What If All BFDI Contestants were in BFDIA

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 25. 08. 2024
  • This my favorite of the bunch so far, I like this scenario quite a lot and hopeful someone watching this will continue where I left off or make their own from the beginning just like this one also shoutout to Pencils Animation for commenting on one of my What If videos
    Tags: #battlefordreamisland#bfdi#bfdiwhatif#whatifbfdi#battlefordreamislandwhatif#bfdia#battlefrodreamislandagain#bfdiawhatif#whatifbfdia#osc#objectshow#object#obejectshowcommunity

Komentáře • 124

  • @CrayonsOfColour
    @CrayonsOfColour Před měsícem +11

    9:22 how does this disqualify fries? I feel like he’d just do some random other thing to keep him in, plot armour would keep fries in no matter what.

    • @maniacaal
      @maniacaal Před 20 dny

      Yeah I agree, it wasn't a Teardrop in TPOT situation with Fries so I feel like that was a really dumb choice to make

  • @jpvera3042
    @jpvera3042 Před 2 měsíci +43

    What if the failed debuters also joined, there were 8 teams of 8, but it canonically takes place after BFDIA and IDFB? Oh, and what about in episode 16 the show gets split, making two shows? I think that would be pretty cool.

    • @TrissyTGHYT
      @TrissyTGHYT Před 2 měsíci +7

      and also what if the hosts were sentient numbers and an x

    • @girlpower_gacha
      @girlpower_gacha Před 2 měsíci +4

      And what if those numbers had extremely op powers

    • @jpvera3042
      @jpvera3042 Před 2 měsíci +5

      oh yeah that would be cool too! Jacknjellify should do that sometime

    • @Ok56736
      @Ok56736 Před 2 měsíci +2

      @@jpvera3042Yep that would be cool!

    • @GoldolorTheKartKid
      @GoldolorTheKartKid Před 2 měsíci +2

      And what if said sentient Number and X were from a Classic JnJ video?

  • @JaxsonLepley
    @JaxsonLepley Před měsícem +4

    BFDIA 13 was confirmed to be released in mid July and is going to be focused on characters who haven’t been seen in a while

  • @TylerTheMemer
    @TylerTheMemer Před měsícem +11

    You know what's sad? Every season 1 contestant that were present were in season 1 EXCEPT Pen, Blocky, Eraser, and Snowball.

    • @Ridwan45032
      @Ridwan45032 Před měsícem +1

      And Woody (If deceased it counts)

    • @Ridwan45032
      @Ridwan45032 Před měsícem +1

      But Pen was so close to join BFDIA

    • @boxytablet
      @boxytablet Před měsícem

      It’s blocky not block have you even watched the show 😂

    • @SharkTheTitanOfAmazingStuff
      @SharkTheTitanOfAmazingStuff Před měsícem

      David was present

    • @TylerTheMemer
      @TylerTheMemer Před měsícem +4

      ​@@boxytabletBro I've been watching for years it was a spelling mistake 💀

  • @electrowarrior_pvz2
    @electrowarrior_pvz2 Před měsícem +4

    BFDIA 13 is a episode about eliminated contestants

  • @newlife3810
    @newlife3810 Před 2 měsíci +6

    Call to adventure

  • @JaeFresh504
    @JaeFresh504 Před měsícem +2

    Sure Rocky did nothing, but that might also help him go under the radar and be safe against YellowFace who was outright cruel to Bomby for being purple

  • @BlueTheCubeReturns
    @BlueTheCubeReturns Před 2 měsíci +3

    This would happen if Announcer lied

  • @ElloBoi712
    @ElloBoi712 Před 2 měsíci +6

    Donut would go over SB, SB's a veteran plus I'm pretty sure SB would do most of the tugging so he'd survive but oh well, still a good video

    • @pillowrain
      @pillowrain Před 8 dny

      yeah, the whole team except for Donut were veterans, why didn't someone else go? why Snowball? leafy stole Dream Island and still she's safe?

    • @ElloBoi712
      @ElloBoi712 Před 8 dny

      @@pillowrain fr

  • @ghytseries5101
    @ghytseries5101 Před 15 dny

    In this timeline, W.O.A.H. Bunch reigned supreme, and i guess the torture will now be targeted towards FreeSmart and Team No-Name. May i continue this as a BFDIA "My Way"?

  • @TheRedMarkerGuy
    @TheRedMarkerGuy Před 4 dny

    Actually I think that since Pen and bubble are on Team No Name PB may not win the prize due to those 2 being more popular so W.O.A.H Bunch loses in BFDIA 5

  • @Gaming_with_james.
    @Gaming_with_james. Před 14 dny +1

    Bfdia 14 might go with pin getting face and size back, since icy didnt get out, shed only want revenge on ruby and icy not book and for the 2 mini teams it could go
    Pencil match
    Ruby bubble
    Icy book
    Leafy teardrop
    Coiny pin
    Nickel bomby
    Pen eraser
    Dora and needle (suprising, ik)
    Blocky spongy
    and tb would solo it
    Freesmart woukd work together
    Woah bunch woukd slip up into group
    Tennis ball could do good
    The placements would be
    1st: needle dora (bfb dora is how shed be)
    2nd: pen eraser (they could get there right after the other 2)
    3rd: blocky, spongy ( pen and ereaser would help them)
    4th: pencil, match (they both can easility work together, like friends would)
    5th:ruby bubble (help off pencil and match)
    6th: book, icy (same as bubs and ruby
    7th: tb (he could make a good invention)
    8th: leafy, td (td would carry
    9th: pin, coiny (they could get top 5, but pin has the mechsuit)
    Last: nickel, bomby (they prob would mess up a ton)
    Who would get out?
    Nickek would win prize cuz of his goofiness
    But bomby would be safe due to nickel saracasm, what a td senario!

  • @SharkTheTitanOfAmazingStuff
    @SharkTheTitanOfAmazingStuff Před 2 měsíci +3

    The only reason why Firey got eliminated in BFDIA 8 is because he got botted

    • @Imam14-q6y
      @Imam14-q6y Před měsícem

      Oh no

    • @Ridwan45032
      @Ridwan45032 Před měsícem

      Because he won season 1

    • @insert2006
      @insert2006 Před měsícem +2

      He wasn't botted, he was voted off because he try to sabotage Freesmart along with Gelatin
      Also most of you saying who got eliminated are botted

    • @amethyst_2763
      @amethyst_2763 Před měsícem

      @@Ridwan45032 that doesn't mean he should be eliminated THAT early.

  • @Sticky_note_and_friendsy15
    @Sticky_note_and_friendsy15 Před měsícem

    I'm so happy Dora survived for a while

  • @dalV_Studio
    @dalV_Studio Před 26 dny

    Everything was good until Golf Ball got eliminated

  • @deez8769
    @deez8769 Před 21 dnem

    Ofc acoustic woody got out early

  • @PeytonandsadieAugest2024
    @PeytonandsadieAugest2024 Před 2 měsíci +1

    In Bfdia 5e bubble got disqualified. Not still here

  • @VJ101ISBEST
    @VJ101ISBEST Před měsícem

    Can you do What if all the BFDI contestants joined BFDIA and all the failed debuters also joined BFDIA next?

  • @Italy-plays
    @Italy-plays Před měsícem

    GOOD JOB MAKE PART TWO

  • @Ridwan45032
    @Ridwan45032 Před měsícem

    0:31 Why did Leafy Switch? She was friends with Firey

  • @thesmm2311
    @thesmm2311 Před 3 měsíci +6

    I don't think I would have jumped into assuming that Leafy and Evil Leafy are the same person so quickly for this What if.
    Also, is there a reason for Gelatin to crush Leafy?

    • @oddballer5950
      @oddballer5950  Před 3 měsíci +2

      Uh well no in-canon Gelatin just crushed her for an unknown reason

    • @raphaelreacts1936
      @raphaelreacts1936 Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@oddballer5950 doesn't him and firey say the right after

  • @Ridwan45032
    @Ridwan45032 Před 27 dny

    Can you do what if BFDIA had randomized contestants

  • @Kthenoob2280
    @Kthenoob2280 Před 2 měsíci +1

    3:35 wouldn’t they go to from the start,I mean coiny was always on that team

    • @oddballer5950
      @oddballer5950  Před 2 měsíci

      Well I feel like they would want to be on the larger team at the beginning

  • @ryousuke_superior
    @ryousuke_superior Před 2 měsíci +1

    I thought Woody would stay over David.

    • @tyworld-vg9yu
      @tyworld-vg9yu Před 2 měsíci

      yes he would if he was in bfdia they prob try to improve him like bfb but not as much so david would go

    • @tyworld-vg9yu
      @tyworld-vg9yu Před 2 měsíci

      also easer and td would have there rivalry start here sense this would be a good time to start that

  • @Mystic_chip
    @Mystic_chip Před 2 měsíci

    What about the fact, with all characters present it would be the original cast of BFDIA, before all the rules came in

  • @sehjaskohli598
    @sehjaskohli598 Před 2 měsíci

    Episode five strikes woody once again.

  • @the-youtube-show
    @the-youtube-show Před měsícem

    Wow, that's alot of people

  • @King_Waffle7789o0
    @King_Waffle7789o0 Před 2 měsíci +2

    But leafy and David not in the show

  • @TacoAAnimator
    @TacoAAnimator Před 2 měsíci +1

    Instead of having bfdia 5b not happen how about leafy got mad because of pin talking smack about her and turned into evil leafy

  • @samizaag1316
    @samizaag1316 Před měsícem

    Then u will be happy because boibuy is here

  • @JaxLacasandile
    @JaxLacasandile Před 2 měsíci

    Fries is gonna go Cray Cray in the WTF

    • @hamdanitahir6948
      @hamdanitahir6948 Před 2 měsíci

      WHAT DID YOU SAY no bad word in our CZcams channel

    • @JaxLacasandile
      @JaxLacasandile Před 2 měsíci

      @@hamdanitahir6948 relax it means the weak trembling fortress did you watch Bfdia 7

  • @Paninw306
    @Paninw306 Před 28 dny +1

    Predict:Tb switches to no name and free smart loses 100% well pencil wins the prize and book is probably eliminated the prize is (using a word generator) firm? Well I guess a firm from loser idk
    BFDIA 14
    Free smart uses a swap token on needle and make teardrop switch like Coiny did,and blocky,eraser and pen will switch to a new team letting Coiny and pin switch creating team no name once again,that will probably lose the contest,Coiny wins the prize and pen is not popular as the others so he is eliminated.the prize is… a banana GENERATOR WTF
    BFDIA 15
    No name switches to woah bunch because of the error they made and freesmart loses once again ruby is wins the prize that is…tin! What the- anyway ice cube is eliminated
    BFDIA 16
    At this one freesmart get angry and make switch leafy,Dora and nickel and wins pin wins the prize that is… an umbrella :l oh also spongy is eliminated right before rejoin
    BFDIA 17
    REJOIN TIME! Least votes:spongy most votes:fries. Fries rejoins on freesmart cuz won last time
    I will do BFDIA 18 to 23 when I am feeling to (probably tomorrow) and reply if something is wrong and see you next time :)

    • @oddballer5950
      @oddballer5950  Před 28 dny

      No dude this is great Thank You man

    • @Paninw306
      @Paninw306 Před 27 dny

      @@oddballer5950thanks today I will do part 2 (18 to 23)

    • @Paninw306
      @Paninw306 Před 27 dny

      As I was saying
      BFDIA 18
      I think that the failed rejoinders will explore Yoyolecity like in BFDIA 13 did (I mean in the real timeline) so there will be no elimination but there will still be the laser and the flying LOL
      BFDIA 19
      Woah bunch wins and time for the elimination,Needle,that in this timeline switched to freesmart wins the prize that is… a sign WORD GENERATOR CAN YOU PLEASE MAKE SOMETHING USEFUL? anyway Dora is not that enjoyable so she is eliminated
      BFDIA 20
      DEBUT TIME!!!I will use only the actual debuters of this season and the points all the way back in BFDIA 1… with 36 votes,Lollipop JOINS THE GAME *sound when winner debuted in tpot.mp3* and will join on freesmart because of the least members
      BFDIA 21
      wow I didn’t think I could make a timeline THIS FAR.By the way now I think freesmart wins and let’s see in woah bunch who will be eliminated…coiny wins the prize that is an ape (???) and tb is eliminated because he wasn’t even trying to win after golf ball gone
      BFDIA 22
      Nothing special will happen in this episode and whoa bunch loses,blocky will block the other to win a prize that is a street but can’t block the elimination of his friend eraser that gets erased from the game
      BFDIA 23
      Freesmart finally loses nickel and teardrop wins a cloud
      Probably today I will do to 24 to 30 and bye :)

    • @Paninw306
      @Paninw306 Před 27 dny

      As i promised,here is the part 3 (i will stop at the ending of this season)
      BFDIA 24- wait wait wait let’s do a recap in woah bunch there are:coiny,blocky,pin,bomby,in freesmart:ruby,needle nickel,fries,lollipop,pencil,match,teardrop,bubble,leafy.ok now we can
      BFDIA 24
      Needle,fries and leafy switch again causing freesmart to lose,ruby wins a ball and nickel run ends here
      BFDIA 25
      REJOIN TIME! (Looking in the BFDIA 1 debut leaderboard)it’s not donut,it’s gelatin with 52 votes joining woah bunch one again!
      BFDIA 26
      DOUBLE ELIMINATION!!! This time there is no contest,no prize and 1 elimination each team starting off with woah bunch at the bottom 3 of blocky,leafy and bomby.Blocky escapes here and bomby survives and leafy will be chased right in the WTF,in freesmart the bottom 3 will be lollipop teardrop and match.lollipop doesn’t get eliminated,match does.
      BFDIA 27
      Lollipop switches for her Bfb self with gelatin causing freesmart to lose pencil this time but ruby’s prize is a bird
      BFDIA 28
      All freesmart members switch except ruby and bubble that somehow win time,unlike bomby does now,also pin wins oxygen
      BFDIA 29
      Today ruby and bubble lose and,since in this timeline bubble is a constant,she will probably get eliminated saying goodbye to ruby’s robot that she won as a prize
      BFDIA 30
      Today we will end here with a debut (using the BFDIA 1 leaderboard) the top 2 is between lightning and marker.Marker will mark the spot for a next contestant joining the game
      Doing part 4 when I am feeling to,bye :)

    • @Paninw306
      @Paninw306 Před 25 dny

      Welcome back to the series that no one asked about cuz I am not getting attention by anyone :(
      BFDIA 31
      Time for a 1000 iq move! Ruby picks a target so Coiny can use launching Pin so she switches,that means coiny will switch too,same as blocky,followed by fries,then gelatin the lollipop creating a split between woah bunch,the old one has time to be eliminated with needle eliminated and with teardrop winning a fan
      BFDIA 32
      FINAL 9!old woah bunch wins and bye bye fries once again,also lollipop wins a painting
      BFDIA 33
      Merge time!no more teams and no alliance,get it coiny? Speaking of coiny,alongside teardrop wins immunity and goodbye gelatin,also no more prizes
      BFDIA 34
      Marker wins,unlike lollipop that get eliminated
      BFDIA 35
      Blocky wins and,since pin is just an object can’t do anything by herself so she gets eliminated
      Mergers: Marker,teardrop,coiny,blocky,ruby
      I will do the ending NOW
      BFDIA 36
      Marker wins and between a small amount of votes with teardrop,blocky Is eliminated
      BFDIA 37
      Ruby wins and marker is eliminated for sure
      BFDIA 38- FINAL 3
      Coiny,Teardrop and Ruby
      Everyone has a great motivation to win
      Ruby:is funny
      Teardrop:is cool
      Coiny:dominated during the season
      Well at 3rd position we have teardrop
      And now the final two,who will win BFDIA
      And the winner is… COINY
      I think it’s pretty obvious that he won,he is the creator of the greatest team in all the seasons
      Well now it’s all over… if you liked this timeline pls tell me in a reply and for the last time bye!

  • @PuppySpark
    @PuppySpark Před 2 měsíci

    I think you forgot everyone hates leafy so her alliance would not mater

  • @JannushanJasotharan
    @JannushanJasotharan Před 2 měsíci

    Teardrop can't die to fire

  • @KomodoKrap420
    @KomodoKrap420 Před 2 měsíci

    Do bfb but even numbers don't count

  • @jampi_2008
    @jampi_2008 Před 2 měsíci

    But... Bfdia 12 only had inmunity for 1 team, why only team no name is ufe?

    • @oddballer5950
      @oddballer5950  Před 2 měsíci

      Because with more contestants they wouldn't have reached the halve-way mark at that point in this scenario

    • @jampi_2008
      @jampi_2008 Před 2 měsíci

      @@oddballer5950 i don't think they would put a team of 2 ufe whitout another team ufe tbh

    • @CrayonsOfColour
      @CrayonsOfColour Před 2 měsíci

      Well I’m pretty sure they only did that because of the “halfway” mark, so it won’t happen here.

    • @jampi_2008
      @jampi_2008 Před 2 měsíci

      @@CrayonsOfColour still makes more sense that put no name ufe whit 2 members

    • @CrayonsOfColour
      @CrayonsOfColour Před 2 měsíci

      @@jampi_2008 it doesn’t.

  • @BHHWandBFDI
    @BHHWandBFDI Před 2 měsíci

    (SPOILER ALERT)
    In bfdia 13, pin will win the prize and bomby will probably get eliminated.

    • @kyrieford6712
      @kyrieford6712 Před 2 měsíci

      1st safe: tennis ball
      2th: Coiny
      3rd: Pin
      4th: fries
      5th: golf ball
      The bottom two are bomby and nickel, last one safe is…
      6th: nickel
      Eliminated: bomby

    • @RadicalBearz
      @RadicalBearz Před 2 měsíci

      Or Nickel

  • @aylenreyes2894
    @aylenreyes2894 Před 2 měsíci

    BFDIA28

  • @Draco15-107
    @Draco15-107 Před 2 měsíci

    //