YT46 Are there 72 Virgins in Paradise? "Hoor" in the Quran by Dr. Hany Atchan
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 05. 2021
- Does the Quran promise martyrs 72 virgins in paradise? What awaits those who are martyred in the way of Allah according to the Quran? The truth confirms a deep understanding that may surprise. A detailed description of virgins in paradise, with the Quran for the thinking person.
To learn more, Please follow us on
Facebook Marvelous Quran
Website www.marvelousquran.org
You may contact us at
Gmail MarvelousQuran@gmail.com
Please Share, Subscribe, and Like
Quran Translation and Commentary by Dr. Hany Atchan
As a Muslim girl and then as a married woman I always felt that the traditional interpretation was disrespectful towards me and towards women in general. One of the reasons why I couldn’t bond with the Quran until now. Jazakum Allahu khairun Dr. Hany for helping my reentry into trying to understand Allah’s message.
Lol.
👍👍
@@Lunyore Looking at a mirror?
The reason you couldnt "bond with the Quran" is because you have a hidden hatred or envy towards men, and i dont think Allah wants to guide someone, whos heart is not pure.
Also a simple google search would show you that Hooris is applied both to men and women equally, and you anyways get anything and whatever you want forever in Paradise. (Mentioned in the Quran over and over again)
I think Allah just wants to delude you furthermore with this guy, because you have hidden hatred against the Quran and Islam.
But i cant speak on behalf of Allah, its just my assumption, and i want to warn you, to not just follow this guy, because he just does this and that. i dont know if his methodology has any basis or not.
But concerning the position of women in the "traditional" translation of Quran
(i copied that from another comment)
Sometimes i really ask myself, if you guys actually read the Scripture, or like Allah often says, you just throw it over your shoulder and do not care. i had to think maybe half a minute to find so many instances, that proof, that the notion you want to bring across about the most Perfect, As-Samad. Alhamdulillah
And they say, "The Most Merciful has taken [for Himself] a son." You have done an atrocious thing. The heavens almost rupture therefrom and the earth splits open and the mountains collapse in devastation that they attribute to the Most Merciful a son. And it is not appropriate for the Most Merciful that He should take a son. There is no one in the heavens and earth but that he comes to the Most Merciful as a servant.
Quran 19:88-93
Please tell me, you really would think just a millisecond, its about the gender thats being attributed, or the attribution itself, that is the horrible, horrible crime.
May Allah give us protection from this. May Allah give us Guidance.
And then:
Those who pronounce ẓihār among you [to separate] from their wives - they are not [consequently] their mothers. Their mothers are none but those who gave birth to them. And indeed, they are saying an objectionable statement and a falsehood. But indeed, Allāh is Pardoning and Forgiving.
Quran 58:2
"no mockery/repulsion of wives"
Let them live where you live ˹during their waiting period˺, according to your means. And do not harass them to make their stay unbearable. If they are pregnant, then maintain them until they deliver. And if they nurse your child, compensate them, and consult together courteously. But if you fail to reach an agreement, then another woman will nurse ˹the child˺ for the father.
Quran 65:6
"special protection from Allah in times of divorce"
and when baby girls, buried alive, are asked
for what crime they were put to death,
Quran 81:8-9
"Baby girls as witnesses before Allah against the horrendous crimes against them (based on gender)"
And there is a verse too, that condems the behaviour from men, hiding ashamed when it is revealed to them, that they will get a baby girl and not a boy. but i cant find it right now. Ins sha Allah someone could provide it here
Thank you Dr. Hany I always believed that 72 Hours cannot be the word of my ALLAH. You have brilliantly clarified, it is the interpretation of misogynist minds
Assalam walikum wa rahematullahi wa Barakatahu, I'm a converted Muslim & a new student of Arabic..It was 2 days back when I heard about this mis interpreted concept of 72 virgins in paradise I literally fell into pieces.. & was looking for a proper explanation since I knew it can never be a plan of Allah SWT, & now I'm so relieved after I found this video... Jazakullah Khairan.. May Allah bless you
@Paromita Roy
Alhamdulillah. Happy to have you with us.
Truly marvelous interpretation. Somehow for me, it was always difficult to reconcile with the traditional interpretation. Thank you Dr. Hany. May Allah's blessings with you. You are tasked to carry out a gigantic task and you are doing it so well. جَزَاكَ ٱللَّٰهُ خَيْرًا
I'm amazed how a word which is very obvious ( _hoor_ ) became to refer to women? As an Arabic speaker I find it to be deliberate corruption. The word _hee-waar_ comes from the same root to mean a dialogue between two parties; so to *unravel* each, his/her, intentions, or to come to an agreement on common ground.
Very important to note not a single educated Muslim Imam/scholar would take this (72 virgin fallacy) seriously. Most who argue about such interpretations are _jahallah_ or deliberately misleading their flocks.
Ah you're an arab i thought you were persian.
Alhamdulillah. Thank you so much, the traditional concept of hur left me baffled for many years and the description of the hur was so beneath the majesty of the quran and islam. I could not accept it. Thus I was struggling in fully embracing my deen. Because to embrace my deen fully I needed to embrace all the details of the quran...... But now I have found peace at least with this issue. Alhamdulillah and I pray for you and your family.
Thank you!!! May God keep us guided. Please share and review other videos on the channel. Regards
❤ Thank you, Allah (SWT) saved me and your video helped me alot.... ❤
Logical interpretation and very convincing!
We are grateful we have people like you, with your academic qualifications, who are dedicated to interpreting the Quran through such organic methodology that comes directly from the Quran itself. Thank you Dr. Hany
Wow, thank you!
quran centric also talking about it
Dr. I so much appreciate you for this beautiful message, alhamdulilah I found my Jannah. exactly what I told my family during prayer that you have to pick different ayat from Quran (in accordance to inspiration from Allah) to make a full sense of what you are teaching and you buttress just that in this video. Alhamdulillah. Thank you so much sir
Alhamdulillah
😂Dr with what degree?
Alhamdulillah. After learning from up to your latest presentation (2.10), now I can really understand your message in this video. Thank you Dr Hany.
Alhamdulillah
Sincere gratitudes for sharing with us this invaluable information. Brilliant - concise - correct - objective - precise "Methodology" as The Book meant to be. God bless you.
When you hear of what the pious men will be given of the pious women you wonder what would the pious women be given as a reward for their efforts. Thanks Dr for unraveling the hur.
May Allah reward you for your effort, but as an arabic speaking person Im not covinced, but will watch more of your videos, inshaalah
Salamun Alikum. Thank you for such an indepth explanation. It's really amaizing.
You are most welcome. Please watch the videos after this one. Welcome aboard
Impressive! This is so true. I would want you to interpret Surah Ya Seen 🤲🙏
Alhamdulillah for an answer which I've been praying for.
Alhamdulilah. Gives us a reason for rebuttal about the meaning from those who need a reason to mock.thanks
Alhamdulillah. Much more is coming insha Allahh. Keep watching
Jazakallah khair, Dr. Hany. Another excellent video, and your interpretation makes complete sense. I look forward to your insights on the term "Jinn", inshallah
Thank you kindly. Insha Allahh
Jazakallah kheer, may Allah grant you janatul fardoos 🙏🌹
Aameen. You too
Thanks for sharing!
May God bless you
Same to you! Plz keep watching. Regards
My brother, this is beautiful. Thank you so much.
Dr Hany, thank you for reminding me of the "A-HA" moment :)
My pleasure!
Thank you for making such a clear and well-explained video!
Glad it was helpful! Keep watching our channel
Most convincing
I was literally loosing my stong iman watching various doubtful contents about islam. You have come forward to show the lights on this darkness. May Allah increase you more in knowledge and accept all of your efforts. Thanks a lot, Dr.
MashaAllah. Really really appreciate your works and efforts. May Allah swt bless you with health and more of knowledge to share. JazaakAllah
Alhamdulillah
Very intelligent interpretation may Allah SWT grant you increase in knowledge and Wisdom.
You too. Kindly spread the word.
@@MarvelousQuran already shared with others InshaAllah this channel will grow.
Thank you for an explanation of a widely misunderstood word in the Quran! I was always convinced there has to be a deeper explanation and was so happy to come across your video. A million thanks!
Alhamdulillah
Alhamdulillah! time to go back to basics.
Sincerely speaking Dr Hany u really amaze me the way u interprete the noble Qur'aan . I have watched so many vedios where u are doing u best to help the Muslims ummah to understand the holy scripture . My first vedio I watched on this channel is "why there are no Chinese prophets in the Qur'aan" followed by "who is Abu Lahab" and it's absolutely correct the way u present ur evidence .
Truely our tafsir scholars base their interpretations of the Qur'aanic text on the corrupted Bible and the language of the poets which the noble Qur'aan is innocent of .
I'm anxiously waiting for ur future segments notably "part 2 of the story of prophet Ieesaa and Maryam"
Also the full stories of prophets Yoosuf and Moosaa pbut
There are some questions I have regarding the segment titled "who is Ismaeel"
Thanks very much Dr Hany
@ Mustafa Mohammad
The Quran is amazing, my brother! It's not me!
Alhamdulillah. We are living in special times.
I was already crying about the misundertood version of the 72 virgins. Now Im relieved to listen to you and comparing that word across quran like you explained. Thank you so much! Greetings from Argentina 🇦🇷
Alhamdulillah for this. We'd really like you to clarify certain other verses which are hard to accept by a woman's heart! Allah SWT says that the Heaven is equally granted for both men and women as per their count of deeds. There is no doubt about that and the equality He promises.
But there are some repeating verses that talk about Kaafirs equating other gods with Allah SWT and attributing a child to Him. Where He says like "why would Allah prefer a female child for Him but a male child for you?" This verse comes when the Kaafirs seemed to attribute a female child to Allah SWT. The ultimate message here "He neither begets nor He was begotten. He doesn't need anyone. He is the Supreme. He is One". But why that comparison above in order to bring out such a message? I always needed this clarification. Thank you!
Insha Allah! May Allah bless us with His Wisdom!
In my own Opinion, Allah SWT has granted you this insight and knowledge because in this time of this world, the 72 virgins myth is too prevalent in everyone including believers.
Alhamdulillah. Plz watch the other segments on the channel and spread the word. Regards
Alhamdulillah . Salam from Singapore. For so long I had been making d'uas for Allah to let me understand the Quran and understand Islam . And HE makes come across this Channel. Thank You Dr Hany
Alhamdulillah
Thank you brother for the information may Allah bless u.
My pleasure. Please help us spread the info. Regards
@@MarvelousQuran inshallah brother will spread.
Assalamualaykum Dr Atchan. I wanted to ask regarding one of your video regarding the story of Moses (SAW) where you are saying that one of the hand of Moses (SAW) could be chopped or malformed. I agree that linguistically, it made sense but I was wondering if there was something that could support your exegesis. Also, do you have any book of yours available so that I can read because I do appreciate some of your explanations. Lastly, there is a Mufti known as Mufti Abu Layth. I was wondering if you would have a MindTrap session with him and share more about your discoveries.
Salamun Alaykum
I have a book that will become a reality soon insha Allahh. A few chapters are available in manuscript form for private reviews. I could share something with you depending on your interest.
W.R.T Mufti show, I need to learn more. Kindly follow up using the email marvelousquran@gmail.com
Thank you very much
In the previous verses of Sura Ar-Rahman (I.e. the verses immediately preceding verse 72), it seems that Jannah is being described and verse 72 and 74 are a continuation in that context (for example, verse no. 56 onwards).
Could you please shed some light? Thank you in advance!
@This Guy Right Here Great question. In the second part of the video I provide a definition of Jannah to mean "the private understanding". "Hoor" (i.e., the scriptural verses) are the basis for this private understanding. And therefore, the context for the verses your mentioned is exactly the same thing: The private understanding that Allahh provides to those who are "Muttaqoon" (i.e., disciplined in applying the Quranic methodology). I hope this helps.
Regards
Thank you so much Jazak Allah Jazak Allah I am so happy to hear you. Mash Allah Alham du lilah as sisters have a brother like you!
I really liked and admire explaining the true meaning of Qur`an with Dr Hany. My question respectfully is that, how it is not possible scholars before you did not understand at all?what is wrong the virgins in paradise lets assume its that why because wallahu known best. Misogynistic is bit seems hard a strong description for the uluma before you. Its amazing what you doing anyway. allah now best. Thank you.
Thank you for your comment. Allow me to provide some answers to your excellent, and politely put, questions...
1. Why did scholars before me NOT understand these concepts? Answer: Allah decides when and to whom he guides people to the Quranic methodology (Verses 2:142, 2:213, 10:25, 24:46, 28:56). NONE of the scholars have developed their opinions based on AN ORGANIC QURANIC METHODOLOGY. None of them even recognized the need for a Quranic methodology! You need to ask them, not me, why THEY DID NOT DO SO!
2. The dictionary defines "Misogynist" as "a person whose views are shaped by ingrained and institutionalized prejudice against women." Having read so much of the early "scholars" opinions on women issues, I'd say that applies almost perfectly.
3. What is wrong with virgins? Will women have their own male virgins too? Will we have any reproductive functions in Paradise in the hereafter? Will women be carrying babies 9 months, as on Earth? Didn't the Quran describe the pregnancy as "Kurh", meaning "something forced upon them"? Will they be forced to go through pregnancy in Jannah? etc. etc.
Please continue this conversation with further questions if you have any. I really appreciate your questions.
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran Dear Sir, I may concoct some counter-arguments for your Ist and 2nd answers but your answer no. 3 has really knocked me out.
@@ashahadalmuthaab793 Thanks very much for your generosity advise, I very well known already will not fell easylly inshallah. But it needed to be stopped by those have the adequate knowledge. I have the qur`an what wrong or right, but in teaching is another case. people who misteach should be noticed. Thanks very much.
Dr. ,With great respect to you and your efforts , I did not find any other scholar interpreting Quranic Verses like this, I accept that every scholar can have his own understanding of every Verse, but what you are trying to interpret is completely different and we don't find these meanings in Sahaba and tabieen until our time.Your intention is very pure I know, but this will create so many doubts about 1400 year scholars and especially about Sahaba rizwanullahi alaihim, because they were the people of this language, why did not they get these meanings?and it turns out that there will occur a strong doubt about muslims' understanding of their Holy Book, that they did not understand the meanings of verses during fourteen hundred years and they claim there Deen is the truest and crystal clear???
It is very clear with this methodology.
I'm not an Arab language speaker but a student of literature in English at a modest level yet I'm able to understand quite clearly what the doctor is saying.
Dr Hany, Is this applicable to al-Kahf 18: 33 context for the owner of two "gardens" as well? The word "yuhaawiruhu" unravelling the results from two "realms or abodes" the beautiful state of disciplined in applying Qur'anic methodology
Very good masha Allahh
Indeed this is logical
new subscriber!!!!!
Welcome Aboard. Glad to have you
Great service to Islam! By removing the muck from our minds.
Thank you Allah for guiding me to this, and thank you sir for creating this video !
Alhamdulillah. Plz sub, like, and share. Best regards
Dear dr. Hani, again thanks a lot for the topics you are dealing with they are really very important. It's so interesting I cannot wait to get to the end to comment. Can I say something? In your explanation of Hur or Hoor as used in the Qur'aan, you are limiting yourself to only one meaning of the word. Yes Arasool said "Allahumma inee a'udhu bika min al hoor ba'da alkawr here it is ok to say hoor here means unwrapping but in my humble opinion, not the way you are translating or maybe interprating it in this particular verse. HOOR in Arabic lexicon has many meanings, It could be used HIWARA as a verb (which you are insisting on) or used as Hoor, a noun. In this case in the Qur'aan it is a noun and not a verb to render unwrap as it's meaning as you claim. That said, there is nothing wrong at all if it means virgins - which is the one of the meanings when used as a noun as in the verse of reference. And what is wrong if Allah says that Muslims accepted in Paradisewill have virgins. You'll realize Allah Subhaanahu wa taala uses very polite words when it come to relations ship between men and women such as Baashir for intimacy, and hoor is another splendid word for beautiful spouses, what is wrong with this? Let us discuss further as we go along. Thanks Dro Dr. Hany
Just wondering... How does your sister or daughter feel about the classic Tafeer interpretation of Hoor?
And BTW, the fact that you changed the classic interpretation to "hoor is another splendid word for beautiful spouses" (instead of wives) proves my point.
Finally, the hadeeth of our beloved SAWS is not " a'udhu bika min al hoor ba'da alkawr"... It is a'udhu bika min al hawri ba'da alkawr"... Hawr is related to the verb "Ha-Wa-Ra" which means exactly what I explained in the video.
Thank you for this indepth explanation Peace.
Thank you for your kind comment. It takes one to know one. Plz spread the word. Regards
How liberating! Finally we may be able think through the verses with due reverence. Thank you Dr. Hany our prayers are with you!
Salaamun Alaykum Dr Hany. I came across this for the word Hoor and it's root:
********
Freedom and Liberation: One of the primary meanings of the root is related to freedom and liberation. Words derived from this root often convey the idea of breaking free or being released from something. For example:
حرية (ḥurriyya) - Freedom
تحرير (taḥrīr) - Liberation
********
Can that be applied to the translation? The Ayaat of the Quran being free and liberated from the superficial layer?
(I've posted this on YT139, but may be better suited here)
Thanks so much for this beautiful explanation. How about verses 37:48 to 49? I'm guessing same idea? Would really appreciate a response 🙏
Brilliant explanation
Excellent program
I am so thankful for this. This makes Quran a more intellectual academia rather than sounding like another fantasy biblical scriptures. Please interpret more.
@Sultry S Please watch the videos that were released after this video. Regards
@@MarvelousQuran Definitely will do. Love this way of interpreting the Holy Quran. It's enlightening my Weltanschauung.
thank you so much
Surah Al-Anaam, Verse 93:
وَمَنْ أَظْلَمُ مِمَّنِ افْتَرَىٰ عَلَى اللَّهِ كَذِبًا أَوْ قَالَ أُوحِيَ إِلَيَّ وَلَمْ يُوحَ إِلَيْهِ شَيْءٌ وَمَن قَالَ سَأُنزِلُ مِثْلَ مَا أَنزَلَ اللَّهُ وَلَوْ تَرَىٰ إِذِ الظَّالِمُونَ فِي غَمَرَاتِ الْمَوْتِ وَالْمَلَائِكَةُ بَاسِطُو أَيْدِيهِمْ أَخْرِجُوا أَنفُسَكُمُ الْيَوْمَ تُجْزَوْنَ عَذَابَ الْهُونِ بِمَا كُنتُمْ تَقُولُونَ عَلَى اللَّهِ غَيْرَ الْحَقِّ وَكُنتُمْ عَنْ آيَاتِهِ تَسْتَكْبِرُونَ
Who can be more wicked than one who inventeth a lie against Allah, or saith, "I have received inspiration," when he hath received none, or (again) who saith, "I can reveal the like of what Allah hath revealed"? If thou couldst but see how the wicked (do fare) in the flood of confusion at death! - the angels stretch forth their hands, (saying),"Yield up your souls: this day shall ye receive your reward,- a penalty of shame, for that ye used to tell lies against Allah, and scornfully to reject of His signs!"
(English - Yusuf Ali)
How many times has this interpretation been used as a mocking point by both muslims and non-muslims...it is impossible that Allahh swt would include a verse that incites so much mockery among people, just impossible...everyone can think of an instance in their life when this verse was brought up for discussiom and "contempt"... I am so relieved that Dr Hany by the will of Allahh can open new windows for us. Alhamdulillah.
Nonsense.
The more of your videos I’ve watched the more it’s become clear that you are following a methodology that is not from classical scholarship or viewed from the lens of the sunnah but your own desire to not appear “misogynistic” to those who subscribe to Liberalism.
Not every word of Qur’an is supposed to be taken from literal meanings but through the lens of hadith and meanings as they were understood by the Salaf. Otherwise we might as well say Zakat doesn’t mean charity but means “to purify” if you want to take the literal approach.
@33 Pol lol respectfully read a book about the science of hadith because only a very shallow understanding will make someone believe hadith is not Wahi. The narrators of hadith are the same people who narrated qur’an - the only difference is the number of chains of narration, where they vary from high to low numbers for hadith but remain high for all of Qur’an.
Secondly, the Houris (hoors/hoor al-Ayn) have variously been described as being “chaste females”, “restraining their glances”, “modest gaze”, “wide and beautiful/lovely eyes”, “untouched in the Qur’an itself - his whole argument falls apart here alone.
@@callmechowdree689 no need to be disrespectful to people making an effort. Yes, you may disagree and nobody is forcing upon you.
I don't know if you have done your due diligence to find out if there interpretations than the traditional one to you dearly adhere to.
Providing you a link and it's up to you to check and reflect
czcams.com/video/PMHnkQwb3ZQ/video.html
He is most likely a freemason satanist.
@33 Pol And this man is enlightened with Wahi???? His interpretation is totally out of context read the whole Surah Dukhan......
@@alhassani626 bro what, u mean the channel owner or the commenter, either way this makes no sense
Alhamdulillah 💡
Dr Hany most of your videos sound were very soft. 🙏
Try on a different device. We tested several videos, especially this one, and there is no problem
@@MarvelousQuran noted with thanks.
Ameen . Beautiful
السلاعليكم
What are your sources for this way of tafseer which literature can i consult ?
جزاك الله خيرا
السلاعليكم أيضاً ;)
We provided all the evidence directly from the Quran. What are we missing? Why is the Quran not enough to explain itself? Do we need some quote that we are told is attributed to a person who died 1200 years ago before we allow ourselves to understand the Quran and before we allow God (the living) to provide his direct guidance?
My friend: Those who want to silence God would rather speak on his behalf to control your mind!
@@MarvelousQuran the quran is a miracle and needs profound knowlegde for it's maverlous meanings he can provide .But not every laymann is supposed to give his interpretation because we both know there are some phrases conducting people with bad intention to do fitna. I really have regards for your work and respect you as someone having more knowledge as me but it's my duty to question it's substance. Because i can't share your Knowledge to others saying i know because a guy on youtube said so if you understand my point.
انا اقصد السلام عليكم بس افق الم
الله بارك فيك
I thank you so much! I thank you so much for your work. Unfortunately, there is so much misunderstanding and misinformation on the subject of the 72 virgins intended for men to sleep with. Many women are very hurt at the thought that they have to share their husband with many other women in paradise and even watch their beloved husband having intercourse with so many women so Hoor al Ayn. This is really very hurtful. Because of all this false information and ideas about Jannah, many religious women even lose their iman and start doubting the religion. Thank you for sharing the truth and helping many women.
Hi. Your ideas are geniune and original and therefore very valuable for thinking. Three suggestion: first, all of your audiences are not english fluent, so please use more easy words and speak slower. Second, you have some texts. They are tiny in some cases and it is hard to read them. If use more pages for showing them, its better. Third, people like me need to know the periority of videos to see. Which one is first, which one is next and... at the end, you have begin great work so making mistake is unavoidable. I am not agree with your work about zolgharnin for example. But the whole work is great so i hope for you good luck.
The sequence of videos is according to their publication date. Check the channel page, under videos. Start from the oldest.
ALHAMDULILLAH for the truth!
Aslamualaikum doctor
What would you suggest to a non -arab person if he wants to interpret the quran in the true way? I started watching your vedios , the quranic methodology and nested interpretation surprised me but i don't know arabic . Does the methodology apply on TRANSLATIONS?
Only if the translation is really consistent and uses the Abrahamic locution.
What do you think about the previous ayat tafseer? (55:70) it also related to the ayat that you had discussed? Is that ayat true meaning of the beautiful woman or is there some other meaning to be unravel or unpack too?
The Aya 55:70 is describing the verses of the Quran. They are the source of good information for application, and they contain the enclosed insight.
Some 'scholars' or da'ees say things like 'if I describe the Hur to you as the Qur'an describes them, you're gonna need to go do ghusl.
This is much different.
The disfavour that illiterate people have done to the grandeur and uniqueness of the words of our LORD ALMIGHTY ALLAH SWT... They've given opportunity to the may sayers to point fingers at the flawless speech of my LORD...
Grateful to you Sheikh for unraveling the truth for us...
May LORD ALMIGHTY ALLAH SWT bless you with more wisdom and knowledge for the benefit of Muslim Ummah...
JazakALLAH khair
Excellent Dr., can you explain the other three verses from the quran that has the word "hūr"
@Syarz Asterisk They all refer to the same thing... Different benefits of being in Jannah (private understanding) with "Hur" (i.e., ayats that need to be unraveled to comprehend...
Even today one CZcamsr from Sri Lanka used the 72 virgins reference to humiliate the Muslims. But, Alhamdulillah…. your take on this subject and the believable explanation with its logical arguments is like a sword to cut that man’s tongue…..
Thanks so much Dr Hany ( its like pure honey to our intellectual guidance)😊👍
I m quoting from Ibne Kathie
" (in pavilions), Al-Bukhari recorded that Abdullah bin Qays said that the Messenger of Allah said,
إِنَّ فِي الْجَنَّةِ خَيْمَةً مِنْ لُوْلُوَةٍ مُجَوَّفَةٍ عَرْضُهَا سِتُّونَ مِيلً فِي كُلِّ زَاوِيَةٍ مِنْهَا أَهْلٌ مَا يَرَوْنَ الاْخَرِينَ يَطُوفُ عَلَيْهِمُ الْمُوْمِنُون
Verily, in Paradise, the believer will have a tent from a hollow pearl, the width thereof is sixty miles. In each corner of it there are wives for the believer that do not see the other wives, and the believer will visit them all.
In another narration the Prophet said that this tent is thirty miles wide.
Muslim recorded this Hadith and in his narration, the Prophet said,
إِنَّ لِلْمُوْمِنِ فِي الْجَنَّةِ لَخَيْمَةً مِنْ لُوْلُوَةٍ وَاحِدَةٍ مُجَوَّفَةٍ طُولُهَا سِتُّونَ مِيلً لِلْمُوْمِنِ فِيهَا أَهْلٌ يَطُوفُ عَلَيْهِمُ الْمُوْمِنُ فَلَ يَرَى بَعْضُهُمْ بَعْضًا
Verily in Paradise, the believer will have a tent made of a hollow pearl the length thereof being sixty miles. In it, the believer will have wives who do not see each other, and the believer will visit them all.
فَبِأَيِّ الَاء رَبِّكُمَا تُكَذِّبَانِ
Brother. We are using a Quranic methodology for interpretation. Ibn Kathir and all the others did not use this methodology. Please watch the videos on methodology, especially this czcams.com/video/noBa4w76O58/video.html
@@MarvelousQuran i dont have anything Against ur methodology..
I believe its the miracle of Quran that a single ayat has more then one right interpretations..
You opened my eyes and mind both, I want to translate in my language Urdu for public, what to do in this case?
Thank you. You have my permission but please allow me to have a friend approve the translation before you publish
sabir fadlan before you translate learn as a detail because it can be lost in the translate. I am not arab I ajib. but we want to get correct message from allah don't we. may god guide us amin. dont rush for beauty lol first.
Great effort in dispelling some of the really embarrassing interpretations. 😊
Thank you kindly! We aspire to ascribe to Allahh the reverence due him. With your help, Insha Allahh, the whole world will get to understand the Quran in a holistic and better way. Plx spread the word... Regards
im a simple guy with simple reading, what he just said made my head hearts.. There is no way you can go from Hur to the verses of quran. Its not possible linguistically or metaphorically
But I thought Quran was simple that a child could understand it? It’s so clear?
Who said that and where did the Quran stated such things ?
Every knowledge is an energy intensive process that every individual should toil since childhood.
Hello, first of all i would like to thank you for your effort trying to think out of the box, but to be honest i am left with more questions then answers after watching your videos ( i have watched few, and can’t judge yet), but i have a question there, when to know which verses can your methodology apply on, i went back and checked for exa. The word الأرض , which was mentioned in the quran in 451 places, and i can’t tell which verses complies to your method. If it was explained please point me to the related video.
Thank you.
The methodology is not mine. It is extracted from the Quran.
Re. Ardh, the vast majority of verses that include Ardh are referring to scripture.
In a few cases, it could refer to earth/land, and possibly both that and scripture (dual meanings).
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran Thank you for your reply, i know that you are introducing it as fact, but am still trying to wrap my head around this concept, thus am approaching it with a critical thinking and so far it’s an interesting theory that definitely should be studied. I have joined you recently and i’ll continue watching your lessons.
Thanks
thank you very much, ...
You are welcome! Welcome to As-Sarh
Thank very much , can you please make a video to help me understand the difference between الروح and. النفس
Thank.
Sorry I’m deeply troubled by this concept in Quran I am trying to learn Islam and this part really confuses me. Are you suggesting that it is not literal but a metaphor and there isn’t sexual desire and physical gratification in this lower carnal perspective?
💓Aameen💞Alhamdulillah
Can you give more examples of janna not meaning paradise in hereafter like the example for ibrahim a. S
“Al- Quran is simple and easy to understand but not for the simple minded…”
Good explanation
Exactly. Thank you
Simply superb
Thanks a lot
So Sir, does it mean that wherever the word "Hoor" coming in Quran it doesn't mean Virgin Female ? One of the root meaning you described here is different from what I comprehend from other sources. What I understood by the root meaning as white/clean or sometimes as nymph. Please correct me if i am wrong.
They twisted the meaning to suit their conditioning at the time when women were considered a possession. Plz Sub, Like, and share. Regards
Salaam Alaykum, which English translation of the Qurán do you recommend?
The closest is Mohammad Asad, but it has many problems. Available online I think. Regards
@@MarvelousQuran Where can I study the Quran through Abrahamic locution?
Thank you very much for your time and effort to make this video. I’d like to contact you about the verses of Adam and Iblees. I think it’s very important and did some serious research. I use the Quran as the only source, so I don’t use Hadiths. Maybe you’re interested in taking a look at it.
Use the email marvelousquran@gmail.com
there is difference between your translations about kawkab in regards to story of Joseph and in this video you translated it as planet please explain
@ Shah Nawaz Good observation. In this video, we had not explained the concept of nested interpretation yet. So I used the common translation. In Yusuf's dream video, we explained the nested interpretation in more details, and that was essential to understand the story of Yusuf. Thanks
Dr. Hany, What about 55:70? 55:70 is still talking about Women. How do you interpret it?
This question was answered in the comments earlier
Those interpreters of the Quran and the Mullahs and the Peers ought to be ashamed of themselves for degrading the Words of Allah swt. It only goes to show their own depravity.
Thankyou Dr for your wisdom and analysis.
sir please provide a hadees in reference to what you just said .any reference from the time of the blessed prophet Muhammad s.a.w himself where he or any of his companions interpreted the blessed ayaats as you have .otherwise it is really confusing.may Allah swt forgive us all in associating something with Him swt which is not true .
I trust the words of my lord over the words transmitted (possibly incorrectly). Plz Sub, Like, and share. Regards
Very nice video brother
Thanks. Keep spreading the word. Regards
then why does further in this chapter it says; women who lower their gaze and examples of fruit. And then the hurs are compared to coral and rubys.
and in surah Naba its also mentions full breasted women as reward. Explain that ?
dr. Hani, I am still listening to you and your methodology. Here I'm intrigued if not confused about your interpretation of Al-Mutaqoon using your methodology to mean "Those who work in a disciplined manner to apply the Qur'aanic methodology....." From where did you get this meaning?.
1. Even if you use the occurrence of a word in a hadeeth to justify a meaning in a Qur'aanic verse you could still be very wrong and if even you use the same word that occurs in one verse to justify its meaning in it's occurrence again in another verse you could still be wrong. The two meanings could be different. You being an Arab, (I am not an Arab FYI) you know as well as I do that many Arab words have linguistic meaning and Sheria meaning, and these meanings are sometimes interchanged in the Qur'aan or in the hadeeth. Where a word could have a linguistic meaning somewhere in another place in the same Qur'aan or in a hadeeth it could have linguistic meaning. For example, if Allah uses the word Innaa AWHAYNAA ilayka kama AWHAYNAA ilaa Nuhin wannabiyeena min ba'dihi, in Surah Alnisaa vs 163, here Allah is taking about REVELATION in used in Sharia, but if Allah says Wa AWHAIYNAA ilaa UMMI Musa.... in Taha, it is not REVELATION as revealed to Prophets because Prophet Musa's mother was not a prophet, it means here a kind of inspiration which we do not have details of but not REVELATION as given to Prophets. So you see here that using the meaning in one place to explain it somewhere else can be problematic or even misleading. I could give more examples, but this media is not for that.
JAZAAKA ALLHAU KHAIRAA.
Plz do yourself a favor... Stop making comments and watch a few videos to develop a good understanding before you start rejecting. You have not seen the full picture, and you're already rejecting this new 3ilm.
Additionally, this is not "my methodology". I never claimed that it was "my methodology". So please stop mis-attributing the methodology and misleading people.
Take the time to learn please. There is much that you do not know yet. Be patient with yourself. Allahh will hold you accountable for every word that you use.
Yes, like anything new, you have to allow yourself time before you appreciate the scope of the whole 3ilm.
Regards
So ahadith that talk about the hur, are they mistranslated? “It was narrated that Abu Hurayrah (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “The first group will enter Paradise looking like the moon on the night when it is full, and those who follow them will be like the brightest shining star in the sky. Their hearts will be as one, and there will be no hatred or jealousy among them. Each man will have two wives from among al-hoor al-‘iyn, the marrow of whose calves can be seen from beneath the bone and flesh.” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari, no. 3014; Muslim, 2843.”
We demonstrated our methodology for distinguishing between a narration that uses the proper Abrahamic locution vs. a narration that violates the correct definitions of the Abrahamic locution. This narration violates the Abrahamic locution, and it includes details that could not have possibly come from our beloved SAWS because he would never add additional details, especially about Ghayb, above and beyond what the Quran provides.
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran that’s one thing that’s confusing. You’re teaching that the Qur’an using the Abrahamic locution, but I was under the impression that Ibrahim didn’t speak ‘arabi. Also, that Allah sent down the Qur’an in ‘arabi telling an nabi, may peace and blessings be upon him, to explain it. I honestly don’t discount issues being understood using Ibrahimic locution, but the first generation doesn’t say that that’s how they were taught. Where can I find that they were?
We explained the difference between Language and locution. Locution is about the indications of specific words and expressions and style of composition, not about the language in general.
BTW: How do you know that Ibrahim did not speak Arabic, or an early form of Arabic?
@@MarvelousQuran based on what I’ve read on how what we know to ‘arabi came about. That doesn’t mean an older form didn’t exist that he spoke…but that’s not what’s reported. Anything you have on this would be highly appreciated.
@@MarvelousQuran language vs locution…like how Americans and the English both speak English yet have different usages/understandings of words. That’s understood.
As salaamun alaykum warahmatullah wabarakatu. I think we should exercise great caution in calling people names here. What the sheikh said to me is a matter of opinion. It's not absolute in itself. And human reason, no matter how well informed, cannot sit in judgement over the the word, designs, or actions of Allah SWT. Many scholars, hadith's etc have put forward a meaning contrary to what you are presenting here. Does it mean they are all misogynists? And what makes you think you yourself have not caught the feminist bug? Allah creates what he likes and assigns the roles he likes. He makes something a stone and decides to make another a tree. In the same way he decides to make a man and a woman and elevated them above all else. Do you hear the trees complaining about the status given to them? Or do you hear the coals complaining? You make it sound as if assigning 72 virgins to a man diminishes the status of a woman! Since this is just an opinion emanating from logical reasoning, have you ever considered the following; what if you are wrong? What if the literal meaning of ayah is exactly what is meant, and what if all those scholars and hadiths that interpreted it as such are right. What happens to the name calling? Misogynists as you said. I also read in the comment section somebody said something like it's beneath the Qur'an to tend towards misogynistic tendencies. Now come to think of it, who is anybody, whose only yardstick is reason, to even judge the Qur'an? We are Muslims and once we know that it's the word of Allah, whether we understand it or we don't, whether we are comfortable with it or we are not, we submit to it. Understanding can come later and even if it doesn't, we must still submit to it. Once again, human reasoning cannot sit in judgement over the word of Allah. In summary, there is nothing misogynistic, demeaning, or bad in having 72 virgins in paradise(in the literal sense) if that is what Allah has intended for the successful ones amongst us. May Allah SWT make us amongst the most successful in this life and in the here after. Aameen thumma ameen. Ma salaam.
15:75 indeed in that are the signs for those who discern.
OMG. To think most of the commonly used translations , translate "hur" as "women" !! " protected truth to be unravel " has a lot more dignity & substance and relevant , surely! Masya allah. Assalam from Malayis!
Glad to have you part of the community. Regards
Jzkh bro, where is ullima of the world no debate corrections or even challenge. I know what I do in my heart and allah only ofcourse. shukran.
I am still confused. If hawara is to open (like a scarf) in an orderly manner, then what is the hoor in jannah?. Some people say it's companions. Please anybody help me.
Jannah is "the abode of privileged understanding". It is a metaphorical representation for concealed understanding within the ayats of the Quran.
The "Jannah" of the afterlife is wayyyy beyond the descriptions in the ayats of the Quran.
..
The methodology shall not selectively be applied at different thresholds because of contextual interpretation. The original Lissaan shall not be altered. There is no amount of research that has the authority to misinterprete the original locution of the message.
So be it, the women in heaven, Jannah, with beautiful eyes await you.
What (or who) awaits your daughter or wife or mother, my brother?
Or do you think the Quran was revealed just for men?