I have used this bag for the best part of 18 months now and I think its one of the best “personal bag” options. I have travelled on Wizz Air, Ryan Air, Virgin, BA and Austrian with no problems. I do find using packing cubes a good option and a Smart water fits perfectly in the water sleeve. 😊
@@jamesirvine711 Depends on the airline and the seat, but underpacked it should fit under the seat on most airlines. The bag is very soft and squishable.
Good morning! 🌞 Funny thing, I wasn't even shopping for lightweight duffle until you pulled this out to compare in your recent Katmandu Lighthall review. Over a lifetime of one bag travel, or at least the last decade or so, I tend to lean towards bags without too many "features" but with a greater volume. Not too many pockets, I don't need a pencil holder .. I use pouches and packing cubes so simple works for me. I also try not to pick a manufacturer and stick with it like I did with Timbuk2 when I lived in San Francisco, but I really like Osprey, even carrying the Aura65 on a portion of my last PCT. This lightweight might be my next train travel bag. When I think of the word cavernous I know I'm not going to fill it with heavy tech or heavy hiking boots and I tend to carry only a tablet in a padded case so that usually fits in right between large packing cubes and is properly cushioned. Interior tie downs work for this but but properly situated between cubes works too. I was seriously considering the Katmandoo and yes, they are entirely different bags, but I hated sacrificing so much carry volume for what is indeed a proper strap system. I gladly trade off more rugged straps for volume because I'm really looking at duffels that just get me through an airport or on and off a train. I have discovered that wearing a lightweight puffer vest when transferring from train or plane works for me because it additionally gives more padding and makes even a duffle more comfortable. Long-distance city treks or a trip to the Gobi desert would demand the better carry system but for short trips and cititravel I really like this! Maybe I need both!?! Well, at least I have you comparing these bags so that I can make a better choice.. Cheers!
You need both! Different bags for different trips. The Daylite is great for short trips, if you don't need to carry it much, or like you said if you have a jacket to give more padding. But not the best of you need to carry it around all day.
@@OneBagTravels at first I told myself I didn't need this one as I have a similar Peak Design 35l duffle .. it's sexy and has great rigidity but the the opening is just not as accessible as this suitcase opening. It is also best used with the pricey PD packing cubes and interior is dark whereas the Osprey lets so much light in and the interior colours are best for finding items. I'll use the PD for camera gear. Obviously I have a travel bag addiction, and I probably will get both.. the only reason I hesitated is the Katmandu LH is not available in person here in Seattle and I want to make sure it fits my frame... as far as this Osprey - thanks for the affiliate link!
@@OneBagTravels I did not know that you were the Southern Oregon! I think the only time I've watched one of your videos on site was a trip you took to California. Doesn't the PNW just beg for a good trip to see the west of the USA! I lived in a San Francisco for years as I did a lot of travel to Asia during that time, I really didn't investigate the west except for Tahoe and Yosemite .. when I got back to the US in 2016 I was astounded of so much beauty in the PNW .. I'd only seen segments on my PCT in 2012. I summited both Mt Hood and Mt Adams and was aiming for either Mt Rainier or Mt Saint Helens... First the world fell apart and then my world fell apart .. For the past year I've been dealing with a medical situation and to get through it I've been planning a train trip in my mind. Years ago it my second year at Northwestern University I grabbed a few friends and we crossed the US on Amtrak; Chicago to Seattle, down the coast to LA and returning to continue on to NYC. I've always wanted to revisit that trip but as it takes 3 days just in the coast to coast crossing it was going to take a bit of time. If I'm able to with this health situation I plan to take advantage of multi-trip Amtrak rail passes for another cross-country trek... hence the interest in a good size duffle, as of course every type of trip demands a new bag purchase! 🤔🤷♀️😆
@@IntriguedLioness I was in SoCal before this and moved to the PNW last year. It's so pretty, so much to do an explore. That train trip sounds awesome, I hope you feel better soon so you can go on another adventure 😊
Good question, I haven't tested the Migrate Duffel. They look similar though, simple duffel with large opening and thin minimal straps. Opening is different, Daylite has a side lid, Migrate has a long zipper.
If you can pack small enough to fit in 30 L then yes this bag will work, my only criticism is the shoulder straps are rather small and thin, so it could get uncomfortable if you're carrying it around like a backpack all day
I'm not sure such a bag exists 😆 But the Porter is the closest I can think of. Not a true duffel, but big panel opening is basically a duffel. Laptop compartment, awesome compression straps, and backpack carry.
Check out the Osprey Arcane Duffel if you have not already! It doesn’t have compression straps but it has a lot going for it and it’s lightweight. It has a dedicated laptop compartment, very decent harness system with hideaway shoulder straps and comfortable back panel, and comes with a detachable duffel strap too. It’s one of the best backpack/duffle bags I’ve seen with laptops in mind. If you’re open to other brands, also check out the Patagonia Mini MLC another great bag!
I have used this bag for the best part of 18 months now and I think its one of the best “personal bag” options. I have travelled on Wizz Air, Ryan Air, Virgin, BA and Austrian with no problems. I do find using packing cubes a good option and a Smart water fits perfectly in the water sleeve. 😊
I use it as my gym bag =)
Is it not way too big when full to fit under the seat? Or do you use it less than full?
@@jamesirvine711 Depends on the airline and the seat, but underpacked it should fit under the seat on most airlines. The bag is very soft and squishable.
Thanks! Very thorough review, and excellent balance of criticisms with the bag's strong points. (Was hard to find a review that did both well!)
Thanks! I've been using it mostly as a gym duffel.
A real review, thank you. Ive been searching to try and find out if the zips were lockable…. Only this review told me. Shame on Osprey
Osprey has the worst pics and descriptions, but good for reviewers like me 😃
So it works as a “underseater”! Thx for the information
It's pretty tight for under the seat, but it's soft so can squish easily.
Very helpful review. Thanks!
Good morning! 🌞 Funny thing, I wasn't even shopping for lightweight duffle until you pulled this out to compare in your recent Katmandu Lighthall review.
Over a lifetime of one bag travel, or at least the last decade or so, I tend to lean towards bags without too many "features" but with a greater volume. Not too many pockets, I don't need a pencil holder .. I use pouches and packing cubes so simple works for me. I also try not to pick a manufacturer and stick with it like I did with Timbuk2 when I lived in San Francisco, but I really like Osprey, even carrying the Aura65 on a portion of my last PCT.
This lightweight might be my next train travel bag. When I think of the word cavernous I know I'm not going to fill it with heavy tech or heavy hiking boots and I tend to carry only a tablet in a padded case so that usually fits in right between large packing cubes and is properly cushioned. Interior tie downs work for this but but properly situated between cubes works too.
I was seriously considering the Katmandoo and yes, they are entirely different bags, but I hated sacrificing so much carry volume for what is indeed a proper strap system. I gladly trade off more rugged straps for volume because I'm really looking at duffels that just get me through an airport or on and off a train.
I have discovered that wearing a lightweight puffer vest when transferring from train or plane works for me because it additionally gives more padding and makes even a duffle more comfortable. Long-distance city treks or a trip to the Gobi desert would demand the better carry system but for short trips and cititravel I really like this!
Maybe I need both!?! Well, at least I have you comparing these bags so that I can make a better choice.. Cheers!
You need both! Different bags for different trips. The Daylite is great for short trips, if you don't need to carry it much, or like you said if you have a jacket to give more padding. But not the best of you need to carry it around all day.
@@OneBagTravels at first I told myself I didn't need this one as I have a similar Peak Design 35l duffle .. it's sexy and has great rigidity but the the opening is just not as accessible as this suitcase opening. It is also best used with the pricey PD packing cubes and interior is dark whereas the Osprey lets so much light in and the interior colours are best for finding items. I'll use the PD for camera gear.
Obviously I have a travel bag addiction, and I probably will get both.. the only reason I hesitated is the Katmandu LH is not available in person here in Seattle and I want to make sure it fits my frame... as far as this Osprey - thanks for the affiliate link!
@@IntriguedLioness Osprey would make a great train bag. Seattle isn't too far from me, you know I'm in southern Oregon?
@@OneBagTravels I did not know that you were the Southern Oregon! I think the only time I've watched one of your videos on site was a trip you took to California. Doesn't the PNW just beg for a good trip to see the west of the USA! I lived in a San Francisco for years as I did a lot of travel to Asia during that time, I really didn't investigate the west except for Tahoe and Yosemite .. when I got back to the US in 2016 I was astounded of so much beauty in the PNW .. I'd only seen segments on my PCT in 2012. I summited both Mt Hood and Mt Adams and was aiming for either Mt Rainier or Mt Saint Helens... First the world fell apart and then my world fell apart ..
For the past year I've been dealing with a medical situation and to get through it I've been planning a train trip in my mind. Years ago it my second year at Northwestern University I grabbed a few friends and we crossed the US on Amtrak; Chicago to Seattle, down the coast to LA and returning to continue on to NYC. I've always wanted to revisit that trip but as it takes 3 days just in the coast to coast crossing it was going to take a bit of time. If I'm able to with this health situation I plan to take advantage of multi-trip Amtrak rail passes for another cross-country trek...
hence the interest in a good size duffle, as of course every type of trip demands a new bag purchase! 🤔🤷♀️😆
@@IntriguedLioness I was in SoCal before this and moved to the PNW last year. It's so pretty, so much to do an explore. That train trip sounds awesome, I hope you feel better soon so you can go on another adventure 😊
Review didn't cover water resistance or anything. I guess by omission, can i assume it doesn't have that feature? Oh well
Yeah, this bag isn't really waterproof at all.
the weight? (THANKS for sya the centimeters)!
I don't always say everything in metric but I put it in the description. Weight is 0.55 kg.
I have it on 60L, Is great bag.
How's the backpack carry on the 60L, are the straps bigger?
How does this compare to the Eagle Creek migrate duffel?
Good question, I haven't tested the Migrate Duffel. They look similar though, simple duffel with large opening and thin minimal straps. Opening is different, Daylite has a side lid, Migrate has a long zipper.
@@OneBagTravels both are the same price but I think the Eagle Creek uses stronger materials.
Do you recommend this bag for 1 week trip? Thanks.
If you can pack small enough to fit in 30 L then yes this bag will work, my only criticism is the shoulder straps are rather small and thin, so it could get uncomfortable if you're carrying it around like a backpack all day
Which osprey bag would you recommend that has a laptop slot and compression straps that would work as duffel and converts to backpack? Thanks!
I'm not sure such a bag exists 😆 But the Porter is the closest I can think of. Not a true duffel, but big panel opening is basically a duffel. Laptop compartment, awesome compression straps, and backpack carry.
@@OneBagTravels thanks! love your vids
Check out the Osprey Arcane Duffel if you have not already! It doesn’t have compression straps but it has a lot going for it and it’s lightweight. It has a dedicated laptop compartment, very decent harness system with hideaway shoulder straps and comfortable back panel, and comes with a detachable duffel strap too. It’s one of the best backpack/duffle bags I’ve seen with laptops in mind. If you’re open to other brands, also check out the Patagonia Mini MLC another great bag!
@@stefanluciaan Great suggestions, I've tried the Arcane, great bag. I have yet to test the Mini MLC but it's on the top of my list!