10 Reasons Why Gareth Southgate Can't Manage Manchester United
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 05. 2024
- Take advantage of MANSCAPED®’s best valued bundle and save 20% Off and Free Shipping with the code Howson at Manscaped.com. That’s 20% off with free shipping at manscaped.com and use code Howson Time to save and shave with MANSCAPED®
Gareth Southgate is the second favourite to replace Erik ten Hag as Manchester United manager this summer and his Premier League stats are worth taking a look at. One of the few reasons Southgate has been linked is that In recent seasons, United have made the headlines for its off-the-field antics as much as its on-field ones. So given his reputation for improving the in-house culture, it may be not too surprising that Southgate has been so heavily linked lately. Who will be the next manager of Manchester United? Apparently Thomas Tuchel or Southgate, the choice of many former and current players. But his stats as a Premier League manager make for difficult reading. Here are 10 reasons why Gareth Southgate cannot become the manager of Manchester United...
🔔 Subscribe now for the freshest Football and Manchester United updates straight from Old Trafford. Here, you’ll be the first to catch:
🏟️ Football News: From the Premier League to the Champions League, we have all the hottest news covered.
🥅 Man Utd News: Get the latest scoops straight from Old Trafford.
🌟 Man United Academy News: Keeping tabs on the future stars of the club.
🎥 Live Stream Reactions: Join us as we share live reactions to all the Premier League and Champions League matches.
🎬 Manchester United Documentaries & Vlogs: Deep dives and behind-the-scenes insights into your favourite team.
⚽ Goals, Highlights & Player Analysis: Detailed analyses focusing on stars such as Bruno Fernandes and Marcus Rashford.
🎧 Podcasts: Tune in for rich discussions featuring special guests and Erik ten Hag's press conference reactions.
📢 Transfers & Premier League Buzz: Be the first to know all the freshest transfers and Premier League news.
Your support is our strength! Contribute and enjoy exclusive perks:
💖 Patreon: Access behind-the-scenes and more here: bit.ly/HowsonPatreon
💎 CZcams Membership: Unlock exclusive perks: / @stephenhowson
Deepen the conversation:
Check out Howson IRL here: / @howson-irl
💬 Reddit: Engage with our community: / howson
🎤 Podcast: Tune into our in-depth discussions: apple.co/1qQHSdF
Stay Connected:
👍 Facebook: / mrstephenhowson
🐦 Twitter: / mrstephenhowson
📸 Instagram: / mrstephenhowson
🎵 TikTok: / mrstephenhowson
🌐 For more, visit: www.stephenhowson.com
#ManchesterUnited #GarethSouthgate #Southgate - Sport
United fans rarely agree on anything, but the only two things I’ve seen that is unanimous is Glazers Out and that we don’t want Southgate.
110%
According to a previous poll 1% wanted him in.... I just hope and pray that was all trolls
RECTIFICATION !! RÉAL UNITED FANS AGREE ON A LOT OF THINGS ! Social Media are full of fake United Fans who say stupidity on it ! I suppose they are City Arsenal and Liverpool fans pretend to be United fans 109% !!!
@@davidellinsworth3299If he can have Kane Rice and Bellingham in yes if not then 0% CHANCE IN MY OPINION WHICH IS APPROXIMATELY THE CHANCES HE HAS…
@@sivispacemparabellum3056bro Kane and Bellingham are not going to united
1. It's Gareth Southgate
2. It's Gareth Southgate
3. It's Gareth Southgate
4. It's Gareth Southgate
5. It's Gareth Southgate
6. It's Gareth Southgate
7. It's Gareth Southgate
8. It's Gareth Southgate
9. It's Gareth Southgate
10. It's FUCKING GARETH SOUTHGATE
Wow, you lot just hate him eh?
@@thrilla72 Hate is a strong word, we'd be fine with Mr. Waistcoat to stay the England manager... We just don't want a guy who undoubtedly will make Maguire his first choice CB at the helm of our Club. Do whatever with England...
Well said mate 👏👏
Its a solid list and true
@@ameyagokhale5123couldn’t of said it better myself 👏🏾
I want a “500 reasons why”, 10 part documentary 😂
The only reason Southgate got the England job after the Allardyce 'scandal' was because they wanted someone squeaky clean. The only reason England have reached the latter stages in recent tournaments is because they've had piss easy group stages. Soon as they've played a decent team they've been found wanting. In the premier league United will be up against decent teams every other week. In the next few years (while we're rebuilding) we need a manager who can help us win games where we're the underdogs. Southgate will never be that man.
This is just a lie isn’t it? Who did England get knocked out to in 2016 again? Southgate is the only manager to defeat a top nation within 90 minutes for England in nearly 60 years, not saying I want him as manager but to say he hasn’t done a good job for England means that no one has ever done a good job for England barring Alf Ramsey.
“He fuxks with the light off” what a line 🤣😂
Only 10? Ste, you're slacking!!!!
Every single fan needs to keep as vocal as possible in how little we want that bell end as manager!
We need to keep Ineos on notice
I think Howson is the only person in the world that is taking it seriously. Even the tabloids that invented the link don't believe it.
@@mundolioknows6447 The club pays attention to the media though and we have to be undeniable! I'd rather be vocal than seeing Southgate leading the Utd team out
@@Lioris13 it's simply not going to happen. The only reason he's done this video is because he did some stats research after the initial tabloid link and he doesn't want to waste it.
Don't forget the fan backlash among other things is why Greenwood didn't come back.
The noise when it was revealed the board were considering bringing him in, put a damper to that plan.
@@Lioris13 The club used to listen to the media. The guy running the club now has just spent over £1.3b of his own cash to buy a 25% state in Utd. I'm not SJR, but if I'd just spend £1.3b, I wouldn't be paying attention to the media who generally are just scum in this country.
Forget his record, forget his style, forget his tactics. When it comes to managing blue chip clubs, especially Man Utd, the key prerequisites are, suave, charisma, stature and an ability to command a respect that borders on fear factor. And I’m not just describing Fergie here, think of all the great managers throughout history; Busby, Shankly, Pep, Clough, Lippi, Jose, Ancelotti, Cruyff, they’re all cut from the same cloth. You need that aura before you even start a conversation.
10 reasons!? Holy fuck someone means business 👌😂
This is just the first part of a series
Also worth noting that come the start of next season is will be two months shy of FIFTEEN YEARS since he last managed in club football
Honestly this is why of people involved in football on CZcams I’ll only watch Howson. He actually researches everything and then gives an informed opinion
Is it a prerequisite for a manager or any potential manager to be a friend / fan of Rashford? Mourinho, Ole, Ragnick and Erik seem to be pressured into keeping Rashford happy and as soon as Rashford mood dips managers are fired. I know correlation doesn't equal causation but there's something wierd going on.
Biggest nonsense I've ever read. You think it's a conspiracy to keep Rashford happy.... Jesus fucking Christ mate, this is a YOU problem.
Unreal 😂😂😂😂
I agree with every point apart from using his previous premier league stats.... he took over a team the year after he was playing for it and it was also 14 years ago... you cant suggest he's not had the ability to change just a little bit in 14 years??
His stats and ability as the England manager is enough to write him off on its own
Yeah, we can all agree that Southgate with England isn't the manager we'd want managing utd. However Ste using Southgates stats as Boro manager is just stupid. You can put Pep or Mouriniho as manager of that Boro side, and they probably wouldn't have got an awful lot more out of the Boro side than Southgate did.
Yeah I don’t agree with using his Middlesbrough stats against him, they was a poor side. Give anyone that Middlesbrough side and they’d struggle too.
I think he was using them stats as a correlation to what he still does to this day. Looking at how England struggle and even falter agains clubs of equal parity or better and not being able to show adversity. But ya boro isn’t really much to hold a torch to. But for also having a part time job for the past how long to actually having to do the work everyday day for year/years to coke doesn’t bode well either
The fact that Stee felt the need to do this Video scares me!!
If I was Southgate I wouldn’t want to give up my cushy England job.
Next season Utd are going to be scrutinised like never before, whoever the manager is will need a good start to the season.
Excellent analysis, he must be in the masons.
Southgate the ultimate yes man. The only thing all supporters can agree on is that he's not the man for utd.
Case made, with passion. I can think of any arguments to your case. My case is more emotional. It sticks in my mind the quarter against france where England were on top but we couldn't win. Deschamps made changes so france did win.
Him & Potter are the 2 I’m terrified of them bringing in.
If Ineos bring Southgate then we will definately know Ineos have no idea what they are doing which is as good as Woodward running the club
Not watched the vid yet, but you did well being able to narrow it down to just 10. If we got Southgate with that current squad, we’d be Newcastle between 2009 and 2016
Couldn't agree more 👏
Ste any chance we can get a video on McKenna ?
"Mr. sparkling water and ready salted crisps"🤣
Spot on lad
Gareth is John major reborn
I don't want southgate - the only way somewhat see the vision is if we had Southgate in a 'people manager' role purely for the 'culture' and then hired an actual head coach for the style and tactics on the pitch
Sat in a cafe watching this one.
Laughing at some of these stats 😂 out loud.
No need to list 10. The fact he is Gareth Southgate is reason enough
Love its upped to 10 reasons
He fucked up badly against Italy in the Euro final. He picked Sterling based on the tap in goals he scored for Man City because City have so many options that when they play the ball across the 6 yard box, Sterling races in for a tap in. England did not have that luxury of great players around Sterling and Italy just man marked him so he could not get near the ball in the penalty area. Did Garish WaistCoat spot that and make any changes ? No, he just expected England to bang their heads against the Italian defensive wall even harder.
Lol, 5 reasons is already a lot. We got an extra 5 for good measure. But I agree. We can't have Southgate at United.
Ha challenge accepted Ste ; )
Gareth will have a statue out of OT by the end of the January transfer window.
1. GS comes in and slightly underachieves on his aforementioned premier league record with united. we are 8th with ETH so with Gareth almost definitely we'll be in a relegation scrap by the 4th gw onward.
2. The Glasers out movement reignites stronger than ever before.
3. Our stock just crumbles and is sold as pennies on the dollar.
4. Regular Joes are buying them in bulk with Sir Jim and INEOS upholding their agreement with the Glasers and buy them out by new years eve (talk about a Santa gift heh?).
5. SJR throws them out of our club before the ink dries out on the sale agreement, scraps the A&B shares bs, installs a 50%+1 majority vote fan ownership of the club and bows out with a hired plane doing rounds over Old Trafford with a banner that reads "Mission Accomplished".
Talk about a masterstroke. Pants off & roll out the sausage rolls...
when I saw the title I was like only 10🤣😂🤣😂
Only one reason needed
1. Gareth Southgate
hit the nail on the head perfectly, but its such an united thing to do
What McKenna is doing at Ipswich has echoes of Alf Ramsey 1962. Keep watching and keep ETH in the meantime
You missed a positive for Southgate managing United..... We need a manager who can wear a waistcoat.
It's Sareth Goutgate, can't believe we didn't see it. It's a lot of gout waiting to happen, we don't need another ailment at United.
you're very kind to Southgate to say he may only have had the 3rd best squad...
He has had the best squad by some margin for the majority if not the entirety of his tenure.
He will probably do a press conference where he will channel his inner Jose Mourinho to reveal that failing to win a competition with this England squad was the greatest feat of his career
The Curve ball is SJR has Southgate as the scapegoat for EtH
Ste i normally dont agree with you but i fully agree with on this vid. we can not have Southgate as a manager
The rest of the world is laughing at England for having Southgate
Only 10!? 🤨
The England culture change comes from the rivalrys fading over the years. Southgate cant claim that
Man City and Liverpool, remember when Sterling and Gomez fell out?
Southgate's club record is even worse than Moyes' prior to United. He hasn't managed a club side since leaving Middlesbrough FIFTEEN YEARS AGO!!!!
What are these hats please anyone ?
I think there are a thousand reasons actually 👀
I think Ten Hag will get another year to turn it around due to a lack of credible candidates. We need an inspirational manager that's tactically astute and in it for the long haul. We don't want the type of manager that starts well, then falls out with everyone and then leaves after two years. I'm not entirely convinced ETH is the right manager but I'd love him to prove me and many others wrong next season.
He can take his ball boys shoes and feck off 😂
Had to mention ole. Just can't help yourself can ya mate 😂😂
Ste you could've done two different episodes of '5 Things' and gone further into these points, because they're excellent. Someone needs to send this to Sky, and the MEN, and all these other prats who even suggest Sareth Gouthgate (and 2 videos is more adsense rev)
My first question is would Middlesbrough have him back ? Even if “Yes” the fact that that question can be ask is the reason why United should absolutely say No.
Ange suddenly looks a bit disturbed at spurs, outside bet?
Just 10 things?? You disappoint me Howson. You could do another 2 or 3 parts to this.
Record very similar to Ole at Cardiff then?
He can if thats whst Ineos decide. Jury is still out on Sir Jim etc etc
God, what a nightmare PE teacher Mourhino would be.
On paper doesn't England have the most valuable squad in the world at the moment? Yet somrhow Southgate manages to screw up whenever they meet a top 10 team.
He is too loyal to some players while being the opposite with others, say if Maguire got 10 own goals, gave away penalties he would still be the first name on the sheet but not with say for example evans
It's bad enough really disliking the team, I'll also end up disliking the manager even more .
Sad teams indeed
Wasn't there a Netflix TV show by that title?😂
10 REASONS WHY.....( Not sure 😂)
United have a PR team. Id use southgates name to get people on side with ten hag
Im no advocate for Southgate by any means but does anyone know Solksjaer’s win rate in the EPL before he managed United?
I ask because Howson would never say a bad word of him and still puts Ole in high regards
Slightly different scenario, his record at Cardiff was not great but results there were not all down to him. Subsequently he guided Molde to two league titles which at least was a full time position rather than the part time England job. More importantly Ole was hired by United as interim manager, and his performance in that capacity earned him the permanent manager role. Southgate will be walking in with a permanent contract with only the part-timer international credentials. Completely agree with Stephen's views, would be very worried if Southgate was in the running.
His win rate was better than Malky Makay in the Prem...
@@spammalina thanks for the effort but my question wasn’t answered, instead I got more Ole praising🤣. Not to worry though
You don't have to convince me. From the first time I saw Southgate's name linked as manager, it was no way. I got the same rush of blood when they announced Moyes. You have to be kidding. So far not impressed with Ineos. Loads of talk. No way of doing most of it. Not in less than 20 years. Still mostly owned by Glazers. Nothing is likely to change. If they appoint Southgate it will be a joke. All these supposedly great sport brains would instantly loose any credibility. This current England squad is the best we have had in years. Given now that there aren't many English players in the English Premier league. Better system in 1966. And as you say won nothing. Playing for your country is totally different anyway. Many players at club level couldn't give a toss. Regular pay cheque. Turn out, sit on the bench, out injured. Same as a boring office job. But you might see that lift for country. Well you can hope. But Gareth Southgate. God help us.
Hes not man enough to manage any of the top 6 sides in the Premier league hes a yes man to the FA
EtH IN
I’d genuinely rather have Sean Dyche at Utd than Southgate.
10:46 Sareth Gouthgate 😅😅😅
Little Spoonerism😂
Yes Southgate is just too cautious may as well bring back Morino!
I'd bring back Mourinho and pay him triple if it meant Southgate not getting the job!
Tbf I'd probably hire Sreth Gouthgate over Gareth Southgate
As a united fan outside Europe plz plz plz just dont let him mange united this my msg for u united fan in city of manchester
Man Utd need to listen to they fans. Just like what WWE as been doing recently
you know its serious when there are more than "5 things" we can learn" looll
Jesus.... He:s not going to become United manager. Its paper talk. He worked with Ashworth for England. Thats the entire substance of it.
Youre getting more obsessed with Southgate than you are about Maguire.
Southgate is a woke failure whose only talent is taking one of the best squads we’ve had and stealing defeat from the jaws of victory. God forbid he comes to Utd, it will be the final nail in the coffin.
Agreed, the cowardly tactics in the euro final against an Italian side that were there for the taking did it for me. I screamed at the time when England went into their shell after opening the scoring. Anyone apart from Waistcoat could see there would be only one winner after the first ten minutes and it wasn’t England. Southgate is beyond incompetent
INEOS want the whole England setup, from the coaching staff to the medical department to the analytics team. Bringing Southgate is the easiest way to acheive that. Then if he fails, they can sack him after a year & retain the setup
What's that set up won in the poorest international football period ever.
@@garethdeere4822 International set-ups are of a certain standard & Dave Brailsford knows that very well
Says who? You're making it all up simply because we are linked to Dan Ashworth who once happened to work for the fa.
@@mundolioknows6447 strange thing to assume without knowing who I am... 🤔
@@Cold_Logic ok... right.... Let me guess... Sir Jim Radcliffe?!
You're a little spod with an active imagination and a keyboard. Don't even pretend to be part of the Ineos set up.
Completely agree not the manager for Man Utd. But can we also try to understand why most of the fan base want to keep Ten hag ? The only reason I hear is that we can't be firing managers every 2 years, but that's how you get a good one in. Any reason to retain him (dont see any) :
1. Man management ?
2. Tactics ?
3. In-game management ?
4. Transfers ?
5. Consistency ?
6. Coaching ?
Sancho , rashford , greenwood, Anthony issues , the take over , injuries , poor var decisions , individual errors is the reason, ten hag deserves another season
INOES will be monitoring Mckenna first season in the premier league
@@davidublin Sancho is the only one I can agree. rest are his own making or shouldn't affect him or his team either, goes to show he can't keep the team motivated to perform irrespective of the noice outside. From your list there's no mention of any positive attribute he's brought to Man u and only speaks of the negative aspects wrt personel that's to be expected.
You'll seem to think INEOS is a magic wand our wizard of a coach is missing all these days ? INEOS is not Quatar they dont have unlimited credit. We've 1 maybe 2 (built on top of a good 1st season 2024-25) good transfer windows. And Ten hag if retained is going to flush it down like the 500 million he did the season before.
I'd keep ETH over Southgate all day long
@dilipg8389 how many accumulation of injuries has ten hag to deal with, who brought in the doctor from arsenal ?? , we haven't even got a fitness coach which ten hag requested, john murthough and Richard Arnold paid way over odds for players not ten hag ,,,
The positive is his first season at united and the promoted youth players love ten hag like the young ajax players did
Qatar would still face the financial restrictions as ineos, YOU SHOULD KNOW THIS !!!!!!!!!
@@tommills9575 I've started with the same definitely not the manager we're looking for. Since we're on a clearing out journey I want them to clear out everything Coaches, Manager and players. And then rebuild.
Who says southgate would want the job anyway 😂 it’s a impossible job at the moment
He got Boro relegated and fell into the England job as an emergency "safe" pair of hands, good luck to him, but that doesn't qualify you as a Man United manager!
If Ten Hag leaves, Rashford gets a clean slate. I cant have it.
I don't get the hate? Clean slate? He played for us with a bad back! He fought for kids.
He scored 30 goals last season.
This season, he is playing with a manager playing with a 3-1-6 in possession when we can see there being issues since the very first game vs Wolves.
And having to play with hopeless Hojlund who is invading his space.
Please... Licha, Mainoo, Bruno and Rashford that is the heart of our team
@@preetjitsingh328 I might have agreed if i did not have eyes.
I heard this about southgate. Pleeeeeaaaasssse nooooooo
INEOS is here to deteriorate not rebuild....
What has Ten Hag actually done to prove he's any better than Southgate exactly? Fuck me Steve McClaren won titles in the Eredivisie if Ten Hag is meant to be good enough to manage United Southgate definitely is.
If your going to choose an England manager, then surely Sarina Weigman is the only choice? She wins!
Only 10?
The only reason England have done alright under southgate is because they've had easy runs and good players
Ste dislikes Southgates so much, he doubled the reasons to get the point across😂😂😂. Love to see it
Paper talk,if ineos are actually considering this they should stick to pushbikes
If INEOS plan is Gareth Southgate then they are clueless and i'll be very concerned going forward with them, SURELY they cant be bringing in Blanc, Ashworth, Brailsford, Berrada, Wilcox and they assess the football world and think this Muppet is the man to take United further
If Dan gets his mate an interview I’m afraid Sir Jim will fall for the waffle.
Surely Jim has seen the negative response and steer well away.
10 reasons why Gareth Southgate can’t manage more like.
Keep southgate on England Job, i'd take Ten Hag
I think Southgate will challenge ETH to see who will be the 3rd worst post-Fergie manager.
Can't be worse than Ragnick and / or Moyes; or could he???
Ste, love the content I'm always here to watch your stuff but you put 9 too many things on the list could of been 1 reason...its Gareth Outgate....that's right I typed Outgate in prep for November 2024 when we want him gone
He 'managed' to take Middlesborough down.
There is no way this group of senior players will accept Southgate, I think the only guy they would accept is Rooney. Rooney is not ready yet and may never be. He came out the other day and said some of the players are faking injury, so not likely. Just stick with ETH, mind the medical department and bring in some fast tough young players, with the idea of bullying other teams in the league and the two cups, no Europe to play for.
I gave him a chance with england we did well making our first final since 66 only to piss it away with awful game management, then he proceeds to get us relegated from the nations league with some of the worst football i've ever seen, we've not been that much of a laughing stocking since taylor in 94
A doubt west ham or everton would have a punt on southgate so utd is being trolled when his name is mentioned...
Shouldn't the title of the video be "10 Reasons Why Gareth Southgate Can't Manage"!!