A fresh start: Why is Indonesia building a new capital?
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 09. 2024
- Subscribe to our CZcams channel for free here:
sc.mp/subscrib...
Read more on this story: sc.mp/no25t
Download the SCMP App and get a 14-day free trial (valid until August 11, 2024): scmp.onelink.m...
Indonesia’s current capital Jakarta is home to about 10 million people and has become prone to overcrowding, pollution and chronic flooding, prompting efforts to build an entirely new capital from the ground up called Nusantara. Outgoing Indonesian President Joko Widodo came up with the idea in 2019, and proposed its construction on the sparsely populated East Kalimantan province. Nusantara’s first residents are expected to move in by the end of 2024, but will the city be ready in time?
Support us:
subscribe.scmp...
Follow us on:
Website: www.scmp.com
Facebook: / scmp
Twitter: / scmpnews
Instagram: / scmpnews
Linkedin: / south-china-morning-post
#scmp #SCMPOriginals #Indonesia
Let's Support Nusantara from Calamba City Laguna in the Philippines 🇵🇭💕🇮🇩
I'm a Filipino and because Indonesia is my country, I like to see Nusantara because this very nice place compared in New Clark City because it was controversial since it was surrounded by controversial POGOs so I like Nusantara so much 😊😊
I hope to see you in Indonesia next year and I will be waiting for you 😊😊😊
Love from Calamba City Laguna in the Philippines 🇵🇭💕🇮🇩
What?
@@holdenmcgroin8699 Let me explain, I love Indonesia but I like Nusantara because it was a beautiful capital but New Clark City is less known because the area has a news of POGOs(Offshore Gaming) which is controversial by the govenrment(I’m an Anti-Pogos)
But Nusantara and New Clark City is very beautiful place so hopefully Nusanta will be completed in the future and I like to visit that soon 😊😊
@@holdenmcgroin8699 He's just an Indoweeb
Clark is nice city
@@perwiranegara Yes both Nusantara and Clark is nice city but hopefully these two will be completed in the future
Only a fool woulf believe Jakarta would be abandoned, it is practically impossible, Jakarta is not only the largest city and metropolitan in southeast asia, but also the second largest in the world in terms of population, economic wise, it is the largest in southeast asia, The Big Durian won't be abandoned, it would be like US abandoned New York city.
🇵🇭🇹🇭🇻🇳🇲🇾🇺🇲>>>>>>>>>🇲🇨dark short people.
only a fool who think to just build a new futuristic city will solve all problems
Bogor should be the next capital😂
@@fikriakhdimaulana nobody said that IKN would solve all the problem, you are the only fool here my friend
@@briantarigan7685 you're the only idiot here
$33B is honestly cheaper than resuming Jakarta Sea Wall (or Garuda Island) project, which is estimated $40B before get scrapped.
One thing to consider : Investors flocked to sea wall project but pessimistic about new capital.
😂wont be successful 😂
So they gave up on Jakarta and just let it sink?
@@wanrazul we are to expect to have smaller cheaper wall here in Jakarta
@@HowToChangeName
free west papua❤
Free Timor❤
we've done it in Malaysia, it works wonderfully, goodluck Indonesia!
Whats it called?
@@Derek_Antonioputra jaya
@@Derek_Antonio putra jaya
@@Derek_Antonioputra jaya
Capital city still kuala lumpur. Nusantara is new capital city.
Putrajaya only a place of government building
Sebagian orang Indonesia di ajak maju dan bangun pembangunan sangat sulit.Terlalu negatif pikiran sebagian orang, dulu berusaha bangun Indonesia, tetapi mereka melakukannya dengan tanpa rencana dan sangat kacau, punya pikiran keras dan tidak mau di atur. Sehingga hasilnya kondisi Jkt kacau. Kenapa perlu mendengarkan orang asing dan sebagainya, setelah kalian tiada
anak dan cucumu di berikan tinggal di Jakarta yang banyak polusi dan macet, negara luar sudah maju, Indonesia masih kacau. Bangunlah pertahap,semua pengusaha yang ada di Jakarta buka cabang usahanya di ikn, jangan terlalu mendengar kata orang asing. Saya sendiri sebagai orang kalimantan sangat setuju dengan pembangunan ikn, saya sendiri sudah 10 tahun lebih berkerja dan menetap di Jakarta. Dukunglah ikn supaya ekonomi di masa depan semakin membaik, memang sekarang sedang tidak baik, tapi tetaplah berpikir dengan keyakinan dan kemajuan diri sendiri.
itu akibat doktrin politik kebencian yg diciptakan partai berbasis agama😂😂😂😂
Media asing apalagi Barat tidak akan memberitakan berita yang baik. Sudah tahu lah maksud dan tujuan nya apa.
@@dwigunarto2091 gara2 Indonesia mayoritas islam.. langsung ke intinya saja.
@@dwigunarto2091ini media china, bukan barat
@@absentmindedshirokuma8539 China negara asing kan?
Terimakasih kepada kalian semua di manapun berada yang selalu mendukung upaya kami dalam memajukan negara kami. Kami suddah muak bertahun-tahun selalu diremehkan oleh negara² lain. Bangsa kami bukanlah bangsa yang kecil. Kami selalu diajarkan untuk mempunyai jiwa nasionalisme yang tinggi, jadi mohon jangan usik kami dan sekali lagi kami ucapkan kepada kalian semua yang selalu mendukung kami.
Indonesia love you all. ♥🇮🇩
当印尼想要更多的发展时，来自美国的制裁也在筹备当中。
@@rnrxt-og1ix....mengapa harus takut AS??? ada rusia & china sahabat kami...ratusan juta rakyat kami yang sangat NASIONALIS...BERPIKIR ULANG AS
@@rnrxt-og1ixsiapa itu amerika mereka hanya peliharaan zionis israHELL yg suka megongong kedaulatan negara lain, asal anda tau masyarakat indonesia dan pemerintahannya tidak suka di atur atur atau di dikte oleh negara mana pun, kami indonesia tidak peduli dengan bajingan amerika dengan segala omong kosongnya
Jangan usik tp ngemis investor nya ke negara laen, akhirnya anyeppppp
IKN is city of corruption jokowidodo with 80$B loan from chinese govt such shamefull country with income the people only 100$ monthly
The moving capital actually even exists since first president of Indonesia Sukarno, but after many decades it still postponed until now. The Jakarta sinking reason just additional reason, not the main reason.
not postponed... it was blocked/vetoed by the House.
It was cancelled because of the coup, afterwards all the Soviet efforts to build the city evaporated. Welcome to "Palangka Raya" in which Russian tarmacs are used pretty much in many major roads with the road planning design similar to those in soviet-developed mining satellite cities.
The most "developed" city in all of Borneo according to HDI simply because palm oil plantation managers lives here.
Whatever cracklelacquer5602 said
@@BayuAH ...the Indon ,just like the Malaysian cannot govern the country properly and ensure the country develop well, even after WW2. It governs along religious lines and corruption is a big problem there, ever since 60 over yrs ago. If country like Singapore without any natural resources, can emerge to be the World richest and definitely having the strongest currency in the entire SE Asia, the only reason why Indon and Malaysia failed, is only due to the kind of ppl who rule those countries.
I saw 5 years ago SCMP made a pessimistic report about the delayed construction of KCIC Whoosh. But the fact in 2023, KCIC Whoosh is the first magnificent HSR in Southeast Asia.
And now again, SCMP makes another pessimistic report about IKN. Let's see the progress of IKN in the next 5 years... 😊
Because this channel is fake News media 😂..not single accurate....they said about water problem but it's already solved month ago😂..
@@fajartiyarabdulmajid7807Indonesian government has completed construction of Sepaku Semoi Dam and intake pump as a source of clean water. And water pipe from the dam has been connected to IKN in July 2024.
This is Hong Kong channel news, of course you know in which frequency their strings vibrated.
@@SonyThamrin That's wonderful news. You seem to know quite well with regards to IKN. May I know if you happen to be a local or someone that is in part, making the Nusantara dream came true 😊
Negative news brings more readers/watchers. It's a strategy as old as newspapers existed.
I moved to borneo since 2016 ago because i was so stressfull with jakarta traffic jam
I woke up at 5 am and start to drive motorcycle at 6 am and arrived at my store at 9 am and go back home at 10 pm and arrived at home 00:30 am
I did that for 10 years
I feel blessed after i moved to borneo 😊😊😊😊❤
IKN nantinya dibikin sebagai kota ramah jalan kaki. Saya tinggal di sulawesi dan berencana untuk pindah ke IKN. Saya ingin menjadi generasi pertama yang menempati IKN.
Bagus , sebelum tanah naik 😅@@amomenttoremember1877
@@amomenttoremember1877 selamat datang
Setahuku banyak orang sulawesi di kaltim
@@amomenttoremember1877rencana bisnis apa yang ingin dijajaki saat di IKN pak? Apa bapak sendiri sudah memiliki bisnis sendiri di Sulawesi?
@@rumahfifi Saya orang Solo yang punya rencana yang sama (edit : dengan yang diutarakan Amom)
Can't wait to see this Nusantara developed.
IKN is city of corruption jokowidodo with 80$B loan from chinese govt such shamefull country with income the people only 100$ monthly
Indonesia my lovely country, great decision for moving to Kalimantan .. , not talk about A upto Z we talk about small impact from disaster that its the biggest issue from right now. Nusantara is Bhineka Tunggal Ika our principle for nations
this is better than WSJ report
The main issue of land subsiding is 10 million people of Jakarta getting the fresh water from the ground. Water pipe line is not yet covering whole Jakarta, only around 20 % with not adequate water as well. Land subsiding is only rapidly happening in the north Jakarta near the coast line (sea).
The solution is to build robust pipe water system that cover whole Jakarta. The target is to get there in 2030. For that project of course we need water source and we can easily get it from neighboring province like West Java and Banten. New dam has been built in Banten which name is Karian Dam and it is the third largest in Indonesia (We have 300 dams at the moment with plan to build another 300 new dams)
Project to build water treatment facility has been started two years ago with target completion in 2024. While project to build the pipe water system is started recently with backing from more than 15 banks. If you see some areas in Jakarta business district you can see the work that has been going on and it is the second project that intended to replace the old pipe with the new one
Free West Papua
Frompoor Indonesia
@@muhammadsecret8783 control population poor indonesians
@@NatureWonders709if you free them Indonesia will get poorer
@@NatureWonders709idiot
Great explanation. All the best Indonesia. Breaking the speed record to fit Jokowi term, hopefully can build sustainably after this initial deadline has passed.
IKN is city of corruption jokowidodo with 80$B loan from chinese govt such shamefull country with income the people only 100$ monthly
Working tremendous, this time for Indonesia to create kind a symbol of Independence. Definitely there's have enaugh experience to build new capital city of province and district before. And finaly Indonesia capital city as a last step. Sometimes people critisaise this but where they are when government create some new province capital?
As an Indonesian...i am very proud with my president...Jokowi Widodo 🙌
Oke gas ✌️🤙, indonesia cemas 2045
Proud with massive debt? How naive
@@Alghi451 yang cemas hanya kaum IQ 25% 🙌
You're genuinely feeling proud with a president who awarded the Minister of Communication and Information that can't do his jobs properly at all?
Cemas kau dek🤙@@Alghi451
Tipikal orang indo, ga bisa denger pembahasan yang balance dan kritis lgsg bilang "narasi pesimis", "ngerendahin". Sikap takut otoriter kyk gitu2 tu warisan soekarno soeharto masih dijaga aja katanya dah reformasi. Dah lah pusingk
Bngsa antikritik kaka, makanya berjaya cuma di socmed. Ga pemerintahnya ga rakyatnya sami mawon. Kalo rame2 perang ama netizen luar, menang nih konoha 😂
Ganyang Malaysia tetap terjadi
@@siaprochinjapankorean bro, kerjasama sama malaysia makin tinggi, emang ga ada maksud kenapa IKN dibangun deket malaysia dan brunei. Hehehe..
Amerika udah kalah di asia tenggara sejak 2014...
Btw akun baru lahir kemaren sore.. Joined Jul 16, 2024 Fak yu bosquee... 🖕
@@ntznbgzt presiden Soekarno ikn sudah di buktikan oleh Jokowi ganyang Malaysia selanjutanentah siapa yg akan menjalankan Karna Malaysia tanah perjanjian yg di janjikan milik Indonesia
@@siaprochinjapankorean👌
Sorry Jakarta
You’re not the capital anymore
i believed they get the idea from Malaysia, where Malaysia Government moved their central administration from Kuala Lumpur to Putrajaya. but KL remained as capital city of Malaysia, whereas i believed they remained Jakarta as capital city of Indonesia. correct me if i get wrong.
@@adrianwang2724there are a lot of example out of Malaysia. But yes, one of them is Malaysia.
West Papua will join with PapuaNew Guinea❤
DKJ bill passed 3 month ago it's means Jakarta isn't Special Capital Region but only Special Region without "Capital"
West papua will be New Capital of Papua New Guinea❤
I envy Indonesia. I like that they use their native language in governing stuff (lol idk the exact word). Here in the Philippines (US colony) our language is dead. We use English in passing laws, bills etc. By the 1987 constitution .
Okay, but what about the other dialects in The Philippines besides Tagalog?
The Philippines should look at Singapore for its example of how to make their future better.
Your comment seems very slanted and uneducated.
We don't use native language in government thought? Bahasa Indonesia is a second language for most of Indonesians; with their native regional language being the mother tounge
What's the problem, Singaporean uses English as well.
Sobra OA ka naman
I understand where you're coming from honestly. The influence left by the Americans such as English and its culture is very prevalent in the Philippines that it starts to overshadow the overall identity of the country. Some kids learn to speak English first before Filipino or Tagalog
This project is very ambitious. I hope it will succeed.
We are fed up with the issue of deforestation !!
We want to develop our country for the welfare of our own people.
-
It's just the media that exaggerates this, like troubled waters, non-existent investment, lol. It's clear that development doesn't just take 1 or 2 years... it takes decades, so there's no time limit... remember, this capital is building from scratch, unlike other countries. So foreign media seems jealous of development in Indonesia
1. Indonesia is building a new capital because of a few reasons. Among them are :
2. Most of the rivers around Jakarta are severely polluted. The residents turn to extract underground water and subsequently results in " Jakarta sinking ".
3. Jakarta road traffic is badly congested due to improper car and motorcycle control policy.
sok tau lu goblog
Free West Papua❤
Free Christians ❤
Indonesia is poor😂
Joker🤡 country
@@NatureWonders709papua and Christian already free in Indonesia
@@absentmindedshirokuma8539haha 😂discrimination against christians so high in indonesia
The more people say negative things, the more they fear the progress of this great country. Let the dogs bark, the caravan continues to pass..., keep moving forward, don't mind the barking dogs... Glory to Greater Indonesia, Happy Independence Day !
Congratulations to Indonesia ❤
dulu scmp pernah bikin narasi pesimis tentang kcic nyatanya kelar, kalau ndengerin yg pesimis nggak pernah kemana2 :p
@@tarotnight457 bikin jalan, bbm subsidi juga proyek rugi
@@satyaprastya @tarotnight457 "proyek rugi" itu moving goalpost, Tahun 2020 scmp pernah nulis proyek kereta cepat jakarta bandung sudah 5 tahun dan nggak ada tanda2 mau selesai nyatanya sekarang sudah beroperasi.
bahwa rugi operasional ya namanya juga baru beroperasi.
Mbahnya kereta cepatnya jepang juga nggak langsung untung [untung karena subsidi dan penyewaan properti di sepanjang jalur bukan karena tiket], banyak line yg rugi juga.
di seluruh dunia yg namanya angkutan umum massal bisa berjalan karena subsidi baik itu berbasis rel atau bus, kalau dihitung berdasarkan kerugian akibat kemacetan jalan/polusi oleh kendaraan pribadi subsidi itu
Nggak ada seujung kukunya.
@@jatrindoantaransentra9251 kalau cuma perspektif "rugi operasional" itu salah besar. Ada dampak ekonomi tidak langsung yang tidak bisa dimasukkan ke nilai ekonomis tiket saja.
Bayangkan waktu yang dihemat
Subsidi bbm yang dihemat
Waktu yang di hemat
Pergerakan ekonomi yang lebih cepat
Hal2 tersebut tidak tertuang dalam perhitungan kerugian operasional.
...bantalnya di curi😅
@@T-rex513 itu masalah di mental penggunanya bukan di KCICnya
Happy 79th Anniversary Independence Day, Indonesia 🇮🇩 ! 👍👍
( 17 August 2024 )
🎂🎁🎉
-
Nusantara will be like Washington DC and Jakarta is the business hub like New York. Still the core problem of everything in Indonesia is corruption and weak justice system to corrupt officials and corrupt citizens.
Washington DC to NYC still close.while Jakarta to Nusantara is too far even on different islands
Thank you Mr. Bahlil Lahadalia for the investors explanation. Some CZcams channels just say "Oh no, no one invest on Nusantara it's gonna failed" Pessimistic of foreign channels are abundant
Iya udah dari lama bgt dijelasin tapi media selalu bikin sentimen negatif. Pdhl dari dulu udh dibilang. klo tahap pertama itu bikin infras utama dan gedung pemerintahan dulu, RIng 1, Ring 2.. Lalu investor Nasional dulu dikasih prioritas, setelah itu baru investor asing.
IKN is city of corruption jokowidodo with 80$B loan from chinese govt such shamefull country with income the people only 100$ monthly
Alhamdulillah make Indonesia great again
Insya Allah Nusantara akan terbangun dengan megah hasil karya dari Putra/Putri terbaik bangsa
The question should not be WHY, but WHY NOT EARLIER?
This is definitely a step in the right direction.
I hope this goes well for them, I'm excited to see the results
Orang indonesia tipikal Pintar ber narasi dan Argumen. Namun miskin akan kemampuan intelektual, inovasi, Teknologi, dan penelitian. Lebih suka berdebat sampai mulut berbusa, tapi kerja nyata 0. Jika ada lomba perdebatan dunia, Orang indonesia akan jadi pemenang juara umum. Karena mereka lebih suka Berdebat, Mengkritik, tapi tidak ada hal nyata yang bermanfaat untuk Negara maupun orang lain.
salah bang orang India juaranya
Betul. Kita butuh orang yang beraksi bukan hanya bernarasi. Jika orang indonesia punya mindset seperti pak jokowi, negara ini sudah makmur dari dulu.
@@kubotite9168 jangan salah india lebih banyak orang pintar dan berpendidikan. Banyak Diaspora India yg bekerja diLuar Negeri dan menjadi CEO. Mereka pintar dalam hal IT, Finance Analys. Hanya saja kemajuan India & Diasporanya terhalang sistem Kasta dan Nama besar marga Keluarga. Andai 2 hal ini bisa dihapuskan maka India akan maju seperti China. Namun ini hal yg sulit mengingat budaya lokal yg telah ada ratusan bahkan ribuan tahun di India.
100%. Cuma cuap cuap giliran diminta bekerja banyak alasan dan skill tertinggal 😅 cape deh.
Betul
Basically Indonesia doing Brazil experience. Brazil creating Brasilia in edge of Amazon jungle, Indonesia creating Nusan6in edge of Kalimantan jungle.
It will face decades of challenges that similar case Brasilia face.
Indonesia near Balikpapan ( 1 hour after toll road finished) .. Balikpapan is one of the most important city in Kalimantan Island. Kalimantan Timur Province is a home for big company : Oil and Gas, Petrochemical, Coal and also cement industry. So everything will be easy, available and its not isolated area. In the beginning logistic will be issues, but after the harbour and airport completed in Nusantara it will be more easy. Due to its central location in Indonesia, Balikpapan or Nusantara airport will become hub to west and eastern part of Indonesia.
🇵🇭🇹🇭🇻🇳🇲🇾🇧🇷>>>>>>>>>🇲🇨🦍
@@Edgar_Ramirez471 bot
Except Brazil's GDP per capita is twice of Indonesia
Nusantara Indonesia merupakan peradaban bangsa Indonesia yang MeRdeka dan berdaulat penuh 🇮🇩👍
Jakarta is indeed facing many problems, and building a new capital city is not entirely wrong, but what needs to be known is that the construction of this new capital city also brings many problems, as shown in the video, many local people are forced to move even without appropriate compensation. In addition, the budget used is also very large. Without clarity on when foreign investment will enter, it is not impossible that the state budget will be forced to be used to cover the cost of expenses, which will ultimately cause a deficit in state finances, the impact of which of course will return to the Indonesian people.
32 billion USD is also a very large fund, when compared to just building one city, why not use the funds to develop cities in Indonesia, the benefits will clearly be enjoyed by the Indonesian people, compared to the new capital city which will only be inhabited by officials and civil servants.
Why?To create development on all Indonesias islands.
Nonsense. It's completely politically driven. There are other top priorities besides building a palace in the empty land that will literally only be used by those corrupt officals
No its not, its just Jokowi personal vanity project.
@@ALIGwedew62jokowi will be only there for 4 months,
We hope so, its right in the middle of indonesia. Central govt will be able to look on the other part of indonesia not just java.
@@absentmindedshirokuma8539 and his son is the current elected vice president of indonesia.
IKN baru, tempat tinggal yang di prioritaskan hanya untuk SDM tinggi yang rajin, cerdas & pintar, bukan untuk SDM rendah yang jumlahnya banyak, kumuh, dekil, malas & bodoh
Makanya bersaing supaya mampu jadi SDM yg tinggi. Dimana-mana kalo mau daftar sekolah, kuliah, kerja kan juga diseleksi siapa yg layak dan siapa yg enggak. Kalo mental kek gini dipelihara terus ya wajar kalo banyak yg ngatain SDM rendah. Bukannya upgrade diri malah nyalahin orang2 yg berusaha & bekerja keras
Dasar komentar paling TOLOL...
Jakarta akan dipinggirkan. 😅
IKN untuk seluruh anak bangsa tanpa terkecuali. Tetapi standard kualitas ASN harus tinggi!
Korupsi indonesia sangat transparan...
Meski mental siapa yang kompeten dan mampu dialah yang maju dah ada lama dari dulu, tapi akan banyak ada kecemburuan sosial kalau tidak dimbangi dengan fasilitas rakyat, kemudahan...
*NUSANTARA BARU*
*INDONESIA MAJU*
*INDONESIA JAYA JAYA JAYA*
🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
We are talking about a Vision of a future of Indonesia.. Unluck people mightbe effects but as less as possible, its not forgotten its sacrifice of our children's future. NKRI maju
Lihat lah Indonesia. Kalian selalu iri dan dengki sama Malaysia, tetapi Malaysia selalu sokong Indonesia.
More reason for Sabah and sarawak to go independent from Malaysia...
Why?
Reason? 🤔
Haha Electric Still Import From Malaysia,Sarawak Until 2062 But Dreams On Having Sarawak And Sabah Gains Independent And Joint Indonesia One Wrong Move Just Switch Off Entire Kalimantan Go Dark
Indonesia From The Past 70 Year Focus To Much On Military And Neglect Important Infrastructure, And Facility
@@T-rex513 why not?
@@sayfolman7752 Sabah and Sarawak can go independent just like Singapore! Even today 2 million Malaya residents works in Singapore, as Malay Arab sultanate is an obsolete useless bunch!
what a great decision for indonesia
It's just for Joko's personal ambition with minimal impact for the country. Spending so much only for the comfort of government officials and I'm not even sure they will feel comfortable. While millions of people in Jakarta are left behind without clear solutions.
TIDAK ADA SATUPUN NEGARA MAJU DIDUNIA INI MENGINGINKAN NEGARA BERKEMBANG NAIK MENJADI NEGARA MAJU...
Jakarta was not left behind. Literally still get more money than IKN combined.
@@absentmindedshirokuma8539 So, what's the current major project for millions of people in North Jakarta threatened by floodings?
@@intriguingfacts5434 land reclamation, sea wall, and even more water pump. Not to mention all the public transport project. The jakarta garuda sea wall alone cost 20% more than whole IKN proposed budged. If not because local populace resistence, it couldve done much faster than IKN.
Bruhh... Have you been to jkt(?)😂 No one's gonna think jkt will be abandoned,it's like nyc and washington dc example. Jkt is already so populated with all its problems, it's just to share the burden of government capital and economy capital city
I m optimistic and hopefully it will be a great success.
Mau optimis atau gak, bangun kota perlu waktu, dan harus orang profesional yg bertanggungjawab nya, setidaknya ini gak seperti Neom city Arab saudi yg lebih gak masuk akal
JOKOWI smart enough to build new Nusantara for $33 Billion rather than fixing jakarta that cost $40 Billion
The new capital also a way to fix Jakarta main problem -> overpopulation
There are many project has done or on progress to solve Jakarta problems :
1. Sea Wall czcams.com/video/umEgh1rECfg/video.html
2. Dam in jakarta upper stream river czcams.com/video/0liV2IuFKY8/video.html
3. MRT Project Phase 2 and Phase 3 czcams.com/video/3noIRwld_E4/video.html
4. LRT Jabodebek czcams.com/video/k8JAXUE2fOw/video.html
5. Sodetan Ciliwung czcams.com/video/snz0QhNizMU/video.html
6. Ciliwung river revitalization in Jakarta czcams.com/video/dTesKSMRAhs/video.html
etc
Coba update video terbaru tentang Ibukota Nusantara.
Still far more cheaper than malesIYA Chinese forest city spend for 100 bilions failed projects. Nusantara even has build dam,road network, impresive building, bridge and many more. Can't even compare the sucses in 1 batch
kebanyakan orang indonesia kalo di ajak membangun negara.selalu berpikir negatip itu sebab negara gak maju maju.terlalu mudah di propokasi oleh orang asing
BG try our country once visit Indonesia our people are very kind no need to be afraid and the prices are cheap
Indonesia (BG)Bang English"brother"
6:53 The man on the right, Gibran, is literally Jokowi's oldest son. Feels like quite too large piece of an information to not be mentioned there.
how is he relevant to be mentioned ? he is not the reason why indonesia is building a new capital. If anything we should blame anies baswedan for being an inept governor of jakarta who could not work hand in hand with the central government to fix jakarta's problems.
Its blasphemy to mention the word Nepotism in Indonesia
@@kevindurden337there is no balsphemy. It's the norm. Even main opposition name in Indonesia like anies and megawati is part of nepotism dinasty.
Is he important? For you maybe, but not for the rest of us.
@@kevindurden337is it really nepotism? We as the civilians vote for the team we wanted, is it a criminal offense if the son of a president wants to run for vice presidency? I think it should be equally fine.
The bad thing is if the president uses his own power to openly support his son, but from what I’ve seen so far Jokowi is just personally supporting him without using his presidential authorities much, though correct me if there’s something I’m missing since I didn’t follow it much
indonesia will be the greatest
Indonesia 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩❤❤❤❤
this is not journalism at all, SCMP you are very biased
Membutuhkan beberapa dekade untuk membuat nusantara benar benar menjadi kota yang hidup
Betul. Butuh sepuluh tahun bahakan lebih..
Jakarta kota bisnis, Nusantara kota Pemerintahan
Great new cptal, ❤❤❤❤,
Kalimantan word sounds like from Visayan language.
what does it means?
@@rickydimas2674 Kalimtan in Visayan mean "forget" and I heard many Visayan words from these 2 people 4:00 and 6:00.. like undang and gibayaran.. its Visayan words. undang = stop, gibayaran = pay.
@@ColoniaMurder20interesting, meanwhile in Indonesian language, undang = invite , bayar = pay.
@@Luluskuy root word of "gibayaran" or "ginabayaran" is "Bayad".. our language have complicated prefixes and suffixes in our language. and Visayan language dont have much influence from foreign language.. aside how we count.. we prefer use Spanish way how to count becuz its much easier.. than use count as "usa, duwa, tulo, upat, lima and so on..
The amount of planning and construction required is insane.
That's why it's called debt trap.
@@Bubba-q2b Indonesia is a rich country
@@satyaprastyarich in debts & c0rruption?
They should've scaled the city back a bit, it's too lavish.
@@Bubba-q2bIndonesia still one of lowest debt precentage to gdp in the region.
Kota itu Indah hanya dengan satu aja yaitu BERSIH. Tolong pak disetiap kota/ kabupaten perketat plastik. Bersihkan pemukiman liar di rel dan sungai. Sampah buat penyakit dan banjir. Pakai tas buat belanja dan ikan, daging pakai daun pisang dll
Last sentence is very powerful. Since from the very beginning, this project already raised a lot of question. Didn't involving with the public, agreement from the parliament was a mere formality and the result of "consolidation" from the president, not to mention they didn't take professional and academics advice into consideration for this project's site placement.
Certainty is not favoring too much into this project, hence the further lags and delays, concerning investors, resigning of the project leader and his vice. Uncertainty encircles this project, even the president struggle and doubt to give answer to the press. Expect lots of struggle and turmoil for the next leadership of Indonesia with it's economy.
Jakarta is singking
My worry is Nusantara is closer with the south China sea and many say the scs is the future big conflict in SEA...
Indonesia should hire Dprk to build this city
me as Indonesian : keep moving.. go on.. leave bad comment behind !!! maju terus ikn.. bangun terus.. 🎉🎉🎉
Bad decision, very very bad decision
Why dont they hired government people from Kalimantan itself and let the original government workers in Jakarta stays in Jakarta🤔🤔🤔
Dayak people can get higher rank job & changed their loves for a better like the rest of Borneo Island such as Brunei & Sabah Sarawak part of Malaysia
You cannot directly appoint someone to work in the government, in Indonesia we will hold a national recruitment for example in 2023 there will be 2.4 million applicants from all over Indonesia.
She's Martina, not Simanjuntak 🤦♂️ Indonesians go by their first name not surname/family name/clan name.
Ya memang begitu nyebutnya report internasional, liat aja donald trump sebutnya trump.
setuju sekali untuk pindah ibu kota ,pembangunan tambah merata
If they don't improve their traffic laws the new capital will polluted as well
Of course, have already learned from Jakarta
I will explain a little about the new capital of Indonesia. The plan to move the capital from Jakarta has been around for a long time, namely from the era of President Soekarno, President Soeharto, President SBY and was only built by President Jokowi. why President Jokowi? because President Jokowi knows that Indonesia will soon be golden in 2045. If this is not built, how long will this golden Indonesia be realized! Even though there have been a lot of mockery during its development, this is for the sake of the equitable development of Indonesia, which is not only Java-centric, but Indonesia-centric! People on the island of Java think that the new capital is just a waste of money, they don't know that people on all the islands want their regions to develop like Java. The concept of the IKN capital is a forest city, green city, smart city, building that unites with nature. The land used for the capital in Borneo is not native forest, but paper production forest!
The process will not be smooth. And the challenge will not be small. But once it is done, hopefully, this is something that every Indonesian can be proud of.
Tuhan Yesus memberkati Presiden Jokowi dalam pembangunan Indonesia❤❤❤❤❤❤
Beda agama woyy
@@cxteamy9675 semoga hidupmu berkat, diluar negeri sudah bahas ekonomi tapi anda bahas agama 😇
Maju terus indonesia,biarkan asing dan beruk2nya di indonesia menilai negatif
Indonesia
Capital: Nusantara (effective from 17 August 2024)
Largest city: Jakarta
The main issue of land subsiding is 10 million people of Jakarta getting the fresh water from the ground. Water pipe line is not yet covering whole Jakarta, only around 20 % with not adequate water as well. Land subsiding is only rapidly happening in the north Jakarta near the coast line (sea).
The solution is to build robust pipe water system that cover whole Jakarta. The target is to get there in 2030. For that project of course we need water source and we can easily get it from neighboring province like West Java and Banten. New dam has been built in Banten which name is Karian Dam and it is the third largest in Indonesia (We have 300 dams at the moment with plan to build another 300 new dams)
Project to build water treatment facility has been started two years ago with target completion in 2024. While project to build the pipe water system is started recently with backing from more than 15 banks. If you see some areas in Jakarta business district you can see the work that has been going on and it is the second project that intended to replace the old pipe with the new one
the main concern is capital city now located at jakarta not represent indonesia because far from east indonesia. and jakarta also sinking.
10 % tidak setuju. 90 % setuju.
Setiap keputusan besar.. pasti ada pro kontra.
Sudh biasa
betul.. dan itu terjadi saat project MRT dan Kereta Cepat.
I will explain a little about the new capital of Indonesia. The plan to move the capital from Jakarta has been around for a long time, namely from the era of President Soekarno, President Soeharto, President SBY and was only built by President Jokowi. why President Jokowi? because President Jokowi knows that Indonesia will soon be golden in 2045. If this is not built, how long will this golden Indonesia be realized! Even though there have been a lot of mockery during its development, this is for the sake of the equitable development of Indonesia, which is not only Java-centric, but Indonesia-centric! People on the island of Java think that the new capital is just a waste of money, they don't know that people on all the islands want their regions to develop like Java. The concept of the IKN capital is a forest city, green city, smart city, building that unites with nature. The land used for the capital in Borneo is not native forest, but paper production forest!
Kenapa sih banyak berita tentang IKN. Krn IKN ini digadang² akan menggantikan Singapore dalam hal membawa orang kaya berinvestasi. Pembangunannya masih panjang. Ada 4 tahap. Tahap pertama aja belum selesai. Jadi, makanya banyak yg penasaran dg IKN bisa apa enggak menyaingi Singapore yg cm ⅓ Jakarta luas wilayahnya.
🤣🤣🤣
Gak perlu membandingkan negara raksasa dengan sebuah kota😂
@@amomenttoremember1877 kalo ngetik jangan sambil ketawa. Kl ketawa² terus gak jelas, mending cek kejiwaan. Siapa tau anda stres
@@BikinRomantis880 yaudah saya pakai emot nangis aja😭
they could’ve used all that money to solve their issues n build manufacturing hubs powered by clean energy in kalimantan… jobs n communities will be built over there n then they can think abt moving their capital
The only people who reject it are the government's opposition. 80% of Indonesian people agree with moving the capital to Kalimantan.
Relocating capital is necessary but building nonsensical garuda shape palace is ridiculous. You don't build to impress, but for it's functionaliies.
this is how minimalist and brutalist architecture took over
This, it's disappointing to see the lack of vernacular buildings there, like I don't hate it but it's not perfect either. It's literally just about being pompous and futuristic, the mindset from 60s boomers who really wanna get rid of "colonialism".
it's has functionalities maybe you haven't see the video where's people can relax and sit there
Do You know DUBAI?😂
South east Asia country have one thing in common, making empty promises and the people will keep believing them, before election promises from the government is all sweet , after the election it's all salty and badd
Kalimantan is not in Borneo; Kalimantan is Borneo. Kalimantan is an Indonesian name for Borneo.
There is definitely lot to get fixed for, but the policy to move capital is just inevitable. It has been suggested since 1950's but lack of planning had been delayed it since.
A lot of these arguments are true, if it was posted a month ago.
ขออภัย การลดค่าสกุลเงิน มีมารตการพิสูจน์ใด้ ถูกต้องตามหลักวิชาการ.ข้อมูลช่วยเหลือ อยู่ที่ใหน สำคัญ ต่อ มวลรวมนัยประเทศ รายละเอียดไม่ทราบรู้
After the Dutch had connected all the cities on Java by rail in the thirties, the next project was to make Bandung the new capital of the Dutch East Indies. The Dutch already knew that Batavia was unsuitable as the capital. Much swamp and flooding and the climate was much too humid compared to Bandung. But the Second World War prevented Bandung from finally becoming the capital.
The most difficult thing to move are the embassies & the parliament/congress. It will take atleast 20-30 years for the new city to develop naturally.
it will be finished in 2045 (stage 5). But if they work with the current speed, in the next 5-10 years this city will be more lively and livable.
Pak jokowi bekerja nyata. Bukan sekedar berbicara manis seperti pendatang arab itu.
Don't ask people who really enjoy living in Jakarta. They are too old to moving outside their comfort zone...
The Indonesian government under Jokowi's administration only allocated 20% of the funds for Nusantara, while 80% will come from investors. If I recalled Jokowi said there are still no investors willing to invest in the project due to financial risks.
So far, the government has focused on domestic investors, Indonesia has correctly chosen Borneo as its capital.
Hopefully IKN will be successful, not like previous cities.
Well, we as Indonesian will support it. but looking at the current rates.... Clearly the designs are more to impress investors.... not so realisitic.
which got me thinking, was our government so dumb to think that what investors care is looks???
@@agps4418Ask Muhammad Bin Salman for that
@@giraffestreet that is incomparable, the form of his country is different with indonesia's
@@agps4418You think The Line is not just to look cool for investors. They literally invite Michio Kaku just to talk about how "futuristic" the city will look like. He's not an engineer he is a theoretical physicist, why is he even there?
Finally, the Indonesian capital city is ready to operate in other countries
Equal distribution of opportunities for Indonesians rather than concentrating on one place/area in all aspects of society. Philippines needs to learn from this move. Conservation of culture is a concern for some, but I believe that is an easy feat if the society as a whole will put effort towards it.
Indeed, Indonesia is improving much like China, it seems they implement policies within days unlike in U.S. Europe and Philippines who have more than two-party system which only engage in talks, talks, debates, talks and one policy to be implement takes months or years
Nusantara is a prestige project for the Indonesian presidents. Eventually Nusantara will become the city for the political elite. The embassies will also move, but the current embassies in Jakarta will become consulates. Because no matter what, Jakarta will always have the economic attraction and people and (international) companies will continue to come to Jakarta. Jakarta will continue to grow and there will be no millions of (poor) people from Jakarta moving to Nusantara.
Just as New York is more popular than Washington or Amsterdam is more popular than The Hague.
The more precise explanation is similar case of Brazil. When they move capital from Rio, doesn't mean Rio diminishing or reduce in economic importance.
IKN - Istana Kelelawar Nyoman
Anak Abah Anies tantrum
Hahh. Setelah membangun pulaunya selama lebih dari setengah abad dari hasil rampasan APBD sekitar. Sekarang anda terlihat iri dengan pembagunan daerah lain.. kasihan sekali. Anda mngkin berhasil membangun pulau yang megah, tapi tidak dengan isi kepala anda sekalian
Why the capital city is moved ?
The current capital of Indonesia, is congested and even more worrying, it’s sinking by as much as 25cm a year! About half of the city of more than 30 million people already lies below sea level.
But largely because all the economic activity in the country is centered in Jakarta, the current capital, and long term predictions show that if the capital stays there the economic inequality will just continue to get worse.
Jakarta started out as an economic hub under the Dutch East Indies Company and two centuries after the company left its still one of the most important economic hubs in Asia. There were attempts to move the political power elsewhere in the 20th century, both by the Dutch and by the independence movement, but it settled in Jakarta anyway.
What that means for most of Indonesia’s people is that most of the country’s money settles there which means there’s none for other regions in the country. It is hoped moving the capital will create new economic links in the center of the country.
This isn’t the first time a country tried this. Brazil moved its capital from thriving Rio de Janeiro to centrally located Brasilia in the 1960s for the same reason. In fact, most U.S. states rejected their largest city as the capital for much the same reason. That’s why they have Albany, Lansing, Harrisburg, Springfield and Sacramento being the capitals of states with much larger population centers. All of those cities are centrally located within their state. Indianapolis was made the capital of Indiana precisely because it was in the center of the state.
So there are several reasons behind this decision:
1. Overpopulation and Congestion
2. Environmental Concerns
3. Economic Development and Regional Balance
4. Administrative Efficiency
The decision to move the capital is part of Indonesia's vision for sustainable development and aims to address various challenges faced by the current capital, Jakarta.
This is long term projects and result will be reach in next 15 - 20 years.
That's why their neighboor "tiny dot island" country - as accomplices or agent of western side, and some of western countries, including their media are really afraid of this project because they've already understand very well that Indonesia will become a major economic power in Southeast Asia, and it will have a big impacts on the economic of "tiny dot island" country, and western interests also in Indonesia. And they are always reporting of this great country and developing of their new capital city in a different perspectives - sceptical & negative news, compared to other asean countries who always support the new capital city of this great great country and the economic growth of Indonesia and Asean.
You should be proud Indonesian !
It's not about physically relocating but about adopting a better mindset and a more efficient bureaucratic system.