ASKA's vocal is superb! Caught my attention almost instantaneously! Although the "Super star avenue" has moved onto season 7, I still come back to watch the old footages from season 1, the true classics - ageless.
owhhhh!! aska is SOOOOOOOOO GOOD!!! ;P ahahahahhaa.. i love his voice! ;p hehehhee... the mc is so bad!! she didnt believe aska bout his girlfriend!!! hahahaha.. ;p thanks for uploading ;p
hahahha.. yay for both of them!! ;p anyway.. i think the mc is really MEAN!! how could she said such things to aska?!?! ahahahhhha.. i love aska! i think he's really GOOD! ;P
Aww, I thought they sang well together! It would be really annoying if they kept trying to battle each other in the song, it's nice this way. :) Different voice tones, that's what their duet special. Physics! \o/
第一届的星光大道只记住的杨宗纬的声音，这么多年后回看还是太有感染力了
第一屆超級星光大道是永遠的經典
那時每週等的就是這個歌唱比賽節目
讓人記憶深刻的參賽者至少有五位以上
真的好懷念
好喜歡他們真誠的友誼,希望能在回復啊
看來看去 還是最喜歡一班
2021回顧🤣
裕文真的帥帥
友情長存 互相鼓勵！
這時候的他們好真喔.
你那麼愛他超好聽的歌
Come back 2017 watch again. Aska was so innocent and so cute. This is why i love about him. Really too nice guy until now.
这个视频看了好多次……还是青菜萝卜吧……我特别喜欢唱这首歌的潘裕文，特别感动我，尤其是唱“你那么爱她，为什么不把她留下”时候看向杨宗纬的那时……
希望他們倆友誼長存
故意去找原唱的视频来看，先要说对不起原唱歌迷，没有惡意的！真心话，除了喜欢原唱，还有杨宗纬唱的，原因很简单，唱出感觉，有感染力，很有印象，还是唱现场的呢！谢谢你们大家有耳福了！感恩满满……
yap lee fun 周唱的太快樂
真的，潘就是太平靜，如果他有楊的唱功，應該就能20分以上。
我一直都不明白
潘裕文哪有评判说的那么差
我觉得唱的是很感动啊
而且最后无法自拔 的合音太好听了
明明就超好聽,真希望現在還能夠看到他兩合作對唱....哀 不過大概已經不可能了吧
ASKA's vocal is superb! Caught my attention almost instantaneously! Although the "Super star avenue" has moved onto season 7, I still come back to watch the old footages from season 1, the true classics - ageless.
great song, love their combination,
Aska's voice is impressive and touching
還滿好笑阿~>
物理的介紹aska講的好好笑XDD
超好聽的啦......:)
仔細戴耳機聽， 你就會發覺鴿王和他的差異了
其實潘王子唱得也很好呀...
只是他和宗緯的風格不同...
我個人是比較喜歡啊潘的演唱風格..
特別是"你深愛她 這是每個人都知道呀"這句真的很好聽
小蟲的話說得真毒
最後還要陶子打圓場
「我完全沒有任何理你」
peter is damn amazing.
鴨子好靚
杨宗纬不知道拉那个潘裕文多少条街。。。。杨宗纬一开口就是专业。
一班 the best!!
Even though she's joking, implying Aska is ugly is over the line. If I were Aska, I would be really hurt by that comment.
@waisun1227
我非常喜歡聽潘裕文唱歌, 也非常喜歡他那空靈純淨的嗓音, 不過我覺得就像評審老師說的, 或許潘是走比較飄逸的美聲路線 (所以唱月光和離人能夠扣人心弦), 但唱這首歌和楊宗緯搭配, 就顯得弱了一些. 這首歌是屬於那種要用比較厚實的嗓音來帶出濃厚的情感的. 老實說, 潘的聲音一出來我剛開始有點失望, 因為對這首歌來說較為單薄, 而且情感到高音時才全部出來. 不過後來潘在棒棒堂節目中和野獸合唱的那ㄧ次, 聲音的厚實度和情感都有出來, 令我驚艷. 潘王子還是最棒的啦!
看看四班的給分 再看一班...唉
2 of the best!
owhhhh!! aska is SOOOOOOOOO GOOD!!! ;P ahahahahhaa.. i love his voice! ;p hehehhee... the mc is so bad!! she didnt believe aska bout his girlfriend!!! hahahaha.. ;p
thanks for uploading ;p
good bye my love我的爱人
hahahha.. yay for both of them!! ;p anyway.. i think the mc is really MEAN!! how could she said such things to aska?!?! ahahahhhha.. i love aska! i think he's really GOOD! ;P
Aska is the don!!
在6分23秒中,潘裕文笑得好可愛....
Aww, I thought they sang well together! It would be really annoying if they kept trying to battle each other in the song, it's nice this way. :) Different voice tones, that's what their duet special. Physics! \o/
always feel hurt that Pan was being criticise like that by the judge, I feel comfortable listen to their duet, they just have different style...
OMG can't believe the host makes fun of Aska, they're both the same
雖然一開始有點音有點不準
不過其他都不錯！
棒！
桃子姐為什麼不繼續問楊宗緯下去呢， 他女友這一段好好笑
I agree, don't understand why people think it's poor. Probably those from Taiwan province don't agree,haha
agree!
@antingting 完全同意你的讲法！！杨宗纬真的太过了
其待物理再度合唱!!
thaz GOLD stuff
so hilarious!!
細細聽 真的差很多 一個是K歌 一個是 專業
我超喜歡陶子的!!沒了她, 我相信星光大道真的不太好看
潘裕文的音线有点弱.....不行..
like it..^^
2:18 才开始
i think not bad leh, but yang zhong wei own pan yu wen a little...
Tao zi is so funny
Pan不适合这首歌。没有唱得多好或不好，只有选对了适合自己得歌才能发挥得好。
@ahCh1Ng0320 你確定棒棒堂能唱嗎?!?!在跨年或節目上的時候那個聲音總是走音的團體 我可以承認能跳能搞笑 不過唱歌這方面實在有待加強 飛輪海也是時好時壞 出道這麼多年 進步的幅度真的太小了 這樣看起來還是外貌加分比較多ㄚ
本來心情係低落...
但聽完陶子的笑話心情就好多啦=)
that xiao chong is just biased. i think peter and aska were equally good.
aska voice sounds very similar to sam lee!!!
日
小蟲懂條毛
陶晶瑩對楊的追問女友之事太過份了、請不要死纏爛打。曾見陶對胖子老師也是不近情理。知道妳會説話但不要缺德！
兩個唱的都不錯
就是長得好看一點的那個男的聲音不好聽
what is the song that 楊宗緯sang at 1:44?
陶晶瑩對楊的追問太不厚道了、亦曾見過對胖子考師同様情形。見好就收，別太過份。妳這樣只顯出妳的不專業！
這樣18分 從3 4班以後 18叫基本分吧??
我不知道ㄝ 我喜歡陶子 可是他損那男生的話，聽了很不高興
乾
Where the hell did you get that from?
But it's stupid and low-class of you saying that
I don't like you
但起码他是老实的。
没有报假岁！
老师讲话。。。严厉
一點都不好笑阿,就算為了製造效果也沒必要死纏爛打的問
Lol you say Yang Zong Wei 不能看 ROFL
小胖也沒他們唱得好啊，所以他沒資格當評審囉
会听的人都听得出"洋葱"的声音明显单薄啦.........
他连基本的中气都不足，好听个鸟？
宗緯长得有点像恐龙
杨之所以能够在星光红 全因有小虫和张宇这两个没水准的评判!!无论杨唱成怎样烂(甚至都还没唱)都已在心底给予高评价了!!! 在这首歌里,左听右听都听不出杨到底好过潘那里!!显现出小虫的评语真的太过头了,烂评判!!!
怎麼說呢，也跟評審無關，評審只是說出他們心中的感覺，其實你看這十年來，成果就非常明顯了，老潘聲音是不錯，可是就是沒有辨識度，美聲那種真的也平平，沒有太多的特色，現在是用模仿林宥嘉+自己的方式唱，雖然有進步，可是還是差太多了，老楊真的給什麼歌，只要不是太難的歌，馬上就唱出那個感覺了，甚至還超越原唱，這就是很明顯的差距了，老天給它們的成果真的差滿多的。
yiaphwee 今天楊跟潘的成就，你是看到了，如今對這兩位評審有何看法？