Charlie was really going through it. His god-son of sorts is a werewolf, his daughter's something else, and he's not allowed to ask questions. Poor guy.
@@mish8183 In the book he would rather not know. In the movie, he wanted to know. Unfortunately, either way, he would be dead if he knew when Aro eventually read Edward's mind (or the mind of anyone but Bella who knew of Charlie's awareness of vampires).
Charlie’s reaction when hugging Bella in this scene always gives me this hard lump in my throat or just flat out makes me cry. He realizes that his daughter doesn’t feel the same anymore. She’s stone hard and cold, but he avoids questioning it so he doesn’t lose her. Charlie deserved better. I haven’t finished reading Breaking Dawn yet, but I just wished Stephenie could’ve cut Charlie some slack and give him that same power as Bella where no one would be able to read his mind; that way he could safely know what was going on with her without getting anyone in trouble...
Edward can partially read his mind, in midnight Edward says to himself that Charlie is not as quiet as bella. He wonders even if Charlie s parents are alive to listen to them. So whereas bella is full mental shield, charlie has one to I think.
I love how when he hugs her he can feel how cold she probably is and he kinda hesitates and you can tell he's about to question it before he just lets it go and keeps hugging her
Well, it's fine because she stops wearing contacts when her eyes go gold, so although he won't ever see them freakishly red, he'll know they're not her normal brown
Did anyone else feel sad for Charlie when he hugged Bella and at 3:06 he frowned because he expected her to feel 'warm' but now she's ice cold. And the sadness and confusion on his face when he realised that his daughter is different and he'll never know why is heartbreaking.
Ok, but really, it'd be kind of heartbreaking. His wife ditched him with Bella when she was a baby, then Bella comes back to Forks when she's 17, hits it off with this Cullen boy, runs away extremely suddenly for some time and comes back injured, then the Cullen boy and his family leave and Bella goes into a very depressive state for months on end, looks like she might be getting a little bit better with Jacob, then suddenly runs off again to save Edward somehow, then Edward comes back, and a few months later Bella and Edward say they want to get married. The new couple leave on their honeymoon, and the next thing Charlie knows is that Bella is ill, but eventually gets better somehow and has a baby that looks suspiciously like him. From Charlie's POV, Bella runs away a lot and gets into a lot more risky and strange behavior and situations after beginning a relationship with Edward.
@Alex Paul she stops edward from killing himself. Told jacob to run when one of the guys turned into a wolf cause she didn't know he was a big ass wolf. She left the first movie because she had to protect her dad and made edward take her home to check on her dad . She couldn't help but grow feelings for jacob and kept rejecting him so that he would move on cause she didn't want to play with his feelings . She even thought about moving on from edward to jacob when he disappeared but didn't wanna rush things because she was still thinking of edward and asked him to give her some time. She defends her daughter and protects everyone with her new vampire powers ....but yeah shes a bitch and a player
@@nicoleavalon936 Facts. As a girl with a great relationship with her father I could not have done that and would have chosen Jacob and just lived happily like that.
@@taylorr8848 naw, she was selfish for getting involved. She was a teenager, and Edward is hundreds of years old. He shoulda had the sense to stay away from her. If movies like this were real, and we could see how things are in the future, I think Bella would regret her decision. Dying is a part of life, she basically sold her soul to be an immortal with super powers, and when she dies she doesn’t get the same death as a normal person.
The fact she has Bella's eyes was a big tip off for Charlie , but then he broke down the baby's name and realized it's Rene (Bellas mom) and Esmee (Edward's mom) name put together. Her middle name is also Carlie which is just Carlisle and Charlie put together.
@@Lady-Seashell-Bikini this is entirely false lol he adores having her there he’s just a quiet and shy person, when she leaves in the first book he was devastated
@@uhuhuh1966 Doesn't change the fact that she was cooking all the meals and cleaning his home. And of course he'd be devastated, but let's not pretend he was the perfect parent. There's a reason why Bella was so closed off.
I never noticed before but charlie probably figured out that renesmee was actually their biological child but he didn't question it because he didn't want to lose Bella. Also he probably knew something supernatural was going on with her when he hugged her cause he noticed she was hard and cold.
Yeah in the books he knows that something is up but doesn't want to know the exact details. He also realises that Renesmee is Bella's biological daughter because Renesmee's eyes are identical to both Bella's and his own (Bella inherited her brown eyes from her father)
I WISH THAT CHARLIE SAW HER REAL EYES AND THAT HE TOLD HER THAT HE GETS PANIC AND TELLS HER THAT SHE'S SO COLD...THAT HE WOULD TELL HER TO FOLLOW HIM TO THE DOCTOR! I DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW THE DIRECTOR WAS THINKING...IT COULD HAVE BEEN SO MUCH BETTER DRAMA...
@@mineonlyedwardcullen True, but it was for his own personal safety that she had to keep the truth from him. I do like how Bella asks him to just trust that she is safe and happy. Even if she never became a vampire, there still would have come a time where Charlie would need to accept the fact that his daughter was not a kid anymore and that he needed to let her grow up and live her own life.
It just occurred to me that Kristen was wearing contracts through the entire series, because her natural eye colour is green. She had to wear chocolate brown for Human Bella, bright red for Newborn Bella, orange(ish) for Several Months Old Newborn Bella, gold for Vampire Bella and mud brown for Charlie (when she was a newborn trying to hide her red eyes).
exactly what I was thinking! and though that sence with the eyecolor was cute, vampire Bella was still wearing fake contact lenses, to mimic her old eye color when Charlie was like "she has your eyes, Bella" and I think that's funny 😂 They have to be really good contacts to match her old eyes but I guess the Cullens didn't have an issue with money so.
Charlie had it the roughest. Literally Bella didn't give a shit if she hurt him or lied to him. Hell she was gonna let him believe she was dead if not for Jacob.
Big fan of the word 'literally', eh? Like to squeeze it in every time you say something? All righty then, but be aware that intelligent people are laughing at you when you add the word literally to everything you say.
man. she really just threw all of her happiness into this weird vampire and his family. and then disgarded her own, like they didn't matter. she talks to her dad like she doesn't respect him. now that i'm older, i realize how toxic this whole relationship is. not something to aspire to have, at all.
For real. I enjoy these movies because of Rob and Kristen's chemistry, but this entire relationship was messed up. A channel called Cinema Therapy seriously reviewed these movies and broke down exactly what was wrong with Bella's relationship with Edward and Jacob.
I totally agree 150%. I honestly only watch clips from this movie for Bella's outfits and her hair lol. I'm not a fan of Kristen Stewart but I would kill for her body.
She suppose to live her life for her parents? Her mom's out living her best life. Her father is a cop n fisher man . It's consumes all his days. I'm happy for her. 😂😂😂 .. least she didn't just leave, faked her death. She should have kept her life and loved a man. But besides that they make a beautiful couple. 🌻
Still feel bad for Charlie. It's like all this time he had no idea of what's really going on. He didn't know her daughter married a vampire. He suspected Renesmee is Bella's biological daughter but there's nowhere to ask. He definitely noticed Bella's change but still couldn't get an answer.
Jess dont forget shes also hard now, in the book when she talked about snuggling with Edward she always referred to what she would imagine it would be like to be snuggling with "Michelangelo's David" so I imagine when he hugged her she felt hard like stone as well as cold
Never understood how Bella managed to keep Charlie at bay. I miss one phone call from my Mother and she goes insane. Poor writing for Charlie was meant to care for Bella a ton, he wouldn't have just let her go missing for weeks on end without tracking her down. All I know is if I tried that my mum would have the FBI/CIA/Police Force on my ass.
Yeah I thought that was a huge plot hole too. I mean, in Eclipse when the hikers go missing, Charlie tells Bella that if she ever went missing he would never ever stop looking for her, and in New Moon he goes insane with worry when she takes off to Italy just for two days. I know the Cullens tell him that she's sick/contagious - any loving dad would just ask what hospital she was in and declare he would go see her even if he had to wear a hazmat suit.
Same here! If I was allegedly “sick” and bedridden somewhere with some dangerously contagious disease, *no one* could tell my parents to stay away. Even if they had to swim to me. So…new plan 😂
In the books Bella doesn't see her mother again, which is an unbelievable plot hole in my opinion. I mean, Bella is her mother's only child, plus in the first book she describes her mother as her best friend. Then it's all like "Hey mom, I've got mah man and mah baybee now, so byeeeee!" Renee might be ditzy but she loves Bella more than anything, she would never accept not seeing Bella again
+ChooseYour Poison In the books, she explains that she intentionally chose not to see her mom again, despite the pain it would cause her emotionally, because she considered herself a "Danger Magnet" and that her mom would be endangered. The idea was to never see her father again as well, but they changed that plan once Jacob interfered and revealed the supernatural to him.
I still cry every time Charlie expresses his feelings like “I miss you Bells”, like I kinda feel like I’m in his place of parenthood, even tho I’m not even a teen yet lol 😂. I absolutely love Twilight!
Because laws of volturri, and Charlie decided that he doesn't need to know everything (in the books). Why not just change Charlie? Because of their treaty with the shapeshifters, bella is an exception but i think the Cullens don't want to again break the treaty for something they could avoid, like not telling charlie.
Carmela Camba yes! Exactly! Why not just turn Charlie? Then he wouldn’t have to grow old and end up leaving Bella. Also, I feel like an explanation would be needed when Charlie sees Bella and she looks 18 when she’s supposed to be 80.
It would be interesting to see Charlie Swan to be one of their kind especially that in Midnight Sun book, Edward couldn't clearly read Charlie's mind so what if Charlie Swan might've had special gift of a similar mental shield like Bella's? It's like James is a tracker, but Demetri is a God-like tracker. Imagine if Kate or Jane tries to use their gifts on Charlie, he would get hurt, but ONLY very little.
Jazzy Jonas they did but they put Mekenzie's (the actress that played renesme)face on the baby so she look the same later. They used sevral baby as she was growing up
WHY WASN'T CHARLIE HAPPY WHEN HE SAW BELLA? HE WASN'T HAPPY EITHER WHEN HE SAW RENESMEE...THEY DIDN'T EVEN ASK HIM IF HE WANTED TO HOLD HER!WHY?!:'(THEY DIDN'T ASK HIM ABOUT WHY HE WAS SAD!:'( WHY?!
Charlie is described in the books stoic and uncomfortable of showing emotion, so even if he was ecstatic about seeing his daughter he wouldn't because that's part of his characterization. As for him not holding her? Even if he asked it would have been too dangerous. Reneesme (sp?) is part vampire (so is quite strong and needs to drink at least some blood in order to survive) and a baby, and a majority of the time when a baby is faced with something new if tends to stick it in their mouths. So a vampire baby is less likely to have control over their impulse in not drinking from a living person.
Honestly for me Charlie was the only Character that actually stayed good and true to who he is. Of course he's mad/sad/angry and has questions Bella cant even buy Alcohol yet. He definitely deserved better or at the very least learned the truth so he can help the humans who are being murdered by Vampires. Especially when the army was created and all those missing teenagers.
LoveAlwaysNelle i would have dealt with different babies. but seeing that fake one in the theater literally had me and everyone else in there in tears of laughter
Edward: Charlie can't come near Bella! She'll be in pain like scorching daggers down her throat! She'll kill him in an instant! Also Edward: let's give them some privacy...
I wish we had Bella’s mom’s reaction on this “adoption”. Plus her reaction to a hug from her now cold/hard daughter. Would have made for a more interesting movie.
I love twilight but I hate that people don't sympathize or ever mention Charlie. All they do is mention edward or jacob or others but never her own dad. She's the only child if she's gone then Charlie would be one depressed man. He's the character I felt bad for.
One of the things I never got was the whole idea of renesmee. They never told Charlie "hey by the way this kid grows very quickly and before you know it she will be 8. It won't take 8 Years, but instead maybe 8 weeks or 8 months." He never questioned why she's so big all of a sudden the next time he sees her. At least a better excuse could have been given about her other than she's my niece/daughter.
Renee was a negligent child who made Bella be the responsible one. That's part of the reason why Bella comes to live with Charlie. She doesn't want to be in the way. Sad.
mineonlyedwardcullen well she tried since she wasn’t breathing, so she wouldn’t have been tempted by him, but I think if she kept looking at his neck she wasn’t fully controlling herself. It’s her dad but he’s human after all, so it’s normal that she was tempted 🤷🏼♀️ I know it’s sad...
I just watched all five movies and Billy Burke was like a rock in all of them, always believable even when no one else was. That’s why this scene is so heartbreaking.
Every moment with her and Charlie is my favorite because I think of me and my father's relationship and how strong it is. This scene makes me cry everytime.
Charlie knows the cullens and knows how cold their skin is, and remembering bella's warmth and now hugging her and she being cold skinned, he probably would gather in a few years time what has happened, when she doesnt age, and with the Renesme growing so fast xD
I WISH THAT HE HAD SO MANY QUESTIONS AND FORCED HER TO TELL HIM EVERYTHING! I'M SO ANGRY ABOUT THAT SHE DIDN'T WANT TO SAY THE SECRET!:@ I WONDER HOW CHARLIE WOULD HAVE REACTED IF BELLA TOLD HIM THAT SHE'S A VAMPIRE...WHAT DO YOU THINK WOULD HAVE HAPPEN?
So, here's the deal with that. Charlie knows "something" is up, but he is not allowed to know the specifics. As long as Charlie just accepts what he's told, and then doesn't go researching like Bella did, he'll be safe. Though let's say we're after the Volturi incident a few years down the road. While they wouldn't actually do it, it would be relatively safe to possibly tell Charlie, at least for a while. The Volturi don't get out very often, so it would likely be decades before they ever found out, if not a couple of centuries.
Is Charlie really going to die if he finds out a bit of Vampire kind, or the Volturi will just forced him to be silent? Sorry Idk abt Twilight that much
I remember in the book she explained her fathers’ scent didn’t smell appetizing which Edward and his family feared. She could smell him, but it was just in the memory of her father, something like that. And when Charlie looks at her weird when she hugs him, it’s because she feels like a cold brick in his arms 🤣🤣 book fun facts lol
Actually, someone please correct me if I am wrong. But in the book, does it not say that newborn vampire Bella finds that her dad's scent is more potent and a more powerful attractant to her, and that it was possibly because he is family to her. It was because of his biological connection to her human self, even though she is now no longer human. That she had to fight that much harder to resist his blood and that every breath it took for her to form speech to talk to him and answer his questions was the worst torture?
Honestly, I know in the book Renesmee is described as a very aware and intelligent infant because of what she is. But I would happily have allowed them to miss out that detail and just had her be a normal baby in the film so she didn't look so creepy with all the CGI. I was very thankful they made her a bit older later on in the film than she was in the book and used a proper actress as opposed to the creepy child all the way through.
Bella was willing to throw away her entire life like planning on pretending to die and lay in a coffin while her parents cry over her, that’s terrible, forever leaving her parents her family
Hawa Ahmad uhm.. She lived with her dad since twilight. You obviously didn't watch the whole movie, and doesn't even understand the fact of being a hard rock like vampire with incredible strength. That kind of hug you're talking about would kill her dad.
This is poss the saddest moment in the movie. Charlie finds out that the daughter that he reconnected with is forever gone but he finds out that he's a grandfather of a furiously fast growing little girl.
The title says Charlie finds out about her...he doesn't find out shit. I understand she can't really tell him because the Volturi would be after him, but geez she really treated her parents badly especially her dad who tried so hard for her .. I feel so sorry for Charlie. Bella put her feelings for Edward above her own family, put them in danger, fucks off without telling her dad anything and then keeps even more of a distance from him after becoming a vampire. And he gets no real explanation at the end of it all.
Two. She told edward she didn't want to hurt him and he told her that she has to ...so she said hurtful things and left so the other vampire would follow them and not go to her house with her dad there
Charlie deserves better. He loved Bella so much, the least she could do was tell him what she was. Every time he called her Bells’, it made me almost cry! He was the only character I acknowledge
Bro if she would've just tell him, then maybe he wouldn't be more concerned and upset. Yet she's making it more worse for him. I've always felt Charlie needed to know what happened. But you know Bella will always protect her dad no matter what happens lol.
Bella really does have a selfish attitude. Out of all the people she been selfish with, her dad was the one who got it the most. She expected him to just accept she was with Edward, and then to accept she married him, left to say she was “sick” but got pregnant and died and became a vampire and expected him to accept who she became by not exactly telling him who she became. I felt bad for Charlie actually through the series
Charlie was really going through it. His god-son of sorts is a werewolf, his daughter's something else, and he's not allowed to ask questions. Poor guy.
He rather not know
@@mish8183 In the book he would rather not know. In the movie, he wanted to know. Unfortunately, either way, he would be dead if he knew when Aro eventually read Edward's mind (or the mind of anyone but Bella who knew of Charlie's awareness of vampires).
He's a smart man I think he could probably figure a lot of it out on his own especially the vampire part.
tiyabear how is jake his godson
Jessica Sheridan I said of sorts. It’s not cannon, I just figured it’s a safe bet because Billy and Charlie have been friends since they were kids.
i cant believe the filmmakers saw that baby and thought "yep, that looks good."
Fr
It looks so fake it hurts.
Amelia Rose yeah
but she is cute
tho
It’s because they spent all their budget on a doll that ended up looking too creepy so they scrapped up whatever was left and used that toward the CG.
Charlie’s reaction when hugging Bella in this scene always gives me this hard lump in my throat or just flat out makes me cry. He realizes that his daughter doesn’t feel the same anymore. She’s stone hard and cold, but he avoids questioning it so he doesn’t lose her. Charlie deserved better. I haven’t finished reading Breaking Dawn yet, but I just wished Stephenie could’ve cut Charlie some slack and give him that same power as Bella where no one would be able to read his mind; that way he could safely know what was going on with her without getting anyone in trouble...
Just read midnight sun and edward cant read his mind
Laiz Diniz really??? I’m reading it right now. I’m on chapter 6 so far
Edward can partially read his mind, in midnight Edward says to himself that Charlie is not as quiet as bella. He wonders even if Charlie s parents are alive to listen to them. So whereas bella is full mental shield, charlie has one to I think.
Have u finished reading the book
he actually has some partial resistance to mental powers like bella
I love how when he hugs her he can feel how cold she probably is and he kinda hesitates and you can tell he's about to question it before he just lets it go and keeps hugging her
I wish that he asked her about why she's so cold:/
And I wish that Bella forgot to wear contacts,and then he would have seen her red eyes...
Well, it's fine because she stops wearing contacts when her eyes go gold, so although he won't ever see them freakishly red, he'll know they're not her normal brown
Now that's good acting
Cassandra Barba I think he's also feeling how hard her body is, like hugging a marble statue.
Cassandra Barba that's why he said when she became a vampire your the same temperature
Poor Charlie, he found out his granddaughter is a horribly rendered cgi baby.
🤣🤣🤣
poor charlie😂😩✋🏻✌🏻
To be fair it’s from 2012
I came here to say that excat thing! It never stop being confusing
😂😂😂😂😂
Did anyone else feel sad for Charlie when he hugged Bella and at 3:06 he frowned because he expected her to feel 'warm' but now she's ice cold. And the sadness and confusion on his face when he realised that his daughter is different and he'll never know why is heartbreaking.
petition to rewrite the entire books but in charlie's pov now
Ok, but really, it'd be kind of heartbreaking. His wife ditched him with Bella when she was a baby, then Bella comes back to Forks when she's 17, hits it off with this Cullen boy, runs away extremely suddenly for some time and comes back injured, then the Cullen boy and his family leave and Bella goes into a very depressive state for months on end, looks like she might be getting a little bit better with Jacob, then suddenly runs off again to save Edward somehow, then Edward comes back, and a few months later Bella and Edward say they want to get married. The new couple leave on their honeymoon, and the next thing Charlie knows is that Bella is ill, but eventually gets better somehow and has a baby that looks suspiciously like him. From Charlie's POV, Bella runs away a lot and gets into a lot more risky and strange behavior and situations after beginning a relationship with Edward.
Fredster !! I do agree
@Alex Paul she stops edward from killing himself. Told jacob to run when one of the guys turned into a wolf cause she didn't know he was a big ass wolf. She left the first movie because she had to protect her dad and made edward take her home to check on her dad . She couldn't help but grow feelings for jacob and kept rejecting him so that he would move on cause she didn't want to play with his feelings . She even thought about moving on from edward to jacob when he disappeared but didn't wanna rush things because she was still thinking of edward and asked him to give her some time. She defends her daughter and protects everyone with her new vampire powers ....but yeah shes a bitch and a player
Noras Doodles she also legit chose Edward and being a vampire over her father and mother so...
@@nicoleavalon936 Facts. As a girl with a great relationship with her father I could not have done that and would have chosen Jacob and just lived happily like that.
That poor guy was left by his wife then his daughter ditches him constantly and lies all the time. Its ridiculous.
I mean if this were actually true in rl you would probably do the same thing so you wouldn't get yourself killed nor anyone else.
Well yeah, but she does it to protect Charlie. If he ever knows that she's a vampire the Volturi will kill him
@@chooseyourpoison5105 after the war was over, she could’ve said something
What’s the excuse there?
@@ninjanibba4259 the vulturi we're still in power therefore Charlie would still be killed.
@@taylorr8848 naw, she was selfish for getting involved. She was a teenager, and Edward is hundreds of years old. He shoulda had the sense to stay away from her. If movies like this were real, and we could see how things are in the future, I think Bella would regret her decision. Dying is a part of life, she basically sold her soul to be an immortal with super powers, and when she dies she doesn’t get the same death as a normal person.
"Do you turn into an animal, too?" Gets me everytims xD
PinkCatz LMFAOOOOOOOO
PinkCatz I thought it was funny when Jacob was like “she wishes she was that awesome”. XD
It doessss🤣🤣🤣
“She wishes she was that awesome.” -Jake lol 😂
No, dad, save it for classic vampire to turn into bats😅
"i just watched the kid i've known for his entire life turn into a very large dog." WHY DOES THIS MAKE ME LAUGH EVERY TIME
lol it just happened as i saw your comment
Maya Banks I saw this before It happened lol
Maya Banks 😂😂
Lmfao! Gets me every time too 😂😂😂
Maya Banks me too😂
You can tell from the way he says 'She's got your eyes Bella' that he knows she's their kid somehow, and not adopted
In the book Charlie actually figures it out instantly ans freaks out at them a little.
Lol. Obviously. That’s the point
The fact she has Bella's eyes was a big tip off for Charlie , but then he broke down the baby's name and realized it's Rene (Bellas mom) and Esmee (Edward's mom) name put together. Her middle name is also Carlie which is just Carlisle and Charlie put together.
You can't pull a fast one on Mustache Dad.
Bella’s wedding was the last moment of Charlie and his daughter as a human 🥺
It's honestly a good thing that he didn't see her while she was pregnant.
If you can’t accept that Charlie is the best character in this entire series than you are living in denial.
and Carlisle
He's the ONLY character I give a damn about in this series. Team Mustache Dad for life!
In the book, he's really not that great. Bella basically acts like his mom, and he doesn't even really want her there
@@Lady-Seashell-Bikini this is entirely false lol he adores having her there he’s just a quiet and shy person, when she leaves in the first book he was devastated
@@uhuhuh1966 Doesn't change the fact that she was cooking all the meals and cleaning his home. And of course he'd be devastated, but let's not pretend he was the perfect parent. There's a reason why Bella was so closed off.
I never noticed before but charlie probably figured out that renesmee was actually their biological child but he didn't question it because he didn't want to lose Bella. Also he probably knew something supernatural was going on with her when he hugged her cause he noticed she was hard and cold.
Yeah in the books he knows that something is up but doesn't want to know the exact details. He also realises that Renesmee is Bella's biological daughter because Renesmee's eyes are identical to both Bella's and his own (Bella inherited her brown eyes from her father)
^ in the movie too, that's why he says "She has your eyes, Bella... Need to know, I guess."
I WISH THAT CHARLIE SAW HER REAL EYES AND THAT HE TOLD HER THAT HE GETS PANIC AND TELLS HER THAT SHE'S SO COLD...THAT HE WOULD TELL HER TO FOLLOW HIM TO THE DOCTOR! I DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW THE DIRECTOR WAS THINKING...IT COULD HAVE BEEN SO MUCH BETTER DRAMA...
@@mineonlyedwardcullen because it follows the book. Not the director.
"She's got your eyes Bella"
All Charlie has to do is look up ice cold people 😂
Danillle D isnt that exactly what bella did in the first movie lmaoo
Worked for Bella.
what?
Or cold one's, and he'll need no explaining from Bella 😂
@@Tasha22Bella imagine him finding out by looking that up and be like gawd damn it and throws his coffee and sits thier thinking about life
i feel so bad for charlie :(
it wasnt charlie that threw it it was jacob and it was rosalie
I feel so sorry for Charlie too,so cruel of her to not tell him everything'((U)
@@mineonlyedwardcullen True, but it was for his own personal safety that she had to keep the truth from him. I do like how Bella asks him to just trust that she is safe and happy. Even if she never became a vampire, there still would have come a time where Charlie would need to accept the fact that his daughter was not a kid anymore and that he needed to let her grow up and live her own life.
mineonlyedwardcullen the Volturi would kill him if he found out
Danielle Martinez how would they know
Their baby looks like a Sims toddler..
Niall Prideaux screaming
Lmfao😂
Niall Prideaux bruh I'm freaking dying the baby does look dead on a SIM baby😂😂😂😂
Lol yes!!!
Niall Prideaux it’s a puppet
It just occurred to me that Kristen was wearing contracts through the entire series, because her natural eye colour is green. She had to wear chocolate brown for Human Bella, bright red for Newborn Bella, orange(ish) for Several Months Old Newborn Bella, gold for Vampire Bella and mud brown for Charlie (when she was a newborn trying to hide her red eyes).
I can imagine they could also change a lot of it via post production though.
Do you mean contacts
Are you from the UK bc you spelled color, colour??
exactly what I was thinking! and though that sence with the eyecolor was cute, vampire Bella was still wearing fake contact lenses, to mimic her old eye color when Charlie was like "she has your eyes, Bella" and I think that's funny 😂 They have to be really good contacts to match her old eyes but I guess the Cullens didn't have an issue with money so.
she did wear contacts throughout and she wore wigs sometimes as well because her hair was too short from other projects
That baby looks so animated
Yah
That's the point they wanted the actress playing renessme to be seen all through her growing forms eventually leading to the actual Mackenzie
the baby is animated,smh 😬😈
In the book the baby is described like a perfect baby and that stuff, so I think that they needed to animate the baby, I guess
camii15ilg IDK why they need a CGI baby tbh. There are plenty if beautiful babies out there
Charlie is the most underrated character in this entire series.
“Renes...mee...?”
Even the dad knows it’s an awful name lol
It's awful.
@@misspopcoin2204 your awful
@@elfranzathesquirrel9461 still not as awful as that name 🤷♀️
@@misspopcoin2204 explain how it's awful. It has meaning
dfeenix 🤣🤣
I always felt so so bad for Charlie. He’s been trying to be the best dad he can even though Bella hasn’t really let him in.
why the baby is the scary one in a movie about werewolves and vampires
Seyn Ramc What
Seyn Ramc omg lol
That's a real baby. The CGI one that looked like Chuckie was not used after all.
The baby really is creepy isn't it?
Charlie had it the roughest. Literally Bella didn't give a shit if she hurt him or lied to him. Hell she was gonna let him believe she was dead if not for Jacob.
You clearly didn’t read the books lmfao
Big fan of the word 'literally', eh? Like to squeeze it in every time you say something? All righty then, but be aware that intelligent people are laughing at you when you add the word literally to everything you say.
“You don’t turn into an animal too do you?” I love Charlie lol
Right
The look on his face after hugging her (and probably thinks he's hugging a corpse) and his voice cracks breaks my heart every time
man. she really just threw all of her happiness into this weird vampire and his family. and then disgarded her own, like they didn't matter. she talks to her dad like she doesn't respect him. now that i'm older, i realize how toxic this whole relationship is. not something to aspire to have, at all.
For real. I enjoy these movies because of Rob and Kristen's chemistry, but this entire relationship was messed up. A channel called Cinema Therapy seriously reviewed these movies and broke down exactly what was wrong with Bella's relationship with Edward and Jacob.
Bella is really selfish
Yes! When I was a kid I thought this was so romantic but now as an adult I see how toxic this really is
I totally agree 150%. I honestly only watch clips from this movie for Bella's outfits and her hair lol.
I'm not a fan of Kristen Stewart but I would kill for her body.
She suppose to live her life for her parents? Her mom's out living her best life. Her father is a cop n fisher man . It's consumes all his days. I'm happy for her. 😂😂😂 .. least she didn't just leave, faked her death.
She should have kept her life and loved a man. But besides that they make a beautiful couple. 🌻
I desperately want to think that after all this Charlie went on to become a hunter and cop who specialized in investigating the supernatural.
Lizzy Chrome basically he becomes a Winchester
Ooh that's a great take for Charlie! It certainly would spice up his boring Forks life!
"I've just watched a kid i've known for his entire life turn into a very large DOG."
That line cracks me up every time.
The dads acting is better than hers
fucking indeed
The babies acting is better then hrs and Edwards combined
The babies acting is better then hrs and Edwards combined
Skylor Hollifield true
i doubt its very hard for a dad to act like a dad XD
can there just be a movie about Charlie? he's the best character lol
several 하고 numerous 차이 알려주세요
The Pumpkin Queen
right?!?! THANK YOU
The Pumpkin Queen How ‘bout a book?
yes,Charlie is the best character
Still feel bad for Charlie. It's like all this time he had no idea of what's really going on. He didn't know her daughter married a vampire. He suspected Renesmee is Bella's biological daughter but there's nowhere to ask. He definitely noticed Bella's change but still couldn't get an answer.
think he finds out Bella is a vampire when he hugs her x
I was actually starting to think that as well
No it's because how tight she hugged him
It was because she was so cold
Jess dont forget shes also hard now, in the book when she talked about snuggling with Edward she always referred to what she would imagine it would be like to be snuggling with "Michelangelo's David" so I imagine when he hugged her she felt hard like stone as well as cold
I wonder if he knew that Edward and his family were vampires
*Charlie is 75* "Bella how do you still look like a teen" "teach me your ways"
Never understood how Bella managed to keep Charlie at bay. I miss one phone call from my Mother and she goes insane. Poor writing for Charlie was meant to care for Bella a ton, he wouldn't have just let her go missing for weeks on end without tracking her down. All I know is if I tried that my mum would have the FBI/CIA/Police Force on my ass.
HouseVictoria well she was considered sick and contagious so he couldn't visit and she was to weak to speak...that's why.
Yeah I thought that was a huge plot hole too. I mean, in Eclipse when the hikers go missing, Charlie tells Bella that if she ever went missing he would never ever stop looking for her, and in New Moon he goes insane with worry when she takes off to Italy just for two days. I know the Cullens tell him that she's sick/contagious - any loving dad would just ask what hospital she was in and declare he would go see her even if he had to wear a hazmat suit.
Yesa
Same here! If I was allegedly “sick” and bedridden somewhere with some dangerously contagious disease, *no one* could tell my parents to stay away. Even if they had to swim to me. So…new plan 😂
The thing that confused me about the ending to this series is, did Bella ever see her mom again?
kayjay1196
Probably
kayjay1196 no wait yes she was alive during the battle
In the books Bella doesn't see her mother again, which is an unbelievable plot hole in my opinion. I mean, Bella is her mother's only child, plus in the first book she describes her mother as her best friend. Then it's all like "Hey mom, I've got mah man and mah baybee now, so byeeeee!" Renee might be ditzy but she loves Bella more than anything, she would never accept not seeing Bella again
+ChooseYour Poison In the books, she explains that she intentionally chose not to see her mom again, despite the pain it would cause her emotionally, because she considered herself a "Danger Magnet" and that her mom would be endangered. The idea was to never see her father again as well, but they changed that plan once Jacob interfered and revealed the supernatural to him.
Also, you got the definition of "plot hole" wrong
'I just watched a kid I’ve known his entire life turn into a very large dog." LMAO!
most awkward father daughter relationship scene ever
I still cry every time Charlie expresses his feelings like “I miss you Bells”, like I kinda feel like I’m in his place of parenthood, even tho I’m not even a teen yet lol 😂. I absolutely love Twilight!
The dad is honestly the best character ever 😭😭😭
charlie didn't deserve any of the emotional abuse she put him thru T.T
He had no idea that his daughter was already physically dead as a human being. He was talking to an immortal being and hugging a corpse 😩
Hi_Shadow Whoa, that's actually true.
Charlie at least deserved an explanation. Bella kept leaving without explaining, she didn’t even trust her own father enough to tell him the truth.
Because laws of volturri, and Charlie decided that he doesn't need to know everything (in the books). Why not just change Charlie? Because of their treaty with the shapeshifters, bella is an exception but i think the Cullens don't want to again break the treaty for something they could avoid, like not telling charlie.
Carmela Camba yes! Exactly! Why not just turn Charlie? Then he wouldn’t have to grow old and end up leaving Bella. Also, I feel like an explanation would be needed when Charlie sees Bella and she looks 18 when she’s supposed to be 80.
It would be interesting to see Charlie Swan to be one of their kind especially that in Midnight Sun book, Edward couldn't clearly read Charlie's mind so what if Charlie Swan might've had special gift of a similar mental shield like Bella's? It's like James is a tracker, but Demetri is a God-like tracker. Imagine if Kate or Jane tries to use their gifts on Charlie, he would get hurt, but ONLY very little.
The only thing that bothered me was renesmee cuz they didnt use a real baby. I think that wouldve been a lot better
Jazzy Jonas they did but they put Mekenzie's (the actress that played renesme)face on the baby so she look the same later. They used sevral baby as she was growing up
How can u say, my daughter looks like my daughter, but isn't my daughter. Ah soo funny
WHY WASN'T CHARLIE HAPPY WHEN HE SAW BELLA?
HE WASN'T HAPPY EITHER WHEN HE SAW RENESMEE...THEY DIDN'T EVEN ASK HIM IF HE WANTED TO HOLD HER!WHY?!:'(THEY DIDN'T ASK HIM ABOUT WHY HE WAS SAD!:'( WHY?!
please answer on my questions about what you think
Charlie is described in the books stoic and uncomfortable of showing emotion, so even if he was ecstatic about seeing his daughter he wouldn't because that's part of his characterization.
As for him not holding her? Even if he asked it would have been too dangerous. Reneesme (sp?) is part vampire (so is quite strong and needs to drink at least some blood in order to survive) and a baby, and a majority of the time when a baby is faced with something new if tends to stick it in their mouths. So a vampire baby is less likely to have control over their impulse in not drinking from a living person.
why is everyone hating on twilight?
If you listen closely he says right after Edward says daughter he says right the adoption they had told him that they were adopting Edward neic
Honestly for me Charlie was the only Character that actually stayed good and true to who he is. Of course he's mad/sad/angry and has questions Bella cant even buy Alcohol yet. He definitely deserved better or at the very least learned the truth so he can help the humans who are being murdered by Vampires. Especially when the army was created and all those missing teenagers.
Charlie: "She's got your eyes Bella" gets to me every time 😢💕
Bella has some awesome self control unknown to newborns. She got smushed by Charlie's hug and was able to keep from attacking him.
Why couldn't they get an actual baby?
They had real babies in the filming process. They kept switching babies out for a few scenes.
Iman Zulfiqar because the child in the book was so special they couldn't find a real kid to play the part til the. Character was older
it's I think because they found the older kid and wanted the baby to look like the child so they put the kid's face on the baby or something.
LoveAlwaysNelle i would have dealt with different babies. but seeing that fake one in the theater literally had me and everyone else in there in tears of laughter
The baby has to look special and "glowing"
Edward: Charlie can't come near Bella! She'll be in pain like scorching daggers down her throat! She'll kill him in an instant!
Also Edward: let's give them some privacy...
🤣🤣🤣
I wish we had Bella’s mom’s reaction on this “adoption”. Plus her reaction to a hug from her now cold/hard daughter. Would have made for a more interesting movie.
I love twilight but I hate that people don't sympathize or ever mention Charlie. All they do is mention edward or jacob or others but never her own dad. She's the only child if she's gone then Charlie would be one depressed man. He's the character I felt bad for.
Not only did Edward Cullen ruin Bella’s life, he’s probably ruined Charlie’s.
How did he ruin Bella’s life
He didn't ruin bella's life he saved her life because he didn't want her to die and plus he really loves bella and he can't live without her either
“She’s got your eyes Bella “ lmao
One of the things I never got was the whole idea of renesmee. They never told Charlie "hey by the way this kid grows very quickly and before you know it she will be 8. It won't take 8 Years, but instead maybe 8 weeks or 8 months." He never questioned why she's so big all of a sudden the next time he sees her. At least a better excuse could have been given about her other than she's my niece/daughter.
Charlie is a much better parent than Renee ever was. He doesn’t get enough credit.
Renee was a negligent child who made Bella be the responsible one. That's part of the reason why Bella comes to live with Charlie. She doesn't want to be in the way. Sad.
Edward! That is NOT how you hold a baby!
lol I thought the same thing!
:)
Except that's a CGI baby. He's probably holding a sack of potatoes or something.
+G Scarlatti 😂😂😂😂
lol
so true
how can Charlie not be suspicious that Bella is really cold 😕😕
OMG WHAT?!DID SHE?!:O :@ :'( (U)
mineonlyedwardcullen yes, at 1:38 and 1:42
flower castiel Omg so scary!😲😱 SHE can't even CONTROLL herself for her dad!😲😱😢😭💔
mineonlyedwardcullen well she tried since she wasn’t breathing, so she wouldn’t have been tempted by him, but I think if she kept looking at his neck she wasn’t fully controlling herself. It’s her dad but he’s human after all, so it’s normal that she was tempted 🤷🏼♀️ I know it’s sad...
He was but stopped himself from asking
I always felt like Charlie was owed a better explanation than that
I just watched all five movies and Billy Burke was like a rock in all of them, always believable even when no one else was. That’s why this scene is so heartbreaking.
Every moment with her and Charlie is my favorite because I think of me and my father's relationship and how strong it is. This scene makes me cry everytime.
Charlie knows the cullens and knows how cold their skin is, and remembering bella's warmth and now hugging her and she being cold skinned, he probably would gather in a few years time what has happened, when she doesnt age, and with the Renesme growing so fast xD
I wonder what Charlie’s theories are about what is happening to Bella
I WISH THAT HE HAD SO MANY QUESTIONS AND FORCED HER TO TELL HIM EVERYTHING! I'M SO ANGRY ABOUT THAT SHE DIDN'T WANT TO SAY THE SECRET!:@ I WONDER HOW CHARLIE WOULD HAVE REACTED IF BELLA TOLD HIM THAT SHE'S A VAMPIRE...WHAT DO YOU THINK WOULD HAVE HAPPEN?
mineonlyedwardcullen but then Voltori could kill Charlie.
So, here's the deal with that. Charlie knows "something" is up, but he is not allowed to know the specifics. As long as Charlie just accepts what he's told, and then doesn't go researching like Bella did, he'll be safe. Though let's say we're after the Volturi incident a few years down the road. While they wouldn't actually do it, it would be relatively safe to possibly tell Charlie, at least for a while. The Volturi don't get out very often, so it would likely be decades before they ever found out, if not a couple of centuries.
Is Charlie really going to die if he finds out a bit of Vampire kind, or the Volturi will just forced him to be silent? Sorry Idk abt Twilight that much
is it just me or has bella had a glow up when she turned into a vampire
She had a glow up
I remember in the book she explained her fathers’ scent didn’t smell appetizing which Edward and his family feared. She could smell him, but it was just in the memory of her father, something like that. And when Charlie looks at her weird when she hugs him, it’s because she feels like a cold brick in his arms 🤣🤣 book fun facts lol
Actually, someone please correct me if I am wrong. But in the book, does it not say that newborn vampire Bella finds that her dad's scent is more potent and a more powerful attractant to her, and that it was possibly because he is family to her. It was because of his biological connection to her human self, even though she is now no longer human. That she had to fight that much harder to resist his blood and that every breath it took for her to form speech to talk to him and answer his questions was the worst torture?
What's with all the distortion? It makes me dizzy.
Cool
Most likely because of copyright infringement.
I feel so bad for charlie.. he deserve a normal life.. he was a good father..
Honestly, I know in the book Renesmee is described as a very aware and intelligent infant because of what she is. But I would happily have allowed them to miss out that detail and just had her be a normal baby in the film so she didn't look so creepy with all the CGI. I was very thankful they made her a bit older later on in the film than she was in the book and used a proper actress as opposed to the creepy child all the way through.
Honestly, in the entire part when charlie sat next to her, she was looking at him like he's a burger... and her eyes kept going to his neck 🤣
Poor Charlie. He’s one of the most likable characters in Twilight.
Bella was willing to throw away her entire life like planning on pretending to die and lay in a coffin while her parents cry over her, that’s terrible, forever leaving her parents her family
So your father-in- law shows up, and asks"where's Bella?". and everyone just goes along with it? what the hell?
WHAT DO YOU MEAN?
WHAT?
That not her father in law that her dad
Charlie is just an epic character he accepts everything without question 😊
if i can see my dad after long time.. i will hug him so tight.. not just watch n seat at couch like nothing happen.. phewww
Hawa Ahmad uhm.. She lived with her dad since twilight. You obviously didn't watch the whole movie, and doesn't even understand the fact of being a hard rock like vampire with incredible strength. That kind of hug you're talking about would kill her dad.
ooo i seee..forget that one.. i did watchg whole movie marathon for the whole series ..in one night.. tq for make it sense..agent romanoff
and one thing.. im not a vampire.. thank god for created me who i am😂😂😂
Shes a newborn and her dad's blood would tempt her. zz
Hawa Ahmad She can't fully control her taste
This is poss the saddest moment in the movie. Charlie finds out that the daughter that he reconnected with is forever gone but he finds out that he's a grandfather of a furiously fast growing little girl.
I hate the way bella treats her dad.
The title says Charlie finds out about her...he doesn't find out shit. I understand she can't really tell him because the Volturi would be after him, but geez she really treated her parents badly especially her dad who tried so hard for her .. I feel so sorry for Charlie. Bella put her feelings for Edward above her own family, put them in danger, fucks off without telling her dad anything and then keeps even more of a distance from him after becoming a vampire. And he gets no real explanation at the end of it all.
IBeMelissa exactly why Bella Swan is the absolute worse
In the first movie edward wanted to leave with bella but bella told her to take her home cause of her dad and she didn't want him in danger .
Two. She told edward she didn't want to hurt him and he told her that she has to ...so she said hurtful things and left so the other vampire would follow them and not go to her house with her dad there
She was heart broken about the things she told her dad
Not only that she thought her mom was in danger and risked her own life to go see if she was okay after the other vampire called her
vampires don't have balls..... they're being clutched by the volturi 😂😂
What?
What???????
What????????
What on earth are you on about? Or more to the point, what on earth are you on?
Charlie deserves better. He loved Bella so much, the least she could do was tell him what she was. Every time he called her Bells’, it made me almost cry! He was the only character I acknowledge
pau 666 The best acting by far. His scenes always made me laugh.
Her dad is so cool, he never asked any questions about Bella, but he knows about his daughter
how cgi is that baby
Menna Carey very cgi
Menna Carey as cg as the rock scorpion
+MagKhaila Bentil
Just the face and some movements
Who's watching this 2018
charlie cracked me the hell up. one of my favorite characters aside from jasper and alice. i still love bella and edward though
Bro if she would've just tell him, then maybe he wouldn't be more concerned and upset. Yet she's making it more worse for him. I've always felt Charlie needed to know what happened. But you know Bella will always protect her dad no matter what happens lol.
Who's watching this in 2017?
Carrot the ferret I am ,love it
I am
Carrot the ferret I'm watching this now
Me
me! and Im shocked that I once loved this movie
Charlie is the best father in the world.
Poor man, all that he has had to put up with that daughter.
Charlie probably thought Bella was in a cult
Renesmee was actually really cute in this scene. How smiley she is with her grandpa. Almost makes you forget how monstrous this child really is lmao.
she doesn't tell HIM TO STAY THERE LONGER,why?:'(Tell me😢😭💔
Her instinct to drink his blood would be too strong
in the book he stayed all day and it was him who suggested need to know not bella
Very touching father and daughter moment. Heartwarming no doubt about it in a strange way.
I️ can’t take this seriously with the baby looking that fake 😂😂
still one of my favorite movie
"She's got your eyes Bella"
Yeah, photo-shopped onto her.
make more twilighlit
I love it
Trinity-Faith Eastman is is spelled twilight
Bella really does have a selfish attitude. Out of all the people she been selfish with, her dad was the one who got it the most. She expected him to just accept she was with Edward, and then to accept she married him, left to say she was “sick” but got pregnant and died and became a vampire and expected him to accept who she became by not exactly telling him who she became. I felt bad for Charlie actually through the series
3:21 can he not feel the ice old skin?!
he felt that at 3.06
+Razeena Beegum so why did he not assume she was a vampire after Jacob showed he was a fucking fuk warewolf
+Razeena Beegum he did feel it because he wanted to back away but he didnt
Nat Fernandes exactly
he probably knew, but he was probably, hesitated to ask
She's got your eyes Bella. He can't ask questions but he's clearly not stupid.
I can see Renesmee has red eyes
athena mok she has brown
I like the first music in this scene they don’t forget their roots
She is so adorable
When he feels how Cold she was that got me