1 Year Anniversary Special: My Top 20 Batman Stories

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 25. 07. 2024
  • It was exactly one year ago I started reporting from Arkham Asylum.. Lets celebrate by ranking my 20 favorite Bat-Comics! Let me know yours in the comments! And thank you for watching!
    Batman was created by Bill Finger and Bob Kane. All related characters are properties of DC Comics.
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 190

  • @mr.rogues4145
    @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +79

    Wow this video was a tough b*tch to make.. Took a very long time and a lot of hard work.. I’m glad I got it finished on time! Also, my voice was a bit weak when I recorded so I may sound even weirder and creepier than usual, as if that was possible! Anyway, thanks for watching and helping to make this little corner of ours of CZcams so awesome!

    • @danielperrett3782
      @danielperrett3782 Před 7 lety +2

      Gotham Rogues Hey Rogues! I just want to say I'm a huge fan of your videos. Your one of my favorite youtubers and I hope one day you have millions of subscribers! If you ever want an idea for a video you should review the Batman villain Dr. Hurt. Okay keep up the great work! 👍👍👍

    • @zachsoroka8707
      @zachsoroka8707 Před 7 lety +1

      Gotham Rogues

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +7

      Thank you for being a fan! Yeah I might do Dr Hurt as a Forgotten Villain. He is pretty obscure after all.

    • @girlygamer-id8og
      @girlygamer-id8og Před 7 lety +2

      Gotham Rogues happy 1 year of the best channel

    • @girlygamer-id8og
      @girlygamer-id8og Před 7 lety

      Gotham Rogues I have a cool 2 tas episode you can review since I watched all of volume 2 you can review paging the crime doctor and mudslide

  • @chaseosborn6503
    @chaseosborn6503 Před 7 lety +53

    Some of my favorite Batman comics (in no particular order):
    1. Knightfall
    2. No Man's Land
    3. The Cult
    4. Ten Nights of the Beast
    5. The Ratcatcher
    6. Detective Comics #27
    7. Year One
    8. Going Sane
    9. Fear for Sale
    10. A Death in the Family.

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +8

      Awesome list! Fear for Sale and the Cult were two others that I seriously considered for my list.

    • @CartoonManWhoo
      @CartoonManWhoo Před 3 lety

      comixntoonz.blogspot.com/2019/05/80-years-of-batman.html

  • @KidCthulhu82
    @KidCthulhu82 Před 7 lety +33

    20. Prey
    19. The Joker's 5 way revenge
    18. The man who laughs
    17. Zero year
    16. Dark Knight returns (It's so low on my list because although I love the story, I hate the art)
    15. Ressurection of Ra's Al Ghul
    14. Birth of The Demon
    13. Black mirror/Skeleton cases
    12. I am Suicide/I am Bane (it's fresh in my mind and I really enjoyed it)
    11. Under the hood
    10. Arkham Asylum: A serious house on serious Earth
    9. Court of Owls
    8. Knightfall
    7. No man's land
    6. Tower of Babel (I think this counts, as it was kind of a Batman story)
    5. Hush
    4. Batman R.I.P.
    3. Killing Joke
    2. Death of the family
    1. Endgame
    But like you said at the end, I might change my mind tomorrow. Too many great stories and I had a tough time narrowing my favourites down.

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +11

      Cool to see Prey and Birth of the Demon on your list! And it's funny I also hate the art of TDKR but like the story.

    • @KidCthulhu82
      @KidCthulhu82 Před 7 lety +5

      Thanks. I really feel Prey is an underrated classic.

    • @CartoonManWhoo
      @CartoonManWhoo Před 3 lety

      comixntoonz.blogspot.com/2019/05/80-years-of-batman.html

  • @leafyishereisdumbnameakath4259

    The Ratcatcher would've fit perfectly in the show "Gotham". He could've built up Killer Croc too if Gotham has the rights.

  • @user-wo5tc9ux7u
    @user-wo5tc9ux7u Před 2 lety +1

    A list like this is so refreshing compared to the usual ones consisting of hush, long halloween, tdkr, court of owls etc

  • @MAMoreno
    @MAMoreno Před 5 lety +6

    I'm glad to see at least one list like this that isn't completely made up of predictable choices. Even if some of these issues wouldn't necessarily break my personal Top 20, I'm still supportive of any list that encourages people to check out good solo issues or two-parters from each era of Batman's 80-year run instead of just handing them _DKR_ and _Court of Owls_ and calling it a day.

  • @ignitionfrn2223
    @ignitionfrn2223 Před 2 lety +8

    1:35 - N°20 - Threat of the two headed coin
    2:40 - N°19 - Batman meets bat mite
    3:40 - N°18 - Love bird
    4:35 - N°17 - A bullet for bullock
    5:35 - N°16 - The ratcatcher
    6:40 - N°15 - The riddleless robberies of the riddler
    7:45 - N°14 - Knightfall
    8:50 - N°13 - No man's land
    9:50 - N°12 - Red rain
    11:00 - N°11 - Ticket to tragedy
    12:10 - N°10 - The killing joke
    13:10 - N°9 - The original two face trilogy
    14:20 - N°8 - Only angels have wings
    15:20 - N°7 - The original man bat trilogy
    16:25 - N°6 - Going sane
    17:30 - N°5 - Blind justice
    18:40 - N°4 - Dark knight, dark city
    19:40 - N°3 - The coming of clayface 3
    20:50 - N°2 - Year one
    22:00 - N°1 - The eye of the beholder

  • @RadinV1
    @RadinV1 Před 4 lety +2

    Going sane
    Goin' sane
    Go in' sane
    Go insane

  • @theshark4559
    @theshark4559 Před 7 lety +20

    Love you rogue don't stop making videos 🦇🦇🦇

  • @miketheeditor4798
    @miketheeditor4798 Před 7 lety +6

    I'm new to reading Batman comics, so these are the ones I've read so far.
    (In the order of when I read them.)
    1. The Killing Joke.
    2. Year One.
    3. The Long Halloween.
    4. Dark Victory.
    5. A Death In The Family.
    6. The Dark Knight Returns.
    7. Knightfall. (still reading.)

  • @CoffeeFilms17
    @CoffeeFilms17 Před 7 lety +17

    I'm happy to have been here since the beginning

  • @scottfree2248
    @scottfree2248 Před 6 lety +3

    Recommended reading
    10. The first appearance of Joker
    Batman #1 1940
    9. Batman # 296 ( A great Scarecrow story)
    8. DC Superhero Spectacular #1
    Batman Versus Kobra. Beautifully drawn by Jim Aparo.
    7.The Demon of Gothos Manor
    Beautiful and Haunting art by Irv. Norvick.
    6.The original Man Bat Trilogy
    Neal Adams at his finest!
    5.Brave and the Bold # 93 A classic Batman and House of Mystery Story! Beautiful Neal Adams art!
    4. Batman Night of the Reaper
    Brilliant writing by Denny O'Neill and brilliant art by Neal Adams.
    3.The untold story of Batman.
    A great three part miniseries with incredible Jim Aparo art.
    2.The original Ra's Al Ghul saga. Incredible art by Neal Adams. His illustrations of Talia were stunning!
    1. The Secret of The Waiting Graves. An incredible gothic horror story. Neal Adams version of the Batman reincarnated The Dark Knight from a figure of parody to an avenging figure of the night.

  • @miketheeditor4798
    @miketheeditor4798 Před 7 lety +57

    Man. I need to go to work in 5 minutes...... Nahhh Gotham Rogues is more important. 😁

  • @rorylumley4727
    @rorylumley4727 Před 7 lety +7

    I also really like bat mite glad to meet another fan

  • @xxsilentreatmentxx
    @xxsilentreatmentxx Před 7 lety +5

    My all time favorite is 'Venom' by Denny O'Neill. It doesn't feature any costumed rogues, just a twisted pharmacist and a General. It's a great Batman-centric story dealing with his drug addiction and realizing his human limitations. My favorite aspect of it is how Batman cares more about the pharmacist's daughter and the General's son than their parents do.

    • @dantedlane2
      @dantedlane2 Před 5 lety +1

      What else do you recommend besides the most famous ones

    • @Tabish29
      @Tabish29 Před 2 lety

      Venom is indeed one of the best if not the best Batman story I've ever read.

  • @scotia7326
    @scotia7326 Před 7 lety +13

    just saying I'm only doing 10 because I'm REALLY tired.
    10-The long Halloween (bit of a cliche to put this here, but I just love the concept of a villain in the rogues gallery representing a month or holiday, ivy was March with st Patrick's day, joker was Christmas, Scarecrow for Halloween, etc, plus being an artist myself, I won a certificate from my high school for my profile of poison ivy influences by the art in this book)
    9-Batman R.I.P. (By one of my favourite authors and an inspiration to me grant Morrison ((I'm also from glasgow)) not the best art but Morrison writes with perfect understanding of batman and his world)
    8-Death of the family (a brilliantly written batman and joker story with fantastic artwork)
    7-Going sane (I agree with you rogues, this is a bit of a masterpiece. An incredibly intriguing story which poses questions ive asked myself sometimes about the two's relationship)
    6-*going to cheat a little and put a whole selection of stories* Batman black and white stories. (okay not all of these are great, some of them are pretty bad in fact, but the few ones I read over and over again are:
    -Two of a kind by Bruce timm
    -A black and white world by Neil gaiman
    -Case study by Paul dini
    and
    -perpetual mourning by Ted mckneever
    all fantastic stories and alot of other short stories you should check out)
    5-Eye of the beholder (perfect two face story in my opinion)
    4-Mad love (another cliche but the writing of Paul dini and art by my drawing idol Bruce timm reminds me of my childhood)
    3-Endgame (also more of a batman and joker together story but the way this is written with some tongue in cheek dialogue and an origin story for mister J which I can accept, it's a personal fav and the way I think the batman should end)
    2-The killing joke (possibly number one but it's more of a joker AND batman story, but Alan Moore being my favourite author of all time, I had to include this)
    1-Whatever happened to the caped crusader? (pure masterpiece)

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +4

      Cool list! Nice to see someone else include Eye of The Beholder as well ;)

  • @grantpooley2148
    @grantpooley2148 Před 5 lety +1

    Batman #400 is what got me into comics. It's such a great issue and prominently features most of his villains at the time.

  • @spencerwatson771
    @spencerwatson771 Před 7 lety +8

    I'm loving these videos! Keep it up.
    I like that you started branching off into other heroes' rogues as well.
    I'd also like to see something about Morrison's R.I.P. run.

  • @dfcsons
    @dfcsons Před 6 lety +2

    Solid list....I'd throw in Batman 253 myself, where he and The Shadow teamed up in a one shot. I really like the channel, I regret it took me this long to find it!

  • @jackofallclaws6672
    @jackofallclaws6672 Před 7 lety +6

    Or maybe a Top 10 Batman Designs. I know that you mainly do Villains and not Heroes but I think it would an interesting Change Of Pace.

  • @mitchbray6637
    @mitchbray6637 Před 4 lety

    My number one favorite Batman story is Batman issue 40 aka "Fatal Wish". In it, Batman tries to stop a sniper from killing anymore people than he has, but when the killer wishes that everyone was dead, it triggers a painful memory from Batman's past and causes Bruce to lose focus. As a result, the sniper dies by a policeman's bullet It really shows how unable Batman is to elt go of the past and is a reminder that if you can't let go of the past, then you cannot solve the problems of the present. And also, the cover is awesome.

  • @VonWenk
    @VonWenk Před 5 lety +3

    "Eye of the Beholder" is my favorite post-Crisis reimagining of anything, mainly because it established Harvey Dent as having mental problems before he was disfigured.
    My top 10 (at the moment):
    1. The Laughing Fish/Sign of the Joker
    2. Case of the Honest Thief
    3. Messiah of the Midnight Sun
    4. Batman Year One
    5. Tomb of the White Bat
    6. The Batman Nobody Knows
    7. Daughter of the Demon
    8. Boxing
    9. Deathmask
    10.The Gorilla Crime Boss of Gotham City

    • @Nick-qf7vt
      @Nick-qf7vt Před 3 lety

      Great list! Some really obscure picks there

  • @laztoth3104
    @laztoth3104 Před 5 lety +2

    Love your Channel! It's a great history of the comics. I remember reading or having them when I was a kid. So THANKS for the Channel 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @rodster6campingprepper
    @rodster6campingprepper Před 7 lety +2

    Knightfall, Killing Joke, Dark Knight Dark City, A Gotham Tale, Laughing Fish. Just off the top of my head.

    • @CartoonManWhoo
      @CartoonManWhoo Před 3 lety

      comixntoonz.blogspot.com/2019/05/80-years-of-batman.html

  • @entennstudio
    @entennstudio Před 4 lety +1

    Finally a list that includes my all time favourite Batman stories “Blind Justice!”! So underrated, such fantastic story! Great list!

  • @Nick-qf7vt
    @Nick-qf7vt Před 5 lety +2

    Oh boy... this was tough.
    1. The Killing Joke
    2. Knightfall (including Knightquest and Knightend)
    3. Year One
    4. The Long Halloween
    5. Arkham Asylum
    6. The Dark Knight Returns
    7. Endgame
    8. The Man Who Laughs
    9. Earth One
    10. Detective Comics 27-37
    11. Dark Victory
    12. Zero Year
    13. Gotham By Gaslight
    14. Vampire Trilogy (Batman vs Dracula, Bloodstorm, Red Rain)
    Ones I still need to figure out the ranking of are Gothic, The Laughing Fish, Prey, Death of the Family, Ego, Dark Knight Dark City, and so many others.
    P.S., since you said you wish Bolland drew more Batman comics, he wrote and drew a story for Batman Black and White which has since been included in new versions of the Killing Joke, now with colour!

  • @joshuanelson6795
    @joshuanelson6795 Před 10 měsíci

    As others have said, I'm glad that you don't just go with the most popular choices and actually have some more obscure stories. As great as the most celebrated Batman stories are, there are far too many great ones that people tend to overlook and aren't even aware of. Anyway, after reading as much Batman as possible from various eras, my top 20 would have to be:
    20.) Ten Nights of the Beast (1987)
    19.) New Gotham (2000)
    18.) Heart of Hush (2009)
    17.) A Lonely Place of Dying (1989)
    16.) Endgame (2015)
    15.) The Man Who Laughs (2005)
    14.) Prey (1991)
    13.) Birth of the Demon (1992)
    12.) Eye of the Beholder (1990)
    11.) The Court of Owls (2011)
    10.) Night of the Stalker (1974)
    09.) A Death in the Family (1988)
    08.) Year One (1987)/Zero Year (2014)*
    07.) Son of the Demon (1987)
    06.) Death of the Family (2013)
    05.) No Man's Land (1999)
    04.) Knightfall (1993-94)
    03.) The Killing Joke (1988)
    02.) The Dark Knight Returns (1986)
    01.) The Long Halloween/Dark Victory (1997-2000)**
    *I couldn't decide which origin I liked more, so I put them both together.
    **Both go together perfectly as one big story.

  • @hiramdoup524
    @hiramdoup524 Před 4 lety +2

    Three great Batman stories from The Brave And The Bold: #79 Track of the Hook! Batman meets Deadman and joins the quest for his killer. ( The Deadman series introduced the League of Assassin's, which would lead to the introduction of Ra's Al Ghul!)
    #108. The Night Batman Sold His Soul. Is the mysterious man Batman and Sgt. Rock hunting for Hitler as Rock claims , or Satan as he claims to be to Batman?
    #195. Night of Blood . Batman teams up with Andrew Bennett of the House of Mystery's I, Vampire series!

  • @KR-nf3is
    @KR-nf3is Před 5 lety +1

    For me
    5. Year One
    4. Requiem of a Killer
    3. Challenge of Calendar Man
    2. Going Sane
    1. The Long Halloween

  • @stevendykes6854
    @stevendykes6854 Před 7 lety

    Fantastic list, and more importantly happy anniversary! Here's looking forward to another great year for the show!

  • @tayojones9460
    @tayojones9460 Před 7 lety +1

    What a great way to celebrate your one year anniversary! I have enjoyed watching all of your videos, especially your videos on underrated rogues and top 5 villain lists. I can't wait to see what other surprises you got up your sleeve.

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +1

      Thanks Tao, and for sticking around for such a long time ;)

  • @Puddin_Tame
    @Puddin_Tame Před 5 lety +1

    "Blind Justice" may be the most underrated Batman story of all time.
    Really surprised "The Dark Knight Returns" didn't make your list!

  • @CartoonManWhoo
    @CartoonManWhoo Před 3 lety +1

    My fav. 20:
    1. The Joker’s Five-Way Revenge (Batman #251)
    2. Strange Apparitions (Detective Comics #469-479)
    3. Daughter of the Demon (Batman #232)
    4. The Dark Knight Returns (miniseries)
    5. Batman: Year One (Batman #404-407)
    6. There is No Hope in Crime Alley (Detective Comics #457)
    7. The Long Halloween/Dark Victory
    8. Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth (graphic novel)
    9. Mad Love (The Batman Adventures: Mad Love #1)
    10. The Killing Joke (one-shot)
    11. Night of the Reaper (Batman #237)
    12. A Vow From the Grave (Detective Comics #410)
    13. Night of the Stalker (Detective Comics #439)
    14. The Batman Nobody Knows (Batman #250)
    15. Dreadful Birthday, Dear Joker (Batman #321)
    16. Shaman (Legends of the Dark Knight #1-5)
    17. The Joker/The Joker Returns (Batman #1)
    18. A Lonely Place of Dying (Batman #440-442, The New Titans #60-61)
    19. Robin the Boy Wonder (Detective Comics #38)
    20. Slayride (Detective Comics #826)
    comixntoonz.blogspot.com/2019/05/80-years-of-batman.html

  • @HomburghGuy
    @HomburghGuy Před 7 lety +2

    Interesting list. Batman: Gothic will always remain my favorite Batman story.

  • @danielcuevas5899
    @danielcuevas5899 Před 7 lety +3

    Congratulations Man !

  • @Applepoisoneer
    @Applepoisoneer Před 4 lety

    I don't know how I missed this video when it came out, because I'm pretty sure I've been subscribed since then. This was a great list and I'm so glad you're still going strong. Thanks for three years of great videos.

  • @AAllen-br8it
    @AAllen-br8it Před 7 lety +1

    I'm proud for this channel. I've taken a break to say Happy 1 year anniversary, Rogues. I got excited when I saw this in my notifications and I plan on watching it tonight. Will give my feedback then. Thanks for all of your hard work and entertainment.

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +1

      Thank you Mister, hope you like it! And looking forward to your list ;)

  • @J2M_official
    @J2M_official Před 7 lety +8

    I just teared up watching this video ;_; ! It's my boys first birthday!!!! But in all seriousness, what a milestone hey. From 0 subs and views on the very first day you started to where you are now! Your subs/fans could not be proud of you. 1 year is a mere pitstop in your journey to success on CZcams and I hope to see you continuously posting your amazing content. I hope that I can be here from the (near) beginning till whenever you reach 100k, then one 1 mil and so on. Congratulations brother and a remarkable choice of stories too if I do say so myself!!! Waiting on that face reveal ;)

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +5

      Thank you very much my old ninja friend!!
      I did a face reveal long ago actually, the video is called Rogue Thoughts.. ;)

    • @J2M_official
      @J2M_official Před 7 lety +3

      OOH i really have missed a lot XD!!! brb gonna go take a peak at this sexy guy

  • @DARTH_COMiX
    @DARTH_COMiX Před 5 měsíci +1

    my 5 are:
    1.war on crime
    2.strange apporitions
    3.knightfall
    4.devil's advocate
    5.alan grant and norm breyfogle's run on detective comics/batman/shadow of the bat

  • @nope5657
    @nope5657 Před 3 lety

    -Grant Morrison's run
    -Tom King's run (yes, I said it. What you gonna do?)
    -No Man's Land
    -TDKR (I mean, it's TDKR)
    -Most of the Legends of the Dark Knight run (it has some duds...but the majority of that run is surprisingly solid all the way around)
    -Strange Apparitions (this was the first crop of old school comics, along with Lee's Spidey, that got me to appreciate older comics)
    -The OG Batman and the Outsiders run by Mike Barr
    -The second run Doug Moench had on the character with art by Kelly Jones (most fans consider this minor Batman... it just WORKS for me)
    -The various "Adventures" titles that spun off BTAS
    - The Batman Black and White series
    -The OG Finger/Kane stuff from the 40s. I struggle with Golden Age stuff generally...but those first few years of Batman still hold up. They're simple, straight forward, and surprisingly grim little superhero/crime comics.
    - Peter J. Tomasi's Batman and Robin
    -The Long Halloween
    -Year One
    -Scott Snyder's run
    -Grant/Breyfogle run

  • @NoahFineburgh
    @NoahFineburgh Před 7 lety +1

    Great channel, I love your reviews. Especially the Riddler stories

  • @DiegoGuzman-nf4im
    @DiegoGuzman-nf4im Před 7 lety +1

    Congratulations! keep making this videos, i enjoy it a lot. Grettings from Colombia

  • @jamesstacey6495
    @jamesstacey6495 Před 5 lety +2

    Joker's five way revenge, the reaper, knightfall, detective comics 407, the laughing fish, batman comics 234, vengence of bane, batman comics 308, detective comics 525

  • @wesleywiggins958
    @wesleywiggins958 Před 5 lety +1

    1. Year One
    2. Earth One Vol. 1
    3. The Killing Joke
    4. No Man's Land
    5. The Man Who Laughs
    6. One Night In Gotham City (Technically a Superman tale, but Batman is pretty much the main focus)
    7. Knightfall
    8. The Laughing Fish/Sign Of The Joker
    9. The Black Mirror
    10. Batman R.I.P.
    11. The Court Of Owls
    12. The Long Halloween
    13. Dark Night, Dark City
    14. Mad Love
    15. The Cult
    16. Dark Victory
    17. A Death In The Family
    18. Venom
    19. Arkham Asylum: A Serious House On Serious Earths
    20. Love Bird

  • @inaogreimar2176
    @inaogreimar2176 Před 7 lety +1

    Happy Anniversary gotham rogues i have been a subscriber for 8 monthes and have faloved and loved your channel ever since you can see from all the coments i have made.

  • @halowafflebrains
    @halowafflebrains Před 7 lety +4

    Congrats man, and awesome work on this vid. Just found your channel a few weeks ago and I'm addicted to your vids. Great content and research

  • @crackedbatstudios
    @crackedbatstudios Před 7 lety +1

    Happy anniversary

  • @bcal8118
    @bcal8118 Před 7 lety +1

    U do an amazing job man,and u have a great story telling voice lol,keep up the great work!!!

  • @adamaksoy4169
    @adamaksoy4169 Před 7 lety +5

    Love your videos been subscribed since day 1

  • @thomascarbone8045
    @thomascarbone8045 Před 7 lety +1

    Great video man! I actually just bought and read Dark Knight, Dark city from my comic book store because I remembered how good you said it was, and I really dug it. So thank you and happy one year to you!

  • @darthgriffin7741
    @darthgriffin7741 Před 4 lety +1

    I ain’t gonna make a whole list because I’m about to go to bed, but Detective Comics #574: My Beginning and My Probable End is a fantastic issue ANY Batman fan should read, like seriously, my best advice I could give anyone is read that story, and then immediately read Batman Year One, they kinda go hand and hand, and then go read Zero Year if they want to.

  • @melissiaharris536
    @melissiaharris536 Před 5 lety

    I'm a huge fan of the channel keep up the good work

  • @richardsreviews8820
    @richardsreviews8820 Před 7 lety

    Love the channel. I'll give my list of top Batman stories tomorrow as it might take a while to make.

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety

      Thanks! Alrighty, looking forward to it!

    • @richardsreviews8820
      @richardsreviews8820 Před 7 lety

      Just gonna do comics, and I know I'll forget some. Out of order, by the way
      Jokers Five Way Revenge
      Night of the reaper
      Secret of The Waiting Graves
      Saga of The Demon
      The Bruce Wayne Murder Case
      Moon of the Wolf
      Island of mister Mayhew
      Batman RIP
      Air Time (detective Comics 751)
      Batman 682-281
      The Dark Knight Returns
      Broken City
      Long Halloween
      Dark Victory
      A Lonely Place of Dying
      Scott Snyder's whole run besides Superheavy (excluding what I haven't read so far)
      Court of Owls, City of Owls, Death of the Family, Zero Year (though I found it slow in parts), Endgame, My OWn Worst Enemy, also several of the annuals
      The Strange Costumes of Batman
      The Batman of Zur-en-argh
      The Penguin Affair
      Detective Comics 821
      I probably missed some

  • @Godzilla00X
    @Godzilla00X Před 7 lety

    You're one of the greatest Superhero guys on youtube IMO. Hoping for many more years of your vids man! Can't wait to see what you come up with next. Glad to see you like Red Rain, it's one of my favorite Batman comics as well. Would you ever consider doing a video discussing your thoughts on Batman Beyond?

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety

      Thank you very much! Sure I'll most likely get to Beyond eventually.

  • @Undead853
    @Undead853 Před 6 lety

    Hey dude really good video! Batman is my favourite super hero, so you have earned my subscription :)

  • @johnmonroe1771
    @johnmonroe1771 Před 7 lety

    Hey Gotham Rogues to fully complete the trio of 70s comics well one of them is from the early 80s but here we go since you've done Killer Croc,Man-Bat, The last one should be Swamp Thing I mean suprisingly he was extremely popular in the 70's hell he even got his own movie I would love for you to review him I've been a fan of him since I was a kid growing up in Louisiana and he's even got a race car based on him really cool stuff, Have a good day!

  • @snulch503
    @snulch503 Před 4 lety

    I don't know how I would go about ranking them, but up there I would have to put Batman and Robin Reborn, Batman Rip, Batman the Black Mirror, Court of Owls, The Cult, Long Halloween and Arkham Asylum, a Serious House on Serious Earth, (not in any particular order). Anything written by Grant Morrison or Scott Snyder I usually end up enjoying anyways. Great Video. Keep up the awesome work.

  • @jackofallclaws6672
    @jackofallclaws6672 Před 7 lety +15

    Here is an idea for Underrated Rouges: The K.G.Beast!

  • @dantedlane2
    @dantedlane2 Před 5 lety +4

    Batman love bird
    No man's land
    Ticket to tragedy
    Detective comics 66 62
    Only Angels have wings
    Going sane
    The coming of clayface 3

    • @Nick-qf7vt
      @Nick-qf7vt Před 3 lety

      What's Detective Comics 66 62?

  • @indumatipngtuber2790
    @indumatipngtuber2790 Před rokem

    I remember a TAS story similar to that Penguin Episode.

  • @kokiheavymetal
    @kokiheavymetal Před 4 lety

    My top 20 would be:
    - No mans land
    - Cataclysm
    - Knight quest
    - sword of Azrael
    - Birth of the Demon
    - Knights End
    - Contagium
    - venom
    - Batman & son
    - The return of Bruce Wayne
    - The Black Glove
    - R.I.P
    - Year One
    - Knightfall
    - Endgame
    - Death of the family (new 52)
    - Court of Owls
    - Batman incorporated
    - Hush
    - The Dark Knight Returns

  • @AAllen-br8it
    @AAllen-br8it Před 7 lety +1

    It was a great list I enjoyed watching it very much. I was so happy to see Dark Knight, Dark City mentioned. I knew that Eye of the Beholder was going to be on here lol I have it in a Batman Forever promo collection of some of the best Riddler and Two-Face stories. It was my favorite story In the whole book.
    Geez. like you said, making a list of best Batman stories is a BITCH. I would have to go through my collection to rank the ones that I have as a top 10. But Idk if I could rate them based on all of the bat stories I've ever read. I think maybe I'll try, if I get time, to just list the top 10 of my collection maybe not even in any particular order, but just to get dialogue going on about the topic.

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety

      Thanks glad you liked it! Yeah it is really tough.. I almost opted to not do the video and do something else instead..

  • @dougshoemaker7733
    @dougshoemaker7733 Před 6 lety +2

    The Joker's Five-Way Revenge from Batman 251. Written by Denny O'Neil and illustrated by Neal Adams.

  • @timsmalley7432
    @timsmalley7432 Před 3 lety

    I love Knightfall and No Mans Land. Long Halloween and Hush also.

  • @turtlecomicreviews7599

    New here! Love the 20. I just started getting into comics and kve been considering the batman golden age omnis. Wanted to see if maybe that would be a good start, i know its his first stories so maybe it should be a great place to start but maybe not.

  • @shanedevereux8122
    @shanedevereux8122 Před 7 lety +2

    i loved the art of bullet for bullock dont know why

  • @Marcissus
    @Marcissus Před 2 lety

    I intentionally keep my favorite Batman story a secret, it’s super obscure and like no one knows it.

  • @BobbyChrisafis
    @BobbyChrisafis Před 6 lety +1

    For Me:
    10. The Cult
    9. Gotham By Gaslight
    8. Noel
    7. Cycle of Violence
    6. Joker: Devil's Advocate
    5. Arkham Asylum
    4. The Long Halloween
    3. Year One
    2. The Killing Joke
    1. The Dark Knight Returns

  • @Excellsion
    @Excellsion Před 5 lety +1

    20:20 I hate to be that guy but dang it the guy is dabbing.

    • @CartoonManWhoo
      @CartoonManWhoo Před 3 lety

      comixntoonz.blogspot.com/2019/05/80-years-of-batman.html

  • @cpc9563
    @cpc9563 Před 7 lety +1

    Dr hurt is not really forgotten he is actually underrated

  • @robertnorton8519
    @robertnorton8519 Před 2 lety

    I really like your video's, and I have nothing bad to say about any of them, except the like of nightfall!!!! It's the one thing that at the time made me stop collecting batman comics, but your stuff rocks

  • @richardmeyer6807
    @richardmeyer6807 Před 7 lety +5

    Here's to another 100 episodes. 🍷

  • @osiancoleman8447
    @osiancoleman8447 Před 6 lety +1

    Very unique list

  • @mattisdx93
    @mattisdx93 Před 7 lety

    älskar dina video. från en gemensam batman fan

  • @dougshoemaker7733
    @dougshoemaker7733 Před 7 lety +1

    My favorite Batman story is Whatever Happened To The Caped Crusader? which appeared in Batman 686 and Detective Comics 853.

  • @spencerwatson771
    @spencerwatson771 Před 7 lety +4

    Also like to see a list of the best Dennis O Neal /Neal Adams stories.

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +2

      Hmm a top 5 on that subject could be interesting yeah.

  • @michaellonbon2584
    @michaellonbon2584 Před 4 lety +1

    My top 3 batman reads all time #1 long halloween and dark victory #2 death of the family #3 the dark knight saga.

    • @michaellonbon2584
      @michaellonbon2584 Před 4 lety

      Also love hush, court of owls, zero hour, endgame, year one and master race. Batman so bad ass chuck norris checks under his bed for batman before lights out.

  • @wesd7338
    @wesd7338 Před 6 lety

    i think its a year one one shot, "Baggage" . sweet story. No rogues per say but very cool.

  • @doujinloverXD
    @doujinloverXD Před 7 lety +2

    Love all your video's.
    You may not know much about me, but I'm a major comic book collector too with a specialty in DC. Perhaps we could do a collab video sometime?

  • @JDdr86
    @JDdr86 Před rokem

    13:02 -13:08 Preach, brother, PREACH!!!

  • @jmace2424
    @jmace2424 Před rokem

    Knightfall is my favorite series

  • @KidCthulhu82
    @KidCthulhu82 Před 6 lety

    20. Year 2; Fear The Reaper (First Batman comic I ever read)
    19. My own worst enemy
    18. Batman Incorporated
    17. Black Mirror (Technically a Batman story even though it's Grayson under the cowl)
    16. Prey
    15. Under the hood
    14. Lovers and Madmen
    13. The Joker's 5 way revenge
    12. Court of Owls
    11. Zero year
    10. Hush
    9. Dark Knight returns
    8. Batman R.I.P.
    7. Tower of Babel
    6. Dark Knights Metal
    5. No mans land
    4. Knightfall
    3. Killing joke
    2. Death of the family
    1. Endgame (I know it's really new, but this is my favourite Batman story ever. I love what Snyder has done with the Batman mythos)

  • @gameree96
    @gameree96 Před 5 lety +4

    5 Dislikes..? Uh, guys. The Like button's on the left, not the right. Come on, people! Get it right sometime! XD

  • @cole6843
    @cole6843 Před 3 lety

    20. Batman vs predator
    19. Batman venom
    18. Death in the family
    17. The last arkham
    16. Devils advocate
    15. Gotham by gaslight
    14. Fever
    13. My own worst enemy
    12. Prey
    11. Year one
    10. The dark knight returns
    9. Death has the last laugh
    8. The long halloween
    7. Knightfall
    6. Eye of the beholder
    5. Penguin triumphant
    4. Dark knight dark city
    3. No mans land
    2. Cult
    1. Serious house on serious earth.

  • @osiancoleman8447
    @osiancoleman8447 Před 6 lety +2

    Mine is I think which isn't definite cuz it's hard for me cuz I've read loads like u someone tell me if they disagree with some (haven't read prey
    Knightfall or no mans land)
    20.Black glove
    19.A lonely place of dying
    18.Zero Year Dark city
    17.Zero Year secret city
    16.time and the batman
    15.Endgame
    14.Dark victory
    13.Hush
    12.Superheavy/bloom
    11.Batman and robin reborn
    10.whatever happened to the cowed crusader
    9.RIP
    8.Killing joke
    7.DKR (haven't read it in years so probably would be higher if I remembered it better same with killing joke and Year one but remember them better)
    6.Under the hood
    5.Death of the family
    4.Black mirror
    3.Year one
    2.Court of owls
    1.Long Halloween

  • @Jack-ry7fl
    @Jack-ry7fl Před 5 lety

    I'm just trying to read more batman stories so I'll do a top 5 in no order
    1. Court of owls
    2. Fear of faith
    3. Batman rip
    4. The long Halloween
    5. Death of the family

  • @jackofallclaws6672
    @jackofallclaws6672 Před 7 lety +1

    Also what are your thoughts on OTHER Dark Heroes aside from Batman like HellBoy or The Specter? Sorry for so many questions Boss Bub.

  • @Xehanort10
    @Xehanort10 Před 6 lety

    9:07 The bit when Joker kidnaps babies and is planning to kill them really disturbs me. It's one of the sickest, most evil things he's ever done. And even Joker knows he's gone too far because he frowns after killing Sarah Gordon instead of smiling or laughing as he usually would.

  • @adamaksoy4169
    @adamaksoy4169 Před 7 lety +2

    1st view and like!

  • @Babbleplay
    @Babbleplay Před 5 lety

    People have mixed opinions of the animated Brave and Bold series, but, making Bat-Mite an entitled fanboy was a natural evolution of the character.

  • @Tabish29
    @Tabish29 Před 2 lety +1

    Venom.
    Gothic.
    Shaman
    The Lazarus Affair
    Year One.
    To Kill a Legend
    The Vampiri arc of the 80s
    Englehart Rogers run.
    Batman 600
    Batman 302. Attack of the Wirehead Killers
    Knightsend arc

  • @TherealDCAvenger
    @TherealDCAvenger Před 8 dny

    Here's my list
    No.1 Prey (My first batman comic)
    No.2 Knightfall
    No.3 The Man Who Laughs
    No.4 Creatures of Clay
    No.5 The Dark Knight Returns
    No.6 The Long Halloween
    No.7 Madness means the Man-Bat
    No.8 Gothic
    No.9 Son of the Demon
    No.10 Scottish Connection
    Honorable mentions [AKA I haven't read them yet] Joker's Boner, The Man-Bat Trilogy, Batman 1989 comic adaptation (I intend on buying the latter)
    [Edit] I know this channel is dead and this video is old but I still wanted to post my list

  • @earth12-dcau59
    @earth12-dcau59 Před 5 lety

    Top 5 Batman beyond stories

  • @waddlecopter3139
    @waddlecopter3139 Před 2 lety

    Gotta admit. Kinda sad to not see The Long Halloween on the list

  • @astrocitizen
    @astrocitizen Před 7 lety +1

    24:15 -- I think this the first time you've mentioned one of the live action TV show villains by name...

  • @karagouzzan6268
    @karagouzzan6268 Před 7 lety +7

    1. Batman Hush
    2. Batman Gotham By Gaslight
    3. Batman The Long Halloween
    4. Detective Comics #27
    5. Batman The Doom That Came To Gotham
    6. Batman No Man's Land
    7. Batman and Son
    8. Batman Strange Apparitions

    • @karagouzzan6268
      @karagouzzan6268 Před 7 lety +2

      9. Batman Endgame

    • @karagouzzan6268
      @karagouzzan6268 Před 7 lety +1

      And finally my all time favourite....

    • @karagouzzan6268
      @karagouzzan6268 Před 7 lety +3

      10. Batman A Death In The Family

    • @karagouzzan6268
      @karagouzzan6268 Před 7 lety +2

      Jacob Benton
      Thanks and if you'd like to see Batman reviews and top 10's make sure to check out my channel and share it with your friends. I'd really appreciate it

  • @j.j.hatter8444
    @j.j.hatter8444 Před 7 lety +1

    I really don't know what my Top 20 would be...and RIGHT NOW, I'm a little too lazy to try and make it. You have a lot of great choices, a few of which I haven't really read. Mine would be very different, however, I'm certain. Here's a quick list of some story arcs/novels/comics that you did not include on your list, which would have been somewhere on mine.
    1. Batman: Nine Lives (If you haven't read this Elseworlds story, you should. I honestly do believe you'll enjoy it...well, except for the way they work Riddler into things. That's really the only problem I HAVE with this comic, honestly.)
    2. The Long Halloween (I know you don't like Jeph Loeb that much, and I can totally understand why, but I really do love this story. It would probably be up there in my top five.)
    3. Gotham By Gaslight (Another Elseworlds story, with Batman in a Victorian/Edwardian era setting.)
    4. A Death in the Family (classic)
    5. The Laughing Fish/Sign of the Joker (classic)
    6. Batman: Madness (again, it's my favorite Mad Hatter story; the other two stories included in the "Haunted Knight" anthology were okay, but this one takes the cake for me)
    7. Under the Red Hood (I saw the movie before I read the story arc; I like them both quite a lot)
    8. Night of the Owls (I'm glad to see the Court of Owls are steadily making their way into other media, via "Gotham" and "Batman vs. Robin.")
    9. Night of the Shadow (I almost forgot this one. I don't want to go too into detail here, but suffice it to say it's a somewhat similar story to that of the TAS episode "Beware the Gray Ghost!" and involves Batman encountering a character who was a major inspiration in his real-life creation, way back when Bob Kane thought him up...and it connects this character to Bruce Wayne in a manner that does not break the fourth wall. There's a recent comic series that's ongoing involving similar ideas; once it finishes, I may consider it a contender, too.)
    That's almost half a list there, albeit in no particular order. XD

    • @mr.rogues4145
      @mr.rogues4145  Před 7 lety +1

      Awesome list! Night of the Shadow, is that the story from the 70s where Batman meets the Shadow? Haven't read it in over a decade..

    • @j.j.hatter8444
      @j.j.hatter8444 Před 7 lety

      It's one of two, yes. They recently released a six-part miniseries (the fifth issue just came out this week; the sixth is next month) that's also a crossover between Batman and The Shadow. Honestly, it just may be one of my new Top 20, even better than Night of the Shadow. It has a lot of what made Night of the Shadow great, thematically, but is able to take more time, and do a little more with its story, given the six-part structure. (If there's any major downside for me - SPOILER ALERT - it's that the only major Bat-Rogue is the Joker...which I guess makes sense, especially since Mr. J. is bloody everywhere...but considering in issue three we tease Batman being captured by A WHOLE SLEW OF VILLAINS, it's sort of disappointing that they are dealt with so easily and quickly in issue four.)

  • @shachafavidar7490
    @shachafavidar7490 Před 5 lety

    batman under the red hood takes it alll

  • @footballpro6092
    @footballpro6092 Před 7 lety +1

    can you do a video on the series Gotham joker

  • @yaboicameron77
    @yaboicameron77 Před 5 lety

    Can you do a. Review of the Arkham unhinged comic series please?