Namaz Mein Hath Bandhne Par Ikhtilaf Kiyun Hai? | Shia Sunni Namaz Debate | Mein Aur Maulana | Ep 01
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 07. 2024
- Namaz Mein Hath Bandhne Par Ikhtilaf Kiyun Hai? | Shia Sunni Namaz Debate | Mein Aur Maulana | Ep 01
Mufti Rafiq Salafi ( Wahabi Scholar)
Allama Hayat Abbas Najafi ( Shia Scholar)
نماز میں فرق کہاں سے آیا ہے ؟ | شیعہ سنی میں نماز پر بحث | میں اور مولانا
مفتی رفیق سلفی ( وہابی عالم)
علامہ حیات عباس نجفی ( شیعہ عالم)
#Namaz #NamazKaTareeqa #Shia #Sunni #Podcast #Episode1 #owaisrabbani
#owaisrabbani #mainaurmaulana #motivation #podcast #video #sunni #podcast
0:00 - Intro
1:11 - Namaz Kiya hai?
3:10 - Namaz Kaese Parhni Hai?
6:22 - Kiya Rasool Allah SAW Ne Haath Khol Kar Namaz Parhi Hai?
9:04 - Namaz Mein Hath Bandhne Par Ikhtilaf Kiyun Hai?
11:00 - Namaz Mein Farq Kahan Se Aya Hai?
17:55 - Wahabi Maslak Mein Haath Khol Kar Namaz Parhne Se Namaz Hojaegi?
18:58 - Rukooh Aur Sajde Kay Darmiyan Rafah Ul Yadain Hoskta Hai?
21:09 - Ashrah e Mubashira Kay 10 Naam Kiya Hain?
23:00 - Kiya Ummat e Muslima Aik Hoskti Hai?
27:01 - Namaz Mein Topi Pehanna Wajib Hai?
29:06 - Allah Se Namaz Mein Dua Ki Jasakti Hai?
29:52 - Qaza Namazein Kisi Ko Paese Dekr Puri Karwa Sakte Hain?
31:18 - Eid Ki Namaz Ki Kiya Wajibaat Hain?
34:46 - Outro
A video essay is a piece of video content that, much like a written essay, advances an argument. Video essays take advantage of the structure and language of film to advance their arguments.
Disclaimer: All content on this channel is subject to copyrights, illegal use of content from this channel is prohibited & will result in immediate take down. Content can't be reproduced without prior written permission. This Channel is managed by MetaMorph'd
Metamorph'd, provides only technical and graphics services. We are not in charge/responsible of any content that goes up on CZcams.
In case of copyrights infringement, please contact at contact@metamorphd.com
For any other query please email at contact@metamorphd.com
Proud to be Shia n Ali ( a.s ) ❤
Proud to be shia Of Imam Ali a.s ❤❤❤❤
We are proud to be unmah of Muhammad Saws.
@@khan_5789 hame fakhr hai abu bakar suwerr ko ka’ffir kehne par…. hame fakhr hai umar hamari ko ka’ffir kehne par….. hame fakhr hai Syed Fatima a.s. ke qatilo ko ka’ffir kehne par…. hame fakhr hai
@@khan_5789 ''حدثنا ابو سلمة یحیی بن خلف ، حدثنا عبدالاعلی عن محمد بن اسحاق عن عبداللہ بن ابی بکر عن عمرة عن عائشة رضی اللہ عنہا، قالت: لقد نزلت اٰیة الرجم ، ورضاعة الکبیر عشراً ولقد کان فی صحیفة تحت سریری فلما مات رسول اللہ ﷺ وتشا غلنا بموتہ دخل داجن فاکلھما''
(سنن ابن ماجہ، ابواب النکاح، رقم: ۱۹۴۴)
''سیدہ عائشہ رضی اللہ عنہا سے روایت ہے انہوں نے فرمایا: رجم کی آیت اور بڑی عمر کے لڑکے کو دس بار دودھ پلانے کے مسئلے پر مشتمل آیت نازل ہوئی تھی۔ یہ دونوں آیتیں ایک کاغذ پر لکھی ہوئی میرے بستر پر پڑی تھیں۔ جب رسول اللہ ﷺ کی وفات ہوئی تو ہم آپ کے کفن و دفن وغیرہ میں مشغول ہوگئے، ایک بکری آئی اور وہ کاغذ کھا گئی۔''
Proud to be a Muslim ALHAMDULILLAH ❤
@@syedalizaidi649abey pehle Rasulallah saws ki ummati to banja.. tu to Hazrat ali ki shia hain yani kafir..😂
Mashallah
Shia Scholar explain it very well
Yeh ujaat hain in ki dono ulamh sue awaam kay agay nangay go gaye kag haath Bana aur choorna sabat hai rasool ullah aur sahaba say. Lekin dono apnay firkay kay gutter may itnay doobay howay kay dil may uss Namaz ko Sahi nahi samjtay lekin audiences kay lege inkaar nahi ker saktay kay sabat nahi. Yahi hain woh Kuttay Jin ka zikker Qurab may kia gaya hai kay ur hnazzer ki terha in ki antay inkay irdh girdh ho gee. The common Muslims must save themselves from these Ulamah sue of sects becasue they gave nothing to do with Islam. All 72 sects are going to hell and this is what rasool ullah told us. Sunni and Shia are the leaders of 72. And u can count they counted like 50 sects from Shia and sunni all of them are astray because they will never complete full Islam of Quran and Sahi hadees. They pick and choose hadees even Quran based on their astray sects. Yeh in haramio ki ukaat hai.
He is wrong
@@Anarchist369 🤣🤣
@@Anarchist369 mirza ali aur molana ishaq ko bi sunn lo
@@senrio8812Hassan Allahyari ki b sun lyn 🙄
Proud to be Hussaini 🥰🚩
Proud to be a Shia
I am sunni but i am shocked and happier at some points of Shia scholar
Because u r Muslim...
Hazrat Ali alhail bat sey Hein pala Nabi Pak phr Nabi Pak ka ghr wala Phr shahba karam 🥲 Ya WAHABI AJEEB HEIN shahba or alhail bat mein COMPARE HAIN HE NAI im muslim ❤️
Ye Gai mukalid ilm se Khali hote hai bas jidd pr jite hai
MashAllah Research more jazakAllah
@@fymejdi2599Nabi (saw) ne farmaya meri ummat 73 firko me bategi, sahi rasta (mein aur mere sahaba) pr jo hoga, aur sahaba mein hazrat ali r.z bhi shamil hai
Proud to be SHIA MUSLIM
Proud to be only muslim 🎉
@@studentofemam134 Proud to be a SHIA MUSLIM
Bulb
@@mohdsaquib5301 ese nhi sir... poora bolo.... Bar Umar Lanat Beshumaarrr
Tum asli Syed ho nhi jhola chap Sayed ho tum 😂😂😂
ہم نے تو دین رسول اللّٰہ صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم اور آپ ص کے گھر والوں سے لیا ہے نہ کہ باہر والوں سے اِس لئے اِس میں شک و شبہ کی گنجائش نہیں❤❤ بیشک لبیک یا حسین۴!
. .
..
😢😮😢😢😢😮😢😢
!ل(پل😊
😊
❤❤Geoo❤❤❤
ہم نے بھی نبی کریم صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے گھر والوں سے لیا عبداللہ بن عمر رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ سے جو ہمیشہ رسول کریم صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے ہاں آتے تھے اور رہتے بھی تھے
Proud to be a Shia Muslim Shia SCHOLAR was Perfectly Right
Phle 3 khlifa hi glt the toh namaz ke phle 3 tarike bhi galat aur fir 4th khlifa Moula Ali A.S bne aur rasoole khuda ko jahiri waqat se gye huye 25 saal ho gye moula Ali A.s ne apne imamat me pehli namaz padhaai Toh andhe shaabi ne cheekh maar kr sab ko bta diya aj Muhammad wali namaz yaad gyi I am proud to be a shia❤
I'm really thankful to Almighty Allah swt that he let me born in Shia family....N if we taught them day and night we gave them 100%proven hadees and Facts but still those types of people's couldn't accept the truth,fact bcz they r happy to live their lives in darkness 🙏 ❤❤❤❤❤
Moulana Hayat has always been a great source of logical argument. He put everything very clearly and behaves exactly as a religious scholar.
Shia scholars are smashing it!!❤❤❤
Proud to be shia muslim❤❤
kam cal Maulana Sahab
@@khan_5789 tehreef e Quran to tumhari bukhari mein hay humari naheen hazrat ayesha ko zaniya sahabi ne kaha hum ne naheen hum Sahabi(ra) ko bura naheen kehtay na buray ko sahabi kehtay hain taqayya to ANBIYA(as) ne bhi kiya hay
Aal e Muhammad s.a.w par Salam bheje bagair kisi ki namaz b qubool nahi hoti.
Sab se afzal h Muhammad s.a.w. Or aal e Muhammad s.a.w❤
Sunni alim ki thi tevriya chadh jaati hai, maula ali sabse afzal pe. Ye sunni afzalyat bhi khilafat ke line se samajhe hai.
Ahle bait se pyar karne walo ko Mera Salam....
❤❤❤❤❤
Proud to be shia
Surah al araf ayat 28- 29 namaz is tarah ada Karo jayse dunya me aye aur jayse dunya se jao ge ya Ali AS madad ❤❤ 🇩🇪
Proud to be shia - e - Ali a.s ibne abi Talib a.s
Proud to be shia... Great job janab owais rabani sahib but please make sure that the guests you invited must be honest because this aalim sahib always denied a true ahadees although they also have a proof in their own books but he denied it with a illogically reasons
Proud to bhi hussaini shia
Kufa ke gaddar 🤣🤣
Proud to be Muslim ❤
Both are Muslim
Not a Shiya Sunni
Yes both are Muslims Yazid bhi Muslim tha.Shia the followers of the Prophet and his family,Sunnis the followers of Umar.
@@razakurji9745 What.... the prophet( swaws) folded his hands in salah...
Hazrat Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) said:
When anyone of you stand for prayer (salaah) than he should place his hands on his chest.
Book : Khisal
Page : 414
Wa’il ibn Hujr reported: He saw the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, raise his hands upon entering into prayer, exalting Allah, and Hammam described his hands as parallel to his ears. Then, the Prophet wrapped his hands in his cloak and placed his right hand over his left hand. When he intended to bow, he would take his hands out from his cloak, raise them, exalt Allah, and then bow. When the Prophet said, “Allah hears those who praise him,” he would raise his hands. When the Prophet prostrated, he prostrated between his two palms.
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 401
This is recorded by Imam Tirmidhi in his “Sunan” [Al-Manaaqib, manaaqib Abu Bakr and ‘Umar]
حدثنا الحسن بن الصباح البزار أخبرنا سفيان بن عيينة عن زائدة عن عبد الملك بن عمير عن ربعي هو ابن حراش عن حذيفة قال قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم “اقتدوا بالذين من بعدي أبي بكر وعمر”
Narrated by Hudhaifa (ra), he said: Prophet (saw) said, “follow those after me: Abu Bakr and Umar.”
Imam Tirmidhi said, narrated to us Hasan b. Sabbaah, reported to us Sufiyan bin Uyaina, from Zaa’ida, from Abdul Malik bin ‘Umair, from Raba’ee b. Haraash, from Hudhaifa (ra) …hadith…
Dr. Bashshaar Awwad said in his Tahqeeq of in the tahqeeq of above hadith: Humaidy (449), Musnad Ahmed (5/382), Sharh Mushkil al-Aathaar (1226, 1227, 1228, 1229), Baghwi(3895).
This hadith has also been recorded by Ibn Sa’d (2/334), Tahawi in “Sharh Mashkil al-Aathaar” (1229), Baghwi (3893) without having the name of Zaa’idah in the Sanad.[Tahqeeq Sunan Tirmidhi (6/43), h-3662]
Tirmidhi said : and this hadith has also come through Sufiyan Thawri, from Abdul Malik b. ‘Umair, from servant of Raba’ee, from Raba’ee, from Hudhaifa.
Regarding this, Dr. Bashshar Awwad said: This has been recorded by Ibn Sa’d (2/334), Ibn Abi Shaiba (12/11), Ahmed (5/385, 402), Ibn Majah (97), Faswi in “Al-Ma’riah wa At-Tareekh”(1/480), Ibn Abi Aasim in “As-Sunnah” (1048), Tahawi in “Sharh Mushkil” (1224), Al-Hakim (3/75), Khateeb in “Tareekh” (4/347). [See Tahqeeq Tirmidhi by Bashhar Awwaad, vol.6, page-43,44]
In another narration the name of servant of Raba’ee is mention.
Tirmidhi said: “this has also narrated by Ibraheem b. Sa’d, from Sufiyan Thawri, from Abdul Malik bin ‘Umair, from Hilaal slave of Raba’ee, from Raba’ee, from Hudhaifa.”
This is recorded by Bukhari in his “At-Tarikh Al-Kabeer” (8/no. 2741), Al-Faswi in “Al-Ma’rifah” (1/480), Ibn Abi Aasim (1149), Tahawi in “Sharh Mushkil Al-Aathar” (1230, 1231, 1232) [See “Tahqeeq Tirmidhi” by Bashhar Awwaad, vol.6, page-43,44]
As it is clear that all the above mentioned chain goes back to a common narrator Abdul Malik bin ‘Umair, and he is Thiqah (trustworthy) [“Taqreeb” (2/364. no.4200), “Al-Meezan” (2/660, no.5235)]. But he is also a well known ‘mudallis’, i.e. one who used to hide the narrator in the sanad with ambiguous words (but not necessarily everytime).
And in the above routes sometimes Abdul Malik narrates from Hilal servant of Raba’ee, and sometime he narrates directly from Raba’ee. This cause very few scholars to declare this hadith to be unauthentic (e.g. Ibn Hazm). However they were wrong and major scholars said otherwise, as we’ll see insha Allah.
As for the Tadlees of Abdul Malik, then one should keep in mind that its not necessary that all the narrations of a Mudallis is Tadlees. Abdul Malik might have heard this narration from both Hilaal and Raba’ee, as he had seen even great companions like Ali b. Abi Talib and his hearing from Raba’ee is proven. On the other hand its also possible that this narration is really a Tadlees, and Abdul Malik hide the narrator Hilal from the Sanad. If he has heard this from Raba’ee then the narration would be Sahih. And if Abdul Malik heard this from Hilaal then also the Sanad would be atleast Hasan. This is because Hilaal is “Maqbool” according to Ibn Hajar, [Taqreeb 2/576] meaning his narration should be acted upon in case if there are other chain to support it. And there are many chain to support this as shown below.
@@razakurji9745
This is recorded by Imam Tirmidhi in his “Sunan” [Al-Manaaqib, manaaqib Abu Bakr and ‘Umar]
حدثنا الحسن بن الصباح البزار أخبرنا سفيان بن عيينة عن زائدة عن عبد الملك بن عمير عن ربعي هو ابن حراش عن حذيفة قال قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم “اقتدوا بالذين من بعدي أبي بكر وعمر”
Narrated by Hudhaifa (ra), he said: Prophet (saw) said, “follow those after me: Abu Bakr and Umar.”
Imam Tirmidhi said, narrated to us Hasan b. Sabbaah, reported to us Sufiyan bin Uyaina, from Zaa’ida, from Abdul Malik bin ‘Umair, from Raba’ee b. Haraash, from Hudhaifa (ra) …hadith…
Dr. Bashshaar Awwad said in his Tahqeeq of in the tahqeeq of above hadith: Humaidy (449), Musnad Ahmed (5/382), Sharh Mushkil al-Aathaar (1226, 1227, 1228, 1229), Baghwi(3895).
This hadith has also been recorded by Ibn Sa’d (2/334), Tahawi in “Sharh Mashkil al-Aathaar” (1229), Baghwi (3893) without having the name of Zaa’idah in the Sanad.[Tahqeeq Sunan Tirmidhi (6/43), h-3662]
Tirmidhi said : and this hadith has also come through Sufiyan Thawri, from Abdul Malik b. ‘Umair, from servant of Raba’ee, from Raba’ee, from Hudhaifa.
Regarding this, Dr. Bashshar Awwad said: This has been recorded by Ibn Sa’d (2/334), Ibn Abi Shaiba (12/11), Ahmed (5/385, 402), Ibn Majah (97), Faswi in “Al-Ma’riah wa At-Tareekh”(1/480), Ibn Abi Aasim in “As-Sunnah” (1048), Tahawi in “Sharh Mushkil” (1224), Al-Hakim (3/75), Khateeb in “Tareekh” (4/347). [See Tahqeeq Tirmidhi by Bashhar Awwaad, vol.6, page-43,44]
In another narration the name of servant of Raba’ee is mention.
Tirmidhi said: “this has also narrated by Ibraheem b. Sa’d, from Sufiyan Thawri, from Abdul Malik bin ‘Umair, from Hilaal slave of Raba’ee, from Raba’ee, from Hudhaifa.”
This is recorded by Bukhari in his “At-Tarikh Al-Kabeer” (8/no. 2741), Al-Faswi in “Al-Ma’rifah” (1/480), Ibn Abi Aasim (1149), Tahawi in “Sharh Mushkil Al-Aathar” (1230, 1231, 1232) [See “Tahqeeq Tirmidhi” by Bashhar Awwaad, vol.6, page-43,44]
As it is clear that all the above mentioned chain goes back to a common narrator Abdul Malik bin ‘Umair, and he is Thiqah (trustworthy) [“Taqreeb” (2/364. no.4200), “Al-Meezan” (2/660, no.5235)]. But he is also a well known ‘mudallis’, i.e. one who used to hide the narrator in the sanad with ambiguous words (but not necessarily everytime).
And in the above routes sometimes Abdul Malik narrates from Hilal servant of Raba’ee, and sometime he narrates directly from Raba’ee. This cause very few scholars to declare this hadith to be unauthentic (e.g. Ibn Hazm). However they were wrong and major scholars said otherwise, as we’ll see insha Allah.
As for the Tadlees of Abdul Malik, then one should keep in mind that its not necessary that all the narrations of a Mudallis is Tadlees. Abdul Malik might have heard this narration from both Hilaal and Raba’ee, as he had seen even great companions like Ali b. Abi Talib and his hearing from Raba’ee is proven. On the other hand its also possible that this narration is really a Tadlees, and Abdul Malik hide the narrator Hilal from the Sanad. If he has heard this from Raba’ee then the narration would be Sahih. And if Abdul Malik heard this from Hilaal then also the Sanad would be atleast Hasan. This is because Hilaal is “Maqbool” according to Ibn Hajar, [Taqreeb 2/576] meaning his narration should be acted upon in case if there are other chain to support it. And there are many chain to support this as shown below.
@@razakurji9745 Weldon 👍
Proud to be a Sunni Muslim.
Alhamdulillah, I'm muslim but the major problem is that our people is stuck in shia- sunni debate and Islam's enemies are advancing technologically
It's been 1445 years ago to be revealed the Holy Quran and you muslims still don't know the namaz....
Such a shame 😞
USA ke most advanced technology wale drone ko maarke girane wale nation ka naam pata hai? Woh log Shia-Sunni debates bhi karte hain aur technology advancement bhi karte hain. Kyonki woh dono ki importance ko jaante hain. Afsos aapne waqt ko muyyan nahi kiya apne liye isi liye pichad gaye.
Muslims tr
Farq ayaa jab musalman ny hazrat Ali as ka haq sahaba ko dy dyh........Or hatta k rasool k aal ko chor k sahaba ko chor dyh.......To isky culprit sahaba hain.....
Haq Ali k sath hai ....❤
Mula ali nafse rasool hai mashaallah ❤
Aur ye nafs e rasool sunni aiim ke hisab se abubakr umar usman se niche tar hai, ye abukakr umar usman nafs e rasool se badhkar hai, afzal hai koi logic bhi kaam karti hai.
I just adore Owais rabbani's way of asking questions
Loads of love from Kashmir❤
Karr kaema kaara
The best thing i found in this podcast is both of respectful Scholars, behaved very polite and respectful to each other.
Salam Mola Hussain AS Mola Abbas AS 😭♥️🇩🇪
Mufti sahab ne SAAF SAAF bata diya Ittehaad pasand nhi hai mufti sahab ko....
Par alhumdulillah molana hayat sahab ne bata diya HUM SHIA(ALHUMDULILLAH) ittehaad karna chahte hai isiliye namaz bhi kisi bhi firqe ke imam ke pichhe padh sakte hai.❤"HAIDER E QARRAR"🙌🏻❤
❤ LABBAIK YA HUSSAIN AS ❤
Ma Sha Allah, Allama sahab did a great job free from firqa wariyat tried to unite muslims Ma Sha Allah
Mola ali a.s allah aor uske rasul ke baad sub se afzal
Rasul Allah s.a.w ki hadees e mubarak hai Mane Kun to mola fahaza aliun mola jis jis ka me mola us us ka ye ali mola ab aap khud faisla kare Nabi e Karim kis kis ke mola hai ❤
❤ JIS NAMAZI K DIL MAIN MUHABBAT EHLAY BAIT AS NA HO ... USKI NAMAZ MUN PAR DAY K MARI JAYE GI
Hath khol kar namaz parna Hi Nabi saww ka tarika hai, Sunni ref… Sunan Abu Dawud 730❤
Abe jahil inginiyar Mirza ke moqallid tamam ambiya alaihissalam ki sunnat hai daya hath baya hat par rakhna hai
Amma aaesha rajiyallaho anha riwayat karti hai
اصحاب نے دن میں دو گھنٹے رسول اکرم کے ساتھ گزارے ھونگے لیکن حضرت علی نے نبی اکرم کے گھر میں پرورش پائ۔۔
Ap log sahabi se nafrat q krty he
Last line ❤ namaz me to 12 ke manne wale h.
Namaz ke bahar nahi mante .
Wah re musalman😅
❤ya Ali madad 🤲❤
Mashaallah, I am proud to be shia muslim.
Shia Alim sahee fermarahey hey
Well done ,informative , well explained program ,
Perfectly framed Questions . Keep up the great work
Quran aur ahlebait thats clear
Awais rabbani bro you are doing excellent work please keep this kind of knowledge conversation going,
Dawat e hakk, without firkawariyat, Shia alim is great source of knowledge and Logic......
اللہ کریم سے یہ دعا ہے کہ یہ چاند ہمارے لئے پورا سال باعث رحمت ،صحت اور تندرستی کے ساتھ، ایمان کی سلامتی کے ساتھ، قرضوں سے نجات اور ملک اور قوم کی خوشحالی کی نوید ساتھ لے کر آئے۔آمین ثم آمین یا رب العالمین
Molana sahib ne bilkul drust farmaya Allah pak jazay kher ata farmaye ♥️♥️♥️
Proud to be Hussaini😊
Hazrat Abdullah ibn Zubair never prayed with closed hands but always with open hands.
Proud to be sunni waah ekdum sahi btaya unhone and shia scholar ne bhi politely baat kiya
Healthy and positive discussion. If these two gentlemen can talk peacefully and tolerantly, why not others.
A best host ever .Awaise Rabbani from Skardu❤❤
حضرت علی رضی اللہ عنہ کے پاس پانی لایا گیا، تو انہوں نے کھڑے ہو کر پیا اور
فرمایا :
کہ لوگوں میں سے بعض کھڑے ہو کر پانی پینے کو مکروہ سمجھتے ہیں اور میں نے نبی صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کو (ایسا ہی) کرتے دیکھا، جس طرح تم نے مجھے کرتے ہوئے دیکھا۔
صحیح بخاری:جلد سوم:
Great knowledge sunni scholar ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Labbik ya hussain....zindabad raho shia n ALI🎉
what an amazing topic , well done,Much needed discussion. Waiting for more
Yeh ukaat hain in dono ulamh sue ki. awaam kay agay nangay ho gaye kay haath Banda aur choorna sabat hai rasool ullah aur sahaba say. Lekin dono apnay firkay kay gutter may itnay doobay howay hai kay dil may uss Namaz ko Sahi nahi samjtay lekin audiences kay lege inkaar nahi ker saktay kay sabat hai. Yahi hain woh Kuttay Jin ka zikker Quran may kia gaya hai ur hanzeer ki terha in ki antay inkay irdh girdh ho gee. The common Muslims must save themselves from these Ulamah sue of sects because they have nothing to do with Islam. All 72 sects are going to hell, and this is what rasool ullah told us. Sunni and Shia are the leaders of 72. And u can count they counted like 50 sects from Shia and sunni juat sitting here. all of them are astray because they will never believe in the full Islam of Quran and Sahi hadees. They pick and choose hadees even Quran ayat based on their astray sects. Yeh in haramio ki ukaat hai.
MashaAllah loving your podcast
Thanks
Bohat behtreen program he apka. is m hume her maslaq ke new Ulma ko sunne ka moqa milta he or bohat mohabat bharha mahol jis m koi cheekho pukar chilana larna nh hota sunne m maza ata.
Allah Tallah apko jaiza e khair de.
i am shia and i appreciate this healthy discussion and constructive criticism. MashaAllah how they both respected each other without being too loud.
Amazing Topic. Healthy discussion
Well done .keep up the great work. 👍
Shukria
@@OwaisRabbanitake Hassan allahyari in live program
🌷🎁🌷مومنین کو ہفتہ ولایت مبارک: (18 تا 24 ذی الحج۔۔ عید غدیر تا عید مباہلہ) ❤❤عید غدیر■ حضرت محمد ص پہ ختم نبوت کی دلیل، ⚘دین کی تکمیل اور ⚘اللہ س کی نعمتوں کے کمال تک پہنچنے۔ ⚘قیامت تک کے لیئے رسول اللہ ص کے خلفاء راشدین اور امت کے اماموں کی تعیین ⚘رسول ص کے بعد دین (احادیث و تفسیر) جس سے لینا ہے اسکی تعیین۔۔۔۔۔۔۔ کا دن۔ 🌷💙جب رسول اللہ ص نے فرمایا۔ "جس جس کا میں آقا و مولا ہوں اس اس کا یہ علی آقا و مولا ہے"۔ 🌷💚💙اسی مقام پہ حدیث متواتر ثقلین و خلیفتین بھی فرمائی کہ "میں تم میں دو گرانقدر چیزیں (2 خلیفے) قرآن اور میری آل پاک ع یعنی میرے اہل بیت تطہیر ع چھوڑے جا رہا ہوں کہ جب تک تم ان سے متمسک رہو گے۔ میرے بعد ہر گز گمراہ نہیں ہو گے۔ اور یہ دونوں ایک دوسرے سے کبھی جدا نہیں ہوں گے۔ یہاں تک کہ حوض کوثر پہ مجھے ملیں" 🌷😭😭😭🌷 مگر سقیفہ میں رسول الخاتم ص کے انہیں متواتر فرامین کو روند کے جنت کے سردار علی مولا ع سے انکا حق یعنی اسلام کا حق "خلافت بلافصل" غصب کیا۔ اور اہل بیت تطہیر ع کو دیوار سے لگایا گیا
❤💚❤ عید مباہلہ● کہ جب اللہ س کے حکم سے رسول اللہ ص اپنے معصوم اہل بیت تطہیر کو ضدی و ہٹ دھرم جھوٹوں (عیسائیوں) کے خلاف اور ان پہ لعنت کے لیئے لے کے نکلے۔ 💙 اور نصاری ان ہستیوں سے لعنت کے مقابلہ (مباہلہ) سے دستبردار ہو کے پیچھے ہٹ گئے۔۔ 🌷😭😭😭🌷مگر۔۔ ان اہل بیت تطہیر ع، جنت کے سرداروں کے فدک و خلافت بلافصل جیسے حقوق کو خود (نام نہاد) مسلمانوں نے ہی رسول ص کے بعد لوٹا۔ ● دربدر کیا۔ ● ان سے جنگیں کیں۔ ● ان کو نمازوں میں گالیوں لعنتوں کا نشانہ بنایا۔ ● ان کو زہر و اسلحہ سے قتل کیا۔ ● ان کی خواتین بچوں۔ بیماروں۔ زخمیوں کو قیدی بنا کے درباروں بازاروں میں پھرایا۔۔۔ 🌷💜🌷 ان عیدوں پہ 💙(🌷سورہ المائدہ: آیات 3۔۔ 67-- ⚘سورہ المعارج: ابتدائی چند عذاب والی آیات۔۔ ⚘سورہ آل عمران:61 کے مقام نزول۔۔۔ 💖📚سنی شیعہ تفاسیر سے ان آیات شریفہ کے شان نزول دیکھے جا سکتے ہیں)۔
Proud to shia.
Sunni bhaiyon Shia haq pr hain ❤ Allah sabki Hedayat kare
Shia alim is right way
Ahlesunnat aalim sahih farma rahay hain
MASHALLAH ❤
Proud to be a Shia Muslim
Proud to be shian e Ali a s
Allah tabarak hum sub may itehad or ek dosry ki Respect karna ki Hidiyat dy
Itehad e Ben uL Muslmeen Zdabad , Pakistan zindabad
Behtreen topic❤ simply Awesome 👍 looking forward for more.....
Thanks, Will surely do it
Proud To Be Ahle Hadees❤
Owais Bhai!
Beautiful conversation and what a respect. we must all follow this. Respect each other.End of day we pray to Allah.
نماز میں تکبیر تحریمہ کے علاوہ ہاتھوں کو نہ اٹھانا بھی مسنون ہے:
حَدَّثَنَا هَنَّادٌ حَدَّثَنَا وَکِيعٌ عَنْ سُفْيَانَ عَنْ عَاصِمِ بْنِ کُلَيْبٍ عَنْ عَبْدِ الرَّحْمَنِ بْنِ الْأَسْوَدِ عَنْ عَلْقَمَةَ قَالَ قَالَ عَبْدُ اللّٰهِ بْنُ مَسْعُودٍ أَلَا أُصَلّي بِکُمْ صَلَاةَ رَسُولِ اللّٰهِ صَلَّی اللّٰهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ فَصَلَّی فَلَمْ يَرْفَعْ يَدَيْهِ إِلَّا فِي أَوَّلِ مَرَّةٍ. قَالَ وَفِي الْبَاب عَنِ الْبَرَاءِ بْنِ عَازِبٍ قَالَ أَبُو عِيسَی حَدِيثُ ابْنِ مَسْعُودٍ حَدِيثٌ حَسَنٌ وَبِهِ يَقُولُ غَيْرُ وَاحِدٍ مِنْ أَهْلِ الْعِلْمِ مِنْ أَصْحَابِ النَّبِيّ صَلَّی اللّٰهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ وَالتَّابِعِينَ وَهُوَ قَوْلُ سُفْيَانَ الثَّوْرِيّ وَأَهْلِ الْکُوفَةِ.
حضرت علقمہ رحمہ اللّٰہ بیان کرتے ہیں کہ حضرت عبد اللّٰہ بن مسعود رضی اللّٰہ عنہ نے فرمایا: کیا میں تمہیں رسول اللّٰہ (ﷺ) کی نماز نہ پڑھاؤں؟ تو انہوں نے نماز پڑھائی اور صرف پہلی مرتبہ میں اپنے دونوں ہاتھ اٹھائے. امام ترمذی رحمہ اللّٰہ کہتے ہیں: حضرت ابن مسعود رضی اللّٰہ عنہ کی حدیث حسن ہے، اس باب میں حضرت براء بن عازب رضی اللّٰہ عنہ سے بھی حدیث آئی ہے، کئی اہل علم صحابہ کرام اور تابعین میں سے یہی کہتے ہیں اور یہی سفیان ثوری اور اہل کوفہ کا بھی قول ہے.
(سنن الترمذی - رقم الحدیث:257)
اس حدیث کی تصحیح و توثیق کرنے والے اور اس سے حجت پکڑنے والے ائمہ حدیث:
سفیان ثوری رحمہ اللّٰہ: اس حدیث کے مرکزی راوی سید الحفاظ امیر المومنین فی الحدیث کا خود بھی اس پر عمل ہے یعنی ان کے نزدیک بھی یہ حدیث صحیح ہے.
(سنن الترمذی - ج1 ص297)
امام ترمذی رحمہ اللّٰہ: اس حدیث کو حسن اور ایک نسخۃ میں حسن صحیح کہتے ہیں.
(سنن الترمذی - ج1 ص297)
(شرح سنن ابی داؤد للعینی - ج3 ص341)
امام ابو علی الطوسی رحمہ اللّٰہ: وَحَدِيثُ ابْنِ مَسْعُودٍ حَسَنٌ کہتے ہیں.
(مختصر الأحكام مستخرج الطوسي على جامع الترمذي - 2/103)
امام نسائی رحمہ اللّٰہ نے اس حدیث سے حجت پکڑی.
(سنن نسائی - رقم الحدیث:1027)
محدث ابو جعفر طحاوی رحمہ اللّٰہ نے اس حدیث سے حجت پکڑی.
(شرح معاني الآثار - رقم الحديث: 1349,1350)
امام دار قطنی رحمہ اللّٰہ: اسنادہ صحیح کہتے ہیں.
(کتاب العلل للدار قطنی - 5/172)
امام ابن حزم رحمہ اللّٰہ: صَحَّ خَبَرُ ابْنِ مَسْعُودٍ کہتے ہیں.
( المحلی بالآثار - ج 2ص578)
عبد الحق الإشبيلي رحمہ اللّٰہ: هَذَا حَدِيث حسن کہتے ہیں.
(كتاب الأحكام الكبرى لعبد الحق الإشبيلي - 2/191)
امام ابن القطان الفاسی رحمہ اللّٰہ: والحديث عندي لعدالة رواته أقرب إلى الصحة کہتے ہیں.
(بيان الوهم والإيهام للفاسی - ج5 ص367)
ابن التركماني رحمہ اللّٰہ: والحاصل ان رجال هذا الحديث على شرط مسلم کہتے ہیں.
(كتاب الجوهر النقي - 2/78)
امام مغلطائی رحمہ اللّٰہ: حديثاً صحيحاً کہتے ہیں.
(شرح سنن ابن ماجه لمغلطاي - 5/1468)
امام زیلعی رحمہ اللّٰہ: و الرجوع الی صحۃ الحدیث لورودہ عن الثقات کہتے ہیں.
( نصب الرایۃ للزیلعی - ج1 ص396)
امام عینی رحمہ اللّٰہ: والحاصل أن رجال هذا الحديث على شرط مسلم، فالحديث حينئذ صحيح کہتے ہیں.
(كتاب نخب الأفكار - ج4 ص166)
أبو الفيض مرتضى، الزّبيدي رحمہ اللّٰہ: والحاصل أن رجال هذا الحديث على شرط مسلم کہتے ہیں.
(كتاب تخريج أحاديث إحياء علوم الدين - 1/352)
الملا على القاري رحمہ اللّٰہ نے اس حدیث سے حجت پکڑی. (الأسرار المرفوعة - 1/492)
امام قاسم بن قطلوبغا رحمہ اللّٰہ نے اس حدیث سے حجت پکڑی. (التعریف والاخبار ص304)
اس کے علاوہ غیر مقلدین محقق علماء بھی اس کو صحیح کہتے ہیں.
احمد شاکر المصری: صحیح ( شرح الترمذی - ج2 ص40)
ناصر الدین البانی: وهذا إسناد صحيح على شرط مسلم. فالحق أنه حديث صحيح.
(صحيح سنن أبي داود - 3/338)
صهيب عبد الجبار: (الجامع الصحيح للسنن والمسانيد - ج 25 ص303)
Great Awais Bhai. We want more podcasts
Jazak’Allah
اللَّهُمَّ صَلِّ عَلَى مُحَمَّدٍ وآلِ مُحَمَّدٍ وعَجِّلْ فَرَجَهُمْ
GOOD DEBATES. SHOULD CONTINUE.. MASHALLAH
Yeh ujaat hain in ki dono ulamh sue awaam kay agay nangay go gaye kag haath Bana aur choorna sabat hai rasool ullah aur sahaba say. Lekin dono apnay firkay kay gutter may itnay doobay howay kay dil may uss Namaz ko Sahi nahi samjtay lekin audiences kay lege inkaar nahi ker saktay kay sabat nahi. Yahi hain woh Kuttay Jin ka zikker Qurab may kia gaya hai kay ur hnazzer ki terha in ki antay inkay irdh girdh ho gee. The common Muslims must save themselves from these Ulamah sue of sects becasue they gave nothing to do with Islam. All 72 sects are going to hell and this is what rasool ullah told us. Sunni and Shia are the leaders of 72. And u can count they counted like 50 sects from Shia and sunni all of them are astray because they will never complete full Islam of Quran and Sahi hadees. They pick and choose hadees even Quran based on their astray sects. Yeh in haramio ki ukaat hai.
Best podcast ever
Jazak’Allah
Proud to be shiya asna ashri
MashaAllah
Thanks
Masah Allah jazakallahu kher Allah ulma e haqq ahle Hadith ki hifazat kare ameen ya rab❤❤
الحمداللہ شیعہ مسلم❤
Good job Owais bhi
Thank you
ناصبی ماموں پارٹی جلتا ہے مولا علی علیہ السّلام سے
❤میں کیا بیان کروں گا تیری شان یاعلیء❤ جب تیرا مداح خوان ھے یزدان یاعلیء❤چہروں کو دیکھتا ہوں تیرا زکر چھیڑ کر ❤ھے تیرا زکر نسل کی پہچان یاعلیء ❤
❤مولا علیء کا نام لینے سے مومن اور منافق جدا ہو جاتے ہیں ❤
Allah salamat rakhy both Ullma karim ko
I am sunni but now i am thinking to make shia because shia scholar they havee logically way of talk
Subhan Allah
Hassan Allahyari sahab ko bi invite karein prodcast mein🔥🔥or Hath khol kar parhna sunnat ha hath bhandh kar parhna bidat ha
Bhai Yeah Ikhtalaf wali baat hai ek Dosre ko bura Mat bolo Dono ki Namaz Ho jati hai❤
Allahyari America mai hai
Aur us ka shio sai koi taluk nahi
اللہیاری انتشار ہے اس لئے نہیں بلاتے ہیں
Shaitanyari kisko Muhammad hijab ne nanga kiya tha debate mai😂
@@Ali-ey5ys tumhare shia se kia taluq he kahan se late ho jali certificate 😂😂😂
I love you mola Ali as
What a healthy discussion. Love you from Kargil India
Mr too bro
It is truly commendable to witness a healthy discussion that values the parallelism of respect and the exchange of different perspectives, deserving accolades . . . Good job, keep working with the same level of dedication and excellence👍👍
Thank you for your feedback
Listen Hassan Allahyari and Zarq Naqvi and learn Real Islam.
@@OwaisRabbani talk to sayed arif kazmi
Yeh ukaat hain in dono ulamh sue ki. awaam kay agay nangay ho gaye kay haath Banda aur choorna sabat hai rasool ullah aur sahaba say. Lekin dono apnay firkay kay gutter may itnay doobay howay hai kay dil may uss Namaz ko Sahi nahi samjtay lekin audiences kay lege inkaar nahi ker saktay kay sabat hai. Yahi hain woh Kuttay Jin ka zikker Quran may kia gaya hai ur hanzeer ki terha in ki antay inkay irdh girdh ho gee. The common Muslims must save themselves from these Ulamah sue of sects because they have nothing to do with Islam. All 72 sects are going to hell, and this is what rasool ullah told us. Sunni and Shia are the leaders of 72. And u can count they counted like 50 sects from Shia and sunni juat sitting here. all of them are astray because they will never believe in the full Islam of Quran and Sahi hadees. They pick and choose hadees even Quran ayat based on their astray sects. Yeh in haramio ki ukaat hai.
@@ShiaTrueIslam512real Islam by shai the people who wrote 1000 of letter to Imam Hussain Aleh Salam for giving bayat on his hand and when Imam Hussain Aleh Salam reached karbala they betrayed Imam Hussain and Martyred him.
Lanat Unpar jisne khootot likha Imam Hussain ko aur unpe jinhone Imam Hussain ke karbala aane ke baad unhe tanha chod Diya sirf Jaan aur maal ke Darr se, are chutiyon kufiyon agar uss waqt tum Imam Hussain Aleh Salam ke saath khade hote aur Shaheed hoo jate to Rabb e Kaba ki kasam jisne Imam Hussain ke liye apne Jaan pesh ki hoti to un sabhi Jaan pesh karne walon ko Huzoor Muhammad Mustafa Sallallahu Aleh wa Sallam khud apne haaton se Kausar ka jaam pilate afsoos magar tum kufiyon ne mauka khoo diya sirf Jaan aur maal ke Darr se.
Podcast 💫✨️🙌👍
Thanks Please share feedback Humaira
@OwaisRabbani Great use of platform with amazing topic . There is a need to talk on this topic . Best raised debate!
More power to you
@OwaisRabbani i love your work but most of times u doesnt allow to complete shia alim to speak.....Else love ur work
@@sayedyawaraabdi6514 Baradar you need to watch all of podcasts every alim from every sect has given equal time
Masha Allah
Mashallah 2no ulma bht achy andaz se biyan karty ha
18:14 isliye to divide hota hai Islam ke
“Ye haath kholk kar namaz parta hai iske piche nai parsakte hai” or na 12Imam ka name pata ho Islam kia sikaiga🤦🏻♀️
Proud to be ahle hadees ❤
jake marja gustheke rasull
😂
Alhamdulillah ahlehadees hi Quraan o Hadees ka manhaj hai baqi haq Kam mangharat ziyada
حضرت علی نے بلواسطہ نبی صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم سے طریقہ سیکھا اور شیعہ حضرت علی سے نماز لی ھے۔ اب یہ دیکھیں علی نے ذیادہ وقت نبی مکرم کے ساتھ گزارہ یا اصحاب نے۔ کیا اصحاب اور اہلبیت کا مقابلہ ھو سکتا ھے۔۔
Mufti Rafiq Sahab Lagta Hai Apni Hi Khitabain nhi Parhte
Prayer with open hand in Sahih al Sitah among the ten Companions of the Prophet 👇
1) Sahih Bukhari Hadith 828
2) Sunan Ibn Majah 863
3) Sunan Abi Dawud 734
4) Jami` at-Tirmidhi 304
Who prayer with folded hands 👇
Narrated `Aisha:
That she used to hate that one should keep his hands on his flanks while praying. She said that the Jew used to do so
- Sahih al-Bukhari 3458
Jewish reference
And in front of him he will be careful to put his left hand on his right hand in his prayer
- darchei moshe Orach Chaim, Simon 95:4
Great 👍
Bhai mai ne saari hadeese check ki hai Jaa kar aap ya to ye hadeese dekhe nahi ho ya phir saaf saaf jhoot bol rahe ho .,yahdee kumullah
@@rightway3914ankhain khol kr check krain mil Jayega Pura tareka don't worry ja kr dekhain Pura tareka bataya hai Kahi bhi Hadith main hath bandhna nhi likha all bone straight back to original position mentioned
@@rightway3914 Yaha screenshot ka option nhi wrna wo post krta main
its a good subject , you should get all the muslim countries imams/scholars to have a panel of discusion
unfortunately, that would only create chaos, a single host can hardly handle two guests at a time
Very good question rabbani bhai
Jazak allah khair dua hai
Behtreen platform ilmi akhtalf dor krne ke behter koshesh hai awais bhai ap ka andaz b👍
Alhamdullilah Ahlul hadees
Sunni molvi ka chara q utar jata ha mola ali ka name sunta he
@@mohdbaqir5302 hum Ali RA se waise mohabbat krte jaise Allah Ke Rasool ne btaya ! Mangarth riwayat ka sahar nhi lete !!
@@DawahToday Nabi kay baad sab se afzal kon?
If you can invite Hassan Allahyari virtually in your podcast, that'd be highly appreciated.
بغیر کسی کے سلف کی گستاخی کئے عالمانہ طریقے سے یہ مقالمہ اچھا لگا۔
اختلاف اگر اچھے طریقے سے کیا جائے تو یہ بھی باعث برکت ہے
Well explained by Sunni Alim