Stoicon 2018: Antonia Macaro on "How Buddhist is Stoicism?"

Sdílet
Vložit

Komentáře • 8

  • @antainmaclochlainn1457
    @antainmaclochlainn1457 Před 2 lety +7

    The speaker's book 'More Than Happiness' - a comparative and critical analysis of Stoic and Buddhist ethics - is probably the best work of popular philosophy I've ever read. It asks serious questions of both philosophies without resorting to the sweeping statements and catch-all condemnations of hostile commentators. Does a fine job of distilling highly complex systems of thought too.

  • @peterz53
    @peterz53 Před 5 lety +1

    Excellent!

  • @Nick-cp3sr
    @Nick-cp3sr Před 5 lety +1

    Brilliant explanation and synthesis of Buddhism & Stoicism...
    I feel the same - I have to reject the metaphysics of both traditions...
    (though understand many others are fine with the metaphysical components)...
    i’ll certainly be getting the book! Thanks so much for posting👍

  • @eddygan325
    @eddygan325 Před 3 lety

    Thank you for sharing.
    In Early buddhism, to practice the Right mindfulness, u must have Right View and right virtue(Sila) first.
    In my own experience, is really important to have right view and virtue before practice right mindfulness. Because mindfulness is like a vehicle, if u use it wrongly, will bring u out of the path.
    If it's Right - Mindfulness, it's should lead us to Right-Samadhi and the end of suffering.

  • @Csio12
    @Csio12 Před 10 měsíci

    If the non egoic state is beyond thought emotion memory, how can one describe it as bliss nirvana. Surely describing it is a memory of its existence and therefore another egoic state.

  • @Csio12
    @Csio12 Před 5 měsíci

    Whats wring with being oneself. Every religion is constant self criticism to reach some impossible goal of what they think is perfection

  • @sociolocomtsac
    @sociolocomtsac Před rokem +1

    Compassion isn't the same as empathy. Equanimity is not passivity, and is more about not being attached to outcome i.e. "must be a certain way." This woman is clueless in many ways.

  • @alecmisra4964
    @alecmisra4964 Před 5 lety +1

    That was dissapointing (the highest stoic complement!)