Can Türkiye Act as a Balance Against Russia and China in Central Asia?
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 08. 2024
- In this special edition of Strait Talk from the capital of Kazakhstan, Astana, join us as we look at Türkiye’s growing role in Central Asia, especially with the Turkic states that are looking to harness their potential to become a regional force.
Strait Talk, hosted by Ayse Suberker, is TRT World’s programme that features in-depth analysis of Türkiye’s role in the world.
Guests:
Zhanat Momynkulov, Academy of Public Administration Under the President of Kazakhstan
Talgat Moldabay, Eurasia National University
Abiyur Alshimbayev, Country Manager at Turkish Aerospace Limited
Aytunc Keskin, COO at Kazakhstan Aselsan Engineering
Huseyn Arslan, YDA Group Chairperson
Mustafa Kapucu, Turkish Ambassador to Kazakhstan
We are Turkic people.
Our higher identity is coming back to us 🇰🇿
You can find your identity back in Mongolia.
@@Khachaturr Learn about flags and geography.
You da student of MC'donalds.
Look at a Kazakh and an anatolian Turk. Literally no resemblence.
@@vlad_47 I'm the Tatar Türk from Türkiye. Let's compare come on. Hadi du te în... Acuma marş marş.
@@KhachaturrSure. 👍
Our lands used to stretch from Korea to the Black Sea.
We remember.
God bless turkiye from somalia
God bless Somalia from Mars
Shut up doqon kaa tahay was
..may Allah bless Somalia, our brother nation
TURKIYE❤
Dadka hanagu soo jeedin reer baadiye tahaye
the positive development of bilateral relations between Kazakh republic and Türkiye is pleasing to every Turkic people around the world..
Bravo turkiye from Malaysia
Malagaysia. 😂
@@surojeetchatterjeepajeet will be pajeets
LONG LIVE TURKIC UNION 🇹🇷🇺🇿🇦🇿🇰🇿🇭🇺🇹🇲🇰🇬
You forgot to include the flag of Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus.
@@serhancofci2509Kardeşim, maalesef işletim sistemlerinde Kuzey Kıbrıs Türk Cumhuriyeti bayrağı yok çünkü Kuzey Kıbrıs Türk Cumhuriyeti dünya tarafından tanınmayan bir devlettir. ❤️🐺🇹🇷🇦🇿🇰🇿🇹🇲🇺🇿🇰🇬🇭🇺KKTC🐺❤️
Kardeşim, Kuzey Kıbrıs Türk Cumhuriyeti'nin bayrağı yoksa KKTC ile belirtebilirsin.
Its good to be partners. But remember the west refused to allow Turkey into the EU for decades. Turkey needs to support friends that support them.
Turkic states are from same source, culture,language. We are all brothers of same great Turk nation
Teşekkürler 🇹🇷🌹🌷❤️
Well done Turkiye 👍
Kazakhstan has the longest border in the world with Russian Federation! 🇰🇿☝️
What is your point?
Yea that’s a bad thing
@@istanbullubenim5543 Kazakhstan should send oil through Azerbaijan. It is necessary to leave the EAEU and the CSTO and establish a military and economic alliance with the brotherly Turkic countries!🇰🇿🇹🇷🇦🇿🇺🇿🇰🇬
@@LastHope77777Kardeşim biz Türkler arasında böyle bir uluslararası birliğin olmasını çok isterdik ama Türkiye dahil tüm Türk devletlerinin askeri altyapılarını tamamlamaları gerekiyor. Ukrayna NATO'ya katılacağını söylediğinde ne oldu? Rusya Ukrayna'ya balıklama daldı. Rusya'ya bu fırsatı vermemeliyiz. Eğer tüm Türk devletleri en son modern silahlarla donatılmış olsaydı, Rusya bu devletlere saldırmaya cesaret edemezdi ve bu birlik daha kolay kurulurdu. Öncelikle bu birliğin uluslararası alanda etkili olabilmesi için Avrupa Birliği ve NATO modelinde olduğu gibi devletlerarası kurumların ve orduların koordineli bir şekilde çalışabilmesi gerekiyor. Yapılan toplantılarla bu oluşumların temelleri atılıyor. Bu düzenlemeler tamamlandıktan sonra bu birlik dünyaya duyurulacaktır. Bu birlik sayesinde hepimiz teknoloji ve ekonomi açısından gelişeceğiz. Askeri kanat sayesinde süper güçlere ve diğer oluşumlara karşı daha caydırıcı olacağız. Ortak projeler ve işbirlikleri sayesinde hepimiz gelişmiş ülke konumuna yükseleceğiz.
@@LastHope77777no Kazakistan ve Rusya 🇰🇿🤝🇷🇺 dosttur ikisiylede iyi ilişkiler içindedir
Yaşasın Türkler ! 🧿
Tutkic Union Army should unified their system so that it will be easy to coordinate when come to national security. It should establish a central command to response to any threat internal and external.
SON'S THE ONLY WARMONGERS ARE WESTERN NATION'S....WHO ONLY HAVE WAR MACHINES PRODUCTION...HIGH PROFITS FROM CORRUPTION TO POLITICIANS......
please do more long videos like this on this channel! I LOVE AYSE
Nice to see you really
Turkiye must have in the past half a century or more learn its lessons of dealing with the west particularly US, UK and EU.
🇰🇿🇹🇷❤️❤️❤️
It is false that Tajikistan is turkish speaking country. False news ...
Everyone gets that mixed up because it's an obscure "stan" country right in the middle of a bunch of "stans" that speak some form of Turkic.
Tajikistan's count citizens is 6 mln people and Turkic people's count is 3,5 mln
Half of Tajikistan is a country of Turkic origin and located in the Turkistan region.
Dispute with you is useless. You aren't aware of history of Tajik people. Tajiks nation has thousand years of history. In 10th century Tajiks established their first state Samanids State. At that time none of Turkish states didn't exist.
Tajikistan isn’t in the organisation.
I think they should also include Iran, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Tajikistan in their mega plan....It will boost muslim power.
this is a turkic only institution. Don't need you animals to this
Turkish blood and none Turkish Muslims in Central Asia, must united with Turkish people. .
eskiden müslümanlar toplu halde hareket etme kabiliyetine sahipti ama artık bu çok zor farklı düşüncelere sahip insanlar bunu reddediyor
@6:15
Of course we know that is tajik flag
Tajik not turkic😊
Tipik olarak Tacikistan'ın çoğunluğu Türk, Asya kökenliler ve iranla dil ve azınlık bir topluluk dışında alakaları yok
Half of Tajikistan is a country of Turkic origin and located in the Turkistan region.
@@TUR7777 what ? Tajiks have lived there thousands of years before turks left mongolia
Samarkand and bukhara are tajik cities
@@joebidet2050 How does it feel to be a liar and dishonorable? Stealing the history of Turks has become a habit for you. Learn to be honorable from the Turks.
@@Samanyolu-ov1ykno your wrong
Yes
I hope so.
Answer : No it’s switching from Russia to China
If Turkey can be a country, then Turtle can too
alpha is a word of Turkic origin.
Türkistan.
It’s not Gulf, it’s Persian Gulf. Go read the basics of history and geographic name.
Very stupid thumb nail. Why should Turkiye think on those lines. Turkiye considers itself as a member of the global community. Turkiye does not think in terms of US UK or EU as a hegemonic State.
Present day Education science Technology Economy and complete unity can make great
Turks will re-unite around the world under one big Union, the Turkic Union --> TURAN
Turan ???
That's pre turk
Ferdowsi made same mistake
🖕No
Why have to balance "against"?
Because
Alhamdulillah ❤
Dutch and german language and blood are closer than kyrgyz and turkiye but no dutch man calls germany his brother country 😂
That is your business man.
Yes but Dutch and German are very cooperative
@@hotkayz cooperative yes
But never heard them call each other brothers
Many Dutch don't like Germans
All Turk nations are much closer by blood than any german dutch and whatever. And we don't care what they call each other actually we don't care what in small countries which cannot withstand russia think.
@@joebidet2050 Because Europeans dont value their Kin and Community as much as Turks.
"Israel killed own citizens on October 7 in ‘Hannibal Directive’"
The Telegraph:- 13 June 2024
"In recent conflicts, such indirect deaths range from three to 15 times the number of direct deaths. Applying a conservative estimate of four indirect deaths per one direct death to the 37 396 deaths reported, it is not implausible to estimate that up to ***186 000*** or even more deaths could be attributable to the current conflict in Gaza"
__The Lancet - Gaza report 2024
Gaza report? 😂 that's your source.
Turkije should put there focus here not on europe
Turkiye want to join Euro Union for decades...and EU rejected...Turkiye is Asian😂😂😂
😂I'm not Turkish I live somewhere east of Asia and Turkish people and greek people is Soo hard to differentiate 😂. You liar they look greek when I visited both land
Jai Hind. The Ottoman had always considered themselves the successor to the Caesars of East Rome as the Sultans of Rum.
Hey dont get scared about unification of Turkic peoples all over the world including Hungarians who are the descendants of Attila Khan who happens to be one of the most noteworthy commanders of Turkish armies.
Turkie rejected to join evro union in which century are u living Mr 😊
Soon, half of Turkey will be Kurdish. In Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan, Russian language is dominant in major cities and among educated. One third of Uzbekistan are also Tajiks.
You don't know Central Asia
@@Ohio980 Put forward your arguments.
@ashkanshekarchi7753 in Kazakhstan main big cities are now being kazakhized, rapidly and overwhelmingly, they are historical and social dynamics. 72% of population are Kazakhs. 82% of capital Astana,are Kazakhs, 70 percent of Public state university grants are met with Kazakh language already. 60% state budget for information is in Kazakh language, officially. After Ukraine war2 in 2022 the Kazakhs try to speak and work in KAZAKH. Decolonization=Derussification=Desovietization.
@@Ohio980 Yet, whoever Kazakhs I see online or overseas speak Russian. They produce nothing substantive in Kazakh. Let alone that these new-born countries would not survive one American hegemony collapsed. Central Asia would be divided and swallowed up by Russian, Chinese and Iranian encroachment. Same goes for Baltic countries, Ukraine, Belarus and Moldova.
@@ashkanshekarchi7753 it is wishful thinking about Kazakhs and the US.
The question asked in video --
A controversial question !
If corruption rid off, economy will prosper in those countries especially in Kazakhstan. The only one enemy is their spoiled system where a person (president) has been ruling for a decade.
What is a Turk ??
Today 50 different ethnic mix
Uyghur uzbek kyrgyz kazakh etc
All mixed with saka iran tocharian
Andronovo etc
Even language is different
Qarluk kipchak etc
All Turks are descended from the Altaic people. We are one.
@@Step2andBeyond well actually
Turks split from Mongols about 7000 years ago
Mostly likely in ne modern day china
Turkish language is about 4500 years old and many scientists believe started in modern day central mongolia
In that time turks have mixed with dozens of many peoples
Are uyghurs turks ? Starting In 850 ad They mixed with tocharian Indo European speakers who practiced Buddhism
One example
@@joebidet2050 Uyghurs are our Turkic brothers too. Mongols are not Turks. They are like our cousins. It doesn't matter if we mixed. We are still Turks.
@@Step2andBeyond
I didn't say Mongols were turks
I know the Mongols are your cousins
I said that in my previous post
Just giving you history lesson
2024 there is no one "turk "
Not language not people
Similar yes
Spanish and Italian are closer in blood and language than Azerbaijan and kyrgyz
But a Spaniard would never say he is Italian:-)
@@joebidet2050 The roman language was forced on the gauls, hispanics, etc which is why they speak similar languages.
In contrast, the Turks have a shared lineage (even if not genetically than at least culturally).
I am Iranian Turkmen. I have zero family in Turkey. When I do a 23andme test, it predicts that I'm ~50% central asian (Turkmenistan, Balkan area), ~45% anatolian (Aydin and Sivas), and 5% other things. Why does it predict that I am Turkish if I have no family there? Because our genes are similar. Anatolia is a mix of Turkmen people (like me) and other tribes, but the dominant culture is Turkic, and they are my kin just like the Uzbeks, Kazakhs, etc.
ARMENIA IS ON
HIGHLANDS OF ARMENIA
🇰🇿🇨🇳🇹🇷🇺🇿🇦🇿🇵🇰
Tajikistan is not turki-speaking country. Please correct it. Tajiks are one of the ancient nation and they speak their own beautiful language Tajik language.
😂
Half turkic.
With Turk Pezeshkian becoming president of Iran the tide is changing
1. It would be cool if the USA, UK, EU invest and help Kazakhstan purchase oil tankers.
So that Kazakhstan could transport Oil and Gas through the Caspian Sea to Azerbaijan, through the BTC pipeline (Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan).
In order for Kazakhstan to quickly get rid of its total dependence on transit through the Russian CPC pipeline. 🇰🇿🇺🇲🇬🇧🇪🇺
Because more than 50% of oil and gas in Kazakhstan belongs to the USA, Great Britain and the EU.
How will the US, UK and EU send their 50% of Oil and Gas home if tomorrow Russia completely shuts down the CPC pipeline?
2. It would be cool if the USA, UK, EU, China and Turkey invest in the railway sector and in the Caspian ports of Kazakhstan.
And they will help Kazakhstan build a new railway from China to the Caspian Sea, according to the standards of Europe and China.
So that Kazakhstan could quickly get rid of its total dependence on transit through old Russian railways and ports.
Because now the USA, UK, EU, China and Turkey need alternative and safer transit routes through Kazakhstan, bypassing sanctioned Russia and bypassing the not very safe Suez Canal! 🇰🇿🇺🇲🇬🇧🇪🇺🇨🇳🇹🇷
3. It would be cool if the USA, UK, EU, China and Turkey invest in Kazakhstan in such areas as: energy, agro-industry, transport infrastructure, education, science, medicine, raw materials processing, industry, petrochemicals, mechanical engineering, aircraft manufacturing, space sector , military industrial complex, textile industry, construction, etc.
So that Kazakhstan can quickly get rid of its total dependence on imported Russian goods, food and medicines.
Then Kazakhstan can really quickly and painlessly get out of Russia’s traps, such as the EAEU and the CSTO.
And it’s time for the EU to at least cancel the visa with Kazakhstan! 🇰🇿🇺🇲🇬🇧🇪🇺🇨🇳🇹🇷
Because I think the USA, UK, EU, China and Turkey will not benefit,
if a country like Kazakhstan, with such large natural, useful resources and convenient transit routes, again turns into a province of Russia, like in the USSR.
How did this happen to Belarus under the pretext of a “union state” with Russia...
@@LastHope77777 You are pathetic.
From the Unconscious Hell ❤️
To the Conscious Hell 💚
Until the Paradise of Consciousness 💜
The Universe is Not a Hierarchical Pyramid of Mathematic Quantities
The Universe is a Holarchic Sphere of Spheres of Consciousness Qualities
Stay Awake Not Woke ❤️ 💚 💜
300million Turks🤫
Northwest Muslim Turks are getting violated
Turkiye ethnically greek/Roman not Turk; Turks look like Mongol central asian not european
Okay,master
Sure, in ancient times, Greek/Roman were the only worthwhile people to talk about.
True. The blood of Artugrul is diluted.
If you looks for good in history you Will find that your descendets ara Türkish !
If you want !!!
Looks for it!
Mongol Khan, I would say
Viiva iran 🇮🇷 Libanon 🇱🇧 Syria 🇸🇾 Yemen 🇾🇪 are strong ❤. gaza.
Erdogan Israel
jealous
Balance no double dealing snake yes
Look who says that lindu mindu
Go build a toilet in your country, much needed.
Hi I'm from Indonesian I hate religious extremist 😊 including foreign ones
Banu Adam. coffee ☕
Good afternoon ❤Turkic States+❤️🦾😇👋
Is Hungary really a Turkic state? I thought Hungarians were Slavic.
Hungary is Mazharistan, the Mazhars are a Turkic tribe that migrated from Central Asia to Europe
They are not from the same Clan as us they are kipchak turks we Turks in Turkiye are Oguz turks
@turan2815 In Turkey, there are also "Kipchak" Turks like me. A Turk is a Turk, no matter which tribe.
Hungary is mix of Huns ( Turkic), Magyars ( Uralic) Onogurs ( Turkic).
Hungeri- land of Hunns or Gunns
NO.. Turkiye Agreement already fail.. No need second
I don't think so 🤔
Erdogan is not even Turk he is a byzantine Greek what he is talking? Same the Neoturks of Anatolia they are mostly byzantines 😂❤❤
Etruscans who founded Rome were Turks😘
@@TUR7777 lol 😆 😂 🤣
Turkey is going to one more partition
There will never be any danger to Turkiye from any european nation for 100 percent. But there will always be danger to Turkiye from russuans, iranians or some arabs. Just because of location and interests in that region.
Probably just the opposite. Crusaders are still alive.
Turky itself isn't Independent Country its under the NATO American Rules 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
turkey and turks never been under
any country s rule its the most independent country although its in nato but has been let down by European Islamophobia and its discrimination and is now considering to look elsewhere to serve its economy and military protection because NATO is getting into too many uneeded civil wars mostly with their private armies that is destabilizing the region so maybe it's better for turkey to be more neutral and stop supporting the colonialist zionist based geo politics of NATO s double standard of Ukraine and GAZZA .
@@raifdenktas3852 central asian turks were under Russian rule for 130 years
Its KAZAKHSTAN
Not kazakistan
why does everything only have to be in your language of English? no it's Kazakhstan in turkish get used to it and turkiye in turkish not turkey
@@raifdenktas3852 I wrote Kazakhstan
What is problem?
I always said Turkiye
I never say turkey
In Spanish always Turkiye
The English language is Turkic-based. The languages formed in Europe come from Turkic roots.
@@TUR7777 😂🤣🤡
Yes, my dear brothers, my beloved Palestine is the cradle of Christianity and Judaism, and it contains Al-Aqsa, the third holiest place for us Muslims in Palestine. Bethlehem, the cradle of Christ, is a blessed land, and it is the holy land, and it has been our land for tens of thousands of years, and it is the land of the Canaanite Arabs, the original Palestinian people, and they have lived in it since the Islamic conquest in the era. The Umayyad, Abbasid and Ottoman Arabs, Muslims, Christians and Jews are like brothers and neighbors under Palestinian rule to the owners of the land, but the Zionists came and the British occupation brought them to our land as compensation to the Jews for what they did to them Hitler. The question here is that who did the Holocaust, the Germans, why do I, the Palestinian Arab, pay the price? Why not Germany? Why do I, the Muslim, pay the price for crimes? Committed by the Germans and Nazi Europe, fascism is the root of all evil in the world. Our problem is the occupation
If you did not until now, let me tell you, it's always been us and them, no matter what. Also if you don't know history, you won't know what's happening now and why, period and you won't ask those questions.
Oh, please be quiet! Millions of your immigrants are pouring into Europe and destroying the peaceful life there. If you are still complaining about Germany or Europe, why don't you go to your communist China and North Korea or even to your blood brother Saudi Arabia ! All of your endless disputes among yourself in the Middle East have no more market in Central Asia.
Iran and Hungary should join Turkic states organisation..
Aryans has nothing to do with Turkofiles.
@@surojeetchatterjee Aryan bir ırk değil dildir 😁
@@user-pf1mf5tn7h who told u that ? There is no language called Aryan. Its a civilisation.
@@surojeetchatterjee aryan terimi naziler döneminde yükselişe geçti ve bunu araştırırsan sadece din dil ve kültür olarak hint avrupa dil ailesindekiler için kullanılmış ve ırkta değildir
@@user-pf1mf5tn7h aryans has specific gene pool. Aryans has multiple races & languages. But Turks doesn't fall in that. Kurds fall in that.
Turkiye is close and very dependent on Russia and China. Turkiye can't act against Russia and China.
Türkiye is a bridge between of two continents and Türks are the only one who can choose the candidate for passing trough that bridge.
That's how Türkiye is...
@@erkuttimur:
Passing through that bridge at whose cost ?
@@erkuttimur Turkiye is landlocked. Turkiye needs access to the wider world.
@@LibochMy son just chill and accept the truth about the geopolicital stuation of today's worldwide.
You should Try to adapt. 🙋🏻♂️
@@Liboch Which cave did you come from? You are 2,000 yrs too late. Turkiye, with a coastline of 8,333 km long is surrounded by the sea, except its western border.
Central Asian ate NOT Turk At all ' they are Mongolian and Tajik Persian 100% 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
But their language and culture, religion is not Mongolian, nor Persian))) TURKIC !!! JUST REMEMBER
You know nothing about Central Asia. Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Turkmenistan are Turkic countries, and Tajikistan is a Persian country!
The majority of Central Asia is made up of Persianized Turkic people.
@@sellys2608 Ahahhah Except for a small community whose language is mixed with that ugly Persian, most of them resemble the Turks, not the Indian Persians.
Lol i am central asian Uzbek Turkic i have not encountered to mongols since i was born i am 22 years old and big part of gypsy people are tajiks Turkic Uzbeks never marry them they are beaggers, i do not hate them but it is a fakt 😂 you so funny bro
👉🌍❤️🇧🇩❤️🇦🇪❤️🇹🇷⭐Сара исҭахуп Ҭырқәтәыла Апрезидент Ердоган Бангладеш аминистр хадас исыԥхьарц, аха уи амчра заҵәык имоуп аполициа, амчра имам ауаа дырҭахӡам, избан акәзар 12 шықәса иара изы аус зуеит, ирацәаны избеит, убри аҟнытә сара хара сыҟоуп хара уажәшьҭа сара заҵәык соуп иеиҭаҵразы ааԥхьара исҭаз👈
Nope I don't think so
Who tf are you?😂
Tajikistan, kazakhistan these countries are liberal not practicing muslim
Tajikistan is not a Turkic country
So Türkiye is secular. 🤷🏻♂️
Who cares? Living in peace is everyone's wish, no matter what race, gender or religion you belong to. Don't try to grow bone in egg 😂
Tajikstan isn’t liberal at all lol😂😂😂😂. It’s a brutal dictatorship
@@user-vb6df4sd8d :
Then just replace him with China's Xi tler
Good afternoon Ayse Suberker ❤️🇹🇷🇷🇺🇨🇳🦾😇🌹🕊️
The term Central Asia was coined by Turkish enemies. Turks call it Turkestan. Turks do not like the word Central Asia at all, and whoever uses this term persistently will never take it seriously and even be wary of it.
Aryans land is not turkistan. Not all central Asia is turkic.
@@surojeetchatterjee There're more Türks than İndian speakers even in Iran so let's drink some Turkish "Ayran" cheers 🥛. 😋
Yes
It’s not Gulf, it’s Persian Gulf. Go read the basics of history and geographic name.