all three doshas. Vaata and Kapha it cures completely and also cures Pitta if taken with some ayurvedic medicines. It has all the 18 odd micronutrients that are available in mud (Jersey cow has only 3).
    All the 148 ailments can be cured by gau mootra( Cow urine). This is the only thing with such a possibility. Have done thousands of experiments on this and found mind boggling results. It has 18 micro nutrients that are essential for the body. The only other place where all 18 found together is soil. Best time to take gau mootra is morning. If very ill take upto 100ml in a day best to take it twice a day on an empty stomach. Rest of us can take upto 50mm once a day on empty stomach.
    Skin ailments are usually caused by Sulphur deficiency. Psoriasis has been cured, eczema, khuzli, khaaj etc were cured.
    It cures TB much earlier compared to allopathy. It never recurs if treated with gau mootra. Studies were conducted on patients at AIMS. If taking allopathy, its speed of cure is increased manifold when combined with gau mootra.
    Joint pains were cured in three weeks.
    Cold and cough - dama and asthama and TB were cured by this very swiftly.
    When Gau-mootra was given to patients already taking allopathy, the effectiveness of the medicines was increased many fold. This is true for almost all serious ailments.
    As per contemporary research 48 ailments are cured by completely by gau-mootra. Research on cancer is going on with tremendous results. Blood cancer is not showing so much improvement. A large hospital has been set up in Valsaad to cure cancer with Gau-Mootra. (Throat, Esophagus and stomach cancers are already showing huge improvements).
    According to research deficiency of Curcumin leads to cancer - i.e. growth of tumor and later cancer. This is found in ample quantity in cow urine in a highly digestible form.
    Only a cow which roams around given useful urine. The urine of a cow that stays tied up is not useful.
    Organic Agriculture - cotton has gone up to 7 quintal per acre from 2-3 earlier, wheat from 12 quintal to 24-25 quintal, rice from 15-17 quintal to 30 quintal, sugarcane from 8 feet high to 14 feet, recovery from 8% to 14%-15%. Gud made from gobar as fertilizer sells for 70/kg in the international market. Only India can produce this.
    In our culture cow is always referred to as ‘mother’. It has been said that a cow has 33 types of devatas in its body. “Gobar main Lakshmi mootre Dhanvantari”.
    Glucoma, retinal detachment and cataract etc all can be cured using gau mootra. Use gau mootra drops in the eye. It works wonders for all eye related ailments as they are mostly due to Kapha.
    > If ears of children are giving off pus - put drops of gau mootra.
    > For running nose and cold etc for children - use gau mootra ghrit.
    > Gau ghee in nose helps in deep sleep, snores can be reduced.
    > Hair loss - make curd and keep it in copper vessel for 5-6 days, rub it into head and then wash it off using shikakai. Wash hair with gau mootra once a month for long term health of hair.
    > Ribs, or chest congestion can be cured by a spoon of gau mootra.
    > Renal problems are taken care of by gau mootra.
    > Pitta patients need to increase ghee consumption while taking gau mootra to balance its effect.
    > Dark circle under eyes, and any other skin problems can be cured.
    > Its distillate or ‘ark’ can be used. Ark should only be taken in very small quantities i.e. 1 spoon.
    > The leftover after making ark is used for making soap, shampoo, floor cleaner etc.
    > Cow ghee sells for Rs.4000 per kg in Germany etc. They are desperate for this real ghee but don’t get it anywhere.
    >To make Gau Panchamrit you need > gobar(cow dung),Cow Urine, Milk, ghee(sort of classified or melted butter), Curd, (includes honey or gud(Jaggery (unrefined sugar))) is an elixir for VPK.
    To know more Join Aayurveda, Aayurveda gives you solutions for all kinds of ailments like cancer, diabetes, asthma, hair whitening, hair fall, cough,weak eyesight, tumur, arthritis, skin problems etc etc
    The vitamins present in cow milk makes bones stronger. Vitamin K1 activates osteocalcin which is the main noncollagen protein found in bones. Osteocalcin give proper directions to calcium in the body. Its levels remain lower when the body lacks adequate vitamins causing shortages of minerals. A cup of cow milk daily covers the whole necessary elements. Leftopherin, which is the protein which binds the iron in cow’s curd or its milk boosts up osteoblast i.e. insulates the cells which is responsible for the formation of bones. This just reverses the processes of osteoporosis.Cow milk cures numerous serious diseases

  • @southtechie
    @southtechie Před 9 lety +4

    Religious beliefs should not be imposed on the people forcefully. Let the people decide what to eat. Let the saffron fascists do not snatch the basic rights.

    • @southtechie
      @southtechie Před 8 lety +1

      Jake Ryan human right is more important you ugly pig.

  • @ganeshkd9272
    @ganeshkd9272 Před 9 lety +2

    why such hypocrisy....ban every thing and make India a vegeterian Country....

  • @tagleluinzs662
    @tagleluinzs662 Před 6 lety +3

    Beef curry is my favourite food haha

  • @Antony-vm3mv
    @Antony-vm3mv Před 7 lety +1

    When will India stops believing in these Arabian nights stories like Bagawat geeta,Ramayana,Mahabarath,,Quran.

  • @dhruvist
    @dhruvist Před 9 lety +3

    let me just enjoy my beef and bacon burger while i watch this

  • @bengeorge9063
    @bengeorge9063 Před 7 lety

    More than hearing the debate, it is just this Arnab yelling over everyone. Isn't he the moderator ? He spends the entire hour yelling at the top of his lungs !

  • @DigitalAssam2.0
    @DigitalAssam2.0 Před 4 lety +3

    I eat beef while watching this debate

  • @adarshroy3938
    @adarshroy3938 Před 7 lety +1

    I can't believe a couple of adults are arguing whether to ban beef in this day and age! This is a fucking democracy! Follow whatever you want in your own religion, but don't expect others to follow your ideologies! What nonsense!

  • @leoNE743
    @leoNE743 Před 8 lety +3

    :P God be like..."I love you much more than the cows! , why are you loving the cow more than man !?"

  • @anantbhat108
    @anantbhat108 Před 9 lety

    times now and arnab......mad channel mad person......thanks Maharashtra Govt.

  • @tiananiang
    @tiananiang Před 9 lety +8

    Holy Cow........what is this?haha

    • @rolandmonteiro6486
      @rolandmonteiro6486 Před 9 lety +4

      tiana niang be carefull, or u might be imprisioned for 5 years just taking the name of a cow. you never know when BJP will change their own words ... :-) lol

    • @srikanthchandan3213
      @srikanthchandan3213 Před 9 lety +1

      u son of bitch. .....

    • @RaHul-rk4kl
      @RaHul-rk4kl Před 6 lety

      Ajitesh Gaur she is a Christians from northeast

    • @rabaka7899
      @rabaka7899 Před 6 lety

      Ajitesh Gaur ha ha

    • @arnoldbeyel-0374
      @arnoldbeyel-0374 Před 5 lety

      Let's kill all the 🐮

  • @kevipucho9673
    @kevipucho9673 Před 7 lety

    Arnab sir is free and fair person........

  • @venkateshkannan5
    @venkateshkannan5 Před 9 lety +7

    sanjay jha , when are you going to phone bjp office for memebership ? we will wait one more day only.

    • @vipulkumar3293
      @vipulkumar3293 Před 9 lety

      raj malhotra uev got no work like those chaddi bhakts and this is whats expected from morons like u

    • @bali1538
      @bali1538 Před 9 lety +1

      vipul kumar i have got very important work to spank traitors like u
      come with u r real name if u r so brave LOL

    • @vipulkumar3293
      @vipulkumar3293 Před 9 lety

      Vishvaneet Sirohi don't think im gonna respond to ur bullshit

    • @venkateshkannan5
      @venkateshkannan5 Před 9 lety +2

      did i ask you ?

  • @parvezalam6072
    @parvezalam6072 Před 3 lety +1

    Take action on North East state's like Nagaland.. Manipur..... Mizoram and Meghalaya where the beef is legally consumed by the people ❤️❤️

  • @mdmohitulhaque8648
    @mdmohitulhaque8648 Před 8 lety +19

    I eat bull meat everyday, its the tastiest thing in the world

    • @jetflare724
      @jetflare724 Před 3 lety +1

      Bull is not beef and makes you fat as pork

  • @bali1538
    @bali1538 Před 9 lety +14

    arnab this is the second time where i do not support u first being on homosexuality
    as Hindus whether moderates or extremists cows r sacred to us the whole world is shifting towards vegetarianism and every species including cows have right to live i was once a totally non vegetarian person but i never ate cow or pork
    v have to start from somewhere lets start from Maharashtra
    Muslims have to respect the local customs of their host country if they want to integrate to host country
    if they cannot then they r free to leave India and settle in some gulf country or Pakistan
    this is about respecting Hindu traditions

    • @GabbarSeTakkar
      @GabbarSeTakkar Před 9 lety +18

      raj malhotra I am a Hindu and I eat beef. Fuck you!

    • @bali1538
      @bali1538 Před 9 lety +2

      ***** U SEEM TO REPRESENT MUSLIM ESPECIALLY PAKISTANI SENTIMENTS AS IF THERE IS NOTHING ELSE LEFT TO EAT AND THEY WILL DIE OF STARVATION
      go and rant u r anti BJP and RSS propeganda in some hafiz saeed meeting

    • @bali1538
      @bali1538 Před 9 lety +1

      ***** it should be imposed in whole of india but v have to start from somewhere
      people have to be made mentally prepared
      when the focus comes on pork muslims say its against their religion but when it comes against cow meat then people like u say it has nothing to do with religion
      i m against both
      secondly the person indulging in this industry whether hindu or muslim should be made to change his this profession
      it sounds like an excuse

    • @BBQBeerKars
      @BBQBeerKars Před 9 lety +12

      raj malhotra I am quite appalled to see that you have no idea what Hinduism is. There was a time when Hindu Priests also ate Horses, did you know that? I am sure you have heard about 'Ashvamedh yagya', after which the Horse was slaughtered and eaten by all the priests and the king himself. And just to clear your misconception, cow is not the only thing that's precious in Hinduism, every single insect/animal/bird species have an equal importance. So, you cannot kill even a mosquito if it comes to that because it is made by 'God'.
      Beef is not only eaten by Muslims in India but also by many other cultures. It is unfair for people like you to put this on Muslims all the time. There are Muslim communities in India that do not eat beef ONLY because they are living peacefully with their Hindu brothers and sisters. Stop being so communal all the time. If you have a problem with Muslims then may be its you who needs to move out of India.
      I was raised as a Hindu Brahmin but I do eat beef, pork, and what not. Grow up dude. It is food that they are banning, tomorrow they will even ban Oxygen for some godforsaken reason. As long as there are people like you supporting them they will get away with anything.

    • @soulreaperichig0
      @soulreaperichig0 Před 9 lety +2

      raj malhotra And on both issues you are wrong and hypocritical.

  • @Titans178
    @Titans178 Před 5 lety +3

    Those were the days when Arnab was talking sense :)

  • @vidyashankars3870
    @vidyashankars3870 Před 9 lety +2

    Arnab, u have definitely taken money from the lobbyists for ur channel. Naam goswami aur acharan to dekho.

  • @mahatkhansu5424
    @mahatkhansu5424 Před 9 lety +3

    so funny India if ur Hindu pray to cow then why yu sand them n Bangladesh

  • @indianzionist2012
    @indianzionist2012 Před 9 lety +1

    NEWS-HOUR should be renamed as NOISE-HOUR.

  • @icreamlolipop3
    @icreamlolipop3 Před 9 lety +3

    I admire this debate alot by all the parties. Eating is part of personal choice but Cow has some unique benefits in medicine farming dairy etc. What BJP is trying to convey should be done in a liberal way showing the benefits of Cow preservation. I am with BJP on this issue.

  • @mayuresh4green
    @mayuresh4green Před 8 lety +2

    I want my vote back

  • @thesiddhant1998
    @thesiddhant1998 Před 8 lety +3

    I eat beef and I love it. You politicians should take up worthwhile issues,which will actually help the public and not waste time on such trivial matters.

  • @nuc2110
    @nuc2110 Před 8 lety +2

    Gau Raksha Samiti is protecting there owner who is making 4.8 billion /year by selling ther gau matha to world

    • @pravinpinto9791
      @pravinpinto9791 Před 8 lety

      is there any point of this debate?
      har party ka spokesperson will defend his own party....they are very well versed with twisting and manipulating the law.
      owaisi wants to ban pork/trivedi wants to ban beef/satan oooopppsss sry sanatan sanstha is practically useless.(ss is found guilty behind the murders of 3 social activists....
      whatever the issue the common man suffers because these idiotic creatures.
      trivedi said while cooking beef more cfc is released does that dumb f*** knows he was sitting in an ac/fridge also releases cfc...
      NOW I WOULD VOTE ON BANNING AC/FRIDGE.....(LOL) oops forgot the old tv sets as wel ha ha ha
      he also said cow dung is good ...so the people who want to eat beef should eat cow dung now/milk is good however half a litre of milk is costing 20 rs which is not even sufficient for 1 person to fill his stomach.how will that person fulfill the hunger of entire family.....oh btw do ull know any organisation of rss which give COW milk for free(ill stand in line).
      and coming back to owaisi he dint even utter the word pork...if he was so concerned about the economics he should have kept the religion aside and used that word but he dint.
      and i forgot the main point
      letting other world population eat beef is fyn but we should eat..
      majority of beef exportes are gujratis (ooooohhhh now i understood).
      anyways
      tc(have beef/pork/drink some wine) we've got only 1 life
      i still fail to understand what is wrong with pork....i love pork sausages

  • @ravichandel8690
    @ravichandel8690 Před 8 lety +4

    of course he will be arrested as law of land if it is ban then why eat why don't you go in middle east and celebrate diwali in open.

    • @NoelIsaacPharmD
      @NoelIsaacPharmD Před 7 lety +2

      The reason for that being India is a democratic nation unlike middle east which is ruled over by a Sheikh. In India the ideas of a common man contribute to the development of a law which then is voted upon unlike middle east where the ideas of the ruler are the law with no involvement of the people. However, that being said the laws made there are in favour of the people (both citizens and non citizens) and thats also the reason why that citizens of middle east stay in middle east.

  • @vikrantkulkarni9321
    @vikrantkulkarni9321 Před 9 lety

    arnab is amazing debater and anchor.

  • @zubbairzubbi5889
    @zubbairzubbi5889 Před 9 lety +3

    Beef is good for health

  • @anoopsharma4882
    @anoopsharma4882 Před 9 lety

    When you say 'WE'. DO NOT SAY 'YOUR PRIME MINISTER'. You are a citizen of India not Pakistan.

  • @joeldsouza6315
    @joeldsouza6315 Před 8 lety +3

    I think I'm in Saudi Arabia

  • @kondak147
    @kondak147 Před 9 lety

    Beef banning law itself is against the basic human rights. I have the right to eat what I want. People involved in this banning needs to be brought to justice and punished.

  • @mrmanoja2640
    @mrmanoja2640 Před 9 lety

    Very brave initiative by Maharashtra government... This is welcome...Future impact on economy would be great..

  • @dranilganvir6133
    @dranilganvir6133 Před 9 lety

    I am Indian first and Indian last. Indian Christians should be allowed to eat beef. Some Brahmans are running this state of Maharashtra and the treasurer is empty.

  • @shahidulalam2342
    @shahidulalam2342 Před 8 lety +2

    Eat beef and enjoy.

  • @KoolBoyzProduction
    @KoolBoyzProduction Před 9 lety +2

    i liked beef,beef was good

  • @Sandeep_Hande
    @Sandeep_Hande Před 9 lety +2

    Super funny that Arnab started this debate by saying let's not make it a religious issue and he gets Sanatan Santha on panel..Either he is really naive or thinks people who watch this show are..

  • @mukundkulkarni4905
    @mukundkulkarni4905 Před 9 lety +1

    I completely agree wid his views on banning alcohol.Thais is one vice that has destroyed the human race. But as of now Govt has got d courage to stop cow slaughter. When d Govt develops enough strength to ban alcohol v will support that also.

  • @vairagijayesh
    @vairagijayesh Před 8 lety +2

    If bjp is going to do like this ...then definitely they going to loose ...please bjp guys ....correct yourself ...boss there is no use to do development if problem like beef ban ...AAP come to Maharashtra ....

  • @vishwasdev7266
    @vishwasdev7266 Před 7 lety +2

    माँ प्रकृति सृष्टि गाय नेचर कायनात का आदर प्रेम जरुरी है अगर आप को परमपिता परमेश्वर एकेश्वर खुदा भगवान को भी पाना है तो...अगर तुम सोचते हो की तुम माँ का अपमान, अनादर करके परमेश्वर परमपिता की कृपा और प्यार को पा सकोगे तो ये नामुमकिन है,,और अगर तुम सोचते हो की तुम परमपिता परमेश्वर खुदा का अपमान अनादर करके माँ प्रकृति माया सृष्टि को पा सकोगे तो ये भी नामुमकिन है...माँ और परम पिता अटूटनीय , एक ही है,,,वो एक दुसरेसे बहुत प्यार करते है,,,,किसीभी एक का अनादर दूसरेको नहीं भाता,,उनके प्यार से ही कयनते universes विश्व ब्रह्माण्ड निर्माण होते है....ॐ ओम ओम माँ परमपिता सुखी रहे सुखी है उन्हें नमन,,,वसुधैव कुटुम्बकम,,,,ॐ ओम ओम माँ परमपिता,,,
    हम तोह पृथ्वी को भी माँ कहते है क्युकी वह हमारा ख्याल करती है क्योंकि वो हमें हवा पानी कहना देती है, फिर भी हम इंसान उसे कष्ट देते है,, पोल्लुशन ङेकोफ़्रेंडलीनेस जैसी हरकते करते है, गाय तो प्रकृति सृष्टि पृथ्वी स्वरुप है ,,सृष्टि का प्रतिक है,,गाय का घी अमृत और दूध जीवन है,,गोबर और उसके शरीर के तरंग निसर्ग के लिए पवित्र और उपायकारक है , गाय की सेवा पूजा माँ सृष्टि प्रकृति की सेवा बराबर है,,सतो गुण का सम्मान है ,
    और जब ईश्वर खुदा भगवन कण कण में व्याप्त है, दुनियामे ऐसी कोई जगह नहीं हो सकती जहाँपर वो नहीं हो सकता , वो हर तरफ व्याप्त है समान समान ,**ईशावास्यमिदं सर्वं**, **सर्वं खलु इदं ब्रह्मम**, **सोऽहं**, **ॐ तत सत**, (वही एक शाश्वत सनातन) **यात्र तत्र सर्वत्र** वही है साकार निराकार सगुन निर्गुण त्रिगुणातीत परे, सबके अंदर और बाहर समान समान व्याप्त सर्वत्र, जो तुम्हारे आस पास है और जो मेरे आस पास है वो ईश्वर समान और एक ही है मेरे दोस्त , तो हज़ारो लाखो आकारोंमे रूपोंमें दिशाओंमें जगहोंपर उसी एक और एक ईश्वर को देखना पूजना जानना ही सच्चे एक ईश्वर की भक्ति और उस भक्ति की सच्ची कसौटी है,,माँ और पिता से ही सरे ब्रह्माण्डोंका निर्माण है ,सारा विश्व माँ और पितामय है,
    वो परमपिता है जिनका मस्तिक्ष कई ब्रह्मांडो से बड़ा है , हम शायद ही कभी जान पाए उन्हें जाननेका पूजनेका सही तरीका,हमे बस चाहिए की हम अपना १००% पूरा, सही, सभ्य निर्दोष, हृदयपूर्ण और सच्चा प्रयास करे माँ और पिता को समझने का पहचान ने का ,,वो तो माँ पिता है,, समझ जाते है अपने बच्चोंके इरादोंको, सच्चे प्रयास और प्यार को, बिना कहे,, और वो सब जानते है, हम बस उसी रह पर चलते रहे जो माँ पिता की अनुभूति करा सके,,ॐ ॐ ॐ भगवन कभी भेदभाव नहीं करते ,सबको उन्होंने सुख दुःख विजय पराजय सामर्थ्य अंग दिए है, सबको आत्मरक्षा भी दी है,,यहाँ तक जानवरोंको भी, उन्हें कभी किसी एक ही धर्म या कास्ट के लोगोंपर लगाव प्यार नहीं है,वो सबको चाहते है, समान समान,
    दोस्त, माँ शब्द बहुत बड़ा है, हम तो दूसरोंके माँ को भी माँ कहते है,,इज्जत करते है,,हिंदुस्तान में ईश्वर के साथ साथ माँ शब्द को जोड़ा हुआ है,, ईश्वर परमपिता माँ ये शब्द और इनकी व्यापकता समझने के लिए प्रक्टिकल प्रोफेशनल स्वार्थी विचार नहीं चलते , होशियारी या दिमाग भी नहीं चलते, जब खुद खुद ईश्वर भगवन प्रक्टिकल प्रोफेशनल नहीं है,, परे साकार निराकार त्रिगुणातीत है तो उन्हें जानने के लिए नेक दिल/ मन ही लगता है , और निर्दोष प्रयास लगते है,, ॐ ॐ ॐ औए ये प्रयास तो माँ पिता परमात्मा को भी समाज आता है
    माँ पिता सुखी रहे सुखी है उन्हें नमन ,,,,ॐ श्री ॐ माँ परमपिता...
    भक्ति में परमपिता या माँ ( प्रकृति शक्ति सृष्टि नेचर गाय कायनात )इनमे से किसी भी एक का किया हुआ अनादर द्वेष भक्ति को पूर्ण नहीं बनाता है, और दूसरे को नाराज कर देता है,,जैसे माँ प्रकृति का किया हुआ अनादर परमपिता को नहीं भाता और परमपिता का किया हुआ अनादर द्वेष माँ को अस्छा नहीं लगता ,वो दोनों एक ही है, दोनों अटूटनीय है ,वो सबसे प्यार और रहम करते है, कोई एक ही मजहब उनके लिए प्यारा नहीं है, अगर ऐसा होता तो वो उसी एक मजहब को ही सुख देते, दुःख कभी नहीं देते बरकत देते, चार चार हाथ और पैर देते, पर ऐसा नहीं है मेरे दोस्त,, वो सबको देते है, सबको चाहते है,,सबके प्यार को समझते है, उनकी निर्मिति पे उंगली उठाना, किसी को भी कम, छोटा या गलत समझना सबसे बड़ी नासमझी है ,,माँ और पिता सुखी रहे,,वो सुखी है,,उन्हें मेरा नमन , ॐ ॐ ॐ माँ परमपिता ॐ

  • @avinash7335
    @avinash7335 Před 8 lety

    If slaughtering and eating an innocent animal is justified, then feeding human meat and slaughter of humans should also be justified, and all anti human trafficking laws should be abolished from the country, hope my all secular, democratic friends shall also agree with it.

  • @normster1000
    @normster1000 Před 8 lety

    I asked for beef curry in an Indian restaurant in the US and nearly got into a fist fight with the owner !

  • @dranilganvir6133
    @dranilganvir6133 Před 9 lety

    The Hindus Eat Beef is a famous book written by Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar.

  • @PraveenPoonia84
    @PraveenPoonia84 Před 9 lety +1

    If you guys have time listen to Rajeev dixit .. he is the guy with facts and still if you are not agree with him.. give me one reason not to ban Beef.. For Arnab you prove today no one can be right every time like you are not this time