Looking back at the Supreme Court’s term and its landmark rulings
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 06. 2024
- As the Supreme Court concludes another term, it is once again reshaping the legal landscape, with decisions on abortion, gun rights, social media and more. NBC News’ Liz Kreutz sits down with a panel of judicial and legal experts to reflect on this year’s rulings and their consequence. NBCUniversal News Group is the media partner of Aspen Ideas Festival.
» Subscribe to NBC News: / nbcnews
NBC News Digital is a collection of innovative and powerful news brands that deliver compelling, diverse and engaging news stories. NBC News Digital features NBCNews.com, MSNBC.com, TODAY.com, Nightly News, Meet the Press, Dateline, and the existing apps and digital extensions of these respective properties. We deliver the best in breaking news, live video coverage, original journalism and segments from your favorite NBC News Shows.
Connect with NBC News Online!
Breaking News Alerts: link.nbcnews.com/join/5cj/bre...
Visit NBCNews.Com: www.nbcnews.com/
Find NBC News on Facebook: / nbcnews
Follow NBC News on Twitter: / nbcnews
Get more of NBC News delivered to your inbox: nbcnews.com/newsletters
#SupremeCourt #SCOTUS #abortion
Landmark rulings are an understatement! No more life appointments, term limits for Supreme Court.
and adjust their term limits NOW!!!
@@hooker4749 Yes, exactly!
Right after term limits for congress.
Remove and replace Alito and Thomas. They have shown nothing but extreme corruption at the very least.
Not to worry....Trump will replace them 😂😂
We need a trifecta in Washington DC
Homeless bans are cruelty. Kicking someone that is down, is cruelty. Destroying/confiscating someone's property is cruelty.
These are 8th Amendment violations, medical and financial discrimination.
As a person on Disability, govt mandated poverty, I cannot afford housing or a campground, and therefore have no choice but to park on the side of the road. The Safe Parking areas are so restrictive that I don't qualify, since I'm disabled and not going back to work. And they kick people out at 7am, not able to return til 7pm, with no place to go during the day. And forced to this regardless of the medical ability to drive safely at that moment. And they threaten to tow my RV, taking everything I own, because I have medical issues.
Again, medical and financial discrimination, and 8th Amendment violations.
I've been fighting this locally, after seeing that several cities and counties throughout the country ruled them unconstitutional, and now the supreme Court rules against my life. They think it's ok to criminalize us for being on govt mandated poverty....
I want to sue the SC over this! I've been threatening to sue my county, they've been sued before over these bans.
Of course, we don't want people trashing an area, but that's what litter fines are for.
They can't treat someone as guilty of a crime they are not committing. I, in an RV, raised to be respectful by my parents, make no mess outside my vehicle, I shouldn't be treated as guilty because other people are guilty. That's injustice.
Being Disabled doesn't mean I should lose my Rights to Life, Liberty, and Pursuit of Happiness.
Yet cops threaten to take everything I own, and random people threaten to vandalize my shelter. And somehow these people don't think that vandalism is a crime......... 🤷🏻♂️
The SC needs to be sued.
You are absolutely right! I couldn't agree with you more.
It's despicable how many laws there are that are basically punishing poverty or disability.
@@DJJonPattrsn22 And keeping ppl with disabilities poor.
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
@@DJJonPattrsn22In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.
Its written as a title sentence. What God is doing and when.
GOD manifested himself let there be light his word ruach spirit was hovering (this is wave function) between the face of the deep which is buoyancy or what is too gravity and the face of the waters. Helium don't freeze and is element depiction of the face of the waters.
Nothing by definition is a perfect vacuum no thermal energy. The Schwinger effect and zero factor and factorial and Casimir effect give evidence to how nothingness creates something. God is within our universe and has proven so by suggesting himself a man who says he is the word the ruach of God.
On the Sabbath day God made nothing. The Sabbath is known as the first day in Christianity, and Einstein suggested light and matter are interchangeable E=mc2
You know had there been atmosphere instead of vacuum the helium would have froze.
Praise YHWH and Yeshua and The Holy Spirit all glory to God
@@adinahirschmann3112In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.
Its written as a title sentence. What God is doing and when.
GOD manifested himself let there be light his word ruach spirit was hovering (this is wave function) between the face of the deep which is buoyancy or what is too gravity and the face of the waters. Helium don't freeze and is element depiction of the face of the waters.
Nothing by definition is a perfect vacuum no thermal energy. The Schwinger effect and zero factor and factorial and Casimir effect give evidence to how nothingness creates something. God is within our universe and has proven so by suggesting himself a man who says he is the word the ruach of God.
On the Sabbath day God made nothing. The Sabbath is known as the first day in Christianity, and Einstein suggested light and matter are interchangeable E=mc2
You know had there been atmosphere instead of vacuum the helium would have froze.
Praise YHWH and Yeshua and The Holy Spirit all glory to God
Tenure at the university I taught at was not a guarantee of a job for life. We were assessed yearly, and if our performance didn’t meet a particular level two years in a row, dismissal proceedings could begin. Maybe more assessment and job performance demands would work?
Sorry George but they mean to completely dismantle those agencies one by one
Lack of regulations means disaster.
Regulations are protections to keep the public safe.
@@adinahirschmann3112like air and water
Didn’t the court just rule on receiving tips. I wonder who will get tips for this ruling
It’s why Trumps now promoting cancelling tips if he wins. That way he wont have to pay any tax on the money he will receive from Fossil Fuels, NRA or Big Pharma
Project2025 unfolding before our eyes
Sweet!! A lot better than Globalization
@@joecancer6013 For whom?! Only for (mostly) white men of power and privilege. The belief being that autocratic patriarchal domination MUST be sustained.
@@joecancer6013 Globalization is here like it or not.
@@joecancer6013 we live on a globe, with other people. Denying that is just stupidity.
@@williamsrdan Who is denying it? Reading comprehension is tough for you or your emotional.
All of your speakers are focused on the larger picture, the major issue is if the decisions are moved to the judicial, they do not have the numerical capacity to decide in a reasonable time.
None of the Speakers showed that they had any real answers or even any idea of what to say. All I saw was big ????? hanging over their heads. Its like they don't want to accept the Reality of what just happened to our Democracy. Our Rights, ect....
Could've listened to this panel for an hour longer. Disappointed there was no mention of Martin v. City of Boise, as inflation and housing shortages are pushing millions of Americans to the brink.
Biden did that
@@joecancer6013 Thanks for your intelligent response.
@@91ir07 You're welcome. I saw you were on Msnbc and needed some facts instead of propaganda.
@@joecancer6013 Thank you. Can you elaborate on how Biden alone is responsible for housing shortages, workers' wages not matching productivity for decades, private equity buying up houses throughout the country, cities lacking affordable housing, and inflation? I'd love a few non-biased, non-propagandized studies to support this hypothesis that you call "facts." I'm guessing you don't have any, but truly open to reading them if you do. I'll wait.
@@joecancer6013Including 🌏🌍🌎🌕🌌 inflation too 🧠
I don't see anything wrong with -having- _demanding_ a *follow-up interview:* Any of the justices who sat there in front of Congress and *lied out of one of their two faces* when they said _"I respect _*_settled precedent, and Roe is settled precedent",_* should be brought before Congress again and asked *_"So, what's up with that?!"_*
Supreme Court has done nothing but hurt America for the last 2 years. They are only with traitor Trump...which means they are for putin.
Repubs control the process. Removal begins in the House.
Roe is in the hands of the people. Don't be Naive.
@@joecancer6013 The people voted to keep it, over and over again. And if that is the case then TN and others would put it on the ballot. No naivety over here.😎
Will they also get a chance to still ask Justice Jackson to define what a "Woman" is I wonder😂
Legislation needs to be drafted and brought to the American people for a re-structure of the Supreme Court appointments, and have them accountable as any other federal employee.
Exactly!!💯🎯. Thats why we need to steer clear of the Manchins and Sinemas and VOTE BLUE down the ticket to reclaim the House; hold the Senate and Presidency-TRIFECTA!!! Republicans would need to BEGIN the impeachment process for SCOTUS.😮
President, Senate and House election all crucial for America. Vote blue 💙
Voting Blue since 1972.
Something needs to be done and all the talking needs to stop too much talk not any action
We need to vote all Democrats into the House of Representatives and maintain the Senate. That is the only way we're going to be able to get out of this mess
The situation is so bad that the whole Roberts court will need to be reviewed and many rulings overturned. Congress will need to begin writing laws to check the courts for corporate and political bias. All protections of corporations over people or liability will need to be stripped. Any action against professional doctors to be stripped because judges are not licensed doctors with credentials to judge health or outcomes.
Overturned by whom!? SCOTUS is the highest Judiciary body...so who will overturn them? If only wishes were horses.
@@linusfingesi2222 after Biden reelection I hope he install a new AG who will not be as timid to investigate the court. Thomas and Alito will be the lowest hanging fruit. While a Senate work to end ambiguity of laws and groups can challenge Alito’s claim that the second amendment is not to arm state militias. To codify Roe into law with no exceptions. In other words all of us… the people
@@linusfingesi2222 A New court without Thomas Alito and if Roberts smell the roses and retire. We the People. A Democratic senate and house.
@@mrlh61 wishful thinking at best and you know it...House doesn't matter when it comes to SCOTUS....you need 60 Senators in the Senate and no way will the Dems get that (might not even hold on to the Senate as the Senate Electoral Map this election favours the GOP) presidency is a toss up right now and definitely the Dems will probably swing the House....so with that in mind SCOTUS is going to be like that for a while (Thomas and Alito will not retire if Biden is re-elected and there is nothing he can do about that...same way RBG refused to step down when she was pushed under Obama only to pass away under Trump).
I'm not American, but I'm very sorry that the USA is increasingly similar to a third world country...
Thanks. We're working on it, but it's awfully hard.
That’s where the money disappears. A whole lot of kickbacks for the favors! Only the public is dumbfounded.
What George doesn’t understand is that the judiciary is ignorant about science. They are really stupid about what nitrous oxide is. Gorsuch proved that. We need experts to decide complicated solutions.
9 out of 10 Doctors prefer Cambels. 100% of Scientists agree with who funds them.
@@joecancer6013 what is a Cambels?
Sorry Conway, this time you really don't know what you're talking about. This ruling is a parallel to the RvV - In that case the judges step in and overrule the doctors, in this case the local (bribable) judges will rule about things they don't understand, instead of leaving it to the federal experts in the area.
Experts in Federal government? What are you smoking?
@@magicmandj Yes. Experts in government.
Why doesn't the Supreme Court operate like an appeals court? There should be a large bench from which you draw a certain number of justices. Plenty of room for recusal, plenty of justices to decide, much more impartiality of decisions and they could handle their larger docket in a timely fashion.
With this debacle decision we can lose the government of people, today I'm not sure if equitable
corporate entities care about people's lives
Let me be clear . Ninety nine percent of companies only care about their bottom line and shareholders, never outcomes for the better of societies.
They care in as much as it affects their bottom line. The stock price is all that matters to them.
The REAL problem with Justice Thomas that NOBODY is talking about is this:
The reason HE gives for his "mistakes" of not reporting all these gifts & so on is that he misunderstood the statue and the legal form he was filing out.
How is that nobody else find this deeply disturbing?
I mean, if the man can't understand a simple statue on ethics, or how to fill out a government form... WHAT is the basis for his ability & authority to decide the most difficult, complicated and important interpretations of laws in the nation?!?
HIS OWN explanation for his misbehavior completely undermines his credibility without even examining the ethical issues...
You sir are precisely why I try to read as many comments as possible. We've been all concentrating on the ethics of this add infinitum and this is a perspective that calls into question his ability to reason.
If we want change we need to vote blue at the state level more than ever.
@Bigfield47 but what can we do to change what the Supreme Court has already undone or put into place unless we can change the members of the Supreme Court or get them to abide to an ethics rule?🙄
Too bad. Trump is going to get another Supreme Court pick! Eat your heart out
So you want more states like California, Chicago, NY etc etc.
Democrat judges can't not even say what a woman is.
The court has really changed! Thats an understatement..The future looks bleak.
Vote for democracy and the Supreme Court, wish more people understood that in 2016.
George! They're doing exactly what Aileen Cannon is doing! It doesn't take 6 months to say NO
The idea the corporations don’t already functionally own the regulatory agencies is absurd
They don’t. They control the lawmakers - lobbying.😎
😅😂 Boeing is doing great regulating themselves
@@joecancer6013 🎯 You nailed it. Exactly my point
Vote blue 💙 America our only safe choice. America needs to reelect Joe Biden n move forward. 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Liz did an awesome job here NBC. Thank you for airing this important discussion on this rogue court.
Third trimester has to be an emergency and it has to be a delivery, not an abortion. Huge difference
It WAS exactly that under Roe v. Wade. The idea of "later term abortions" was BS by those who wanted to re-criminalize abortion. Under Roe, women had unlimited choice ONLY during first 3 MONTHS, then in the snd 3 months, there was more regulation to PROTECT WOMEN'S HEALTH since abortion is more complicated in that period. In the final 3 months, ONLY EMERGENCY of mother's life or seriously danger to her bodily functions. The MAJORITY of abortions under Roe and now are n the first 3 months (92%) Most 2nd trimester abortions were either unexpected heath problems of a pregnancy or due to low-income owmen delaing a first trimester abortion because she has to find the money to get it!
Roe should have been codified! Thomas's wife is MAGA up to her nose. She was at Jan 6. He should have recused!
Reading this AFTER the immunity decision came out. Shtrumph was NOT disappointed as George suggested he would be...😒
If Trump wins and get congress, wave goodbye to this country as you know it...not hyperbole. Its coming, and its coming fast ya'll. Get your stuff in order
lol. You mean we will get back to being a representative form of government like was designed?
Project 2025 is the road-map for a right-wing fascist State.
Isnt NOW is Biden's opportunity to appoint his people to scotus...
The Court has been paid off to do whatever these bribers want them to do. Expensive vacations. The judges need to live within their means like the rest of us.
Now we know, Neil 😢🇺🇲💔
Thanks for educating us.
Spoken like a true Federalist Society member, George!
I have always believed that court decisions should generally be the same given similar sets of facts as is the case with science. Unfortunately, law seems to be opinions and mostly logic. One gets the impression that anyone who is logical can become a judge without legal education
IF THE COURT IS MOVING TOO FAR TO THE RIGHT, then the so called justices are in violation of their sworn-oathes to uphold our Constitution! And... Lawyers - NOT KNOWING - whether or not something is Constitutional - or not - is SICK!
We The People NEED our 2nd Amendment to be fully operational!
I want to hear his response to this now, today.
George, Ted Bundy was well liked and very personable. Untillll.......
Good point
Yes absolutely.
LANDMARK RULINGS ARE AN UNDERSTATEMENT! NO MORE LIFE APPOINTMENTS, TERM LIMITS FOR SUPREME COURT. 🙂😄😀
Wait! Don't we want the people who decide safe levels of toxic chemicals to be politicians and judges?
Only leave 4 minutes for the audience to ask questions. How selfish. You use up 99% of the time and 100% of the Oxygen in the room.
You criticize President Biden. Just listen to yourselves stuttering on this program. And and and just trying to start a sentence. All of you. Just listen to yourselves.
True, they are still young & no disabilities yet they stutter too & having hard articulating what they are saying for more than 2minutes. While Biden is pressured for 2minutes!
Ordinary people will not understand any of this. That is why we have the various agencies in place - so that experts in their fields can implement. No regulation = chaos.
43000 views when I came here, 622 upvotes. While most of the comments are against the court decisions, most of the viewership seems to disagree.
Whats going on general?
Us should set up a judicial commission to appoint judges🤣the arguments I know that,ll be there will be that it,ll also be partisan which is true but the commission will most likely have pple from both sides,,,like it can have the CJ,a representative of the supreme court,the appeals courts,the normal federal courts,,the AG to represent gvt,two representatives of the bar and maybe a representative from each party which can publicly interview judges who apply and have a set and unchangeable qualifications like a certain number of yrs on the bench or in practice,consider them and appoint the best,this whole president appoints is very rare in most countries and naturally they,ll appoint the most liberal or conservative judge they can find
🙏🙏🙏prayers for America 🇺🇸… please let’s fight together get out & vote blue against authoritarianism & convicted felons!!!
The founder didn't give the supreme court a lot of thought and how politicized the court could be. To fix this mess, the constitution needs to be modernized.
The Founders didn't think of a lot of things....Constitution mordenized? Good luck with that. Ain't happening any time in the near future.
The Founders didn't think of a lot of things....Constitution mordenized? Good luck with that. Ain't happening any time in the near future.
They should not be life turns period.
the scotus has gone rogue...feral.
Call in the FBI..
Thank you ☕🗽🇺🇲
Death by 1000 cuts, bled us out
all I know is it changes everything
Well......they didn't get this right did they.....the worst happened!
All Hail the King and his Six Hands!
Happy Independence Day!
I like GEORGE MORE EVERY DAY
Here we go again. Only few will take.to court.
And courts take two to three years!
Begin Impeachments
Only the independently wealthy will survive in the end for anyone. At some point, if you are employed, you won't be. If you have a non- corporate business, you will lose it. Those with power right now, worldwide, are nihilists, and their view is "he who does with the most wins." We must all come to that realization.
There is much more choice in third world countries than in the USA.
I 💖 George
Shut up, George
You're a lousy judge of reality
Those arguments are weak,,,no single group of judges knows everything,,,,were the judges who came up with that precedent two groups of judges,,,bad law is that,,,bad law,,,u could think the US were barely functioning before 1984🤦based on what I got,parliament still has the power to delegate their power for the agencies to decide so what's the big deal🤣🤣🤣pple choose bad leaders then moan and cry when the court says that done decisions can only be made by parliament ,it was wrong for the court to give power to agencies that wasn't given to them by the legislature and that's what Chevron did
SCOTUS' Is going to "overreach" 😢
I have a sixth-sense that some is "up".
🐿️🤫🤫🤫🇺🇸
They already did brither
Chevron was a bad delegation of responsibility by the Court. Worse, it created a perverse incentive for the drafting of vague legislation. This reversal corrects both issues. As a side benefit it should slow the march through the institutes and maybe even pivot a reversal of said march.
I cannot like this comment enough!!! Finally congress will have to do their job. Love it!
@@mikemccord8399congress are not experts on all these matters and it is asinine to expect them to be. All pushing Congress outside the bounds of their knowledge does is create a pressure cooker for bad legislation. Moreover Congress cannot agree on anything long enough to actually pass beneficial legislation.
These people caused divide in this country with lies and never correcting audiences. Bs
Why have administrative agency’s if the rules they set don’t matter. That sounds like wasted tax dollars
Why have congress if unelected bureaucrats are going to make all the practical decisions?
The supreme Court should be done away with abolished
The SC is necessary to ensure the other branches of govt follow the law and Constitution....
That said, they are not doing their job, and several of them should be in jail for the injustices they've accepted.
😂
They need to stay in there place stop tacken money and gifts to pass laws6 for th0e rich.
Majority of Roberts Court are the Catholic Church, with their many Greek and Roman god successor saints, is idolitaric and non monotheistic.
We are Evangelical. Rulings on Chevron, et al, are here by NULL AND *VOID*. We pray you come to this alter and repent. He's still saving 2000 years later.
Neil - How's that crow tastin'?
You are clueless !!!
"libertarian" lawyer - what a joke.
Does she think those massive glasses make her look good? Reasonable people wear professional dress.
Really? 🤓 Poppycock
I have dementia and I am voting for Jill Obama
We need Trump and Project 2025 - My hope it is implemented to the fullest extent - a fourth level of government should not exist
No dictators in the USA!
Why do you want to destroy our nation? There is no greatness in anything trump wants to do.
If you want to live under Project 2025 go live in Russia.
The SCOTUS must be expanded 6-5....
99% of the time people only support court packing when their guy is in power.
Old guy here…
I’ll be dead soon so I’m not concerned that the idiocy of ‘merca will lead shortly to its final collapse. Pretty good run for an oligarchy
I’ll be elsewhere… laughing.
People don't believe in laws anymore... like freedom of speech, its elitist bs...
Seems...uh...just a weeee.bit. BIZARRE...ALL.ME.BERS.OF THIS BRILLIANT, VERY DIVERSE AND HIGHLY RESPECTED ".PANEL'..OF ...THESE...DEMOCRAT
S.. ALL ARE.IN AGREEMENT...SOOOO...???? IS THIS A 🤔 UM...SOROS PEPE KIZSSI.
Conway is republican. His ex-wife was in the sjt Whitehouse.
😂😂😂😂😂TRUMP WINNING
No dictators in the USA!
@@williamsrdantooo badd he is crushing braindead joe 😂😂😂😂
You criticize President Biden. Just listen to yourselves stuttering on this program. And and and just trying to start a sentence. All of you. Just listen to yourselves.