Held hostage by Hamas: Testimony of an October 7th survivor | Battle Lines: Israel-Gaza Podcast
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 06. 2024
- A warning this week that this episode contains graphic language that some listeners might find distressing.
In this bonus episode of Battle Lines, we hear from Naomi Greenaway, Deputy Editor of the Telegraph Magazine, who tells the story Adi Efrat.
Adi Efrat was taken from her home on Kibbutz Be’eri and held hostage by Hamas for over 12 hours. Naomi explains that for Adi, her life will forever more be split in two - before and after October 7th, recounts that day, and explains how Adi is still full of hope for peace.
Contributors:
David Knowles (Host). @djknowles22 on X.
Naomi Greenaway (Deputy Editor, Telegraph Magazine). @naomisamuelsgreenaway on X.
Read: October 7 survivor: ‘I was alone with 15 terrorists - I knew at any second they might kill me’, by Naomi Greenaway: www.telegraph.co.uk/world-new...
For 3 months access to The Telegraph for just £1: www.telegraph.co.uk/audio |
Email: battlelines@telegraph.co.uk |
Thanks for sharing this information/ interview and keep up with the latest updates…
Lol it’s a load of Hasbara nonsense
She got away and is now in 🇺🇸
God/Goddeas/Allah/Buddha/Source/Mystery Help Us.
All the Hamas supporters know exactly every atrocity that Hamas did. So showing them evidence or hearing from the survivors doesn't make them reconsider their loyalty to Hamas. It strengthens it. They support Hamas because of the atrocities. They truly believe in Hamas's goals. They are one in the same. The protesters on college campuses and everywhere are extentions of Hamas and their brutality .
The evil from them is inconceivable. Islam.
Wish there was a Gaza the latest podcast
The unstoppable lie, the drama, and the directed script. The game is over. People are aware of who is the real devil in all of this. Have some face saved.
I feel sorry that old lady went trough that as much as I am sorry for all the Palestinian nation which must go trough this horror but not just for 50 days but for 75 years. I have to say something struck my attention when she said Hamas fighters were protecting her like an angels from … and now let’s be honest from what …. From IDF shooting at own civilians. One more thing they brought this wounded woman to this house, which t me again seems like they were protecting them from IDF, because why would they help wounded to escape ? To hide ? Lots of things start to much with the fresh news saying IDF were shooting and burning from the air at everything that was moving, including Israeli.
Lies from Islam never stops. It is in their DNA.
What??? I'm sorry to be hurtful, but your comment really shows how Hamas propaganda has influenced your mind!
First, she said that ISRAELI soldiers were the ones who were surrounding her and protecting her from Hamas!!! She said these Israeli soldiers were like angels surrounding her, but fought like lions to protect her and the others. She said before that, she told them to leave because she didn't want them to get harmed or killed, but they told her they were there to protect her and insisted on staying.
She also said that while they were fighting Hamas, 4 of them were injured. So they saved her life and the others in that house.
The reason Hamas took these people into the house was possibly to kidnap them and take them to Gaza,, or to get information from them (remember, they were shouting questions at the woman who they shot in the abdomen). Then it's likely they changed their minds or got distracted from the Israeli soldiers coming, then didn't go back into the house because the IDF was there.
All of this rubbish about the IDF trying to kill their own citizens and Hamas being the good guys is a crazy conspiracy. If Hamas was so concerned about the hostages in the house, why would they be yelling at the woman who was dying in front of them, barely able to breath with a bullet in her abdomen, demanding answers from her? They certainly didn't give her CPR. did they??
Please re listen to this interview.
@@tlc6756 Sorry to have so misunderstood. Didn't listen properly. Thanks for putting me right. I jumped to conclusions . Anti any attempt to make evil creatures good.
Terrible what happened but a little insight for Israelis what Palestinians have been living with in the decades of brutal removal from their homes and murdered for resisting.
Right. So should your innocent family suffer due to whatever act your government has done? Thought not.
@@Gridpipe Exactly, the genocide against innocent Palestinians because of what Hamas did is unconscionable. The only country can stop this is America, the American people want it stopped but Biden, normally rational is being anything but right now.
They're both in same situation Palestinians always want to kill Jewish people,those Palestinians are not innocent in anyway,they supported hamas on their activities,on the oct 7 attacked there r civilians who joined them to murder Israelites,there's even a documentary where Palestinians say they want to kill all Jewish people,the interviewer ask y most of them say Jewish people are opposing allah Muhammad(the false prophet),they say it's good to throw nuke over Israel what kind of thinking is that?that documentary was done 2019.
If Israel had chosen to abide by the Geneva Conventions as they battle Hamas, support for Israel would not be declining.
how did they violate it ???
Which violation, exactly, has there been? None.
Israel has been fully compliant with International rules of law. Hamas are getting off very lightly indeed
@@wgs8175 According to Amnesty International and all Human Rights Lawyers, Israel has violated every International Law of the Geneva Convention.