Classical Pianists React to Secret (2007) Piano Battle featuring Jay Chou & Zhan Yu Hao
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 07. 2024
- Thanks for watching our reaction to Secret (不能說的秘密)! Were you impressed by Jay Chou and Zhan Yu Hao's piano battle? Let us know what you thought of the pianists in this movie!
CAST:
Michelle Lau, Sara Nikolic, Dan Luong, James Masschelein
FOLLOW US!
FB 👉 / 2sharps1flat
IG 👉 / 2sharps1flat
Michelle
IG 👉 / theopenscore
CZcams 👉 / theopenscore
tiktok 👉 theopenscore
Sara
IG 👉 / saranikolicpianist
Dan
IG 👉 / danluongpiano
CZcams 👉 / danluongpiano
Twitch 👉 / danluongpiano - Hudba
There are Halloween Easter eggs in this video... can you find them??? Be careful of spoilers in the comments down below! 😉
I see Mike Myers at Sarah's window
@@thunderbolt2607 😱😱😱😂😂😂.... how many times???
lol these classical pianists "react" as if they can play better than that
This reaction is better than TwoSetViolins have done. Cause they have also done a reaction on this video but they didn't do any research on Jay Chou. At least you guys did some research. But for your kind information, they didn't double the speed. This is the real speed of Jay's piano playing.
It's not even close to better mate💀
Exactly. The Asian lady assumed that Jay Chou wasn't following the sounds when in reality he could play much faster if he truly wanted to. These people don't know much about Jay Chou, sadly. 5:16
Brett and Eddy are busy practising 40 hours a day, of course they had no time to research. Hahah!
Yes!
I think brett and eddy should stick to the instruments they're experts at. They look stupid when they try to criticize nonviolin players.
Meme's aside, secret is a pretty decent movie.
Jay Chou is a singer songwriter, that is famous for writing all his own music. He wrote the entire score for this movie too. Jay is a musician before he is an actor. Though he isn't Lang Lang or Yuja wang levels of virtuoso, he dominated asian pop with his distinct style of composition.
The point is, classical pianists only know the things in their classical world, they dont care or dont know much about the other things in the real world haha!!
What really makes Jay Chou famous is not his piano skills, but his musical talent
*it's not **just** he's piano skills
@@meowpluff6035his*
Jay Chou is a living legend. Can't wait for his next album. Jay Chou is like the Chopin of modern pop music. Really hope he can release an album here in the U.S someday. Don't even care if it's not in English.
He’s had some exposure to the States, but not quite through an album. He had secondary roles in some movies, made a few movie theme songs, and even has a Netflix show
This movie is the reason why I learned piano 😭 my older friends and my brother were playing it more than 10 yrs ago 🥺 love this movie
"you know for an actor, that's not bad"
*he wasnt an actor to begin with. He is a composer, pianist, and singer.*
li yun di
Then for a composer, pianist, and singer, it is that bad.
@@baole4213 ？
@@baole4213 and hopefully you can find a person who can be a composer, pianist and singer at the same time 😉
@@user-yv4cc9yg6t hey i know its really cool that someone can be all 3. But at the same time, that doesnt mean the standard should be lowered:) he can be an all-rounder but hes not a specialist (it can be good or bad depends on the situation). So all im saying is that compared to other composers like lets say yu peng chen, hes alr. But jay chou definitely has really good songs that i like👍🏼
Both actors actually really know how to play piano .
Jay is the best composer in Asia.
It's amazing that he directed and co-wrote this movie too!
Huh?? No no no. I love Jay's songs but there are many many many great master composers in Asia. For example, Joe Hisaishi who composed tons of great music for studio Ghibli's movies etc. Jay isn't at that level.
@@tian5852The best composer for pop song. He is the King of Mandopop and have sold over 30 million records. He is Asia's best selling artist. He compose all his songs.
@@ericloh4227 Umm no, he was best selling artist but not the best composer. There are C-pop composers who wrote tonnes of songs for many many many famous singers.
yes in asia or east asia. and there is no c-pop
The movie was shot in his high school where he majored in music. He created original pieces for this movie. Hope you will react to those as well.
Michelle's so pretty and elegant, she looks like the 2nd female lead
They both played it live, you guys should watch that.
😮 Thanks for letting us know! - Michelle
czcams.com/video/4JfVP5ivUJ8/video.html
He is the king of asian pop!
You should watch the whole movie
I watched the whole movie after we recorded this, I really enjoyed it! 🎶 I did not expect the plot twist 😆
I can't wait to see it
Well, not really actors...Actually, they are singers and they are very very good in various instruments. Jay Chou is one of the king of asia r&b/pop music.
Twoset should watch this video. They reacted to this piano battle scene over one year ago but could not tell if the piano playing is legit and asked pianists to tell them
I would recommend a drama which called 交響情人夢. It's related to classical music and also fun to watch.
Aside from Mike Myers (which was really well done btw), the ghost of a woman with long dark hair and wearing white appears in the doorway behind Sara. Great editing!
hehe thanks!! glad you enjoyed Michael Myers appearance 😂 .. but what is this ghost you’re talking of?!?!
The other guy is also a musician so not someone who learnt playing the piano for a role. They did this battle live on stage. The speed is real. Anything else can be attributed to not-so-great editing.
I think I have watched this movie at least 10 times. I'm pretty sure I memorized the dialogue lol.
I saw the title alone and said YESSS lol
😆😆😁😁
You should react to the live version of this battle.. 🤣🤣
czcams.com/video/JF95lO-PV84/video.html
Starts at 1:30!
czcams.com/video/4JfVP5ivUJ8/video.html
this was the least roasting reaction on this movie i saw
you deserve more subscriber
Jay is the greatest musician for me, becoz his music touch my heart....
If you did your research, you'll know the other guy(not Jay chou) is also a musician, who plays classical music just like Jay chou, and this is a movie directed by Jay Chou.
I had a good time watching this reaction. Recommendation: Nodame Cantabile live action drama made classical music seems cool to me. Please do a reaction.
Kudos~ at least you know Jay Chou, better than @twosetviolin
They really should watch the live version and react to that instead! It’s legit af!
czcams.com/video/4JfVP5ivUJ8/video.html
not sure if you guys got this right or not but there is actually no voice over for this scene. the other guy is actually a great pianist and they both played the piano in real time when they filmed this. Also jay chou new song is out now and his album will be released on July 15 go listen to it please 👀.
Plsss they need to do a piano battle with each other
hope u can try the '四手聯彈' part. begin no musician, can't tell if their technique are good, but that's elegant and romantic, and so is the playing in this piano battle, for me/us who don't play piano, it's really good enough ❤️
Try watching Keys to the Heart. It's a Korean movie.
Another really entertaining video!
It's no movie, but if y'all are looking for great media featuring classical music I can highly recommend the Anime "Your lie in April".
Keep an eye out for it 😉
It is a movie from 2013!!!
The slower black keys etude is easier to appreciate if you're not familiar with classical music. That's how I felt before.
I like the blue shirt guy always laughing at the teacher
Have you seen The Legend of 1900? This would be fun with that movie as well. :)
I love the music from that movie! I haven't watched the movie yet but it's been in my 'to watch list' for a while!
It's on our 'to react' list too! ☺️
I LOVE this movie so much 'till this day, this is my childhood :)) And yes mygod the white keys are haaarder lol. They're much closer to each other so it's trippy and I mess the white keys a lot on that piece lol.
Both of them are Pianists..
jaychou music
May I ask one question which is she is Korean or Chinese?
OH YO I thought the woman on the top right looked a bit like the woman who was touring Jay at the intro of the movie
Top right lady, does she have any IG? She's cute!
Side note, only here coz I've watched Secret maybe like 4 or 5 times now. Still love the plot
Jay’s live piano battle : czcams.com/video/sVsFwar9428/video.html
Excellent video! I’d sugest another with te reaction to the japanese anime “FOREST OF PIANO” (NETFLIX), which is about a boy who plays a piano that was in a forest....and goes to the Chopin Competition in Varsovia!!!
It’s not CG, they did play in concert lol
Lol, they went from a speed competition to a duet.
Куда пропало видео TwoSetViolin ?
like jaychou
Jay’s opponent is also an musician a
I cant be the only one that saw the guy on the top left corner on that window of the Halloween guy, Michael Myers at 0:09, don't scare meeeee😥😥
wait what?!?!?!?!?!?! 🤡
@@DanLuongPiano haha please tell me you saw it too, stop messing with my head guys 🤣🤣 HAPPY HALLOWEEN
@@coolflamefire I’m one of the editors that worked on this video... What are you talking about?!?!?! 😭
@@DanLuongPiano 😂😂 oh my god I'm so sorry I just realised! My first time watching your videos 🤣🤣. I'm such a fool.🙂🙂At least I know I'm sane now, not just randomly seeing Mr Myers in the background 😶.
@@coolflamefire you guys trying to say that I have ghosts in my house??? Nuoooooo👻👻😱😱🤡😂😂
Watching from 1:54: They're both real pianist. But some part of it is fake like the one hand part
You guys should try black keys to white keys. Trust me, it's not that hard playing it to white keys 😁
One handed part isn't fake lol.
Sad to see keyboard playing has degraded to a shallow show-off of rapid, redundant, repeated notes! Try playing a Bach 5-part fugue! Real piano skills is about control and balance, not sheer speed.
top right lady talks too much
You guys reacting to a piano battle and not even paying attention or listening to it properly uggghhhh
Jay’s live piano battle : czcams.com/video/YOSlWZ6XuzA/video.html