Eastern Front of WW1 animated: 1916-17

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 11. 05. 2024
  • 1,5 years into the Great War Russia began to suffer from increased war exhaustion. In 1916 it mobilized all of its resources to launch an offensive to end the war before it was crippled from war weariness.
    Patreon: / eastory
    Sources:
    Der Weltkrieg 1914 bis 1918
    Österreich-Ungarns letzter Krieg 1914 - 1918
    "Брусиловски: прорыв. Кампания 1916" - Нелипович С.Г.
    ""… Фронт сплошных митингов". Обобщённые архивные данные об июньском наступлении 1917 года войск Юго-Западного фронта." Нелипович С. Г.
    10:45 - commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
    10:59 - en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:...
    Members of the fist company to cross the Danube:
    Jakub Kunčík, Daniel, GenTornado, s3xyfish, Luke Sypkes,Sam Wolf, Kureivun, KARRAZ, Michael Libin, Neil Heriot, Plok, first_last, Bdiah, Jordan Corkins, SG, _thefishball, D C, Craig McCall, Marco, Kevin Castillo, Adam Wallace, Amine Hajji, Michael, Mingjian Wang, Eiko Streitz, אביתר הכהן, Kristaps, Greengsg9, Ned Weinert, Edungeon, Isaiah Snell-Feikema, Rocky Koer, Ori Taichman, Coast Guard #1, Pavel Kletnoy, Philip F Myers, rJ, Talbot-Jaaskelainen, Torfinn Tyvold, João Vítor Guidi, ned hulton, Stefan Moluf, Daniel J Pierce, Yuri B, JAY ALAN EDELMAN, Frank Scheer, Dongbin Zhang, D G, Kelly-Stephen Soo, Mark Fisher, Ryan Harbottle, RocketWrench, Eli Krumholz, Ivan Avdeev, Adam H, Louis Burke, Federico Peyrani, Arta Yusa, Herr Burns, Tibor Helienek, STRONTJESBERG, omega21, aserehuehue, Jorge Campos, Naseem Hanna, Piia Orav, Johan West, Kyle Askine, Erkki Jokinen, Dylan Frank, Woody, Lucio Franceschini, Marek Novák, Tylorn, Ivan Trapić, B L, WillN2Go1 ., CatInSpace, Dennis Anthony Zaluski, Sam Tyson, Christian Richard, KingHarkinian, Travis Fudge, William Bowe, Greg Kondrak, Christopher Plummer, Adam Coni, NvllivsInVerba, Alexander G Morgan, KB, Idan Vegana, Rahs, Arkonos, Nicholas Cubbon, Bogdan Sacarea, VonKickass, Ehood Garmiza, Juan Escobar, Håvard Damsberg, Bram Spliet, Marco Agnoletti, Work_to_do, Robert Vroman, Eric Strachan.

Komentáře • 558

  • @KonstantinValentix
    @KonstantinValentix Před 11 dny +699

    Surely that Lenin guy will make peace asap.

    • @ChobeVelyasha
      @ChobeVelyasha Před 11 dny +35

      Even though o didnt like it still Ussr is the best and Lenin and Stalin too best leaders for Russua

    • @KonstantinValentix
      @KonstantinValentix Před 11 dny +121

      @@ChobeVelyasha Are you high?

    • @ChobeVelyasha
      @ChobeVelyasha Před 11 dny +12

      ​@@KonstantinValentixwhy would you said that

    • @KonstantinValentix
      @KonstantinValentix Před 11 dny +99

      @@ChobeVelyasha Stalin was one of the worst humans to have ever existed.

    • @ChobeVelyasha
      @ChobeVelyasha Před 11 dny +18

      @@KonstantinValentix he was the best ruler for Russia,It would be cool if we had another one that will bring us the land,well we have Putin but its not quite the same

  • @AdrianDeer
    @AdrianDeer Před 11 dny +168

    Meanwhile on the video of the Western Front..
    "Look at the millimeter moving there.. and there.. wow.. such gains in one year" :O

    • @anderskorsback4104
      @anderskorsback4104 Před 10 dny +31

      "As a result of this successful offensive, General Haig was able to move his drinks cabinet five feet closer to Berlin".

    • @t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334
      @t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 Před 10 dny

      seriously why didnt the front move

    • @againsttheleftandright4065
      @againsttheleftandright4065 Před 10 dny +4

      @@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 Large number of troops per mile of front line, more machine guns and artillery, more trenches. Also, mountain terrain in Eastern France.

    • @t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334
      @t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 Před 10 dny

      @@againsttheleftandright4065 then why was ww2 so mobile they had all the things ww1 had was it the vehicles that mad war mobile again

    • @againsttheleftandright4065
      @againsttheleftandright4065 Před 10 dny +4

      @@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334
      World War Two saw the rapid advancement of low-echelon radio communication, mobile armored vehicles, pure motorized combat units, and accurate close air support. It was simply easier to get thousands of troops to a breakthrough location, and support them with trucks, tanks, and aircraft. This benefitted Germany, which had a numerical superiority in troops and aircraft over France. When we look at other parts of World War Two, such as in 1939 Poland or 1944 Italy, many of the issues of World War One are still apparent.

  • @janrolka557
    @janrolka557 Před 11 dny +203

    It always amazes me how forgotten the Brusilov Offenisive is. It was literally the bloodiest battle of WW1 with over 2 milion casualties on both sides. The only other battles that are comparable in this respect are: Kaiserschlacht Offensive, Moscow, Rzhev, Leningrad and Stalingrad. It's also fascinating from a millitary point of view. The Russians used tactics that revolutionized the battlefield. It also creates great opprotunities for what if scenarios. This offenisve could have failed completely as many other russian offensive in the Great War. Is such scenario Russia may have collapsed sooner with grim consequences for the Entente. It also could have succeeded and gave Russia a complete victory in the war. Unfortunately, it is really hard to find any really in depth sources on this topic. If you know any please tell in the comment section.

    • @insane5375
      @insane5375 Před 11 dny +2

      ye, one of the meat assaults that actually did some difference, or didn't?🤔

    • @ChobeVelyasha
      @ChobeVelyasha Před 11 dny +4

      Its bias info about brusliov in this video

    • @jordanpdoesstuff1688
      @jordanpdoesstuff1688 Před 11 dny

      ​@@ChobeVelyashaso do you truly believe the only war tactic russian's know is mass assault?

    • @insane5375
      @insane5375 Před 11 dny

      @@ChobeVelyasha yep, russians never lost tens of thousands in just weeks. Total bias :)

    • @konstantinriumin2657
      @konstantinriumin2657 Před 11 dny +24

      @@insane5375 Well, WWI was all about meat assaults. Even tanks were very rare and rarely influential until late in the war in the western front

  • @FirstLast_Nba
    @FirstLast_Nba Před 11 dny +148

    Fantastic, I'm sure the research and analysis was exhausting, so well done, and we can't wait to see and hear in more detail how the fronts of the red terror moved back fore in the hell that was the soviet takeover of the poor Russian and "Stan" people.

    • @ChobeVelyasha
      @ChobeVelyasha Před 11 dny +5

      Shot video bias against Russia in brusilov enemy lost way more than Russia

    • @Precutlion.9
      @Precutlion.9 Před 11 dny +1

      Why does it says it's been commented 15 hours ago?

    • @martinnemeth6909
      @martinnemeth6909 Před 11 dny

      you'll find that all factions of the russian civil war comitted atrocities and terror on a large scale, not just the reds...

    • @thecommunistparty1917
      @thecommunistparty1917 Před 11 dny +11

      ​@@ChobeVelyasha Casualties-wise both sides lose about the same including dead, injured and PoWs

    • @EEEEEEEE
      @EEEEEEEE Před 11 dny

      E‎ ‎

  • @josefrietveld219
    @josefrietveld219 Před 11 dny +159

    Very informative, easy to understand, love your frontline-approach. Greetings from vienna. On 21th of November 1916 Franz Joseph I., emperor of austria, apost. king of hungary, passed away. He sat on the throne for more than 67 years. A grace of god spared him from seeing his realm rammed to wreck.

    • @ShadowDragon1848
      @ShadowDragon1848 Před 11 dny +7

      Yeah really poor guy 😂😂😂

    • @chissstardestroyer
      @chissstardestroyer Před 10 dny +5

      Yeah, that's what happens when your country adheres to arisocracy and monarchy: it gets badly dismantled and overrun, as inevitably will happen; Franz Joseph's heir, as it turned out, tried to surrender to Wilson, but relying on the idiocy of "divine right' really did it: that alone ended his ability to keep *any* holdings and ensured the near-total-demise and complete wrecking of his country.
      What the Hapsburgs' domains were rightly subjected to way exceeds that of which Germany was subjected to, the reason for this really amounts to the views and history of the Hapsburg empire, which was really the HRE evolved, that emphasis on God's vicar having a close connection *alone* was a justified major cause of its complete total and utter demise; this's not jealousy nor envy at all- it is simple and something far wiser: the complete, total, and utter demise of anything derived from "above" and all that biblical nonsense of how to structure a government!

    • @poneyenshort9616
      @poneyenshort9616 Před 10 dny +4

      "his realm" => the prisons of the people of central europe, the dissolution of this abomination was one the greatest outcome of the first world war.

    • @ShadowDragon1848
      @ShadowDragon1848 Před 10 dny +2

      @@poneyenshort9616 The good thing is, CZcams and similar online locations are the only places where an monarchist can get 98 likes.

    • @josefrietveld219
      @josefrietveld219 Před 10 dny

      Sorry, i‘am neither a monarchist nor a catholic. Just a older human being that isn‘t that harsh in his historical judgements.

  • @MoskauGuy
    @MoskauGuy Před 11 dny +109

    This is best video man thanks for uploading it

  • @wotevert4679
    @wotevert4679 Před 11 dny +83

    wake up eastory uploaded

  • @SNOUPS4
    @SNOUPS4 Před 10 dny +3

    Great video!
    The sound/music balance seems back to being very very nice, this time
    Thanks for having spent the time to make the video for us

  • @NewVegasNerd
    @NewVegasNerd Před 8 dny +2

    It's amazing how excited I get every time I see a new Eastory upload. Way more than anything else I'm subscribed to. Instant watch, every time.

  • @azara9305
    @azara9305 Před 11 dny +12

    I love your vids! Keep up the excellent work.

  • @alexanderpozdnyakov3189
    @alexanderpozdnyakov3189 Před 11 dny +3

    Great video as always! Thanks for your tremendous effort!

  • @ramiromen6595
    @ramiromen6595 Před 11 dny +14

    Loved this series East, took me back to the old Great War channel (which in fact might warrant a rewatch since ww2 is ending)

  • @LuisPereira-xh6st
    @LuisPereira-xh6st Před 10 dny +5

    Was so eager for this video. Very detailed and didatic as the previous ones. Congratulations for the exceptional work. It would be great if you could also cover the WW1 Western front in a future video.

  • @rc59191
    @rc59191 Před 10 dny +1

    So happy you posted again love all the work you do dude.

  • @Hillbilly001
    @Hillbilly001 Před 11 dny +2

    Excellent video as always. Thanks for the post. Cheers from Tennessee

  • @MrBlue66
    @MrBlue66 Před 8 dny +2

    Love your videos man. Very informative and entertaining!!

  • @plavsk
    @plavsk Před 11 dny +3

    thank you for this amazing video

  • @gemusefachlummel6467
    @gemusefachlummel6467 Před 11 dny +47

    Romania was like: the risk I took was calculated. But boy, I'm bad at math

    • @Tovalokodonc
      @Tovalokodonc Před 11 dny +8

      Yeah, and they beat their chest that they held onto Moldavia... The Russian army did.

    • @metodiusm428
      @metodiusm428 Před 11 dny

      @@Tovalokodonc You again? 💀

    • @Tovalokodonc
      @Tovalokodonc Před 11 dny +1

      @@metodiusm428 Idk you , i guess, sure

    • @thieph
      @thieph Před 11 dny +1

      ​@@TovalokodoncTransylvania is Romania, we did the math correctly

    • @Tovalokodonc
      @Tovalokodonc Před 11 dny +1

      @@thieph Something must have been lost in translation

  • @robrot404
    @robrot404 Před 10 dny +2

    I remember a few years back I asked you about doing a video detailing the Russian civil war, and you replied that there was not enough information to make one.
    I guess it took you that long to do all the research lol
    great job, love your videos

  • @MrDoob-xo3sm
    @MrDoob-xo3sm Před 11 dny +1

    Great video! I thoroughly enjoyed it.

  • @IrisKatzur-mr6bc
    @IrisKatzur-mr6bc Před 11 dny +5

    Love your videos😊

  • @aserehuehue
    @aserehuehue Před 10 dny +1

    Always here to enjoy those videos

  • @user-eu3kh6rb1r
    @user-eu3kh6rb1r Před 11 dny +1

    Great content! Love it!

  • @trygveplaustrum4634
    @trygveplaustrum4634 Před 6 dny +2

    Thanks for sharing this! It’s rare to get the perspective of the Eastern Front. I had no idea that the north was so stagnant!

  • @drogotoadfoot6606
    @drogotoadfoot6606 Před 11 dny

    Another amasing job by Eastory.

  • @jt1976jt
    @jt1976jt Před 10 dny +1

    Keep up the good work! Don’t be tied of producing great work even if it doesn’t pay well and is exhausting!

  • @ermanay11
    @ermanay11 Před 11 dny

    Great video as always

  • @ilikenothing488
    @ilikenothing488 Před 10 dny

    another good vid, keep up the work!

  • @zotfotpiq
    @zotfotpiq Před 11 dny +1

    Can't get enough of your content over here in America. Your perspective, presentation, and research are phenomenal. Thank you.

  • @ron3252
    @ron3252 Před 11 dny

    Simply epic. Thank you!

  • @tartinocacaverdi6486
    @tartinocacaverdi6486 Před 11 dny

    Fantastic, thanks a.lot for all your efforts

  • @UlanyUlan102
    @UlanyUlan102 Před 11 dny +2

    Thank you for this amazing video! Im waiting for Italian Front (;

  • @lisakeitel3957
    @lisakeitel3957 Před 11 dny +1

    I would like to thank you for your great job.

  • @gangstarappa
    @gangstarappa Před 11 dny +1

    It's a good day when eastory uploads

  • @antonhunt
    @antonhunt Před 10 dny

    oh nice finally i had been waiting for this for soo long

  • @Usulovski
    @Usulovski Před 11 dny

    @Eastory Thanks for the another great video! I hope you plan to cover Polish-Soviet, Estonian-Soviet and Latvian-Soviet wars as well.

  • @shadeitplease7383
    @shadeitplease7383 Před 11 dny

    What!? I always get excited when I wake up to a new Eastory video

  • @il.nullacosmico
    @il.nullacosmico Před 11 dny

    I love your video good work

  • @Ahmet-no7po
    @Ahmet-no7po Před 8 dny +4

    My grandfather had fought in 1916 within Ottoman VI th Corps in Dobrudja, I am excited to see him as a dot on the map. I hope you will make another animated series for Ottoman fronts in the future

  • @evgeny2141
    @evgeny2141 Před 11 dny

    Amazing, thank you!

  • @FabienLeMans
    @FabienLeMans Před 11 dny

    Thank you very much

  • @paullunsford8921
    @paullunsford8921 Před 10 dny +12

    Thought you had hidden a subliminal message at 10:54, but was just a single frame of "Pogrom of the Winter Palace." Excellent painting, btw.

  • @adoge1175
    @adoge1175 Před 11 dny

    Now I know there is a very low chance you will see this, but where do you get your maps from? They are so high quality and well made. Did you make them yourself?

  • @eminmerttezcan6120
    @eminmerttezcan6120 Před 11 dny

    Great video.But i was wondering if you have any future plans for Caucasus campaign?

  • @berme6858
    @berme6858 Před 10 dny +1

    You´re the best. Can you make a video about the Winter war or the frontline of Finland in the WW2? Thank you.

  • @Superlegend56
    @Superlegend56 Před 11 dny +1

    Hype morning upload

  • @4sakenreaper42
    @4sakenreaper42 Před 7 dny +1

    Good video

  • @scottishbananaclan
    @scottishbananaclan Před 11 dny +1

    Awesome video. It would be so cool if u did one of these videos on the russian civil war. Ofc thatd be a nightmare, but u could probably just cover the southern front against the armed forces of south russia, and the esstern one against Kolchak. Idk lol

  • @pyeitme508
    @pyeitme508 Před 11 dny

    Wow thanks!

  • @hashkangaroo
    @hashkangaroo Před 11 dny +9

    You can see the military mismanagement clear as day in how they did their offensives. Lessons learned:
    1. Don't go on offensives without a clear numerical superiority.
    2. Concentrate numerical superiority against the weaker foe, and don't attack at all against the stronger foe.
    3. Attacking the weaker foe forces the stronger foe to shift troops to help him, which is just as effective as attacking him and for far fewer casualties.
    4. Don't expand the frontline when it forces you to go on the defensive and stretch your lines even thinner.
    5. Don't go on pointless offensives, since defeats sap national morale worse than the continued presence of the enemy on your soil does.

    • @pax6833
      @pax6833 Před 9 dny +4

      Well it's not that Russia was going on "pointless" offensives. Eastory doesn't cover it but many of Russia's actions were in conjunction with the Chantilly conferences, which were an attempt by the Allies to coordinate their war effort. If everyone conducted offensives at the same time, it would overstretch Germany.
      The issue is that the central powers went launched offensives first, and countries like France and Italy were demanding their allies do attacks to relieve pressure on them (arguably before they were ready).

    • @hashkangaroo
      @hashkangaroo Před 9 dny +1

      @@pax6833 The timing wasn't pointless, but each offensive could've been done differently.
      1:21 Should've concentrated more forces on the Austrians, taking some from the center and north (as they would do in later offensives).
      1:42 Instead of attacking the Germans, why not attack the Austrians in greater force? A big enough breakthrough will force the Germans to send troops to help the Austrians. This will have better results (some regained land and less casualties) than OTL (no land, a lot of casualties).
      2:30 Offensive in the north is not going to achieve anything, not even tie down extra German troops, because of the defenses there. Instead, why not attack in the middle to split the Austrian and German lines, or concentrate all forces against the Austrians?
      4:33 Should've held still or sent some troops to join the southern offensive to give them a numerical advantage.
      5:18 Alright, but after all the previous defeats it was a bad idea to go on the offensive anyway.
      6:22 The Romanians would've done much better if they'd joined in 1915, before the Bulgarians had joined the war and when the Russians were still deep in Galicia. As it was, them joining late only weakened the Russians.

    • @ConradJD777
      @ConradJD777 Před 9 dny +1

      >I have 500 hours in hoi4, trust me bro 🤓

    • @hashkangaroo
      @hashkangaroo Před 9 dny +1

      ​@@ConradJD777 Bruh, you only need basic reading comprehension to get this shit as the video plays. Use your brain for once instead of envying those who use theirs.

    • @RegiGiygas
      @RegiGiygas Před 9 dny

      @hashkangaroo Bruh, you only need basic reading comprehension to get this shit as the video plays. Use your brain for once instead of envying those who use theirs.

  • @berserker4940
    @berserker4940 Před 11 dny +1

    Luv me Eastory. Simple as

  • @kousikdhar9031
    @kousikdhar9031 Před 10 dny +6

    Wow! I’ve been waiting for 1916-1917 forever! Can’t wait for the Eastern Front in 1918! Appreciate the videos!
    Edit: Weren’t there also three battles in Romania, that defended Romania against Germany?

    • @94Miker
      @94Miker Před 10 dny

      Yes, the battles of Marasesti, Marasti and Oituz, were part of the Romanian Front after the Kerensky Offensive. The events take place at around 9:20

  • @Ren3gaid
    @Ren3gaid Před 10 dny +3

    It's so weird. In WW1 and WW2 when the enemy broke through Central Powers/Axis lines or couldn't success an attack, Germany sent reinforcements and the front stabilized lol
    Feels kinda like an OP weapon in a strategy game

  • @Camel-from-Arabia
    @Camel-from-Arabia Před 11 dny +3

    But lets not forget that in the same time, Russia fought also in Caucasus Front against Ottoman Empire.

  • @thesenate990
    @thesenate990 Před 10 dny +2

    good luck preparing the civil war video there were many factions within the russian civil war and the amount of chaos that unfolded from it is intense

  • @milerman6712
    @milerman6712 Před 11 dny +3

    You should cover the Napoleonic Wars to.

  • @fisheyefilms2512
    @fisheyefilms2512 Před 11 dny

    Will you also make more videos about the Russian inter-WW period after you're done with WWI on the Eastern Front?

  • @FlorinSutu
    @FlorinSutu Před 10 dny +2

    There was also a strong offensive in July - August 1917, launched by the Germans and the Austro-Hungarians against the Romanian Army, who was defending what was left of Romania. It resulted in several bloody battles. Overlooking the Central Powers forces was general August von Mackensen, at that moment one of the German Empire's most prominent and competent military leaders. That offensive was supposed to crush Romania, then to stab Russia from the south, through Romania. The Romanian Army hold the front line. As result, Romania survived to live another day.
    Romania surrendered in May 1918, two months after Russia sued for peace under Lenin. At that moment it was the only Ally country still functional on the whole Eastern Front. The Central Powers threatened Romania that they will focus on it all their might from the East...

  • @hko2006
    @hko2006 Před 11 dny +2

    10:54 what is the that one frame?

  • @bbenjoe
    @bbenjoe Před 10 dny +6

    Fun fact: The Romanian royal family was actually Hohenzollern. A branch of the German imperial family. So, when king Ferdinand I betrayed them, the emperor angrily had them erased from the family tree.

  • @MenteMaestra91
    @MenteMaestra91 Před 10 dny +1

    Millions of men died for not any progress at all. Being there must've been truly terrifying.

  • @raresduban9315
    @raresduban9315 Před 11 dny +10

    I'm so happy that u included Romania in one of ur videos :D

  • @jt1976jt
    @jt1976jt Před 10 dny +1

    Great work as usual. So interesting from a strategic perspective. From a human perspective, this probably led to 100+ year of continuing tragedy, death, and suffering in the Russia and Europe. Not that the land of Russia was lacking in human suffering before this, but so much more added since.

  • @thebacondefender1622
    @thebacondefender1622 Před 11 dny +4

    Lenin is that one grandpa and uncle looking guy, nothing bad would happen, right?

  • @begemod1743
    @begemod1743 Před 11 dny +5

    Romania got it's shet owned by the central powers 💀
    To think only quantity will do the work is pitiful 😔

    • @metodiusm428
      @metodiusm428 Před 11 dny

      What quantity? The Central Powers outnubered the Romanian forces by 30%, it had no chances from the start

    • @thieph
      @thieph Před 11 dny +1

      We double our teritory, lol. We survived alone in East after Russia collapsed, our only ally in the region. So central power are the suckers

  • @peep39
    @peep39 Před 7 dny +2

    Need Eastory to narrate my Hearts of Iron playthroughs

  • @SrTicMC
    @SrTicMC Před 8 dny

    I am quite dissapointed of you not explaining the Russian revolution, the German offensives over Bolshevik forces or the Brest-Litovsk peace treaty. However, this was a great series, I loved it, good job

  • @nikitakunitz3335
    @nikitakunitz3335 Před 11 dny +1

    WWI was main factor in development of internal situation in Russia. Even relatively succesful 1914 took tens of thousands of most trained and motivated Russian soldiers. As the war prolonged two flows of discontent started to grow.
    The first one was among part of ruling class that wanted to succesfully win the war and was more and more disillusioned with imperial government's and Nicholas II's inability to build an effective war economy and command. This flow of discontent concentrated in the parliament that demanded to form new effective government since 1915. As I know, reluctance of N-II to press commanders of the northern and central fronts to attack together with Brusilov's southern advance to "seize the opportunity of knocking A-H out of the war" made most of general staff completely disillusioned with N-II. In february 1917, Parliament bonded with High Command finally forced N-II to abdicate and formed new government, the Temporary one. But it was far too late and new government proved itself ineffective just the old one. Because not only big men of ruling class determine history.
    The other flow of discontent was popular one. Tremendous inequality, lack of opportunities and decades of oppression, both social and political, made majority of population disillusioned with existing state years before WWI. Already during Rus-Jap war, when in addition to mentioned above common men started to be drafted en mass to fight and die for goals obscure or alien to them, this popular discontent grew to the point when people started to ignore or overthrow imperial authorities, replacing them with local self-governing councils, the soviets. Back in 1907, this revolution was supressed, but this exact situation repeated itself during WWI, only on larger scale. In 1917, as N-II abdicated, people started to openly organise soviets once again, including the central one in Petrograd. One of its first decrees was organisation of soldier soviets on the front, that let soldiers to democratically decide if they want to execute officers' orders instead of blind obedience. This was this "lack of discipline" shown in the video. As Temporary government commited itself to continuing the war, and situation continued deteriorating both on front and inside the country, the soviets started to take more and more socially radical and anti-war stance, as the revolution loomed. That's on this stage Lenin and Bolsheviks came in, and took power months later, promising most clear and radical solutions among other revolutionaries, that resonated in majority of the people: peace as soon as possible, complete abolishment of previous regime and transfer of all authority to the soviets, redistribution of land among peasants who work on it, worker's control in factories, etc. etc.

  • @_N3M3S1S
    @_N3M3S1S Před 11 dny +1

    The Central Power forces also shifted their eastern forces off to the Western Front as a result of the peace agreement with the new government in Petrograd. How many actually were moved would have been a nice finale to the video, but otherwise it was nicely done overall.

  • @konstantinriumin2657
    @konstantinriumin2657 Před 11 dny

    Good luck on civil war video! It won't be easy to adapt your style (with frontlines and divisions) to a war full of insurgencies, switching sides, multitude of factions and general lawlessness

  • @BattleSyth
    @BattleSyth Před 9 dny

    Excellent video, idk how they dealt with constant losses and no gains. Must have been maddening.

  • @Markomilic205
    @Markomilic205 Před 11 dny +6

    The war exhaustion didn't come from those defeats or territorial losses but from burocatic mismanagement and lack of transport which led to rise in food prices and shortages of commodities.

  • @cengizsogutlu
    @cengizsogutlu Před 10 dny +3

    can you do ottoman front pls

  • @theog8891
    @theog8891 Před 9 dny

    Nice video regarding the developments on the Russian front, although the coverage of the Romanian front was very rushed and sparsed, as the video completely ignored the fighting in the Carpathians, the siege of Turtucaia, the counterattack on the Arges river, the retreat at the end of 1916 and the campaign and battles in the summer of 1917.

  • @Dr_Koenigsberg
    @Dr_Koenigsberg Před 11 dny +5

    World Conqueror soundtrack ❤️💪😎

  • @HatredOfMephisto
    @HatredOfMephisto Před 11 dny

    great!

  • @svaert
    @svaert Před 10 dny +1

    This may be one of the most frustrating videos I've ever seen

  • @McRocket
    @McRocket Před 11 dny +1

    I would love to see the Russian Civil War - as I know so little about it.
    Thank you for this wonderful video.
    I had no idea Bucharest was taken during WW1.

  • @andraslibal
    @andraslibal Před 11 dny

    One of the prettiest roads in Transylvania built in 1916 by the Germans to cross the Carpathians is the Transalpina road it is still in use today.

  • @lorenzogiuliani9144
    @lorenzogiuliani9144 Před 10 dny

    Begins of Legend

  • @meyers6975
    @meyers6975 Před 8 dny

    Should have done 1918 too, Operation Faustschlag, but nice video overrall

  • @PanSzrama
    @PanSzrama Před 6 dny

    Excuse me, what city is ther instead of Wrocław or Breslau? 0:44 BRBBEARN???

  • @TenOrbital
    @TenOrbital Před 10 dny

    Is there a link for the corps colours and abbreviations? What's the red 15th corps? Abbr for Me, He, Ko, Sz, Be, Ha, Sn, Kra, Bes etc

    • @Eastory
      @Eastory  Před 10 dny +1

      The red is the Ottomans. The corps with letters are usually the same type as the numbered corps, the only difference is in the name. (Usually named after the corps commander).

    • @TenOrbital
      @TenOrbital Před 9 dny

      @@Eastory - thanks for the response. I would be interested in a link to a key for unit colours and abbreviations (some of your other videos have this). I don't think the information is readily available anywhere else.

  • @catalinmarius3985
    @catalinmarius3985 Před 10 dny +1

    What about the battles of Marasesti, Marasti and Oituz in Romania in 1917? They were significant as well.
    In the summer of 1917, a Central Powers offensive began in Romania under the command of August von Mackensen to knock Romania out of the war. Resulting in the battles of Oituz, Mărăști and Mărășești where up to 1,000,000 Central Powers troops were present. The battles lasted from 22 July to 3 September and eventually, the Romanian army was victorious advancing 500 km2. August von Mackensen could not plan for another offensive as he had to transfer troops to the Italian Front. Following the Russian revolution, Romania found itself alone on the Eastern Front and signed the Treaty of Bucharest with the Central Powers, which recognised Romanian sovereignty over Bessarabia in return for ceding control of passes in the Carpathian Mountains to Austria-Hungary and leasing its oil wells to Germany for 99 years. Although approved by Parliament, King Ferdinand I refused to sign it, hoping for an Allied victory in the west. Romania re-entered the war on 10 November 1918 on the side of the Allies and the Treaty of Bucharest was formally annulled by the Armistice of 11 November 1918.

  • @yobama9880
    @yobama9880 Před 10 dny

    5:26 Interesting Fact: The corps numbered 15 which can been seen in the north is actually an Ottoman corps which came to help Austria Hungary.

  • @milerman6712
    @milerman6712 Před 11 dny

    Could you guys cover the Napoleonic Wars to?

  • @GWManin
    @GWManin Před 11 dny

    I was waiting for the moment for disastrous Christmas battles, but oh well!

  • @andraslibal
    @andraslibal Před 11 dny +2

    Romania, always ready to switch sides when the winds change.
    (background information: Romania at this point had a Hohenzollern King and a defensive pact with Germany, but always wanted to occupy and gain Transylvania).
    After the losses in 1916 the battle at which Russians stopped the Central Powers advance was the battle of Marasesti ... after that they signed a separate peace treaty with the Germans.
    This was forbidden to allies but they did it anyway (betraying the allies in 1917). At the same time the Romanian treasury was evacuated to Russia. It is there still. They are keeping it safe. Then in 1918 one day before the armistice on November 10th Romania broke the peace treaty it signed and re-joined the Allies. All the great conquest of Transylvania then happened against an Austro-Hungarian Army that already laid down their weapons. For two years there was no peace treaty so Romania grabbed as much as it could in the process gaining both Transylvania and also Moldova from the Russians. An army that has not won battles in the world war betrayed its allies three times gained in the end huge territories (it will betray the Allies again by siding with nazi Germany an starting a war of conquest in Ukraine in 1941 and then it will betray Germany at Stalingrad when both flanks held by the 3rd and 4th Romanian armies collapsed and then finally in 1943 August 23rd, switching sides and just killing unsuspecting Germans to end the war on the winning side again).

    • @razvanalbu2104
      @razvanalbu2104 Před 11 dny

      you just hate us cuz you ain't us 😎 Always put national interest first over any shitty alliance

    • @metodiusm428
      @metodiusm428 Před 11 dny +6

      Bs, Hungary did not lay down arms and in fact in 1919 Romania and Hungary fought a war that lasted 8 months in which Romania occupied the vast majority of Hungary, including Budapest and went as far as occupying Győr, so Hungary at the Trianon treaty had no choice but to accept the treaty terms and leave Transylvania. In ww2 Romania was forced to join the Axis as France and UK literally did nothing to stop Germany from invading Poland. It's also bs that the 3rd and 4th armies betrayed Germany at Stalingrand, where on earth did you get that info? Neverming that the Romania then capitulated to the Soviet Union in 1943, and your Horty Miklos also wanted to secretly negociate with the allies but obviously Germany did not let that happen and in fact Horty was then forced to resign

    • @andraslibal
      @andraslibal Před 11 dny +1

      @@metodiusm428 that is not true. The Hungarian Army was instructed by the French to keep withdrawing in peacetime. That is how the Romanians advanced in Transylvania. The regular Austro-Hungarian Army laid down their weapons the one small division that did not was betrayed by the new communist government in Budapest. The offensives you talk about were against the newly formed communist Hungarian regime that armed peasants and workers who had zero military background that is where the big "victories" of the Romanian army came with the looting of Budapest. The Trianon treaty betrayed even the Woodrow Wilson principles giving completely Hungarian lands to both Czechoslovakia and Romania as well along the borders.
      In WW2 Romania went willingly to conquer land from the Soviets look up the 1942 borders of Romania, there was no coercion there, but of course today that is the version of the historical lie that benefits Romanians so that is the narrative.
      Read Ernst Udet's autobiography on what he saw from the air from his Stuka plane on how the Romanian ran and abandoned the flanks in Stalingrad that cause the encirclement.
      Romania did not capitulate to the Soviets they waited until the main German forces, Grossdeutschland who bled to defend them at Targu Frumos withdrew to refit and then they murdered their allies and switched sides collapsing the Carpathian defensive line.
      Yes Horthy wanted to negotiate an exit not to betray and murder unsuspecting allies. There is a difference.

    • @Tovalokodonc
      @Tovalokodonc Před 11 dny

      ​@@razvanalbu2104Way to be internationally recognised as a rat

    • @Tovalokodonc
      @Tovalokodonc Před 11 dny +2

      ​@@metodiusm428Bs, Károlyi completely disbanded the army to appease the Entente. Spoiler: that did nothing, you never stopped with the occupation or obeyed demarcation lines and only caused the Communists to grab power. What you fought in 1919 were ragtag factory militia with no officer corps. You know, the same officer corps that are ideological enemies of the commies.

  • @elmerelles9542
    @elmerelles9542 Před 7 dny +1

    The numbers are mind boggling! And all for nought. It’s hard to believe it actually happened. Fact is truly stranger than fiction.

  • @1enemyturn
    @1enemyturn Před 11 dny

    Thank you. Waiting for the Russian episode.

  • @iamthe1337est
    @iamthe1337est Před 11 dny

    Nice

  • @AtlasAugustus
    @AtlasAugustus Před 10 dny

    The intro music to the video? What is that?

  • @WillN2Go1
    @WillN2Go1 Před 10 dny +1

    Good video. Maybe in the future Russian Civil War videos cover the routes, methods, the 'White Russians' and others took getting away from the fighting, and leaving the country; and where they ended up. (& Maybe make a graphical display of all the major Bolshevik leaders during this early period and the year Stalin had them killed.)

  • @PotionSeller721
    @PotionSeller721 Před 8 dny

    What's in the frame flashing briefly in 10:54?

  • @jeffchengm
    @jeffchengm Před 10 dny

    In that little moment in 1916, Romania had the world in it's hands, with Germany simultaneously fighting titanic battles at Verdun, the Somme, and also in the East detailed here.
    "It is certain that so relatively small a state as Rumania had never before been given a role so important, and, indeed, so decisive for the history of the world at so favorable a moment. Never before had two great Powers like Germany and Austria found themselves so much at the mercy of the military resources of a country which had scarcely one twentieth of the population of the two great states. Judging by the military situation, it was to be expected that Rumania had only to advance where she wished to decide the world war in favor of those Powers which had been hurling themselves at us in vain for years. Thus everything seemed to depend on whether Rumania was ready to make any sort of use of her momentary advantage." - Paul von Hindenburg

  • @WunderChancellor
    @WunderChancellor Před 7 dny

    Did the Russians lack armored cars, planes and such, or was it more of a failure in the command structure?

  • @Republic_on_March
    @Republic_on_March Před 11 dny

    It would be amazing to see your mapping skills on Russian civil war

  • @xxxburke
    @xxxburke Před 10 dny +2

    Your videos are better than sitting in a classroom. Thanks!

  • @thomasfranz6467
    @thomasfranz6467 Před 11 dny

    The French cry for help during Verdun lead to the Brusilov offensive, which was a success in the way that it gave France significant breathing room. For Russia however, it was disastrous. Terrible even thinking about the fact that the Russian Civil War would lead to much higher casualties than Russia had suffered in WW1. Unimagineable suffering...

  • @Gufupandi09th13
    @Gufupandi09th13 Před 11 dny

    I heard the buslov offensive exist cause of the allied power gave Russia a request is to make them split there forces and give the advantage like the western front