James Harrison weighs in on the Rodgers vs Brady discussion | NFL | UNDISPUTED
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 08. 2018
- James Harrison joins Skip Bayless and Shannon Sharpe to talk NFL on today's show. James Harrison makes he's pick for who's more valuable Packers QB Aaron Rodgers or Patriots QB Tom Brady.
#Undisputed #NFL #AaronRodgers
SUBSCRIBE to get the latest UNDISPUTED content: foxs.pt/SubscribeUNDISPUTED
▶Watch our latest NFL content: foxs.pt/NFLonUNDISPUTED
▶Watch our latest NBA content: foxs.pt/NBAonUNDISPUTED
▶Watch our latest MLB content: foxs.pt/MLBonUNDISPUTED
▶First Things First's CZcams channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeFIRSTTHINGSFIRST
▶The Herd with Colin Cowherd’s CZcams channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeTHEHERD
▶Speak for Yourself’s CZcams channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeSPEAKFORYOURSELF
See more from UNDISPUTED: foxs.pt/UNDISPUTEDFoxSports
Like UNDISPUTED on Facebook: foxs.pt/UNDISPUTEDFacebook
Follow UNDISPUTED on Twitter: foxs.pt/UNDISPUTEDTwitter
Follow UNDISPUTED on Instagram: foxs.pt/UNDISPUTEDInstagram
Follow Skip Bayless on Twitter: foxs.pt/SkipBaylessTwitter
Follow Shannon Sharpe on Twitter: foxs.pt/ShannonSharpeTwitter
About Skip and Shannon: UNDISPUTED:
UNDISPUTED is a daily two-and-a-half hour sports debate show starring Skip Bayless and Shannon Sharpe. Every day, Skip and Shannon will give their unfiltered, incisive, passionate opinions on the biggest sports topics of the day.
James Harrison weighs in on the Rodgers vs Brady discussion | NFL | UNDISPUTED
• James Harrison weighs ...
Skip and Shannon: UNDISPUTED
/ undisputedonfs1 - Sport
Does Aaron Rodgers deserve to be paid more than Tom Brady?
Lol Shannon bringing up stats not even the mighty Peyton manning compares to Tommy
He probably does, but he hasn't been paid more than Brady has. Ever since Rodgers has started Brady's cost millions more against the cap than Rodgers has. Yet Rodgers teams are still worse. Not everyone can have arguably the best team building Head Coach/GM in NFL history like Brady has.
Skip and Shannon: UNDISPUTED
#TB12 shouldn’t be involved in the conversation of best QB
he is clearly in a league of his own and #PATRIOTS used and abused Brady
all that money he left on the table
and for what?
not much
that’s what
#ARod has languished in #GB while
#Eli
#BigBen
#Peyton
have collected multiple rings
#NFL sets a Fake salary cap
then complains about not being able to sign players
cap should be $225M
and each team should have to spend 90% of it per season
@@TGTK-FreeSpeech- I think you either misspoke or have bad info. Tom Brady's total net worth is only 180 million.... This Rodgers contract is worth that much in 4 years. That's also Brady's net worth including endorsements and everything else.
BKVR 34 No I'm talking about what both QBs have counted against the cap ever since Rodgers started in 2008. Brady has cost more. The argument that Rodgers has cost more than Brady is wrong.
Don't her cheeks hurt from smiling for 15 straight minutes
Lmfaoo
Lol not with her paychecks probably
I was going to say the same thing
I like smiley girl. She so happy to be there lol
I can't stop looking at her every time they show her now since you said that lol
James was like “woah I ain’t takin less money. Oh it’s hypothetical? Ight dats cool” 😂
James the goat
Lol! I done when saw the facial expression of James.
LOL the face on that man's face lol
Shannon "I'm glad u said that bc in 2014 he beat ur cowboys with a walking cane"😂😂😂
@SamoaVsEverybody_814 ™ 2.0 no he didnt
Yeah they had to change the rules after that because it was a catch
Even if it was a catch there would have still been 4 minutes on the clock for Rodgers to score again
and then presumably a minute or two for romo to score
LeeTravius Mckay nope haha
I like that chick, doesn’t interrupt like Molly from First take she just there listening lol
Yeah, she knows her place. They shouldn't act like they know sports like these guys here.
Louis Adams Women can know sports better than men, but Molly doesn't. She's low grade when it comes to football.
And she cute....
And cúter
She's so dope too.
"he beat boat trip odell" skip why you do him like that i about nearly died when he said that 😂😂😂
I can't go against Brady in the playoffs. I know it's a team sport but Brady has the Jordan and Kobe killer mentality. His lazer focus and comebacks in big games is second to none. Rodgers is more athletic and has better arm talent but mentally Brady all the way. Brady is the Goat.
Aaron has a killer mentality too. GB is holding Aaron back and it's not even funny. I have no doubt Aaron could do what Brady has done with the same team the problem is that Brady has that team because he's taken that pay cut. Skill wise Aaron is better in almost every way. Value wise Brady isn't even in the same realm as Aaron's. Brady is easily the MVP of the league in a literal sense.
Eli?
@@flashfive12 I think Rodgers has better receivers and Brady usually has better defense. But I think this year it's even or take your pick. Both teams are struggling on defense. I think this year Rodgers has a better receiving core. I don't either team will go to there conference championship. Belicheat let go of way to many players last few years because he don't want to pay no one. Should of paid jones, collins, amendola, and Lewis.
mike brown Aaron Rodgers plays better than Brady in the playoffs and the statistics show it. Rodgers has a much higher QB rating, scores more points, throws more TDs, throws fewer INTs, beats Brady statistically in nearly every way. According to Richard Sherman Aaron Rodgers is the smarter QB too. Brady has been lucky to have 14 top 10 scoring defenses. Rodgers has had only 2. That's why Rodgers can score more points in the playoffs, but lose more games. His defenses have been trash in comparison.
@@thegoodtomking2804 nobody cares about meaningless playoff stats like qbr show me wins and loses
If Aaron Rodgers is better than Tom Brady, then Tony Gonzalez is better than Shannon Sharpe.
Rodgers is better than Brady regardless.
Brady is better
Brady is the G.O.A.T.
Wait but tony is better then Shannon
Brady lost to back up qb
This dude Shannon did his impression of a Martian’s voice 🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂💀💀
Comparing Tom Brady to Aaron Rodgers is like comparing MJ to LeBron. Aaron and LeBron are more talented and more versatile but Tom and MJ have that killer instinct and will to win.
Great comparison
Bruce Rivers Lebron has more game winners than Jordan in the playoffs but he doesn’t have a killer instinct? lol 😂
This is why aliens don’t talk to us I know right? In before old head say "He DiD It In MoRe GaMeS". That doesn't matter, he still got more. The durability of a player should be not be a penalty, in fact that should make it more impressive
This is why aliens don’t talk to us Jordan never lost a Finals. Matter of fact he never seen a game 7 🤫
TOTALLY AGREE I've always said the exact same thing.
Aaron Rodgers is 0-36 against teams with a winning record when trailing by 1 or more points in the 4th quarter. How is this still a debate
Because that's not only wrong, it's also because you're talking about a team record statistic not something that's the responsibility of the QB.
yea im sure none of those losses had anything to do with the defense giving up a ton of points in the 4th either. Dumb cherry picked statistics that have nothing to do with Rodgers. Rodgers also was 0-7 in overtimes in his career until the packers beat the bengals in OT 2 years ago. If you actually watched those games.. you would see almost 80% of those games.. He didnt even get a chance to possess the ball... so how is that OT loss on him?? Stupid Stupid people
Dalton Malzahn - do you know what's really stupid? When you throw out a figure like 80% and it's patently false.
Rodgers is 1-37 when trailing by more than a point in the 4th quarter against teams that finish the season with a winning record.
Rodgers averaged less than 21 ppg in those losses - below league average. So whatever the defense was doing - Rodgers wasn't doing his job too well.
You Packer fanboys are cute. So loyal to your binky - even though he just fleeced you!
hi 47-2 when leading going into the playoffs. Meaning he literally plays perfect 24/7. When losing his defense gets no stops. Name a time Patriots gave up 50 points in playoffs? I would wait lls
Peter Kay ur pathetic hater. We all know ar12 the best
Look at belechick now without Brady! LMAO
Shannon "no it's not over"😂
This chic on this show always smiling... love it, she seems like a bright/happy person.
@Timmy Pruitt 😂😂😂
This is basically the NFL MJ vs Lebron
omg somebody's triggered
@@jeremyjones290 Kobe lol
Except LeBron gets his team to the Superbowl every year and is worth it.
Qarcon yeah except Rodgers isn’t a top 2 QB of all time
Jeremy Jones between Kobe fans there are, Kobe fans think Kobe is 2nd and MJ is the goat in reality LeBron is a close second to MJ
Thank you James, finally a guest on this show knows wassup
“Aaron Rodgers needs money to buy shaving cream and razors”
-Shannon Sharpe, 2018
Shannon's Martian voice absolutely killed me
If only Seattle and Atlanta ran the ball... Philly clearly learned from those games
It's now 2020 and one of them got another Super Bowl. Guess who, Shannon!
Just got another one 😂
“It’s not over” 😂😂😂
BRADY=JORDAN RODGERS=LEBRON
also Value I think you should look at it is that 5 rings is way more valuable than just the 1
Zack D but Lebron has more than one championship so that comparison is invalid. Lebron is the goat 🐐
Im talking skill wise. Lebron way more talented than Jordan. Like Rodgers is more talented than Tom. The comparison is not invalid Tom and Jordan will come at your throat. Winning records in championship games unlike Lebron
Yes
@@youwouldntgetit2618 stop it ..
Love when James Harrison is on
I'm in a room with James Harrison, sitting 4-feet away from him...
"I agree with James--blank check and power of attorney!"
If only Seattle ran the ball😧😧😧
he still would have 4
Phillip Stokes Congrats, you can do math
If only their defense protected that 10 point lead in the 4th quarter.
They did on the previous down and didnt get in
Alan Meilinger BooM
I’m very confused on this debate how does one compare 5 SB rings vs 1 SB ring?
Striker BRO football is a team sport. Rodgers stats prove he’s the best of ALL time.
Striker so by this statement, Bill Russel shouldn't even be compared to Michael Jordan. Championships are a team accomplishment dude
If that's how you compare qb talent, then by your logic Joe Flaco is better than Dan Marino and Eli is on the same level as Peyton.
Because a SB ring is a team accomplishment. QB don't play defense. You clowns still don't get this.
Striker Your statement makes no logical sense.
Brady is the goat, five rings says it all, enough with this debate.
Marshawn Lynch should have ran the ball .
RINGS ARE WON BY TEAMS
Foolish debate 5 rings vs 1 ring he has won 8 afc championships and has been to the sb 8 times he holds 6 regular season records , 19 playoff records and 12 sb records. holds 3 league mvps and 4 sb mvps and has lead his team to 15 division titles and is a 4x passing touchdown leader , a 2x passer rating leader, 3x passing yards leader . 13x pro bowl , 3x first team all pro , 2x second team all pro and i could go on for hours and all I can say about Aaron Rodgers is he has a higher passer rating and he can run the ball better but brady has more 4th quarter comebacks as Well and don't get it twisted I think Aaron Rodgers is still very talented and has at least two more sb rings its just I think people are thinking this debate too hard its clear
5 rings says he's been on great teams. That's it.
The team wins games not just one player. If Rodgers played for the Pats they would be unstoppable
Regardless of who you think is better or more valuable, Skip makes a pretty solid point from 3:34 to 5:58.
IM ON THE FLOOR LAUGHING WITH SKIPS COMMENT ABOUT ROGERS TAKING LESS MONEY...LMFAO
Brady's value is unparalleled. AR is great, but he's no Brady, nor will he ever be.
Reoberto pp Because he's not a cheating trump supporter?
Reoberto pp Take away team accomplishments and tell me who’s better statistically.....
@Andrew Fischbach look up the stats. Brady is light years ahead of Rodgers
Man O War what does supporting Trump have to do with anything...
PabloEscobar L football is a TEAM game, and as a quarterback you're playing for TEAM accomplishments... Not individual accomplishments. Lol.
All you have to do is to line up their seasons from 2009 point on up to present when they both played simultaneously and look at the numbers and accomplishment. Erase everything they did before 2009. Advantage: Brady. And if you add what Brady did before 2009, it's not even close. They don't give out trophies to talent and potentials.
Thats true… gotta compare the resume because at the end of the day, its about winning games and scoring touchdowns
Why don't we talk about Brady vs Brees
Joshua Fonua That’s what I’m saying. I’m a huge Pats fan and I honestly believe that Rodgers isn’t even better than Brees
Check Brees post season record to see why.
Emily DeAloe I honestly believe that brees and Rodgers>Brady. The fact it's a debate let u know that Brady only has rings on Rodgers case closed next topic.
@@russell9411 not to mention Brady broke the NFL record for most TDS thrown in a season and helped Randy Moss get the record for most TDS ever caught in a single season. Aaron Rodgers just gets yards and hype.
+Joshua Fonua because for some reason the media talking heads decided to anoint Rodgers as the successor to Peyton in the "Is 'xyz QB' better than Brady" debates when clearly Brees makes much more sense.
Brady is the comeback kid... he’s had better playoffs games... he’s been to super bowls time and time again... win or lose he carries the team like he will again, we don’t have a jordy Nelson, we don’t got no Randall Cobb, Brady can take a 2-3rd tier receiver and turn them into a star ie Welker,Dola,Edelman (QB turned WR) that too me is WAY more valuable to a franchise then rolling out the pocket.. or desperate Hail Marys
Actually ever since Belichick rebuilt the Patriots and started Brady they've gone 14-6 when forced to be without him. That's a .700 playoff caliber record without Brady. When the Packers have been forced to be without Rodgers they've gone 5-14-1 without him, a .250 record.
In fact, no great QB of the modern era has proved to mean less to his team in winning games than Tom Brady has.
Monstah Blitz808 Brady makes people better but the System New England has helps out Receivers.... Welker making the all pro team catching passes from a Underdevelop product in Cassel prove that New England doesn't need a prototypical Receiver to have success....Welker and Edelman is better than cobb and don't act like he didn't talent,Brady had Cooks who's on record pace and Brandon Lloyd for a year who led the NFL in Receiving in 2010.But I will say New England need some Receivers right now it's looking too thin.
@@TGTK-FreeSpeech- stop lying they are 19-19 without Brady
Tod Wilkinson I bet you have Aikman over Rodgers.
Benjamin Mobley You need to read the comment again. It's 100% accurate.
This us exactly why I laugh because they always put MJ over Bron but when they talk football it's like they forget
Love how she smile so much
You can see who really really does it for the love of the game and to get to the ultimate goal and that is winning Super Bowls. How come Dan Marino is hardly ever brought up in the GOAT debates? He was one of the most talented QB's ever but never won a title. Here is a question for everyone, if you were a professional athlete would you rather be remembered as the highest paid athlete or the most accomplished one?
1wt5xrt Tom Brady is not an athlete remember? Plus if you had a winning team and coach like the patriots you think it wouldn’t lighten Rodgers load and he wouldn’t be happier to play the game he loves?😂😂if Brady was on the packers he would’ve struggled and not been as great as everybody wants him to have been
Rodgers is the better QB, Brady the most accomplished. It’s not difficult to understand. Shannon is 100% correct.
Nick and Cris explain it perfectly
I disagree. Brady can make the same throws Rodgers can make. What separates Rodgers is he's more mobile.
Daniel Price Best answer
No he cant, have you ever seen Brady outside of the pocket making the same throws Rodgers does?
@@matattz yes I have. I've seen old games he was making throws Rodgers made. He mad a throw in a playoff game (Brady) he was sway one way and found amendola on the other side of the field. He made a throw against the 49ers in his Superbowl year falling backwards. He's made a throw to amendola against the Jets in 2014 scrambling out the pocket. He's made a throw scrambling out the pocket in 2010 when Pats went 14-2 against the Jets to Brandon Tate. So my guy Brady can do what Rodgers can do.
The only thing that separates them is speed and slight arm strength. Brady is just as accurate and is twice the leader Rodgers could ever hope to be. I’d take Brady over Rodgers every day.
James Harrison looks like Piccolo.
Should've special beam cannoned Foles
😂 cot damn
@@PsychoMantis308 My man didn't have enough time to charge up lmao
This dudes arms are almost the size of Shannon's torso. James a beast!
James Harrison you have my respect
I don’t even like Brady but he better than Rodgers they gotta stop with this nonsense man
If Rodgers plays with the Patriots he will have a difficult time winning less than 10 games. If Brady plays with the Packers he will have a difficult time winning 10 games.
Albie Oval ok? Didn’t know we were living in happy fun time fantasy land
@@brett8202 to evaluate a player sometimes you need to take into account fantasy land. Was Jerry Rice better because he had Joe Montana and Steve Young? Some players do well under different teams, like Reggie White did great with the Eagles and Packers whereas Nnamdi Asomugha was a top #3 cornerback with the Raiders, but not the Eagles. If you don't think about these other factors you call fantasyland, well then why don't try thinking a bit more?
Man I miss when it was Tom Brady and Manning, because you actually argue for Manning. But since he retired everyone is scrambling to try and find someone else who can rival Brady. Rodgers isn't it boys.
Exactly
I mean, seeing as Rodgers is better than Manning, you're wrong.
What are you on about? What case for Manning? Rodgers is way better than Manning and Rodgers v Brady is more credible than Manning v Brady
Perfect
To be honest I would rather see Brees, he has better stats than Rodgers except for maybe passer rating
Shannon: Yeahhhh 13:35
Skip's point on TB12 taking less money is what I bring up a lot. I don't care what professional team sport it is when does a guy who has all the meaningful records take less than nearly 50 players in his sport? We live in a what have you done for me or more specifically what have you done for me lately era and Tom put his team into position to win a Super Bowl last year, what exactly did Aaron Rodgers do during the Super Bowl last year? Oh, that's right he didn't play in it. No athlete that is considered the GOAT of their sport has ever made as little compared to the rest of their league as Tom has.
For all the Brady/Jordan and Rodgers/LeBron comparisons out there you are pretty much right BUT I've seen too many rodgers comebacks and finishes to say he doesn't have the clutchness or killer instinct.
Rodgers has never won a game in which he trailed by more than one point in the fourth quarter to a team with a winning record. He’s 0-36 in those games.
@@DiabloSpiritus that's because GB has always had a horrible 3rd quarter defense.BTW that stat is misleading because if your losing to a winning team down at 4th it's not a close game at that point.
@@DiabloSpiritus Comment of the Day
Marco Lopez If it weren’t a close game the stay wouldn’t say by one point. It would say the lowest number period.
DiabloSpiritus That's on the Packers defense, not Rodgers. Rodgers makes clutch drives only to have his defense lose the game without Rodgers ever seeing the ball again.
Skip's argument is wrong. Ever since Aaron Rodgers started he's counted for millions less against the cap than Tom Brady has. Rodgers has cost less and still his teams are worse. Not everyone can have arguably the best Head Coach/GM in history like Brady.
*"Who?!"* ~ James Harrison on taking less money
We gonna bring in dekizor lmao I love Shannon
It is hard to compare when Tom Brady‘s wife makes $30 million a year too.
i think she makes more than that.lol
Tom Brady was taking pay cuts before he ever met Gisele tho
The ONLY thing Rodgers is better at is Scrambling and Throwing the Ball outside of the pocket. Please Aaron Rodgers win another Superbowl for your team, I'll Wait....
More Harrison please
7:45 lmfao
Shannon "the man who got hurt deserves the most money because I know his stats"😂😂😂
Rodgers is just more talented, plain and simple
@@MBeefpokey period
Every year we hear that Rodgers needs a better this and a better that. Every year we keep seeing a worse and worse Pats team and they still win. I'm not a fan but Brady goat.
@@dracon501 because they cheat for brady and plus he's in the afc
@@leetraviusmckay2919 and has to play against the best of the best in the NFC during the Super Bowl. When was the last time Rodgers was not on his couch on Super Bowl Sunday?
NE drafts better backup QB's. Simple.
They’re not saying Rodgers is better, Tom Brady is obviously the better quarterback and it’s not even close , they’re talking about who is more valuable to the team meaning what would happen to a franchise if the qb was pulled out immediately.
James Harrison always looks like someone interrupted his dinner table prayer.
Roders never lost to a second string
He lose every year with one ring ...
At least Brady had the opportunity to lose to a second string. It’s been too long since Rodgers made a Super Bowl appearance
Rodgers Always loses to injuries... Brady only sat out for injuries 1 time in all his years and it was from a dirty hit from Bernard pollard..
Rodgers has never won a game in which he trailed by more than one point in the fourth quarter to a team with a winning record. He’s 0-36 in those games, which is SUCKY! 😂😂 😂 😂 😂 😂
Gary Turbo roders never played
#RingsAreWonByTeams
Matt TheDestroyer 2 I don’t think Rodgers would have won a single super bowl in the situations Brady was in.
Nope Haha hillarious comment. Brady's been blessed by having 14 top 10 defenses during his career. He's never won a Super Bowl without one. Rodgers has had only 2. One of those being a Super Bowl win. The other being a game were the Packers defense collapsed and lost 51-45. I'd argue the Patriots would have about 8 rings right now with Rodgers instead of Brady.
Tom King yeah? Neither has Rodgers
That game that Green bay lost 51-45 - Rodgers gave the Cardinals two TDs including the game-winner in OT.
Not clutch in that game.
@@MichaelMurphy-kj3xf so using your logic, Brady played badly in SB 52?
Harrison should be involved in every football debate
James Harrison is a “ True Patriot “....
Brady is the goat 🐐 point blank
James E
Brady the goat of qbs
Belichick the goat of coaches
Gronk the goat of tight ends
Belichick made Brady if Rodgers was on the Pat's they would have won 10 super bowls
Travis Hogan not with that green bay defense
Brady has been on better teams. Rodgers has been the better QB.
4/5 SB wins we're with top 5 defenses. Give Rodgers a top 5 defense and he wins just as many SBs.
The most valuable player is Aaron rodger, packer won't win without rodger and patriot win superbowl with or without brady. The patriot are like alabama football where that they don't need a elite qb like aaron and brady to win superbowl. Aaron is a goat on talent and brady is a goat on rings. I rest my case.
You cant say pats wins Superbowl without tom. New england only has 5 superbowl win in history who tom played in. Tom is 41 but Rodgers is 34 years old then they close stats each year. Rodgers had better weapons then tom but tom has gronk.
Matt Cassel couldn't beat a team above .500 in 2008
Lol they don’t win WITH him! Haha Rodgers wouldn’t even be in this conversation without a couple extremely lucky Hail Marys!
aw, patriot fans become butthurt lol. I am just stating fact beside the reason why tom is so successful is because of bill and we all know that.
Terpenator they are not lucky hail marys, they are skill hail marys. Stop being butthurt because tom hail mary last year suck balls that why yall can't go overtime with the eagle. Take the L.
Pure Jealousy from Shannon, he’s got more titles than Shannon lol.
shannon martian sound like a robot lol
Rodgers the goat and deserves every bit of that money!!!
I've seen Aaron Rodgers do some crazy things but if that's the case I put drew brees over Rodgers
What did Skip say to Marvin at 9:00 in?
The only reason there can be an argument for Rodgers being more valuable is that he is younger and has more potential years to play. In no capacity is Rodgers more valuable in any other aspect.
The people comparing regular season stats are absolutely braindead, and it's a shame to see the overall logic and understanding of football fans so low, but it's whatever. The regular season brady is fairly restrained, the patriots never pull out every trick in the book until the playoffs or the superbowl. Why has he just broken the superbowl passing record in two consecutive years? Where's rodgers doing that?
How could you compare a bunch of regular season passing statistics and ignore the fact that brady has shown more VALUE in 2 superbowls than rodgers has his entire career?
There's significantly more to football than regular season passing percentage. This question isn't even "who is the most athletically talented QB, or most precise/strongest QB" this question is MOST VALUE. If you think Rodger's value is even in the same stratosphere as Brady's you've lost your mind. Leadership, paycuts, amplifying the play of everyone around him, knowledge, game understanding, picking apart defenses, sheer will to win --- these are the things that cause Brady to be in more Superbowl's than all of his "current competitors" combined.
I understand the athleticism debate, but if you are comparing Brady's VALUE to Rodger's, stop watching football. You don't know anything.
People need to stop saying Brady = Jordan. It's insulting to MJ. Brady is more of Tim Duncan, best power forward of all time.
That would be Kevin Garnett
Yeah Brady got lucky by being drafted by arguably the greatest Head Coach/GM of all time.
@@TGTK-FreeSpeech- im sorry but not one would be saying he is the best coach without winning 5 from tom... and no other qb could do what he does in that situation on that team year in year out.
Mother Plunger Nobody would be saying Brady is the goat without Belichick.
Heisenberg-SchrodingerEmc2 You've got it backwards. Belichick is the genius who rebuilt the Patriots and started Brady. Ever since that rebuild, they've gone 14-6 without Brady. That's a .700 playoff caliber record. In fact, no great QB of the modern era has proved to mean less to his team in winning games than Tom Brady has.
If I’m an owner picking QBs then 5 Super Bowls is a heck of a lot more valuable to me than 1
I’d have to agree with Shannon on this debate
Please just let James Harrison join undisputed
Rodgers is better. Brady has a defense. Rodgers doesn't. It's that simple.
Look up their clutch stats
@@emmanuelabreu571 "lOoK uP tHeIr cLuTcH sTaTs"
I've watched them both play. I'm a fan of them both, but there are things that Rodgers can do that Brady cannot.
Couldn’t be simpler 👍🏼
Brady has a defense? Did you watch the 2011 season? Did you watch the Super Bowl? In every super bowl Brady has lost, he’s made every play he needed to, to win, but his defense gave up the game winners and Brady would be stuck trying a Hail Mary to win.
Brady went to the Superbowl with the 31st ranked defense
I agree with James and Skip......the Spurs Ducan, Manu and Parker all took less money to help free up cap room to aquire more players in San Antonio. I wish Rogers took less to help the team build.
I think Brady is an evolved version of Montana while Rodgers is a devolved version of prime Steve Young ( at his best he was unstoppable)
And Peyton Manning is a better version of Dan Marino
@@ravens52raylewis87 no sir
@@justicerobinson4662 it was Manning who broke Marinos records in the first place and actually won a Super Bowl so how do you figure he isn't a better version
Imma just leave this one comment all u die hard brady fans can get salty but Rodgers has the best td-int ratio in nfl HISTORY the best completion % in nfl HISTORY and the packers only have 2 wins when Rodgers is down to the pats being 14-6 when brady is down... Rodgers is easily the best and most valuable quarterback not only in the nfl rn but maybe in nfl history
In a more pass friendly League. You seem like someone who couldn't tell me why quarterback stats across the board have gone up over time because you've been a casual fan for a few years and have never bothered to learn about the history of the League.
FYI if you want to talk physically Young >>>> Rodgers
Also, since Rodgers entered the league Brady has a higher td to int ratio than him, again because of the rule changes to defenders. Go read up a bit and stop making yourself look stupid though, please.
Where are the wins tho
How many rings???
He has played less years than Brady and has been injured more than Brady I’d like to see Rodgers stats once he plays as much as Brady has
Rodgers has never won a game in which he trailed by more than one point in the fourth quarter to a team with a winning record. He’s 0-36 in those games, which is SUCKY! 😂😂 😂 😂 😂 😂
Rodgers is the GOAT
Rings don’t mean a thing, it’s a team sport
It is not often that a guest on the show makes Shannon Sharpe look... "small." James Harrison is one of the most impressive human beings on earth.
In other news Rogers jockstrap was found missing from the locker room after a preseason victory
The AFC is like the eastern conference of the NBA, weak af. Brady doesn't have any competition other than the Steelers rn. Put the Patriots in the NFC different story.
They have to play the best NFC team in the super bowl to win it so that doesn't really make sense.
You don't understand what I'm saying, if the Seahawks or the Packers or Falcons were in the AFC maybe the Patriots don't even make the Superbowl.
@@FuryForTheWin
Brady and the Pats have dominated every division. Last year not included :
Vs. the AFC East: 68-20 (.767)
Vs. the AFC North: 25-7 (.781)
Vs. the AFC South: 33-6 (.846)
Vs. the AFC West: 22-15 (.611)
Vs. the NFC East: 14-5 (.737)
Vs. the NFC North: 14-3 (.824)
Vs. the NFC South: 14-3 (.813)
Vs. the NFC West: 7-4 (.636)
Sit down.
@@FuryForTheWin 2 of the teams you just named he's beatn in the SB Atlanta and Seattle
You sound like you don't know what you're talking about
The only people who would argue for Brady are Pats fans, or those who don’t watch football and have just heard Tom Brady’s name mention more times.
As a Ravens fan Brady is better but Rodgers is better in terms of athleticism
8:59 what did skip say??!
Skip speaking facts in this one
"the immortal joe webb" 😅😂🤣 skip a fool
Shannon said day after day we dont judge QB by stats we judge them by rings, but shannon has rarely if not never criticized aaron for winning only 1 superbowl actually he rarely criticised him for making only 1 superbowl 😱 can you believe tom has as much superbowl and rings in the nfc as rodgers even though he played only 3 years there
When Shannon Sharpe talks it sounds like he has a mouth full of marbles.
Brady now that Jimmy G is gone, and of course he's the better QB
>brings up how little Aaron Rodgers has around him
>Fails to mention Aaron Rodgers having an extremely high cap number, thus crippling his team
hard to win when one guy is taking 1/3 of the cap.Thats Rodgers own fault...
He deserves it for carrying the team
You can’t argue with an eye witness who played against Rodgers and Brady for years and with Brady for one.
@ 2:14 the problem with the theory that if you remove the two quarterbacks one team will do better or about the same is that it doesn't tell anything about the quarterbacks, but rather the front office. If you're telling me that the Patriots front office is better at evaluating talent than the Packers, then you're telling me that Brady is better than Rodgers. If the front office can't find a suitable replacement that's on them. But we've seen Packers teams not make the Super Bowl more times that we've seen Brady teams not make the Super Bowl.
They bring in James Harrison a Superbowl champ linebacker to talk more about T. Brady because Skip is so deeply in love with Brady he cant go a day without mentioning him.
Brady 10 Super Bowls, Rodgers 1 Super Bowl appearance. Also remember when Matt Flynn broke a bunch of passing records?
You remove Tom Brady and Patriots arent winning a SB. They might still have a winning record because Bill is a great coach but no AFC or SB
Mohd aymaan replace Brady with Rodgers and YOU tell me what happens? If the team alone can get a great record imagine only needing a qb to be clutch in the 4th while your defense actually gets stops. ?so tell me what happens
Don't even understand this comparison, it's Brady. I like the point James said at the beginning and the edge could be towards Aaron when it comes to team value BUT they also downplaying the leadership Brady has and just his presence can boost his team. Pats may have won when he was out but he was still there as a leader.
Where’s Chris Broussard?
Vonn Hefner vacation
Its sad this was a debate Brady solos
James Harrison was meant for tv
Now 2020 I wonder if Shannon would like to change his answer
Would Skip take less money so they could keep Shannon? Cause he should.