Is it true that Vernacular Schools are the main cause of disunity in Malaysia?
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 03. 2024
- A professor, who himself is a Chinese Malaysian, accused the vernacular schools including the Chinese schools as the main cause of disunity in Malaysia. The professor even accused the Chinese of insulting the Malays and Bahasa Melayu. I do not support this accusation and I list many incidents in Malaysia that has far reaching consequences. 1. The Hadi Awang insult 2. The Sanusi desecration of Hindu Shrine and Chinese Deity 3. Tun M Pendatang rhetoric 4. The Kampung Baru Cina and Bak-kut teh issue 5. The threats to Ngeh and Nga DAP MPs 6. The public school insult to other race incidents 7. The Muslim only Laundromat issue 8. the Taman Austin beating during Friday Prayers 10. The increase of Malays in Chinese Vernacular Schools.
We strongly recommended this genius professor to be the next Minister of education ... any comments....
Speak for yourself. we dont share his view
A wise man usually doesn't get much favor, because of the dunning Kruger effect.
his back will be full of dagger...
@@user-gf7cy8964q This is the modern age mate. People don't kill each other with daggers like the time of Caeser's.
@@enkryptron So, what is your view then? Please share here.
Really wish there are more Malay like professor Tajudin and Madam Mariam Mohtar,then our country can be more peaceful and progress. Thanks professor
Very well said 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
As long as the 22 years traitor and racists clowns are alive this beautiful country will never be in peace as during the 60s
How good if one of these 2 could be made PM. Sick of PMX pandering to different factions and betraying his promises just to shore up “Unity Govt” support.
@@cclye3267Are you listening to Professor Tajuddin and understand his message wholly? Go listen again at 19:57 what he has advice and you may review your comment again.
@@tonyzhan8668 Interesting comment. I did listened to the entire video. But I did not accept all his advices lock, stock and barrel. I voted for PH for many GEs and fervently hoped that PMX would come in and make a real difference. But what did we see in 2024? Saifuddin taking the hardline on a few issues, Fahmi doing his best to censor famous speakers, etc. I really sigh on the lack of a third alternate strong political block.
Just wish we have more fellow malay like Professor Tajuddin...respect and salute to you...👍👍🙏🙏
You are very well said and I salute to Professor Tajuddin and Thank you.I am your loyal Chinese Malaysian fan.
Hadi Awang is bad Muslim
How can this be the main cause of disunity where's more and more Bumiputra opted for vernacular education under the Ministry of education of Malaysia.. Masuk akal tak?
NO DOUBT ! MALAY POLITICIAN IS THE MAIN CONTRIBUTOR TO THE DISUNITY IN MALAYSIA !!!
Almost all of them from the opposition and mostly (some is an understatement) from UMNO who ruled for 60 years
Not the race but lack of wisdom and knowledge.
No doubt.....DAP politicians are the main contributors to national disunity
@@nadaiduit they are there for the money. No passion in nation building.
No doubt that DAP leaders cause national disunity
Malaysia will be very peaceful n harmonious if we have politicians like Professor Tajuddin
And will definitely prosper.
U r right.
Not as a politician bro… as a leader.
when you say politicians ..then automatically the words peaceful and harmonious are not valid anymore
Man with wisdom and tolerant, Malaysia will prosper with more leaders like him .
We are sort of running short of great people like him.
Believe that DAP is one of them.
TQ. A truly "educated" Prof unlike other "qualified" Profs..
Yes a trully educated Prof coz he is contradicting the main views of his own ppl. While at that the other Prof who speaks against Vernacular School is a traitor of your ethnic and race. Who is racist or biased and prejudiced now. Well my friend you make take this Prof Yajudin as one of you by all means. I for one will now consider him not as one of us of the Malay heritage. He is just plain annoying and disgusting
Thank you for taking him off from us.
@@user-jb9bj4rg2y You're A DISGUSTING Racist Living.... Not Consciously Nor Sub-Consciously....
Others pro ada la otak udang kah?
@@gilberthuat372 ada banyak copy Kuching punya prof. Buka mulut sahaja sudah tahu, entah siapa yang salah kalau sijil mereka tidak disita. Harap prof. Tajuddin dapat bawah ramai anak-anak Malaysia ke tahap yang lebih harmoni disemua persada antara langit dan bumi. God bless Prof Tajuddin.
I'm very convinced that the good professor has spoken out of embarrassment for his own kind as one of the educated and moderate Malays who form a good proportion of the majority race in this country. As a Chinese Malaysian who has seen better days since the nation achieved independence from the British, I sometimes feel that the Chineae here were better off coexisting with the colonial masters. We may not have enjoyed the best of everything the British could provide the colonists but we were more civilly regarded by our colonial rulers. It's really sad that after having played our part as equal partners in achieving independence the non-malay minorities, especially the Chinese, were so easily blamed for anything found offensive to Malay culture or their religion.
In the old days, with the existence of vernacular schools (chinese and indian), the rakyat mixed freely and was united. Then came Mahathir, changed the medium of instruction to Malay and the NEP - the country's education went down the drain where we were no longer competent in the English language and competitive against other countries. The politicians and extremist religious teachers with racist remarks were left unchecked. If this issue is not arrested, it will get worse.
On the other side, Singapore must be laughing at us - let the Malaysian politicians continue to fight over petty issues (english/malay, dressing, heritage etc) while they progress ahead. We should be focussing on the economy and get back on track after all the misappropriation of funds. Other SE Asian countries are catching up if not better than us. I hope the new Madani government will bring about change.
Good day from outside of MY. Not an expert on the UMNOcracy but when reading MY history, racial-religious-related bickering started under Mahathir at a time when MY had achieved a level of economic prosperity.
Once big $$$ came in, the more the political class preached unity, the greater the disunity.
Anwar was not necessarily the most ideal guy but after some time, he probably realized the problem was definitely within and thought there should be a different approach.
The $$$ interests decided Anwar was too dangerous and had to be removed. Furthermore, a significant number of influential people not of Malay-Muslim background, despite their unhappiness with the UMNOcracy, had also benefited in proportionate terms and did not want to rock the boat.
The longer the problem dragged on, the $$$ interests decided they had too much to lose, even if there were only limited reforms. Furthermore, the longer the disunity continued, the stronger the fear of an all-or-nothing outcome.🙄🙄
I am a Singaporean but I see no problem in Dr M changing the medium to Malay. Look at Japan and Korea. They also used their native language mah.
If the country is not doing well, do not blame the language. The main problem lies elsewhere.
I agree with you. Your country became intolerant when a politician of Indian origin became Prime Minister. That was the beginning of the end.
@@chinchang5117Mr, you zeroed in on the Malay medium of instruction. Prof Tajudin expounded on a litany of things which created hatred & fear of each other. Do try & look at the whole picture lah 🤨
Prof Emeritus Teoh is a shame and mockery to his own commuity.
Vernacular schools are not the main cause of disunity in fact the real causes of the disunity are extremists political parties in Malaysia with regards to race and religion. There's no evidences to claim that vernacular schools is the main cause of disunity. In fact in Sarawak in particular many non Chinese children including the Malays and the Dayaks are sending their children to the Chinese vernacular schools, and yet the unities among them are extremely well, peaceful and harmony..
Wikipedia Brunei education system. 8 chinese schools(1916), 7 mission schools(1931), 158 sekolah2 ugama(agama) & jawi, 6 arabic schools(1970) & international schools besides universities. They live in harmony.
Wikipedia Brunei education system to open our mind how a small multi-racial country can live in harmony & unity in the absence of toxic politics(3R issue).
Vernacular schools shdnt separate races in their canteen in terms of utensils etc etc. Some are still doing it. I miss those day wen we go over to our malay neighbour's hse for nasi lemak, n the came over to our for fried mee hoon. Where have those days gone?
Shall we copy Brunei social model ? Multi-racial society.
@@chuageokseng2168 Why copy? We are a good model of racial harmony! It's the political party and religious leaders are the one main cause! They are the one that's sowing racial hatred!
Well said, Prof Tajuddin. If Malaysia has more people of your mindset, the country will have hope of recovery.
Full Respect for this Professor 👍👋
I remember very well when my son was in his Tahun Satu class way back in year 2000. He told me that a Chinese classmate of his told him that Malays are stupid & dirty. I wonder how a 7 year old boy could say such insulting words. But I advised my son just to ignore that particular Chinese boy, make friends with others who are kind & smart who do not insult others no matter what race they are. Today my son is a full grown Malay gentleman who has friends of all races.
Your 7 year old kid told you. But my experience was, I was waiting outside my daughter's primary kebangsaan school. I saw how Malay primary school kids insulting Indian kids because of their skin colour! What do you have to say to that? This is one of the reason vernacular schools mushroom, after the abolishing of English medium schools! Tun Razak was wrong to abolish English schools, that unites students of all races better.
Not an expert on this issue but with the constant preaching of "Malays are weak" by the establishment for decades, cannot really blame this classmate for having such thoughts.🙄🙄
I visited Kampung Baru in KL when i was young and a very young Malay girl at about 12 years old spit on my shoes for no reason when i walked pass her. What's your opinion about Malays being taught and indoctrinated to hate non Malays ?
When I was in school in the 60's Tamils were called kling, hitam n Chinese makan babi so why Malays get angry when Chinese or Indians say anything to them, all my siblings left Msia n happy in our adopted country
@@morbid747yeah she is just breeding machine.. 60000breeding machine waiting to fill full their gaps
Prof Tajudin a true liberalist n broad-minded person.
This is the most suitable candidate to head the Muslim society and excellent truth we were educated in that era
It was mamak kutty and the young era politikus who make this country downfall in terms of takut dan Iman sondiri lemah
Liberal is kaaaapppirrr
@@gokusan280Taliban is Satan.
Pragmatic & tolerance are better word than liberalist in this majmuk society
Well-done Prof.
Prof. Tajuddin are real and good Muslim, I respect you, tq
MAHATHIR, ANWAR, HADI, MUHYIDDIN, NAJIB ETC WHAT DO THESE HAVE IN COMMON? THEY SPEAK IN THE SAME LANGUAGE, SHARING THE SAME CULTURE AND EMBRACING THE SAME RELIGION. WHY ARE THEY SO DISUNITED? 😅😅😅😅
Greed is uncontrollable in their mind & heart. The 3 poisons of human mind is Greed Hatred Delusion. Prescription is 😬 Moral discipline, Concentration, Wisdom😬 heals all.
Hunger for power and greed.
Setuju !
What has Vernacular Schools got to do with those goons’ disunity? Its all about GREED and the irony is that they are all MALAYS. 😅
Love for DUNIA is the root of all evil.
Well said professor Tajuddin.Professors should be like him....Great.
For a European living happily in Malaysia since many years , professors Tajudin’s clear messages are so important to peace and harmony in this wonderful country. THANK YOU!
👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍 highest respect and love for this genuine and intelligent gentleman.
Thank you very very much Prof Tajuddin for making such a fair and sensible comment. High respect for you.
I respect Dr professor Tajuddin Tq
Salute.😬
Always like to listen to you sir for your wise and fair explanations. Thank you, sir.
I have the highest respect for you, Professor. I wish there were more like you unafraid to speak the truth. Then there will be less defensive people creating even more divisiveness. I agree that many of the current politicians are responsible for disunity not the vernacular schools.Why are these schools drawing in more pupils of other communities then ?
Well spoken we need more people like U in this beloved country to progress 🙏🏼. Unlike some others to create disunity n slow down the progress of our country.Just look at Spore a small island who have no natural resources can be so successful in every prospects.Wake up.
Prof., you have given a clear and detailed explanation the "why" the non~Malays find themselves being sidelined and hence have to make headway on their own choice.
Terbaik Professor.May GOD bless you with good health to continue provide actual fact to Malaysian.Semoga ini mejadi contoh untuk para Professor utk berbincang secara akademik dan fakta.
Setting Bumi and non-Bumi status is the ultimate cause of disunity in Malaysia. Mother-tongue education would not cause disunity. Salute to Professor Tajuddin.
On the same vein, I can also claim that religious classes like tahfiz, madrasahs and religious higher learnings are the main cause of disunity in Malaysia.
I know of people from vernacular schools speaking normal bahasa malaysia and relate well to their many malay friends. I know of people from religious study who see others as kafir, never mixing with them.
Well said.
Well said Prof. Tajuddin. The Chinese Prof. should be charged for sedition or SOSMA.
I salute you Prof. Tajudin. Professor with brain 👍
Prof ,, Very wise and knowledgeable. Salute , salute, salute.
How come this guy is not the primary minister, he should be at least be the education minister
Terbaik Prof. Tajudin. Semoga dipermudahkan.
I never miss any of Prof’s CZcams videos, they give me hope that we have such intelligent and deep thinking Malaysians.
Many UMNO leaders sent their kids to study in SJK Cina.
You are a very wise man and impartial . Your knowledge of the various races living in Malaysia is very deep and unbiased. Malaysia need people like you to propel to higher level.
Based on the comments made sadly by Malays in the internet it would seem the disunity are caused by products of Sekolah Kebangsaan.Something need to be done by the Educatiion Department to ensure the product of Sekolah Kebangsaan do not become extreme racialist which is not good for our country's future.
In my olden days, we have Malay, Chinese and Indian eating together. You eat yours, I eat mine. When it comes to fruits or fish we share. Nowadays where got? It is because of the politicians who want to win votes and put fear into the majority by creating all sorts of excuses in the name of religion.
But i see many product of vernacular schools express inflammatory comments in social media, vilifying Malays and Islam related matters. who are extremist and racialist int this case?
Well said. You are spitting the fact. Wrong teaching at home is one of the main reason.
@@kamarulariffin5703kindly speak the truth. It was started by malays first. Hope you understand. At home your ppl talk bad about other race using deragatory words. Once malay kids come out from their house and they started to tease and behave cheaply towards other race. I would clearly say racism starts from home. But they are good malay ppl too i wont deny it
An excellent argument by Prof. Tajudin. A voice of reason and a true Muslim
Prof . U & me know very well . No such things . Bullshit . Anyway tqvvm for your positive thoughts . No doubt . Not many Malays who can think openly , wisely , fairly , positively & proffesionally liked u Profff . Salute Bro.
Radical religious leaders, politicians with sinister agenda and suppressive policies will continue to haunt the minorities! The latter can only bear in deafening silence as these obnoxious scumbags literally destroy the crumbling pillars of unity and harmony in our society! We are already living in the 21st century sadly such subversive elements still endeavour to pursue doggedly their dreams of establishing a government based exclusively on their fanatical beliefs and principles!
Thank you Prof for being so courageous in saying what you said. I wonder if you are being isolated by your race for being so contrarian in your views as compared with the many Malay politicians. Thank you for speaking out so tirelessly over the years
The main issue is education quality. Vernacular schools and private schools exists today is due to the quality. We have a phd graduate from national school who is confused between the lim family and the lee family..
UKM just joined in the PhD club of clowns(usm, upm, ukm).
Hahahahahahahah................
Narrow minded politicians need to wake up. Improve the quality of national schools above vernacular schools then you will see exodus from vernacular schools. Singapore did that and were successful.
@@Sangsinga682 Wikipedia Brunei education system. They are multilingual living in harmony in multi-racial society in Brunei our muslim rich brother blessed with abundant oil wealth in SCS. Why we are blinded ?
@@chuageokseng2168 the monarch rules the country and cares for the nation.
malaysian easily swayed by politicians who 'fight for their race, religion and culture'. first we need to remove all these politicians who exploit all these disunity dirty tricks
Prof gave a very balance view on the current situation, unlike the other so called prof who gave a statement that he alone could explain, with suspicious intent. Thank you Prof Tajuddin.
I support and in
total agreement to
Professor Tajuddin's points of view.
MashAllah. Tabarakallah. Alhamduliilah there's a "Malay" Prof like you, Sir. Barakallahu feekum Prof. May Allah help & guide us to be a better citizens in our country. Ameen
Very well said Prof... If only the rest could think like you. SALUTE 🙏🏼
We are still talking about racism ,religion,food ,pendatang etc ,
Singapore - focus on economy -;Bring in American superstar Taylor Swift for 6 concerts ,pay her more than US 120 million n Singapore Boost its gdp by 500. Million In a week - hotels ,airlines ,fully booked ,restaurants ,shopping malls sales up .
How smart Singapore leaders are ?
Pendatang Elon Musk from S.Africa went to America n after a period of time working n setting up business - result Tesla ,Space X etc generating billions in revenue ,providing employment to thousands ,creating wealth in America .
Malaysia how to improve economy ?
Well said Sir. Malay Politicians are the root cause of disunity in thie country headed by UMNO Youth leader. I am even ashame to mention his name esp when I don't know if he is a medical doctor. If its a PHD doctorate that I understand his arrogance.
PHD=Permanent Head Damage. That is the problem we have.
20-30 years ago..lots of malays come and have food with us together and to our restaurants. We always prepare food in most respected way but today none. Most of our food are vegetables, fish,chicken or mutton. All these halal because we normally buy mutton from our mamak (indian muslim). Mamak means uncle in tamil. Where there will be unity!
Pandangan yang mantap Prof.
Semua budaya, bahasa dan kepercayaan agama masing harus dihormati, sayangi bahasa ibunda anda dan tidak lupa asal usul anda. Belajar bahasa Malaysia sebab ia adalah bahasa rasmi negara, Belajar bahasa Inggeris boleh meningkatkan kerjaya dan daya saing pekerjaan, ini zaman belajar, jangan tanya apa yang negara buat untuk saya , tanya apa yang saya dah buat untuk negara? Buka minda baru boleh di sayangi semua orang. Ini lah yang saya belajar dari sekolah Chinese
Kudos to you Sir.So honest,diligent and a truthful explanation.
The ones forgetting or trying to find security,without trusting themself,is surely very alarming.
They are getting worst everyday,making a Multiracial Society,not a safe place to reside.
Karma is going to ruin their existence,if this persists,for they are subject to Answer the Creator.God.
Thank you Prof Tajuddin you have make the point we wish more malay people like you this country will be great country
Thank you Professor for a very balanced analysis on the subject matter. Such matters are important to all Malaysians who truly love the country and who hope that there will always be peace in the country. May I respectfully request the Professor to have your comments conveyed in Bahasa Malaysia so that our Malay Malaysians are similarly informed.
Well done Sir, you tell it like it is. Malaysia needs more Malay people like you. The Malays themselves have to change their mindset in order for this country to progress forward. The minorities in this country have no say and have always been marginalised.
Thank you, for your narrative on the subject of vernacular schools and the false allegations that are spat by narrow-minded Muslims. Hopefully, Malaysia has more people like you and Mdm Mariam Mokhtar in the country. Harmony led to recovery and progress.
Hats off to you, Prof. The country needs more people of your mindset who are not afraid to call a spade a spade to heal us all. Hope the later generations will be wise enough to see for themselves the truth of the situations and have the guts to stand up for justice for all regardless of race or religion
Salute and respect to Professor Tajuddin . Man with wisdom and open minded .
I had 2 of my children sent to Chinese school. I used to ask them if ever they were treated discriminately by the teachers and school. Never once, they answered. We went to China a few years ago and they were like ducks to water. They were happy they can speak Mandarin and overcome the communication barrier.
Your children will be able to take advantage of learning an additional language in their career development
@@co6033
I believe so. I keep telling them they have an asset many Malays do not have.
@@joharimamat1522They have another asset that many Malays don't have - You.
Great Prof Tajuddin, we need more people like him.
Well mentioned, explained & informed Prof.. Many Thanks
Prof, kamu kena buat video ni dalam Bahasa Melayu supaya org2 Melayu boleh dengar dan faham.
Buat dalam bahasa apa pun melayu totok tak akan paham😂
Sudah pun dibuat tq
@@proftajuddin5176 Prof, saya ingat umur kita hampir sama. Saya pun adalah veteran ATM berkhidmat selama 25 tahun. Cina. Kesian saya tengok keadaan masyarakat Malaysia kini. Saya disini ingin berterima kasih kpd Prof yg selalu memberi ilmu kpd masyarakat umum. Take care and wish you and family good health always.
Lately watched and following sir, truly respect and Prof shld be a great Malaysia politician compare many other out there.
Always loved your articles Prof in the star. Have been an avid reader.
Respect n Salute to your Wisdomship,Sir.
Tq Prof. Prof with excellent knowledge.
Good Evening to you dear professor and I really support with all the points which you have highlighted based on the misunderstanding in communication which is being performed by all our 3 basic cultures.
Dear Professor I hope that if all this minor misunderstanding within our cultures are ended then this is when we will see our country Malaysia which I am proud to be a citizen successfully succeed.
I really respect 🙏 you sir for your valuable talk which you have given today. Have a Great day Sir.
Respect to Pro Tajuddin.
Thank u Prof. If only more of leaders think like u 🙏
Insightful and wise opinion. Thank you.
Take care as a few feathers are certainly ruffled. I can feel the "heat" of the Big Three already.
I appreciate Dr for the past twenty-plus years, Malaysia has been plagued by some political jerks, causing stagnation and mutual suspicion. However, I believe that Malaysia still has many academically-minded individuals like the doctor who provide more accurate information to our Malaysian society.
👍👍Prof Tajuddin is really a Very Wise & Truly Good Professor as i listened to his comments in this CZcams✍
Excellent argumentation. So there are now at keast 3 individuals, Mariam Mokhtar, Tawfik Al Attas and your goodself who understand the problems and possibilities of our country. It was good to hear.
Well said proffessor.👍
Prof, salute to you, you had touched, in many of the topics that are of great great concern, to the overall citizens of Malaysia. When we can love muslims, why can't they. As you said please heal Malaysia
Prof Tajuddin, you are very rational and fair in your assessment of the non-Malay citizens of Malaysia. Terima Kasih.
Thank you ❤
Well said, I salute you
Tq prof Tajuddin. We can able to deal with fascist minded politicians at semenanjung. Sarawak and Sabah have no tolerance to fascist politicians from semenanjung. I ❤️sarawak as my second home
I’m upset that I send my kid to SK school but the teachers would be absent in class or rather play hp in class than teaching the students. Hence why I think vernacular school has better teaching for students.
My high respect.
I respect u brother, we got a person with a very clear mind set in Malaysia Tqtq
Prof. you are a very intelligent and kindhearted person. You are the true Gems of our beloved Malaysia who we are very to have. Thank you and God bless you.
Well said. We need to wear Respect.. ❤
Well spoken Professor Tajuddin.tq.
An excellent explanation by Prof. Tajudin. Respect!
Enjoy yr video & insights. Clear minded, knowledgeable with facts. Tq. Gratitude there's a person with decent character, moral & fair. May the nation give birth to citizens of yr character.
Well said. Thank you Prof.
I agreed to what Prof Tajuddin said.He is a learned professor and understand true Islam.
Thank you Prof Tajuddin. You are very wise and love being a man of all season.
Fully agreed with professor opinion ,we hope everyone think like professor and our country will be peaceful and prosperous
Good example and a fair taught on the subject concerned, and always consider the sensitivity of other Malaysians around.
You are the man
Prof YOU ARE NOT ONLY VERY INTELLIGENT AND WELL READ BUT ALSO A MAN WHO TRULY PRACTICES HIS RELIGION AND A GREAT AND ARDENT AND TRUE FOLLOWER OF THE HOLY PROPHET AS COMPARED TO THE WAYWARD AND BLIND RELIGIOUS FANATICS YOU HAVE MENTIONED ...MAY ALMIGHTY GOD ALWAYS HELP , PROTECT AND BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY MEMBERS...
I salute you Professor. I wish more people, especially the politicians , were as level headed as you.
Well said, Prof.
Thank you for speaking out on the various issues in Malaysia subjectively. It's very sad that many politicians intentionally misinterpret Muslim teaching as a tool to create rifts between races for their own political gains.
The shining star of malay intelligentsia.
Very well said, Prof. I salute you. Actually the main cause is the past political govt..which allow this to happen. In the kampung, we don't have any racial issues. It is the political parties dividing us. Hope Prof will produce a BM version soon. Teo KS is flaming the fire by talking nonsense. He needs to learn,relearn and unlearn. Kalau dia ada bukti, mengapa tak buat lapuran polis?
Malaysia is such a beautiful country n had a gd life growing up there, sadly cos of the politicians lots of Msians have left for other countries, BRAIN DRAIN, loss to Msia. From Australia