Fascinating Chinese document surfaces, with insights into how PLA reads Indian strategic mind
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 02. 2021
- #CutTheClutter #ChinaAndIndia
China Aerospace Studies Institute in America has recently translated a PLA document, outlining its long-term military and strategic outlook, into English. Such a document is produced in China only once in about 13 years. In episode 682 of #CutTheClutter, Shekhar Gupta picks up parts of the document that talk about India, and uses this unique opportunity to look at India from the lens of its biggest adversary.
Brought to you by @tata.evofficial
Read the document here: www.airuniversity.af.edu/CASI...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our CZcams Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Please support good journalism by paying for it. Subscribe to ThePrint. Links for both domestic & overseas subscribers are provided here: theprint.in/subscribe/
Sg for Deputy NSA.
And let Rahul Kanwal read this and apply less makeup
@@jeffolsonneil2866 today is Hug day. Dusre jaga mein jake hug(💩)
Shekhar Gupta’s The Print deletes report about CZcams taking down video that argued how George Soros anti-India fund benefits media outfits. Why SG ?????
Sorry SG print is spewing bias and hatred of Hindus on your site. You are being neutral on CZcams but not on opinion pieces.
Good journalism and the print!!!!!
Says who?????
Caspian Report pointed this out exactly. China doesn't want India to develop it's navy and gain the ability to block Malacca Strait through the Andaman and Nicobar archipelago.
Shirvan is amazing!
Thats why they attacked on Indian continent, so that india stop focus on navy and focus on army and airforce....
True.. I was thinking about those two videos when I was watching this video.
Our current Navy Chief and NSA are not fools please have faith on them 🙏🙏
Third aircraft carrier is absolute necessity
How China reads India's strategies?
They secretly watch SG's CTC at 9 PM every day.
😁😁😁😁
😂
😂
@Aryan Godara Yeah, that was such a great speech, and he was talking free-markets and economic reforms unapologetically
😅
I think the Chinese wanted a non violent confrontation which would only lead to military buildup and make India lose resources but after the Galwan incident, their plan got thrown off and a whole country turned against them and in the process they lost soft power and investments in India. Thanks to the brave soldiers for giving us a wake up call by their bravery and martyrdom.
Thanks for the joke. Needed one during this lockdown.
@@barlekha1971 there is no lockdown now
Thx for joke
@@barlekha1971 you are still in lockdown joker.😂😂😂
@@siddharthjain9611 Yes in London it is.
@@barlekha1971 commenting about London in a Indian news channel
Thats cringe
Liking ur own comment
Is cringer
I'm surprised to see how well the chinese analysed India. We need such brains who can do plain analysis logically without getting emotive. I hope we get to see such work from our strategists.
On the other hand the public is being dumbed down intentionally
Check out General Sundarji doctrine on Pakistan and China...
You are truly doing injustice to strategists or you move in wrong circles.
@@mailtorajrao maybe he missed India's Tibetology project...
Well those kind of minds are leaving India unfortunately....
this is the kind of news everyone deserves, where journalist spends sleepless night to read a document to provide the quality content or news to his audience. Thanks SG ❤️
@@gokulvrindavan1858 I hv exactly asked him in my comment few hrs ago... let’s put pressure on him to “declutter” Vinod Kumar’s string claims ... I bet these left journalist ll not do it no matter how much ever they say they are Balanced!! 🤪
@@gokulvrindavan1858 u didn’t get the point... don’t say there is nothing to declutter then Shekar Gupta will give excuse that he only ll talk only if they are cluttered that’s why his show is called “cut the clutter”... hence say it’s very complex, pls declutter 😛😛
This episode caught me by surprise(in a good way). It's one of the best episodes I have seen on Strategy....Kudos to you SG Sir for explanation on document and also sharing with us....
Even Major Gaurav Arya told few months ago in a programme that China did the LAC thing to make sure India doesn't focus on Indian Ocean or make its Navy strong.
Yes. Was it an episode from "Bkitzkrieg" featuring Lt. Gen (retd.) Syed Ata Hasnain?
Correct .
“Chinese are not fools like Pakistani are ,other wise they won’t be what they are now . So Indians need to concentrate more on Chinese “ quote unquote statement by Shekhar Sir
@@sanjayvaidya4925 communism paid them so well that they ousted the capitalist US 😆🤭
Beware US, your days are near
@@rajarshiroy6300 state capitalist*
You don't need to write quote unquote after you've used quotations. It is generally used for verbal conversation.
@@sanjayvaidya4925 They aren't communist like USSR.
Their Economy isn't closed.
They give out loans to whole world and have investments all around the world.
They are a Trade Power.
But USSR had more Moral strength under Gorbachev (ofcourse not under Stalin) but China has lost it under Xi even if they had built up a little bit after Deng Xiaoping.
@@sanjayvaidya4925 They are as communist as the Democratic People's Republic of North Korea is democratic.
We started reading Sun Tzu and they started reading Chanakya Nitti.
By the end of this Cold War we would be speaking Mandarin and they would be speaking Hindi.
par humare bande vaha pr bhi jakr govt. exam crack krke ayenge taki CV mai likh sake
I tried learning Mandarin. That's damn tough dude...
Indo Aryan languages are far easier to learn. 😅
@@ObitoUchiha10089 it's called *sanskrit-based languages*. "indo aryan" is a hyphenated colonial term.
*Sanskrit
@@darkprince8288 My friend, how familiar are you with Greek?
Only journalists left in this country which is unbiased and talks about real issues. Thank you, sir. Big fan #SG.
Hi Yugansh! Thanks for writing in.
@Some guy full of hypocrisy.
@Some guy You've got to be kidding me. Rubbish Kumar.
@Some guy at least sold out media houses are not threat to peace and integrity of our country.
Prof,
Came back to your class after a long gap, and was not disappointed. You are a gem of an instructor.
Respect!
No one has done analysis like this we appreciate Shekhar for gathering so much information for its viewers
But , they made us feel like a strong opponent which reminds me of second chapter of Sunzi "Make your enemy feel stronger than you and attack him with surprise ". Give a thought.
Underplaying & with surprise caught them offguard with limited planning ..
@Aditya Sanjay do not underestimate ourselves but I would say humble ourself to the ground.
1.Moral
2.Heaven
3.Earth
4.commander
5.laws and discipline.
This is what sunzi strategy to compare a army strength. And I see exactly that's what they are doing. But, on the other hand our policy is also been inspired by chanikiya. But, I would say don't try to prove which war scholar is great. But learn both the minds and great our own ,that's what chanikya also say in his kutalya neethi
@Aditya Sanjay I think chanikya works still valid today. That's what I am saying I have read both and believe me chanikya is very wise than sunzi. But our job is study both and be a strategist. I would recommend you to read chanikya
@Aditya Sanjay hmm
@Cutie Bacha Shivbhakt you are Right they thinks we are ego centric but they don't know "for us good things takes time until then just grow"
Will you cover the Greta toolkit and what it reveals??
Yes please
🤣🤣🤣🤣Bhai kyu torture kar raha hai...
Abhi rone lagega ye
It's funny how a teenager is taken seriously .
@@neetuhareet9431 I know right
She even got opportunity to speak at un and davos and all😂😂😂
Greata toolkit is basically the PDF containing entire plan for a propaganda war against indian government which includes when exactly Rihanna and she herself will tweet and other plans which exactly unfolded by those dates
Everyone who politicised Hathras.. everyone who led astray bike theif Tabrez's beatings into some sort of communal lynching.. is now very comfortably silent over brutal murder of Rinku Sharma
If it were Rehan Khan instead of Rinku Sharma, then media will get the spice out of it. Hindus are born to be enslaved by the secular society.
Yes because all the facts aren't out yet. It's also claimed, I read this somewhere that these people were all close. Basically Rinku donated blood to one of the accused's wife. So instead of jumping to conclusions, let's chill and wait for the facts to arrive.
We blamed RSS for lynching of Muslims. In the same way you name an organization for his murder. All of us will fight against that organization. If you can't name an organization it should be seen as an criminal case
@@samarthacharya5180 as if lefties care for the full details when its other way round.
@@abcdmg7730 The peaceful people. 😂😂
As a Chinese native, I’ve always believed it’s a misstep by the Beijing government not to have a good enough relationship with India. But I also understand why given the status quo. It’s getting increasingly important for China to keep up its good relationship with Pakistan, and China currently doesn’t have a strong reason to be relying on India strongly, yet. So that makes the paramount importance of controlling Tibet the dominating factor in the Chinese strategic mind. But I think things will take a turn for the better in the next couple of decades as India expands further as a consumer market and continues to sharpen its edge in technological services, to the point where Indian tech leader can start to take up market shares in China. That’s when we’ll have some fun, and lots of money to be made.
你懂个屁
You are ignorant. India does not want to have good relations with Beijing. It is opportunistically benefiting from geopolitical strife and playing into the American desire to decouple from China.
The explanation is brilliant.Thanks S.G.
No other media houses talk about these vital information and documents.
To China and all other enemies countries.
The Community College of the Air Force, which I have graduated from, is also linked to the Maxwell AFB College as well. I have just subscribed to this channel. Great journalism in India! Oftentimes, better than American journalism.
Better than canadian journalism as well. Great video.
If your enemy is secure at all points, be prepared for him. If he is in superior strength, evade him. If your opponent is temperamental, seek to irritate him. Pretend to be weak, that he may grow arrogant. If he is taking his ease, give him no rest. If his forces are united, separate them. If sovereign and subject are in accord, put division between them. Attack him where he is unprepared, appear where you are not expected.
That's what china is doing! Sg is always top notch with his words.
India has played it's cards well with courage and clarity of thought and action.
Watched Jyoti’s video with General Hooda and Panag today. Congratulations to you SG sir for your leadership and customer centricity. The customer feedback on the product shortcomings ( Jyoti’s relentless interruptions in the previous interviews) has been taken seriously. Jyoti was uninterruptive today ( imaginably would be difficult to overcome her natural instincts). Also your adeptness to counsel her that paid the results ( she being a tough brat to change, required special skills to address her ) ! Fantastic job done overall !
The Biggest Challenge we have is the 0.5 front we have inside the country.
yeah the left,who depends of forgine money might be even china
its called opposition... an essential part of democracy
@@momobhai3792 I am glad you said that, yes it is important how do you reckon I meant opposition? General Rawat last year mentioned this term, he meant amalgamation of a lot of things including giving help to insurgency, spoiling hard earned peace in NE, and successionist movements threatening security and sovereignty. The 26 Jan incident is a hint of what .5 front can do.
One of the best videos that I have seen ever on strategic affairs.Kudos to the print
ARE U TALKING ABOUT THE STRING EXPOSE OF GEORGE SOROS AND HIS ACTUAL LINKS WITH THE GRETA TOOLKIT VIDEO !???.. OH YES IT DEFINTILY WAS EVEN AFTER IT GOT PULLED UP AND ERASED FROM CZcams YEAH !! . : )
Whatever may be our political affiliation or ideology, we should be united when it comes to nation.
*No 1: Don't Only Hope On Government For Income,*
*No 2: As An Individual Look For Different Self Income Not Only Waiting on Monthly Wages,*
*No 3: Always Save The Little You Can And Think Of What To Do With It When It Become Good For Capital.*
It's 100% Good To Have Different Ways To Gain Income, because Government have failed us so therefore let's try and survive
Yes ! For real It is very important to have different streams of income and a diversified portfolio as for me I have already invested in crypto which is very profitable and easy to gain
Exactly I'm also happy to start investing too than to have my money sleeping in bank
Stocks are good but we have to make the right plans
Yes Stocks are good but they are alot of businesses more convenient than stocks
That’s the fact well I only invested in stocks and will love to know a better investment too
Two thousand years ago, the Chinese military strategist Sun Tzu's "The Art of War " said，“To know the enemy and know yourself,and you can fight a hundred battles with no danger of defeat.”
I believe that the Indians never understood the meaning; they did not understand it in 1962, nor do they understand it today.
Two thousand and four hundred years ago, the indian philosopher and statesman chanakya's" arthashastr" said learn from others mistake at worse your mistake and make sure it'll never repeat that's why we kicked out china in 1969.
All warfare is based on deception -Sun Tzu
Excellent decluttering today. Now it is almost clear why the Chinese caused trouble in Ladakh last year. Thank you Mr. Shekhar Gupta
Except it was Indian soldiers who started it first...
I am Chinese and I can tell you that it is not the reason you think.
@@sosoable Lol you still dont know about Chinese soldiers martyrs in last clash even such information is not visible to common citizens of China then how can you expect them to tell you other things. And btw I know you are from Pakistan and even if you are really from China na then you dont even have right to comment here go live in your bubble where YT is banned
Sadly ,Chinese does not care much about India other than a few Bollywood movies and curry dishes.
@@lhctrekker okay chinavirus
Brilliant piece by Shekhar sir, the ending is abrupt but apt. Im paying now to get more of this journalism. Shekar ji, ive been watching each and every episode and I must say that you’re giving news to us as news is supposed to be given. Unbiased. Fair. Without opinion. Where you have opinion, you mention it.
Thank you.
Hi Pushkar, do keep tuning in daily.
Putting this episode to "One of the Best CTC" bin👌👌. Very informative and gives a great idea about how our best adversary thinks and what we can learn to improve.
Fully worth you spending the night reading through the 370 odd pages.Loved it.
Great
Honestly never trust the American interpretation and version of Chinese docciers
They have left many important facts for Indians to mull for
Yes, I was thinking the same throughout the video.
OR MAYBE IT HAS THOSE FACTS AND THIS GUY DIDNT READ THEM OUT TO U FAINTING SHEEPS. :D RROFL LOLS.
Commendable analysis. Thank you for taking the efforts to read it first, explain with lucidity and leave us with various aspects to ponder upon. Thank you Shekhar Ji
"Hey neighbour"😂😂
A great view on foreign policy!🙌🏻
I think this is the true example of "Investigative journalism"👍👍
@@dharamewada6922 bro as a viewer we should appreciate the work of SG.🙏
Investigate journalism would have been when he would have self translated this pages way back in 2013 when it was released in chinese language.
Not now which he got readymade that too after someone posted on Twitter
India must be like "yaar maine toh aisa kuchh socha hi nahi, magar Cheen bhol raha hai toh hoga!"
This video made me renew my 3 month membership. There is no place else where you would get this kind of analysis.
Ahhh.. that's something different.... Really informative....👍👍👍
Do keep writing in, Rituraj.
China: knows A to Z about india.
Meanwhile India: still can't figure out why China broke an almost war out of nowhere.
Bc of india policy change regarding A-370, indian Map changing, inclined more towards pro- U.S during trump regime, being aggressive in indo pacific region, bullying Pakistan twice, haven't joined BRI, political stability, reform oriented growth which lead to economic stability, building alliances with like minded democractic countries like Japan, Australia, South Korea, New Zealand, Taiwan etc. China challenged India (regional player in asia) and U.S ( Global player in world) at the same time!
India has recently started China Studies. I think recently External Affairs Minister talked in China Studies seminar in IIT Madras.
@@vishwakchandra1881 they got agressive because of Infrastructure development in Border areas and I think before 2024 election Army gonna do something big if Economy got revive may be Pangong till Finger 8 capture
@@manojkumar-jt3fw I don't think so we don't know much deep in our countries strategy
Who told you we don't do, almost 90% of India's defense and strategic policies are classified and we only see a surface level discussions in public sphere
hands down !! one of the best episodes of cut the clutter !!
"Defense into offense during wartime" basically what that means is that you have FOBs (forward operating bases) that in the event of a defacto or dejure war, have all the tools and capabilities to launch offensive military operations in their respective AOE (area of effect). That means usually that these FOBs are well fortified with supply lines to not just defend, but turn that defense into offensive actions as per requirements.
I have to commend you for the quality of the episode, Shekhar sir. It was fun, succinctly summarized in an orderly sequential manner and was decluttered.
CTC on string's video..
Franky in this paper, China has in a way given us clarity on what our Geo-Strategic policy should be. Thanks China! :D
deception
" Know Thyself, Know Thy Enemy. A Thousand Battles, A Thousand Victories"
- Sun Tzu
The Chinese have learnt well. There is a lot we can learn from them. If we don't then we will always be in the backfoot.
Finally someone with oversight to look into long term Chinese military goals for India. Finally.
WION and Print are two of my fav channels I refer to when I need a thorough analysis/breakdown; other channels are either pro-BJP or anti-BJP. They have a lost a sight of objectivity.
wion is a part of the zee network and they seem to be pretty biased
@@momobhai3792 they present world news through indian point of view since its one of first indias international channel
Wion is a far right channel. It was introduced for sophisticated English speaking bhakts whom Zee news and Republic could not appeal to.
@@lavkumar420 lol they dont give indian news they present foreign news with indian perspective
@@lavkumar420 And print is far left channel and if you heard shekhar 5 years back you wont be hear.
So India does have a strategic doctrine, rather than just reactionary tactics.
Its like a chess game my friend. Think multiple steps ahead.
@@anilkumarmeher1
True that, but we still don't have answers to the escalation that China did and as far as chess goes this standoff has shown which game we have to play.. Indian chess or Chinese checkers
lol no, this is just applying a pattern to randomness
@Aditya Sanjay
Definitely the nsc and China study group know more than us and will handle accordingly. Dr. Jaishankar drafted India's nuclear policy and last I checked NSA is still drafting our strategic doctrine.
China has made certain assumptions about our so called doctrine and derived counter thought and counter measures. The truth is that we never evolved any strategy or doctrine, and have always reacted to the emerging situation. Nehruvian era thought and policy have taken india down the drain. Post independence, by now we should have been a few notches higher on the power scale. Alas, we'll continue in the same mould, even with the present disposition, as knowledge and ability to foresee and lay out a roadmap for long term development and strength, to project power much beyond our frontiers, is sadly lacking, and neither does anyone want to learn or let professionals do it for them. Sun Tzu and Chanakya are being quoted ad nauseum, as if nobody else was ever born capable enough to evolve and articulate strategy and power doctrine for us.
This episode itself is pure GOLD.
the most relevant, insightful and deep episode of the year, kudos sir
I'm an upsc aspirant thank u for this level of journalism... Respect
2022
@Some guy this is harder than cracking upsc.. I think 😄
Sir... there is so much clutter around the Greta’s Thunberg’s “Toolkit” & it’s players.. why are you not doing any videos rebutting or decluttering the claims of Vinod Kumar’s String video that just got deleted by CZcams! You would be doing a huge favour to your nation
Brilliant stuff and thank you for sharing this piece. Appreciate the effort in going thru this longish translated Chinese document. I hope India's leadership and strategic establishment has already gone thru this and if not they must take a business subscription of The Print. This piece is the reason for subscribing this channel and paying for the quality content.
China act strategically to maintain peace whereas India over-estimated itself , and reacted emotionally and negatively
Thing about navy is also on point.
Chinese have learned art of "Purva Paksha", are we?
Pardon me, but what is the art of purva paksha?
Purva Paksha is ancient vedic technic of debating, in which one studies opponent in intellectually, and then reply.
bad grammer, hinglish as usual. hindi bhi nahi aati, angrezi bhi nahi.
@@sumitgaikwad8854 Thank you.
When SG talking from heart without using paper.
Its Superb ctc
I personally love the strategy kinds of videos and SG provides us the cherry of the cake by bringing written papers, calling US strategist,which are a viable way of seeing ourselves from others perspective.
My two cents on this -- We have to give credit to china , they had planned meticulously . Deng Xioping famously said "hide your capability , bide your time". Unlike USSR ,China will be a formidable adversary of USA , there is an excellent book analysing Chinese strategies pragmatically *You Will Be Assimilated: China’s Plan to Sino-form the World* --- David.P Goldman
USA could have NEVER won against the USSR. The latter kind of sacrificed itself🤦♂️
@@rajarshiroy6300 That's the problem with "Authoritarian" regimes , whole Feedback loop is broken , PRC could go on the same path ( like in Mao's Regime) if rulers Like Xi exercise power there
The traitors actually have crab like mentality so we are suffering lot. No enemy is stronger than us but traitors make the diiference.
I rarely comment online anywhere. But waah! kya episode tha. This is real news. Proud subscriber since July 2020!
Hi Abhishek! Do keep comments coming in.
This episode is brilliant. Truly a Cut the Clutter moment for the Print's avid viewers like me.
I genuinely like listening to Army chiefs. So much professionalism to learn from them. I mean most of them there are exceptions everywhere. I hope this remains true forever.
The chinese document's observations re India's strategies are so accurate that it feels they had Informers at the helm of India..
this was amazing. I hope this channel grows by leaps and bound. I have done my part to support and will keep doing.
This is another one of those typical Shekhar Gupta master classes. Rigorously researched & lucidly explained. Kudos!
Bang on sir feel like having chinese tonite
We are not agressive on all of our international border whether it's Pakistan or China ,we wait for them to take action this has what costed us everytime.
Nice job for educating Indians. From sub-saharian observer
You’re right. This is pure gold. I will subscribe just for this!
This is a quality content and its nearly impossible to find this kind of information on electronic media.
Please talk about String's video takedown & how even social media platforms seem to be driven by an ideology
No you are wrong he used words like hang them to death and he bullied dhruv without anything substantive he bullied him bcz he shares left articles. I dont like dhruv but he bullied him. CZcams has a reason to remove his video.
@Carnivores if he is true liberal he would have clarified your reply but he can't because he is not a true liberal, he is librandu under liberal mask, can't save people like dhruv
@Carnivores yes you are true i dont even watch them bcz of their biasedness but i was pointing at string video not others i didn't liked bullying without any substance thats it.
Thanks. It was pretty good analysis of the thought-reading of the Chinese. Appreciate your outstanding journalistic acumen.
Congratulations 🎉👏 job well done 👍 on decluttering...!!!
When Cholas had a strong navy between 9 to 13 ad, they were ruling the Indian ocean and had control over Malacca straight. Modern India should focus on strengthening the Indian navy at any cost.
When we will release paper on our indo Pacific study
I think this was the best of CTC episode. To the point analysis and decluttering . I hope India’s strategy planners are also listening to this. Thank you very much Shekhar Sir...
Thank you for the analysis and interpretation 👍
He starts talking relevant content only after 5 mins .
Look at our coastline. No country can stop us from making our navy superb because it also has great economical value.
The best Cut the Clutter so far.Just exceptional and so refreshing and appetite-whetting.
Wow. Such a sound and absolutely to the point analysis. That's why I watch the print and shekhar gupta!
If I am not wrong, the Malabar exercises have been going on for a long time before this document came. So predicting Quad, as a grouping of like minded democracies isn't that big an achievement.
Its no great feat honestly. A few students can prepare such documents about china, how the chinese have slowly been becoming more aggressive especially under xinping.
I think the Quad was first envisioned in 2007 or so, but couldn't become real as Australia withdrew, not wanting to impact their relations with China. Covid-19 changed that in 2020.
Kudo to chinese n kudos to SG for unearthing it.
Wow ! Mind-blowing analysis !! Absolutely spot on.
Thank you for this fantastic analysis.
Bullseye 🔥🔥
Your team have taken tha bar of journalism to next level with experience youth and old team,carry on print
This is why people want to pay for this type of journalism thank you print ..keep it on
Quad initial established in 2007 - 08 ... please stop thinking that they read future and predict India’s steps!
This is great journalism ! To bring up something like this as a subject is rather the need of the hour . This act of yours pushes up the value of journalism indeed .
Very commendable to see you talking about this paper sir.
One thing to correct you, the QUAD was first conceptualised in May 2007 in the sidelines of the ASEAN Regional Forum in Manila when the first Quadrilateral Security Dialogue was held and followed by Naval Exercise involving Quad Countries i. e. India, Japan, US and Australia. Australia later left the Naval Exercise but rest of three continued in the form of Malabar Exercise.
I am sure Xl Jl PlG didn’t read this document
Yes, he didn't read ....the Chinese actually dnt care about india, you hardly see them discuss about india.
The print Wion are the only channels who cover good topics other media is like Hindu vs Muslim and saving political puppets
As Buddha and Krishna said Both positive and negative energies are necessary to move a man forward
The print and Wion are hope now in media The print plz reply
Some Print articles are very provacative bordering on minority appeasement
Very well organized thoughts, I am impressed by their seriousness on India, I can only wish that India also has something like this on its neighbors
You never know. Our security agencies are good and I am sure they know what to do.
*@PRINT* Brilliant find and superbly summarized. One of most fascinating CTC recently.
Chinese never thought of Quad. Quad was a result of their actions - remember the member countries were quite friendly with China before being targeted by it.
QUAD is very dangerous because it will make China / Russia / Iran / Pakistan die of laughter LOL
@@nayanmalig No one told about who is more dangerous. But sure you made your spam comment to attract emotional folks! Good luck 👍
@@alifepenneddown true lol.
When did China target the us? And since when Japan has been friendly to China?
@@alifepenneddown What are the actions China took ? bomb dirt poor peasants all over the world, genocide millions, drop agent range, depleted uranium, napalm, invade, loot all the oil and natural resources, call it war and lecture others on democracy and human rights ?
Why don't we translate these Chinese docs, why do we rely on America to do it for us
And americans shouldn't interfere with our internal matters too
@@SBB1337x What kind of a loser are you? This is nations we are talking about. Nations aren't run by morals and values. They will eat you alive if you do so.
How do you know we haven't translated? The Americans made it public, but I can bet my life that India's intelligence has documents of far greater value than this bullshit. Nothing gets out of china without the permission of chinese government. We know this because they want us to know
Best analysis and hard work shows up !!! Kudos.
Priceless episode.... 😍😍