Alaa Hazrat Maulana Ahmed Raza Khan as a Scientist | Earth stationery or revolving around sun?
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 03. 2023
- Being from the blood line of Maulana Ahmed Raza Khan, I started my journey on Sufism a little late then I should have!
According an Irish Novelist Bertrand Russell from where the reasoning of science ends Islamic Sufism starts.
As soon as I started digging into it, I came across a statement of Alaa Hazrat Maulana Ahmed Raza Khan that Earth is stationary and is not revolving around the sun.
This made me extremely inquisitive! And I started working on it as a research case. Pretty soon I came across an a article written by The Nuclear legacy of Pakistan Dr Abdul Qadeer Khan according him " Alaa Hazrat Imam Ahmed Raza Khan was born several hundred years before his time.
This was indeed not an under statement about Alaa Hazrat who has been given high tributes by Dr Abdul Qadeer Khan as a Polymath.
I found another book on Alaa Hazrat titled as "The last Polymath of the Muslim World".
Here I m now starting a research based series of Podcast on Alaa Hazrat Imam Ahmed Raza Khan Barelvi on his own written book fouoz ul Mobeen.
The book has been translated in English with title as "A Fair Success". In that book Alaa Hazrat Maulana Ahmed Raza Khan has provided 105 proofs regarding the concept of the stationary Earth.
I need prayers from you all as I am embarking on a journey which will enlighten me for the rest of my life.
Inshallah
وہ جو کچھ کر کے گے ہیں وہ نگاہ پاک ﷺ کا کمال ہے ایسے کمال کوٸ سگ اے رسول اللّہ ﷺ کہلوا کرہی کر سکتا ہے
i believe Amam Raza Ahmed Khan RA from my core of heart
Masha Allah
@@nomialways So u believe earth is stationery?
اعلی حضرت فاضل بریلوی رحمتہ اللہ علیہ پر لاکھوں کروڑوں اربوں بار سلام ہو❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
My life sayyedi imam ahmad raza khan fazile barelvi❤
Tum bhi Waise hi Andh bhakt hu jaise India k moorti poojak Andh bhakt hute hai😂😂😂😂😂
وہ عاشق رسول تو تھے مگر ان پر یہ کشف نہ ہو سکا کہ زمین حرکت میں ہے۔۔۔۔
Shame on you andhbhakt
Yeh nigha e mustafa s.a.w ka kamal hai k alla hazrat bht barey alim k sath sath ek bht barey scientist bh thy ❤️❤️❤️
Wow wow what a joke 😆😆😆😆😆😆
Aapke Aala hazrat ku science or technology ka koi ilm nahi tha
ماشاء اللہ بہت خوب
اللہ آپکو مزید کامیابی دے
میں بھی کافی دیں سے اس موضوع پر صحیح جانکاری حاصل کرنا چاہتی تھی
اللہ آپکو جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے آمین
Eik mera he Rehmat pay daawa nhein Shah ke sari ummat pay lakhon salam
بے شک اعلیٰ حضرت امام احمد رضا خان رحمۃ اللہ علیہ
اپنے وقت کے بڑے سائندان ہیں
ان کی خصوصیت یہ ہے کہ وہ قرآن اور حدیث کی روشنی میں سائنس کو دیکھتے ہیں اگر قرآن اور حدیث کے مطابق سائنس کو دیکھتے ہیں تو اس کو مان لیتے ہیں اور اسی پر مزید دلائل بیان کرتے ہیں
جزاک اللہ
Lol
That's great ❤ One and Only Imam and scientists Imam Ahlesunnat Ahmed Raza Khan😍
Hi
کمال کے الفاظ ہیں سبحان اللہ قربان جاؤں نبی پاک صلی اللہ تعالی علیہ والہ وسلم پر اور اپ کے آل واصحاب پر
*Daal Di Qalb Mein Azmate MUSTAFA ﷺ*
*Sayyadi AALAHAZRAT Pe Lakho Salaam ❣️*
Mustafa Jane Rehmat pey lakhoon salam
Dimag me gobar
Sir please Ala hazrat k 105 dalail pe b ek mukammal video bnaye
Insha Allah
واہ کیا شان ہے امام احمد رضا خان کی 👌👌👌🌹🌹🌹❤🌷🌼🌹❤
زبردست بہت خوب ❤❤
بہت اچھی گفتگو فرمائی ہے ماشاء اللّٰه
اسلام علیکم
ماشاءاللہ بھائی پڑھے لکھے ہیں اور ان کا دل گواہی دے رہا ہے کہ جس وقت یہ کتاب لکھی گئی تھی کتاب میں مندرجات اس وقت تک کے حاصل کردہ (acquired) علم کے عین مطابق تھے ۔ اور مجودہ دور کی تحقیق کے مطابق حقائق بر عکس ہیں تو مان لینے میں کوئی حرج نہیں۔ ایک بہت اچھی مثال چلتی بس کی دی جس میں سواریاں بس کے اندر ایک دوسرے کے لیے تو ساکن ہیں لیکن اصل میں متحرک ہیں۔ اب کوئی یہ دلیل دے کہ کیونکہ ساتھ والی سواری ساکن ہے اس لیے یہ سیٹ ساکن ہے اور کیونکہ ساری سیٹیں ساکن ہیں اس لیے بس بھی ساکن ہے تو کوئی بھی باشعور انسان اس دلیل پہ چلتی بس کو ساکن نہیں مانے گا۔
Excellent work. Please keep the research coming. Much needed.
انشاءاللہ
czcams.com/video/6thYN-4dLzQ/video.htmlsi=i-LHu9xBEUYv2SVK
See this series has real content from aala hazrat
sir tareekhe islam ki koyi book hai jisko raza academy me mil jaye hindi me - ya market me koyi book hai jo tareeke islam ko step by step likhi gayi ho ...
Beautiful loved it. 1 of the few post I liked. Usually; rubbish. Just little extra INFO: 1 Galaxy has millions of Stars & Planets & in the Universe there is so much & so many stars & planets that we cannot imagine. Our planet earth is in Milky Way galaxy & probably the smallest one at that. I am not arguing that Molana Ahmed Raza is right or wrong. He listed his findings. I personally believe that the earth is always in motion. Thanks
Aap logon me bohot achi bt kahi h aur mene aapki pahli br hi video dekhi j aur ab me Chanel ko sab scribe kr li hun take aapki hr video me dekh sakun
Ala hazrat zinda baad
Another great discussion about his scientific work...God bless❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Alhamdulilah mere sarkare Ala hazrat k kya kahne allah k ata se huzoor saw ki sadqe yeh ilm hasil tha koi mane ya na mane❤
Mashallah❤❤❤ I'm warisulqadri arsalani
Maslak e aala Hazrat zindabad❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Where i can find the books of Ahmed Raza khan for studying and research?
Search on Google fauz e mubeeen dar rad harkat e zameen
Kya ap book ka link share kr skte hai mujhe use kharidna hai
سید اعلی حضرت پہ لاکھوں۔ہحیض میں جل جائیں بے دینوں کے دل یا رسول اللہ کی کثرت کیجئے
Man U need to come to the point early… I got bored. Please try to be brief on the subject
Aalahazrat mere murshid pak k mazar e pur anwar pr karodon rehmaton ka nozool ho or un k sadqey hamari behisab maghfirat ho Ameen. AlaHazratne such farmaya. Mere peer e kamil Zindabad😍😍😍
اعلی حضرت عظیم البرکت امام ال سنت رحمت اللہ تعالی علیہ
Mustfa jane rahmat pe lakhon salam shamay bazme hidayat pe lakho salam
بھت علمی و فکری گفتگو کی گئ۔مسلمانوں کو منصف انداز میں اسلامی نظریات کو سمجھنا چاہیے۔ناکہ یہ فلاں فرقہ ہے تو غلط۔
کیا معاذاللہ کوئ دوسرے فرقے والا کہے کہ اللہ تعالیٰ ایک ہے تو کیا مخالفت میں اس اللہ تعالیٰ کے ایک ہونے کا بھی انکار کر دیں گے۔؟
Ala Hazrat zindabad
الحمدللہ
To bhai mere Ahmed Raza khan sahab jab duniya se bahar gaye nahi, unhe haqiqat ka pata nahi to unhone kaha kyu ki duniya sakin hai. Kah dete mujhe nahi pata. Baat khatam.
Ma Sha Allah...kya khoob discussion hua hai. We need more discussion like this to increase our understanding of the Universe. One suggestion......make a video on big bang theory since when this theory came up atheist were not ready to accept it since it is very close to the revelation which can be seen in all there major religion of the world i.e. Islam, christianity and judaism because it talks about the creation of universe out something and that some thing is noting but the noor of our Nabi e Kareem alaihissalaam (which can be seen in a hadith book of Mussannaf of Abdur Razzaq rahmatullah alaih where Our prophet told Jabir Radiallahu anhu that, at the begining Allah has created the noor of your Nabi and i think in other hadith he told sahaba e kiraam that Allah has created this world from my Noor).....jazak Allah Khair. From India..Muhammad Wasim
Masha Allah
Alhamdulillah finally someone is making sound. From India
neuton ka konsa law space me nahi kam karta hai jara hame bhi to bataye....
Bro even newton kai gravity kai law ko he Einstein ne ghalat sabit krdya...Newton said geavity is a force... As per Einstein gravity is due to space time curvature
Bhai aesa hai physics pad newton s law sirf inertial Frame of reference mein hold hote hain.
Behtreen discussion bothh of respected persons.
Origin ki charecter yah bhi hai ki wo stationary ho. Zameen per ham hain tu origin bhi earth ko hi manenge.
The thing is that Ala Hazrat did not receive any revelation and hence what he said can be right or wrong... Him being wrong in one thing does not effect his respect, so why is it so difficult for barelvis to accept that he was wrong about earth being in motionless state.... futthermore many of the 105 proofs he tried to gives was wrongly deduced from Quraan so the point is that like many other scholars, Ala Hazrat can make mistakes in his deduction from quraan and sunnah.... thats what we are saying
The problem is that he made 105 mistakes just on a single subject.
The problem is that he can twist and turn Hundreds of verses of the Quran and Hadith Just prove his delusional opinion.
He is no special person, he is no where spiritually near to God
at 20:45, he says any object could be pulled due to the magnetic field, and the sun does not have any magnetic field, this doesn't seem right, Gravity is a fundamental force that arises due to the mass of an object. It is described by Einstein's General Theory of Relativity as the curvature of spacetime caused by mass and energy.
The heat of the Sun is a result of nuclear fusion reactions happening in its core. These reactions produce an enormous amount of energy, manifesting as heat and light. Gravity is not dependent on temperature. It is a property of mass and energy.
Magnetic field or gravity main farq pata nhi or kihty hy physics deeply parhi hy😢😢😅😅😅😅
Andhbhati mein India ke kuchh Hindus and most of Bareilvies are equal.
My brothers
Only Prophets are followed and believed without thinking
Otherwise you may fall in Shirk
He was a human, human is to err. He was a mere man to interpret Quran by his own mind.
His interpretation can be accepted or rejected, don't make him equal to Islam. Problen lies when you ask his follwers to say 'yes' for everything he believed in. Kindly remain him as human.
My sincere request is PLEASE NOT SPREAD INACCURATE/ ILLOGICAL THINGS IN THE NAME OF SCIENCE.
Please have heart to listen another point of view.
My counter sincerity.
Regards
you haven't watch full video
Imam Raza Khan was right
By the concept of relativity
What matters is frame of refrence
Earth is stationary from earth fram of reference but from space earth is moving simple as that
Salam
I have sound understanding of some proofs given by Imam Ahmed Raza Khan in his book related to Earth's stationary Issue.
Imam started with great care and introduced the method of inference. West do not even know what are the basics of scientific inference and how the conclusions should be drive. I really support the arguments of Imam with respect of availability of resources at that time. He really made a history and we should informed about his work to our youth
Walaikum As salaam.
How u can help me in this?
And please do watch my new series of videos on Fauz e Mobeen dar rade harkat e Zameen
@@ansunibatain461 I can explain some of the arguments given by Imam Ahmed Raza. Moreover, we can write detail explanation of arguments given in the book with of help of mathematicians, physics and astronomers present in Pakistan.
@@ansunibatain461 Yeah, I am listening some other videos as tool. I read the book first time when I was in 12th grade. I was really curious about it and leave this topic for some time. I think it is time to do research on this book again.
Thanks
Buhat hi achi guftguo hoi sun kar ilam men buhat izafa huwa. Hmara almia yehi he ke ham ne aslaaf ke uloom ko apne Hathon dafan kar dia he aor ab gairon k muqtdi ban kar gumrahi ki taraf bharte chale ja rhe hrn.
Ab ye silsila chalta rahey ga
ماشاءاللہ
Science ki yahi TU beauty hai Kai wo apnay AP ko Perfect nahi kehti,
Science evolution ko manti hai ,
Aur Ye Hum Musalmano ka Claim hai Kai We are best.
اللہ پاک ہمیں اعلی حضرت کی تعلیمات پر عمل کی توفیق دے فرقہ بندی ختم ہو
آمین
So what are you doing for other planets jupiter saturn Mars?
You buy one telescope and location every day you judgment like one years then you understand.
Only not sun but every planet is the rounding where and where is going on say he goings on this way location so where is going sun?
14:12 i understand there was no such place where someone can observe the earth 🌍.
Maslak e Ala hazrat zindabad ❤
Ala Hazrat ki research or ilam kmaal thi.
great discussion on very important topic.
Jo log ikhtylaf rakhty hain un ko bas ghalt sahi ki prwa nhi hoti wo kehty hn bas ham ny manna nhi halan ky kisi ki bat se inkar karna har aik ka haq hai par aik achy triky se or ilmi ikhtylaf rakhny ka lavel bi ho bndy ka, aj jis ko kuch nhi pta hota wo bi uth ky keh deta “ye wohi hn na jinho ny kaha tha zameen sakin”
Jo first daleel boli is video mein (20:00) wo ghalat hai , because scientifically"sun is not a ball of fire"
As a PhD in astrophysics, let me justify imam Ahmad raza sahab... i will try to use simple words...when you deeply study RELATIVE MOTION, you will realise that it doesn't matter which point in the universe is assumed as stationary... because we can relatively take any point in universe as a stationary point and based on that assumption, we can create a model of other celestial bodies floating in space... this is how the universe is designed...any point in universe can be taken stationary or non-stationary based on your chosen FRAME OF REFERENCE... this is the beauty of the creation of ALLAH S.W.T. ...
so it only depends on the reference frame that we are taking in the starting... the earth can be taken stationary and based on that, the whole model of universe can be designed differently... and in this model the space, the sun, the centre of the universe and every celestial body will be considered as moving...it just doesn't matter if someone else uses a different stationary point like the western model of universe has done...both the models will be equally valid because that's how Allah has designed the universe...
But the problem with the western society is that, they neglect this phenomenon and they only want to accept their chosen frame of reference as an ultimate frame of reference and most of them don't even want to accept the simple fact that a model that considers the earth stationary will be equally valid...so if lmam Ahmad is choosing the earth as stationary in their chosen frame of reference, it's equally valid...the model of the universe will be designed differently but it will be equally valid...even if someone claims that Quran and Hadees has considered earth as stationary, it will be considered as a different model of universe with a different frame of reference...it will be equally valid... taking a different approach doesn't always implies taking a wrong approach...Jazakallah Khairan...
Please keep following the series.
Earth is objectively moving, that's how we get days, nights, seasons.
@@aunthegeek5788 nothing can be considered moving "objectively"...if i take earth as stationary, i will get get the same mathematical results for days and nights...the model will change, the result will remain the same... it's just like getting a formation with different formula... that's it...
@@aunthegeek5788 it can be understood by the train example...a person who is outside the train observes the train moving and at the same time a person inside train observes that the first observer is moving... both are right... but the effect that both implies on each other doesn't change...for example if the observer outside the train flashes a torch, the observer inside train will see it like a moving flash and the person outside will see the train passing through it...but for both of them the effective incident time of the flash that effect the observer inside train, remains the same...so the result doesn't change even if the perspective changes...
2 billion k paas ye takat nahi hai ki Dharti ke bahar dekh sake
Space 🌌 se dekh sake dharti ghoom rahi hai ki nahi
2 billion main se koi ek bhi scientist nahi hai😂
Ala hazrat zinda baad
اس سیریز کی اگلی ویڈیوز کا انتظار رہے گا۔
Salute hai bhai ne acha smjhaya Allah pak sab ko hidayat dain ameen
Mashallah
Mashallah sir❤❤
Beautiful debate
اعلیٰ حضرت پر ہماری جان قربان ❤
میں نے یہ رسالہ پڑھ نہیں ہے مگر میں نے سنا ہے انہوں نے قرآن کریم سے دلائل دیے ہیں کہ زمین ساکن ہے
Great
جزاک اللہ
Is this topic worth debatable?
Masha Allah .Bohat acha program
Jazak Allah
Bachay ne kia guftgu ki hy. Masha Allah. App ka channel b subscribe kar dya. Hope for the best.
Jazak Allah
Definitely excellent Information ......👌👌👌
Read the book of Imaam Jafar sadiq alaiyhi salaam on science, and he has proven that all planets are orbiting and revolving on its axis
More vedios on researches of Ala hazrat please 💫
Insha Allah soon
Jo na hota tera jamal hi
To jahan tha khawab o khayaal hi
Sallu alayhay waalehi
Baat sirf itni si he hai
Aqalmand ko ishara hi kafi hai
Mashallah very intellectual discussion
جزاک اللہ
Are bhai india ka chandrayaan 3 jo chand per gya hai woh Earth k rotation ka fayad utha ker hi Chand per pohcha hai
Earth ki tez rotation ne 🌍🌕 chandrayaan 3 ko chand ki taraf fek diya
Ap log sudhar jao
😣
I've also researched this topic and want to write a book about it.
Do share it.
See Gaurav thakur video.
Einsteins theory of equivalence
Earth is stationary.
Either from plane.helicopter or baloon nobody has. seen that Earth is moving.
That can be proved with science theory.
Earth's circumference was first accurately measured more than 2,000 years ago by the Greek astronomer Eratosthenes. Whereas Ahmed Raza bonga kya keh gaya jo yeh log Beth k defend ker rhay
Mashallah aala hazrat zindabad
Imam Aala hazrat ne is k ilaawa or boht si books different topics pr likhi hen plz un ki bhi kabhi detail batain.
Ji zaroor
Bhaiyya suraj aag ka gola hai but uska maas wazan ziyada hai isi liye wo hamesha earth ko bandh ke rakhta hai
Kullu shai in yasbahoon quran ki ayat hai jiska matlab hai sab kuch tair rha hai
اس کا جواب ویڈیو میں ملے گا
@@ansunibatain461 video me galat jawab hai sahi se wajahat nahi kiya unhone
سیدی اعلیحضرت امام احمد رضا خان بریلوی رحمۃ اللہ علیہ پہ لاکھوں سلام
Maslake Aala Hazrat Zindabad ❤❤❤❤
Surah Yaseen Aur Surah Kahaf Main Iska Hal Hai Aur Quran Sachchi Kitab Hai
Fanah_Fillah Fama_fir_Rasool ﷺ Imam E AhleSunnat Jaan E AhleSunnat Pehchan E AhleSunnat Shaan E AhleSunnat Alim E Shariyat Mujaddid E Deeno Millat Sarkar Aala Hazrat AshShah Imam Ahmad Raza Khan Fazil Wa Mohaddis 🥹🌍🤍
Allah aap ko behtareen jza de
قرآن کریم نے دو مقامات پر زمین کو" قرار " سے تعبیر کیا ہے ، بہت سے حضرات نے ان دو مقامات پر استعمال کیے گئے لفظ " قرار " سے زمین کو ساکن و ٹھرا ھوا ثابت کرتے ہیں ، لیکن قرآن میں اس لفظ کو دیگر مواقع پر بھی استعمال کیا ھے اس میں غور کرنے سے ثابت ہوتاہے کہ قرآن نے اس لفظ "قرار " کو قابل ( رہائش) اور قابل ( اقامت) کے معنی میں استعمال کرتا ہے ، لہذا اس لفظ سے زمین کو ساکن و ٹھہرا ہوا ثابت نہیں کیا جا سکتا
MASHALLAH quran b parh lein zra assani hogi k zameen kia haa or kesi haa un bazurgooun ko manna jaa raha jinka naa science se , astronomy se, na koi taluq unka history se, no he Solarsystem ka maloom na universe kaa illm or ZAMEEN sakin haa wah mashallah..
taleem hasil karein or knowledge pe focus karein baba g peer g...
Sir maine ye video dekhte hi ap ke chenal ko subscribe kia hai is niat se ke ap alahazrat ki kitab fouz e mubeen pr tahqeeq kren ge..i am Mphil mathematics but ye book waqe e smjh nhi ati....plz is pe kam kren...alahazrat zindabad..
Insha Allah buhat kaam hoga fouz e mobeen per
Subhan Allah Subhan Allah Subhan Allah Subhan Allah maslake Ala hazrat zindabad zindabad zindabad zindabad zindabad zindabad ❤
Sar mere raza ki shan hi nirali hai
Kam sey kam 5 batey hi bta di hoti takey logo ki twajjo is taref ho jati
مخاطب کرتے وقت ' بچوں' نہیں " بچو" کہا جاتا ہے.
I'm Not That Educated Nor I Know Much About Science But I Really Appreciate Your Work Sir You Really Working Hard On This Subject Please Keep It Up May Allah Give You Strength Amen
Ameen
Jazak Allah
Tahe dil se aap ke shukrguzaar hen
Mr. Ahmad Raza Khan was a great man with complete insight of life and creation both physically and spiritually. Where others wrote hypothesis, Mr Ahmad Raza khan wrote facts. Where some went to seek knowledge of unknown and other worldly events and systems. The Gaurdians and the watchers taught Mr. Ahmad Raza khan. The ones who questioned life. The Great Holy Prophet Muhammad PBUH revealed thee Holy Face to Mr. Ahmad Raza khan. That is the ultimate achievement. After that revelation Mr Ahmad Raza Khan destroyed the german scientists and their allies. Prompting them to reasearch themselves and thus falling to prostration after the fact. The evil satanists and zionists can silence them but The Great Holy Prophet Muhammad PBUH will remain and so will his lovers. The knowledge of Mr. Ahmad Raza khan even surpasses the modern scientists today. The satanists and zionists work till this day to silence Mr Ahmad Raza khans work.
Plz continue
Insha Allah
Hazrat mai khud bhi maslak e alahazrat pe hu
Par unhone gravity ko nahi mana
Masha Allah
Lekin unho ne gravity ko na maan.Ney per apni eak daleel b di
Apne maulana ki personal rai aur interpretation ko Qur'an aur Sunnat ki ain pakki baat declare mat karo, ikhtelafi masail the jo ab declared hogaya he science ki tehkik aur astronomer ke safar se...
Idr udar ki baten fazool me itni lambi video bna di koi research nahi hai in ki
Mashaallah bhoot khub