So....Heifetz had a sense of humour. One of the greatest practical jokes high grade students can encounter from Heifetz. We finally see Heifetz smiling and taking effort to entertain his students. This shows that Heifetz wasnt such a completely controlled person; he also was a human being with human feelings. And....Heifetz enjoyed playing like this as well. Its a revelation. Great!!!
He had a quirky sense of humor and the occasional socially awkward nerd kind of thing. IIRC Once as a kid when Auer asked him to start reading books to broaden his exposure, he innocently went book hunting and picked up the first book he saw, which turned out to be on "lizard reproduction". He was too embarrassed to tell Auer about it the next class. And Auer who was thinking he'd probably pick up some story books had a huge laugh when he finally got the boy to say it. (Jascha Heifetz : Early Years in Russia) In later years these eccentricities in his personality showed up much more. He didn't quite end up the geek, but it did go elsewhere.
Heifetz admitted in later years that he never listened to any such auditions. This sort of horrible-playing skit was something that he enjoyed doing from time to time, and there are accounts of his doing such for at least two decades before this master class (and probably for another decade or so after that).
Most of us violinists agree that Heifetz recorded the best version of Vieuxtemps 4 in history. And here he doesn’t just imitate a bad player - he points out every mistake possible in a very profound way actually, which is very hard to do. Humor aside, to be the best performer of the piece and then doing this is simply next level 😎
Hardest performance of his career by far. He actually has to play badly, which for him is a near impossible achievement. His legato was still good at most places despite his best efforts....
OMG I can't stop loughing!!!! I just LOVE his imitation skill so so much!! HAHAHAHAHAHAH!! I wonder how he keep his serious face while the others couldn't help bursting out laughing! LOL!
For those who care, the pianist is Brooks Smith, who was Heifetz's main (often only) accompanist from 1950 (when Heifetz and Emanuel Bay parted company) until Heifetz retired in 1972.
@@ss032010310103 He brought his Tononi violin to his masterclasses. Though his Guarnerius was his most prized possession, he had a special affection for the Tononi. It was the first violin he bought with his own money as a teenager. He played his Carnegie Hall debut with it and also his last recital in 1972. He even took it to tours in war zones in WW2. That violin's seen a lot.
@@srinitaaigaura oh I see. My teacher studied with him at USC. And he told me he purposely brought a cheaper violin to class so no one could say he sounded good cause of his Strad/Guarneri. Maybe that's the one he meant
@@ss032010310103 Once when a student complained that he didn't have a Guarnerius but only a cheap violin, Heifetz just took the student's violin and played the piece he was studying and produced his signature sound on it. Heifetz might have been strict, authoritarian and very moody, but he had a good side too. If Heifetz liked a student he would surprise them by helping them get better instruments. Rudolf Koelman still remembers the day when Heifetz called him up and gave him some money to help him out. He had been struggling and hadn't told anyone, but Heifetz found out and insisted that when he gives, there are no strings attached ever. Who's your teacher?
The five students you can see in the video are, left to right: Varoujon Kodijan, Adam Han-Gorski, Elizabeth Matesky (mostly hidden by Heifetz), Carol Sindell, and Claire Hodgkins. The other two students were Robert Witte (a short light-haired young man) and Erick Friedman (who can be seen in other videos here).
I love that how no matter how badly it sounds, the majority of it is pretty in tune (except for where he plays out of tune on purpose), and even the octaves and chords are still pretty good hahaha
you rarely ever see a video with Heifetz smiling and laughing. that was awesome. I can't believe someone auditioned that piece with that kind of "preparation" tho
A lot of people seem to think the laughing is fake but, if you ever hang out with music students, you'll see that this actually is their sense of humor. Once your level is so advanced, you are able to laugh at typical mistakes because you realize that unprepared and/or poorly trained musicians look a little foolish when trying to impress. And this, in turn, drives the students to correct their own minor versions of these mistakes.
@@paulcaswell2813 Once when Brooks was asked what it was like to work with him, he admitted it was very challenging as Heifetz could play the piano parts even better than him.
Truly have to be a violinist to completely appreciate the humor of this... I was laughing so hard I almost fell off my chair and hit my head on the corner of the desk!
Some of these comments are extraordinary! This is a VERY funny clip from a very great violinist indeed. Heifetz may well have had a particular audition in mind but this is very, very clever. It is very difficult to play so 'badly' particuarly if you are Heifetz! Lighten up folks.
The work that Heifetz is deliberately mangling is Henri Vieuxtemps' Violin Concerto number 4 Op. 31, which Heifetz recorded in 1935 with the London Symphony and conductor John Barbirolli .
I think it was the end of the masterclass and Heifetz wanted to end it on a lighthearted note, give the students something to smile or laugh about. As i said before, nobody even knows if this was a true story or if it was just a fairytale that Heifetz created so as to make a joke.
His students are enjoying this deliberately awful performance and it actually takes great playing to sound this way. Notice that while the class is cracking up, Heifetz continues to keep a very serious demeanor.
Oistrakh also used to imitate bad playing,only that was not filmed.There is nothing vicious about this famous uncanny imitation of bad playing we all heard countless times.Actually,Heifetz did not imitate anyone in particular, he just gave this 'label' as a 'title' for his little joke.Whats truly amazing is how well he could play so badly.As for his mean nature-it is a well-known fact; only it has nothing to do with the joke.You guys might consider some anger management counseling out there:)
Por favor nunca levanten este video ...perdón pero me enseña muchísimo más q cualquier maestro desde Las tse o Confucio hasta la actualidad ...primavera 2022 en Argentina y su muerte fue en la primavera argentina de 1989
The laughter from everyone there is sycophantic and nauseating in the extreme; I wonder how many of them could have played for Heifetz without succumbing to a fit of nerves?
I love it-I already thought that Heifetz was the best, now that I know he had a good sense of humour as well-I love him all the more. For all you sensitive little children, I hope you don't play anything because God forbid anyone tells you you're not very good and you'll likely burst into tears!
@Adorado31 They weren't actors. They were advanced students at a Heifetz violin workshop (which is on YT). Their laughter must have been a natural reaction to the very tough workshop and criticism they'd all just been through. Heifetz's spoof audition wasn't just for fun, there was a serious teaching purpose behind it. Remember that those students would soon be auditioning for top orchestral jobs, and perhaps one day would be teaching and even judging auditions themselves.
usted q le pase? Es uno de los mejores violinistas en el mundo! y q buen humor tiene el? Es una de las mas grandes personas de la istoria de la musica!
My impression is that Heifetz is presenting an amalgam of bad violin playing under the guise of a bad audition, and not imitating anyone in particular. In other words, he's telling a joke deadpan. I think it's hilarious.
With no doubt Heifetz was the greatest virtuoso of the past century and he came immediately after Paganini for his technique. But here for me Heifetz was a bitch: it isn't correct to make this imitation because every violinist who made an audition for Heifetz could get nervous towards him and probably this pupil studied also a lot in order to prepare this audition. I think that someone of us who is laughing now for this could be very scared making an audition like that.
no, i mean exactly what i said, there are people who practice for hours on end, and struggle with their craft, but because it may not be their talent, they cannot match the level of a heifitz. that the point i was trying to make.
Take this video with some context and a grain of salt. These are professional musicians having a bit of fun, with some educational value too - Even knowing the mistakes takes knowledge of the violin.
He's not actually mocking a specific student. It's all tongue-in-cheek. Here's a recording of him clowning around with Jack Benny: czcams.com/video/seZ4KhYr-Hw/video.html&spfreload=10
No Heifetz was not a mediocrity, that's the whole point...he was a genius. It's ironic when mediocrities laugh at other people because they themselves are not much better. Heifetz was above all other violinists, and the fact that he realised his abilities and talent is a good thing...nothing worse in this world than the pretense of false modesty!! If he was a god on the violin why should he not revel in it, he worked his entire life to achieve it!!
It's part of the 1962 Masterclass TV series (czcams.com/video/RLlUoS8D7Bo/video.html). He's having a little fun with the world-class violinists who are studying with him.
So....Heifetz had a sense of humour. One of the greatest practical jokes high grade students can encounter from Heifetz. We finally see Heifetz smiling and taking effort to entertain his students. This shows that Heifetz wasnt such a completely controlled person; he also was a human being with human feelings. And....Heifetz enjoyed playing like this as well. Its a revelation. Great!!!
He had a quirky sense of humor and the occasional socially awkward nerd kind of thing. IIRC Once as a kid when Auer asked him to start reading books to broaden his exposure, he innocently went book hunting and picked up the first book he saw, which turned out to be on "lizard reproduction". He was too embarrassed to tell Auer about it the next class. And Auer who was thinking he'd probably pick up some story books had a huge laugh when he finally got the boy to say it. (Jascha Heifetz : Early Years in Russia)
In later years these eccentricities in his personality showed up much more. He didn't quite end up the geek, but it did go elsewhere.
Don't think so...he only laughed at other's poor playing.
I hope to be able to induce that much forced laughter one day.
You can hear how he has to concentrate to get a bad intonation. The parts in which he doesn't, they are hopelessly in tune.🙂
I know!! He can't help it!
Heifetz admitted in later years that he never listened to any such auditions. This sort of horrible-playing skit was something that he enjoyed doing from time to time, and there are accounts of his doing such for at least two decades before this master class (and probably for another decade or so after that).
He used it to play pranks quite a few times.
Thankfully so, anyone would have hated to be imitated by Heifetz and this be the result.
I think he also probably did this to break the ice and not have the students be too nervous cause there was no way they could do that bad
Most of us violinists agree that Heifetz recorded the best version of Vieuxtemps 4 in history. And here he doesn’t just imitate a bad player - he points out every mistake possible in a very profound way actually, which is very hard to do. Humor aside, to be the best performer of the piece and then doing this is simply next level 😎
Guys it’s called shredding, and I’ve been doing it my entire life.
If he played this for me id be laughing nervously thinking "does he do this with my playing to other students"
I bet every one of the students was secretly thinking exactly that.
Hardest performance of his career by far. He actually has to play badly, which for him is a near impossible achievement.
His legato was still good at most places despite his best efforts....
OMG I can't stop loughing!!!! I just LOVE his imitation skill so so much!! HAHAHAHAHAHAH!!
I wonder how he keep his serious face while the others couldn't help bursting out laughing! LOL!
He even plays badly perfectly.
my teacher is in there!
i love how heifetz still sounds amazing
Really that’s so cool which one is your teacher?
My violin teacher assigned that I listen to this and said "this is what NOT to do" and I watched it and laughed so hard...
My violin teacher gave me the same assignment today :)
For those who care, the pianist is Brooks Smith, who was Heifetz's main (often only) accompanist from 1950 (when Heifetz and Emanuel Bay parted company) until Heifetz retired in 1972.
I think Bay retired.
And that's what the Dolphin stradivarius sounded like
This was his cheaper modern violin isn't it?
@@ss032010310103 He brought his Tononi violin to his masterclasses. Though his Guarnerius was his most prized possession, he had a special affection for the Tononi. It was the first violin he bought with his own money as a teenager. He played his Carnegie Hall debut with it and also his last recital in 1972. He even took it to tours in war zones in WW2. That violin's seen a lot.
@@srinitaaigaura oh I see. My teacher studied with him at USC. And he told me he purposely brought a cheaper violin to class so no one could say he sounded good cause of his Strad/Guarneri. Maybe that's the one he meant
@@ss032010310103 Once when a student complained that he didn't have a Guarnerius but only a cheap violin, Heifetz just took the student's violin and played the piece he was studying and produced his signature sound on it. Heifetz might have been strict, authoritarian and very moody, but he had a good side too. If Heifetz liked a student he would surprise them by helping them get better instruments. Rudolf Koelman still remembers the day when Heifetz called him up and gave him some money to help him out. He had been struggling and hadn't told anyone, but Heifetz found out and insisted that when he gives, there are no strings attached ever.
Who's your teacher?
The best part is Heifetz's ability to maintain a straight face throughout the entire performance
The five students you can see in the video are, left to right: Varoujon Kodijan, Adam Han-Gorski, Elizabeth Matesky (mostly hidden by Heifetz), Carol Sindell, and Claire Hodgkins. The other two students were Robert Witte (a short light-haired young man) and Erick Friedman (who can be seen in other videos here).
I love that how no matter how badly it sounds, the majority of it is pretty in tune (except for where he plays out of tune on purpose), and even the octaves and chords are still pretty good hahaha
you rarely ever see a video with Heifetz smiling and laughing. that was awesome.
I can't believe someone auditioned that piece with that kind of "preparation" tho
..could never imagine he had such humour....
most beautiful playing i've ever heard. what a master!
I will never think of this piece the same way ever again hahahaha too funny!!
Same here lol, everytime I hear this piece now I get the giggles. XD
A lot of people seem to think the laughing is fake but, if you ever hang out with music students, you'll see that this actually is their sense of humor. Once your level is so advanced, you are able to laugh at typical mistakes because you realize that unprepared and/or poorly trained musicians look a little foolish when trying to impress. And this, in turn, drives the students to correct their own minor versions of these mistakes.
thing is that's exactly what I would do and he'd still play it better than me :/ even if I try
Just imagine how much practice went into creating this. A perfectionist even in comedy!
The face of the pianist @2:00! XD
Lol, what he played there was downright weird....
Brooks Smith - Heifetz's regular pianist!
@@paulcaswell2813 Once when Brooks was asked what it was like to work with him, he admitted it was very challenging as Heifetz could play the piano parts even better than him.
Truly have to be a violinist to completely appreciate the humor of this... I was laughing so hard I almost fell off my chair and hit my head on the corner of the desk!
I think it's very difficult for such an accomplished violinist to purposely play poorly, but Heifetz sure does pull it off extremely well. =]
Some of these comments are extraordinary! This is a VERY funny clip from a very great violinist indeed. Heifetz may well have had a particular audition in mind but this is very, very clever. It is very difficult to play so 'badly' particuarly if you are Heifetz! Lighten up folks.
The work that Heifetz is deliberately mangling is Henri Vieuxtemps' Violin Concerto number 4 Op. 31, which Heifetz recorded in 1935 with the London Symphony and conductor John Barbirolli .
The funny thing is, I bet he spent many hours at home preparing this.
I think it was the end of the masterclass and Heifetz wanted to end it on a lighthearted note, give the students something to smile or laugh about. As i said before, nobody even knows if this was a true story or if it was just a fairytale that Heifetz created so as to make a joke.
As a beginner violinist if I could play this I’d be so proud lol
I understand you well, I have the same situation))
This is so funny!!!! Considering the fact that Heifetz is probably the best performer of the Vieuxtemps 4th concerto in history.
i love 2:04, lol you can tell he's trying so hard to sound bad but he still sounds good
Jamais imaginei que o mestre Heifetz fosse portador de tanto humor. É simplesmente fantástico.
Frankly ...he's naughty...wunderbar
Hihihi! Trop drôle! Je regarde en boucle!
Pauvre Vieuxtemps!
i don't think i've ever met a more self-assured man than him in my entire life.
I love this method. I had a Bulgarian teacher who did this to me after I played horribly. Worked like a charm. It's humiliating.
*twitch* Oh, Mr. Heifetz, you are cruel.
Funny how impossible it is for Heifetz to play octaves out of tune😂
Bro still can't hide his excellent technique!
His students are enjoying this deliberately awful performance and it actually takes great playing to sound this way. Notice that while the class is cracking up, Heifetz continues to keep a very serious demeanor.
The whole thing was funny, but when he did those pizz. chords, he got me :-)
Great. Just great!!! How many times have I heard people play like that and had to try to keep a straight face.
Heifetz rulz.
How he can hold his emotionless face is beyond me
Still my favorite violin clip of all time! Notice how the chick on the far right isn't laughing much...
That put me in tears. I can't even play that much.
Oistrakh also used to imitate bad playing,only that was not filmed.There is nothing vicious about this famous uncanny imitation of bad playing we all heard countless times.Actually,Heifetz did not imitate anyone in particular, he just gave this 'label' as a 'title' for his little joke.Whats truly amazing is how well he could play so badly.As for his mean nature-it is a well-known fact; only it has nothing to do with the joke.You guys might consider some anger management counseling out there:)
WOW, never heard mr. H play so well.
I never knew Jack Benny auditioned for Heifetz!
Uramisten ilyen is van nem hiszek a fülemnek Tulajdonképpen egy ekkora hegedűművész A világ legjobbja lehetetlenség hogy tudta így megoldani
I know that I'm the biggest nerd when I laughed at this
still better than me!
the original shred! love it
its good to know he had a sense of humor
it's the fourth concerto by Henry Vieuxtemps, and there is a good rendition by Heifetz on youtube.
Por favor nunca levanten este video ...perdón pero me enseña muchísimo más q cualquier maestro desde Las tse o Confucio hasta la actualidad ...primavera 2022 en Argentina y su muerte fue en la primavera argentina de 1989
The laughter from everyone there is sycophantic and nauseating in the extreme; I wonder how many of them could have played for Heifetz without succumbing to a fit of nerves?
I love it-I already thought that Heifetz was the best, now that I know he had a good sense of humour as well-I love him all the more. For all you sensitive little children, I hope you don't play anything because God forbid anyone tells you you're not very good and you'll likely burst into tears!
ChrisWatch, it's Vieuxtemps Concerto #4. I think there is a video of Heifetz playing it for real on CZcams
they who laugh, don‘t understand that he’s mimicking them. 😂
Heifetz original 1935 recording of this movement is now on CZcams.Laugh and compare!
This is the opening movement to Vieuxtemps Violin Concerto number 4.
He's absolutely serious---very good humor!.... To need study by "everybody 's" mistakes "....
He just imitated 75% of the "violinists" on youtube! lol
I really cant get bored of this video!! Each time I see it, I almost die by laughing!!
I love 4:03 :))
He's playing Vieuxtemps concerto nr. 4 1st part...
Very beautiful concert though, listen to original too...:)
Haha, he plays better than I do in this video!
Imagine being that student auditioning and seeing this youtube video all these years later and knowing that Heifetz secretely roasted you to everyone.
@Adorado31 They weren't actors. They were advanced students at a Heifetz violin workshop (which is on YT). Their laughter must have been a natural reaction to the very tough workshop and criticism they'd all just been through. Heifetz's spoof audition wasn't just for fun, there was a serious teaching purpose behind it. Remember that those students would soon be auditioning for top orchestral jobs, and perhaps one day would be teaching and even judging auditions themselves.
usted q le pase? Es uno de los mejores violinistas en el mundo! y q buen humor tiene el? Es una de las mas grandes personas de la istoria de la musica!
Great stuff - somehow i feel like i've been laughed at! Bet I sounded like that when i played to Starker...
Vieuxtemps, Violin Concerto No. 4 in D ma, Op.31 - Andante - Moderato
Another comment - the audience's laughter is probably mostly down to their relief at not being the butt of Heifetz's 'joke' themselves.
still better than most people.
2:00 - 2:04 sounds like middle eastern music then cabaret
You know, it's really not easy to play like that intentionally, what a play!
no puede tocar mal,es el interpretacion mas bella entre los malos!!hasta aqui es el mejor
My impression is that Heifetz is presenting an amalgam of bad violin playing under the guise of a bad audition, and not imitating anyone in particular. In other words, he's telling a joke deadpan. I think it's hilarious.
Years before TwoSetViolin was a thing...
Laughter is contagious! haha
laughed my ass off. thanks for the upload. ^^
Imagine this POOR GUY who had to audition for Heifetz
With no doubt Heifetz was the greatest virtuoso of the past century and he came immediately after Paganini for his technique.
But here for me Heifetz was a bitch: it isn't correct to make this imitation because every violinist who made an audition for Heifetz could get nervous towards him and probably this pupil studied also a lot in order to prepare this audition.
I think that someone of us who is laughing now for this could be very scared making an audition like that.
must be hard for someone this good to get it wrong on purpose..
L
M
F
A
O
.
Both violin virtuoso and comedy genius.
Как будто посмотрела немое кино с. Чарли. Чаплиным! Музыканты улыбаются.😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇
hell i wish i can play like that
@olympian1980 Menuhin is still one of the greats.
no, i mean exactly what i said, there are people who practice for hours on end, and struggle with their craft, but because it may not be their talent, they cannot match the level of a heifitz. that the point i was trying to make.
Take this video with some context and a grain of salt. These are professional musicians having a bit of fun, with some educational value too - Even knowing the mistakes takes knowledge of the violin.
Henri Vieuxtemps, Violin Concerto No. 4
THAT'S HOW I PLAY TODAY! LOL!
hahah his vibrato is so funny!
Just the Greatest of all!
What is the work he is playing?
Vieuxtemps Violin concerto no.4
He's not actually mocking a specific student. It's all tongue-in-cheek.
Here's a recording of him clowning around with Jack Benny: czcams.com/video/seZ4KhYr-Hw/video.html&spfreload=10
No Heifetz was not a mediocrity, that's the whole point...he was a genius. It's ironic when mediocrities laugh at other people because they themselves are not much better. Heifetz was above all other violinists, and the fact that he realised his abilities and talent is a good thing...nothing worse in this world than the pretense of false modesty!! If he was a god on the violin why should he not revel in it, he worked his entire life to achieve it!!
damn... still better than me
It's part of the 1962 Masterclass TV series (czcams.com/video/RLlUoS8D7Bo/video.html). He's having a little fun with the world-class violinists who are studying with him.
He still played it very in tone!!! He just could not play anything out of tone.
No, he deliberately played a lot of notes off. What a challenge for him...