Game Theory: The Mystery of Minecraft's Haunted Discs (Minecraft)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 14. 08. 2019
  • Get Your New Back To School Theory Wear Here!! ► creatorink.co/tw-yt
    Today Theorists, I aim to solve another one of the many mysteries of Minecraft. We've explored a lot already, but with a game this big, there is always more to find. Take the music discs, which are the objects you find randomly throughout the game when you do certain things. Except, there are two discs in particular that peaked my interest - Disc 11 and Disc 13. The two "corrupted" discs that, when you play them, sound like something from a horror game rather than Minecraft. What is going on with Discs 11 and 13? Let's find out!
    SUBSCRIBE for More Theories! ► bit.ly/1qV8fd6
    Get the game here ►► www.minecraft.net/
    Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
    Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ► share.epidemicsound.com/MatPat
    SUBSCRIBE for Every Theory! ►► bit.ly/1qV8fd6
    Hang out with us on GTLive! ► bit.ly/1LkSBnz
    #Minecraft #Enderman #Disc11 #Disc13 #Corrupted #Haunted #MinecraftTheory #Theory #GameTheory
    More THEORIES:
    The TRUTH About MINECRAFT’s World! ►► goo.gl/XySv1N
    The END of Princess Peach! ► bit.ly/2CJuYbm
    Minecraft's Ending, DECODED! ►► bit.ly/2d5o2Ky
    Mario Kart 8, Mario's SCARIEST Game? ► bit.ly/2wyeell
    What's Diamond Armor Worth IRL? ►► bit.ly/1Q5xhmM
    Credits:
    Writers: Matthew Patrick
    Editors: BanditRants, Tyler Mascola, Dan "Cybert" Seibert, and Alex "Sedge" Sedgwick
    Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
    Sound Editor: Yosi Berman
    Sources:
    minecraft.gamepedia.com/Music...
    www.minecraft-france.fr/le-se...
    minecraft.gamepedia.com/Ambience
    minecraft.gamepedia.com/Timel...
    www.minecraft.net/es-es/artic...
  • Hry

Komentáře • 57K

  • @gaydes1012
    @gaydes1012 Před 4 lety +63535

    and who would've known that the sweet tunes I was cranking in my epic base held so much hidden lore

    • @dinghyval
      @dinghyval Před 4 lety +661

      Matpat: Uncovering creepy, disturbing, dark lore that destroys my childhood, burning it into a fine ash and burying it deep underground to rot and wither and eviserate and die in a fiery inferno, never to be seen again as I feel my soul being ripped from the seams and following my childhood to the depths of the earth, screaming, shrieking, as it get's dragged down to the dark, destructive unknown.
      ...but yeah.

    • @mrrobertthomas3903
      @mrrobertthomas3903 Před 4 lety +41

      timeroller 😂

    • @undercovertunnel8262
      @undercovertunnel8262 Před 4 lety +186

      timeroller if you were cranking disc 13, you have to have problems lol

    • @undercovertunnel8262
      @undercovertunnel8262 Před 4 lety +12

      scorched_mango 62 lmao yeah

    • @itsdrizzy-_-9391
      @itsdrizzy-_-9391 Před 4 lety +11

      Aww man

  • @dialupdude
    @dialupdude Před 4 lety +4334

    Disk 11 plays
    Players: Omg this is so creepy
    Parrots: *Dancing Happily*

  • @sarahlarose2997
    @sarahlarose2997 Před 4 lety +3471

    pewdiepie: *minecraft*
    jack: *minecraft*
    matpat: *minecraft*
    internet: *minecraft*
    markiplier: *heavy sweating*

  • @jr7762
    @jr7762 Před rokem +1311

    Matpat: “After all discs can’t be crafted.”
    Disc 5: Hold my beer

    • @kitkatpita6703
      @kitkatpita6703 Před rokem +22

      69 likes heck yea

    • @the_seer_0421
      @the_seer_0421 Před rokem +22

      @@rimuru768 I'm sure they knew that

    • @Dr.STorch
      @Dr.STorch Před rokem +10

      Mate yer a wee bit late on that one

    • @whoasked6696
      @whoasked6696 Před rokem +23

      Well.. Disc 5 is kinda weird bc you’re not crafting it by putting other items like stick + iron + wood. You’re just combining the disc itself

    • @trebleclef9844
      @trebleclef9844 Před rokem +16

      @@whoasked6696 true, its just fragments of the disc which you repair

  • @hyperspacestorm
    @hyperspacestorm Před rokem +411

    13: ok a little weird, aside from cave sounds and someone running from a creeper.
    11: slightly broken disk that gives off creepy vibes
    5: completely shattered and sounds VERY frightening

    • @Marilynn_1275
      @Marilynn_1275 Před 4 měsíci +6

      It does, and as to where we find the disc fragments?
      The Ancient City.

    • @hyperspacestorm
      @hyperspacestorm Před 4 měsíci +3

      @@Marilynn_1275 I was too caught up on the disc itself that I never made the connection.
      Slightly embarrassing

  • @SiriusRise
    @SiriusRise Před 3 lety +4707

    Disc 11... Is litteraly the embodiment of fear
    Parrots: so anyway, I started dancing

  • @mcredcreep
    @mcredcreep Před 3 lety +1070

    Disc 11 or 13: *plays*
    Players: *scared shitless*
    Parrots: they're groovin

  • @mehsayori
    @mehsayori Před rokem +422

    Fun fact: While 13 is the same in the game as it is in the OST, 11 is completely different. Instead of being the horror that it is in the game, it's actually a nice and relaxing track in the OST.

    • @sharkshrek4154
      @sharkshrek4154 Před rokem +8

      it's like Greenland and Iceland

    • @Chaosh21
      @Chaosh21 Před rokem +30

      Potential theory, in the game, disc 11 is broken, snapped and ruined, in the out we hear what the disc sounds Iike when not broken

    • @alchemysaga3745
      @alchemysaga3745 Před 6 měsíci +10

      ​@@Chaosh21In that scenario, the version of 11 _could_ hypothetically be the person overwriting the old version of disk 11, in order to record what is going on.
      Now that we know the caver would have been an Ancient Builder, that's an option.

  • @Hero-pw7wp
    @Hero-pw7wp Před rokem +185

    Everyone: Disc 11 and 13 are terrifying
    Disc 5: Hold my random Item sounds

    • @fatuadedipe4589
      @fatuadedipe4589 Před rokem +10

      And the fact that the parrots still dance to them is out of my knowledge.

  • @kiwithechillbirb7594
    @kiwithechillbirb7594 Před 3 lety +1974

    People: “Why do parrots dance to dance to disc 11 and 13 they are so creepy?”
    Parrots: “ *MUSIC IS MUSIC* “

  • @biq5743
    @biq5743 Před 4 lety +9785

    this man has the special ability to remember his shower thoughts

    • @caleblewis8169
      @caleblewis8169 Před 4 lety +591

      He probably keeps a water proof laptop in his shower to record them obviously.

    • @CrabOnABeach
      @CrabOnABeach Před 4 lety +65

      I have that ability too tho

    • @lockthecageheshere1982
      @lockthecageheshere1982 Před 4 lety +34

      Truly 3p1c it truly is amazing

    • @TheEnderLeader1
      @TheEnderLeader1 Před 4 lety +70

      And also to just casually hit your nostalgia buttons and then just keep on talking like nothing happened.

    • @jmorris207
      @jmorris207 Před 4 lety +11

      How Herobrine was born

  • @timothyeichstaedt8007
    @timothyeichstaedt8007 Před 2 lety +92

    After hearing this, disc 11 and 13 are the events that occur when the player is escaping and when they hit the water. Once they hit the water, a form of trauma from the fall causes a delayed form of amnesia that occurs while they are traveling. This results in the player “spawning” in a new area with no previous knowledge

    • @joseph_soseph9611
      @joseph_soseph9611 Před 8 měsíci +9

      That actually makes a lot of sense. My first thought was that the creator of the discs is a different survivor descended from the old civilisation who eventually died or disappeared, but your hypothesis also explains why the player, who is depicted as an adult, wakes up in a hostile world without any items in their possession and no prior memories. This wouldn't make sense if it were not for the events on the discs, making them lose their memories and possessions.

  • @GoblinGaiety
    @GoblinGaiety Před rokem +64

    I'm gonna need an in-depth analysis of where the new music disc "5" that is coming in 1.19 ties into this STAT. PLEASE. Although if you want to wait until 1.19 comes out so we have a better understanding of ancient cities (and namely what the center structure is), I understand. But yay the lore continues!

    • @gigachad24190
      @gigachad24190 Před rokem +5

      As for my theory, I think that disc 5 comes before disc 11. When we hear disc 5, we notice that the character is walking inside caves towards the ancient cities and trying to open a portal, but he encounters the warden and tries to escape from him through the portal .... and here begins the story of disc 11 inside the portal

    • @elliswebster7041
      @elliswebster7041 Před rokem +1

      @@gigachad24190 wow 😲 5 comes before 11? Who would’ve thought

    • @bruuuuuhhhhhhh
      @bruuuuuhhhhhhh Před rokem +1

      @@gigachad24190 Yk what’s cool, if you use the discs 5, 11 and 13 exactly those seconds apart, so 5 at 5 secs, 11 at 11 and 13 at 13 they tell a story, I’ll link a video for it, but you can try it yourself
      Video: czcams.com/video/aOb2tpiBhA4/video.html

  • @guffythefluffy3013
    @guffythefluffy3013 Před 4 lety +3114

    Peoples worsts fears in Minecraft.
    1. Disc 13
    2. Disc 11
    3. Creepers with arms.

  • @orbit7486
    @orbit7486 Před 4 lety +5772

    You left out two details that I picked up through the discs. When he finishes coughing, you can hear a “shh” in the background. It’s not a creeper sound, meaning that it was possibly a SECOND person telling him to be quiet. It was too late, however, and the monsters found them. Then you can only hear one person’s footsteps, meaning that one of them could have gotten killed. When the arrow supposedly “hits it’s target” it could be killing one of the two people. I know I’m late but I wanted to put this idea out there.

  • @Svnshine3_11
    @Svnshine3_11 Před rokem +19

    I love how MatPat’s editors add edits that make me go back to updates after the videos come out and I’m like
    “Wait a minute… they added moss, and he said ‘Creepers are moss bombs’”
    And they added moss in 1.18
    Now that may not sound like an edit but still, they added moss *MOSSBOMBS.*

  • @TheGamingDoggo
    @TheGamingDoggo Před rokem +10

    “They can’t be crafted or anything”
    The warden disk: “allow me to introduce myself”

  • @Some-oz6gh
    @Some-oz6gh Před 4 lety +8827

    "Disc 11 and 13 is the most disturbing discs in game"
    Parrots: *MUSIC IS MUSIC*

    • @LowYummy
      @LowYummy Před 4 lety +108

      Benjamin Wilcox no it would be MCCU, MineCraft Cinematic Universe.

    • @fleckster6903
      @fleckster6903 Před 4 lety +11

      @Benjamin Wilcox totally

    • @ezekiyam3827
      @ezekiyam3827 Před 4 lety +14

      Lol good one

    • @bellalalala3327
      @bellalalala3327 Před 4 lety +10

      @@LowYummy ooh smartie

    • @zephyrash
      @zephyrash Před 4 lety +24

      @@LowYummy We already have a MCCU, It's not too well known though. It's the Marvel Cinematic Cat Universe. Some people have a hard time drawing humans, they created the MCCU so they could still enjoy creating Marvel content.

  • @RomiiPringle
    @RomiiPringle Před 4 lety +1060

    MatPat: "The comments had loads of theorys."
    The comments:
    *Did Mat mine grass with an axe?*

  • @jalapenobee
    @jalapenobee Před rokem +6

    The paper rustling could’ve also been someone reading as if he was trying to do a spell with the fire, or he was looking for something in the cave

  • @nimblejarl7635
    @nimblejarl7635 Před 2 lety +6

    I absolutely did listen to it as a kid but instead of being scared, I was intrigued and thus here I am as a theorist. Finally glad someone solved this, thanks.

  • @elliebrown5990
    @elliebrown5990 Před 4 lety +7966

    You guys remember when they used to put “herobrine has been removed” in like every game update

    • @striver2180
      @striver2180 Před 4 lety +161

      Yes

    • @bananaraptor7747
      @bananaraptor7747 Před 4 lety +85

      yee doggie

    • @x-platainum-tattletail-x5536
      @x-platainum-tattletail-x5536 Před 4 lety +50

      Yep

    • @hmmnope9231
      @hmmnope9231 Před 4 lety +334

      Do you have any herobrine storiesnthat you or a friend experienced? I was alone in a world I had for a couple of weeks, had a small house with a basement carved out and a few chests and torches for light, far from collecting diamonds. But as I hover over my chest facing the outside of my house I see a name tag pop up like it would in multiplayer, like a little grey tag with no name as I had to get closer for the name to appear. And then I saw it shrink down like the player had crouched and the nametag disappeared. And suddenly in my 0 slot of the hotbar, a enchanted diamond sword appeared. I looked at its enchants and it was a "God sword" so I had to go see if whoever was out there was still there, and he wasnt. But I saw my nearby forrest on fire and strangely the fire only burned the leaves, and then went out on its own. This was on a single player server and has never been open to lan, so Im surprised I even have a story to tell.

    • @russianinvader2560
      @russianinvader2560 Před 4 lety +113

      Lmao I never really knew what herobrine was but if they removed it it kept coming back or something.

  • @nightshine_
    @nightshine_ Před 4 lety +2125

    “They’re not made by Endermen. They’re made by men. Menmen. Humens.”
    Yes, Matthew.

  • @coryjamieson3171
    @coryjamieson3171 Před rokem +6

    Those music discs were so creepy and mysterious that even MatPat had to step in to explain these discs. I also loved how Monika from Doki Doki was featured in the intro, although she likely has nothing to do with Minecraft right?

  • @meevalshine157
    @meevalshine157 Před rokem +3

    Can’t wait till you make a video about music disc 5!

  • @deanpai7787
    @deanpai7787 Před 4 lety +640

    My sister: Why don’t you play Minecraft anymore?
    Me after hearing disk 11: That game can change a man...

    • @Banksran
      @Banksran Před 4 lety +10

      EAT THIS!

    • @lovexdeath1636
      @lovexdeath1636 Před 4 lety +7

      The sister: but brother I want you to teach me how I’m a noob at it
      DeanPai 778: sis let show your why I did play it
      Her after hearing 13: Okay my childhood is ruined

    • @codenameasura
      @codenameasura Před 4 lety +2

      Yeah

    • @midnightsparrow1071
      @midnightsparrow1071 Před 4 lety

      Lol not me do

    • @tinamarvin9851
      @tinamarvin9851 Před 4 lety +1

      WHAT DID YOU DO TO DEKU!!!!

  • @Johnsmith-pw3rn
    @Johnsmith-pw3rn Před 4 lety +1438

    “What happened to the civilization?”
    “Gone, reduced to Endermen.”

    • @shork3954
      @shork3954 Před 4 lety +16

      Why the thanos reference 🤣 lmao

    • @BonniebossGaming
      @BonniebossGaming Před 4 lety +14

      There are ender dragon heads in the end city so they killed the dragon

    • @bigboyrob9946
      @bigboyrob9946 Před 4 lety +8

      Perfection right there pal

    • @MagmaBombe
      @MagmaBombe Před 4 lety +3

      Bonnie boss Gaming who says they arent fake?

    • @honeylope9863
      @honeylope9863 Před 4 lety +1

      @@BonniebossGaming r/wooooosh?

  • @mediccheese
    @mediccheese Před rokem +2

    The fact that he just solved an unsolved mystery makes me wonder if he could solve the Old Root ARG

  • @michew5451
    @michew5451 Před rokem +3

    With the new-ish deep dark, the two discs may have come from that biome, giving off clues such as the warden screaming in 11 and the adventurer making too much noise, leading to his death.

  • @tovuu
    @tovuu Před 4 lety +1793

    *so are we not gonna talk about the thumbnail and the creeper having arms?*

    • @Liz-tk7np
      @Liz-tk7np Před 4 lety +15

      Omg ur right

    • @KasaiBuru
      @KasaiBuru Před 4 lety +10

      Nubs :()

    • @bluegloop8023
      @bluegloop8023 Před 4 lety +47

      Creepers with arms...
      Now they can grab you then explode

    • @bluegloop8023
      @bluegloop8023 Před 4 lety +3

      @Eldrich Mario David wut?
      Are you think something you shouldn't?
      Tsk tsk tsk
      Dirty mind

    • @symphora4454
      @symphora4454 Před 4 lety +3

      Creeper

  • @starridreams4653
    @starridreams4653 Před 4 lety +22564

    Herobrine? *Puffs smoke* I haven’t heard that name in years.

    • @pprinter
      @pprinter Před 4 lety +348

      Yeah same, especially with this stupid hold to spam your weapon feature.

    • @braxtongeorge8038
      @braxtongeorge8038 Před 4 lety +526

      I remember those videos where you would be able to spawn Herobrine. I was always sad when it didn't work.

    • @sourcherry5619
      @sourcherry5619 Před 4 lety +432

      He’s the reason why I was scared to play in survival

    • @mafkarr1892
      @mafkarr1892 Před 4 lety +154

      Mr. Dragon Master you shouldn’t smoke in front of kids

    • @supersentaikyoryuger5744
      @supersentaikyoryuger5744 Před 4 lety +42

      Herobrine isn’t real it’s put in as a joke

  • @draugr905
    @draugr905 Před 4 měsíci +1

    Idk who else feels this way but even obviously hearing a creeper is scary because of the impending doom, the sort lighting of the fuse sound it makes at the beginning I find to be really really satisfying. 9:50

  • @reanaa
    @reanaa Před 2 lety +2

    Well done, sound reasoning, and the pace is perfect.

  • @neonlights3739
    @neonlights3739 Před 4 lety +763

    *Disk 13 plays*
    Me: *is terrified*
    My parrots: It’s time to get *funky*

  • @mrpancake8023
    @mrpancake8023 Před 4 lety +2968

    I think all of you are missing the biggest question
    Why the hell can't you craft a saddle

    • @tripaloski_6971
      @tripaloski_6971 Před 4 lety +169

      Yeah i mean it's leather with some string

    • @raahilkhan1004
      @raahilkhan1004 Před 4 lety +171

      @PanicingAnimal shame

    • @Spineless-Lobster
      @Spineless-Lobster Před 4 lety +45

      Chloe Wiggins I think you used too with leather and an iron ingot but the got ride of it.

    • @tacmfd
      @tacmfd Před 4 lety +33

      When my friend found that out he screamed so loud it scared me

    • @Sirdeathvids
      @Sirdeathvids Před 4 lety +25

      Not sure, but they are easy enough to get if you go fishing enough

  • @burna.k.a.turtleonalog4327

    Disc 5 is a new one, but you have to reassemble the disc to make it and it has marching, cuts off in the middle, and has running, heavy breathing, and coughing, and a strange lullaby in the middle

  • @averyblurryduck749
    @averyblurryduck749 Před rokem +2

    excited to see where the heck disc 5 goes into all this, the wild update is rly keeping with the name right now

  • @audreyperson9221
    @audreyperson9221 Před 4 lety +774

    "Who's Herobrine mum.?"
    "Where did you hear that name?"
    "It was in my recommended in youtube. "
    "Take a seat, Alex. Today i'm going to tell you a story."

    • @giovannimassa8881
      @giovannimassa8881 Před 4 lety +64

      Herobrine, haven't herd that name in a long, long time.

    • @jessicakitchens2113
      @jessicakitchens2113 Před 4 lety +9

      Lol

    • @whydoineedthisB
      @whydoineedthisB Před 4 lety +33

      *You close your eyes in order to imagine what is being said*
      *Then you open your eyes...*
      *intro to skyrim*

    • @joshuasimpson4021
      @joshuasimpson4021 Před 4 lety +20

      ɹɐǝʍs I ǝƃɐssǝɯ ʇǝɹɔǝs ɐ ʇoN _Hey you. You're finally awake._

    • @mirai9242
      @mirai9242 Před 4 lety +3

      @@joshuasimpson4021 lol

  • @animatedmoomoo4080
    @animatedmoomoo4080 Před 4 lety +3448

    If you listen to disk 11 reversed at one point you can hear a distorted DONT DO IT
    like so matpat will see

    • @finnormond9364
      @finnormond9364 Před 4 lety +73

      Animated Moomoo we need to get this to his attention then!

    • @julianoabi-samaramagalhaes3294
      @julianoabi-samaramagalhaes3294 Před 4 lety +15

      0 0
      -

    • @buddybud_bud
      @buddybud_bud Před 4 lety +90

      Also at the end of disk 11 I hear like an enderman sound or something

    • @MrOrzech1
      @MrOrzech1 Před 4 lety +18

      Is there any video showing this?

    • @animatedmoomoo4080
      @animatedmoomoo4080 Před 4 lety +14

      MrOrzech ya by a channel named zaff box I think I didn’t hear it at first but someone mentioned it in the comments

  • @timtomas6109
    @timtomas6109 Před rokem +1

    I know I am late by a few years but in Minecraft: the island the main character is blown up by a creeper and launched into a water pool, than gets out out and hides behind a patch of dirt. I find that that little odd detail seems to parallel disc 13. I cannot remember if he was struck by an arrow or not as my books were destroyed in a flood but I think he may have been as there were multiple mobs down there. In disc 11 you can hear flint and steel lighting a fire and paper rustling, and in the island he mines a few blocks and finds coal as well as it being revealed later that what you are reading is a journal left behind by him. From what I can remember is what I have pieced together and I may have missed a lot of detailed.

  • @venom6909
    @venom6909 Před 2 lety +3

    my theory: there was a species before the ancient builders who made the discs. but when the ancient builders arrived, they saw how scary the disc sound was. so then they decided to smash it and that made the evolution of disc 13 into disc 11.

  • @amansaad360
    @amansaad360 Před 3 lety +858

    Disc 11 : literally the word "horror" itself
    Parrots : this is music to my ears

    • @konamicodechinesehacker2405
      @konamicodechinesehacker2405 Před 3 lety +3

      Idk

    • @thegayone1911
      @thegayone1911 Před 3 lety +15

      Parrots just think it’s music we’ve made and don’t want to make us feel bad. They don’t want to hurt our feelings by saying our music is bad. They are so cute

    • @wendy790509
      @wendy790509 Před 3 lety +2

      Parrots = disc 11 = hell horror

    • @WarmBreadBearBuddy
      @WarmBreadBearBuddy Před 3 lety +3

      Am I stupid for believeing that pigs would actually dance to Pigstep?

    • @WarmBreadBearBuddy
      @WarmBreadBearBuddy Před 3 lety +1

      @@wendy790509 it’s H E double toothpicks, keep it family friendly.

  • @InstaFiz
    @InstaFiz Před 4 lety +524

    “You don’t even have hands, how can you hold this in the first place?”
    It gets more ridiculous. They can climb ladders.

  • @AnnFlandermeyerKirwin
    @AnnFlandermeyerKirwin Před rokem +10

    11:39 I was at 13% battery when I saw this😂😂😂

  • @harmtiemens9079
    @harmtiemens9079 Před rokem +2

    Disc 11 sounds like someone building a nether portal and lighting it, then goes through, checking a book and running over (black)stone and then netherrack. Or exiting the nether for that matter

  • @natechavez2069
    @natechavez2069 Před 4 lety +18570

    kids these days dont know just how terrifying herobrine was

    • @Bartholomew3
      @Bartholomew3 Před 4 lety +455

      Oh I do

    • @Bartholomew3
      @Bartholomew3 Před 4 lety +184

      😬

    • @lake7381
      @lake7381 Před 4 lety +1342

      Building the spawner and deleting the world right after lmao

    • @dravyn4124
      @dravyn4124 Před 4 lety +153

      I fckin know righhttttt

    • @colors1653
      @colors1653 Před 4 lety +673

      Bro they’ve removed him like 15 times and he still in 😳

  • @hellointernet2276
    @hellointernet2276 Před 4 lety +944

    Beginning: HeRoBrInE aNd EnDeRmEn
    Ending: so it’s actually just some guy in a cave

    • @SPADE-de1wk
      @SPADE-de1wk Před 4 lety +11

      Actually its multiples of people

    • @rep-vile
      @rep-vile Před 4 lety +20

      I think that Herobrine very likely was part of the old tribe that built the stronghold and made the end portal and all that.
      What did he do and what happened to him then? I'm not too sure.

    • @FUNKYZUNK
      @FUNKYZUNK Před 4 lety +1

      I’m getting some serious deja vu

    • @SPADE-de1wk
      @SPADE-de1wk Před 4 lety +2

      Maybe a certain mob changed the human herobrine to the now herobrine

    • @iamdying9339
      @iamdying9339 Před 4 lety +1

      It can be herobrian he WAS a human I mean

  • @Gh0stData27
    @Gh0stData27 Před rokem +3

    Hope he soon talks about disc 5, 11, and 13 being played together.

  • @ThatDigitalDemon
    @ThatDigitalDemon Před rokem +1

    "It can't be crafted after all."
    Disk 5: *hold my beer*

  • @chxrlies.angels
    @chxrlies.angels Před 4 lety +726

    Mojang: H-He’s figuring us out... h-how
    Scott: First time?

  • @ShayTheValiant
    @ShayTheValiant Před 4 lety +31032

    Everyone's gangsta until the ambient cave noises play.

  • @keramkeramovich8699
    @keramkeramovich8699 Před 4 měsíci +1

    minor detail: the arrow sounds in 13 are actually the old arrow firing sounds, you can check on the "Removed Features" (Java Edition) page on the wiki

  • @thisismyaccount9048
    @thisismyaccount9048 Před rokem +2

    If he came back to this now with the discovery of how 5, 11, and 13 sync he'd have a field day

  • @spudlord7743
    @spudlord7743 Před 4 lety +2938

    There is nothing more terrifying than the cave ambiance sounds

    • @sir_rodent
      @sir_rodent Před 4 lety +115

      I remember I was playing once, I had just watched a video about herobrine and I had just loaded up a new world, as soon. As I spawn I hear a cave noise on the surface and delete the world

    • @senoevil8085
      @senoevil8085 Před 4 lety +7

      OMG YES. Agreed!

    • @willowwilt691
      @willowwilt691 Před 4 lety +12

      *Shudders

    • @urielbudy2498
      @urielbudy2498 Před 4 lety +38

      *pickaxe surprisingly breaks in a dark place*

    • @Buggular
      @Buggular Před 4 lety +12

      sirrodent AKA Jonny Foster Same thing happened to me except I didn't touch Minecraft for a whole two months after that I was terrified

  • @hannasoffan1120
    @hannasoffan1120 Před 4 lety +580

    Me: *Sees Herobrine*
    10 year old me: *Heavy sweating*

    • @theskullboy8700
      @theskullboy8700 Před 4 lety +7

      Aaaaayyyyyy the seizure eyed bastard was a jerk

    • @Korotan_
      @Korotan_ Před 4 lety

      Ikr I’ve personally seen him while playing mc on Xbox when I was young

  • @pokeling2225
    @pokeling2225 Před 2 měsíci +1

    this was my first ever video i've watched on game theory. Thank you matpat for letting me flex my minecraft knowledge.

  • @noahvonstrandmann5158
    @noahvonstrandmann5158 Před rokem +2

    Theory: the enderman were the ancient builders. They can pick up blocks and inhabit every dimension

  • @rwade9664
    @rwade9664 Před 4 lety +876

    Matpat: running from a creeper then falling into water
    Me: having fallen kingdom flashbacks

    • @chairking2759
      @chairking2759 Před 4 lety +25

      R Wade not to mention that in the fallen kingdom music video a skeleton shoots 3 arrows at the king before the scene where a creeper blows up the bridge and he jumps into the water.

    • @viva6235
      @viva6235 Před 4 lety +8

      OH MY GOD! I'M GONNA PISS MYSELF

    • @Ze_Internet_Man
      @Ze_Internet_Man Před 4 lety +2

      anyone getting revenge flashbacks?

    • @foxykj1987
      @foxykj1987 Před 4 lety

      R Wade why did you have to remind me of that sadness ;-;

    • @actualgarbage8549
      @actualgarbage8549 Před 4 lety

      @@Ze_Internet_Man no

  • @Chakar04
    @Chakar04 Před 4 lety +6178

    *Disk 11 is just Steve smoking weed and running away from the cops*

  • @ericamerson9473
    @ericamerson9473 Před rokem +3

    You can always leave it to theorists to make the lore for you.

  • @goldminecrafter
    @goldminecrafter Před rokem +1

    TGT: "After all, they can't be crafted..."
    Minecraft: Adds Disc 5

  • @tryhard007
    @tryhard007 Před 4 lety +1500

    Play disc 11 and 13 at the same time they go together

  • @randomkidonline294
    @randomkidonline294 Před 4 lety +637

    Notch watching this video:
    *“Huh, i never thought of that”*

    • @grantjenkins01
      @grantjenkins01 Před 4 lety +2

      I was just thinking that. There's no way there's lore this deep in Minecraft.

    • @JiuWei_Mic
      @JiuWei_Mic Před 4 lety

      Lol

    • @aarontheperson6867
      @aarontheperson6867 Před 4 lety

      @Papi Oof I think it's referencing how he used to own it, and how he's the one that added these discs and stuff. (I know he didn't make them tho lol)

  • @itstime9023
    @itstime9023 Před rokem

    i know it is kinda late to say but....
    i never thought i would love back-to-school merch so much with such a smooth transition

  • @asrieldreemurr2897
    @asrieldreemurr2897 Před rokem +2

    And we now return with a new music disk ! I can't wait to hear what Mat thinks about the new one

  • @crusadertsakos4638
    @crusadertsakos4638 Před 4 lety +747

    If there was a realistic minecraft version, singleplayer would have been a horror game.

    • @aliyahplays
      @aliyahplays Před 4 lety +19

      CrusaderTsakos soul sand...

    • @fabiotacconi9230
      @fabiotacconi9230 Před 4 lety +6

      i'ts already one now that i saw this video

    • @peterjohnDuenassparta_88
      @peterjohnDuenassparta_88 Před 4 lety +5

      Isnt it already though? Skeleton, Zombie, Silent motherfucking creepers, Endermen Pigmen. Even with the simple graphics, They're very scary and Bone Chilling

    • @phillysapphire603
      @phillysapphire603 Před 4 lety

      @@aliyahplays Tell MatPat I want to see if this ties in

    • @benjaminhazell9417
      @benjaminhazell9417 Před 4 lety +1

      SPARTA_88 nah you’re just a wuss.

  • @ashleygilbert8628
    @ashleygilbert8628 Před 4 lety +643

    My friends: what’s your favorite music?
    Me: it’s complicated.

  • @paulhawes8629
    @paulhawes8629 Před rokem +2

    "nearly died today. A zombie tried to eat me so i took a bite out of them instead." thats what it says in the journal. bruh.

  • @ProwlinThruDaPraries
    @ProwlinThruDaPraries Před měsícem +1

    I just remember discovering the disc and freaking out in a panic because I heard the running and was so scared because obviously nobody but a player running makes that sound effect

  • @pokemonfanclub4907
    @pokemonfanclub4907 Před 4 lety +867

    Disk 11 is actually MatPat running in and copying Scott Cawthons new lore notes

  • @fireballme1153
    @fireballme1153 Před 4 lety +662

    (puts 13 in jukebox)
    Parrots: THIS IS MY JAM

  • @Azarilh
    @Azarilh Před rokem +1

    Also, the disc cat is the first disc added, together with 13, and you could get it only from creepers. Which are connected with cats as you know, which is a curious connection.

  • @tuxedeoboi9155
    @tuxedeoboi9155 Před rokem +3

    Me when watching fnaf videos: great, I understand less now
    Me when watching minecraft theory videos: oh yeah, it's all coming together

  • @jahjahbinks8069
    @jahjahbinks8069 Před 4 lety +6864

    Everybody gangsta till the parrots start dancing to disc 11
    Edit: thanking people for likes is gay no cap

    • @prajaktadandekar9297
      @prajaktadandekar9297 Před 4 lety +132

      Nick Gurr Oh fu*k. you are right

    • @pipikyyy625
      @pipikyyy625 Před 4 lety +256

      Just imagine parrots eyes started glowing and hes starts to ascend As He dances to 11

    • @chuwucate5751
      @chuwucate5751 Před 4 lety +21

      @@pipikyyy625 then megalovania

    • @JustJum
      @JustJum Před 4 lety +13

      @Kimo De Groote completely unrelated.

    • @pipikyyy625
      @pipikyyy625 Před 4 lety +6

      @@chuwucate5751 i would shid my pants

  • @mrtoad7775
    @mrtoad7775 Před 4 lety +835

    This actually creeped me out more than I'm comfortable to admit.

  • @GlitchyTSP
    @GlitchyTSP Před rokem +1

    Something that came to mind.
    If creepers are supposedly artificial in some way, what if the disk dropping is related to some sort of recordplayer-esque timing?
    Bit of a stretch but hey!

  • @StaryGalaxyGacha
    @StaryGalaxyGacha Před 2 lety +1

    the last part changed so fast that my brain can't process with your speed

  • @markdieeyeguy3569
    @markdieeyeguy3569 Před 4 lety +695

    Game theory: *releases new Minecraft theory*
    Microsoft: WRITE THAT DOWN WRITE THAT DOWN

  • @calethni
    @calethni Před 4 lety +552

    *My therapist:* Creepers with hands doesn't exists
    *Game Theorist Thumbnail:* Creeper with hands

    • @yellowdeeemond8099
      @yellowdeeemond8099 Před 4 lety

      BartekQ8905 game therapist

    • @friedtoads13
      @friedtoads13 Před 4 lety

      BartekQ8905 I was gonna comment the same thing lmao

    • @user-wv2rz1xj8x
      @user-wv2rz1xj8x Před 4 lety +1

      If you put a space in between the e and r in "therapist" it makes "the rapist".
      What has been seen cannot be unseen, you're welcome

  • @hgbanthem6025
    @hgbanthem6025 Před rokem

    2 years later these 2 now along with the new disc clearly hold so much lore

  • @CosmosStudios-ho5fg
    @CosmosStudios-ho5fg Před 20 dny

    Who would've thought that those creepy discs would've turned out to be a sort of love letter on what it's like to play Minecraft

  • @skullhead2327
    @skullhead2327 Před 3 lety +883

    11 and 13 disk: people nervous when they play it
    Parrots: we love this and we will all dance to these vibes. Why is this person scared it’s a good beat

    • @sirblue5586
      @sirblue5586 Před 3 lety +4

      @Vaughn Pflug same

    • @sirblue5586
      @sirblue5586 Před 3 lety +17

      I hate how the parrots mimic mob sounds ,for the longest time I thought that zombies were spawning under my house

    • @Barneyfromhalflife1
      @Barneyfromhalflife1 Před 3 lety +2

      This

    • @voidverse3479
      @voidverse3479 Před 3 lety +2

      guys the first time i heard them was like when i was 6 and i didn’t realise the creepy things about them

    • @skullhead2327
      @skullhead2327 Před 3 lety +1

      void verse yep we all know that feeling from something in our childhoods

  • @zgjimrrahimi8286
    @zgjimrrahimi8286 Před 4 lety +623

    Mojang: *watches this*
    hmmm... I never thought about that

    • @cytard
      @cytard Před 4 lety +25

      MOJANG: write that down

    • @gundom3445
      @gundom3445 Před 4 lety +1

      Well if they didnt think about they wouldnt have added the two disks and released the lost journals book

    • @firecracker8474
      @firecracker8474 Před 4 lety +3

      Zgjim Rrahimi
      That’s The Exact Same Thing Scott Cawthon Did Lol.

    • @vextea1503
      @vextea1503 Před 4 lety

      I thought about it and then conviced myself minecraft was a story the player wrote.

  • @Fabioplayz13
    @Fabioplayz13 Před rokem +1

    Theory:
    Maybe the cave ambients is maybe like a survivor of one of the ancient builder who is still alive and didnt go in the end portal

  • @applejuice5162
    @applejuice5162 Před rokem +1

    What if the scrambled book language from enchantments was just their language and they were so advanced that they could fit a whole book into one little page

  • @yuriwashere_1385
    @yuriwashere_1385 Před 3 lety +2702

    I swear he could talk about people eating donuts and I’d be scared af

    • @theouterlimits1
      @theouterlimits1 Před 3 lety +50

      Underrated comment

    • @mayia_rat9469
      @mayia_rat9469 Před 2 lety +43

      You should watch Food Theory then 🥲 some of them are pretty spooky

    • @yoxning
      @yoxning Před 2 lety +7

      You must be a scaredy-cat then

    • @aoife.e.d.927
      @aoife.e.d.927 Před 2 lety +37

      BUT THATS JUST A THEORY, A FOOD THEORY!!

    • @axlr8deathpls294
      @axlr8deathpls294 Před 2 lety +8

      @2024 student7 Trueeeeee except this only applies to me when I am scrolling around youtube at 4 o clock in the morning with my window closed on matpat's scratching sounds scaring the life out of me, honestly should just grind for burgh in pokemon blaze black 2 cuz this is way too spooky for me, I would rather fight a soul dew latios in gen 5 rather than having a creepy youtube video with scratching noises on my not very transparent window which also has a dark shadow covering it, yikes

  • @abbiler3242
    @abbiler3242 Před 4 lety +418

    developers: how complex do you want the lore to be
    notch: yes

    • @Annvivian1
      @Annvivian1 Před 4 lety +3

      Dicscy Dicscy gimme my whiskey
      Actually, Diamonds please

  • @priestofsyrinx6681
    @priestofsyrinx6681 Před rokem

    I am three years late on this, but the sounds of the creeper explosion plus the arrows are the classic sounds (from when the disc was released) rather than the modern sounds that were included as comparison in this video.

  • @Idkk673
    @Idkk673 Před rokem

    Mat you need to make a new one about disc 5! I want to see how that disc fits into your idea of the lore :D

  • @JUDASOFFlCIAL
    @JUDASOFFlCIAL Před 4 lety +479

    everybody gangsta until someone plays disc 11

    • @jeffjeff6160
      @jeffjeff6160 Před 4 lety +6

      disk 13 is the worst

    • @Light_3209
      @Light_3209 Před 4 lety

      @Sweet Cake Shy Its creepy!

    • @ori-onyxvyntarz3276
      @ori-onyxvyntarz3276 Před 4 lety +1

      They never really scared me. I don't know why. I liked the fact that 11 seemed to tell a story.

    • @alastorthedemonslayer4257
      @alastorthedemonslayer4257 Před 4 lety +1

      Try playing them at the same time at night in a cave

    • @sarahtwitt
      @sarahtwitt Před 4 lety +1

      When i was a new player, my friend renamed disc 13 "chirp" (my favorite disc at the time) and gave it to me... I had a heart attack

  • @jamnraquel
    @jamnraquel Před 3 lety +664

    *Minecraft: Rated E for Everyone*
    *Game Theorists: no, we don’t do that here.*

  • @chicken4699
    @chicken4699 Před 2 lety +1

    Me:disc 11 and 13 is just the mobs in game nothing to fear about
    My brain:yes
    My brain at 2AM:the disc is about herobrine.

  • @jordonmaksembawangss8627

    make a theory about the new music disc,the one that came with the caves and cliffs update.Here is some info:the disc needs nine fragments,all of which can most likely be found in the old underground castle like structures,after I heard it completely,it sounded like someone was running away from a warden,there is fire and water in the surroundings,a bat flies away most likely out of fear,the person does manage to escape the warden temporarily,then normal music kicks in before slowly dying down,bubbles are heard,the person continues to try and escape,what sounds like grindstones are heard,this makes me think that the person might be making a weapon,near the end the warden is alerted of the person's location and proceeds to attack.

  • @thetruebaloney117
    @thetruebaloney117 Před 4 lety +819

    Mat pat: * still talking about Minecraft *
    Me: * waiting for game theory theme song *

  • @dying_ken
    @dying_ken Před 4 lety +1008

    Matpat: “WHAT IS THE SECRET ABOUT THE DISCS?!?!”
    Notch in Dream's video: “Oh, yeah, I forgot the lore of that discs.”

  • @snubcone4115
    @snubcone4115 Před 8 měsíci +1

    Matpat my grandma is dying and has 6 weeks or less to live as the cancer slowly takes out her organs and I barely see my parents because they are always having to go to her house and help. Nothing stops me from crying…. But you your videos distract entertain and make me forgot what’s happening yoy make me laugh and make it so much better love the vids and love you man

  • @jangajdos1693
    @jangajdos1693 Před rokem +4

    And now we have the Disc 5 awaiting a theory…

    • @darthyoda4934
      @darthyoda4934 Před rokem

      NEIN NEIN NEIN GESCHLAFEN NEIN NEIN NEIN NEIN AHHH DUDUUDUD DOOOÖF?

    • @jangajdos1693
      @jangajdos1693 Před rokem

      @@darthyoda4934
      I’m afraid I don’t speak the language of your tribe Lord Yoda… please use the Google translator and enlighten me with your wise words.

    • @darthyoda4934
      @darthyoda4934 Před rokem

      @@jangajdos1693 oh sorry about that the translation is “ yes yes yes I very much agree yes yes yes “

  • @nintendogh0st
    @nintendogh0st Před 3 lety +394

    Disks 11 and 13: Death, Despair, Destruction
    Parrots: YUHHH GET INTO ITTT

    • @kathryncanaguier2557
      @kathryncanaguier2557 Před 3 lety +3

      AKAKAJAKAKAKJAKAKAKAKAKDHHDJEJEHS

    • @Luka2000_
      @Luka2000_ Před 3 lety +11

      @@kathryncanaguier2557 my man had a stroke

    • @nintendogh0st
      @nintendogh0st Před 3 lety +1

      kathryn it’s okay take your time

    • @Kimbilly76
      @Kimbilly76 Před 3 lety

      Me as a edgy video game character main guy:MY JAM WOO
      The characters I main:is our player a stalker or a murderer
      A character:well he mains you so yeah

    • @AsRaTCW
      @AsRaTCW Před 3 lety

      @@Luka2000_ lukice

  • @gdmobilerobtop6661
    @gdmobilerobtop6661 Před 4 lety +912

    8 year old me when something strange happens in minecraft:
    "HEROBRINE"

    • @ArgS_T_
      @ArgS_T_ Před 4 lety +5

      Yasss just amazing have you ever thought I'd Minecraft story mode was part of this

    • @redwolf8581
      @redwolf8581 Před 4 lety +1

      When i had heard about Herobrine on a video when i first started playing Minecraft i wouldn’t play for about a day

    • @PBM24
      @PBM24 Před 4 lety

      Dinkleberg...

    • @gdmobilerobtop6661
      @gdmobilerobtop6661 Před 4 lety +1

      @Mike Kimel noones even using pusab

    • @marcelinatavarez4159
      @marcelinatavarez4159 Před 4 lety +2

      Creep er
      AWW MAN
      mat you should have said that

  • @greyfreak5780
    @greyfreak5780 Před rokem +3

    Imagine the how to books of Minecraft was their journals 🎉