I really dislike folks blaming their poor pronunciation on the fact they grew up elsewhere. Can clearly hear you have HK accent in your speech and not CBC accent. Why blame it on that? Just own it
Hoi Yee is quite long winded with her technical comments especially to contestants who really really cannot sing...nor do they understand what she is explaining. A bit of a waste of time and quite boring...I can see why Harry always looks annoyed.
At around 1 hr 11 min a male contestant was made to stand at the centre as if he is to compete now but instead was made to wait for the studio staff to get ready for the competition to re-commence! To me, that is poor stage management and extremely unfair to this contestant. He should have been given an opportunity to stay behind the stage and asked to come out only when the studio is set ready for receiving him to compete.
600 5:51:00 Jazz singing and musicality is very good
6:57:43 546千憶個夜晚好聽，Key咁高都上到去，仲成首唱曬，掂！另外，5:14:24 68昆明火鍋店老闆，都係成首唱曬，勁! 其他，2:46:57 642豬農嘅倩影，2:52:03 551保安阿叔嘅倚天屠龍記都好好！以上100強應該沒有問題。
你講的只有68, 和642 可以入100強. 其餘下年再來
68号黑马
有同感
@@jsj1437😅
68已經係歌手級
5:50:53 600 號嗰位加拿大農民唱得好正，而且好有音樂天份
5:15:13 68号劉洋唱《假如》，來自昆明， 火煱店老板，曾唱酒吧3年，也曾夾band, 是一位不可多得的實力參賽者，未來日子應該可以過關斬將，走得更遠。
《假如》
一份愛能承受多少的誤解
熬過飄雪的冬天
一句話能撕裂多深的牽連
變得比陌生人還遙遠
最初的愛越像火焰
最後越會被風熄滅
有時候真話太尖鋭
有人只好説着謊言
假如時光倒流我能做什麼
找你沒説的卻想要的
假如我不放手你多年以後
會怪我恨我或感動
想假如是最空虛的痛
一個人要看過幾次愛凋謝
才甘心在孤獨裏冬眠
最初的愛越像火焰
最後越會被風熄滅
有時候真話太尖鋭
有人只好説着謊言
假如時光倒流我能做什麼
找你沒説的卻想要的
假如我不放手你多年以後
會怪我恨我或感動
想假如是最空虛的痛
為什麼幸福都是幻夢
一靠近天堂也就快醒了
或許愛情更像落葉
看似飛翔卻在墜落
假如時光倒流我能做什麼
找你沒説的卻想要的
假如我不放手你多年以後
會怪我恨我或感動
假如真可以讓時光倒流你會做什麼
一樣選擇我或不抱我
假如温柔放手你是否懂得
走錯了可以再回頭
想假如
是無力的寂寞
“千億個夜晚” 令我流淚了！
佢就黎爆血管
546"選手 多謝 你的真摰演繹
被546真誠的歌聲感動到了！唱得好好！
546 千億個夜晚，唱得非常好，感情非常到位，感動👍👍👍👍👍
A very touching song in his reality!
為甚麼我看不到 546, 在那 ?
@@waimancheung3442 6:57:43
@@waimancheung34426:570
@@waimancheung3442 6:57:41就有546千億個夜晚
有些參賽者常出現的弊病就是：(1)在未開聲唱歌時已show qauli講自己的參賽戰績等等，這樣的話評審自然會對他們寄予厚望，評分會較主觀性。反觀如果唱得好的話，唱完才講出自己的戰績，這反而會加分數。(2)當評審對參賽者的歌唱技巧給予意見時，部分參賽者好像都不會虛心聆聽，他們會替自己找來很多唱得不夠好的藉口，好像不太應同評論，這種態度是不會進步的。
BTW:真心被546號(6:59) [ 中年好司機 ]的(千憶個夜晚)的歌聲感動了！況且他唱得真的很有感情和很有故事性，能穿透別人的心！希望他能入選。🎤🎶👏😃
"546"選手，第一次令我睇直播嘅時候流淚。感謝你的分享❤
+1 👍
What time?
請問什麼時間·546 唱？
@@macauPMF6:57:52
@@jimmyho19836:57:52
600號是唯一唱Jazz的素人參賽者，好正，她應該入到！她更加是受到經常聽hi fi的父親所薰陶，令一眾發燒友更喜愛她👍
600號是唯一、一个我重聽廿次的選手，非常好，特別突出一个。好想再聽到她，有其他不同類型曲風演出。👍
佢入硬108強！ 娛樂性豐富，唱得又唔差，英文國語廣東都得，聽佢語氣想玩比賽，但長玩佢就唔多想，望她順利進入108。
勁👍🏻
At last, some real talent
68 號非常厲害👍👍
5:14:34呢个云南人暂时是我认为今届中3的黑马
應該請佢做表演嘉賓，而吾係參賽者，佢實在好好。
6:57:51 這個參賽者引起直播觀眾流淚
為了入TVB 估唔到咁多打手 😂😂
唔係打手 如果你有睇直播 哩個參賽者唱完 面試要暫停 因為除咗直播觀眾 在現場的人都需要疏理情緒 哩個係當時娛樂新聞台講的 @@jsj1437
多次打斷靚女評判說話!
講真，546 嘅千億個夜晚有唔少沙石，不過實在唱得很感人，而且首歌難度咁高，現場唱有少少沙石係合理嘅。
3:54:00
執迷不悔😂😂😂
笑到抽筋
其實佢男定女？😅
😂😂😂😂😂
@@yan03134佢好似有鬍鬚!😂
@@SOSOSO238 咁你都睇到😑佢吾講嘢似男唱歌似女，好亂呀🤣
忘記她是他？忘記他是她？
我都聽546聽到心痛流淚，第一次咁明白歌詞，加油😢
68 is super good, wow, such a breathtaking performance
600 her Jazz is GOOD!
5:15:15開始聽，68號真是太厲害超班喎…仲勁過阿信💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻唱到咁高音都咁爆咁厚…爽到了🫡🫡
怕他似中二吳萊邨一曲了😂
7:54:30 Only know this pretty girl, Magic Winnie 🙈 Her voice & pronunciation is somehow disaster 😖
佢硬要唱埋兒歌, 自暴其醜, 韋綺姍老師最後都冇眼睇佢😂
@@conniesin123佢今次無堅持要變個小小嘅魔術，咪算進步咗囉°
海兒真的很有修養，評語很到位，但令人很舒服
对，她不像那些自以为是的评审，又时常自相矛盾，遇到弱的参赛者就说要唱一些自己擅长的歌，遇到很会唱的参赛者就叫他们试一试唱别的歌种，又不见他们自己去挑战美声？
火煱老闆唱得非常好。
伍 sir唔明海兒講咩都可理解，海兒在外國取得碩士，仲嬴到咩獎咁，好猛料！
546. Looks like a Chinese Rick Astley. Great voice. Handsome. Good luck!
551倚天把聲好似秋官，但也有自己的特色
604號（一生中最愛）號把聲舒服靚聲吸引. 真誠有感情！又唔over👍🏻我重覆聽了N次😹
546唱得好好，好感人😢
546唱足6分鈡，伍 sir真係聽啱心情，好感動！
803 號把聲好靚，期待更多唔同歌嘅演繹💪🏻 7:41:59
我較爲喜愛伍仲衡直率的表達。毫不矯揉做作。有很強的壓台感。韋綺珊也具有音樂高手的風範。評語很切合參賽者的強項與弱點。
7:57:38 識左小妍很多年，由一個小妹妹，睇著佢大，雖然全民造星3失敗左，但睇著佢一直進步，唔放棄，作為朋友覺得好感動💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻加油
No 1 口音好似土著仔但又識唱廣東歌 咁真係好野 好多土生土長都唔願意講廣東話 滿口英文 你要加油！
Thanks for support❤
604 唱《一生中最愛》，整體來說，好，應該入圍。
Agree
好鍾意海兒❤
642豬場老細唱歌把聲都幾靚，加油!
姓伍評判 疑似 職場欺凌 新女評判 可能對佢有威脅😡
伍 sir 只係頂唔順佢D懶音同作狀扮專家，以為popmusic同女高音係同一技巧。
絕對認同👍
非常有同感😂😂
Number 604 sing very good 👌 👍
恭喜546拿到200000點擊率
I really dislike folks blaming their poor pronunciation on the fact they grew up elsewhere. Can clearly hear you have HK accent in your speech and not CBC accent. Why blame it on that? Just own it
依個節目﹐就算對我地普通不懂唱歌的人來講﹐慢慢也識聽聽得出﹑邊d參賽者有學過唱歌﹐宜家佢地一開口唱﹑就明顯聽得出喇。
6:57:50 , 劉建偉 , 千億個夜晚 . 韋綺珊示範左 , 咩叫喺錯嘅時候講錯嘅嘢 , 仲唔止一次 , 係連續三次 . 好明顯其他兩位評判 , 聽完首歌後 , 都非常感動 . 兩位評判多次嘗試形容首歌怎樣感動 , 韋綺珊卻一而再再而三插嘴 , 講啲九唔搭八嘅嘢 , 實在大煞風景 !
546 is so touching 🙏👍
有D海選覺得好睇過正式比賽
其實海選當節目播收視仲高呀講真😅
有同感
未開始劇情，係好睇啲
@@user-py7os3vp8s 因為估估算🤣
546千憶個夜晚唱得真係好，希望佢勇敢面对人生，將耒一定好的。
515號 6:46:10
都好聽👍👍
唱千億個夜晚參賽者好犀利，唱哂成首歌，越唱越高音，越唱越面紅，我除咗流哂眼淚，仲好担心佢，因為佢成面都紅哂，佢入一百強冇難度。
個位海兒，佢好有經驗，但是佢地唔係個個唔係唱女高音，男高音，佢每次教佢地好似跟佢學唱高音咁，要人地知唔知你講乜嘢先至得架，奇實我都唔明佢講乜😂
你唔唱歌咪唔識LO
我唔識唱歌，但係我聽得明😊
所以伍sir, 開玩笑話好深奧😅😅
聽得明，覺得佢係真心無私比意見參賽者
海儿绝对是最专业的评审，虽然她资历不够其他的深
評判海兒懶音太多
while Harry kept complaining about the contestants' 懶音, she (the judge) just kept having it herself, lol
伍仲衡又唔咁話佢😂
@@osalau2411 😅
呢個評判可以同FYY一齊做一個節目一較高下懶音同作狀技巧
step by step ... how much... ...
05:15:00 火鍋店老闆畀幾多客人白吃，先可以唱出呢種感情？
一個字：正
火鍋店老闆是不跑7個老婆是唱不出這種感覺
好听
No.68 is the best
海余小姐好漂亮，好可愛 講說話好好好好聽
yes yes yes
“千亿个夜晚”546唱到感动到流泪
I enjoyed watching 1120 at least he/she was very entertaining and not boring lol
支持TVB , 給大眾一個機會 ~
68號 5:15 好好聽，唯一一個聽到好感動
600 5:56:56 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
一個「趕」嘢好特別嘅，話妳咬字爭小小呀，呢個反面教材的確非常到位
Hoi Yee is quite long winded with her technical comments especially to contestants who really really cannot sing...nor do they understand what she is explaining. A bit of a waste of time and quite boring...I can see why Harry always looks annoyed.
2:37:46
声似秋官都唔错，主要系唱得很自然同舒服。好听
25:17 Phantom of the Opera "Love Never Dies"
1:36:58 果個人點解唔用自己歌 interview🤔
有時要突圍就一早哂冷要 Show 有幾多料今次面對競爭好大仲有海外賽分分鐘 7-8 千人爭 108 個位
604👍
68～三甲
海兒好似骨科醫生😂
每次海兒講話伍 Sir 都好唔耐煩！
我都覺得，可能佢講得多左，有時唔知佢講乜，我鐘意其他評判多D。
@@ngyimshan9937 但我覺得他的表情無禮貌無修養！
@@vwong6951认同
9号不錯
whom can tell me?
Love 609, she has a beautiful voice!
有啲炒晒車都話好😅 very interesting
1 號參賽者 41:50 加油！🤗🤗🤗
Thanks for support❤
第一次海選都已好有水準，競爭性好大啊，揀100 個入選真係唔夠，可唔可多的呢
688好聽👏👏👏👏👏時間6：42
認同
1号紐約唱歌好
Thanks for support❤
2:41:13 ex TVB dancer
albert的弟弟终于出来了
还有刘阳加油吧
crazy for global
7:54:32 葉小姸🎉
another or ... both
Queen/ King of excuses are everywhere 😮😵💫
Agreed
Doesn't make them anymore of a better singer..
I like the no.1 candidate, nice voice and attractive.
Thanks for support❤
600 is the dark horse. i think she will go very far 5:51:00
Not even darkhorse...why not the winner
Could be winner. I think she is being under estimated. (Dark horse) She is very very good
保安哥哥好掂👍
中三的男聲佔多，且唱得好的男聲較女聲多
TVB幕後究竟有冇睇過參賽者提交嘅唱歌影片㗎？係咪想玩啲評判同觀眾呢？五音不全都叫佢哋嚟海選. 依家唔係攪中年海選馬拉松呀！救命啊？1016不止髮型男扮女唱歌也貫徹始終同首歌好夾。1120一出嚟以為係鄭裕玲呀！
160唱得幾好聽！
604有喉癌都唱得咁好.勁
803聲音有磁性，似鄭子誠，又睇唔出有六張喎，加油
鄭子誠亦有六十一歲!🧓🧓🧓🧓🧓🧓
點解開唔番條片？
有沒得看memory ?
1120那個是否鄭裕玲😮
Harry Ng needs to tell that Hoi Yee about her 懶音
it's quite irritating.
At around 1 hr 11 min a male contestant was made to stand at the centre as if he is to compete now but instead was made to wait for the studio staff to get ready for the competition to re-commence! To me, that is poor stage management and extremely unfair to this contestant. He should have been given an opportunity to stay behind the stage and asked to come out only when the studio is set ready for receiving him to compete.
no ideas
好似見到鄭裕玲
上届整體質素比較好
係，寄望大灣區和星馬區海選😚🙏👍
今屆主打素人
海兒好q多懶音 點解其他兩個唔叫佢改
點 解 會以為會復完（情感和財赤），明知無可能。
midnight classes
546 Kenny 加油😉