New Junction - Hornby Class 91 Under Closer Inspection
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 09. 2024
- A video I did for the Channel Patreons a couple of months ago, with the arrival of the DVT and coaches I thought it a good time to release this.
Join me as I unbox the new LNER Hornby Class 91 locomotive in 'OO' gauge and discuss my thoughts.
Don't forget you can keep upto date with all the behind the scenes goings on here:
/ newjunction
Real ECML footage curtesy of Lineside SouthEast, click here for more mainline video: / linesidesoutheast
Don't forget you can keep upto date with all the behind the scenes goings on here:
www.patreon.com/NewJunction
Great to have a review which is open and honest, whilst awake to the pressures on manufacturers due to the world situation. Too many reviews on other channels swing from brilliant to rubbish and slag the manufacturers off too quickly. Thanks as ever Richard, keep the videos coming
Thanks Tim, glad you enjoyed it!
Recommended price of £218 on Hornby's web site. Just no way is it worth that. Hornby are leading the charge for our hobby to be entirely elitist. Fueled by Lidl shopping pensioners who have nothing better to throw their money at, this is Kohler's targeted market. It will all end in tears..........
I'm afraid the cost of living affects us all, households and companies alike!
Hornby is a business not a charity
What a bitter rant. If they shop at Lidl , they watch their pennies……did you mean Waitrose ?
@@robd2184
You're missing the point (not surprisingly). These prices are way beyond the means of the average Joe. Hornby will be the first to suffer.......
@@ballbag £50m turnover in their March ‘22 accounts at Companies House with a £2.4m profit. A less than 5% profit on sales hardly seems profiteering - just trying to run a business.
Costs in China have increased exponentially of late. You have to ask are the likes of Accurascale absorbing costs to honour the prices of models they announced 3-4years ago. I would expect their prices to sku rocket within the next 12-18months also.
China (as a manufacturing base) isn’t what it was 10-15years ago.
Nice review Richard. I recon Hornby have come a long way with the class 91. I remember when they announced that they were going to retool the class 91 everyone was very excited about it. A very nice model by Hornby for sure. - Nicholas.
Thanks Nicholas
The details on this loco are stunning! Can't wait for you to run it on your layout when complete! Great work mate!
Thanks Adriel
Very good review Richard. I watched them being built as well as the 90s. 33 years older. A nice model. Thank you
You're welcome Tom
My favourite train. I love it’s sound and the model
thank you for another wonderful video New Junction
You're welcome Mels
Pays your money - takes your choice . £220 for this or £35 for the old one , some craft blades , milliput , plastic card , ph designs etch brass frets , fuse wire , dummy buckeyes , saw up the chassis to reposition the motor where it should be & you will get a great looking model.
What is noticeable is that on the original model is that the brake shoes are in line with the wheels etc are all on the bogie moulding whereas the new one hasn’t
With the original model it was made when Hornby where fiscally on the brink. The 1988 cat mock up promising a great looking model. The model delayed by a year due to funding issues ( company kept afloat by sales of flower fairies / scalextric ) & so they just didn’t have the money to make it as intended . The fact it got made at all is a miracle & all credit to Hornby for sticking to their guns at that time.
I always find it odd with reviews of 91’s / as getting the coaches the right way round seems totally lost on many.
LNER and GNER has been well produced. We won’t mention to swallow one (cough!).
For the decoder I would recommend the dapol imperium 6 function decoder. That allows full lighting control and F3 for the cab light. A Bachmann 21 pin also works, F5 cab light. Avoid zimo unless you want Tom have to change Cv’s. Of course a Hornby 21 pin would probably be the ideal choice..but hold on…it’s not out yet! 🙄 😆
That would explain why I couldn't find one to buy... 😅
Great video Richard got the 91 great model it will be very pleasing to see it passing the new 800 at 100mph
I bought the "For The Fallen" version Richard. It is fabulous, I have no complaints so far. It looks great with the original "Swallow" liveried coaches. I have even run it blunt end forward already. I have seen quite a few real life ones blunt end forward and I think they look great that way.
Yes the blunt end is very iconic!
I got 91118 for Christmas. Its a lovely loco, looks the part, got the speed, just need the coaches.
Its very nice, live mine!
@@NewJunction I'm surprised that there were no problems with mine from some of the stories that I've seen, it was a good deal from the model centre.
Got mine today and the first thing I noticed is the correct shade of red as on my older Virgin Class 91s and LNER HSTs the red is darker.
Great review Richard. I went for the GNER one. Got the Flying Albaman on pre order CANT wait for this one…..
Great video, nice to see a review. The light clusters do come down yes, I was fortunate enough to go to Neville Hill depot and saw 91110 with the blunt end light cluster box open.
Very nice!
Great review richard got the to the fallen 91 well impressed payed £196.00 as soon as I clapped eyes on it had to have one 🚂🚂🚂
What’s the tbing above the new junction sign and will you be running the loco in reveres ether correct end or pulling dvt end(can it connect to DVT
I also found the blunt end intimidating when I was a smaller child at newcastle central and I can't see them as much now
Glad it wasn't just me!
Great Stuff Richard
Thanks David!
It's a beautiful model but completely out of my price range- even the Railroad prices are way outside my budget. A second hand intercity class 91 can be found for £20-£30. Although there is criticism of the pantograph, it is happily available as a spare and I am using one to upgrade the one piece trainset pantograph on my old class 91 model which makes a massive improvement.
We both like the East Coast Main Line, but I am more old school. The 91 is a nice model, but it still looks like a Virgin Loco. I do wish when LNER came back they would have made their own livery, (Green) Martin. (Thailand)
Hi richard, can i ask have u had issues with mk4 DVTs, I have 3x TfW & 1xLNER, have fitted 21pin 6 function decoders ( from rails) but can't get cab lights to operate on any.
circuit are linked through board at both ends & illuminates with meters but not using f1-30, have u had any issues, rang Hornby & no luck
You have to use the Hornby decoder for it to work properly typically
@@NewJunction thanks for reply richard love the channel, the rails connect seems to work with all prototypical lighting but only issue is cab lights, have rewired 1 unit to operate off F1 but that was by cutting & resoldering
Nice review Richard, and that is a great looking model. I'm a modeller of limited means so these new locomotives are a thing of dreams, £200 + is way out of my league. I'm not jealous of modellers who can afford them. I work to my limits and am happy with that. But it seems to me that manufacturers like Hornby. Bachmann, Dapol, will charge a premium price for models that have maybe faults or are flimsy and often with no backup, you can't get spares, I see Bachmann are now operating a spares service so let's hope that live up to a promising start. I relie on Peter's spares and lendons of Cardiff and good old Ebay for my older models. Anyway enough moaning, one little question are you still continuing with your garden railway? I enjoyed following your adventures around the garden with the help of your lovely dog. Take care for now looking forward to seeing progress on new New Junction Eddy xx
Thanks Eddy, like you prices effect me so I'm buying this rake one coach at a time! Needs must..
The garden railway may not be appearing again, although I may do one final episode before I move house. 😅
Great review Richard, even though a I see the real thing every day
Thanks Harry!
Good review there Richard I like the look of the intercity 1
Yes it's OK but again let down by a poor quality DVT sadly
Thanks Stuart!
@@paulypyro I wouldn't say its poor quality, its definitely made to its price point at £65-75. Look at the Bachmann DBSO at £150 as a comparison for an unpowered trailer 😳
When you put the LNER transfers on the HST and 91 are they removable
Possibly but with great care
I have 2 - the intercity and LNER. The model is fine. In line with other manufacturers - just. Price a little steep but enought said about that. My gripe is the decoder. Hornby release a model for which the decoder did not exist. Had to find an alternative which works. Not sure of the situation now - but its too late for me - already bought
Where can I buy Hornby trains
Thanks for the review. I may have missed it, but guessing at the weight mentioned, can we assume it has all wheel drive and pickup ? Important info to know about on track performance and is not actually documented anywhere.
good vid thanks lee
Thanks Lee
if i got to pay a normal price maybe i would consider getting one, sadly that aint the case anymore
It's a fantastic looking loco (a classic) and in a great livery. That said, I have no dog in the hunt regarding Hornby, Bachmann, etc., but for the price these are now going for, there is no excuse for cheap plastic and molding errors in such models. As the prices are reaching what I pay for quality German locos with much more metal, such errors should not be passed by QC or others. It is sharp looking, and if it runs well, all the better, but these little issues, whether it is in design or in material used, should not be there.
You're dead right!
I have a GNER example and it is miles better than the original (really should have been re-tooled years ago!). Looks good and runs well although a bit clunky over some points and that isn’t always consistent. Many people are throwing their toys out of the pram about the pantograph but it doesn’t bother me- it’s much better than the over scale version of old. I’m pleased that Hornby updated the electrical spec for the lighting and a 21 pin socket but would have liked a more detailed cab and blanking piece for the front end. 8/10 for me, considering the RRP. Bought mine reduced which I feel is a more appropriate price for the model.
Thanks for the fair review and I feel the praise and reservations were valid and correct. Looking forward to the mk4s. Interzuma 225 livery next year? 😉
Ditto haha thanks!
Great overview of the hornby class 91 there Richard, in my opinion I think it is a decent model but could do with some improvements, my main one is the pantograph which I would want to be metal personally mainly because my experience with plastic pantographs has ended up with them becoming broken, I will definitely be picking up the loco and DVT in swallow livery but it will only be the loco and DVT because I already have eight of the original mk4 coaches and from what I have been told the new hornby 91 and the old mk4 coaches the colours do match each other quite well.
Nice one!
The biggest issue this model has is that for the money, other companies are making better models of AC electric locos, Bachmann's class 90 immediately springs to mind. Not to mention if the accurscale class 92 turns out okay then that is not only cheaper but more technologically advanced.
Accurascale are certainly adding competition to the mix, great for us consumers!
New to the hobby last couple of years. Seriously the pricing is insane. Hope the plastic packaging is recyclable too. Just keep seeing what could be a great hobby being limited to a few and being bad for the environment with over package prducts.
hate the raised strip under the windows, its flush on the real locos, and the three black dots? .....
If it had the spec my Bachmann class 90 has then nice ,this argument isn’t going away regarding value ,anyway layout is coming along no more hot box loft mate
Cheers
Mark 😃😃
Isnt the Bachmann 90 now £60 more at full RRP?
@@NewJunction it is now mate ,through the roof
Hold up, what sorry? Watching them come through Newcastle Central???? I didn't pick you as a Geordie?
Born and bred, moved south at 11 and lost the accent sadly.
@@NewJunction me too! Only - up north at 11. Scotland. I'm in Australia now though.
What do you reckon the chances are of Hornby doing a standard VTEC red and white 91 and DVT in the future? Or do you think they've 'ticked that box' by doing 91111 (which is an excellent choice of livery, but plenty of others to choose from too)
If its anything like the HST, I'm sure they'll get round to it eventually.
Nice review . I just got one here in the states for $165.00. Great price .
If I could get one for around £130 I might just think about it. £220? Nah! Mark - was yours new/retail or second hand etc? How can they be sold so much cheaper in the US?!
@@paullepine4765 sadly thats become an unrealistic price we're going to have to get used too. There's just not enough margin in that to support a retailer/manufacturer and factory.
@@NewJunction i accept that and i won't be buying full stop. It just concerns me that perhaps Hornby is pricing itself out of business by chasing ever greater (dare i say it) unnecessary detail? My main point though was what was it doing on sale in the US at $165?
@@ballbag perhaps i am giving Hornby undue allowance as i dont know the full financial facts (but if i had to get off the fence it would be very very firmly on your side!), But i would like to know why its being sold (apparently) so much cheaper in the US?
Sorry it was not through Hornby I should have said .
Had a 91 002 in intercity livery. Been looking forward to this for a long time, but I'm bitterly disappointed. On opening the box the pantograph fell off. On the track, it derailed on points, even express points. On checking, the back to back gauge was out. With the intercity model, the cab detail is wrong, I believe these locos didn't have dash cameras. From a DC use point of view, the lights can't be switched off at the blunt end, no good with a train of mark 4 coaches. So, after all this wait for a new class 91, I sent it back to the retailer for my money back. Very poor value for money and poor quality control. I'll just have to remain in the deltic era with the wonderful Accurascale models. Disappointing because I've used the intercity 225 for many years and still do, much better ride than the azumas for all their age.
I have the ‘For The Fallen’ version which is a nice model but fully agree with your review. I hope Hornby take on board customers comments and upgrade the model in future. I’m awaiting the LNER DVT and the new MK4 coaches. I’ve seen mixed reviews/comments about them. Too many factory paint issues, chips, scuffs etc. So awaiting delivery with some trepidation.
I'm always wary of jumping on the band wagon before a model is in front of me, look hard enough and I bet you'll find most with issues lol
Looks great and definitely captures the feel of the 91. I keep being tempted by a GNER version, but this sits firmly in the shadows of Bachmann's 90 and likely Accurascale's 92 at the same price point
100%, it's quite exciting the competition we have at the moment!
Also, a plastic pantograph doesn't work to well if you power your electric locos from the catenary.
Not at all, layouts like that must be rare
I follow your videos with great enjoyment, but when I saw that you were reviewing a Hornby product, I thought, "hello, how is this going to work, he's an employee of Hornby". My fears, however, proved groundless as you seemed pretty unbiased and fair to me. Well done, I think that you seem to be a decent friendly chap, I believe now, that I can add "honest" to that label as well. Keep up the good work.
Thanks Nigel, if it helps clear things up further I don't work for Hornby, but Key Publishing who just license the name for our Magazine. 😊
Hi Richard nice review. I've got the "for the fallen" version. Mine does pull from the lower level to the upper level with no problems at all. However I've had problems with derailing and it's not a back to back problem. It just hates certain points and the transitions from the different levels. Still work in progress as none of my other locos have ever had a problem. Atb Andy
Hi Andy, how strange! More testing required
I’ve got the “fallen” version and overall it’s a good model although it came broken out of the box with the bogie retaining lug snapped off so it just fell out hanging by the pick up wires when I took it out. I chose to fix it rather than send it back from the states, it runs well but it’s clunky over certain points but no derailments so far. I lightly weathered the bogies and side valences to get rid of the plastic look; I also fitted a Bachmann snowplow 🤦♂️ which although is not photo typical improves the look with the nem pocket.
I may take my NEM socket off at some point, keep it safe in its box
Great video. We have ‘For The Fallen’ and a full rake of the new Hornby GNER MK4’s + DVT and 91. Our layout has two not exactly flat sections where the old Hornby 91’s used to struggle massively pulling a train up hill but now the new 91 does it with massive ease at a constant speed, no hesitation. We maybe lucky with that or not, I don’t know. For the decoder for the new 91’s, we used a Bachmann 21 pin decoder which uses the same functions ect as said on the paper given in the box, no need to change CV’s thankfully. I’d still rather have a Cavalex 225 set though haha.
I used the Bachmann chips in the end too
Ah epic
I was considering getting a GNER one even though its slightly out of my region. Unfortunately for the price, the cost cut pantograph and front coupler will mean I won't get it. If Bachmann had made it instead of Hornby I'm sure I would've bought one as the class 90 has a strong pantograph and metal shoe as well as blanking plates for the coupling holes. Not to mention a working pantograph and the fact that you can get them cheaper. Thanks for the great video you've saved my bank account for another day!
Happy to help!
I think it could of benefited from new wheels as I think it has old steam roller wheels and has problems with points and slips
This one handles points no problem
I don’t get why people would put this on a layout without catenary.
If like me, it'll be the last thing I add
I can't believe how expensive this is. In my dreams I would like to build a complete railway set for £220.
That I know is unrealistic.
A whole train for £220?
That sounds fair.
Just one loco?
I am thinking of that 'Drake meme' for some reason.
Don't shoot me, £220 RRP isn't as high as it could be compared to other manufacturers. 😅
Glass half full or half empty depending on you take on what you expect from anew model for me Hornby have again dropped the ball big time so plastic pantograph when on the Bachmann 90 a fully working one, so have running issues big point as Richard says lower skirt looks at best half a job for the price just mould a fully filled in one that you can change over by removing the screws ( simple and easy to do) and a best of both. Does it give value for money then from me a big not a chance so none for me and now looking at the issues with the new MK 4 coaches and DVT’s grrrrrrr .I seriously think if Cavalex had done the project like they were going to then we would have great models that the 91 and MK 4 fleet deserved.
You're not wrong
*** Clonking over points and derailments fix **** The bogies sit too high, up near the frame/body, almost touching so there's no tolerance gap for movement over any slight variations in the track. The bogie locating pin knocks where it meets the chassis housing as the materials are very hard. THE FIX: Slip in a thin spacer, a nylon or plastic washer between the bogie mounting point and chassis to give the extra tolerance for bogie movement to prevent derailments and it also quietens the clonking over points! Ta-dah! Check all the back to backs as some are slightly narrow. I made a washer by drilling a hole through a thin plastic sheet (a Peco point sleeve) and cutting around the hole to make a small washer with scissors. It worked to some degree but a proper nylon washer would be better.
Top tip!
I got mine recently and I've gotta say I love the model so much but for the price I'm really disappointed by a few shortcomings
I think for a £200+ model you have to have a painted cab when not so long ago you could pick up DVTs with detailed cabs for less than £50
I also have to say the pantograph is quite flimsy ? Perhaps that's just an issue with mine (one I don't care much for as I don't normally have them raised anyway)
I just think it's a bit crazy that a £200 model can have these issues
Let's hope the DVT and coaches are of good quality!
Thanks Eddy
It's not a big enough improvement for me to want to replace the original, which incidentally has a metal pantograph (albeit purchased separately).
If you're happy there's no reason to replace the current fleet in your collection 😊
Hi Richard.
Sorry to say but isn't there a conflict of interest as you are a member of hornby.?
I'm very honest with my reviews
The last 2 hornby I got was just worthless.
I'm not raging on hornby but last few years I feel they have lost there way last few years mainly with there QC..
Poor paint work ...light bleeds cracked body's etc.
I have just gone back on my word after the class 92 which again had terrible plastic paragraphs and electricity bits above ..honestly I was fuming with it looked nothing more than a toy and after a hour running it stopped....
I have no issue paying for a nice loco but ...really sorry to say hornby isn't producing it last few years...again I'm not a hornby hater..
Just think issues as I've mentioned should off been seen in QC stage of the finish...
Even hard-core hornby fans I think would agree.
I hope hornby can sort there QC so people can be happier with there purchase.
Not a rant Richard just my 2 pence worth 😉
Cheers Mark
Hi Mark, I actually work for Key Publishing who license the name from Hornby for the magazine, not Hornby Hobbies so I can cast my opinion without fear.
A lot of people are concerned about quality control from manufacturers, and rightly so especially with prices going up, so should the quality!
However, this isn't a review of Hornby Hobbies en masse, just a light hearted unboxing of my new toy and my thoughts.
Nothing serious as its a hobby I'd like to enjoy not something else to loose sleep over. 😊
Regards
Richard
Exactly Richard
It is a hobby and a fantastic one at that))
Thanks for your reply
Happy modeling 😉
@@modelrailwayfantasia same to you, it might be an interesting video idea to discuss the cost of living vs quality control.. 😊
I also have this and just received the DVT which I am extremely disappointed with in terms of the quality and its Lima-esque feel in terms of its quality and finish and just feel the DVT really let's a rake down somewhat. Shame
I really quite like mine, particularly at its price point compared to the £150 DBSO from bachmann
The power car is fine, it's the DVT that's a shocker and I also have the Bachmann DBSO which I really like 👍
Hi Richard….. I agree that this model is a big improvement on the old version, but Hornby have priced this version in the high quality and detailed segment of the market. However they have let themselves and us customers down by skimping on some of the details expected at this price point. The main let down is the pantograph, what are they playing at? 😡
They are taking us for granted and it won’t help their reputation and status in the marketplace. Sadly.
Regards…… Steve L.
Thanks Steve
Mediocre model for a premium price.
Sadly that is where they are now, they have slipped even further down the quality market to a poor mid table manufacturer at best
@@paulypyro They'll be at the same level as Mechano soon.
I really do worry for the future of this hobby when the big manufacturers are charging these insanely high prices
All this will do is drive newcomers away when even a railroad locomotive sits at the £100 mark
Hornby can blame covid and other factors, but when brands such as Dapol and Accurascale are producing beautiful models with far less shortcomings for £120-160 it really makes you wonder why these are so expensive
@@DENPTrains Exactly this, and before covid it was blamed on inflation and rising wages. Inflation has not been 130% over the last 10 years... it's just Hornbys inability to balance a balance sheet.
@@paulypyro Lies
see the thing is hornby their already in financial dire strates so what do they do they raise the prices. And it will bite them in the rear end and also ruin the second hand market because people will go there which i am seeing going up already.
And people are paying it, some of the listing are too rich for my blood sadly
See the thing is that eBay sellers and Facebook market sellers are keeping an eye on the new market and second hand market and will pounce to take advantage to make more money. Like scalpers did with the 30 series graphic cards in 2020. Also doesn't help that Hornby say they want to bring new generations into the model train world when they charge an elite and disgusting price to enter that world which will turn them away. In my shop we do second hand model cars and trains and the like boxed and unboxed and we don't over do the pricing because we know people are not going to pay it.
Not worth the money
Out of interest, what would you price it for? 😊
@@NewJunction well I think I would be better value at about £150 at a push and also you have to get a Hornby chip or have the faf of reprogramming a chip . As for the pantograph it’s utter rubbish , and you can’t get replacement , so the class 91 will be the same
It is altogether rather plasticky. Whether that is the case off camera. But then again the real things are made of plastic I guess.
So 100% accurate? Haha
@@NewJunction Yep!