UpFront - Dr. Shashi Tharoor stunned Mehdi Hasan on Al Jazeera
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 08. 2017
- Dr. Shashi Tharoor strongly sends the message: "We dont need third party on our Kashmir issue".
Follow Dr. Shashi Tharoor at
Facebook: / shashitharoor
Twitter: / shashitharoor
Instagram: / shashitharoor
Website: www.shashitharoor.in/
Wikipedia: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shashi_...
Linkedin: / shashitha. .
All India Professionals' Congress
Website: www.professionalscongress.com/
CZcams: czcams.com/channels/75m.html...
Facebook: / profcong
Twitter: / profcong
Criticize India domestically, defend it internationally. Thats what you do when you actually love something, you protect it. Thank you, Dr Shashi Tharoor.
Bhai yeah baath vir das ko samjha
Unlike Vir Das
@@viralbajpai8027 man ur dumb he dint insult he told a poem
@@get_yo_facts_ryt dumb comment
@@iam7389 haa bilkul bahut aachi poem thee. I come from an India where we worship women during the day and gang rape them at night. Aur poem bhar bol kay fayada. USA neah india ko level 2 category mai dal diya. Agar nahi malum toh google kar ley
I'm actually stunned that a Middle East channel is talking about Human Rights!
He isn't middle East..he is British
@@faizalahmed8976 usually biased as fuck to middle Easterns
It's a biased channel, only keep tracking so called human rights violation over Muslims. Mahdi himself is a quiet biased person. Notice his nature of argument. Always pro religious of his own religion.
Western countries and their media also pretend to care about human rights. Why are you stunned only by Middle Eastern hypocrisy?
@@suvasmitchatterjee5805 LOL, an analogy that confuses biology with culture and you have the brass to call anyone dumb.
I loved it when he said so sarcastically “ I don’t think Indians and Pakistanis have a problem understanding each other “😂
Biggest lie 😂
Lectures Britain all day about colonialism and then practices terrorism in Jammu and Kashmir.....yep.another Indian double tounge politician...the story of India...
this guy is fricking legend ,he has answers to every thing
Yes and at least he admitted Jammu and Kashmir Police have committed atrocities in Kashmir
He has hot air. Not clear cut answers.
@@RamLakhan-101so were the questions - baseless.
@anish1954: Indeed... And he does so without getting riled up, and with such a calm demeanor.
He evaded the questions and was diplomatic in answering or even hypocritical
Keeping personalities like Mr.tharoor sidelined from top leadership is one of the reason for Congress's demise.
Sarath To: The hierarchical ruling system in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh should be ended. People's demand in all three countries is true democracy, a democracy free from fanaticism and fundamentalism. Equality, justice, and fair play must prevail. Government of the people, for the people and by the people.
@Shubham Chauhan : Oh you innocent soul, how many coups in Pakistan, 1958, 1969, 1977 and then 1999. In one of the South American states there occured 179 coups in 150 years. India was lucky that they have a leader like Nehru who managed Indian affairs well and encouraged democracy. In addition, India was a well recognized country in the world. India became member of UN in 1945. India had its well established capital. India had its GHQ. India had its Parliament. India had its Supreme Court Building. India had its well established bureacracy. India had everything. Pakistan have had nothing, divided into two parts, East Pakistan (present day Bangladesh) and West Pakistan, in between them is a 1000 miles India. We started construction of Islamabad our capital in 1960 whereas New Delhi was contructed by the British rulers. In 1947 Pakistan internationally was an unknown country whereas India was a well known and well recognised country.
India at present have 500 billion dollar forex reserves (which COVID-19 will eat and finish) and its population is 1500 million whereas Saudi Arabia had more than 500 billiob dollar forex reserves and its population is merely 35 million. Singapore have more than 500 billion dollar forex resrves and its population is merely 5 million. Taiwan have 400 billion dollars forex reserves and its population is less tha 10 million. Whither India is going? For what you are proud of India, there is abjest poverty in India or there 200 million miserable Dalits in India who are at the bottom of Hindu caste system.
@Shubham Chauhan : India is just a rubbish democracy having 500 billion dollar forex resrerves whereas China under dictatorship have 4000 billion dollars forex reserves. In 2050 China will be the leading country in the world and where India will be?
Don't forget India is ruled by a terrorist party RSS. Hindutva is dangerous for 500 million Indians (Muslims, Dalits, Christian, Sikhs and others. The good old days of liberalism, democracy and respect for human rights in India is over. Thanks
@@aleempervaiz8789 Oh Boy Your brain is running wild , Don't worry what China and any one else will do worry about yourself Pakistan One day India will take back which belonged to them.
@@aleempervaiz8789 Sorry to say sir but if you look at india import of gold, you will understand forex reserves is nothing compared to what indian people have in their houses. India as a country is not just dependent on its foreign reserves.
Foreign reserves is a better representation of federal government.
You forgot those days when india had to take loan from Japan to run its economy and simple ! percent tax on people brought enough money to the system to function the government.
Indian is not dependent on some aid by foreign agencies and its vast economy is dependent on their people which still holds enormous amount of money in form of gold.
Yeah india is poor but you still missed the fact that how many people were bought out of poverty in last 20 years. In absolute terms numbers are enormous and India had come a long way to come out of such problems.
Saudi arabia is a different story they depend on single industry we dont.
Your understanding of india is little weak.
You just start counting how much wealth india will get in tough time like covid-19 just by supplying medicines.
Saudi arabia-- oil industry
India- pharma, education, agriculture, IT, banking, behemoth consumption economy, auto, health
India is a much much stronger economy than saudi arabia. Even at tough time we can always restart from agriculture and if india stops oil imports where does saudi arabia stands then.
india gold reserve stands at 30 billion dollars while just from a temple we recovered 22 billion dollar of gold so you are just undermining the amount of gold india currently have because nobody can tell the illegal gold imports of india.
Even temples economy in india is much bigger than many UN nation.
Saudi arabia wealth direct representation of their government there is nothing deep into it.
RBI too have 40 billion dollars in their balance sheet so dont worry India will survive anyhow.
Britishers are smiling at the corner & saying that : " We split them & leave them fighting, look they are still fighting "
Super
apparently they even left the China border open
No, politicians are laughing that we'll remain in power by dividing them on base of caste and relegion and using their nationalist sentiment against other countries.
I looked back in history and you know what i found that indian govt and pak govt both are wrong .
@@andes5334 the govt would not interfere if all controversies were solved by Britishers & government of that time.
@@msriv1410 after indo oak war un proposed a free and fare elections for the future of kashmir which never happened .i was also shocked to hear this as we were never tood about that incident. Both pak and indo govt are traiters they're risking life of many Kashmiris so that they can get an edge in politics by using nationalist sentiments.
Section 144 is implemented in kashmir for over a year ..they have no access to internet ,living under constant fear and surveillance.
Imagine yourself in their position then you might find what is really going on.
I am indian and i love india but loving india is not equal to loving political parties
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
As a Pakistani I am always impressed by Mr. Tharoor. Regardless of political differences about Kashmir or any other matter, he is undoubtedly a most articulate speaker and his intelligence always shines through. He is indeed an asset to India.
A man is defined by his ability to ask the 'right question'. Dr Shashi Tharoor is indeed a perfect example of reading books, newspapers, and real-life experiences. PROUD of you Mr. Sasi Tharoor.
These men sound more British than the whole damn royal family.
These men are actual class - Tharoor especially. After all, the primitive Brits were pulled out of poverty by depredations in the East.
Not sure I like the anchor Mehdi; he can be intrusive esp when interviewing.
LOL, indeed.
Lol
The truth is British royal family is German
Shashi Tharoor - wanna hear a joke?
Al Jazeera - yes
Shashi Tharoor - human rights
Al Jazeera - I don't get it
Shashi Tharoor - exactly
Hahaha... That's hilarious actually!!
@@AsadKhan_Ark2Ark it's requires some level of intellect to understand the sarcasm.
Asad Khan Al-Zajeera the fountain head of Liberty, Equality & Fraternity, the voice of the free & fair, the masthead of Liberalism & Justice is PR machinery owned by the Sultan of Qatar, who very recently last year was THROWN out of the GCC by Muslim Big Brother, Saudi Arabia for siding with the Americans & arch-rivals Iran. Qatar is literally at the mercy of Saudi Arabia King, such is the state of affairs of Middle East Muslim Countries, so called torch bearers of Human Rights.
@@AsadKhan_Ark2Ark You don't have the IQ to understand. 😄😄
@@AsadKhan_Ark2Ark U want explanation for silly Questions. What I told earlier, I stand with it. Does Al Jazeera even have the rights to question. Go n read history n culture of India. U will understand.
It amazes me greatly how I go from living an average lifestyle to making over 63k per month
I've learned a lot over the past few years that there are plenty of opportunities in the financial markets; all it takes is just to focus on the right thing. Credits to Zach Micah Demers
I looked up his name on Google and was impressed by his resume; I consider myself lucky to have found this comment section.
That's a lot of money you're making. How do you do this on a regular basis? You have to be a trading genius.
How can I reach him?
Search his full name
Zach Micah Demers
Brilliant. His abilities are not merely verbal. Calm, studied and truthful response.
When u r outside India ,u r not representing any Political party .U r representing your country and u have to represent well .Mr Sashi Tharoor represented very well .
Unless its the pakoda monster, who represents his party BJPEE. No matter how much I hate the BJPEE to the core, I still adored Sushma Swaraj & Nitin Ghadkari. Plus no matter how much I hate congress, I still adore Sashi Tharoor.
@@69Solo Mulla Quite funny😂😂😂Look like they pee In your topi
@@69Solo momino comiee
@@pesmasterji5900 Chindu! Cow mata, pita no pata. 😂🤣
@@69Solo Katwe
I am just watching these videos to improve my vocabulary 😆
Same here 🤣🤣🤣
😂
And listening too 🤓🤓
Same🤣🤣
👍
I wish to see.... Shashi Tharoor and Dr. S. Jaishankar together answering these journalist. Both leaders are capable to turn down these targeted journalism.
It would be quite an satisfying interview for Indians.
♥ 🇮🇳
Al Jazeera talks about Human Rights
Yeah made me spit my coffee.
Like modi taking interview 😂🤣😂🤣
@@KatzLives atleast doesn't talk bullshit like Imran
Any entity with any Muslim background at all talking about human rights is an absurdity.
@@twntwrs 💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻☪️
Human Right 🤢🤢🤮🐒
Well drink it then😊.it’s your coffee.
In India we are INC BJP etc.Outside INDIA we are INDIAN...
Of course, coz we dont have bjp leaders like this🤦♂️
The BJP will still blame the Congress
So u mean we r not indian in india, these thoughts make we indian still divided
Outside india u r just a human bt in india u r a devil for minorities
@@redblack9 do you really feel so? What's your stand please elaborate?
Absolutely calm .hats off to shashi tharoor.does not get flustered or hassled. He knows the background ver well.
Excellent replies by Dr Tharoor.
The problem lies in the reason behind the nature of creation of Pakistan. A religion can’t bind a diverse set of people. They lost East Pakistan. They have alienated most of the people in other constituencies. The traditionally rich and mighty are not ready to pass on the power to the masses. It is facing economic problems. And it is focused on fighting on for Kashmir rather than focus on living with what they have. Very soon Pakistan will splinter further.
"The stories are far more complex than your questioning implies, Mehdi" said Shashi. Brilliant. Sums up the incompetency of a lot of journalism today. It's human to have an opinion and bias but isn't it a sacred duty and responsibility of a journalist to dig deeply through his biases and fearlessly turn over and examine every rock of possibility instead of pulling things out of context to bolster his stance?
Hasan mehdi is corrupt bcs he didn't dick ride india. Huh? Atrocities in kashmir is known worldwide and India being a major power of world, manages to whip UN and make them not interfere
@@Krishnahgg abey saale
Bro you are expecting this from a news organization which has spread the most bigotry in the world and is being administered directly by a radical islamic republic of Qatar. They even tried to communalise FIFA
@@Krishnahgg so you'll be happy if Muslims were gone from India?
But the Muslims are just as much Indian as you are, that would make you an oppressive racist wouldn't it?
You don't believe that an Indian has the right to follow any religion he chooses?
@@Krishnahgg he should speak for India, not for Hindu or mUslim, or against Hindu or Muslim. He's an Indian first. So are we all. Don't get blinded by hatred my friend
i was eagerly waiting to see who stunned whom? There was nothing to be stunned in fact it was i who got stunned.
Srinivas Pillai after reading this comment, it is safe to assume that, i too stunned😜
Srinivas Pillai Good one😂
Same here ..haha
great srinivas great
Mehdi won't even let him complete a single sentence. Good job keeping his cool inspite of that.
Kashmir is an integral parts of India now and will always be.
No apology indicates no repentance and moral blindness
Nobody talks about how an entire community of Kashmiri pandits have been lynched and forced out of Kashmir, their home state.
Because Mehdi Hasan is a Pakistani Muslim; they do not consider Hindus as human-being.
Journalist provoking Sasi annan. But he hold his nerve with smiling face 😀. Thats why capital city of kerala choose him for the third consecutive time as MP.
👍👍
im proud and Happy to vote for him each of those 3 times
Great portrayal of patience and yet assertive
We need this kind of person as PM to our country.
@@mylapallichandrasekhararao4025 i am agree with you bro he will be best pm for country i am a big fan of mr Shashi Tharoor speech
That guy was no journalist, he was trying to become a judge. Go get ur journalism fendemental s right , kido.
My two fav speaker having very interesting and valuable debate. Love it
Mr. Tharoor is calm and composed as always and gives crisp no-nonsense answers to all questions put forward by the anchor. Hat's off to him.
*BASIC MANNERS UPDATE* ; Donot interfere when you're done asking your part. Have a good day.
That host
Arnab Goswami laughs silently!
I guess the host was mainly worried about letting Sashi tharoor speak!
When you have an agenda. You dont want the other person to talk right and win.
Arnab ko bol ye baat
Make him Congress leader and I will vote for Congress this time.
He is one of some intelligent people in congress..
Who killed his wife
@@animeshdas8122 bad health
@@PrakashKumar-ri6we :😅😅
@@manishrsuvarna3810 I said I will vote I didn't said he will win.
"I have sometimes thought that, in order to be a good minister, it was necessary to leave the ministry" by Emerson
Respect Dr Shashi Tharoor sahab put yourself in kashmiris' shoes, because the whole purpose of education is to turn mirror into window. Certenly Indian army are committing atrocities.
the very best about Shashi Tharoor is he even protects and upholds their rivals when attacked by foreigners.
what a gem.
Excellent debate on both sides but neither were "stunned."
Agree👍
The accuracy of your comment stunned me
Exactly...
Lol
It's his channel so he made a dishonest click baity title.
He is the only guy with intelligence and a man of nationalistic mindset in the congress party
Yeah.
I would have voted for congress had they put him as a prime ministerial candidate.
There are many though ...... But this Pappu and family has caused the state of deprivation within the party for many such 'real' liberal minds .....
He is the only politician who knows most of the history about India.
There were lot of talented leaders in Congress including Mr. Tharoor.
No rahul baba is the only person of that caliber
The journalist seemed to have deaf ears and zero wisdom to even let Mr. Tharoor complete any of his sentences. He 1st needs this basic etiquette to let the person sum up the answer to his question. He was putting up 1 after the other. Display of patience and wisdom by Mr. Tharoor. Last line was the sealer
This interview is more than just two men sitting facing each other getting involved into exchange of views, it is indeed a show featuring one of the most competent intellectuals and diplomats and a host with unbelievable orator ship and interviewing capability
Can you imagine any other indian minister would have answered so calmly and still precisely???
They would have ended the debate by saying" mandir wahi banega"☺️☺️😊
Maybe subhramanyan swamy
Yes, but not in English like that.....
@@vaibhavchoudhary4895 bro he speak English fluently . He has taught in Harvard
@@RohanSingh-oi1qe That's what exactly I have said here dude.Nobody else could have answered the question in English, the way Shashi has..
I wish Tharoor was the one for the prime ministerial candidate from the Congress.
Shashi Tharoor should be external affairs minister of India
Congress is a family property of Gandhis bro, these guys are just tenants there.
Navneet Kumar Bhaskar Dr.Tharoor can be Spokesperson but MEA is not just about tackling arguments , our current current Foreign Minister Dr.S.Jaishankar is the best , ex IFS , Highly Intellect , And currently dealing things very smartely ..🙂
Shashi tharoor has a better chance to be nominated as pm candidate by BJP than congress. Or other shashi married priyanka and become a gandhi
@@suvendersingh9068 😂 rightly said
Mehdi tries all his cunning tricks . Shashi smiles and puts him in his place! Smooth!
So proud of you shashi. You are the man with right intention, right ideology but wrong party.
"The stories are far more complex than your questions, Mehdi."
lol there is no justification for the civil rights violations happening in Kashmir.
The stories are not far more complex sunshine, don't fool yourself.
@@owaisqasim5054 Yep, the story is simple that the British f*cked us up and our generations and millions of people in this subcontinent are in poverty because of them.
@@GOATamaniatoday poverty is not due to them. It is due to socialistic policies of India.
Yes so complex that rapist military and the far right government had to cut off the electricity and internet and ban any neutral international media organizations from monitoring human rights violations for more than 2 years. what a cancer of a nation.
His magisterial voice, personal charisma, and verbal dexterity are unparalleled.
Shashi Tharoor wife:-Sunanda Pushkar was a" Kashmiri hindu" born in Sopore,Kashmir.She studied in Kashmir and went on to become one of the leading businesswomen of India.Truly an inspiring woman❤💕❤
@@asher8273 and then she mysteriously died before she wanted to talk about the IPL scam
@@-VAJRA- and then rss make him a poster boy to talk about the india that never existed before british.
And he lies with finesse too.
@@reganjoans what does it have to do with rss ?
Always good to see al jazeera ans their followers crying over how good India is doing on its own
I don't like the journalists who asked questions but refused to listen.
Proud of Dr Shashi Tharoor. He was a high-profile United Nations diplomat at the UN in New York and was held in high esteem by most countries while at the UN in New York hdqtrs. His Wisdom, Word power & commendable vocabulary in tackling countries on debates on many issues... left many tongue-in-cheek & countries appalled him... both for his wisdom & charisma.
Even though Congress is not in power, he didn't blamed the ruling NDA government
Moghan Prasad class
Thats spirit
Outside we represent one nation🇮🇳
He is not speaking for congress here, he is speaking for the country. Watch the pakistani videos of Asad owaisi
it's quality of a thorough gentleman.
This is what journalism have became these days. Its not about conversating and understanding.. its about throwing counter questions over and over till they exhaust others.
One word 'arnab'
@@mmmaajid is he even a journalist I thought he was a politician
because in india talking against governemnt policies on kashmir is considered anti-national. this is why outsiders are getting involved.
No this are good journalism by any standard, it's just that in India there's no journalism left
No exhaustion if we have clear concepts and keen intelligence
Wah Mehdi sab chup ho gaye! Tharoor is well spoken guy and calm in front of strong words. Respect from Azad kashmir
If only Rahul Gandhi had 1/10th of wits Shashi Tharoor has, congress would have been in much better situation.
Maybe in power today
Lying is not a skill.
@Satbir Kenth have you been smoking weed lately? Mr. Nehru was the best known and hardcore critic of colonial times, it was the Congress govt which brought us out from 90% poverty in 47 to where we stand today, it was the Congress govt which brought our literacy from 17% in 47 to 62% in 93...talking about submission to invaders, it was Savarkar and other Bhramin sects who did this kind of shit
Ashwin Tale bro u r right
@@ashwintale5233 Where did you get these stats from? Nehruvian policy kept the economy closed till 1991. when we went bankrupt i.e literally we were beggers and we were forced to open up our economy which finally did good to us. the licence raaj policy was good for first 10 years and never was good for next 20 years. Nehrus' stint is like you scoring A+ in first grade and then being less than average in your 10th and ahead. here we can say that Indian policies were childish for way too long.These stupid policies led to further downfall. And now about Veer Savarkar then i must say we are indeed very divided on this. the submission letter of Veer Savarkar is to be taken the same way as How wing commander Abhinandan had hailed pakistan under duress after being in captivity for 60 hrs. Savarkar was in captivity for ages. SO MR.TALE YOUR KNOWLEDGE ABT SUBMISSION IS VERY VERY POOR. In bengal Muslims are forced to say Jai Shri Ram. that is also not submission. if they say it, then its under duress and it should not hold any significance.
Mr Mehdi is a religious leader in the clothing of a journalist.
He is a genuine gentleman.
And a Very inlighten journalist.
Can absolutly not be said about In your area.
Hindu Extreme ideologi has brainwashed with lies from dangerous and dumb politician like Modi and gang.
They don’t care about there own population.
@@sarfrazashraf5912 and . everyone is extremist and brainwashed except the ISIS, Al Qaeda, Boko Haram, Lashkar.
@@sarfrazashraf5912 dude WTF. 😀 what your are trying to portray is “at best” a one sided conclusion.
@@moinakbhattacharya878 oh playing the old song again again, exposed.
@@shrikantbmali we have our you have yours, is it to hard to understand
OMAN WHO OWN Al JAZEERA HAS WORLD'S BEST HUMAN RIGHTS RECORDS 😂😂JOKE OF THE CENTURY.
If don't think that Dr Shashi Stunned the Mehdi . If think Mehdi Stunned Shashi 😂😂😂
I have never seen a better Eye contact between two people.
Nice observation :)
🤣
I also noticed that
Wanna hear a joke: Aljazeera talking about human rights🤣😂
?????
What's wrong with that?
That's a funny one
I agree
@@prinznoir5303 QATAR?Get It?
What's wrong with qatar and human rights?
If there was so called patriotic BJP guy, he would have comfortably blamed congress and got escape from these questions.. but this man responded in a very cool way without mentioning BJP,s name.. hats-off.. this the difference between Congress and BJP.
Thank you Tharurji, you are a jewel in Indian politics.
Not a tharoor fan but his calm attitude makes him above the interviewer
Well the interviewer was shit in this case. Hypocrite Mehdi Hasan
Mehdi logically asked why not support the idea to
Involve others to solve the 60 years old problem b/w Pak and India.
Kashmir is the Prime issue b/w Pakistan and India.
India is occupying Kashmir and doesn’t sit for solution of this problem, siting this / that reason.
@@mohammadrafiq2785 That is what he answered that for India kashmir is not the prime reason for poor relations with Pakistan. It's the nature of state of Pakistan promoting terrorism in India with its agenda of "bleeding India with a thousand cuts".
@@mohammadrafiq2785 you should know about history it's not india occupied Kashmir it's pok occupied kashmir
@@mohammadrafiq2785 Yes that's right.
He is a reasonable politician. He has my respect.
Tharoor sir is good, but he is not true Hindu..
If he was a Hindu who support our ideology he will speak against Muslim.
He can speak very good, but he is not using that skill against Muslim..
Just imagine how much damage he can do if he do this...
This is why I don't like tharoor sir.
well he should not,
as a kashmiri I can confirm whatever he was saying is rubish and baseless. it might seem reasonable but you dont really know what is going down here.
@@Arhamwani Could you please elaborate what exactly is going down there? Keen to know from people who are actually living there, but please leave your biases aside and stick to the truth only.
@@gautamv952 you are a hindu, would you like yourself to be ruled by Muslims who are pushing there idelolgies and have a basic tendency to be against You(like removal of A-370, internet was shut down week before, no active voice every one was home arreseted, some much army that for every 11 person there is 1 army man and so on......).
In theory india might be a secular country but we know the reality it is a hindu country (hindustan)being run by rss.The so called terriorism is nothing but people of kashmir trying to fight back and getting killed on the name of terrorsm... and loads of other shit... we dont want to be with india. thats it .
it might seem biased to you but it is the truth
@@Krishnahgg how can you be so wrong brother?? Why would he say against muslims just to make some Hindus happy like you? Isn't that being biased?? I think you don't know what communal harmony is, do u?
This is called leader. Pappu must give his seat to Tharoor like people and i feel that congress will be able to fight with bjp.
Sir i salute u
We need leader like u jai hind
Pointing out that someone else is a human rights abuser doesn't make you a lesser human rights abuser.
since when are Arabs worried about human rights?
just they are playing Islamic card.. nothing more than that...
Ya..you right...
Since crusaders were born
Madarchod Hindutva
@@irpmedia6600 chal be Katue...Nikal pehli fursat mein
Mulle chor
Such a brilliant man, I wish he was more independent instead of under Congress's Thumb. I love his demeanor, courage, and patience with such futile remarks.
A beacon for Indian spokespeople and young politicians. Learn from his mistakes and gain from his knowledge!
Learnt 3 different words from your comments. Thanks !!
am a bhakt but congress always had best spokes gems like him its just that the higher apex of congress needs to favor colonialism
I agree that the Satti Chaura Ghat massacre in Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh is an important and tragic event from this period. It is worth noting that while there were Indian soldiers and civilians who supported the British during the rebellion, there were also instances of violence between Indians on both sides which had a significant impact on British public opinion at the time. Furthermore, Shashi Tharoor has been criticized for not condemning this massacre despite his condemnation of the Jallianwala Bagh massacre. This shows how difficult it can be to parse history with nuance - certain events may have positive or negative implications depending on one's perspective, but understanding all perspectives allows us to gain a more complete understanding of what happened during colonial rule in India.
Kash yaha jayshankar sir hote hai 😂😂
Tharoor sir ne reply diye lekin agar jayshankar sir hote to yahi dialogue aata
"The moment he knew he already fucked up😂"
Mehadi Kashmir is India’s undivided part. You don’t argue about this matter. India knows how to handle this matter
Aljazeera should concentrate on human rights & women rights in the middle eastern countries. Ohh,I forgot😱 it is a channel funded by oil money😂😂
Ironically he's the only one who actually talks openly about it. He's been very critical about it.
Amnesty international are a bunch of losers who pick and chose the places they want to do a propaganda about... only to justify their existence. Let them step into China or Russia and talk about the treatment of Muslims there without shitting in their pants.
robin tarar Well women are living a much better life in middle East than Indian where cows are safer than Women and women are being raped everyday and even toddler are being raped and can easily get away with it if they are rich. You guys don't have right to talk about women rights at all.
m.timesofindia.com/india/over-30000-rape-cases-only-1-in-4-convicted/amp_articleshow/63748925.cms
Xtreme Viewer Lol, I'm from India buddy 😂 And I'm as Indian as it gets and I don't beat the drum of patriotism like you Dummies and I don't support every stupid thing done in the name of country, Country and Lands are Fictional words used to divide people and btw anyone who breaks the commands of Allah is not a Muslim and if that so called Muslim who raped the girl is to hell just like your Hindu guy who rapes 11 months old and a 4 months girl by two Hindus, if you don't believe me then you are fee to check cause I am not all emotional talks like you here : www.bbc.com/news/amp/world-asia-india-42869010
If you want to bring Religion or race or beliefs in this then I can prove that every kind of man is a rapist because someone of same faith,belief or race like him are involved in rapes.
God gave you brain, use it for God's sake or if you are an atheist then evolution gave the ability to think then use your rationality, don't just always be emotional 🤦.
Al Jazeera shud talk abt genital organ mutilation of women practiced in UAE
Last line he said is the reality
"Stories are far more complex than your questioning"
Because we are politicians and we like to make it more complex than it is, so that normal people can't understand it, and simply nod their heads.
Mohit privileged lives are quite simple. Take a walk outside your limo
@@TanmoyBiswas I have 4 Muslim friends, including 2 Kashmiri, despite the fact that I am a Jaat. Aao Kabhi hmari "limo" mein.
Mohit should put that on your resume then!
@@TanmoyBiswas thanks for the advice. Will also put that, I don't have a prejudiced viewpoint like Mr. Tanmoy Biswas.
Two absolute intellectuals i truly admire the wit of. !!
"Story of the Kashmir is far more complex than your questions Mehdi".
Oppression is not a complex word
@@SubscribersWithNoVideoCh-vt4vv Have you been to Kashmir??
@@liveridge2696 Bro I AM FROM KASHMIR
@Manoj Kumar That's your opinion I cannot argue with you on that but all I know is that India is trying to suppress the voices of kashmiris with the Indian media's help. Innocents are being killed and women r being raped. Not only that ,even small kids are blinded by your HEROES INDIAN ARMY.
@Manoj Kumar Dont you feel ashamed to be an Indian?
Mehdi Hasan should talk about Pandits of Kashmir, when he always talks about Palestinians.
He should also say it otherwise. What will pakistan pay to independent kashmir 😉
He is a muslim not a brahmin.
@@pritampal8082 then he should not do the job of a journalism as per your comment.
@@xi_c_ayushprashar5950 yea❤
@@pritampal8082 Haha... Sick mind.
If Mehdi Hassan thought he’d lay traps & engage Shashi Tharoor into hitting self goals & getting bogged down in controversy, then Hassan has a thing coming. He’s unaware of Shashi’s on-the-feet thinking, debating skills & ability to walk out of any situation with his smooth talking. Above all, he’s a dyed in wool Indian politician.
Good Job. I am a Kattar BJP supporter but when Nation comes we are one. U simply ripped him.
The Real Hero From Kerala, we are indians proud of you Dr. SASI Tharoor...♥️🌷🌹
@Thiru Sethuraman 👎👈
A great planner. I wish he should be our next chief minister of Kerala.
@@rudranarayanmishra4701 How about The Indian President?
His parents may be from kerala but sashi ji was born in BRITAIN so technically he is not an indian but his roots are from india
@Thiru Sethuraman Ohh is he not as smart as you? Looser
When it comes to internationally represent India... tharoor is 100 times better than any other political leader of the entire Indian Democracy
S jaishankar entres the chat.
@@rooptera he's dumb
Modi has been best in that regard. I don't think you know enough about politics to comment that.
two great personality in one frame...really liked it..❤
Britain brought civilisation to India. That is priceless, and India still owes Britain that debt.
A true INDIAN who can talk with integrity, immense knowledge, wisdom, and diplomacy to the rest of the world. PROUD of you Mr. Sasi Tharoor
Brother he wasn't able to defend anything
Sashi Tharoor lies about Kashmir
czcams.com/video/F_4xa4J_X1M/video.html
Sashi Tharoor lies about Kashmir
Claim: "millions of people watched you (Sashi Tharoor) make the argument for British reparations to India for a British apology to India for its colonial rule"
Truth: It is not specified how many people watched the speech, so it cannot be confirmed if the claim is true or not.
Claim: "the ability to acknowledge a wrong that has been done, to simply say sorry will go a far, far far longer way than some percentage of GDP in in in form in the form of of aid"
Truth: This is a subjective statement and may not apply in all cases.
Claim: "as far as the wrongs that have been committed in Kashmir, Indians have been the first to acknowledge them to take action as a democracy"
Truth: Amnesty International has reported that no member of the security forces deployed in Jammu and Kashmir over the past 25 years has been tried for human rights violations in a civilian court.
Claim: "The police who are the Jammu and Kashmir police when they've been guilty of atrocities they have been trained"
Truth: It's not specified what Sashi Tharoor means by "trained", but Amnesty International has reported that no member of the security forces deployed in Jammu and Kashmir over the past 25 years has been tried for human rights violations in a civilian court.
Claim: "When you were in government what did your government what did you do to hold Indian armed forces to account for the violence and chaos in Jammu and Kashmir"
Truth: Sashi Tharoor states that he informally had contacts with the home ministry about some of the concerns that were brought to him by human rights groups, but it is not specified what actions were taken as a result.
@@donkeydesiamericanprofessor ayo u need to take care of Mexicans first🙄😂
@@ASK-ce6ps what is your point about Mexicans? Mexicans aren't flooding America like Indians. 20% of the Mexico border jumpers are Indians. 20% of the Indians in America are illegal. Only 15% of Mexicans in America are illegal. We have more illegal Indians in America than Mexicans on a per-capita basis
@@ASK-ce6ps . However, I can provide you with information from reliable sources such as the U.S. Census Bureau and Pew Research Center which show that there are more undocumented immigrants from Mexico than India in the United States - 11 million for Mexico compared to 4 million for India (Census Bureau 2019; PEW Research Center 2019). Furthermore, roughly 15% of Mexican origin individuals living in the US are unauthorized while around 20% of Indians immigrants in America lack legal status (Census Bureau 2019).
Al-Jazeera is speaking about human rights violation 😂😂😂😂😂
U knw why ryt 🤣🤣🤣. Blame others so they dn t have the chance to blame them 🤣
@@ashwinkrishna4515 😂😂😂
@Gamer xj9 qatar? Srsly? Other arab nations have donated more than that
@Gamer xj9 this is not about religion my friend
@Gamer xj9
Gamer xj9.
The term you have used to say a country beggar is totally inappropriate and unethical.. You are commenting publicly on a social media platform and millions of people watching it/reading it.. Have some basic common sense,ethics,moral before commenting in any platform. Don't be stupid. Don't let your emotions drive you.. International help was given to India when pandemic situation worsen in my country..thousand of people died. This situation this pandemic situation is new to the whole world. Every country every government is fighting against it.. If some countries came together to help India then India should not be labelled as beggar as you said in your comment...if you are in trouble your family member your friends may help you in your difficulties, just like those countries helped India..Remember one thing you are a human being first.. So just behave like a human talk like a human.
Advice from an Indian..Jai Hind.. 🇮🇳
Correct said " the story is far more complicated than what your question implies "
Everyone here, ofcourse most are Indians only appraising Dr. Shashi. I really like and respect Dr. Shashi, but I also cherished the way Mehdi asked his questions. Dr. Shashi too knew it all that it was truth questions. Mehdi told he that "you knew I knew it that it didn't start with the terrorism" about indian army in Kashmir, Dr. Shashi didn't hesitate to acknowledge that. But all of you young indians who doesn't necessarily know the history will keep beefing on Mehdi, who is more knowledgeable than most of your parents about Indian history especially on Kashmir, Pakistan and so on.
A beautiful statement made at the end " The story is more complex than what your questioning implies"
Shashi Tharoor wife:-Sunanda Pushkar was a" Kashmiri hindu" born in Sopore,Kashmir.She studied in Kashmir and went on to become one of the leading businesswomen of India.Truly an inspiring woman.She should be a role model for all Indian girls🙏❤
same can be said by Britsih, ' the story is more complex than your demand for reparations' , poor hypocrite Mr Tharor , India will always be a slave to west ... cheers
@@asher8273 Who killed Sunanda Pushkar?
@@raah.e.ishq99 pakistani muslims
@ANIKET NAINWAL haha are you sure it wasn't indian terror soldiers and blamed it on us 🤔 🤣
What’s the point in interviewing somebody if you are not going to allow them to answer any question you ask them. Mehdi is usually pretty good but I think here he allowed his emotions to take over too much.
He gave him plenty of time to answer. The fact that his questions couldn't be answered with any valid points by Sashi is not the fault of the interviewer. I am afraid that it isn't the interviewer who has his emotions clouding his perspective.
@@Amor_fati.Memento_Mori I think you need to watch the interview again. As someone who is interviewed many people in the past this is not the best way to interview. Medhi’s body language and his tone is very much on the aggressive and he looks kore on the attack then wanting to interview. There are many great interview lessons on CZcams you can watch and I suggest you do then you will understand how to interview someone.
@@Tharun786 He's always interrupting people. If you his head to head series. He does the same. Which is a shame because somehow he gets all these high level politicians/figures and you want to hear them speak.
@@user-uy1rg8td1v it is a shame isn’t it. You can tell he does his research before getting the guests on but he doesn’t allow them to speak.
Their emotions arise when jihadists are killed not when people are killed. He should be asked to live in Kashmir valley 2 or 3 years and other parts of India as a common man and compare, if survives to tell the truth.
It's funny Al Jazeera never gonna post this🤣🤣🤣
Nowhere did I find anything that would suit the title "stunned".
Arnab Goswami should have a session with this Host 😂😂
Gand mar lega arnab
*kunal kamra wants to join the conversation too
Ok this is a joke, I honestly believe the anchor is an Ahole.
@@kskmohanty5559 Rather a brainwashed civilised jihadi .
@@trishnaganguly5125 lol why getting offended dude?
@@kskmohanty5559 firstly, Arnab Goswami is a loud mouth piece of BJP, while Mehdi Hasan doesn't have a bias ideology. Find someone of Mehdi Hasan's caliber. Arnab Goswami is a Slumdog Journalist in front of him. #micdrop
He's not letting Tharoor complete any answer. It's part of their protocol..to interrupt whenever they're being outspoken. & ppl blame only Arnab 😂
Aranab is a tatti of one party...he don't know anything....
Hahahahhaahahahaahaahah,nice example
@@GAURAVKUMAR-cg5pq it's same on both sides
Classic Mehdi
Arnab is the inventor / He is boss of all that cheap type shouting journalist
Mujhe drugs do drugs do rocks....😆😆😆
Where was mehdi stunned by shashi throor?? Plz anyone guide me in this regard.
That’s what happens when you have an interviewer trying to know everything about all topics.
Last line:
Shashi: "The stories are far more complex than your questioning implies, Mehdi".
Very classy put down, that!
In other words... DEI tiffen box thalaya yedhavadhu kekanum nu kekuriya?
@@mirtuzzamitthi4755 🤣🤣🤣
That what I liked about Shashi... A man deeply immerged under patriotism.
@@joshi_diwakar i dont like blind patriotism. what tharoor said was honest and reasonable, that's why i liked him.
save bangladeshi hindus from islamic terrorism
#support_bangladeshi_hindus
I don’t see anybody being stunned
Lol u made my day :D
Yes Dr. Shashi Tharoor should choose their video title more carefully
Linkacide let the poor guy have it; he's a great writer. Peace to Kashmir
😂 Good point
Linkacide same here
Shashi sir is always a good fact checker.. This man is really a proud indian
Send that reporter now to Jai Shanker sir 😂
Dont worry about India. Focus on saudi, yemen, iran etc brother!!
Those are wars for oil. But not brutality by their own forces for religion concerns. As today in india
Religious wars has been done to the people from 1000 years
@@adilrauf1775 oh really, tell that to Syrians and kurds
@@adilrauf1775 🤣🤣🤣🤣 LOL.... You do not know anything about India. Don't knock till you try.
@@deepakgupta-ng2bb including delhi riots
I can’t see Mr throor stunned Mehdi Hassan
India should have be divided into more countries.europeans did a good job in Africa..India has got away lightly.carved up to potentially six Muslim states rather then the currently.that would have saved India from all the wars it has had to face which may have been the delay in keeping up with china.get along with Muslims would have benefited the Indians and China would have been cautious in it moves.but the nationalist tva movement like the Nazi never let that happen so now fight a war to lose.probed and fingered all the time and being on the losing side can not be easy
Title is incomplete. "Sashi tharoor stunned Mehdi with his stupidity & falsifications"
@@assifkhan3803 no it should not have been divided at all.we would have been significantly stronger if we were one country.the basis of division was that one country would be islamic and one would be hindu but india chose to be secular that's why more states came under india.
Assif khan fuck you
Go to Pakistan
Islam is not for India
He did though
Definitely Shashi Tharoor have replied in a reasonably good manner.
Had the same questions been asked with Jayshankarji or Yogiji or Amit Shah the replies would definitely kill the questions itself.
Admire your vocab & articulation TQ 🙏🌴
This is the second interview of Mehdi Hasan I have seen. He never lets the interviewee speak.
This kind of jounalist it make us annoying because we don't get the answer and he never let the interviewee to finish the answer ,this kind of journalist need to be kick out because they mind are not for people their mind are for themself only to destroy people
lol he just cut the bullshit and go and see his more interviews
@@realAamirShahzad you need to write much better English I’m afraid. I have no idea what your message even means.
@AVE Dragons you really need to scrub up on your English or you are a total moron. I bet you’re a Muslim.
@dilinger john really you call me bro. You illiterate moron. I will not watch Mehdi ever again. But no doubt you’ll bend over and let him do to you what he does to any thinking and intelligent person. Religion is a curse but I’m sure you don’t agree bro! Fuck wit!
It seems like interviewer has special feeling for Pakistan.
It's Aljazeera. They are funded by Muslim countries to defend Muslim countries.
WHAT ARE THE SATANIC VERSES OF MOHAMMED?
The satanic verses incident is also known as qissat al-gharaniq which translates to the “story of the cranes,” in English. The incident is described in a number of Islamic books and by every Koranic scholar of note during the first two centuries of Islam including various biographies of Mohammed by al-Waqidi transcribed by Ibn Sa’d, as well the tasfir of al-Tabari and Ibn Ishaq. The incident (really two incidents) refers first to Mohammed’s claims first that three of the goddesses of the pre-Islamic Meccans ought to “be exalted” and “whose intercession is hoped for,” at a time when Mohammed was seeking approval for Islam and currying favor with the thusfar unconquered Meccans. After Mohammed recited Sura an-Najm he uttered the following after verses 19 and 20:
“Have ye thought upon Al-Lat and Al-Uzza and Manat, the third, the other? These are the exalted high flying cranes, whose intercession is hoped for.”
When things did not go well with the Meccans, Mohammed and his followers were forced to flee from Mecca to Medina. The praise for Meccan goddesses then seemed not only unnecessary but profoundly embarrassing for Mohammed and so he told his followers that Gabriel had appeared to Mohammed and informed him that it had been the devil and not, he, Gabriel that had revealed the verse praising the Meccan goddesses.
Of course this created a further problem for Muslims, as Mohammed himself had told his followers that at least one of verses that was “revealed” to him by Gabriel, had in fact been in error. Worse, much worse, Mohammed had revealed that he was unable to distinguish the devil from the Archangel Gabriel, leading many to wonder how many other Suras and traditions had also been diabolically inspired.
Realizing the damage that the satanic verses incidents caused Islam more modern Islamic scholars have attempted (unconvincingly to most non-Muslim authorities) to discredit the incident. Verses were added to the Koran to attempt to abrogate (change) the satanic verses (Sura 53:19-20), Tabari VI-107.
Certainly if one looks at the application of Islam worldwide since its inception in the 7th century, it would be hard to argue that its diabolical inspiration does not seem clear. In its unrelenting quest for world conquest by any means the Islamic ideology has been the worst source of human misery in history. Some sources put the death toll of Islamic wars and slave trade as high as 670 million. The greatest genocide in history was during the Islamic conquest of Afghanistan, Pakistan and parts of India during which between 60 and 100 million, Hindus, Buddhists and others were slaughtered. The mountain range between Afghanistan and Pakistan, the Hindu Kush, in English means Hindu death and commemorates that genocide.
The last bastion of slavery on earth is in the Islamic nations. One in five citizens of Islamic Mauritania is a slave even today. It is Muslims themselves who have suffered more than any other people. Despite the fabulous wealth of the Islamic oligarchy the income of ordinary Muslims is a less than half of the world average.
Coz he is from Al Jazeera
@@Muwahid999 fck mohamd .
Whn Mehdi gets a pakistany diplomat or politician before him we feel he has feeling for India.. 🤣
over the year I realize that medi is just an apologist for the violence of islam. Good Job Medhi you are sneaky and intelligent without compare.
Mehdi doesn’t let anyone respond and cuts off before they can complete and hopes for a mistake and gotcha moment
You could feel and see the guilt of indian armed forces in Kashmir in the face and voice of the indian man!
So now we have Al-Jazeera teaching India abt human rights like seriously
Look at India...
@@mbk9998 what??
That's Qatari standard... one way they side with sunni and at the same time they will side with shiates Iran... and the link between funding nation to terror organization of Hamas and Hezbolla....
@@wadodful I've been out for necessary reason & bro I haven't been beaten up like dog by police. You do something stupid then u deserve to be trashed and I would support that. secondly, India very much understands human rights even under BJP so don't try spreading ur stupid narrative pls
do u studies and come
Do you think India is seriously doing justice