Dr Zakir Naik Answered on the topic "Why are Music and Dancing not allowed in Islam? by Dr Zakir Naik" on the topic "Ask Dr Zakir (Chennai)" ADZN_CH_04
First of all learn how to spell kid it's laughed not laught you dumb moron and second of all Zakir sir is correct you're just mad for no reason you're just a dumahh lol@@philippkaelin3673
@@philippkaelin3673this is the same islam that europe is going to become unfortunately. no music, no dance, no pig meat, no freedom, mohammed had sx with a 9 year old. It's all there in the quran. Just read it. I personally see more humanity in religions such as hinduism and buddhism, perhaps because these religions acknowledge atheists like me but also because conversion is never forced upon one.
Are playing computer games prohibited too then? Cuz it takes us away from Allah and how about watching movies or any other form of entertainment for that matter. Shouldn't God prohibit entertainment in general then? Can someone please answer me. I'm a Muslim and I'm curious
@@auroobashafquat309 Thank you very much for your answer! Appreciate it. One final question: How is listening to music different from playing sports then. I mean sure sports is a great way to stay healthy and fit and is very advisable to do. But listening to music has its own benefits too that is it's a great stress reliever and gives your mind great relaxation
@@auroobashafquat309 sorry for the many questions. I'm just curious,not defiant. I'm also asking these questions because I find that Dr Zakir's answer is heavily flawed
I asked same. However music can be allowed. What music is allowed is something who not make you over emotion. Make close to Allah and far from what forbid. For example. If any song talk about free sex its forbid. But if music remember you about love who granted by Allah is okay. Playing game is okay. Allah ask to human for entertaimen them self too. But if too much and forgot life is forbid. If the game is borrowing you yo violence is forbid. If games make you or having contain who make you far away. Its forbid
So you just copy this two sentence compliment and paste it on pretty much every popular videos of Zakir Naik to show everyone that how much you've studied about Islam and it's teachings so you don't get caught by us like how Daud Kim was
She laughed because of his extreme thougths,e.g women cannot dance because the woman is revealed and people see her. Eventhough they protect women and love them, they do not give them the freedom that would be the same as men.
Let challenge bro say yoyr wife to dance in stage and here ppl cmmts without knowing them 90% boys describe your wife in sexual way so if you r real men you should get anger agree or not
Bro she laughed but not because she was intelligent enough to understand that zakir naik was saying illogical things rather because of higher order clever conversation skills of zakir nayak where he clevery mixes humour in accordance with the nature of the question asking person.Zakir knew she was a casual girl so he deliberately used light words like girlfriend boyfriend to raise her humourous side and doing what he was accusing music for i.e. taking away from logical thinking by creating an ambience
Here he is saying dancing is haram, he said DANCING ITSELF! not being a DANCER is haram. The difference is that being a dancer is showing people, while dance is DANCE itself that doesn't involve in talent shows and clubs/parties. If I dance by my own as a small part of my day is NOT haram because I also get time for woreship in a part of my day. MY opinions about this topic all: 1. Music SHOULDN'T just be called haram because it keeps u away from worship, u can do both! (I do both myself, is it that hard to believe?) listening to music can help with getting stress off, I'm not saying that Quran can't, it just another refreshing way. Songs that has bad words/sexual topics/drinking or any sin topics I consider as haram, because when u sing u begin to get used to the words and ur mind wouldn't find sins like this as big as someone who doesn't listen to the song, but OFC everything is based on INTENTIONS PEOPLE!!! There is good songs out there, I personally listen to Drumstep, Dubstep, and Trap kinda music that most of them doesn't even have lyrics.. And if it does their are NOT sinful and I just love it while playing video games too. 2. As I said, Muslims can devide their time to thank Allah AND have fun while doing what they love (dancing) BUT ofc if girls start to dance like in some movies and begins to show, and show, and SHOW.. THIS will obviously be a problem because they are: 1- making other people (let's say guys who watched a movie where a girl dances) have sins, and guess who is getting these sins too? IT'S THE DANCER because she was part of making this, it's just fitna 2- When it becomes normal for her to dance, haya'a and modesty will fly away slowly, it becomes normal for her to hang out with any guy, there WON'T be barriers anymore... Which is happening rn as a sign of the hour.
And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing, etc.) to mislead (men) from the Path of Allah without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allah, the Verses of the Quran) by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment (in the Hell-fire). (surah luqman verse 6)
Just to clarify some point because some person seems not understand completely the matter: 1. Music is prohibited when it takes you away from God (for example the modern music is plenty of bad words, nude people, bad teaching etc..) 2. Dancing is prohibited for men and women; is clear that dr. Naik was talking about women because body of women is more attractive during a dance so women must be protected from the eyes of other men. 3. Music makes you dream about something that is not in your real life and music can also set your desires and bring you in some bad behavior. 4. Islam teaches us to control our desires and leave our passions, they can bring us away from the right path. Music doesn't help to control our desires but often it put our desires out. 5. Music made for glorify Allah SWT is ammitted indeed a lot of amazing nasheed have been created . Jazak'Allah khayran .
@@443tify I invite you to look better in Islam because you are saying something wrong. Knowledge is everything. You are just barking. Looking at the other major religion is clear that Islam is more modern and not retrograde as you are saying.
Remember dear brothers and sisters that if you pray Salah and you do every sin except for shirk then you have a 99 percent chance of going to jannah because Salah is that amazing and Allah loves those who pray Salah but of course Allah hates the other sins but Allah is Rahman so Allah will inshallah get you into jannah so please pray Salah jazakallah
I don't completely disagree but when a rapper talks about killing his homies and smoking drugs, the youth get inappropriate ideas. So if music is supposed to express God's love explain this please.
Not to mention most pop songs all talk about "chasing love", or your ex, and most especially sexual relationships. Why would this be an expression of God's love? I'm not saying it's completely wrong but it makes sense why it's not allowed. At least for music it makes sense to me.
@@khaildbinalwalid2647 Is tap dance also prohibited. Performwd by men to showcase the skills. And is listening to foreign songs also prohibited. The songs you hear that you don't know the meaning of.
Assalamwakum, Listening to and performing music is mubaah due to the hadith of Ibn Umar when he listened to the shepards flute while he was traveling with the Messenger of Allah (saw). "Nafi reports that when the Messenger (saw) heard the sound of a shepherd’s flute, he thrust his fingers into his ears and then asked: ‘Can you still hear it Ibn ‘Umar?’ He continued moving ahead until Ibn ‘Umar said: I can’t hear it, so he (saw) took his fingers out of his ears.’ Thus, the Messenger (saw) did not forbid the shepard or rebuke him and nor did he forbid Ibn Umar from listening. However this permissible action may become Haraam if it falls within two principles: ‘If any aspect of a permitted thing leads to a harm then that aspect is prohibited, but the thing remains permitted’. And ‘The means to a Haraam is itself Haraam.’ The likelihood of leading to Haram is sufficient here. If music incites the instincts like most Arab music does or it is accompanied by dancing or when mixing takes place in musical events. Then the music in this case becomes Haraam. This is because the incitement of the instincts in most cases, especially when there is an interest in music, leads to Haraam. This is besides dancing and mixing is Haraam. Allahoalam
If the goal is to bring glory and praise to God, then music is allowed, The book of Psalms is a collection of songs, King David wrote much of it, and played instruments, The bible mentions that we should sing to God with joyous hearts, and through music. Worshipping and praising God is not a somber empty dead ritual, but a happy joyous, heartfelt gratitude for all He has done for us, through His son Jesus Christ.
Listening to music is not sinful unless you do it too much or if you don’t listen to the Quran or if you drink alcoholic drinks or do illegal sexual intercourse or wear silk. If you practice your Islamic duties and you listen to music in your free time then it’s not sinful.
Not all scholars are the same. There are 3 kinds of scholars. The ones who say the truth and don’t care about what others think, the ones who want to make the state happy and the ones who wants to make the country happy.
Music is Mathematics, an art, an expression of emotion.. Music is some thing that unites.. Music is something above all languages.. Dancing is meditation,physical activity, an art and an expression. Com on open up.. why there is so much judgement.. As much as i know there are lot of Great composers from muslim side of the world.. many sufi and Kawali..
Let them say whatever they want to. He doesn't know anything about sufi and other forms. How can singing take you away from Almighty good? Rubbish. Dancing I can understand but the reason he gave for singing is literally stupid.
Usually when guys dance, they dance in marriage etc.... therefore he is not pointing that out, if a girl dances with herself in her house without exposing that to anyone then she is allowed to do that, as long as it doesn't go out of the Sharia Law.
Vipul Mestri Well, i'm a convert along with my Sister, and she is very happy with wearing veil and Niqab, if you were a true Muslim you would simply accept it and eventually you will find that the damage of it is way greater than the use of it.
Guys I just wanted to share what a famous German philosopher said... "Life without music would be a mistake" ~Friedrich Nietzsche There are tooo many religions so there is nothing such as a universal truth.. Follow what suits you best
In the Quran there are parts that say that illegal sexual intercourse is haram and drinking alcoholic drinks is haram separately but, there is nothing in the Quran that says that music is forbidden.
Thank God... He did not prohibit mics and wearing a suit and tie... Otherwise you would have to shout out to so many people. Rules as per convenience..
@@umair.shakoor10 May I know the reason? That why decent music is haram? And if Allah has an objection with the music then why he has given the talent to sing to the Muslim artists like Atif Aslam, Rafi sahab, Suraiya and many more.. I'm just asking...
@@gaganbisht849 Look honestly I am nobody to explain something to you cause I'm not that educated in this field. However Dr Zakir clearly states music is haram and why it is so. Also mufti Menk and all the others also believes the same.
"because we love our women, that's why we don't want to exhibit them." What if the women themselves want to exhibit themselves? This is such a fearful philosophy as well as cynical. It also asks people to be responsible in strange ways. The onus is on the people who see the dancing and the singing to behave themselves, not on the singers and dancers to hide. If you take away basic human venues for happiness, you're not creating spiritual or philosophical enlightening, you're creating frustration that will result from strict puritanism.
Because wen women exhibit themselves they cause alot of social ills, like how theyre egos grow so much bcuz of all the people looking, how women start hating each other bcuz they dont look as good, or how men compete with each other, or how women who dress in revealing cloths cause men to lust which is a sin,or how they get so high on themselves bcuz of the way they r treated that they start being dismissive towards other human beings, really good looking girls feel they r superior and thats the truth
abel reynoso So more like your worried about the opinion of MEN than the rights of WOMEN. Typical. Plenty of women don’t dress “modestly” which in terms of Islam is “oppressively” and they’re not raped, beaten, lusted after, etc. You people are just deviant sexual little raping beast who have no self control or discipline. And because you have no self control or discipline you try and force away anything that might prove it.
Najma Noor Who told you they didn’t? It’s personal choice. Freedom. I know you Muslims can’t stand the idea that you don’t control everything but there it is.
@@sajidahmed-vl9go what? No! Hijab is for women and men are not allowed to wear tight clothes that expose their body shape. Men and women are both told to lower their gaze to the opposite gender.
Samveg Lohiya listen carefully of what he said when giving that example please. He wasn’t talking about poetry he was talking about how some songs mention the impossible and take a person away from Allah swt .
brother, dance or music may not always keeps away a person from the creator. But when a person get too much involved in these, like music... It happens.. People get the tendency to forget their beliefs seeing other cultures and things... Am an example Am a muslim... I watch all kinds of music.... Movies.... Likeq dance... Everything.... But i have never thoughy of the fact that these things will keep us away from Allah... What he said is correct. Sometimes i don't do my salah(NAMAZ) at the right time, because am watching a movie.. Because i don't want to stop watching the movie in the middle... I often doesn't do my salah. That means these things made me forget about my prayer... I hope you now know why🙂 Even i realised my mistake now only... After watching this video May allah bless him🤲🏻
@@kaizen_monk its true and it is scientifically proved by einstein equation E= mc2 ...which states that when an object travels with the speed of light time stops for it
this demonstration gives me some reflection. god have give you also ears to hear and have created the rythm and the waves and put is golden number in the music system. because music it's a part of mathematics.it's attested that the practice of instrument make the musician more powerful than the others people. all physical make sound and heat. sound is a part of the world. Language, speech words are humans sounds. And only the greatest know perfectly all those languages of the universe. Arabic people are poets, they are diplomate, they have a great ability to keep the rythm and to be constant, they have a great sense of music so why could this forbidden for them?. The question of the music in islam is really difficult. It can be an object of conflict. But music in itself is not a problem. In fact there is no rationnel reason for this, or a consensus clear. You didn't said music is forbidden you said that daff is allowed, you didn't say singing is bad, it was about the words. Some people told me it's forbidden because it can keep you far from your religious practice. so if you want also this argument to yours, you can, i won't say , how this guy is a thief. this summer i was in morocco, i have meet some young gnawa people, they were dancing and singing song about our Muhammad and Allah. Their Faith and their love for the creator was really sincere, and people was happy to give them something. When you switch from society, it's really hard to understand why some ideas are more or less accepted. Why this part of the human knowledge is so differently understood at a time or at a place. It is also understandable that your speech reinforces an already acquired audience, but it can take many people away from the path that Allah has only revealed to the prophets. As much as possible I invite you to study music to listen to it, you will see that it can not be as unlawful as some exegeses claim. On the contrary, it is a blessing that teaches us to listen better to others, the world. it certainly does not answer the questions of men, but as religion it must bring men together. And that's what it's about ... are wars a cause of religion? no, but we did it in his name. can music kill? no, but she also accompanies the soldiers. So at the end i didn't feel more advanced with the question.
Good explanation. However, just to add, in some cultures, music and dance are an integral part of worship. Hinduism and Sufism surely integrate worship into music. Need to see the context of the singing or dancing. Music can also heal certain psychological illnesses. Music can improve alertness in children. Not the trashy kind of music, but Mozart, Beethoven symphonies for example.
And lemme tell u something, people with high standard taste of music is a wise man. Ofc based of context why to avoid certain genre of music is to not mislead ourselves subliminally. Oh if you ask me, the song i hate the most is Closers by Chainsmokers. U will hear an obnoxious arrangement of melodies that will makes you dumb. And also that one line lyric "We will never getting older" contradicts to real life teachings And also Fk that tiktod cringe remix and such
Nature has its own music. We may not be able to hear the sound of natural vibrations but it's there. What's part of nature is given a new dimension by humans. Like everything else, too much of anything is poison but if used in the right way, it can actually be beneficial.
The quran can aleviate many mental illnesses, especially anxiety and stress, so depending on anything other than allah and his words to help you is Shirk, and you just proved it with your words, you are only suppose to be reliant on allah, this is why music is haram
Every human is an artist, talent is given the the Allah only, so why we can't show it up? I used to sing and dance to explain motivational or moral value. And I love it
Bro now my mom wont let me buy a guitar because she saw this video and turned muslum and im christian since she converted now i cant even buy/get a guitar until im 18 and move out by the way im 15 and my birthday is in june 1rst so thanks a lot🙃
And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing, etc.) to mislead (men) from the Path of Allah without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allah, the Verses of the Quran) by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment (in the Hell-fire). (surah luqman verse 6)
I guess one of the reasons is that it will take you away from allah so even if you don’t understand the meaning ,the beats and the instruments are the ones prohibited so I think it isn’t right
😊 💎 As Salamu 'Alaikum uar RahmatuLlahi ua Barakatu! 💎 😊 Peace and love from Allah be upon you and those you love, those who love you and those who love those who love you. :)
How can anyone believe in Islam when it encourages Muslim man to have sex fantasies with 72 virgins in heaven after they die ? And why isn't the 72 virgin sex fantasy not haram but listening to music and dancing is haram ? Islam as it is right now is a political movement and not a religion.
There is no such thing as paradise, there is no Allah. Just enjoy your life when you are living it. Read up about the universe and evolution then you will realise that Allah did not create anything and does not exist.
@Mr. Banana Isis and all other Islamic terrorists implement Sharia law. They punish anyone (including Muslim's) who breaks it. This is why the world should ban Sharia law.
Prohibiting Muslims from singing can be likened to prohibiting human beings from laughing. Singing is an attribute inherent in all humans and it is God himself that created us so. It is a natural skill in us all. How then should God prohibit it. This and many other similar issues make this faith highly questionable!
@Super woman will you think a 50 kg Man can see a GOD ????😀😀 I wana to tell U that our earth is billion times smaller than a Sun,& you know sun is just a star??haha Les think now abt the whole universe?? Do you think anybody will see Him??
You r not peacok U r a humen a superior being in the sight of Allah high more than Angels? After that your creater the Lord gives u instructions how to spend your temporary life in this world???
@Super woman i talk abt whole humenity not only muslims? And you r teaching me about high thinking 😕very nice U make me impress? Whata thinking to dance coz peacock is dancing😕😕😕 Amazing?
How did you have a drivel like "music is haram." Is eating patato haram too ? Or drink peach juice. I live in Turkey but i never heard about any idea like "music is haram". We have great music culture in Turkey. There is no evidance about haramness of music in İslam.Dont talk nonsense.
we all one day must die. and this world is test for us. if we find right path then we don't need to fear of anything. region is nothing but humanity is everything. everyone have a unique and beautiful mind. but how to use it that is totally depand on us. in this planet we all are creator of one god. and one day we must believe on that god that is real people call them in many great beautiful name but he is one.
Asalaamualaikum. We are living at a time where time is ticking fast. Music can lead to addiction. With that being said, it can then be very time consuming. And then you got sports broadcasted on television which is another time consumer. And then you got soaps, movies, media, gaming platforms, paying a visit to your friends/family, time spent at work, etc. My question is, how much time do we have remaining for our Deen?
Exactly! the quran should be the reason you love allah and the creation, and prayer and giving in charity, music does not benefit your islam, it does not bring reward, it doesnt help your body, and if anyone cclaims it helps the mind, then its clearly shaytan speaking because praying and reading quran is suppose to help the mind
i read the comments and God, why so much hate people? just bcz your opinions differ doesn't mean you will say all these hateful things. For heaven's sake, show a little respect.
Hadiya ikr? And I’ve been literally there on every comment trying to defend my opinion like bruh?! I understand that you probably hate Islam and Muslims but atleast as a human race, you can keep the comment section a bit dignified. Does it cost you?!
music is in nature... if allah created nature he created music ... so dont worry listen to music and also dance... dont follow muhammad just follow allah
@@superman5507 that 2 days is just gap between extreme sexual pleasures he was having daily... he used to have sex with all his wives at one night one after another ... sometimes he used fuck ayesha and go for preaching with all sperm strains on his clothes.. ayesha used to stop him and clean that dirty shit on him...😷 such a shit man he is 🤦🏻♂️...that is why i am saying believe in allah is good but not in Muhammad
@@vikramssctelugu6148 prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H is mentioned in hindi scriptures and bible...Allay says in Quran that if you obey Prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H then it means that you obey Allah and if you disobey Prophet Muhammad P.B.U H then it means you disobey Allah ..prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H did everything with Allah 's command and prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H personality guide us in every aspect of life and i dont know about the stain thing that you have said but if i generally speak will you intrude in your neighbours personal life that how many time does he and her wife do sex in a day ......you should find authentic reasons and dont use abusive language just clarify your confusions by asking politely
Dr Zakir used to be a person I loved to listen to when I first started my journey to Islam, but now I see how many times he singles out women as if these things that are prohibited are only prohibited for women. This kind of teaching really reminds me of the radicalized teachings that only poison the young Muslim minds and teaches them wrong. Although I still believe that he is very knowledgeable, at the same time he decided to follow a more radical path of faith that I disagree with.
I personally believe that he is poisoning Muslim minds as well. Music is not haram. These beliefs are crazy, people like this have fabricated so many lies and are brainwashing people. This person speaking out supports terrorist beliefs and as a result was banned in India. Is that Islam? No.
Razzak khan my point isn’t really about music being haram (obviously a song with a certain beat and dirty lyrics can’t be halal) but my problem with him is that he usually singles out women when he speaks about something haram... As if dancing isn’t prohibited to men also. I mean, it’s not only based on this video, I’ve been watching him for a while... although thanks for Mufti Menk 😀
@@muichiroutokito9159 No, the hadith he quoted is real. Music with instruments except the mentioned one is haram. He doesn't support terrorism and he always makes that clear. He is a representative of Islam if he uses correctly the Quran and hadith. We all know there's no substance behind his India ban. Now I don't know if you genuinely want to learn about the religion or not. That's up to you. But let's try having an open mind to things.
He did give women as an example because of the modern day dance culture. What I mean is, dancing nowadays has really moved towards a direction of women exposing and shaking as much as possible. It's still haram for men, I think, but when dancing, a man's hijab is almost never really compromised. With that being said, I do understand your concern to an extent but his teachings being of a radical nature? That I just don't see.
fist thing .... dancing doesn't meaning dancing on stage or performance....it's a way through we can relax our self or to feel comfortable.....even animal can also do...its a natural thing which nature or god have given us ... apart from that dancing is very good for Heath .... improved condition of your heart and lungs increased muscular strength, endurance and motor fitness increased aerobic fitness improved muscle tone and strength weight management stronger bones and reduced risk of osteoporosis better coordination, agility and flexibility improved balance and spatial awareness increased physical confidence improved mental functioning improved general and psychological wellbeing greater self-confidence and self-esteem better social skills. so don't lesion to this people ..he is illiterate...he just make make people's fool ...
Assalamualaikum I've got a question about music, is listening to classic music such as mozart or chaupin haram? Because this type of music is said by numerous psicologists is good.
from what i know, any kind of music, using musical instrument, is still haram. prophet muhammad (pbuh) said that zina and music's instrumental is haram. well, im not an syeikh so thats the only thing i know.
Sir... I agree with you, A blank minded person or say a zero situation is necessary to find our soul. . From past time it's seen that many kind of dance and music is there to show off body parts. . Now the mobile apps and websites are there to ruin the culture
Music and dance are human nature. They exist in every single culture that has ever existed. To deny them is to deny humanity. Islam is full of strange ideas. The prohibitions against music and dance are definitely strange--and disturbing. Music and dance are expressions of joy. The ayatollah Khomeini said, There is no fun in Islam. Fun is joy, happiness. Islam forbids these things? Wow, how sad. Peace, and joy, y'all.
Arabic culture doesn't mean Islamic culture. There are even arab prostitutes are their, it doesn't mean Islam supports prostitution. Learn islam, not arabs or parkisthanis or iranis.
What about the music or lyrics that tells about life or gives us some insight about someone else's life or conditions that they are living in, and types of dances or mudras in dance that express the same thing.There are shades in everything ,everything has bad sides and good sides it's about taking the out the best and applying it in our life,as also said by Allah in Surah 39 verse 18. Thanks.
Assalamualaikum my brother may you explain sarah 31_laqanda verse 6 to me its speaks about music on the note 161. I.e. that which has no benefit. Describe by different sahabah as shrik (associations with Allah). Misleading stories frivolous songs, are music but includes all which distracts or divert one from the Qur'an and remembrance of Allah.
Those kind of concepts don't really exist objectively in Islam. If you're following the Quran, you can be said to be loving yourself. If you're following the Quran, you can be said to be free of mental issues. That's the basic idea.
@Cherylxox Islam does speak about serenity . This is a quotation from Quran where it says in the remembrance of Allah do hearts find peace . For muslims , it’s an absolute truth . Those who have believed and whose hearts are assured by the remembrance of Allah . Unquestionably, by the remembrance of Allah hearts are assured. Those who have believed and done righteous deeds - a good state is theirs and a good return. Surah Ra’d Ayat 28-29
I think there is a divergence of openion between Muslim Scolars regarding listening and paying the musical instruments, some SCOLARS in Islam dont see any harm in listening to pure music like Mosar, bethoven, extra, even Music with singing is allowed in islam as long as the singing is not about drugs, alchool, sex, violence or any singing which go against the teaching if Islamic shariaa., also there is another condition to this permission is that listening to music should NOT make you forget your duties towards Allah and remembering him, like if you are busy listening to music all day long ( some work places ike warehouses factories, coffee shops, retailerss ) they play music and songs and songs all day long and everyday, and you forget about prayers time or remembring Allah an listening - reading Quran, in that situation this music and singing become a form of worship and replace the quran and makes you forget about Allah, in this situation this abuse of listening to music and songs becomes haram.. It is NOT the good music and the good singing which are Haram, but it is what type of music we listen to and the way we listen to it in our daily and social life, these factors can effect the good music and it beomes haram in islam. same thing about dancing, families are allowed in islam to enjoy music, singing and dancing, no harm in that in Islam as long as we do it according to islamic laws. Unforunately, there are few scholars in isalam are quit old fashion and very hard on their views about music and singing and they put lof restrictions and haram about many things without having a solid prouf from the Quran and the teaching of prophet Muhamed Peace be upon him. ,
@@RoronoaZoro-mw7wu you guys are disturbing 🙄 , I mean I hate islam , but today I know the islam(mental diseases) affected your brain with such stupidity,
@@yogiadityanath9354 you hating Islam doesn't matter. Cos y'all lack the brains to understand the wisdom behind such things. So only y'all find it as a mental disease.
Why not cricket is haram which takes you away for hours cant understand logic of these jahil mullahs . My question is simple that what is the verse of Quran which prohibit music.
But,for the dancing part, when it is about singing nasheed, it is allowed even in front of other people as long as the hijab conditions (clothes,no makeup..)are respected right?And you said because we use our body to entertain it is haram but from hijab conditions ,the whole body is dissimilated so in that case we are dancing with nasheed,with no moves that can be "sexy" it just becomes an ensemble of moves with the nasheed and acapella And again since a hijabi can play sports in front of others for example ,dancing becomes halal right? I'm just saying what I think please correct me if I'm wrong.
Music is prohibited because takes one away from God. It doesn't at all make you happy (only superficially). But true peace only comes from obeying Allah.
Imzy01 You only believe that because of pressure from you're community and the fact you were brought up to believe that,it's not true,music is good for you.
+rosie811honey Actually personally I was a huge music fan before. I have seen a huge difference in my spirituality when I stopped listening to music..just generally I felt at real tranquil peace that I hadn't felt before. Music takes a person away from reality especially when they get hooked on it, the moment they stop listening they feel they need it again.
Bro in islam music is not haram but you also heard that some dirty dirty lyrics so these music are haram in islam not all music you might be understood what i'm trying to say..!!❣
Heh, RIGHT, so why music and dancing aren't still prohibited in islamic countries? There are many muslim musicians. What's the point here? Don't they believe in harmness of music & dancing to the society?
Mr Zakir I have a question this is urgent to me the question is can we do dancing by wearing cover and unfit dress And sing what is true I am asking this question cuz my dream depends on it pls I need the answer
I do agree with what the doctor says but I have a question and it wiykd mean a lot if one you guys answer this. So what about music with plain sound tracks such as electronic music which does nit include any instrument. What uc the electronic music has a few words such as "pump it up, you gotta pump it" pls answer both questions. I want to know the truth. Thank you
Brother please listen all these videos. And in place of music you hear Quran recitation it will definitely relax and calm your mind. Music is totally prohibited in Islam , music is a weapon of shyateen. I hope you understand.
@@amanmahmood1316 well I do not agree, on Balkan we have ilahije (islamic songs) and there are some musicians that do not inspire haram (like imagine dragons...), also there is no place in Quran that prohibits music... Dancing is stupid, but music helps me study, workout ect.
I am really glad to see this because it shows some attitudes that are common in Islam that many in the West do not realize. Singing, dancing are frequently seen as problem, notice the audience is mostly men and there is a women section. These are not "extreme" views. This is mainstream Islam.
My friend worked in war zones across the globe with the UN, Medicin Sans Frontiers and various other organisations. He said in each desperately tragic place, people found happiness and community through music and dance, except one place. The one place that he said was the most miserably awful, soulless and depressing place was Darfur. The people were strictly forbidden to sing and dance. They had nothing to connect their community except misery. He refers to it as the most miserable place he ever experienced. Shame on any culture that supresses a fundamental tool of actual human civilisation.
How about the songs like 25 rasul,10 malaikat,Allah made everything and tala al badru alayna songs? These are song and are bringing us closer to Allah right? I normally memorise the prophets and angels by using songs in this list. I am just a kid and curious.
Not every muslims are following this. My muslim friends enjoy listening to kpop and dance. Even indian music composer AR Rahman also doenst follow this. As long as people are enjoying their lives n dont harm others, its ok for me.
Yes, she is laughing but she isn’t disrespecting! She is giving respect and listening carefully! May Allah Guide us all to the right path ❤️
Yeah she laughes for jokes lol, it's good I think
She laught because what Zakir says is just stupid.
First of all learn how to spell kid it's laughed not laught you dumb moron and second of all Zakir sir is correct you're just mad for no reason you're just a dumahh lol@@philippkaelin3673
@@philippkaelin3673this is the same islam that europe is going to become unfortunately. no music, no dance, no pig meat, no freedom, mohammed had sx with a 9 year old. It's all there in the quran. Just read it. I personally see more humanity in religions such as hinduism and buddhism, perhaps because these religions acknowledge atheists like me but also because conversion is never forced upon one.
@@philippkaelin3673islam
Are playing computer games prohibited too then? Cuz it takes us away from Allah and how about watching movies or any other form of entertainment for that matter. Shouldn't God prohibit entertainment in general then? Can someone please answer me. I'm a Muslim and I'm curious
@@auroobashafquat309 thanks for your answer! But the question still stands: is entertainment in general haram since it brings us away from God?
@@auroobashafquat309 Thank you very much for your answer! Appreciate it. One final question: How is listening to music different from playing sports then. I mean sure sports is a great way to stay healthy and fit and is very advisable to do. But listening to music has its own benefits too that is it's a great stress reliever and gives your mind great relaxation
@@auroobashafquat309 sorry for the many questions. I'm just curious,not defiant. I'm also asking these questions because I find that Dr Zakir's answer is heavily flawed
@@auroobashafquat309 You are a nice person. God bless you and I wish you the best in this life and the next. Thanks for your answer. Peace!
I asked same. However music can be allowed. What music is allowed is something who not make you over emotion. Make close to Allah and far from what forbid. For example. If any song talk about free sex its forbid. But if music remember you about love who granted by Allah is okay. Playing game is okay. Allah ask to human for entertaimen them self too. But if too much and forgot life is forbid. If the game is borrowing you yo violence is forbid. If games make you or having contain who make you far away. Its forbid
Well.. I had music ads after watching this video.
😂😂😂 environment
@@abdullahmishal5916 No.. right after the video has ended, the ad started in the same page.
You tube control ad not zakir
@@mohdwaseem7048 Yeah because the keyword 'music' is used in the video title. And the Chanel is monetized by ads.
Bro advertisements are based on your activities on internet, musical ads will be shown if u watch musical videos
Mashallah! Thank you for helping me find Islam and all the work you do for the ummah :))
SubhanAllah. All perfect praises belong to Allah-the Lord of the worlds!
Welcome my sister to religion of peace islam I watched many videos in your channel it's amazing
@@trassimdog hahahha religion of peace 💀
💗
So you just copy this two sentence compliment and paste it on pretty much every popular videos of Zakir Naik to show everyone that how much you've studied about Islam and it's teachings so you don't get caught by us like how Daud Kim was
Dont go to the comments. Its full of ignorant people
exactly and report them if u accidently see them at least they'll get removed that way
Aisha Ali thanks for the info
Neo Wolfe
Aisha Ali yeah, report for free speech!
YES! I agree!! seriously people! don't go to the comments!!!
Super intelligent people out there ain't it? LOL!
The girl stared to laugh then she controlled herself :D :D
She laughed when Dr zakir Naik was being funny but she cleverly understood what he was saying never the less like you 😂
She laughed because of his extreme thougths,e.g women cannot dance because the woman is revealed and people see her. Eventhough they protect women and love them, they do not give them the freedom that would be the same as men.
Manash Datta yeah bcz she realised how stupid she sounded earlier. She’s cute!!
Let challenge bro say yoyr wife to dance in stage and here ppl cmmts without knowing them 90% boys describe your wife in sexual way so if you r real men you should get anger agree or not
Bro she laughed but not because she was intelligent enough to understand that zakir naik was saying illogical things rather because of higher order clever conversation skills of zakir nayak where he clevery mixes humour in accordance with the nature of the question asking person.Zakir knew she was a casual girl so he deliberately used light words like girlfriend boyfriend to raise her humourous side and doing what he was accusing music for i.e. taking away from logical thinking by creating an ambience
اللہ مجھے پریشانیوں سے نجات عطا فرمائے
May God save me from troubles
آمین
Amin
Ameen
Aameen sum Aameen
امين
Ameen
@saketh aekka ameen
Here he is saying dancing is haram, he said DANCING ITSELF! not being a DANCER is haram. The difference is that being a dancer is showing people, while dance is DANCE itself that doesn't involve in talent shows and clubs/parties. If I dance by my own as a small part of my day is NOT haram because I also get time for woreship in a part of my day.
MY opinions about this topic all:
1. Music SHOULDN'T just be called haram because it keeps u away from worship, u can do both! (I do both myself, is it that hard to believe?) listening to music can help with getting stress off, I'm not saying that Quran can't, it just another refreshing way. Songs that has bad words/sexual topics/drinking or any sin topics I consider as haram, because when u sing u begin to get used to the words and ur mind wouldn't find sins like this as big as someone who doesn't listen to the song, but OFC everything is based on INTENTIONS PEOPLE!!!
There is good songs out there, I personally listen to Drumstep, Dubstep, and Trap kinda music that most of them doesn't even have lyrics.. And if it does their are NOT sinful and I just love it while playing video games too.
2. As I said, Muslims can devide their time to thank Allah AND have fun while doing what they love (dancing)
BUT ofc if girls start to dance like in some movies and begins to show, and show, and SHOW.. THIS will obviously be a problem because they are:
1- making other people (let's say guys who watched a movie where a girl dances) have sins, and guess who is getting these sins too? IT'S THE DANCER because she was part of making this, it's just fitna
2- When it becomes normal for her to dance, haya'a and modesty will fly away slowly, it becomes normal for her to hang out with any guy, there WON'T be barriers anymore... Which is happening rn as a sign of the hour.
So, with regard to dancing, what he's saying is that muslims are unable to control themselves or am I missing something here?
Muslim men you mean
@rDk2048 the fuck u mumbling about?
And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing, etc.) to mislead (men) from the Path of Allah without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allah, the Verses of the Quran) by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment (in the Hell-fire). (surah luqman verse 6)
@@lilosnitch3247 To the untrained eye the clear night sky is but a chaotic mess. To the sailor it is a welcome guide.
@@DaevorTheDevoted stop being such a try hard no ones gonna quote u Sun Tzu wannabe
Just to clarify some point because some person seems not understand completely the matter:
1. Music is prohibited when it takes you away from God (for example the modern music is plenty of bad words, nude people, bad teaching etc..)
2. Dancing is prohibited for men and women; is clear that dr. Naik was talking about women because body of women is more attractive during a dance so women must be protected from the eyes of other men.
3. Music makes you dream about something that is not in your real life and music can also set your desires and bring you in some bad behavior.
4. Islam teaches us to control our desires and leave our passions, they can bring us away from the right path. Music doesn't help to control our desires but often it put our desires out.
5. Music made for glorify Allah SWT is ammitted indeed a lot of amazing nasheed have been created .
Jazak'Allah khayran .
Your Absolutely Right! This Is Also My Point
🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷
These rules are illogical asf. Islam is made up by primitive cave dwellers. Islam doesnt belong in the 21st century
Where do you control your desires when you marry more than one wife, you are not doing some social service
@@443tify I invite you to look better in Islam because you are saying something wrong. Knowledge is everything. You are just barking. Looking at the other major religion is clear that Islam is more modern and not retrograde as you are saying.
Remember dear brothers and sisters that if you pray Salah and you do every sin except for shirk then you have a 99 percent chance of going to jannah because Salah is that amazing and Allah loves those who pray Salah but of course Allah hates the other sins but Allah is Rahman so Allah will inshallah get you into jannah so please pray Salah jazakallah
What if someone rapes, kills but sincerely does 5 times Namaz
Lol... Chuthya
@@atlantisassociation5152 according to Quran shit, he will go to Jannah even if he rapes his own mother, but does 5 times namaz
@@vardhan2725 shut up
@@vardhan2725 when u cant respect someones religion dont expect others to respect your religion
Love is the beauty of Gods creation through music, poems, and art
I don't completely disagree but when a rapper talks about killing his homies and smoking drugs, the youth get inappropriate ideas. So if music is supposed to express God's love explain this please.
Not to mention most pop songs all talk about "chasing love", or your ex, and most especially sexual relationships. Why would this be an expression of God's love? I'm not saying it's completely wrong but it makes sense why it's not allowed. At least for music it makes sense to me.
@@AliKhan-sd2ks agreed
They call it religion of pees
@@HamHata According to dictionary.com "pees" means either of the following:
1) the letter p
2) A british penny.
And your point was?
who wants sadguru vs dr.zakir naik hit the like💪
Sadhguru will destroy him in a debate
😂😂 just see dreams guys
@@sriniwaspotale612 no He will Defeat
NO need to debate ... He isn't a bookwarm ...he is a seeker !!
Repent and go to confession before it's too late, you will be saved if you do so! (Google "Sodom and Gomorrah today" for evidence of the Bible.)
He gave a example of nonsense song ...what about all those motivational songs ...that encourages us to achieve our dreams...are those haram too???
Didn't you hear him he said those type songs which takes far away from your creator not all type of songs
replay the video dear
I’ll tell you music which includes drugs, adultery or any evil vice is prohibited ok?
@@khaildbinalwalid2647 Is tap dance also prohibited. Performwd by men to showcase the skills.
And is listening to foreign songs also prohibited. The songs you hear that you don't know the meaning of.
@@khaildbinalwalid2647 how can anyone take far away from Creator.either song or dance. Going far , coming near bullshit concept
Dr Zakir Naik: No man can bring the moon.
Gru: Hold my SR-6 Shrink Ray.
Iss chutiye ne sach maan liya tha lagta 😆😆😆😆😆😆😆, wa Bhai wa Zakir Naik ki jai ho
Go and worship cow first
rockingalvin2012 go spread hatred among muslims and hindu
@@belalazam1129 o shut the fuck up
When no one gets a joke.
Assalamwakum, Listening to and
performing music is mubaah due to the hadith of Ibn Umar when he listened to
the shepards flute while he was traveling with the Messenger of Allah (saw).
"Nafi reports that when the Messenger (saw) heard the sound of a
shepherd’s flute, he thrust his fingers into his ears and then asked: ‘Can you
still hear it Ibn ‘Umar?’ He continued moving ahead until Ibn ‘Umar said: I
can’t hear it, so he (saw) took his fingers out of his ears.’ Thus, the
Messenger (saw) did not forbid the shepard or rebuke him and nor did he forbid
Ibn Umar from listening. However this permissible action may become Haraam if
it falls within two principles: ‘If any aspect of a permitted thing leads to a
harm then that aspect is prohibited, but the thing remains permitted’. And ‘The
means to a Haraam is itself Haraam.’ The likelihood of leading to Haram is
sufficient here. If music incites the instincts like most Arab music does or it
is accompanied by dancing or when mixing takes place in musical events. Then
the music in this case becomes Haraam. This is because the incitement of the
instincts in most cases, especially when there is an interest in music, leads
to Haraam. This is besides dancing and mixing is Haraam. Allahoalam
Thats a very good argument brother. I wish more scholars would be as smart as you.
@@kiyanelkebir9110 "scholar" xD
Jawed Khan are you alive so that I can reply u for this idiotic statement u stated in comment without knowledge?
Aleykumselam verahma
If the goal is to bring glory and praise to God, then music is allowed, The book of Psalms is a collection of songs, King David wrote much of it, and played instruments,
The bible mentions that we should sing to God with joyous hearts, and through music.
Worshipping and praising God is not a somber empty dead ritual, but a happy joyous, heartfelt gratitude for all He has done for us, through His son Jesus Christ.
I think whatever is with love to God , can't be more perfect , but when comes to other things we should think more
That fucking logic.
Adryan Tang van Rijin Please visit: moderateislam.skyrock.com
Peace•
TheFlyingHorse1 I hate all of you so called " moderate ".
Why the cut on 1:51
Im a Christian and a lot of music right now is sinful but music like jazz and classical and even some pop? No way! God gave us music as a gift
Absolutely true.may Allah safe us and our coming generation from such activities because many of us still don't consider it as a sin.
Listening to music is not sinful unless you do it too much or if you don’t listen to the Quran or if you drink alcoholic drinks or do illegal sexual intercourse or wear silk. If you practice your Islamic duties and you listen to music in your free time then it’s not sinful.
Not all scholars are the same. There are 3 kinds of scholars. The ones who say the truth and don’t care about what others think, the ones who want to make the state happy and the ones who wants to make the country happy.
@@creepykongs6662 Yes it is sinful, the prophet taught it to us in a hadith.
@Love isn't Lust are you a quranist?
Music is Mathematics, an art, an expression of emotion.. Music is some thing that unites.. Music is something above all languages.. Dancing is meditation,physical activity, an art and an expression. Com on open up.. why there is so much judgement..
As much as i know there are lot of Great composers from muslim side of the world.. many sufi and Kawali..
Love peace harmony in kawali sufi they talk about gods creature they admire god
At the time when u feel tired u can recite or listen to the holy quran
It can be feel happy us🤩🤙
Jaleel 007 I listen to Quran and music too, why is it haram
@@ailuvkurdistan
And you are Army...😊😊
BTS is optional. However, the fandom does many things that are haraam.
btw vocaloid is better
zakuro wdym by that? Millions of ppl are in the fandom, u can’t say that smh
I hate dancing and party, but i love music what should i do? 😂
Yeah...same
May Allah increase your Iman sister or brother
Watch "Shaytaan Asks You Not To Sin After This (Insha'Allah)" on CZcams
czcams.com/video/C8vApPtcodc/video.html ...hope u watch im sure it help u ☺❤
Listen to nasheeds
Let them say whatever they want to. He doesn't know anything about sufi and other forms. How can singing take you away from Almighty good? Rubbish. Dancing I can understand but the reason he gave for singing is literally stupid.
They'll keeping on hating but we will continue practising our religion and do our best to practise all of its teachings.Alhamdhullillahi allal Islam
Lol then dont watch srk salman khan aamir khan movies and disown them as muslims if u have shame and guts
In sha Allah
@@ck3289 Yes,,I never watched a movie in my life and I am proud Alhamdulillah,,
@@ck3289 LoL exactly 😂 I was thinking there were all no-brainer followers here nice to see another intellect
The world has been westernized,people think if u dont do whatever the west do u r uncultured 😆
question is about dancing.he's only focusing women or girls...don't men dance? fool trying to make other fool
Yea.all this is bullshit
Usually when guys dance, they dance in marriage etc.... therefore he is not pointing that out, if a girl dances with herself in her house without exposing that to anyone then she is allowed to do that, as long as it doesn't go out of the Sharia Law.
Y canr she do whatever she wants? U d fuck is he to make people not be happy?
Vipul Mestri Well, i'm a convert along with my Sister, and she is very happy with wearing veil and Niqab, if you were a true Muslim you would simply accept it and eventually you will find that the damage of it is way greater than the use of it.
I dont agree.women have restrictions n men dont
👋I cannot spend a day without listening to a song what should I do
@@rumaisahadi2 I was going to say the same🙂
Try to decrease first then instead of listening music listen Quran it will help you may be
I would say the Quran is best it really gets rid of anxiety at least for me
Become a Christian that's what
Guys I just wanted to share what a famous German philosopher said...
"Life without music would be a mistake" ~Friedrich Nietzsche
There are tooo many religions so there is nothing such as a universal truth..
Follow what suits you best
In the Quran there are parts that say that illegal sexual intercourse is haram and drinking alcoholic drinks is haram separately but, there is nothing in the Quran that says that music is forbidden.
Thank God... He did not prohibit mics and wearing a suit and tie... Otherwise you would have to shout out to so many people. Rules as per convenience..
Hahaha
I personally think it depends on the type of music
Andrew Coke music is music
It Is just like saying drinking depends on the type of wine
@@umair.shakoor10 then Kun faya Kun and bhar do jholi songs are also haram? Aren't they?
@@gaganbisht849 Yes, every type of qawali is also haram. Music in general is haram. It's just how it is.
@@umair.shakoor10 May I know the reason? That why decent music is haram? And if Allah has an objection with the music then why he has given the talent to sing to the Muslim artists like Atif Aslam, Rafi sahab, Suraiya and many more.. I'm just asking...
@@gaganbisht849 Look honestly I am nobody to explain something to you cause I'm not that educated in this field. However Dr Zakir clearly states music is haram and why it is so. Also mufti Menk and all the others also believes the same.
just watching osho, and come here like going stoneage
😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂
Hahahah..
@Kim Evangela Nice One:-))
All RSS TERRORISTS watching and negative commenting
This is a very peaceful religion..........
😂
110% I agree with you bro all we have to do in this religion to know about it
Very sitarcal comment 😂😂
@@sankalpchourasia1402 you are not on the right path just want to say that may Allah guide you ameen
@@tiktok-dk6mb 🤯
"because we love our women, that's why we don't want to exhibit them."
What if the women themselves want to exhibit themselves? This is such a fearful philosophy as well as cynical. It also asks people to be responsible in strange ways. The onus is on the people who see the dancing and the singing to behave themselves, not on the singers and dancers to hide. If you take away basic human venues for happiness, you're not creating spiritual or philosophical enlightening, you're creating frustration that will result from strict puritanism.
Because wen women exhibit themselves they cause alot of social ills, like how theyre egos grow so much bcuz of all the people looking, how women start hating each other bcuz they dont look as good, or how men compete with each other, or how women who dress in revealing cloths cause men to lust which is a sin,or how they get so high on themselves bcuz of the way they r treated that they start being dismissive towards other human beings, really good looking girls feel they r superior and thats the truth
Who told u muslim women want to be exhibited
abel reynoso So more like your worried about the opinion of MEN than the rights of WOMEN. Typical. Plenty of women don’t dress “modestly” which in terms of Islam is “oppressively” and they’re not raped, beaten, lusted after, etc. You people are just deviant sexual little raping beast who have no self control or discipline. And because you have no self control or discipline you try and force away anything that might prove it.
Najma Noor Who told you they didn’t? It’s personal choice. Freedom. I know you Muslims can’t stand the idea that you don’t control everything but there it is.
music is the precious gift to humanity. no religious person can ever understand or accept that.
💀💀
Ong
Its not its harmful. It comes from hell.
Why is it that your videos have music in them
is it cool for males to dance and sing on the stage without exposing himself I think "of course" why not
It's not. The 'hijab' is for women and men
@@sajidahmed-vl9go what? No! Hijab is for women and men are not allowed to wear tight clothes that expose their body shape. Men and women are both told to lower their gaze to the opposite gender.
Yes, you can do it as long as you don't break the rules.
No
@@alimranahmed4116 hijab is more than just a scarf, therefore hijab applies to both women and men
Talking About moon and stars is Poetry my dear friend
It is not taking you away from reallity
Samveg Lohiya listen carefully of what he said when giving that example please. He wasn’t talking about poetry he was talking about how some songs mention the impossible and take a person away from Allah swt .
Sainab Jagne absolutely right!
brother, dance or music may not always keeps away a person from the creator. But when a person get too much involved in these, like music... It happens.. People get the tendency to forget their beliefs seeing other cultures and things... Am an example
Am a muslim... I watch all kinds of music.... Movies.... Likeq dance... Everything.... But i have never thoughy of the fact that these things will keep us away from Allah... What he said is correct.
Sometimes i don't do my salah(NAMAZ) at the right time, because am watching a movie..
Because i don't want to stop watching the movie in the middle... I often doesn't do my salah.
That means these things made me forget about my prayer...
I hope you now know why🙂
Even i realised my mistake now only... After watching this video
May allah bless him🤲🏻
@@sainab9603 Muhammad flew to heaven on a winged horse.. isn't that impossible too ?
Why do u muslims cherry pick ?
@@kaizen_monk its true and it is scientifically proved by einstein equation E= mc2 ...which states that when an object travels with the speed of light time stops for it
this demonstration gives me some reflection. god have give you also ears to hear and have created the rythm and the waves and put is golden number in the music system. because music it's a part of mathematics.it's attested that the practice of instrument make the musician more powerful than the others people. all physical make sound and heat. sound is a part of the world. Language, speech words are humans sounds. And only the greatest know perfectly all those languages of the universe. Arabic people are poets, they are diplomate, they have a great ability to keep the rythm and to be constant, they have a great sense of music so why could this forbidden for them?. The question of the music in islam is really difficult. It can be an object of conflict. But music in itself is not a problem. In fact there is no rationnel reason for this, or a consensus clear. You didn't said music is forbidden you said that daff is allowed, you didn't say singing is bad, it was about the words. Some people told me it's forbidden because it can keep you far from your religious practice. so if you want also this argument to yours, you can, i won't say , how this guy is a thief. this summer i was in morocco, i have meet some young gnawa people, they were dancing and singing song about our Muhammad and Allah. Their Faith and their love for the creator was really sincere, and people was happy to give them something. When you switch from society, it's really hard to understand why some ideas are more or less accepted. Why this part of the human knowledge is so differently understood at a time or at a place. It is also understandable that your speech reinforces an already acquired audience, but it can take many people away from the path that Allah has only revealed to the prophets. As much as possible I invite you to study music to listen to it, you will see that it can not be as unlawful as some exegeses claim. On the contrary, it is a blessing that teaches us to listen better to others, the world. it certainly does not answer the questions of men, but as religion it must bring men together. And that's what it's about ... are wars a cause of religion? no, but we did it in his name. can music kill? no, but she also accompanies the soldiers. So at the end i didn't feel more advanced with the question.
A/a ma question is
Is it wrong or right to add music in Islamic naats?
Good explanation. However, just to add, in some cultures, music and dance are an integral part of worship. Hinduism and Sufism surely integrate worship into music. Need to see the context of the singing or dancing. Music can also heal certain psychological illnesses. Music can improve alertness in children. Not the trashy kind of music, but Mozart, Beethoven symphonies for example.
And lemme tell u something, people with high standard taste of music is a wise man.
Ofc based of context why to avoid certain genre of music is to not mislead ourselves subliminally.
Oh if you ask me, the song i hate the most is Closers by Chainsmokers. U will hear an obnoxious arrangement of melodies that will makes you dumb. And also that one line lyric "We will never getting older" contradicts to real life teachings
And also
Fk that tiktod cringe remix and such
Even meth can be used to treat certain illnesses it's still a drug tho
Nature has its own music. We may not be able to hear the sound of natural vibrations but it's there. What's part of nature is given a new dimension by humans. Like everything else, too much of anything is poison but if used in the right way, it can actually be beneficial.
The quran can aleviate many mental illnesses, especially anxiety and stress, so depending on anything other than allah and his words to help you is Shirk, and you just proved it with your words, you are only suppose to be reliant on allah, this is why music is haram
@@emmyjannah which verse ? The one where he married a child ?
May Allah guide everyone on the earth.. to walk on correct road
May Allah sw give u double your age so that you keep on preaching our Noble Islamic religion your bro in Islam from Somali. 134 .
What sort of a God is he then? The world is here for us to explore. We have to take different roads.
Every human is an artist, talent is given the the Allah only, so why we can't show it up? I used to sing and dance to explain motivational or moral value. And I love it
*What is ariana grande doing here????*
Ariana run namaz
@@Abcde-fx1rj lol
H P I wonder 😂😂😂😂😂
rDk2048 even skills that can be used for illegal things can be used to help humanity and islam
He always says the right words. MashAllah❤
I have to do a solo dance for a class assignment but i get to choreograph it and only my female teacher will see it. Can i still do the dance?
May Allah guide us💖
Bro now my mom wont let me buy a guitar because she saw this video and turned muslum and im christian since she converted now i cant even buy/get a guitar until im 18 and move out by the way im 15 and my birthday is in june 1rst so thanks a lot🙃
And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing, etc.) to mislead (men) from the Path of Allah without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allah, the Verses of the Quran) by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment (in the Hell-fire). (surah luqman verse 6)
Is listening to music in a different language which you do not understand prohibited?
Thanks :)
I guess one of the reasons is that it will take you away from allah so even if you don’t understand the meaning ,the beats and the instruments are the ones prohibited so I think it isn’t right
Shounak Chatterjee music is not good
Hahaha.. music is haram! Hahaha bwahaha...
I heard a song about drugs, pretty catchy but i had to stop listening to it
Assalamulaikum brother just want to ask that in islam told us to allowed to do ratib
Masha Allah clearly explained
😊 💎 As Salamu 'Alaikum uar RahmatuLlahi ua Barakatu! 💎 😊
Peace and love from Allah be upon you and those you love, those who love you and those who love those who love you. :)
walekum-asslam
Dont listen to music
ALLah ap ko 500 sal ke zundgi daay taky humari any wali 14 nasly ap ko yaad rkhy😀😀😀😍😍😍
I can use ncs music in background of my CZcams videos ???
No.. it is prohibited.. so is any type of entertainment which moves you away from Allah..
Cool content bro i ike it
Don't mind hate comments! Just think! By brain. Jazak Allah
How can anyone believe in Islam when it encourages Muslim man to have sex fantasies with 72 virgins in heaven after they die ? And why isn't the 72 virgin sex fantasy not haram but listening to music and dancing is haram ?
Islam as it is right now is a political movement and not a religion.
@@bricla9178 the 72 hurr is myth it no where mention in quaran
There is no such thing as paradise, there is no Allah. Just enjoy your life when you are living it.
Read up about the universe and evolution then you will realise that Allah did not create anything and does not exist.
@Mr. Banana Isis and all other Islamic terrorists implement Sharia law. They punish anyone (including Muslim's) who breaks it. This is why the world should ban Sharia law.
@@abrahmicsupremacist38 no dont say anything on your own it is true
But if verses of a song (with music) praise the God, would it still be prohibited?
Prohibiting Muslims from singing can be likened to prohibiting human beings from laughing. Singing is an attribute inherent in all humans and it is God himself that created us so. It is a natural skill in us all. How then should God prohibit it. This and many other similar issues make this faith highly questionable!
Masha Allah nice bayan
In christianity ur r blessed double if u praise god in song
When God does'nt like music what the hell u will pray???
@Super woman hehe really?
Jesus is true God?
He tell you in christinity that music is complsory fo u to pray??
@Super woman will you think a 50 kg Man can see a GOD ????😀😀
I wana to tell U that our earth is billion times smaller than a Sun,& you know sun is just a star??haha
Les think now abt the whole universe??
Do you think anybody will see Him??
You r not peacok U r a humen a superior being in the sight of Allah high more than Angels?
After that your creater the Lord gives u instructions how to spend your temporary life in this world???
@Super woman i talk abt whole humenity not only muslims?
And you r teaching me about high thinking 😕very nice U make me impress?
Whata thinking to dance coz peacock is dancing😕😕😕
Amazing?
Sir i want to know that the muslim actor like shahrukh khan salman khan etc who dance in flim is phrobitited or not. Please sir reply..
How did you have a drivel like "music is haram." Is eating patato haram too ? Or drink peach juice. I live in Turkey but i never heard about any idea like "music is haram". We have great music culture in Turkey. There is no evidance about haramness of music in İslam.Dont talk nonsense.
Not all music are haram. Depends on the lyric.
PaperCurrencyIsA Scam No you are wrong.... all Music is haraam.
only ....one sided drum. ( duff).
is allowed.
thats used in Naats .
@@rahman.rahman6961 I will not argue with you about Feqah. We are holding to the Syafie's opinions.
@@rahman.rahman6961 Here is my argument against you: www.siasat.pk/forums/threads/music-is-halal-allowed-in-islam-sahih-bukhari-muslim-hadith.79447/
No brother the music is haram it doesnt need any bad lyrics because even music along can take you far from god
@@rahman.rahman6961 If music is haram because it "distracts" you, then every form of art or entertainment is haram
we all one day must die. and this world is test for us. if we find right path then we don't need to fear of anything. region is nothing but humanity is everything. everyone have a unique and beautiful mind. but how to use it that is totally depand on us. in this planet we all are creator of one god. and one day we must believe on that god that is real people call them in many great beautiful name but he is one.
Ur absolutely correct. The Quran,The Bible and The Vedas do tell us there is one God.
@@Carlhev right
Asalaamualaikum. We are living at a time where time is ticking fast. Music can lead to addiction. With that being said, it can then be very time consuming. And then you got sports broadcasted on television which is another time consumer. And then you got soaps, movies, media, gaming platforms, paying a visit to your friends/family, time spent at work, etc. My question is, how much time do we have remaining for our Deen?
Exactly! the quran should be the reason you love allah and the creation, and prayer and giving in charity, music does not benefit your islam, it does not bring reward, it doesnt help your body, and if anyone cclaims it helps the mind, then its clearly shaytan speaking because praying and reading quran is suppose to help the mind
@@emmyjannah what about music theraphy,lulabies
And we can also teach relgioun from music
Everyone is suddenly a psychologist and does exactly the same thing now, I guess.
MashaAllah Correct speech by Dr.Zakir Naik Sahab ♥️
#MashaAllah
ALLAH bless u #DR #ZAKIR #NAIK
U R OUR PROUD (REAL HERO)
PRoud to be a #MUSLIMAH
i read the comments and God, why so much hate people? just bcz your opinions differ doesn't mean you will say all these hateful things. For heaven's sake, show a little respect.
Hadiya ikr? And I’ve been literally there on every comment trying to defend my opinion like bruh?!
I understand that you probably hate Islam and Muslims but atleast as a human race, you can keep the comment section a bit dignified. Does it cost you?!
Monetizing youtube channel allowed in islam ??
Good question
The thing is music is in my head and I dont know what to do but to sing it dive me crazy trying to not song...😢
music is in nature... if allah created nature he created music ... so dont worry listen to music and also dance... dont follow muhammad just follow allah
@@superman5507 so the sounds nature makes ... birds that dance ... is it all saitan creation?
@@superman5507 i am not a muslim but but i believe in allah .. but i dont like muhammad he just used gods name for sexual desires and power desires
@@superman5507 that 2 days is just gap between extreme sexual pleasures he was having daily... he used to have sex with all his wives at one night one after another ... sometimes he used fuck ayesha and go for preaching with all sperm strains on his clothes.. ayesha used to stop him and clean that dirty shit on him...😷 such a shit man he is 🤦🏻♂️...that is why i am saying believe in allah is good but not in Muhammad
@@vikramssctelugu6148 prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H is mentioned in hindi scriptures and bible...Allay says in Quran that if you obey Prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H then it means that you obey Allah and if you disobey Prophet Muhammad P.B.U H then it means you disobey Allah ..prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H did everything with Allah 's command and prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H personality guide us in every aspect of life
and i dont know about the stain thing that you have said but if i generally speak will you intrude in your neighbours personal life that how many time does he and her wife do sex in a day ......you should find authentic reasons and dont use abusive language just clarify your confusions by asking politely
Dr Zakir used to be a person I loved to listen to when I first started my journey to Islam, but now I see how many times he singles out women as if these things that are prohibited are only prohibited for women. This kind of teaching really reminds me of the radicalized teachings that only poison the young Muslim minds and teaches them wrong. Although I still believe that he is very knowledgeable, at the same time he decided to follow a more radical path of faith that I disagree with.
czcams.com/video/YDrPbgE9h58/video.html hope this clears out for ya :)
I personally believe that he is poisoning Muslim minds as well. Music is not haram. These beliefs are crazy, people like this have fabricated so many lies and are brainwashing people. This person speaking out supports terrorist beliefs and as a result was banned in India. Is that Islam? No.
Razzak khan my point isn’t really about music being haram (obviously a song with a certain beat and dirty lyrics can’t be halal) but my problem with him is that he usually singles out women when he speaks about something haram... As if dancing isn’t prohibited to men also. I mean, it’s not only based on this video, I’ve been watching him for a while... although thanks for Mufti Menk 😀
@@muichiroutokito9159 No, the hadith he quoted is real. Music with instruments except the mentioned one is haram. He doesn't support terrorism and he always makes that clear. He is a representative of Islam if he uses correctly the Quran and hadith. We all know there's no substance behind his India ban.
Now I don't know if you genuinely want to learn about the religion or not. That's up to you. But let's try having an open mind to things.
He did give women as an example because of the modern day dance culture. What I mean is, dancing nowadays has really moved towards a direction of women exposing and shaking as much as possible. It's still haram for men, I think, but when dancing, a man's hijab is almost never really compromised.
With that being said, I do understand your concern to an extent but his teachings being of a radical nature? That I just don't see.
fist thing .... dancing doesn't meaning dancing on stage or performance....it's a way through we can relax our self or to feel comfortable.....even animal can also do...its a natural thing which nature or god have given us ...
apart from that dancing is very good for Heath ....
improved condition of your heart and lungs
increased muscular strength, endurance and motor fitness
increased aerobic fitness
improved muscle tone and strength
weight management
stronger bones and reduced risk of osteoporosis
better coordination, agility and flexibility
improved balance and spatial awareness
increased physical confidence
improved mental functioning
improved general and psychological wellbeing
greater self-confidence and self-esteem
better social skills.
so don't lesion to this people ..he is illiterate...he just make make people's fool ...
Chal be, woh prove ke sath sab bata ta hai Dr zakir, giving refresh is better then to blame anyone, this is what he does
Assalamualaikum I've got a question about music, is listening to classic music such as mozart or chaupin haram? Because this type of music is said by numerous psicologists is good.
no thats not haram inshaAllah...
Musical instruments are forbidden
from what i know, any kind of music, using musical instrument, is still haram. prophet muhammad (pbuh) said that zina and music's instrumental is haram. well, im not an syeikh so thats the only thing i know.
Lots of love and respect for you brother zakar
Sir...
I agree with you,
A blank minded person or say a zero situation is necessary to find our soul.
.
From past time it's seen that many kind of dance and music is there to show off body parts.
.
Now the mobile apps and websites are there to ruin the culture
What about belly dance ? it's an Arabic culture ?
you answered yourself :D, its an Arabic culture not muslims culture :D.
But not in islam, its start before the islam, now it is fully banned in arab.
Belly dance is inappropriate.
Music and dance are human nature. They exist in every single culture that has ever existed. To deny them is to deny humanity.
Islam is full of strange ideas. The prohibitions against music and dance are definitely strange--and disturbing. Music and dance are expressions of joy. The ayatollah Khomeini said, There is no fun in Islam. Fun is joy, happiness. Islam forbids these things? Wow, how sad. Peace, and joy, y'all.
Arabic culture doesn't mean Islamic culture.
There are even arab prostitutes are their, it doesn't mean Islam supports prostitution. Learn islam, not arabs or parkisthanis or iranis.
What about the music or lyrics that tells about life or gives us some insight about someone else's life or conditions that they are living in, and types of dances or mudras in dance that express the same thing.There are shades in everything ,everything has bad sides and good sides it's about taking the out the best and applying it in our life,as also said by Allah in Surah 39 verse 18.
Thanks.
Yesss i was wondering the same like their are some motivational songs which depressed people listen and makes them feel better.
Assalamualaikum my brother may you explain sarah 31_laqanda verse 6 to me its speaks about music on the note 161. I.e. that which has no benefit. Describe by different sahabah as shrik (associations with
Allah). Misleading stories frivolous songs, are music but includes all which distracts or divert one from the Qur'an and remembrance of Allah.
The man is just supernatural
Superanimal
Pls stop the 🧢
@@dunyamaharaj928 oh yes your mom
@@baadshah4718 watch your mouth, it's a haram
@@SonicVisualGR I know but I can’t swallow any bad words towards my beautiful Islam
And what about songs that represent deeper and important topics such as mental illness and loving yourself?
Too much entertainment is what you should avoid
That's it
rockingalvin2012 please have some respect and understand what you saying don't just throw words that is not true about Islam.
rockingalvin2012 If you’re not educated about islam then please keep your opinion to yourself
Those kind of concepts don't really exist objectively in Islam.
If you're following the Quran, you can be said to be loving yourself.
If you're following the Quran, you can be said to be free of mental issues.
That's the basic idea.
@Cherylxox
Islam does speak about serenity .
This is a quotation from Quran where it says in the remembrance of Allah do hearts find peace . For muslims , it’s an absolute truth .
Those who have believed and whose hearts are assured by the remembrance of Allah . Unquestionably, by the remembrance of Allah hearts are assured. Those who have believed and done righteous deeds - a good state is theirs and a good return.
Surah Ra’d Ayat 28-29
I wish I could ask Dr the question I have in my mind!!!
I think there is a divergence of openion between Muslim Scolars regarding listening and paying the musical instruments, some SCOLARS in Islam dont see any harm in listening to pure music like Mosar, bethoven, extra, even Music with singing is allowed in islam as long as the singing is not about drugs, alchool, sex, violence or any singing which go against the teaching if Islamic shariaa., also there is another condition to this permission is that listening to music should NOT make you forget your duties towards Allah and remembering him, like if you are busy listening to music all day long ( some work places ike warehouses factories, coffee shops, retailerss ) they play music and songs and songs all day long and everyday, and you forget about prayers time or remembring Allah an listening - reading Quran, in that situation this music and singing become a form of worship and replace the quran and makes you forget about Allah, in this situation this abuse of listening to music and songs becomes haram.. It is NOT the good music and the good singing which are Haram, but it is what type of music we listen to and the way we listen to it in our daily and social life, these factors can effect the good music and it beomes haram in islam.
same thing about dancing, families are allowed in islam to enjoy music, singing and dancing, no harm in that in Islam as long as we do it according to islamic laws.
Unforunately, there are few scholars in isalam are quit old fashion and very hard on their views
about music and singing and they put lof restrictions and haram about many things without having a solid prouf from the Quran and the teaching of prophet Muhamed Peace be upon him.
,
“Whoever says that all music is prohibited, let him also claim that the songs of the birds are prohibited”- Abu Hamed Al Gazzali
For the birds is their language but for humans is not a language but just for mere pleasure of saitan ,or are a bird?
facts
@John Calder dont disrespect religions i hope god guides u to the path of those he has favoured not of those who have evoked his anger
@John Calder bro, you can't give a competition here....we use quran as tissue paper...and
prophet (shit be upon him😂)
@John Calder don't disrespect others religion and believes plus don't talk about our MUHAMMAD (S.A.W ) IN that way .
Husband and Wife can Dance all they want in Privacy, where its only just the two of them.
Yes they call that the dance of death because if your caught your in big trouble
Dr Naik said that in the video
If I used soft music in my cooking video , is it haram as well ?
Only duff is allowed
Music has the power to unite humanity, breaking down barriers and reminding us of our shared humanity.
There are good things in music of course but it is better to abstain from it
Music is so beautiful even in the Bible it helped king Saul with his mental Illness
@@jorelletaylor5408 quran is better
@@jorelletaylor5408 religious tolerance ☪️✝️☮️✌️🕊️
@@bulldzr2601 hm, why is that 😮😮 it's a part of culture it ain't harming nobody
Send these people in 14th century.
Pretty much what ISIS is doing
Abe jaa pagal
Let us be as we want we don't want to bother you guys and don't bother us about the way we live. Thank you
@@RoronoaZoro-mw7wu you guys are disturbing 🙄 , I mean I hate islam , but today I know the islam(mental diseases) affected your brain with such stupidity,
@@yogiadityanath9354 you hating Islam doesn't matter. Cos y'all lack the brains to understand the wisdom behind such things.
So only y'all find it as a mental disease.
Why not cricket is haram which takes you away for hours cant understand logic of these jahil mullahs . My question is simple that what is the verse of Quran which prohibit music.
Whats the verse of quran which prohibits music.........None!
But,for the dancing part, when it is about singing nasheed, it is allowed even in front of other people as long as the hijab conditions (clothes,no makeup..)are respected right?And you said because we use our body to entertain it is haram but from hijab conditions ,the whole body is dissimilated so in that case we are dancing with nasheed,with no moves that can be "sexy" it just becomes an ensemble of moves with the nasheed and acapella And again since a hijabi can play sports in front of others for example ,dancing becomes halal right? I'm just saying what I think please correct me if I'm wrong.
How about if we have to dance at school?
Indian culture loves dancing,that must be one big reason that they don't get along very well with Muslims.
Music is prohibited because takes one away from God. It doesn't at all make you happy (only superficially). But true peace only comes from obeying Allah.
Imzy01
You only believe that because of pressure from you're community and the fact you were brought up to believe that,it's not true,music is good for you.
+rosie811honey Actually personally I was a huge music fan before. I have seen a huge difference in my spirituality when I stopped listening to music..just generally I felt at real tranquil peace that I hadn't felt before. Music takes a person away from reality especially when they get hooked on it, the moment they stop listening they feel they need it again.
Imzy01
I don't begrudge you what makes you happy,it's when it affects other people that it becomes a problem.
+Imzy01 u do know that science already proven music is good for u right?
a man without music is simply not a human being.
Exactly! I cant imagine my life without music
Yeah.
Bro in islam music is not haram but you also heard that some dirty dirty lyrics so these music are haram in islam not all music you might be understood what i'm trying to say..!!❣
Heh, RIGHT, so why music and dancing aren't still prohibited in islamic countries? There are many muslim musicians. What's the point here? Don't they believe in harmness of music & dancing to the society?
Mr Zakir I have a question this is urgent to me the question is can we do dancing by wearing cover and unfit dress And sing what is true I am asking this question cuz my dream depends on it pls I need the answer
Music , affects senses better than any art , Einstein loved Mozart's music
🤣👍🤣
@@toxickittygaming2519 I like Mozart and I am not Muslim... music is TIMELESS and Islam isn't... Islam will eventually collapse 🎵
Mash Allah chehray pay kitna noor hay .love u dr😍😍
By that logic any form of entertainment is wrong, reading, watching movies, playing outside.
I do agree with what the doctor says but I have a question and it wiykd mean a lot if one you guys answer this. So what about music with plain sound tracks such as electronic music which does nit include any instrument. What uc the electronic music has a few words such as "pump it up, you gotta pump it" pls answer both questions. I want to know the truth. Thank you
What if I listen to music but pray and do everything on time and do remembrance of Allah? Is it still haram? And why?
czcams.com/video/A8cFOShV4fw/video.html
czcams.com/video/ee6qv9oOkyA/video.html
czcams.com/video/KunLxP8ltBU/video.html
Brother please listen all these videos. And in place of music you hear Quran recitation it will definitely relax and calm your mind. Music is totally prohibited in Islam , music is a weapon of shyateen. I hope you understand.
@@amanmahmood1316 well I do not agree, on Balkan we have ilahije (islamic songs) and there are some musicians that do not inspire haram (like imagine dragons...), also there is no place in Quran that prohibits music... Dancing is stupid, but music helps me study, workout ect.
I am really glad to see this because it shows some attitudes that are common in Islam that many in the West do not realize. Singing, dancing are frequently seen as problem, notice the audience is mostly men and there is a women section. These are not "extreme" views. This is mainstream Islam.
My friend worked in war zones across the globe with the UN, Medicin Sans Frontiers and various other organisations. He said in each desperately tragic place, people found happiness and community through music and dance, except one place. The one place that he said was the most miserably awful, soulless and depressing place was Darfur. The people were strictly forbidden to sing and dance. They had nothing to connect their community except misery. He refers to it as the most miserable place he ever experienced. Shame on any culture that supresses a fundamental tool of actual human civilisation.
How about the songs like 25 rasul,10 malaikat,Allah made everything and tala al badru alayna songs? These are song and are bringing us closer to Allah right? I normally memorise the prophets and angels by using songs in this list. I am just a kid and curious.
Yes sure my brother/sister in Islam...A nasheed without music is permissible
This is not fair for women ... Rules should be made for both male and female ..
Not every muslims are following this. My muslim friends enjoy listening to kpop and dance. Even indian music composer AR Rahman also doenst follow this. As long as people are enjoying their lives n dont harm others, its ok for me.
I am muslim and I am the biggest fan of kpop