1. it's not dropping 2. if it releases he's not gonna make a review about it because "he doesnt want to give the idiot anymore attention" (my predictions)
In the past couple of months, Ye’s fanbase has really proven to be one of, if not THE worst by justifying and meatriding anything he says and/or does as well as going at anyone’s throats for even so much as slightly criticizing him. It’s honestly sad and kind of pathetic to see.
This what i was thinking, Everyone keep saying Fantano hate Kanye but dude has given him some pretty fair reviews, Dude actually had one of the most positive reviews of Ye I've seen, As I've seen so many trash that record, Rolling Stone i believe ranked it as the "Worst Album of the decade" Which is crazy lol it's honestly one of Ye's better projects IMO short and sweet, Some GREAT tracks on there, No clue how any Kanye fan could listen to Ye and say "That was awful" It's like a top 5 Ye project tbh.
Ye 2018 was complete shit and near a 1/5 album rating. Only people who listen to the same music like drones daily like it. Anyone who’s actually listened to different genres of music and has taste knows it’s terrible. Ghost town saves it from a 0 score.
@@barkley8285 I listen to a ton of genres (mainly rock), and i liked ye. Ghost Town is one of his best songs ever, and Violent Crimes is also a masterpiece. And while the rest of the album doesn't quite reach those heights, i would still rate the tracks above average. So all in all, i could understand a 6/10 or 7/10, but 2/10 is ridiculous.
@@barkley8285 Wtf you talking about? Ye had some pretty unique tracks on it tbh, Hence why it was actually mostly casual listeners who hated it so much. Your typical music drones legit skipped over the album because they were told to lol And also idk why you feel the need to say "Anyone" Who's actually listened to different music knows, When your really just speaking for yourself, I listen to everything from Kanye to Gregory Alan Isakov, The Beatles to JPEGMAFIA, Pantera to Norah Jones, Music is my life and as someone who almost always listens to different genres, I thought Ye was a solid album, It's totally fine if you disagree, People have different opinions, But you def don't speak for everyone who listens to different genres lol
Spot on - I’ve been saying this for years. Not many artists Fantano has reviewed has a 10, two 9’s, and three 8’s in their discography. Oh and 3 more 7’s isn’t too shabby either, considering he can be a tough critic.
@@Prodbyjah464 lol u woke up angry didnt u. your logic makes no sense, theres a difference between remembered and relevant. hes rereviewed certain albums before (like mbdtf, a kanye album) years later after seeing how they changed the landscape of music or how they aged well. theyre only not “relevant” becuz they dont contain up to date information thats imperative to the critique of an album. stop generalizing fans of people that shits annoying
@@kingdess0Ik I’m late but reading this comment you really have no idea what relevant means or what relevance is, also even if those specific Kanye albums like mbdtf or yeezus have gained more relevance over time because of how they impacted music, that doesn’t mean Anthony’s original reviews or opinions are any less valid, yes he could acknowledge how influential they were but that isn’t gonna change the fact he still probably isn’t a fan of the album as a whole, there are many albums that are influential but aren’t that great (a lot of lil Wayne albums) not saying those Kanye albums aren’t great or agreeing with Anthony’s ratings on them, I’m just saying that there impact and influence doesn’t mean someone can have an opinion about them and that they’re free from any criticism which is something you Kanye Stan’s can’t handle.
What happened to it, man? He actually used to have one of the cooler mainstream audiences and now he’s just the Donald Trump of rap music; everything he says is correct all the time and if you don’t agree, “you just don’t get it, man”. It’s all just so… groan-worthy
@@mrlevinielsenAge of his Fanbase Changed. What you remember is his old fanbase that was around when his first 3 Albums released. But alot of these People lost interest when they got Older. Now he got a new very young Gen Z fanbase wich first Kanye Album was Yeezus or Life of Pablo and they Glaze Kanye to the Max.
I agree with him for the most part. Especially the Graduation opinion, many people my age think that’s better than College Dropout or Late Registration, but I find that sort of baffling. Ye’s first three albums are all tremendous “, no matter what.
Graduation is in my eyes cleaner and more pop sounding (In a good way) so its a better listen espacilly for modern listners while espacilly the college drop out has some really goofy sounding beats. Not to say its bad because its objectively not, but you also have to think how things have aged for more modern ears, a lot of Kanye listeners, me for example where way to young to active listening to those albums when they came out.
I feel like Kanye fans think that every Kanye album is the best album of all time and if you say otherwise you are critizising Kanye and are being a Kanye hater
idk why kanye fans have such an obsession with people’s opinions about him. as a kanye fan his fanbase is annoying asf it kinda makes me feel guilty to be apart of it sometimes.
I think Kayne will forever be my biggest personal test for the "separate the music from the musician" theory. Do I love his music? Absolutely. It's safe to say that Graduation had shaped my taste in music even to this day. But he's also a terrible, terrible person with some truly fucked up opinions; and in genre where the creators put so much of their own soul, thoughts and consciousness into their creations, where do we even draw the line to separate them? Where does the musician end, and music begin? So even for a rando like me, feelings on Kayne is too complicated to sort out. I can't even imagine being a critic, whose opinions on music is scrutinized and weighted so heavily.
@@godofnothing428 corny bars that got him album of the decade, if kendrick made it, which he made 2 better albums already, it would be the best album to exist
I love KanYe but i’m not biased so let me rate them for you •The College Dropout- 10/10 for a debut album and just emerging out of the r&b / hip-hop scene, the production and use of sampling in The College Dropout was GROUNDBREAKING and the quality of music sounds like it came from an experienced producer and musician. this to be a debut album (despite previous mixtapes) is absolutely phenomenal and changed the course of r&b and music in general. •Late Registration- 8.5 to 8.9/10 despite not being nearly as good as The College Dropout. the production in this album could be argued to be better. This album is in my opinion what caught a lot of people’s eyes when it came to music production and what not. Songs like “Gold Digger” and “We Major (feat Nas!)” shaped even modern Kanye and, was unfortunately a lot less influential than that of The College Dropout. •Graduation- 9 to 9.2/10 Graduation although glazed and extremely overrated is a classic and a must listen to record. the production is absolutely top tier but not as good as that of Late Registration or The College Dropout. the tracks though WOW. i think Graduation is where Ye was not only realised as a good producer but a good marketer and public voice. the collab with Takashi Murakami for the album cover and the collaboration with Daft Punk (which was the most popular DJ / producing duo of the early 2000s to mid 2010s) not only boosted Ye’s popularity but somehow theirs. •808’s And Heartbreak- 7.5 to 8.2/10 first off i wanna say I’m not rating this album based on influentiality as this would be in the 9.8-10 range. purely off of music quality. which i must say isn’t bad but certainly isn’t anything compared to The College Trilogy. Ye’s voice doesn’t suit the genre and the heavy 808s over the melodic bass line. it just sounds to “poppy” (relating to pop as a genre) and the only real standouts in this album are “Bad News” “Love Lockdown” and “Heartless” which in themselves are okay and not quite up to his standards which he set for himself with his previous 3 records. but the Production? again superb and as i stated earlier influenced an entire era and more to come of pop and hip-hop. •My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy- 9.5/10 this rebound from his previous work is so good and so power (no pun intended) the production and track creation of this album deserves more than credit from album reviewers like myself and Fantano but an award. this is the first time we have properly seen Kanye disassemble a song and combine it with other songs to make a beat. like in “POWER” where he sampled 3 songs to make the ad-libs and beat. his rapping and lyricism also isn’t as corny and actually makes sense and sounds good. perfect tracks that have come out of this album include “Runaway” and some other decent tracks like “Dark Fantasy” and “Hell Of A Life” which is my personal favourite also exist on this phenomenal record. •Watch The Throne- 6 to 7.5/10 This collaboration with Jay-Z gained so much hype and so much popularity around the time for it to be so lacklustre. coming off My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy and even 808’s And Heartbreak. this album is merely nothing special and overhyped. it still included amazing production as always might I add. especially in songs like “N***as in Paris” and “Otis” which uses melodies like no other and even creates recognisable tracks just from one note like in previous songs such as “Runaway.” kanye also still seems to be showing more lyrical prowess than that of his other works this alongside Jay-Z makes him sound so crispy. •Yeezus- 8.6/10 i never understood why this album was so hated and unlistened to? i hold the belief that the best production of all time exists on this record with Mike Dean and i believe even timbaland working on this album alongside Ye himself. the track “Bound 2” always surprises me every time i listen to it. i just don’t get how you can sample so many songs including a very popular song in “Nobody To Love” and still make it sound good. but that’s not all, his other tracks like “Blood On The Leaves”, “Black Skinhead” and in particular “On Sight” include some of the best production of all time not just by the man himself. despite these achievements, there’s no real consistency. “Send It Up” “Guilt Trip” and “I’m in it” bring down the albums quality heavily and i feel like quality over quantity could’ve been more effective than just bringing down album overall with them songs. •The Life Of Pablo- 8.4/10 i feel like this album is so different and such a switch up from Yeezus. it wouldve made more sense for it to be after or before My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy but im not complaining. The Life Of Pablo is an incredible record which just aged quite badly. especially with tracks like “Pt.2” which included a sample from “Panda” which was pushing top of the charts at the time. but still there’s songs to be talked about which hold up well today. “No More Parties In LA” “Famous” “Waves” “Wolves” and “Father Stretch My Hands Pt.1” are some of the more memorable and quality tracks on this studio album which leave an imprint on people. still showing production supremacy and featuring Kendrick Lamar on one of the tracks on this album, who was starting to form an identity as a well respected rapper and lyricist / storyteller at this time. •ye- 9.1/10 the quality over quantity aspect i was talking about in reference to Yeezus earlier has been fulfilled. every track on this album is so incredible and i feel like this album expresses Kanye’s emotions and feeling more than any. you actually can take a dive into how he feels as a bipolar person and as a man who’s in the music scene and industry as a whole. “Violent Crimes” and “I Thought About Killing You” are the most impactful on the album and are such good tracks to play. i feel like ye needs more credit and The Needle Drop actually praises this album to standard i think. •KIDS SEE GHOSTS- 6.5/10 BEFORE YOU FLAME ME. LET ME EXPLAIN. this album has no real quality. and to be honest with you just annoys me. the album run was tarnished at KIDS SEE GHOSTS. there’s an okay track in here in “Reborn” but is there anything else really? i mean I can say KanYe’s production was great as always and actually aged quite well like in Yeezus but that’s about it. i feel like Kid Cudi was so boring and this album in the general was just. meh. •Jesus Is King- 6.5 to 7/10 yes i like this more than KIDS SEE GHOSTS. despite not being the most “christiany” album. the music slaps. “God Is” and “Follow God” are so good and the fast paced rap production paired with bars about his love for God somehow fit decent? i don’t know how people can hate this record. it’s one of the best “Gospel” records out there and actually one of Kanye’s most slept on albums for no reason. •Donda- 5/10 this is Kanye’s worst record by an absolute country mile. there’s no songs that stick out to me on this album apart from “Praise God.” i feel like this album in particular is glazed and loved by Ye fans because it’s made by Kanye. you cannot convince me people actually listen to “Off The Grid” it’s so bad and to put it bluntly absolutely terrible for his standard. this was better off not being made and WHY WASNT YANDHI MADE (off topic just forgot about Yandhi) •Donda 2- 7.5 to 7.9/10 before you attack me. i like it a lot 😅. this album should’ve been released on major streaming platforms. tracks like “Mr.Miyagi” are really really good and “Pablo” is one of my personal favourites by him. i feel like if this was released and maybe refurbished a little bit more by Ye this could’ve been one of his best. despite my love for it i can still see it’s very much not finished and some of the tracks on this album are really weak and unlistenable. •VULTURES 1- 6.5 to 7/10 i don’t not like this album and when it first dropped i rated it a 8. but i feel like i was one of them people who liked it just cos it meant Ye was back. this is a really okay album and does include good songs. like “BURN” and “FUK SUMN” but tracks like “CARNIVAL” and “KING” and “BEG FORGIVENESS” and even “BACK TO ME” in my opinion are weak and really overhyped. i don’t see the attraction with over 75% of the songs in this album and to put it how it is this is a record which would’ve been better off replaced with Donda 2. this is really weak. this took so long oh my god. i think i like Ye too much
ngl only thing that annoys me is giving mbdtf a 6. It's easily his best rapping, it has the best features, some of the best production, and the concept of the album is amazing where he takes his life in power, all of the lights interlude represents funeral music, and the rest of the album is his Dark Fantasy. I seriously don't care what you say, if you don't like Mbdtf you don't like Kanye
Wait till u find out opinions exist, i also highly disagree with his mbdtf take but at least he doesn't constantly shit on it and he acknowledges why ppl like it
@@alberito4632 "wait til you find out opinions exist" 🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓☝☝☝☝☝☝☝☝ do they actually????!!!!!!!??????? 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 i hAD NO IDEa!!!!!! 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 THANKS FOR LETTING ME KNOW! I WILL NEVER SHARE MY OWN OPINION ON ANYTHING AGAIN! 💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿
@@alberito4632 kind of a dumb opinion but maybe his reference point was different than most people. hes also kinda old he likes different things within albums compared to u and i
Correction: you DIDN’T hate Kanye before he said any of his outlandish anti-Semitic stuff post-Donda, but AFTER that you clearly are going to have a deep rooted woke prejudice moving forward in anything he releases lol
What pisses me off is If you're not a Kanye fan, they're like "Well you just hate Kanye, you're just biased, cope and seethe, he didn't do nothing to you!" But if you *are* a Kanye fan and you are criticizing him they go "This is what you signed up for as a Kanye fan, Kanye has always been this way, and what about all the other shitty music you listen to?" Istfg you can boil down these oxygen deprived idiot's opinions to "LALALALA! I'M NOT LISTENING LALALALALA! YOU'ER A HATER LALALALALA!" as they shake in anger.
anyone who says his music "was always like this" is dumb the difference between college dropout and something like donda is from heaven to earth,dude changed his style completly
10 seconds into the video and he's showing that he rated most of kanye's albums 4 or 2's out of ten , definetly wont be sharing this video in the family group chat, cant believe ant tony no fanta would do this
Ye fans so insecure because some mainstream media gave him bad reviews based on people he collabed with. But I always felt like fantano only goofed on ye as a person because he’s been spewing garbage rhetoric online but gave the music fair reviews.
crazy how psychotic fans get man, no one is beyond criticism. acting like someone should be universally and objectively praised is a horrible mindset to have
Now everything is completely clear to me. So many delays with Vultures are mainly cause Ye couldn´t handle lemon giving him another underwhelming grading lol
Too many people think in a simple-minded, either-or way. They think you either love something or you hate it; something is awesome, or it's trash. So even when you thoughtfully break down the positives and negatives of a piece of work or body of work, they still try to push you to one extreme or the other, claiming you're blindly allegiant or a hater.
Remember when you seriously reviewed convicted murderer and infamous neo-nazi Burzum but now you sold out so Kanye West (Imfao) is too beyond the pale?
Dude listened to all of the lights, a song clearly about his relationship with the press and the world after Taylor swift, and concluded with " kanye made a song about beating women" like wow that was a dying and a miss, but totally not biased. Just a reviewer not looking at full context of the album as a whole.
Reviews aside it’s very weird how much you act like you don’t wanna associate with Kanye or his fanbase yet you keep farming interactions by constantly putting out videos about him over and over. Rent free
I mean you did give one of his most critically acclaimed albums a 6/10 for largely petty and esoteric reasons when almost every major outlet saw the value in it and gave a high score,hailing it as one of the best albums of all time. People can tell if you really just don't fw the music or if there's other perceptual and personal reasons behind a score.
Fantano doesn't get to have opinions until he reviews yuno miles
anthony doesn’t want to give his first 11
Yuno should be dropping the album soon so melon would have no excuse
No he doesn’t get to have them at all after that sexy red review
He interviewed him
@@xd_enge1229shit was so funny
After watching this I can take away that Anthony hates Kanye west with a burning passion
@RobL846
Had Kanye not became a rapid anti Semite, I wouldn't hate him too.
@@alienboy1322 Kanye isn't antisemitic.
@@lukecarroll19
And Anthony isn't white.
@@alienboy1322 he's biracial
@@alienboy1322good one brah 😂 u sound fully vaccinated u ok?🤡
To the most diehard Ye fan, anything but glazing is hate
I just can’t process thinking donda is better than mbdtf and yeezus
Donda was aoty don't trip nobody can make gospel hard and he did effortlessly
@@saqib7965that album was trash, don't trip yourself
@@maverick6466 go listen to drake donda was amazing
@@saqib7965 it wasnt even best rap album of 2021, baby keem cleared
He never said mbdtf is worse, just that he enjoyed it less. His ratings are based on personal enjoyment not objective critique
I predict he is gonna give vultures a 6 or 5.
Edit: man was i dead wrong 💀
if its ever gonna drop
@gloopgaming7412 at this rate the chances of it not dropping are higher then it actually dropping
Yeah this new kanye and ty record, IT'S NOT GOOD (BAAAAAANG)
He cant rate it if it doesnt drop
1. it's not dropping
2. if it releases he's not gonna make a review about it because "he doesnt want to give the idiot anymore attention" (my predictions)
Drake is who he hates, not Kanye 😭
Don't forget about NAV, lol.
Drake is trash
Anthony's true hatred is reserved for Hopsin.
He HATES Nav too
@@saqib7965Drake isn’t trash your just a cornball
Holy shit, that graduation rating went up
deadass tho, i could’ve sworn it was in the 3.50s or 60s before
@@endytoly8485 it it out of 5? And who's doing the rating
@@thialhoinj1971 it averages out all the ratings on the site, 3.7 is really good
@@thialhoinj1971 user ratings on music aggregate site rym
@@thialhoinj1971it’s aggregate. You can see over 50,000+ people have rated it. Yes it is out of 5. The website is called RateYourMusic.
In the past couple of months, Ye’s fanbase has really proven to be one of, if not THE worst by justifying and meatriding anything he says and/or does as well as going at anyone’s throats for even so much as slightly criticizing him.
It’s honestly sad and kind of pathetic to see.
How dare Ye's fans not accept our opinion of him and have their own opinions! They should accept he's cancelled and stop listening
fantano bad reviewer
Ye the goat tho
@@asbestosman how is he cancelled?
@@io3324 Exhibit A
For how much you dont like talking about kanye, you sure like talking about kanye 😂
This what i was thinking, Everyone keep saying Fantano hate Kanye but dude has given him some pretty fair reviews, Dude actually had one of the most positive reviews of Ye I've seen, As I've seen so many trash that record, Rolling Stone i believe ranked it as the "Worst Album of the decade" Which is crazy lol it's honestly one of Ye's better projects IMO short and sweet, Some GREAT tracks on there, No clue how any Kanye fan could listen to Ye and say "That was awful" It's like a top 5 Ye project tbh.
Ye 2018 was complete shit and near a 1/5 album rating. Only people who listen to the same music like drones daily like it. Anyone who’s actually listened to different genres of music and has taste knows it’s terrible. Ghost town saves it from a 0 score.
Ye is one of his worst projects. Its automatically impossible to be his top 5 when his first 5 Albums exist.
@@barkley8285 I listen to a ton of genres (mainly rock), and i liked ye. Ghost Town is one of his best songs ever, and Violent Crimes is also a masterpiece. And while the rest of the album doesn't quite reach those heights, i would still rate the tracks above average. So all in all, i could understand a 6/10 or 7/10, but 2/10 is ridiculous.
@@barkley8285 Wtf you talking about? Ye had some pretty unique tracks on it tbh, Hence why it was actually mostly casual listeners who hated it so much. Your typical music drones legit skipped over the album because they were told to lol And also idk why you feel the need to say "Anyone" Who's actually listened to different music knows, When your really just speaking for yourself, I listen to everything from Kanye to Gregory Alan Isakov, The Beatles to JPEGMAFIA, Pantera to Norah Jones, Music is my life and as someone who almost always listens to different genres, I thought Ye was a solid album, It's totally fine if you disagree, People have different opinions, But you def don't speak for everyone who listens to different genres lol
yeah its just cos he shat on mbdtf lol people have this false perception
Kanye fans in the comments once again proving they're one of the worst fanbases of all time
for defending an artist best album?
@@justastupidduckwithahat6393 It's crazy how quickly you identified yourself as someone not worth talking to
@@joshgibbons-eyre8697 womp womp
Kanye West more like Kanye Best
My problem with him is putting sexyy red over mbdtf
Spot on - I’ve been saying this for years. Not many artists Fantano has reviewed has a 10, two 9’s, and three 8’s in their discography. Oh and 3 more 7’s isn’t too shabby either, considering he can be a tough critic.
Two 10s
i think he just needs to re review some albums like yeezus and watch the throne his reviews of them aren’t relevant
@@kingdess0if it aint relevant then how would you or anyone for that matter know or bring it up, god Kanye Stan’s really don’t know shit do they
@@Prodbyjah464 lol u woke up angry didnt u. your logic makes no sense, theres a difference between remembered and relevant. hes rereviewed certain albums before (like mbdtf, a kanye album) years later after seeing how they changed the landscape of music or how they aged well. theyre only not “relevant” becuz they dont contain up to date information thats imperative to the critique of an album. stop generalizing fans of people that shits annoying
@@kingdess0Ik I’m late but reading this comment you really have no idea what relevant means or what relevance is, also even if those specific Kanye albums like mbdtf or yeezus have gained more relevance over time because of how they impacted music, that doesn’t mean Anthony’s original reviews or opinions are any less valid, yes he could acknowledge how influential they were but that isn’t gonna change the fact he still probably isn’t a fan of the album as a whole, there are many albums that are influential but aren’t that great (a lot of lil Wayne albums) not saying those Kanye albums aren’t great or agreeing with Anthony’s ratings on them, I’m just saying that there impact and influence doesn’t mean someone can have an opinion about them and that they’re free from any criticism which is something you Kanye Stan’s can’t handle.
1:20 literally summarized the situation in just these 10 seconds
why do people care so much?
Confirmation bias
If they didn't then Fantano wouldn't have a job
Kanye's fans are as deranged as he is.
Because Kanye is their daddy
Bro I don't fucking know. People get so torn up over one bad Anthony fantano review it's crazy 😂
kanye fans again prove to be one of the worst fanbases on the internet 💯💯💯
What happened to it, man? He actually used to have one of the cooler mainstream audiences and now he’s just the Donald Trump of rap music; everything he says is correct all the time and if you don’t agree, “you just don’t get it, man”. It’s all just so… groan-worthy
@@mrlevinielsenAge of his Fanbase Changed. What you remember is his old fanbase that was around when his first 3 Albums released. But alot of these People lost interest when they got Older. Now he got a new very young Gen Z fanbase wich first Kanye Album was Yeezus or Life of Pablo and they Glaze Kanye to the Max.
@@questionyourself718cuz he the goat
Kanye West fans are basically male Swifties st this point.
@@questionyourself718 source: my ass
Dark fantasy rating is still atrocious stop denying it
angery haha
I'm just salty because Late Registration deserves to be seen as Ye's "perfect" album.
@@catholicpog7183it’s flawed
Your rating of his rating is atrocious just admit it
Only has a handful of great tracks, the ending of the album sucks
Ye Stans have be really annoying this couple of months
Fantano casually addressing the backlash for his Vultures 1 review before it even dropped
Btw guys even if dark fantasy is low its still a positive score 6 is a ok rating
Idk why so many Kanye fans are such crybabies. They are literally crying about a mans opinion ffs
Huh how ironic 💀
Just clocking in to say Computer World on the wall is based
tbh opiinions are opinions and i think we should respect one another and fantano just dont miss
😂😂😂guess u haven’t seen the sexy red review cuz I officially stopped taking him serious as any type of “critic” after
@@M1CHAELMARGIELA he said he just likes sexy red because it’s dumb fun it’s not like he gave it a 10/10 and called it an intellectual masterpiece
Me over here having only heard 1 song by Kanye still nodding along to this drama like I know what's going on 😂
I agree with him for the most part. Especially the Graduation opinion, many people my age think that’s better than College Dropout or Late Registration, but I find that sort of baffling.
Ye’s first three albums are all tremendous “, no matter what.
Graduation is in my eyes cleaner and more pop sounding (In a good way) so its a better listen espacilly for modern listners while espacilly the college drop out has some really goofy sounding beats. Not to say its bad because its objectively not, but you also have to think how things have aged for more modern ears, a lot of Kanye listeners, me for example where way to young to active listening to those albums when they came out.
Baffling?
@@marcuslee698 words?
Edit: it means confused if you’re honestly wondering.
Graduation sounds better therefore it is better. Not that hard to understand. Sounds better = better music.
@@sabus1265no.
"I cAn'T beLievE yOu gAvE MBDTF a 6!11!1!!!11!!!!!" - 🤓
Come up with an original take dude
@@haroldtodd7802 No
I feel like Kanye fans think that every Kanye album is the best album of all time and if you say otherwise you are critizising Kanye and are being a Kanye hater
idk why kanye fans have such an obsession with people’s opinions about him. as a kanye fan his fanbase is annoying asf it kinda makes me feel guilty to be apart of it sometimes.
Nah
I think his opinion changed just a little bit
yeah nothing to worry about..
Fantano we need a Classic Review of The College Dropout
I think Kanye fans might just see him as such a god that even giving him a 7 feels like an injustice to them
He’s gonna give vultures a 2 or 3
this aged well
this aged horribly
no it hasnt?
Kanye gave your wife a soft 10.
Thank you mariokarter13
thats actually funny
💀
I would argue that you don’t hate him enough😂
Swiftie mentality
your name is music sucks, your prrofile is a guitar, what does ts mean???????
"musicsucks5843" good one
jew
Bro this guy 100 comments on fatano's channel 😭
I think Kayne will forever be my biggest personal test for the "separate the music from the musician" theory. Do I love his music? Absolutely. It's safe to say that Graduation had shaped my taste in music even to this day. But he's also a terrible, terrible person with some truly fucked up opinions; and in genre where the creators put so much of their own soul, thoughts and consciousness into their creations, where do we even draw the line to separate them? Where does the musician end, and music begin?
So even for a rando like me, feelings on Kayne is too complicated to sort out. I can't even imagine being a critic, whose opinions on music is scrutinized and weighted so heavily.
His personal issues are art just like the music. I don't expect artists to be perfectly normal morally upstanding people.
the impact of graduation on hip-hop is insane lol
@@catholicpog7183 He's doing nazi shit, there's a big difference between morally reprehensible and saying antisemitic shit.
it is his crazyness that lets him make such good albums
If Kendrick made MBDTF you would've given it a 10.
Nah
Yup
Kendrick wouldn’t have made mbdtf, corny bar after corny bar on that record
@@godofnothing428 corny bars that got him album of the decade, if kendrick made it, which he made 2 better albums already, it would be the best album to exist
I love KanYe but i’m not biased so let me rate them for you
•The College Dropout- 10/10
for a debut album and just emerging out of the r&b / hip-hop scene, the production and use of sampling in The College Dropout was GROUNDBREAKING and the quality of music sounds like it came from an experienced producer and musician. this to be a debut album (despite previous mixtapes) is absolutely phenomenal and changed the course of r&b and music in general.
•Late Registration- 8.5 to 8.9/10
despite not being nearly as good as The College Dropout. the production in this album could be argued to be better. This album is in my opinion what caught a lot of people’s eyes when it came to music production and what not. Songs like “Gold Digger” and “We Major (feat Nas!)” shaped even modern Kanye and, was unfortunately a lot less influential than that of The College Dropout.
•Graduation- 9 to 9.2/10
Graduation although glazed and extremely overrated is a classic and a must listen to record. the production is absolutely top tier but not as good as that of Late Registration or The College Dropout. the tracks though WOW. i think Graduation is where Ye was not only realised as a good producer but a good marketer and public voice. the collab with Takashi Murakami for the album cover and the collaboration with Daft Punk (which was the most popular DJ / producing duo of the early 2000s to mid 2010s) not only boosted Ye’s popularity but somehow theirs.
•808’s And Heartbreak- 7.5 to 8.2/10
first off i wanna say I’m not rating this album based on influentiality as this would be in the 9.8-10 range. purely off of music quality. which i must say isn’t bad but certainly isn’t anything compared to The College Trilogy. Ye’s voice doesn’t suit the genre and the heavy 808s over the melodic bass line. it just sounds to “poppy” (relating to pop as a genre) and the only real standouts in this album are “Bad News” “Love Lockdown” and “Heartless” which in themselves are okay and not quite up to his standards which he set for himself with his previous 3 records. but the Production? again superb and as i stated earlier influenced an entire era and more to come of pop and hip-hop.
•My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy- 9.5/10
this rebound from his previous work is so good and so power (no pun intended) the production and track creation of this album deserves more than credit from album reviewers like myself and Fantano but an award. this is the first time we have properly seen Kanye disassemble a song and combine it with other songs to make a beat. like in “POWER” where he sampled 3 songs to make the ad-libs and beat. his rapping and lyricism also isn’t as corny and actually makes sense and sounds good. perfect tracks that have come out of this album include “Runaway” and some other decent tracks like “Dark Fantasy” and “Hell Of A Life” which is my personal favourite also exist on this phenomenal record.
•Watch The Throne- 6 to 7.5/10
This collaboration with Jay-Z gained so much hype and so much popularity around the time for it to be so lacklustre. coming off My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy and even 808’s And Heartbreak. this album is merely nothing special and overhyped. it still included amazing production as always might I add. especially in songs like “N***as in Paris” and “Otis” which uses melodies like no other and even creates recognisable tracks just from one note like in previous songs such as “Runaway.” kanye also still seems to be showing more lyrical prowess than that of his other works this alongside Jay-Z makes him sound so crispy.
•Yeezus- 8.6/10
i never understood why this album was so hated and unlistened to? i hold the belief that the best production of all time exists on this record with Mike Dean and i believe even timbaland working on this album alongside Ye himself. the track “Bound 2” always surprises me every time i listen to it. i just don’t get how you can sample so many songs including a very popular song in “Nobody To Love” and still make it sound good. but that’s not all, his other tracks like “Blood On The Leaves”, “Black Skinhead” and in particular “On Sight” include some of the best production of all time not just by the man himself. despite these achievements, there’s no real consistency. “Send It Up” “Guilt Trip” and “I’m in it” bring down the albums quality heavily and i feel like quality over quantity could’ve been more effective than just bringing down album overall with them songs.
•The Life Of Pablo- 8.4/10
i feel like this album is so different and such a switch up from Yeezus. it wouldve made more sense for it to be after or before My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy but im not complaining. The Life Of Pablo is an incredible record which just aged quite badly. especially with tracks like “Pt.2” which included a sample from “Panda” which was pushing top of the charts at the time. but still there’s songs to be talked about which hold up well today. “No More Parties In LA” “Famous” “Waves” “Wolves” and “Father Stretch My Hands Pt.1” are some of the more memorable and quality tracks on this studio album which leave an imprint on people. still showing production supremacy and featuring Kendrick Lamar on one of the tracks on this album, who was starting to form an identity as a well respected rapper and lyricist / storyteller at this time.
•ye- 9.1/10
the quality over quantity aspect i was talking about in reference to Yeezus earlier has been fulfilled. every track on this album is so incredible and i feel like this album expresses Kanye’s emotions and feeling more than any. you actually can take a dive into how he feels as a bipolar person and as a man who’s in the music scene and industry as a whole. “Violent Crimes” and “I Thought About Killing You” are the most impactful on the album and are such good tracks to play. i feel like ye needs more credit and The Needle Drop actually praises this album to standard i think.
•KIDS SEE GHOSTS- 6.5/10
BEFORE YOU FLAME ME. LET ME EXPLAIN. this album has no real quality. and to be honest with you just annoys me. the album run was tarnished at KIDS SEE GHOSTS. there’s an okay track in here in “Reborn” but is there anything else really? i mean I can say KanYe’s production was great as always and actually aged quite well like in Yeezus but that’s about it. i feel like Kid Cudi was so boring and this album in the general was just. meh.
•Jesus Is King- 6.5 to 7/10
yes i like this more than KIDS SEE GHOSTS. despite not being the most “christiany” album. the music slaps. “God Is” and “Follow God” are so good and the fast paced rap production paired with bars about his love for God somehow fit decent? i don’t know how people can hate this record. it’s one of the best “Gospel” records out there and actually one of Kanye’s most slept on albums for no reason.
•Donda- 5/10
this is Kanye’s worst record by an absolute country mile. there’s no songs that stick out to me on this album apart from “Praise God.” i feel like this album in particular is glazed and loved by Ye fans because it’s made by Kanye. you cannot convince me people actually listen to “Off The Grid” it’s so bad and to put it bluntly absolutely terrible for his standard. this was better off not being made and WHY WASNT YANDHI MADE (off topic just forgot about Yandhi)
•Donda 2- 7.5 to 7.9/10
before you attack me. i like it a lot 😅. this album should’ve been released on major streaming platforms. tracks like “Mr.Miyagi” are really really good and “Pablo” is one of my personal favourites by him. i feel like if this was released and maybe refurbished a little bit more by Ye this could’ve been one of his best. despite my love for it i can still see it’s very much not finished and some of the tracks on this album are really weak and unlistenable.
•VULTURES 1- 6.5 to 7/10
i don’t not like this album and when it first dropped i rated it a 8. but i feel like i was one of them people who liked it just cos it meant Ye was back. this is a really okay album and does include good songs. like “BURN” and “FUK SUMN” but tracks like “CARNIVAL” and “KING” and “BEG FORGIVENESS” and even “BACK TO ME” in my opinion are weak and really overhyped. i don’t see the attraction with over 75% of the songs in this album and to put it how it is this is a record which would’ve been better off replaced with Donda 2. this is really weak.
this took so long oh my god. i think i like Ye too much
he lost me when he disliked yeezus
ngl only thing that annoys me is giving mbdtf a 6. It's easily his best rapping, it has the best features, some of the best production, and the concept of the album is amazing where he takes his life in power, all of the lights interlude represents funeral music, and the rest of the album is his Dark Fantasy. I seriously don't care what you say, if you don't like Mbdtf you don't like Kanye
Wait till u find out opinions exist, i also highly disagree with his mbdtf take but at least he doesn't constantly shit on it and he acknowledges why ppl like it
@@alberito4632 "wait til you find out opinions exist" 🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓☝☝☝☝☝☝☝☝ do they actually????!!!!!!!??????? 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 i hAD NO IDEa!!!!!! 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 THANKS FOR LETTING ME KNOW! I WILL NEVER SHARE MY OWN OPINION ON ANYTHING AGAIN! 💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿
@@alberito4632 kind of a dumb opinion but maybe his reference point was different than most people. hes also kinda old he likes different things within albums compared to u and i
Out of all the terrible music related fan bases. Kanye stans are some of the worst.
Correction: you DIDN’T hate Kanye before he said any of his outlandish anti-Semitic stuff post-Donda, but AFTER that you clearly are going to have a deep rooted woke prejudice moving forward in anything he releases lol
shut up man
@@seign6703 Didn’t add anything to the discussion. Sounds like ur the one coping lollllll
What pisses me off is
If you're not a Kanye fan, they're like "Well you just hate Kanye, you're just biased, cope and seethe, he didn't do nothing to you!"
But if you *are* a Kanye fan and you are criticizing him they go "This is what you signed up for as a Kanye fan, Kanye has always been this way, and what about all the other shitty music you listen to?"
Istfg you can boil down these oxygen deprived idiot's opinions to "LALALALA! I'M NOT LISTENING LALALALALA! YOU'ER A HATER LALALALALA!" as they shake in anger.
anyone who says his music "was always like this" is dumb
the difference between college dropout and something like donda is from heaven to earth,dude changed his style completly
Now they’re gonna say,” insane glaze”
Love seeing that Chris Farren record in the back ❤️
and Hellmode right next to it!
Kanye has given people so many reasons to hate him lmao
Anthony Fantano and Andrew Schulz fight it out for Ye's no.1 hater
Biggest artist of our generation hate him or not
10 seconds into the video and he's showing that he rated most of kanye's albums 4 or 2's out of ten , definetly wont be sharing this video in the family group chat, cant believe ant tony no fanta would do this
Ye fans so insecure because some mainstream media gave him bad reviews based on people he collabed with. But I always felt like fantano only goofed on ye as a person because he’s been spewing garbage rhetoric online but gave the music fair reviews.
yeezus review was not fair at all
Nah you can tell he still hates kanye
I love Kanye’s music but the fanbase needs to realize not every ye album is a 10/10
Hes gonna give vultures 1 a light 2
He’s a liberal. Of course he hates Kanye lmao
Kanye is a Neo Nazi. Are you saying you can only hate Nazis if you’re a liberal?
To be fair Kanye seems like a pretty insufferable person.
Well, at least Kanye Fans can remember up to a year while you can’t even remember what you said 10 minutes ago
This reputation you have of being unfair to Kanye is so funny, because your shorts content makes you look like the biggest Kanye glazer on the planet.
crazy how psychotic fans get man, no one is beyond criticism. acting like someone should be universally and objectively praised is a horrible mindset to have
if anything he hates mgk😂
Anthony didn’t hate Kanye until he talked about the tunnels
Vultures coming up - Fantano gives it 4.
bro saying this so he can review vultures objectively without criticism
“Not review” lol
Why y’all care it’s his opinion , music is subjective
The commenter saying “why do you hate him, did he punch you? Like no reason” HE LITERALLY SAID HE LIVED HITLER WHAT
The yeezus review still hurts Fantano
Man.. theres no getting through to those fans. Theyre not people you want to try to convince anyways. Everyone else got your back on this💯
you hated Kanye once he said something about jewish people bullying him
You just can't understand the music he makes
If you think he‘s unfair towards Kanye look at his Drake reviews
Drake is trash since NWTS ironically
@@saqib7965iyrtitl*
Was not expecting Fantano to turn into Carl Wheezer at the beginning of this video 😮
Kanye fans are just way too defensive can't handle a single piece of criticism towards him even though he does have bad albums
Can’t wait for Fantano to give Vultures a low score not for the quality of the project, but for how much distaste he has against Kanye :)
I hate Kanye now. 2000s Kanye is great
shit opinion
fantano gave college dropout a 10, late registration,graduation 8 and 808s a 7 he doesn’t hate kanye
late registration a 9*
I like how unapologetically ruthless he is in this clip. Kanye fans are annoying.
You know I still don't know what he gave the college dropout
I would give it a 9. It has a few flaws imo
What we learned in this short fantano "hates" kanye
Now everything is completely clear to me. So many delays with Vultures are mainly cause Ye couldn´t handle lemon giving him another underwhelming grading lol
Too many people think in a simple-minded, either-or way. They think you either love something or you hate it; something is awesome, or it's trash. So even when you thoughtfully break down the positives and negatives of a piece of work or body of work, they still try to push you to one extreme or the other, claiming you're blindly allegiant or a hater.
Glad that fantano confirmed that KSG is still a 10 cause the alt channel vid on it wasn't as clear
14 years later grown men still crying about MBDTF getting a 6 will never not be funny
Remember when you seriously reviewed convicted murderer and infamous neo-nazi Burzum but now you sold out so Kanye West (Imfao) is too beyond the pale?
There's racist lyrics on the burzum album he reviewed? If not, your point is not valid.
@@JulianoKM10 name an objectively racist lyric in vultures
If you want someone Melon hates think of that dude McDonald
fantano doesn't owe kanye a review, he's free to review who he wants
Bro dressing like he is about to get bullied in 7th grade
you dress up like a fucking piece of broccoli
Dude listened to all of the lights, a song clearly about his relationship with the press and the world after Taylor swift, and concluded with " kanye made a song about beating women" like wow that was a dying and a miss, but totally not biased. Just a reviewer not looking at full context of the album as a whole.
Also just like lowkey insane to think that after the last 2-15 years of kanye shit that anyone would have a non biased opinion on the guy
It’s like the Kanye fans only watched the first 4 minutes of your Kanye worse to best
Rent Due
If we only had a memory that short we wouldnt continue to roast you for your MBDTF review
That’s part of the short memory lol. You remember it because it gets mentioned every 5 seconds in the comments.
I agree with everything you said but giving MBDTF a 6 is insane
7/10 would be the highest the Album could get without discrediting other Albums that honestly deserve a higher Rating.
It made him famous 😂
To be fair fantano the twisted fantasy review is a pretty foul one
im nt gonna lie, i really enjoyed donda 2
The college dropout is the greatest hip hop album of all time argue with a wall
Rating KSG higher than MBDTF is actually a crime
Reviews aside it’s very weird how much you act like you don’t wanna associate with Kanye or his fanbase yet you keep farming interactions by constantly putting out videos about him over and over. Rent free
Watch the Throne should be 3.25 average on RYM, and 75 on AOTY, mfs hating for no reason, it got like 2-3 odd songs maximum but It's a great album
『 just to give him an "unlistenable" 😐 』
This is such a unfair rating to treat a superhero
bro is the taylor swift fan of rap😂😂😂😂
He doesn't hate kanye when he needs to pay the landlord!
Personally as a Jew, I look at it as "I personally enjoy the music, even if he's an asshole" just like old people such as Elvis or Morrissey.
he's so misunderstood 😭
oh and kanye is interesting, too
I mean you did give one of his most critically acclaimed albums a 6/10 for largely petty and esoteric reasons when almost every major outlet saw the value in it and gave a high score,hailing it as one of the best albums of all time. People can tell if you really just don't fw the music or if there's other perceptual and personal reasons behind a score.
MBDTF is objectively not higher than a 7/10. Anyone ranking it higher is putting alot of personal Bias into it.
@@questionyourself718Its almost like music is subjective and peoples personal bias plays a large part in how we percieve all forms of art🤯
@questionyourself718 lol
It's a 10/10 album enough said
@@Adrian-fo4kv read again what i said. I refered to the part of his comment where he made an argumentum auctoritate.