What is TMC doing right now? Handing over revolvers to local goons and making the state more prone to poverty. Look at the recruitment to State PSCs and the recruitment of teachers you will get the result in your hand. The leaders are not letting the administrative to functioning according to the norms. They are Orang Utangs in clothes.
Raising voice for adivasi, doesn't mean supporting cpi or cpm ... She is simply saying that do something for marginalize people ... No matter of what party or ideology u belong
Jab kisi bat ka pata na ho to bolte nhi hain... Now these days indians are thinking that they r like Americans Europe . Who u r? India was never ever as a one country..
@@sadiyasineen5893 lol.....keep telling yourself that...everyone knows what happened during that time...and why it happened...it's all out there...go look it up....
@@sadiyasineen5893 Try to accept the truth. Ever heard of the Nizam's army which was there in Hyderabad. And which committed serious atrocities on Non-Muslim people?
"India has fought its own people the moment India became an independent country...in Goa." Are you seriously suggesting that kicking out Portuguese imperialists amounted to fighting its own people?
Oriental Despot It was a Christian Crusade Happening in Goa and 1000 years of foreign oppression Genocides resulting in Deaths of zillions is the very same people who Susaana is Talking about. she is extremely dangerous and conniving Sociologist in the garb of a liberal intellectual.
I have not been a great fan of Arundhati Roy. But if you listen carefully to what she says in this conversation, she is right. Democracy works mostly in urban areas and that too for the well connected in India. For tribals in states like Chatthisgarh, Jharkand, they do not care about democracy as living is an ordeal for them. When the benefits and produce of the their land are supposed to go to them according to law, state governments collaborate with industrialists and mine owners and the tribals are left with nothing. What do you do in that scenario? A good example is how the BJP government has changed and influenced every democratic institution in India in the past two years. Our concept of free media is a farce. And forget the BJP, even the congress would have done it if in power. It is important to realise this and ask questions and think logically instead of running after fallacies like nationalism and historical legacy which do not contribute in any way if you do not have two square meals.
She didn't answer any of the question! Salwa Judum was started by the govt and the local tribes contributed a lot and helped the govt. to fight naxalism
And notice- how Power of Tata/Godrej has become less- And Ambani's has become more. Indira Gandhi helped Ambani's ( Banias)-- herself a Brahmin woman--- and brought Parsi Industrialists down.
She is a christian and she hates hindu. She doesnt say these groups who indulged in violence . As she criticises india and wants it to be broken. She is lying about tribals. The biggest center of naxal is in abujhmad where there are no mines. Since she is rejected outright by Indians thats why she goes and speak out side india. One big critic of PM, Ramchandra Guha has bared her lies.
I agree the confusion of whom to support but even early man had tools and using them is fine. Devoid of the present day tools would be foolish in all aspects.
You must be a cow born. Apple isn't a capitalist firm, its a technology driven modern company that makes money from its ideas not leveraging the capital. A capitalist company is Reliance because Ambani has no clue about oil chemistry, he invested money in Reliance which is nothing but a flour mill.
Gurinder Singh sir i am a materials scientist doing a research on where apple gets its materials from for making it phones...you have no idea the extent of damage and destruction it causes in africa.. go and search about coltan... if that guy is a cow born then you are an ignorant buffoon...
@@gurindersingh8109 Gurinder Singh Yes you old fool, its just a Public Enterprise running on the principle of No Profit No Loss; You could even ask for a free iPhone when the next edition comes out and if we go by your definition it is nothing but a 'public good'. Ask yourself, are ideas and innovation placed in public domain or patented?
No..the msg is clear that bash India..bash Indian culture.. bash Hindus on foreign land....try with all strength to derail India from all it's developmental programs...sit with and support separatist elements in Kashmir...Justify all other, Maoist like, terrorist....Not to criticize Islamic terrorism...Not to lead a movement against Christian missionaries who are converting gullible Hindus in villages by using money, propaganda and other temptation... Talking of poor of India all over the world and doing nothing....
I love listening to Ms.Roy. Her barbs make we hindus look like strong, cold and calculated imperialists. She makes us look 1000x times strong than we actually are. Thanks Ms.Roy. You have boosted our confidence and delivered some good comedy.
Roy isn't attacking individual hindus. She's outlining a capitalist and oppressive state that privileges upper caste hindus who have used that system to their advantage. She is also using facts to back up her statements. Don't be so dismissive of what she has to say, just because you can't see your own privilege. Also, if you reply to me, i don't want to hear about hoe hard your life is, how you've struggled etc. Like I said, this isn't about one person. It's about a government that is more concerned with maintaining their own power than helping its citizens.
@@amygill3218 Hey Don't talk as if you know everything about India. You don't know what Hinduism means. 1. 70% of the leaders in India are not "Upper cast ppl". 2. Tata and Godrej are not hindus they are Parsi 3. That Bitch eats in india and shits in US. You ppl are behind that shit. 4. We are the oldest surviving Civilizations in the world & And continue to do so. 5. Do you fake feminist talk about Saudi Arabia 's oppressive regime over Women ???
Arundhati Roy can't be more irrational. She brands Indian Army as Hindu Upper Cast force victimizing the minorities and tribals. It's a fact that Indian Army has a large section which comes from tribals(from Jharkhand, Terai region, Telangana) and religious minority as Sikhs. Her distortion of facts are reaching astounding heights!
Well Amith, the discussion in this section is about 10 min clip and I would appreciate if you send me the link to the complete video. However it makes more sense to base the discussion on the answers she gave and not on prequel or sequel. Quoting her exact words "an upper caste stake", which brings to two conclusions "an upper caste stake" in deployment of army(which you said) or "upper caste stake" in terms of numerical strength(which I concluded). I know this gives you all the more reasons to pester me to read her essays which I doubt I would, don't you think somewhere that criticizing our Government is not the way forward? Certainly we are not the children born in utopia and our leaders have not been the enlightened ones, yet it is more important to give away our cynicism and skepticism and look at the systematic problems that have happened because of mismanagement and not because of some nefarious motives. Won't you urge Arundhati to come over the negativity and apprehension and play a more decisive than divisive stand for betterment of millions of underprivileged people who come from all castes, communities and regions of India.
My bad! I find that mentioning "upper caste" is certainly divisive. I find mentioning "Hindu" is divisive. As I mentioned before, the problems she has mentioned are not because of "upper caste" or "Hindu" but systematic mismanagement of resources by our leaders who have happened to be from all religions and social strata. I don't know if her mention of "upper caste", "Hindu" has a broader interpretation, but her crucifying "upper caste", "Hindu" is divisive.
There was verna system in india , it is true that it was manipulated later but these were fault line the big gaps came during foreign rule . They wanted to break and convert india . There were always movements from with in the society and amazing personalities like swami dayanand saraswati , what a great influence he is and founder of arya samaj .The change came from within and he was never a preacher of hate but wanted to remove wrong practice. The teachings of arya samaj are great force to remove caste system . It would have been great work had she contributed to it spreading the message . but being a christian she did not . It is also important to study history of christianity , its realities( it is now believed that jesus was a fictional character, and many stories were planted across the world) . Vedic knowledge is the knowledge that has influenced many civilizations in the past and were following vedic culture . Spritual knowledge , yoga traditions . People should know what is going on and should realise how spiritual knowledge and traditions in hinduism( images of gods) is related to yoga .( chakras and all) .
Narayan, Arundhati is an intellectual who has put forth the unfair grip of the high caste hindus over the national resources. The sections of army-men those come from tribals are primarily low level sepoys and they work under commands that originate from the very senoir officers who are again high caste hindus. Moreover, the role of these tribal or other soldiers of army, is very mechanical, just to carry out orders, no room for personal decisions.
+bharat vaasi but why have we carried on this pathetic concept of martial race even today in the army?.?. The airforce and navy doesn't have it. It's utterly pathetic and messed up..its sadly legitimising the concept of upper caste hegemony. and before u call me unpatriotic...I just cleared my cdse exam..my ssb is in may. future army guy here.
You need to educate you on why temples are like that. Who can manage temples? You are also forgetting how just till few decades back temples managed by privileged castes were barring entry to dalit people. You want a repeat? Even temples in bjp run states are like that. Why not show that new model in bjp governed States instead of using this template to sow hatred and discredit Indian laws.
And she does not name Pranoy Roy. The biggest Media manipulator in India. Ha... Police had 50%reservations for non upper castes , and she has gumption to lie straight through the cheeks!
The issues that arundhati has been addressing is no more a piece of concern in india... India has moved far away from those things.. She is just repeating the lines of different books that she has read and the interesting thing is dat those writers are also kind of comrades ...
As a christian, India is a great country that respect all religions even those of the minorites. My relatives in India are mainly christians and are proud of their country and the government that has recently brought out tremendous developments.
Seeing so many comments just criticizing her makes it evident that none of these people understand what she is saying or why. And the fact that she said this in 2011 is astonishing. For today, with BJP in power and it's working and it's romantic relationships with the corporates, like the Ambanis is so so evident! Let me break it down to you in very simple manner how *"HINDU CORPORATE STATE"* is a real thing and bigger than ever: 1. HINDU -- Because BJP is in power right now and whose prime mandate for elections is only and only Hindi Rashtra and Ram Mandir. And to not overlook that it's the child of RSS, which, if you'd only know, is as pro-Hindu as it can get! 2. CORPORATE -- Because if you can't simply understand the romantic relationships and the favorism that the current government has with the big Corporate boys such as Ambanis, then I don't know what will make you understand this! These corporate fellows will always be major part of Indian politics (which is not very surprising but very much normal to me) just like it happens all over the world. From where does the parties get money when they are not in power?
if what u believe is true then She is someone who can see the future... because 2014 is the first time in the history when the country gave a mandate this huge! Before 2014 began how could India have been The "HINDU CORPORATE STATE" that you fear so much...
Salok singh communist played dirty game twice once in 1985 as said by dalit activist and last year in bhimakhogaon where all men with pen are dangerous them men with guns proves all under scanner URBAn NAXAL ......
@Agnish Roy Oligarchs are found in communist backed countries.. Free market promotes wealth making for everyone through hard work and monetizing ideas.. How come India has oligarchs? BTW India has federal structure where states have the freedom like US.. If India would not have been a federal structure how come people of different states , caste , creed , religion are able to preserve their identity , language , literature.. Do you even know what you are talking about?...lol
@@VV-lq4di You are probably the type that posts comments that neither support or oppose the argument but plainly judges people in a derogatory tone. Have a good day!
She is a good role model for those who sit and do nothing , but moaning about the system, while enjoying the good benefits the same system provides.She is a good role model for those who don't take responsibilities to change the system in a manner in which they want to change , but sitting and discussing endlessly about how bad it is. All I can see is her sweet voice and good english with void meaning. She is not providing any real solution because giving solution to a problem is more difficult than raising a problem. She blames democracy in India and then she says China is more worse. Corporate power is not just in India, but it is also in the west (yes she admitted it) . We can easily see how corporate giants swept away the business of millions Americans and Europeans. Do she propose a model like communist group dictator China? NO. Or like Arab or North Korean dictator family rules? NO. Those are all worst. Basically her IDEAL world is not possible in earth, as nature itself follows Pareto rule. Tatas are not Hindus by the way, they are Zoroastrians, a persecuted religion in the middle east Islamic countries. I know she will not mention this, because if she did, then she will lose a large fan base.
***** No. No. No. No killing at all. I think something went wrong in the puberty of males where their thinking gets tangled and twisted. We must not use force as a means of control. The mere idea of controlling someone other than self is an aberration of humanity. Yes you are correct about the West it is almost totally screwed. A very small crack of light can be seen however. I believe it will be that we will defang male rule and be guided by women for the next ten years, till the earth is cleaned up, till happiness sings in the hearts of all and till we construct a method through the use of the internet where everyone can represent themselves on any issue and no longer will a head of state be able to thrash the population with their puerile whims. This is called a womens' council and it is being developed now and it is beautiful. Because we all are beautiful and we should only accept that which touches our heart in a beautiful way. Imagine living in such an atmosphere!
+Denise Ward At least we men settle our differences even if its by killing each other. It's better than hating, gossiping , foul mouthing each other for life and beyond. lol
+arbaaz9044 You know the fact that you think it's better says a lot about your condition. Who in their right mind would stop someone from getting an education? Men did that to women (and still do in some parts) and they did it systematically. Now that speaks volumes about the kind of thinking in the male cranium. Oops, I just saw the LOL part.
+Noble Intellect Ok let's look at that. It infers that women are responsible for mens actions which is drivel. We're all responsible for our own actions. Those who give the orders are not the culpable ones, it is those who carry out the deed. There can be no dodging that. We have to, as individuals, carry the responsibility of what deeds we perform and what we support with our money or our labors. How can it be any other way and make sense? We cannot blame another's rule-making on our carrying out those rules or orders. Personal responsibility means also that we have power and can change things. But if we feel we are the victim of someone else's pressure, then we fail to grow up and we remain "rudimentary".
***** Thugs like Modi right? And what would you say about the systematic genocide which took place in New Delhi in 1984 against the Sikhs. When during the riots a congress worker screams (while looking at a sikh child)..."yeh saap ka bachcha hai , ise bhi maro".....What about the comments made by Rajiv Gandhi during the riots that "When a big tree falls, the earth shakes"?.....And what about the ethnic cleansing which took place in Jammu when thousands of Kashmiri Pandits were forced to leave their homes....What about the poor security forces who gets butchered by the Maoist rebels?....Are they saints??....
Shiva purana chapter 12: when shiva saw women starters misturabating , hindu priest gave him curse and his penis was cut cut down and it’s now known as shivalinga
Somebody is crediting themselves for being able to see through the intellectually complex things!!! But I wonder how come they can't see a simple thing that every free nation state shall fight the threats to it's integrity either internal or external. And fighting the 'insurgency with perceived narrow idealogy' in the interest of larger national cause is very much justifiable.
"The government ran public companies and the country into bankruptcy." Wrong. For public companies, if you exclude the "sick" companies that the Indian government routinely bought off the rich prior to 1991, public companies were only 1-2 percent less profitable per-capital employed than their private counterparts, and this was in the 80s when much of the permit-raj restrictions had been removed.
Roy you are factually incorrect when you mention Goa, Punjab. Problem is you don't work on ground, all you do is write for elites who are obsessed with the idea of sounding different. Also you bother only about Royalty, not at all about Emancipation of the masses.
What was that awesome question?.. He was supporting corporates manipulating tribal areas with support of govt. ..... Stop being flaunted by a person speaking english
This media is as biased as mainstream media. I'm a liberal saying that. Leftism isn't liberalism as many Indians think. Why does BJP win 2014 and 19? Because of their neo-liberal ideology (free market economy) and not because of radical supporters. You can't call yourself liberal if you hate neo-liberalism or libertarianism or capitalism
Islamic terrorism is nowhere near to corporates. A religion(?) which gets offended just by a caricature must investigate its doctrine . Indian moderate Muslims never truly condemned islamic terrorism, also boycotted Macron and supported france history teacher killing. True ,real and horrifying face of Islam and pseudo secularism got exposed all over the world. Western and European countries too getting taste of Peaceful religion
Mind of every individual is different and it can't be helped.... Has an idea of idealism... Good, one can think so... Yes, certain things can disturb, different people differently... No way... No escape ways.. Having born... Being around, bearing is inevitable... Milton, don't know whether desperately said ; " They also serve, who only stand and wait ".. Humble pardon will go a long way🙏
What you accept Arundhati 80% people are Hindu. And what you are Saying, giving one sided pictures of India. I have so many things to contradict your lecture. Some stories could be right, but not absolutely everything is correct. You are misleading people out side INDIA.
it was answered equally well I have no clue why people get so offended by different opinions and perspectives they behave as if their lives depend on the way they think
MK Dhar was senior IB officer working as press reporter for Hindustan Times during militancy in Punjab ! He had also admitted that there was "killing squad" and he was not part of it. Let Govt release all confidential papers about Punjab/Sikhs now that 30 years have been completed and Secret Act no longer applies.
This chap asked a good question and the mob mentality of this sick people is repulsive. Shouting people down is not how you argue. Well it is how these people argue.
We are not expecting any support from caste ridden Hindu radical ideologies and their slaves . Since world knows what she is doing and we know how to defeat anti Indian rss radicals and their supporters. Downfall of this radical rss ideology have started already.
@@vijayadeva06 am not rsd nationalist And nationalists and leftist are just collectivist brothers so keep fighting u both are wrong eventually. And fall? Communism has completely fallen so what are you talking about
@@yydd4954 what a silly and cheap way of thinking you have 🤣 and I am not expecting any good virtues or traits from the supporter of rss who are definitely a fascist and caste ridden pigs👈🏽. If you have tiny fraction of common sense then you would have understood her stand 👈🏽😎
she is saying everything correct....but nobody will support her because she is fighting for them who r dying from hunger,poverty and inequality....they dont even know she is fighting for them....
She is fighting for a foriegn agency so that Infia fights in between. She is doing nothing for poor. She is visiting foreign countries and getting paid for that.
The points about violence against tribals and forcibly taking away their land is true and it has been the same ever since British Raj's Indian Forest Act 1884. However, its a bit simplistic to say that it is a totalitarian Hindu state because thankfully at the moment its not. However, there is that risk with certain parties that they will try to impose their narrow religious conception on the diverse population and that might ultimately lead to greater violence and fragmentation of Indian society.
Genuinely answered. Very simple why the Major political parties exactly disclose the funding sources, and how they could manage financially such a marathon exercise of campaign while mo individual member of any party pay subscription out his or her own pocket.
You are great to expose the true pictures of our state and its democratic set-up but it is difficult to change the situation as the fanaticism is growing faster now. Anyway we have to do something to check this trend. Your work is commendable. Hoping for the better.
India is a corporate Hindu state? We will take that. Socialism has failed, and Non Hindus have ruled India for too long! We need a natural democracy that serves the majority. We know that minorities in India are safe and prospering unlike India's neighbors! Arundhati Roy has a right to talk freely, she won't be in Pakistan. Water is elixir of life, without which we parish! I have no Idea why these guys get so much attention.
Give out a Booker prize, Nobel prize, High prices for mediocre-paintings/art-movies, and get the "eminent" personalities of India to do a saboteur's job at low risk & high efficiency ! We are wise to it now, firangis ! We treat these Jonahs with the contempt they deserve.
In a very direct or nuanced way, I can uncompromisingly say that Arundhati Roy thrives on the oxygen of publicity she gets. People in India have this inveterate habit of treating every other person with a decent vocabulary as a public intellectual. I did accept her criticism if she had not used aberrations in society to pass sweeping generalisations about the whole country. She exclaims that India is a corporate upper caste construct....how fashionable !! Since the dawn of the country in 1947 until its rebirth in 1991, India was a borderline communist state which had made it a policy to exclude private and individual enterprise. People like her bask in dividends of economic growth and are equally disingenuous while criticising the same.
@5:17 Punjab, Hydrabad, Nagaland, Mizo were controlled by Indian Government. They were all tribal or Christens! What can be more lie then this? Hydrabad, Punjab - no tribal or Christens! Because of Punjab was divided into two countries there was mass killing and Government had to step in. Nizam of Hydrabad after independence from Briton wanted separate Muslim state and Govt had to step in. Mizo and Nagaland has tribal people. They were not Christen. Missionaries invaded this reign, later Maoist took over this land under support by Mao in China started riots and Govt had to step in. China is doing same thing in Ughar. Anyone criticize Chinese Prime Minister, the Chinese military steps in to take control!
Roy partly belongs to Kerala where the so-called upper castes are starving and the so-called lower castes have a very good time. Here the laborer decides the wages and not the farmer etc.
I some how try to contradict Arundathi Roy but am unable to. As I am convinced from her speech that Democrsy is for only few. Still I think she speaks only one side of the coin.
@@sanhithareddy9571 thats a propaganda not a film! but i also agree that kashmir incident did happen and that has to be known but not from any such movie but from scholars and academicians
I loved the conversation, but the title of this Post ie. RADICAL CONVERSATION is too extreme in todays world. Would you please change it to something softer ie. KILLING TRUTH/SWANSONG OF INDIAN DEMOCRACY etc.
Couple of points are right like long time neglect of interior/ remote areas, but since she & her supporters implicitly justify violence by these people in return, their cause & means lose respectability. She should know Indian media is more controlled by Left than Hindu-Right or others quite evident in any case of rape or murder where victim happens to be Dalit splashed as deliberate case of Dalit-oppression. Any anti-majoritarian disinformation campaigning leftist & atheist is proclaimed as a "rationalist". Beef-ban is used as an opportunity by fanboys to provoke insult & ridicule vegetarians (who are mostly Jains & upper-Hindus). Hateful people much less for secretly against India here but for genocidal-level venomous hatred against certain religion, castes & groups are attempted to be promoted as national martyrs/ heroes (just for that). And India is comparatively newly freed, huge developing nation with very big population, there's bound to be a lot of problems, confusion, complaints & mess before it climbs its way to peace & prosperity. The way you promote & want disintegration of it in name of freedom for every single thing it can only get fragmented into a catastrophic civil war before some kind of Armageddon which is what you want.
@Electroweak Epoch so you want a civil war in India? You'd rather enjoy watching millions dying only for your belief that Brahmins & rajputs are ruling the country (which they are not, many at top including President & PM are from other castes). See it's people like you who are the biggest & more direct threat right now, because you propound your beliefs as facts and support violence & killings and targetting whole communities in order to achieve your objective, which is total control.
Baki sab to theek tha lekin Hindu corporate state and Kashmir are different issues ,lekin ye aurat Yaha mulloke gunahoko najar andaj karke uppercaste hinduvoke gunaho ko highlight karrahi hai , ye Sahi nahi laga
In West Bengal they were in power for 34 years.... but have done nothing for adivasi people. Instead of giving food they have given AK-47.
What is TMC doing right now? Handing over revolvers to local goons and making the state more prone to poverty. Look at the recruitment to State PSCs and the recruitment of teachers you will get the result in your hand. The leaders are not letting the administrative to functioning according to the norms. They are Orang Utangs in clothes.
WATCH THE FILM .....BUDDHA IN A TRAFFIC JAM
Raising voice for adivasi, doesn't mean supporting cpi or cpm ... She is simply saying that do something for marginalize people ... No matter of what party or ideology u belong
Jab kisi bat ka pata na ho to bolte nhi hain...
Now these days indians are thinking that they r like Americans Europe .
Who u r?
India was never ever as a one country..
@ur calpal do you have any proof ???
We, the Telangana and Hyderabad people invited the Indian Army to save our lives from cruel Nizam and his Razakars.
Nizam was a very kind hearted nawab he wasn't cruel.you are lying.
@@sadiyasineen5893 lol.....keep telling yourself that...everyone knows what happened during that time...and why it happened...it's all out there...go look it up....
@@sadiyasineen5893 Try to accept the truth. Ever heard of the Nizam's army which was there in Hyderabad. And which committed serious atrocities on Non-Muslim people?
Marathas finished Nizam... you forgot
@@sadiyasineen5893 lol kuch bi
"India has fought its own people the moment India became an independent country...in Goa."
Are you seriously suggesting that kicking out Portuguese imperialists amounted to fighting its own people?
Oriental Despot Goa was far better off with the Portuguese
@@trickshotmonkey patram tuka goachi history khabar asa re???
@@ri3282
yes.
just look at many native goans wit Portuguese names... how happens that is anybodys guess.
Oriental Despot It was a Christian Crusade Happening in Goa and 1000 years of foreign oppression Genocides resulting in Deaths of zillions is the very same people who Susaana is Talking about. she is extremely dangerous and conniving Sociologist in the garb of a liberal intellectual.
I think she means Goan Opinion poll where Goa fought to be a state?
I have not been a great fan of Arundhati Roy. But if you listen carefully to what she says in this conversation, she is right. Democracy works mostly in urban areas and that too for the well connected in India. For tribals in states like Chatthisgarh, Jharkand, they do not care about democracy as living is an ordeal for them. When the benefits and produce of the their land are supposed to go to them according to law, state governments collaborate with industrialists and mine owners and the tribals are left with nothing. What do you do in that scenario? A good example is how the BJP government has changed and influenced every democratic institution in India in the past two years. Our concept of free media is a farce. And forget the BJP, even the congress would have done it if in power. It is important to realise this and ask questions and think logically instead of running after fallacies like nationalism and historical legacy which do not contribute in any way if you do not have two square meals.
the eye sees middle aged people. the mind sees rebel teenagers
She didn't answer any of the question!
Salwa Judum was started by the govt and the local tribes contributed a lot and helped the govt. to fight naxalism
Do u know tribals are killed in the name of naxlism.theyvwere killed buy English withe collobration of Hindu upper caste .go through histroy
She can't, it requires integrity .... honesty...
@@vijaydeshpande6348 she has more in her finger than all of BJP
Local Kashmiri also help perish Hindutva in Kashmir valley in 1990
@@bheemkabir5736 local gujrati also help in perish in Islamists in 2002
Her talks resembles me listening to Barber shop and tea shop talks 30 years ago in Kerala villages while they wait for the service to kill time.
Tata, godrej not even Hindus!!
even premji isn't a hindu.
And notice- how Power of Tata/Godrej has become less- And Ambani's has become more. Indira Gandhi helped Ambani's ( Banias)-- herself a Brahmin woman--- and brought Parsi Industrialists down.
Caste system sucks and these right wing Hindu illiterates will make sure Hindus dont end that in India. what a pitty.
They have been co-opted in the upper caste structure and re-inforces it. It is a state of mind.
She is a christian and she hates hindu. She doesnt say these groups who indulged in violence . As she criticises india and wants it to be broken.
She is lying about tribals. The biggest center of naxal is in abujhmad where there are no mines.
Since she is rejected outright by Indians thats why she goes and speak out side india.
One big critic of PM, Ramchandra Guha has bared her lies.
seating in AC room using apple mobile. & talking about capitalism.
I agree the confusion of whom to support but even early man had tools and using them is fine. Devoid of the present day tools would be foolish in all aspects.
Very premilinary understanding of capitalism you have bro...dont differentiate the socialist and capitalist on basis of ac and iphone
You must be a cow born. Apple isn't a capitalist firm, its a technology driven modern company that makes money from its ideas not leveraging the capital. A capitalist company is Reliance because Ambani has no clue about oil chemistry, he invested money in Reliance which is nothing but a flour mill.
Gurinder Singh sir i am a materials scientist doing a research on where apple gets its materials from for making it phones...you have no idea the extent of damage and destruction it causes in africa.. go and search about coltan... if that guy is a cow born then you are an ignorant buffoon...
@@gurindersingh8109 Gurinder Singh Yes you old fool, its just a Public Enterprise running on the principle of No Profit No Loss; You could even ask for a free iPhone when the next edition comes out and if we go by your definition it is nothing but a 'public good'.
Ask yourself, are ideas and innovation placed in public domain or patented?
the msg was clear that politician are slave of corporate because of huge fund they gets
every country ,, every politican is ?? so ..
I feel so petty
No..the msg is clear that bash India..bash Indian culture.. bash Hindus on foreign land....try with all strength to derail India from all it's developmental programs...sit with and support separatist elements in Kashmir...Justify all other, Maoist like, terrorist....Not to criticize Islamic terrorism...Not to lead a movement against Christian missionaries who are converting gullible Hindus in villages by using money, propaganda and other temptation... Talking of poor of India all over the world and doing nothing....
If corporates are not there who will create jobs?
Or do you idolise the former soviet union like economy?
@@SuperFatafati Corporates ko Sar ka Taaj nahi banaya tha Congress ne jo aaj Modi ne banaya hai .
I still wonder what Arundathi Roy has done to alleviate the condition of the poor except attending press conferences...
Whatever she is doing, nobody has done it before, you should appreciate her.
Oh my God, this is so dumb! Really?
@@abnajar7269 yes very true !
Which is exactly the need of the hour
What have you done?!?
I love listening to Ms.Roy. Her barbs make we hindus look like strong, cold and calculated imperialists. She makes us look 1000x times strong than we actually are. Thanks Ms.Roy. You have boosted our confidence and delivered some good comedy.
Are u dumb because I think don't know facts. Indian army can't take any action untill and unless government says to do. She is talking nonsense.
Roy isn't attacking individual hindus. She's outlining a capitalist and oppressive state that privileges upper caste hindus who have used that system to their advantage. She is also using facts to back up her statements. Don't be so dismissive of what she has to say, just because you can't see your own privilege. Also, if you reply to me, i don't want to hear about hoe hard your life is, how you've struggled etc. Like I said, this isn't about one person. It's about a government that is more concerned with maintaining their own power than helping its citizens.
That's best sarcasm I've witnessed in comments till now.
PS Mrs A R is really stupid...
@@amygill3218 Hey Don't talk as if you know everything about India. You don't know what Hinduism means.
1. 70% of the leaders in India are not "Upper cast ppl".
2. Tata and Godrej are not hindus they are Parsi
3. That Bitch eats in india and shits in US. You ppl are behind that shit.
4. We are the oldest surviving Civilizations in the world & And continue to do so.
5. Do you fake feminist talk about Saudi Arabia 's oppressive regime over Women ???
@@keshav3593 Ab woh cup rahegi
Arundhati Roy can't be more irrational. She brands Indian Army as Hindu Upper Cast force victimizing the minorities and tribals. It's a fact that Indian Army has a large section which comes from tribals(from Jharkhand, Terai region, Telangana) and religious minority as Sikhs. Her distortion of facts are reaching astounding heights!
Well Amith, the discussion in this section is about 10 min clip and I would appreciate if you send me the link to the complete video. However it makes more sense to base the discussion on the answers she gave and not on prequel or sequel. Quoting her exact words "an upper caste stake", which brings to two conclusions "an upper caste stake" in deployment of army(which you said) or "upper caste stake" in terms of numerical strength(which I concluded). I know this gives you all the more reasons to pester me to read her essays which I doubt I would, don't you think somewhere that criticizing our Government is not the way forward? Certainly we are not the children born in utopia and our leaders have not been the enlightened ones, yet it is more important to give away our cynicism and skepticism and look at the systematic problems that have happened because of mismanagement and not because of some nefarious motives. Won't you urge Arundhati to come over the negativity and apprehension and play a more decisive than divisive stand for betterment of millions of underprivileged people who come from all castes, communities and regions of India.
My bad! I find that mentioning "upper caste" is certainly divisive. I find mentioning "Hindu" is divisive. As I mentioned before, the problems she has mentioned are not because of "upper caste" or "Hindu" but systematic mismanagement of resources by our leaders who have happened to be from all religions and social strata. I don't know if her mention of "upper caste", "Hindu" has a broader interpretation, but her crucifying "upper caste", "Hindu" is divisive.
There was verna system in india , it is true that it was manipulated later but these were fault line the big gaps came during foreign rule . They wanted to break and convert india . There were always movements from with in the society and amazing personalities like swami dayanand saraswati , what a great influence he is and founder of arya samaj .The change came from within and he was never a preacher of hate but wanted to remove wrong practice. The teachings of arya samaj are great force to remove caste system . It would have been great work had she contributed to it spreading the message . but being a christian she did not . It is also important to study history of christianity , its realities( it is now believed that jesus was a fictional character, and many stories were planted across the world) . Vedic knowledge is the knowledge that has influenced many civilizations in the past and were following vedic culture . Spritual knowledge , yoga traditions . People should know what is going on and should realise how spiritual knowledge and traditions in hinduism( images of gods) is related to yoga .( chakras and all) .
Narayan, Arundhati is an intellectual who has put forth the unfair grip of the high caste hindus over the national resources. The sections of army-men those come from tribals are primarily low level sepoys and they work under commands that originate from the very senoir officers who are again high caste hindus. Moreover, the role of these tribal or other soldiers of army, is very mechanical, just to carry out orders, no room for personal decisions.
+bharat vaasi but why have we carried on this pathetic concept of martial race even today in the army?.?.
The airforce and navy doesn't have it.
It's utterly pathetic and messed up..its sadly legitimising the concept of upper caste hegemony.
and before u call me unpatriotic...I just cleared my cdse exam..my ssb is in may. future army guy here.
temples are managed by govt but mosques and churches are free to do as they want but this arunadhati has no issues with that
@Mr X no corrupt politicians
You need to educate you on why temples are like that. Who can manage temples? You are also forgetting how just till few decades back temples managed by privileged castes were barring entry to dalit people. You want a repeat?
Even temples in bjp run states are like that. Why not show that new model in bjp governed States instead of using this template to sow hatred and discredit Indian laws.
@@softgrowl its a fact / and as you said till few decades back /now its diminishing / Dont keep it alive
Wow never new that hindu never free dam!!!!
One of the few voices of reason left in this world. A really brave person from India.
"Rare" and "Rare"!
Yes rare because no terrorist allowed here
Her brother is Pranoy Roy who is the CEO of NDTV
Exactly! Run by same upper caste
Lalit Kumar Christopher Roy is Arundhati Roy.
Pranoy is not Arundhuti's brother.
We are living in post truth era
And she does not name Pranoy Roy. The biggest Media manipulator in India. Ha... Police had 50%reservations for non upper castes , and she has gumption to lie straight through the cheeks!
The issues that arundhati has been addressing is no more a piece of concern in india... India has moved far away from those things..
She is just repeating the lines of different books that she has read and the interesting thing is dat those writers are also kind of comrades
...
Under peaceful conditions, the militant man attacks himself - Nietzsche
As a christian, India is a great country that respect all religions even those of the minorites. My relatives in India are mainly christians and are proud of their country and the government that has recently brought out tremendous developments.
LOL!!! Yeah sure. Lookup Mohua Moitra's maiden speech just so you can educate yourself by a tad notch.
@@joneskiller8 b!tches are not considered as indians ☻️
Troll
That's why your churches are destroyed and your nuns are raped.
Seeing so many comments just criticizing her makes it evident that none of these people understand what she is saying or why. And the fact that she said this in 2011 is astonishing. For today, with BJP in power and it's working and it's romantic relationships with the corporates, like the Ambanis is so so evident!
Let me break it down to you in very simple manner how *"HINDU CORPORATE STATE"* is a real thing and bigger than ever:
1. HINDU -- Because BJP is in power right now and whose prime mandate for elections is only and only Hindi Rashtra and Ram Mandir. And to not overlook that it's the child of RSS, which, if you'd only know, is as pro-Hindu as it can get!
2. CORPORATE -- Because if you can't simply understand the romantic relationships and the favorism that the current government has with the big Corporate boys such as Ambanis, then I don't know what will make you understand this!
These corporate fellows will always be major part of Indian politics (which is not very surprising but very much normal to me) just like it happens all over the world. From where does the parties get money when they are not in power?
if what u believe is true then She is someone who can see the future... because 2014 is the first time in the history when the country gave a mandate this huge! Before 2014 began how could India have been The "HINDU CORPORATE STATE" that you fear so much...
Salok singh communist played dirty game twice once in 1985 as said by dalit activist and last year in bhimakhogaon where all men with pen are dangerous them men with guns proves all under scanner URBAn NAXAL ......
@Agnish Roy Oligarchs are found in communist backed countries.. Free market promotes wealth making for everyone through hard work and monetizing ideas.. How come India has oligarchs? BTW India has federal structure where states have the freedom like US.. If India would not have been a federal structure how come people of different states , caste , creed , religion are able to preserve their identity , language , literature.. Do you even know what you are talking about?...lol
What's wrong with being a *Hindu* and *corporate* state?
It must be hard to be a truth speaker in a country full of ignorant misogynists. She's heroic for still trying.
Lmao. What does this have to do with misogyny? She is just another failed commie who does not want to live in a democracy.
I wasn't entirely convinced with Arundhati Roy's answer.
Bharadwaj Parameswaran You are probably a Modi fan
@@VV-lq4di You are probably the type that posts comments that neither support or oppose the argument but plainly judges people in a derogatory tone. Have a good day!
Bharadwaj Parameswaran I was wrong on this one - my apologies.
@Fire Heart and youvdo8have brains
I am a Gujrati Muslim.... She is Communist... She is living in her own bubble..not practical at all
Jai Hind 🙏
mujhe laga TATA wale are Parsis.......
See how her communal remarks works, nobody is bothered whether TATA is a hindu or muslim or christian, she has researched and found TATA is Vaishyas
AMITKY07 not everything is about Hindu Muslim. She was talking about corporate controlled media.
V V
She mentioned herself that India is a Hindu state
Thats why it’s pointed out TATAs are Parsis
Supriya So what? A Hindu state means right wing fundamentalists are taking over. Does not mean there will be no successful non Hindus!
Lol
She is a good role model for those who sit and do nothing , but moaning about the system, while enjoying the good benefits the same system provides.She is a good role model for those who don't take responsibilities to change the system in a manner in which they want to change , but sitting and discussing endlessly about how bad it is. All I can see is her sweet voice and good english with void meaning. She is not providing any real solution because giving solution to a problem is more difficult than raising a problem.
She blames democracy in India and then she says China is more worse. Corporate power is not just in India, but it is also in the west (yes she admitted it) . We can easily see how corporate giants swept away the business of millions Americans and Europeans. Do she propose a model like communist group dictator China? NO. Or like Arab or North Korean dictator family rules? NO. Those are all worst. Basically her IDEAL world is not possible in earth, as nature itself follows Pareto rule.
Tatas are not Hindus by the way, they are Zoroastrians, a persecuted religion in the middle east Islamic countries. I know she will not mention this, because if she did, then she will lose a large fan base.
I agree.
This woman just let's out loud farts and does nothing to clear up her system so that we could stop hearing her farts
She answered romantic story with another romantic story...
Someone's misery is romance to you. Clearly when she mentions upper castes she's talking about people like you
correction in last comments. ,"who are barely 14-15 % of the total population"
Implementation is one of the real problem and more importantly democracy for few👍
The common denominator in those who perpetrate wars and trauma is....men.
*****
No. No. No. No killing at all. I think something went wrong in the puberty of males where their thinking gets tangled and twisted. We must not use force as a means of control. The mere idea of controlling someone other than self is an aberration of humanity. Yes you are correct about the West it is almost totally screwed. A very small crack of light can be seen however. I believe it will be that we will defang male rule and be guided by women for the next ten years, till the earth is cleaned up, till happiness sings in the hearts of all and till we construct a method through the use of the internet where everyone can represent themselves on any issue and no longer will a head of state be able to thrash the population with their puerile whims. This is called a womens' council and it is being developed now and it is beautiful. Because we all are beautiful and we should only accept that which touches our heart in a beautiful way. Imagine living in such an atmosphere!
+Denise Ward At least we men settle our differences even if its by killing each other. It's better than hating, gossiping , foul mouthing each other for life and beyond. lol
+arbaaz9044 You know the fact that you think it's better says a lot about your condition. Who in their right mind would stop someone from getting an education? Men did that to women (and still do in some parts) and they did it systematically. Now that speaks volumes about the kind of thinking in the male cranium. Oops, I just saw the LOL part.
+Noble Intellect Ok let's look at that. It infers that women are responsible for mens actions which is drivel. We're all responsible for our own actions. Those who give the orders are not the culpable ones, it is those who carry out the deed. There can be no dodging that. We have to, as individuals, carry the responsibility of what deeds we perform and what we support with our money or our labors. How can it be any other way and make sense? We cannot blame another's rule-making on our carrying out those rules or orders. Personal responsibility means also that we have power and can change things. But if we feel we are the victim of someone else's pressure, then we fail to grow up and we remain "rudimentary".
+Denise Ward you are not good at sensing the tone are you ? : P
Her voice is so serene so poised she is so much integrated . No storm can budge her confidence and dignity . ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
That is because she has taken pot and she is liar.
Have you slept with her? What rubbish!!!! She is the worst human being in the history of India.
corporate hindu government? what the heck is this woman talking about? which century does she live in?
***** Thugs like Modi right? And what would you say about the systematic genocide which took place in New Delhi in 1984 against the Sikhs. When during the riots a congress worker screams (while looking at a sikh child)..."yeh saap ka bachcha hai , ise bhi maro".....What about the comments made by Rajiv Gandhi during the riots that "When a big tree falls, the earth shakes"?.....And what about the ethnic cleansing which took place in Jammu when thousands of Kashmiri Pandits were forced to leave their homes....What about the poor security forces who gets butchered by the Maoist rebels?....Are they saints??....
***** Tell me your nationality so that i can frame my answers accordingly
So you're
Come to the streets of India
She lives in this century! You obviously don't
Qur'an (8:12) - "I will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve. Therefore strike off their heads and strike off every fingertip of them"
Shiva purana chapter 12: when shiva saw women starters misturabating , hindu priest gave him curse and his penis was cut cut down and it’s now known as shivalinga
7:40, 👏👏👏👏
She nailed it on the head
Tata is not a Hindu. He is a Parsi.
If i was present at this press conference i would have asked her in a democratic country is privatisation good or bad
Excellant narration to the world they will open the eyes and probe but we will close our eyes.
Somebody is crediting themselves for being able to see through the intellectually complex things!!! But I wonder how come they can't see a simple thing that every free nation state shall fight the threats to it's integrity either internal or external. And fighting the 'insurgency with perceived narrow idealogy' in the interest of larger national cause is very much justifiable.
Yeah majority rules...... minority sucks.... It is a phenomena
1:45 Just observe the air run out of the room the moment he tells her to mention the benifits of Free Market. So open minded.
"The government ran public companies and the country into bankruptcy."
Wrong. For public companies, if you exclude the "sick" companies that the Indian government routinely bought off the rich prior to 1991, public companies were only 1-2 percent less profitable per-capital employed than their private counterparts, and this was in the 80s when much of the permit-raj restrictions had been removed.
Roy you are factually incorrect when you mention Goa, Punjab. Problem is you don't work on ground, all you do is write for elites who are obsessed with the idea of sounding different. Also you bother only about Royalty, not at all about Emancipation of the masses.
The guy was asking awesome questions. Our media should be like this.
Our media can't be like this because when they do they get a notice for being an*i national" and if they still continue they get arrested for UAPA .-.
What was that awesome question?.. He was supporting corporates manipulating tribal areas with support of govt. ..... Stop being flaunted by a person speaking english
This media is as biased as mainstream media.
I'm a liberal saying that.
Leftism isn't liberalism as many Indians think.
Why does BJP win 2014 and 19?
Because of their neo-liberal ideology (free market economy) and not because of radical supporters.
You can't call yourself liberal if you hate neo-liberalism or libertarianism or capitalism
Islamic terrorism is nowhere near to corporates.
A religion(?) which gets offended just by a caricature must investigate its doctrine .
Indian moderate Muslims never truly condemned islamic terrorism, also boycotted Macron and supported france history teacher killing.
True ,real and horrifying face of Islam and pseudo secularism got exposed all over the world.
Western and European countries too getting taste of Peaceful religion
@@mondoterramortua whom you talking about, kindly mention clearly ....
phenomenal thinker!
Mind of every individual is different and it can't be helped.... Has an idea of idealism... Good, one can think so... Yes, certain things can disturb, different people differently... No way... No escape ways.. Having born... Being around, bearing is inevitable... Milton, don't know whether desperately said ; " They also serve, who only stand and wait "..
Humble pardon will go a long way🙏
After RTC strike in Hyderabad govt has increased it's ticket price per km 5 rs like that.. whereas last year only they made it same rise in price.
she is in her own world.
she is an agent of congress.
she looks stoned too.
What you accept Arundhati 80% people are Hindu. And what you are Saying, giving one sided pictures of India. I have so many things to contradict your lecture. Some stories could be right, but not absolutely everything is correct. You are misleading people out side INDIA.
She is telling 100% truth.
Imran Khan how about we bring in sharia law?? I am sure u will be happy with it isn’t it?
and what's the alternate to private media .state owned media?like door darshan,like media in China and Korea?
She is giving logical fallacies, things which she is telling happens in every country. Just wants india to cut down in small pieces
Cimmunists main thing is this only they want every state to be a different country.
Paid sanghi coolies will never accept the truth and will allow the country burning.
Whoever the dude is who asked the questions. I bow to thee.
it was answered equally well I have no clue why people get so offended by different opinions and perspectives they behave as if their lives depend on the way they think
@@anusuyarao6249 nope
I support Arundathi Roy..!
although she couldn't defend first question , the answer for alternative was awesome..
MK Dhar was senior IB officer working as press reporter for Hindustan Times during militancy in Punjab ! He had also admitted that there was "killing squad" and he was not part of it. Let Govt release all confidential papers about Punjab/Sikhs now that 30 years have been completed and Secret Act no longer applies.
This chap asked a good question and the mob mentality of this sick people is repulsive. Shouting people down is not how you argue.
Well it is how these people argue.
she's right, India is all about satisfying egos of upper caste ruling class people
What is the name of the person asking questions
Ok where is the video where she actually answered the questions?
2:38 uncle busy taking out bugger from his nose.
Superb points Ms. Arundhti in ripping this RSS ideology conspired government. We people support you and let’s renovate this country & system
No nobody supports her. Ur alone
We are not expecting any support from caste ridden Hindu radical ideologies and their slaves . Since world knows what she is doing and we know how to defeat anti Indian rss radicals and their supporters. Downfall of this radical rss ideology have started already.
I don't see points
Ur intellectual capacity is too small
Am sorry
There's no point at all
@@vijayadeva06 am not rsd nationalist
And nationalists and leftist are just collectivist brothers so keep fighting u both are wrong eventually.
And fall? Communism has completely fallen so what are you talking about
@@yydd4954 what a silly and cheap way of thinking you have 🤣 and I am not expecting any good virtues or traits from the supporter of rss who are definitely a fascist and caste ridden pigs👈🏽. If you have tiny fraction of common sense then you would have understood her stand 👈🏽😎
so she can question whosoever's funds she wishes, but we cant question those so called "Researchs" and surveys she claims!!
Complete truth has fructified in front of our eyes in 2019-2023 period.
she is saying everything correct....but nobody will support her because she is fighting for them who r dying from hunger,poverty and inequality....they dont even know she is fighting for them....
She is fighting for a foriegn agency so that Infia fights in between. She is doing nothing for poor. She is visiting foreign countries and getting paid for that.
Fighting..ha..ha..haa..Not fighting.. but fooling...and you seemed to be a befooled one..ha..ha..ha..
Left is the best option for India. See west Bengal. The most prosperous state of India with not even a single poor citizen.
I can sense sarcasm. 😂😂
are bhai bhai ekdam khatarnak sarcasm🤣🤣
being a member of such public sector as u have discussed I say I'm totally in command to discuss with u ..will u Plz????
It's good to be opiniated for a genuine cause......
fortunate to see at least some sense in India too bad she is not the PM or things would have been different
Oh my gosh... She doesn't understand how any business works.
The points about violence against tribals and forcibly taking away their land is true and it has been the same ever since British Raj's Indian Forest Act 1884. However, its a bit simplistic to say that it is a totalitarian Hindu state because thankfully at the moment its not. However, there is that risk with certain parties that they will try to impose their narrow religious conception on the diverse population and that might ultimately lead to greater violence and fragmentation of Indian society.
Crystal clear explanation
Genuinely answered. Very simple why the Major political parties exactly disclose the funding sources, and how they could manage financially such a marathon exercise of campaign while mo individual member of any party pay subscription out his or her own pocket.
You are great to expose the true pictures of our state and its democratic set-up but it is difficult to change the situation as the fanaticism is growing faster now. Anyway we have to do something to check this trend. Your work is commendable. Hoping for the better.
Fanaticism which is growing today is a response to Islamic fanaticism that has existed in the sub continent for the last few hundred years ;)
Roy is the best. glad she is opening everyones minds.
Still hadn't offered any alternatives.
she smoked high quality weed
As she says while answering she definately is a mental case.
India is a corporate Hindu state? We will take that. Socialism has failed, and Non Hindus have ruled India for too long! We need a natural democracy that serves the majority. We know that minorities in India are safe and prospering unlike India's neighbors! Arundhati Roy has a right to talk freely, she won't be in Pakistan. Water is elixir of life, without which we parish! I have no Idea why these guys get so much attention.
I like her. one of the few Indian who are honest.
Give out a Booker prize, Nobel prize, High prices for mediocre-paintings/art-movies, and get the "eminent" personalities of India to do a saboteur's job at low risk & high efficiency ! We are wise to it now, firangis ! We treat these Jonahs with the contempt they deserve.
right bro. !
In a very direct or nuanced way, I can uncompromisingly say that Arundhati Roy thrives on the oxygen of publicity she gets. People in India have this inveterate habit of treating every other person with a decent vocabulary as a public intellectual. I did accept her criticism if she had not used aberrations in society to pass sweeping generalisations about the whole country. She exclaims that India is a corporate upper caste construct....how fashionable !! Since the dawn of the country in 1947 until its rebirth in 1991, India was a borderline communist state which had made it a policy to exclude private and individual enterprise. People like her bask in dividends of economic growth and are equally disingenuous while criticising the same.
Im totally with u mam no matter u r toward or anti national. I take u r truth at least
Splendid
@5:17 Punjab, Hydrabad, Nagaland, Mizo were controlled by Indian Government. They were all tribal or Christens! What can be more lie then this? Hydrabad, Punjab - no tribal or Christens! Because of Punjab was divided into two countries there was mass killing and Government had to step in. Nizam of Hydrabad after independence from Briton wanted separate Muslim state and Govt had to step in. Mizo and Nagaland has tribal people. They were not Christen. Missionaries invaded this reign, later Maoist took over this land under support by Mao in China started riots and Govt had to step in. China is doing same thing in Ughar. Anyone criticize Chinese Prime Minister, the Chinese military steps in to take control!
Roy partly belongs to Kerala where the so-called upper castes are starving and the so-called lower castes have a very good time. Here the laborer decides the wages and not the farmer etc.
She is right up to sm extent.....actually this is a complicated thing to explain..
How to turn a man to a business man and investor. Above 50000₹/month salary is what you opt. Below that is daily wages quotas.
no court of appeal in india....and all these years i was under the belief that we have a functioning judiciary.
I some how try to contradict Arundathi Roy but am unable to. As I am convinced from her speech that Democrsy is for only few.
Still I think she speaks only one side of the coin.
who is that guy sitting next to her ? looks very familiar.
i want to know whos sponsoring arundati
Golden words - India's a democracy but only for some people.
She is included in 'some people '
Really wonderful intellectual person
Find more of it on #kashmirfiles
@@sanhithareddy9571 thats a propaganda not a film! but i also agree that kashmir incident did happen and that has to be known but not from any such movie but from scholars and academicians
Its called procedural democracy rather than functional democracy...
I loved the conversation, but the title of this Post ie. RADICAL CONVERSATION is too extreme in todays world. Would you please change it to something softer ie. KILLING TRUTH/SWANSONG OF INDIAN DEMOCRACY etc.
I don't even care about Arundhati Roy ever since she was praised by Zaid Hameed
Only because she was praises by a muslim, you dont like her. What is the meaning? What is there in you? Think..!😓
She's praised by many honest people
Quite subjective analysis. The only fact she has, is 'when you see'.
Actually this is the only way see can sell her books, through manipulation.
Sell her books ??? She has written just one book.
Just one.
@@usc4405 oh i think you have little knowledge in this aspect! She has written number of books! Pls read those before coming with a comment like this!
Omg her voice !!!
Would she reveal the details about the people who fund her?
Couple of points are right like long time neglect of interior/ remote areas, but since she & her supporters implicitly justify violence by these people in return, their cause & means lose respectability. She should know Indian media is more controlled by Left than Hindu-Right or others quite evident in any case of rape or murder where victim happens to be Dalit splashed as deliberate case of Dalit-oppression. Any anti-majoritarian disinformation campaigning leftist & atheist is proclaimed as a "rationalist". Beef-ban is used as an opportunity by fanboys to provoke insult & ridicule vegetarians (who are mostly Jains & upper-Hindus). Hateful people much less for secretly against India here but for genocidal-level venomous hatred against certain religion, castes & groups are attempted to be promoted as national martyrs/ heroes (just for that). And India is comparatively newly freed, huge developing nation with very big population, there's bound to be a lot of problems, confusion, complaints & mess before it climbs its way to peace & prosperity. The way you promote & want disintegration of it in name of freedom for every single thing it can only get fragmented into a catastrophic civil war before some kind of Armageddon which is what you want.
_
@Electroweak Epoch so you want a civil war in India? You'd rather enjoy watching millions dying only for your belief that Brahmins & rajputs are ruling the country (which they are not, many at top including President & PM are from other castes). See it's people like you who are the biggest & more direct threat right now, because you propound your beliefs as facts and support violence & killings and targetting whole communities in order to achieve your objective, which is total control.
Baki sab to theek tha lekin Hindu corporate state and Kashmir are different issues ,lekin ye aurat Yaha mulloke gunahoko najar andaj karke uppercaste hinduvoke gunaho ko highlight karrahi hai , ye Sahi nahi laga
RedArmyTank
And PUHHHLEASE, I want PROOF, actual empirical evidence that poverty has worsened, not polemics.
awesome mam