Why Nations Fail - پاکستان کی ناکامی کی وجہ
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 03. 2023
- Why is it that some countries some nations take the giant leap and become successful while a lot of others miss the train of prosperity and progress. Over the years, scholars have come up with many hypothesis pertaining to the reasons behind the failure of nations. Some attribute this failure to the geography of a country while others blame the cultural roots. However, there is one very solid and the most pivotal reason behind failure of nations. That is the reason I discuss in detail in today's video. It has got great learning for you. I content is inspired from the book "Why Nations Fail".
![दुनिया की अगली बड़ी शक्ति: इंडोनेशिया [Indonesia: a rising power in the global economy]](/img/n.gif)
Huge fan of you janab,,,,they way you speak mind blowing ,,, great knowledge you have Masha Allah,,,, Allah Pak apko mazeed knowledge Dy ,,,,
Today's video will help you learn what's going wrong with Pakistan. Hopefully, people can learn and make our country better.
WHAT ARE THE SOLUTIONS THAT AN INDIVIDUAL CAN DO? MAKE A DETAILED VIDEO ON IT.
@@osmanbey9543 whatever you do your goal should align with the country goal or nation goal but unfortunately the govt is unable to give this nation a goal. For example Malik Riaz is only doing investments in real estate to make only his money so his business is only giving profits to him but not giving anything to Pakistan nation or Pakistan economy. Instead of putting money in real estate if he should put his money in making those things which Pakistan will export that will be helpful to him as well as to Pakistan.
Your hypothesis is flawed. You have twice given the example of the Koreas but skipped the ideological differences between them. One Korea is governed by an ideology while the other is not. Pakistan is also an ideological country hence is a failure. If a nation is dominated by religion it can hardly make progress. No developed nation is religious. If there is any, please name it.
@@abdullahshirazee6456 ISRAEL
@@abdullahshirazee6456 AND I WANT THE ANSWER WHAT AN INDIVIDUAL CAN DO?
Not possible in Pakistan as we don't want to change,we all just want a miracle only.
@Storage Unit bhi akela imran khan kia karsakta hy jo pakistan ke taqatwar logh hy imran khan ki madad ke bajaie imran khan ko kamyab he nai hone tehte kiyu ke sab ki chori ki dokan bandh hojaige
@@storageunit9552
To bhai sahed sub kuch ap khud bhi to thek nahi kar sakte...... kya aj tak ap ne apni street mein two (2) bricks bhi lagai ya lagwai hain.... aur kya ap khud se complete street ko banane ka expense kar sakte hain..... ya phir apni street ki shop mein apni marzi ka rate fix kar sakte hain.......???
Ap apni street repair nahi kar sakte aur baatein ap Imran Khan ki kar rahe hain......??? Ek Nation ya Country ka a system hota hai us ke koi leaders hote hain jo koi vision dekhte hain aur is ko implement karte hain.......
Bhai saheb agar Imran Khan aye ga to woh country mein aisi policies banae ga woh aise laws aur constitution laye ga jo ordinary people tak benefit jaye ga........ ordinary people bhi Pakistan ki development mein take part karain gay......
To phir Imran Khan ki demand wrong kyu hai????
Who says it is not possible in Pakistan? Don't you relate yourself to Pakistan? Do you feel ashamed of being Pakistani?
Before I start some thing Big......
My question is: Is it possible to grow a tree if its roots are in Pakistan, stem in UK, can bear fruits in China?
Definitely --- Not possible @ all. Why? The reason is very simple: To get fruits from Tree, its roots, stem, branches and fruits must be at one place.
When we are too shattered, deviated, confused and are in crisis, how we can even think of any solution?
Last but not least: When we becomes donkey, everyone will be ready to get ride on you. So don't be so pessimistic, just Do any thing that really create difference in this beautiful Pakistan.....
I have met many Pakistani who always criticises themselves, others, Pakistani system and much more but when I asked them did you ever spend one rupee or took one step to make any change and could never get any reponse but silence or shout or abuses.
@@iq2823what have u done for Pakistan?
Besides abusing people's faith
@@KanishQQuotes
I have done many things for my country and people living in it and still doing a lot of things for its betterment from buying a book for poor to pay fee for poor children from feeding a poor to give charity for Hospitals, Needy, for supporting Sports personal if someone is interested in any game, for arranging and supporting in jobs i.e. IT, Business Mangement, Finance and other fields of life wherever I have contacts and have done lot more for jobless personal not only in Pakistan but also outside of Pakistan i.e. Gulf Countries (UAE, Qatar, Saudi, Kuwait), European countries and Australia and many more.....
I created a difference even a lit bit like dot. But I did. Because, I have aspiration to leave my footsteps on this beautiful planet before I leave this beautiful country to the journey of eternity. At least, I have tried to create a difference. I made it and did it. That's why and how I am satisfied!
Why aren't you so satisfied. I know one reason, you always thought and thought and thought but never moved a bit.
"Stop thinking ---- Start doing".
This life is too short. And for "Doers" like me. A century is not Enough!
The minute he said that the educated & Intellectual people creates institutions, I only remembered Vikram Sarabhai, the Scientist that lead Indian Space program & played a vital role in creation of ISRO
What does that have to do with Pakistan? Mind your own business. Enjoy landing of Chandrayan 3 on moon
Look Book Buddy, to be honest from a very, very elderly indian engineer this is the 1 St time i come across a pakistani, who preaches a proper way forward for fellow pakistanis God Bless U.
مقبوضہ پاکستان ۔۔۔ عوام پریشان
You are truly educating the innocent public of our country. We never expect this from any Punjab Text Book Board or any other. We waste our time in Mirza Ghalib poetry and rubbish novels.this is our educational system
Shut up you know nothing!? What should be included then in our curriculum!? Bhangrhay!? Jugatain!? Chawalain!? For which you Punjabis are fond of!!
Problem was never with Ghalib's poetry or those novels. They were good in themselves but the way it was taught and studied. We never read that for educational or exposure purpose, but for passing exam that is the problem. PTB board also selected content from good sources but couldn't even properly added in the text books.
انصاف اور عدل قائم کر دو، کامیاب ہو جاؤ!
Again a quality content. Book buddy deserves times more audience and views. It is one of those few platforms that delivers fact based knowledge backed by contemporary examples.
Shah Rukh is above and beyond populism and catchy terms, the Supreme reason for his engrossing analysis.
hamri duty hai ka hum in ki videos ko ziyda se ziyad share karen.he is doing great job. pakistan ki youth 132 million using internet par inka subscribe itna kam hai. it is so disappointing. he is deserving a lot.
Absolutely perfect and to the point description janab !! Thanks for making and sharing the video.
Excellent informative videos thank you for your effort
Well explained book buddy,
Hatts off.
Very informative well done.
On point analysis! Your content is brilliant!
simply brilliant!
بہت خوب مزا آگیا
Behtreen malomat
Excellent analysis.
thanks bro bohot informative video thi
Good analysis, keep it up 👍
Wow... beautiful analysis and a great informative video. Keep doing the great work Bro❤
#Bookbuddy u explained top notched. 👍
Mashaallah ❤ great Jehaad❤....Allah o Akbar...
You doing really well for the nation of Pak.
This channel deserve more subscribes.
Nice and Informative content.❤❤❤
Very though provoking vedeo 👍
ماشاءاللہ بہت خوب
پاکستان کی ترقی میں اسکی فوج کا کردار نمایاں رھا ۔ھماری دفاعی ٹیکنالوجی دنیا کے لیے حیران کن ھے
You are true youth leader and teacher❤
Good one Ustad .
Excellent work Sir ❤
we badly need such education content which can drive us ahead as a nation.
Great buddy❤
Shandar yadagar video
We all should work hard for our country ❤ your content is good
Very predilection for you❤
Awesome sir ❤️
Absolutely outstanding we are facing same issues.
Great ❤
First Pakistani channel that i find informative logical.Excellent job done.
well informed video
Great sir
I liked your explanation bro
👍
You Rock bro.😊
Good Education is Directly Proportional to a Developed Country
India Invest in IITs 1 Billion Dollar Yearly which is too low but still Get IT Exports 200 Billion Dollars+ Yearly
It's Power Of Education
Pakistan Can Also learn from This Instead of Fighting with India
Bro you are great 👍❤
پاکستان میں جب تک وسائل کی منصفانہ تقسیم نہیں ہوتی مسائل حل نہیں ہونگے
No words for your contribution to the deprived and ailing society. Thank you very much for creating mass awareness, people like you are hope of Pakistan.
Respect, love and tribute to your efforts for sharing your knowledge with people who don't have access and capacity to understand real issue. I pray May Allah accept your efforts like jihad.
God bless you. ❤
Thank You!
Well explained
Good job
A much needed video for the present circumstances
But the problem is nobody is willing to take a step forward. Everyone just keeps on thinking that it is our politicians who ruins the country but we don't realize that all of us are also not sincere with the country.We have not completed our task ;rather we are waiting for someone who will sail our boat. We should realize that :the change starts with you
Well done
Allah us qaom ki halat nai badalta Jo apni halat khud nai badalta...
Bhai Saab nice information made more videos
Excellent Work Keep it up Bro. Whenever you make a video on a specific book or topic, I tried to find that book and buy it and read it by myself. Thanks again. Stay Blessed
Good for you, for loving and reading books!
Causes of failure of state:
1. Existence of extractive political and economic institutions instead of inclusive political and economic institutions.
2. Consolidation of power.
3. Creative Destruction
very very good study kindly focus on the economic performance history of intervening sections, departments, organizations
Change begins from within
Instead of pointing 👉 fingers
We must start from within ourselves
I subscribed your channel on 129k subscribers your videos and knowledge is mind blowing
Bilkul sahi kaha sirf hm log hi political institutions ko theek kr sakta hai aj nahi to kal inshallah.mera andaza ma hma Social Sciences students ki zarorat hai wo bhi mukhlis hon.Wo is mulk ko stable kr sakta hain
I like your patriotic to word's Pakistan.
Because of honesty
Today the 30th may 2023 is my first time to have watched and heard this channel you are doing best service for the this poor and underprivileged people God bless you
What a great analysis your speaking ability is awesome inspiring sharo ji ❤️
Sir 😊👍
@@BookBuddyOfficial please ye btayen... what's the reason to divide by 12
sir you are doing a great job. please make more videos on intellectual development. ap ka subscribe itna kam kyun hai you are deserving a million of the subscriber.
super
پاکستان کامیاب ریاستوں کی فہرست میں کیسے شامل ھوا یہ ایک کہانی نہس حقیقت ھے ھمرے خیر خواہ خود حیران ھیں
In The "Startup Nation" The Book focusses on Appreciating Failure Why not to Appreciate the Failure of Pakistan. May be After Failure we Learn some valuable Lessons from our Failure and may be people start working from their hearts for the well of their Country Or else we will be in the same condition for ever.
Ek dafa poora collapse zaroori hai.
@@fahadhussain66 elaborate
Every citizen of Pakistan should fulfill its own duties the right of one person should be protected by the other in this way progress will be possible!
If more n more people would think n analyse like you
Literacy is the only cause of prosperous nations because it gives you the vision and courage to speak. As a Muslim majority nation, we have failed to understand our deen which has made education compulsory for every man and woman. It solves all the problems.
پاکستان کا ایک ادارہ جو ساری پاور اپنے پاس رکھتا ہے اور باقی اداروں کو اس نے اپاہج کر کے ناکارہ بنا دیا ہے پورے ملک پہ اس کی مناپلی قائم ہے، لیکن اس ادارے نے پروپیگنڈہ کے ذریعے لوگوں میں تاثر پھیلایا ہے کہ اگر ہمارا ادارہ نہ ہوتا تو پاکستان کو وجود ہی ختم ہو جاتا، لیکن عوام بھی اتنی جاہل ہے کہ کبھی یہ سوچا ہی نہیں کہ اسی ادارے کی وجہ سے ملک ٹوٹا تھا۔
اگر ہماری فوج دیکھ ٹھیک ھو جائے تو ہمارہ ہر ادارہ ٹھیک ھو جائے گا &100/ اگر ہمارہ ہر ادارہ ٹھیک ھو جائے گا۔ جب سب ادارے ٹھیک ھو جائیں گے ۔ تو پھر پاکستان کو ترقی کرنے سے کوئی نہیں روک سکتا۔ مگر افسوس کہ جو طاقت میں ہیں وہ بیک فٹ پر جانا نہیں چاہتے جو أنے والے وقت میں پاکستان کو خدانہ خواستہ تباہ کر دیگا۔ اللہ معاف کرے۔ اگر اسی طرح نظام چلتا راہا تو ؟؟ پاکستان ھے تو ھم سب ھیں۔۔ جس ملک میں انصاف ختم اور ظلم بڑہ جائے۔ ۔ اور جہاں طاقتور اور کرپٹ کو عزت اور۔ اور جہاں اہماندار اور غریب پر ظلم اور دبا کررکھا جائے۔ اور معاشرے میں اسکا مزاق اور پاگل کہا جائے ۔ وہ معاشرہ تباہ ھی ھونا ھوتا ھے ۔ اللہ پاک پاکستان کی خود حفاظت فرمائیں۔ أمین۔
Good
Book review of Why Nations Fail..😊
پاکستان میں لکیر کے فقیر وں کی حکمرانی ھے۔جو خود بھی نہیں سمجھتے
بلکہ آوروں کو بھی کام کرنے نہیں دیتے
mashallah
ہم صرف بھولی بھٹکی قوم ہیں
جسے ہر طریق سے بھلایا بھٹکایا گیا ہے
Salam from Dadu Sindh. ..Sir aap ne buht achhe tareeke se Pakistan ke barbadi ka explain kiya ..But mein jo kuchh April 022 se April 023 tk Pakistan ke barbadi ko smjha hon uss mein mujhe ek he reason smjh aaye he k iss mulk/kom k sayah sufaid k Malik 10-12 jammat pass Journel hen ..aur yeh mulk/kom tb tk nhin sudhre ge jb tk hum as a Nation apna gareban inn 12 jammat pass Journelon se nhin chhurrate ..
ھزاروں بے جا مداخلت کے پاکستان انمیں نمایاں ملک ھے جسنے چیلنجز کے باوجود ترقی کی
When we say we are the best, we stop all options of improvement becuz of this world is improving and we are the best😅
Top fan
Teacher Allah Hafiz
In Arabic Countries oil is the prime reason for Per Capita income and not Islam .But in Pakistan Islam is the prime reason for Per Capita Income .Countries without natural resources but rich have their Brain while Pakistani have Khali Veja or filled with kachra.Dear no use being aggressive rather take it positively and as challenge .Best of luck. 👍👍👍
Good research.
These all factor of less Growth
Capital income may be.
But this too much effect by illiteracy,spritaual and patriotic
toward your land,where you live.
The answer is simple: Religion.
NO ITS DEVISION FIRQAY BAAZI STILL MUSLIM ULMA ANTI DEVELOPMENT
Its Exploitation of Religion*
In the last 75 years of Pakistan's history, the military Establishment is the main culprit because they have ultimate power and unconstitutional interference in civilian institutions and politics therefore, Pakistan is failed state, if Pakistanis destroy the hegemony of establishment then Pakistan will progress InshaAllah
Intellectual myopia
Apki tareef
Religious orientation play important role.
Religious orientation affect thinking towards technology.
Technology play role in development
No Muslim country contribute to innovation. They only use technology invented by others
We need Poor people for Zakaat and Bheria & Alamgir Daster kawan
پاکستان کا مسلہ کیا؟؟
لا الہ الا اللہ۔۔😂😂😂
Sir plz make a book reviews of Pakistan a hard country, Jinnah of Pakistan and zulfi of Pakistan
You said that we have educated and intellectual people and at the end of the video you said that we need educated people, very intelligent and also sincere, sympathetic to their country and thinking about the welfare of Pakistanis.
But according to me we have educated people. And also intellectual people but we need very much to be loyal, patriotic to their country and that we are not.
You don't need progress because you've Islam.
Due to corrupt bureaucrate and politicians God bless effectors
پاکستان کے سیاسی لیڈر پاس ہورہے ہین !
11:20, party wrong. The Ottomans were not really against the printing press. At that time, in the 16th century, an Italian publisher Paganino Paganini printed scriptures of the Quran with immense errors. To curb anything from happening like this (the dissemnation of erroneous scriptures), the Ottomans prohibited the use of printing press for quite a while as they didn't want the scriptures of the Quran to be tampered with. At that time the Quran was written by hand.
Ottomans couldn't compete with the colonial west, as they no longer were able to tax the western countries for requiring a pathway into Asia. The west simply went westwards in search of newer colonies and brought back a behemoth of stolen gold, silver and other plentiful resources. The Ottomans were simply outmuscled eventually. Ottomans couldn't get out the Mediterranean blockade to commission westward ventures. European renaissance was funded by the colonial riches. It all boiled down to money and superior ammunition. The US Arizona has money, the Mexican side simple doesn't.
I have read both of these books, Why Nations Fail, has tons of cherry picking in it, certain specific cases to suit the author's objective. Presently, democracy has taken serious hits and is on the decline in my opinion, the illusory gamut of free speech practiced in the west is slowly unraveling, people are somewhat tricked into thinking that their voice matters, had that really mattered, Iraq and Afghanistan would have been a different story. The Chinese model has somewhat rejuvenated interest in a coherently driven authoritarian government. Authoritarian changes and reforms have worked better for them, those changes may not have been possible in a democratic setup. They have given people, jobs, education, health, better social life rather than the right to vote. I would trade my right to vote over basic amenities of life any day. Samuel P Huntington for me is gonna win in the longer run. Fukuyama's End of History is a thing of the past now. One size doesn't fit all.
Also the mention of wes German and south Korea is invalid as both are backed by American influence to counter political narratives. . . . However I see that the people have able to create rule of law in usually where there is progress . . .
"From Third World to First World" must read book about Singapore.
👍👍👍