RDR1 (PS4) vs RDR2 - Comparison of Details! (improvement?)
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 08. 2023
- The lastest "release" from Rockstar, the PS4 port of the Red Dead Redemption, vs. everyone's favourite Red Dead Redemption 2! let's compare the details of the two greats!
Has it got improved for PS4 / PS5 consoles? What's your opinion on this release? Let's discuss!
Thanks for watching, and happy gaming! 😊❤️ - Hry
Rdr1 was so ahead of its time, the rdr series as a whole is just perfection ❤❤❤
I still don’t really understand why people complain about how long the skinning animation in rdr2 is, it’s only like 2 seconds longer.
Yeah and it's realistic cuz in real life it'd take minutes
The drunk animations in RDR1 is just amazing and funny 🤣. I remember laughing so hard when I saw this the first time I played the game.
They are from GTA IV.
I have been watching you more than 5 years and you never changed ! Good job man, your videos are so fun
Thank you so much bro! 🥰🥰
@@BlaZe92How long have you been on this channel？
@@kojima8756 6 yrs
For me Rdr1 is a spaghetti western and rdr2 is a classcal western .I like the story of rdr1 more than rdr2 and I feel attached to John Martson more than Arthur but both are great protaganists.
Same here.
Me too.
Coz we played RDR1 first
You must be on meth 😂😂😂😂
Rdr 1 is better realistic
Really?
Arthur shows so much more depth and personality. He felt like a real person and not a protagonist from a video game.
Arthur is up there as one of the best fictional characters I ever seen.
That's diminishing returns in graphical fidelity, RDR1 really holds up pretty well.
Lol um actually it doesn't. A compressed CZcams video doesn't show the whole story.
@@googlemyself4091 Obviously RDR2 looks better. I have 100% RDR1 and played several hours of RDR2, due for a full playthrough soon. But these games were 8 years apart, compared to how games from 2002 held up against RDR1 and games from 1994 before that, it holds up very well. That is diminishing returns.
Not really, is it just me or is some details hard to see apart from eachother in RDR1? So much on screen is just gray and camouflaged unintentionally. I have trouble making out the smaller details, but in rdr2 it's much easier. But maybe much of that is just the camera angles.
No it doesnt 😂😂😂
@@Persion4786Yeah I’m a RDR2 veteran at this point, played 350+ hours since the game dropped in 2018 across three saves. I just started Red Dead 1 today actually and have put a few hours in. What grabbed my attention immediately was how much more difficult RDR1’s gun combat is compared to 2. But I think unintentionally half of the time. I couldn’t see the target half the time, they blend in with the night or the background way more than in RDR2.
I laughed my ass off at John just lying there drunk in the comparison
the intro was crazy man🔥🔥🔥
Thanks homie! ❤️
Bro is comparing the game with the second protagonist. Nice
❤️❤️
The second person in rdr2 is John Marston who is who you play as in red dead 1 (other than Jack)
@@Mr_Miner_102 no way!!!
I'm confused by what this comment means. The second protagonist? John Marston's kind of the protagonist of the Franchise, everything Arthur does winds up being for John, as well as everything Jack does when he's an adult.
@@F13FAR0 well you said “second protagonist” John is the first protagonist and as much as I hate to admit this, Arthur is a side character
This video was truly amazing brother👍, and all of youre comparison is really fun to watch.
Thank you so much bro! ❤️❤️
I still own rdr1 and undead nightmare on my ps3 and they still look perfect, no need to even pay $50
I have it on ps3 and xbox. Would have liked it on ps5 for faster loading and better raytracing and shades but not at this ridiculous price. Should be 30 euros not 50.
@@RedsparInvestingthere is no ray tracing and no PS5 version unfortunately. No 60 fps either as it’s only running the PS4 version in back compat. Although the game in 4K looks really good.
@@mandrews6282I have a ps5. It's on the ps store
It's time to pay. No more going camp to camp 💀
And I played it and completed on PC didn't spend a penny 😅
Red Dead Redemption graphics still look so pretty and it has great lighting, environment and ambient music
I get to finally play this game on PC via emulator and having so much fun playing it.
Wish Rockstar would listen to the fans and also give us a PC port.
Yes
Nah.
Yes(2)
The drunk animation in rdr1 is amazing it's kinda like gta4
The improvement is crazy
It's the same game from the Xbox360/PS3 era. In true current Rockstar's fashion, they just put something out there to keep investors happy while they keep finding new ways to increase Shark Card sales. At least they didn't let Grove Street Games massacre it like they did with the GTA trilogy.
I still find it amazing red dead 2 is a prequel to red dead 1
RDR1 still holds up. Too bad there isn't a proper remake using RDR2 engine.
It's a good thing there isn't. I'm tired of the forced slow pace that claims to be immersive but actually takes away my immersion because I'm always forced to do 15 minutes of the things I don't want to do for 5 minute of fun
@@flamingmonkey7712 You can have your shit graphics and lame gameplay from 13 years ago. Go play Russian roulette with an automatic, you're not good enough to be breathing the same air as people whose parents aren't brother and sister.
@@JimDavid-wg3sw so you're making fun of me for playing video games, when you play video games yourself. Tell you what. Why don't we discuss this in person. Give me your home address. You're tough, right? What do you have to worry about? Just make sure your family is home. I'll have a little fun with them while you watch.
^Nostalgia cope is insane 😂
bro rdr1 movement feels so real
Also compare the size of both games😄
Great video
Thank you Cristian! 🥰🥰
What is the horse called the really brown one when you compare the walk rdr2
Oh I usually use mods to spawn. So I really don't remember the name.
Its not a big surprise that the graphics from RDR2 (2018) are better than RDR1 (2010). But its a shame that the physics of RDR1 are so superior compared to RDR2 (which feels like a slightly improved GTA5 ragdoll model). RDR1s ragdoll physics made me addicted to kill/push NPCs and watch them acting... Shootouts were so fun... You expected them to fall like in a movie and it was entertaining AF. Getting drunk was so funny to see john stumbling around and falling 100% euphoria ragdolled and physics-based... RDR2 has nothing to offer but downgrades, when it comes to these points...
I think the same man
RDR2 has ragdoll physics that are similar to real life.
@@snanimations1524 Yes of cause... People getting pushed away from bullets and rotating arms when getting shot to the head... I dont know in what reality you live but RDR2s physics has nothing to do with real life.. Also its good that its not like real life because that would be boring AF.
@@anymyo9882RDR2’s physics are way closer to real life than RDR1
@@snanimations1524 but why is that good? kills all the fun. It has to be entertaining, not realistic. All action movies are unrealistic but people like it because its entertaining and fun to watch... why should that be different in video games?
Its good to see these video than rather spending a 50$
😎
I'll be glad to buy this
RDR2 looks real in comparison
it is sad that john from rdr1 cannot swim
I liked the fairy tale🌹
Try adding captions to parts of the video where they are really needed and not expecting us to fill in the gap by ourselves... Some of us haven't played these games so it'll be nice to fill us in(like enxgma videos).... Great vid btw
Thank you very much for the suggestion! ❤️
The entitlement...💀
I love rede dead redemption 2 for everything ❤
I would love to see a PS5 version of RDR2 with upgraded tech for grass, ground and light
damn that intro 🤩
🥰🥰🥰
NO WAY WATER LOOKS LIKE THAT IN RDR HOW
it’s crazy how far the RAGE Engine has came I got high expectations for GTA6 🤯
honestly i do not see any improvements other then xbox360 style graphics. i mean there isn't even fire spread... something gta sa has which released in 2004
Truly a rockstar moment
❤❤❤
When is rdr1 disc version coming? Ps4
October 13
@@travisplayz7108 thanks
Time to go to the mall and make our purchases.....
Today(Oct 13)
RDR1 on PS4 is the 100% same game on PS3
Something if they did 8-10 years ago when PS4 was new in Market. Then it would've been better.
No, they removed the multiplayer
The new release of RDR on (ps4), looks really comparable to RDR 2 (ps4) in my opinion.
A lot of the graphics are clearer but the game play (horse movement) seems to be a big laggy. Am I the only one who sees it that way?
W video
Nice foo! 👍
😎 Yo homeboy, wassup wichchu?
Rdr1 graphics has better shadows
Rdr1 is better than boring outdated red dead 2
No it doesnt
@@RedDead-ww3vgimagine saying that with rdr2 pfp
@@anarchistmaverick9507its his opinion kid . Grow up and learn how to respect others opinion . And stop defending rdr2 rockstar doesn't care about
@@user-fk9dg3wu1p Why? You think Rockstar cares abour RDR1? XD After this low effort joke for 50 bucks?
Bro there no comparison with RDR 2
So going from camp to camp 50 times is some fun stuff? 💀
@@Harp_and_Guitar_Moving_Forwardok boomer
I always been about the graphics so i would go with rdr2 since the graphics look better
rdr better overall imo
@@draco2xx i was gonna buy rdr1 but the graphics looks outdated, still looking like ps3 graphics. Wish they could remaster it cause i wanna play it. I played rdr2 frist for a reason i wanna play the story in order
@@alphaorlando3974 you should play the emulation version of it on pc at 4k 60fps
@@draco2xx not even close. RDR1 has shit graphics and a shit story. Garbage.
@@alphaorlando3974 I guess your never gonna get to play all the good delisted games
4:02 maybe because John put him down a bit too hard
Nothing can beat the drunk Rdr 1 I am afraid
I kinda prefer RDR 1 because it doesn't go overboard with realism. Having to watch Arthur slowly skin an animal was cool at first. But seeing it over and over feels lame. Not to mention that you *slowly* pick up the skin or carcass. The game wants to be realistic, but magic rope pops up that automatically ties the dead animal to the rear of the horse
Yeah I agree. I don’t think red dead 2 I needed to be so realistic. It would be like if when GTA 6 comes out if they made you stop for gas but on top of just parking at a pump if you actually had to get out swipe your ATM card and then sit there for a couple minutes as a tank refills.
There’s a reason why, in movies as well as in video games, you don’t always do things realistic because it’s boring as hell and that’s not why you’re playing the video game four.
You can't skip these animations? I don't remember.
Honestly i prefer it that way as the whole point of it was to make you feel the slow-paced feeling of hunting and cooking to survive. There wasn't some macdonalds near you waiting to served you food and a large sprite to go and all the towns and big cities were miles away from you that you needed to hunt to survive and such. I hope in GTA 6 we can pump our gas and running past red lights that actually make the cops react to it.They could make those into a realistic difficulty where it feels so real that even your character actually has to use the bathroom after eating 8 hours ago or they may poop their pants and NPC will react to you pooping on yourself and not taking care of yourself similar to San Andreas.
Y'all complain too much. Gaming community is full of complaining ahh internet geeks. If it's realistic "oh no they did it too much" if it's just made for fun and has fantasy elements "it's not even realistic, rdr2 is best game of the decade because of how realistic it is"
@@mellochello921
bruh skinning the animal and hunting isn't even slow paced in rdr 2. An actual professional hunter analyzed the footage of hunting in rdr 2 and pointed out so many inaccuracies. Go try skinning a deer in less than 10 seconds
Rockstar is not at fault for being greedy , it's because of crazy fans who make 3 quality games gta trilogy and gta 5 expanded successful 🤮🤔
Red Dead Redemption released on PS4 and Nintendo Switch, also, for PS5 having a PS4 version be like.
👇
I've pre ordered the first game for PS3. Loved it. But I have zero interest in replaying it. Now if this were GTA 4 with both DLC packs I'll gladly throw them $50 even for a simple overpriced port.
Absolutely! 50 is too much just for the port.
They had full remasters planned for Red Dead and GTA 4. After all the backlash to the Trilogy they canceled both. My guess is they pushed this port out the door to recoup some of the costs of the canceled remaster project. Hoping we get GTA 4 at some point still, even a port, but probably not given the reaction to this one. At least it actually has a PC version and runs at 60 fps on XBox. Shame these games are becoming lost to time essentially in the process.
First viewer bro 🎉🎉
🥳❤️❤️
Its not remastered so it's basically a ps3
Yeah, only the port
RDR2 like an remastered version of RDR1, it dont have any bad things
for how much a shady cunning crook rockstar is if they remake rdr for next gen i would absolutely buy it at retail price cause it's that's good and im embarrassed to even say it
rdr2 has a better story, while rdr1 is funner
Funnier? How?
RDR2 had several laugh out loud moments while RDR1 really doesn’t
@@Indigo_1001you eat babies
@@Indigo_1001fanoy alert
@@Indigo_1001meant more fun or something i think
Yeah The Ragdolls And The Execution Plus The GOATED Undead nightmare
At least we can said that RDR1 remake is way better than GTA Trilogy 🤣
Ps: Hope they release PC version of RDR1 Remake
&
Fact: John Marston drunk animations is similiar to Niko (GTA 4)
yes i think because they used the same ragdoll engine (euphoria)
It's not a remake
There wont be remake never mate , game holds up nice well and it doesnt need remake
Rockstar ain't making new games anymore but instead keep doing remaster of their older titles and milking money from GTA online 😅
not bad for rdr
PS4 Pro RDR1 VS RDR2
RD1 is better
i cant help but feel that rdr2 ruined marston in epilogue, hes literally just arthur morgan with a different face and voice
Gta 4 NEXT!
RDR2 IS REALISTIC MORE THAN TO RDR1,IN DETAIL,GRAPHIC,MOVEMENT.....
Nope 💀 sterile environment
Okay so
🤜🤛😎
Wassup homie!
both games used the same engine !
No they didn't. Yes they used RAGE but very different versions of the engine
First 🥇
Thanks bro! 🥰🥰
Your welcome my pleasure 🤗🤗🤗❤️❤️❤️
both games are great, but rdr2 is slightly better than rdr1
Funny some things look better on rdr1 : dynamite in the water, in the sun. Still prefer 1 to 2 as not much freedom in 2, so scripted. Shame 2 could have been grand instead of good. 1 was grand in her days
2 is definitely grand
Just because you don’t prefer something doesn’t mean its bad
ha
the first rdr is better than the second one imo, from story, gameplay to the atmosphere. rdr 2 is very empty outside of towns, story didn't interest me as much, the missions weren't that good either except the train robbery. i always tend to go back to rdr and have a lot of fun playing especially bounty hunt missions
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!
Yeah rdr 2 gameplay was kinda mid and the missions are sometimes repetitive but I think the story and the details make it worth it
Seems like you haven't played RDR 2 . May be you couldn't afford it .
@@abhinandsnath How anyone could think that RDR1, with its archaic graphics and wonky movements, is somehow better than RDR2 is beyond me. He must be inbred. His parents are brother and sister!
@@abhinandsnathAngry cause bad mouthed your favourite game?
Rdr2 is too blurry looking. Rdr1 was perfect.
Ffueresy
It's insane how RDR looks better than RDR2 in every situation. Rockstar really couldn't outdo RDR. Rdr2 is still good though
This is just not true lol
LMAO
Nice one
bro relly said that.. hell nah... you on something bro
i literalyl wanted to puke when i saw the surroundings in that horse ride... how do you even say these words while rdr1 has TRASH surrounding graphics. look at the trees! mfs look like out of ms paint bro
Sheesh rdr1 meat riders be coping in the comments
No improvement just a another old game :(
💀👎
An oldie but a goodie
Certainly glad I didn't waste $50 on this steaming pile of shit with its ancient graphics and wonky movements. This RDR1 isn't worth $.50, let alone $50!
It's like comparing the PS3 version. It didn't change at all, it's just a port. This video serves zero purpose.
Showing that it didn't change will serve something as well