Pitchfork's AOTYs of the 2000s

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 21. 05. 2023
  • Ranking Pitchfork's top album of each year from 2000 to 2009.
    Find all of P4k's yearly lists here: pitchfork.com/features/lists-...
    ===================================
    Patreon: / theneedledrop
    Follow your melon:
    Twitter: / theneedledrop
    Instagram: / afantano
    Twitch: / theneedledrop
    TikTok: / theneedletok
  • Hudba

Komentáře • 1,6K

  • @Pixiesforever7
    @Pixiesforever7 Před rokem +4339

    Thom Yorke kicking himself for not calling it Kid S

  • @nickfiscella9267
    @nickfiscella9267 Před rokem +3284

    Anthony has really changed since the Pitchfork review. It was sad watching him balled up in the fetal position, crying & apologizing to Pitchfork here

    • @thath09
      @thath09 Před rokem +69

      Lol. Lots of ppl on YT not aware that the Pitchfork review was not real and was a joke 🥴

    • @Noirlore
      @Noirlore Před rokem +28

      These jokes are so lame

    • @ervin7178
      @ervin7178 Před rokem

      @@thath09 it’s not a fucking joke to me, I’m not gonna let pitchfork publish slander about my close personal friend althony rightano

    • @yt.lilsantee
      @yt.lilsantee Před rokem +13

      Nothing has ever been the same since "the incident"

    • @8thFurno
      @8thFurno Před rokem +4

      He’s a changed man now. He’s in a new era of his career.

  • @almosthelpless9374
    @almosthelpless9374 Před rokem +364

    It's really hard to pick an album of the year for 2007. In Rainbows, Sound of Silver, Untrue, Strawberry Jam, Person Pitch, and For Emma Forever Ago are all classics.

    • @BrofUJu
      @BrofUJu Před rokem +37

      For Emma was 2007? Holy crap I'm old

    • @gabrielfleisner870
      @gabrielfleisner870 Před rokem +4

      I would also add Lust Lust Lust by The Raveonettes, which came out in 2007.

    • @andrewr3169
      @andrewr3169 Před rokem +4

      @@BrofUJu self released in 2007 and then Jajaguwar re-released it officially in 2008 on a much larger scale.

    • @vansdan.
      @vansdan. Před rokem +11

      glad people are repping Burial. dubstep was done dirty

    • @iamgroot2448
      @iamgroot2448 Před rokem +16

      Is oracular spectacular not a contender?

  • @fortheloveofmusicandphilosophy

    Songs for the deaf is by far the album from 2002 that has held up the best. The production on that album is just on another level, let alone how catchy the songs still are 20 years later

    • @p0werfu11
      @p0werfu11 Před rokem +68

      Love Songs for the Deaf, love Turn on the Bright Lights, but this year was so stacked with great rock records: You Forgot It In People, In Absentia, ( ), Lil Beethoven

    • @1992AJL
      @1992AJL Před rokem +7

      I only just learnt it's the same producer/engineer as the prime Good Charlotte albums, if you go back and listen the production is unnecessarily good.

    • @That1svini
      @That1svini Před rokem +51

      I personally think Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots is the best from that year that album is just so beautiful.

    • @wilatti3450
      @wilatti3450 Před rokem +43

      Yeah but yankee hotel foxtrot is just too good. One of the best albums of all time, despite what fantano might believe

    • @sanfordcurtis8242
      @sanfordcurtis8242 Před rokem +31

      Geogaddi is AOTY worthy

  • @obsidianman50
    @obsidianman50 Před rokem +548

    Praising Radiohead albums like Kid A has become so typical that its basic in music communities to the point that underrating Kid A because liking it is basic, is basic

    • @anabell7184
      @anabell7184 Před rokem +35

      it happens... that jonathan ross interview with jonny and thom, you can see how uncomfortable thom is with the fact that ross is overpraising kid a.

    • @eliasmg9144
      @eliasmg9144 Před rokem +1

      Basic

    • @eliotkersten2073
      @eliotkersten2073 Před rokem +102

      I call it The Dark Side of the Moon-effect

    • @mimic6494
      @mimic6494 Před rokem +24

      So if you praise it you're basic if you don't praise it you're still basic?

    • @iceyroo
      @iceyroo Před rokem +49

      @@anabell7184 it deserves all the praise, one of the best albums of all time

  • @pauljeffreymusic
    @pauljeffreymusic Před rokem +78

    For 2001, apart from The Microphones, Opeth's Blackwater Park should have been mentioned, it blew every one away, not just in the metal world but all genres of music.

    • @tylersquanto8938
      @tylersquanto8938 Před rokem +14

      Meh, there were better metal albums that came out that year like Jane Doe, Lateralus, Toxicity, and Iowa

    • @user-xc9sm5pb1z
      @user-xc9sm5pb1z Před rokem

      your taste inmusic is superb, sir
      I commend you

    • @shemsuhor8763
      @shemsuhor8763 Před 11 měsíci +11

      >toxicty
      >iowa
      Better than BWP
      Lol
      Lmao even

    • @Luxalim
      @Luxalim Před 11 měsíci +1

      ​@@tylersquanto8938 All of those albums have absolutely nothing on Blackwater Park

    • @whym6438
      @whym6438 Před 11 měsíci +1

      It's Pitchfork in the 2000s, they're never going to acknowledge that a prog metal album even exists, never mind it being better than their AOTY. The sole exception is if it's a Mastodon album.

  • @davidc246
    @davidc246 Před 11 měsíci +59

    I think fleet Foxes deserved at least A, just because helplessness blues is better doesn't make it less of a great debut. Comparing it to a later album that didn't exist yet is a bit weird in the context of the video imo.

    • @davidmattox1308
      @davidmattox1308 Před 5 měsíci +3

      Felt like he rated them all in present context, like the Funeral tier. Talked a lot about how various albums aged well/poorly

    • @CL2-
      @CL2- Před měsícem

      @@davidmattox1308 Yes but in the case of Fleet Foxes he just talked about how he likes their other album more, not that it necessarily aged poorly. I don't think comparison to other works from the artist should be part of the tier list criteria.

    • @zackzallie8735
      @zackzallie8735 Před 21 dnem

      @@davidmattox1308 I feel like the only one whose still love Funeral. Fantastic album.

  • @williammoyle1385
    @williammoyle1385 Před rokem +882

    I love how Fantano subtly roasts Wilco whenever he can 😂
    Unsubscribed

    • @thisaintnoparty
      @thisaintnoparty Před rokem +159

      Foxtrot, specifically.
      Someone that loved that album must have hurt him.

    • @GadBoDag
      @GadBoDag Před rokem +200

      A heavy metal drummer stole his girl

    • @Sport87ywhvifcc11
      @Sport87ywhvifcc11 Před rokem +122

      positive, encouraging statement
      contradictory negative statement
      please laugh

    • @dpage446
      @dpage446 Před rokem +103

      ​@@Sport87ywhvifcc11 quirky meta reply

    • @gab2876
      @gab2876 Před rokem +30

      ⁠@@dpage446 calling out quirky meta reply reply

  • @JemaKnight
    @JemaKnight Před 5 měsíci +29

    Listening to Illinois was always such an experience. After so many years, it's a nostalgic experience. It's like getting to relive the memories of a summer vacation you had as a kid, every emotional high and low. There's really nothing quite like it.

  • @jamiestonks
    @jamiestonks Před 10 měsíci +11

    turn on the bright lights at b tier is an issue we need to discuss anthony

  • @rzk4176
    @rzk4176 Před rokem +49

    Vespertine by Björk was the album of the year in 2001, maybe even the album of the decade.

  • @Newmoonbyelliott
    @Newmoonbyelliott Před rokem +70

    Illinois is such an amazing album

    • @Revnoir29871
      @Revnoir29871 Před 8 měsíci +2

      Definitely brilliant yep

    • @kylefoley6745
      @kylefoley6745 Před 6 měsíci +2

      Just heard it for the first time today. Beautiful Album

  • @thekeywitness
    @thekeywitness Před rokem +127

    2000 -- The Avalanches - Since I Left You
    2001 -- The Strokes - Is This It?
    2002 -- Boards of Canada - Geogaddi
    2003 -- The New Pornographers - Electric Version
    2004 -- Madvillain - Madvillainy
    2005 -- Spoon - Gimme Fiction
    2006 -- TV on the Radio - Return to Cookie Mountain
    2007 -- LCD Soundsystem - Sound of Silver
    2008 -- TV on the Radio -- Dear Science
    2009 -- Grizzly Bear - Veckatimist

    • @frajoladellagato
      @frajoladellagato Před rokem +1

      Can’t argue with any of these!

    • @razzledcroaker3678
      @razzledcroaker3678 Před rokem +7

      Good list! You had me until Grizzly Bear. Veckatamist has some great tracks, but it's also pretty front loaded, with a few weaker tracks towards the end that drag it down for me.
      Idk who else would go there, tho. Bat For Lashes, Girls, or Antlers are up there for me, but I might just stick with Animal Collective.
      Edit - I'd also sub out NP for Ween's Quebec. Freaking love that album to death.

    • @waz3128
      @waz3128 Před 11 měsíci +7

      2000 - At The Drive In - Relationship of Command
      2001 - The Strokes - Is this It
      2002 - The Walkmen - Everyone Who Pretended To Like Me is Gone
      2003 The Rapture - Echoes
      2004 - Animal Collective - Sung Tongs
      2005 - Smog - A river aint too much to love
      2006 - Grizzly Bear - Yellowhouse
      2007 - MGMT - Oracular Spectacular
      2008 - Portishead - Third
      2009 - Animal collective - Merriweather Post Pavilion

    • @johnnycatsup
      @johnnycatsup Před 11 měsíci +4

      2000 -- Grandaddy - The Sophtware Slump
      2001 -- Circulatory System - s/t
      2002 -- The Notwist - Neon Golden
      2003 -- Broadcast - Haha Sound
      2004 -- Air - Talkie Walkie
      2005 -- Deerhoof - The Runners Four
      2006 -- Midlake - The Trials of Van Occupanther
      2007 -- Okkervil River - The Stage Names
      2008 -- ** pitchfork got this right **
      2009 -- Bibio - Vignetting the Compost

    • @YesNo-yl6ws
      @YesNo-yl6ws Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@johnnycatsupman you have some amazing taste, you got any more recommendations? 😅

  • @Amouroso
    @Amouroso Před rokem +252

    Oh this a fantastic way to continue this style of video! Love love love these tier list videos so much. Here’s to many many more! Thanks for all the content Anthony + Editors!

  • @slamkos
    @slamkos Před rokem +30

    you should do a tier list for the best albums per year from RYM, tonytano.

  • @geoffreym4772
    @geoffreym4772 Před rokem +16

    I actually like the more classic, maybe even archaic sort of take on folk that the self-titled Fleet Foxes album had, as compared to Helplessness Blues. That's not to say I like it better, but it's a tough call. And I love them both for very different reasons. Plus, it seems a little unfair to look into the future and judge an AotY on that grounds. lol

  • @adamauxier4035
    @adamauxier4035 Před 6 měsíci +3

    I think the thing you gotta understand about Kid A was that it was the closing of the coffin lid on the Boy Band/Rap-Rock-Korn era. Thats why old guys love it so much. It shut that whole chapter

  • @christopherrroth6043
    @christopherrroth6043 Před rokem +33

    MPP is such an unbelievable record but I feel like I can't enjoy it without being accused of being a complete poser so thanks Anthony for making me feel validated

    • @UndercoverNormie
      @UndercoverNormie Před 10 měsíci +2

      Just tell them what your favorite AC albums are in order 😆 People talking shit probably don't even know.

  • @basehead617
    @basehead617 Před rokem +27

    Really wish you did the last few years of the 90s as those were also epic years for Pitchfork

  • @jasonkh4
    @jasonkh4 Před rokem +50

    Burial’s Untrue is one of the greatest albums ever, not just of 2007

    • @riffrangler
      @riffrangler Před rokem +5

      W, very underrated

    • @doloreshaze-ji4jw
      @doloreshaze-ji4jw Před 11 měsíci +4

      Yes

    • @itsPonkulz
      @itsPonkulz Před 10 měsíci +3

      @@riffrangler Definitely not underrated. It's getting much praise and it's well deserved.

  • @th3giv3r
    @th3giv3r Před rokem +18

    2005 had Sleater-Kinney, The Woods, and Bloc Party, Silent Alarm as well, but SS is solid

    • @danielgray65
      @danielgray65 Před 11 měsíci +4

      Silent Alarm might be my favorite album of the entire decade, but I still would give AOTY to Illinoise, it's just musical perfection and groundbreaking in every possible way.
      But yeah, Bloc Party is fucking amazing, Matt Tong on drums fuckin BROUGHT IT on their first two albums.

    • @therealninjastar
      @therealninjastar Před 15 dny

      @@danielgray65Silent Alarm is my second favorite album right behind AM’s Whatever People Say I Am, nothing beats that for me

  • @Brandonhatesmayo
    @Brandonhatesmayo Před 10 měsíci +4

    2009 was a big music for me graduating highschool and I do love MPP.

  • @TreelessPlain
    @TreelessPlain Před 2 měsíci

    MPP was the one for me. It came out during my junior year of high school. It’s the one that opened my eyes to all the amazing current music I was missing out on. It truly changed my brain chemistry.

  • @thenerdyman2001
    @thenerdyman2001 Před rokem +377

    Can’t wait for Fantano to rank Pitchfork’s AOTY’s of the 90s

    • @-Scrapper-
      @-Scrapper- Před rokem +6

      Shoo

    • @lopezfan24
      @lopezfan24 Před rokem +144

      Same. 1890’s music is so underrated.

    • @no-vk2qe
      @no-vk2qe Před rokem +12

      ​@@lopezfan24 Jay Z js a rapper from the 1890s btw

    • @kebab_boi
      @kebab_boi Před rokem +1

      Bro I see you in every music ig comment section lmao

    • @echosmyron1278
      @echosmyron1278 Před rokem +3

      How would that work? They deleted whatever 90s lists they made from their archives. I think that they only ever published a small list in 1999.

  • @anotherbookreview9903
    @anotherbookreview9903 Před rokem +5

    MPP and Silent Shout both sound really really good. Ditto FF.

  • @jacktheripper6909
    @jacktheripper6909 Před rokem +4

    great video idea

  • @theyreMineralsMarie
    @theyreMineralsMarie Před rokem

    Can't believe you mentioned Wolves in the Throne Room. I feel so seen.

  • @Ultamik3y
    @Ultamik3y Před rokem +33

    AOTY 2002 is undoubtably Geogaddi by Boards of Canada for me

  • @philippboetcher9959
    @philippboetcher9959 Před rokem +20

    The rapture were amazing, crazy energy, them and the Walkmen were both super energetic driven albums, genre defying!

    • @UndercoverNormie
      @UndercoverNormie Před 10 měsíci +1

      That's what I'm saying. I used to love both of those albums

    • @ashtheviking5007
      @ashtheviking5007 Před 7 měsíci

      I always felt like the rapture was a bit of a ripoff of public image ltd. Felt the same about Interpol and gang of four. 🤷

  • @grasseaterrr
    @grasseaterrr Před 5 měsíci +5

    MY album of the years for the 2000s decade.
    2000: Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven - Godspeed You! Black Emperor
    2001: The Glow Pt. 2 - The Microphones
    2002: Songs for the Deaf - Queens of the Stone Age
    2003: Velocity: Design: Comfort. - Sweet Trip
    2004: Madvillainy - Madvillain
    2005: Pink - Boris
    2006: Donuts - J Dilla
    2007: Untrue - Burial (sorry In Rainbows)
    2008: Hi everyone, Nice to meet you. We Are Midori - Midori
    2009: World is Yours - MASS OF THE FERMENTING DREGS

    • @Mickey_Barho
      @Mickey_Barho Před měsícem

      Yes, Mass of Fermenting Dregs. And I'm also agree with almost all your choices :)

  • @jwht8424
    @jwht8424 Před 7 měsíci +2

    Fantano putting Illinois in the S category kept me subscribed.

  • @richteffekt
    @richteffekt Před rokem +6

    2000 Relationship of Command - At the drive in
    2001 tied: Lateralus - Tool / Leaves Turn Inside You - Unwound
    2002 Tied: El Cielo - Dredg / Original Pirate Material - The Streets
    2003 - Effloresce - Oceansize
    2004 - The Libertines / College Dropout
    2005 - The Back Room -Editors
    2006 - Whatever People Say I am (...) - Arctic Monkeys
    2007 - Neon Bible - Arcade Fire
    2008 - The Seldom Seen Kid - Elbow
    2009 - Crack The Skye - Mastodon

    • @YesNo-yl6ws
      @YesNo-yl6ws Před 11 měsíci +1

      Great picks

    • @danielgray65
      @danielgray65 Před 11 měsíci +2

      That Arctic Monkeys album fuckin slapped... that and Brand New's The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me for 2006
      Hip Hop was Food and Liquor by Lupe Fiasco... one of the best debut albums in hip hop history... Lupe is a fucking alien on the mic

    • @SwitchbIade
      @SwitchbIade Před 10 měsíci

      Good takes except for neon bible

  • @matthewchrist9082
    @matthewchrist9082 Před rokem +6

    Bluish still puts me on a beach in a dream

  • @thespymachine0
    @thespymachine0 Před rokem +11

    I've been watching you since you first started, and being reminded of that Fever Ray pick for 2009 AOTY just brought me back. Fantastic album.
    I'm so happy that you're still doing this stuff today.

  • @UndercoverNormie
    @UndercoverNormie Před 10 měsíci +2

    Wow man, I haven't thought of The Microphones in a looooong time. That was a fantastic album kind of in the same territory as The Books - The Lemon of Pink. Meanwhile, I just listened to that Rapture album literally yesterday. I agree I don't like it as much as I did as a twacked out teenager but liked it much in the same vain as Chk Chk Chk, Cut Copy, and all the other dancy bands at the time. Interpol over QotSA Songs for the Deaf is ridiculous. Enough on that. I would give Strawberry Jam AOTY long before Person Pitch. I like Panda, but I never understood the insanely high reviews back then. Fleet Foxes debut, I never stop listening to it. I never get tired of their albums or performances. And Merriweather is a no-brainer. Let the normies into the Animal Collective universe. Pretty good takes from the Meloness.

  • @k____b
    @k____b Před rokem +1

    Merry Christmas melon.

  • @ciaran1988
    @ciaran1988 Před rokem +3

    Surprised 'You Forgot It In People' wasn't given a mention.

  • @RoweReviews
    @RoweReviews Před rokem +5

    love this idea, its fun hearing your thoughts on older albums

  • @Ducaso
    @Ducaso Před 11 měsíci

    I agree with your assessment of Echoes all this time later. I’d go so far to say that it’s just fine.

  • @shemsuhor8763
    @shemsuhor8763 Před 11 měsíci +4

    I have that Animal Collective album cuz Sputnik ranked it giga high yeaes ago and I thought I'd order it and give it a shot. Never really "got it". But it was interesting. Haven't listened to it in probably 7 years at least. Might have to spin it.

    • @masemoney666
      @masemoney666 Před 8 měsíci +1

      did you give it a spin? it's a real grower. i think it's just wonderful.

  • @josephpickard3108
    @josephpickard3108 Před rokem +4

    The fear that Ryan Dombal instilled in bands was very real. The AA Gill of college critics

  • @andrewferris8169
    @andrewferris8169 Před rokem +64

    Neighborhood #1 alone makes Funeral deserve an A Tier atleast

    • @brycedavis9458
      @brycedavis9458 Před rokem +16

      Wake Up, Rebellion, Neighborhood 4 are all absolutely fantastic

    • @jackleslie7391
      @jackleslie7391 Před rokem +2

      @@brycedavis9458 Even Neighbourhood 2 and 3, every cut on there is fantastic

    • @ChristofEightyEight
      @ChristofEightyEight Před rokem +9

      I think it's easy to hate on Arcade Fire because of their poor run of recent albums but tbh they single handedly made indie mainstream for 2004-2012 or so. I prefer The Suburbs but if there's one album that defines nostalgia for me in the 2000's it's funeral

    • @johnbeck2837
      @johnbeck2837 Před rokem +1

      ⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@ChristofEightyEight arcade fires great, they always got the critical appraise and have a good fan base, but single handedly? That’s a bit much, there were a lot of great bands pushing indie to the forefront, in fact I would say arcade fire was the laughing stock of indie back then unless you got it, mainstream music loving people didn’t care for them and would borderline tease you if you liked them, now that changed since then but during the time I saw it

  • @Electrohead92
    @Electrohead92 Před 7 měsíci

    I’d be curious to see your thoughts on all the albums that Pitchfork gave a perfect 10 upon release. Some choices are pretty interesting like Source Tags & Codes.

  • @stuartdunlop8834
    @stuartdunlop8834 Před rokem +2

    15:43 - You made me jump and nearly made me throw my breakfast across the room, thinking there was an impostor in the house. Kudos to you, sir.

  • @justbaz7471
    @justbaz7471 Před rokem +33

    I’m surprised that Deathconsciousness by Have A Nice Life didn’t get a mention for 2008, it’s one of the greatest albums of all time imo and stands out from all the other sounds at the time

    • @SquidoKiddo
      @SquidoKiddo Před rokem +2

      I'm with ya there, great album

    • @merely_aida
      @merely_aida Před 9 měsíci

      +++

    • @hugjass6585
      @hugjass6585 Před 7 měsíci +3

      i like that album a lot but i also feel like it didn't age well

    • @waspswarm870
      @waspswarm870 Před 7 měsíci +1

      ​@hugjass6585 what about it didn't age well to you im genuinely curious because i think it holds up as an all time great

    • @ghxztpxppglv33
      @ghxztpxppglv33 Před 5 měsíci +1

      @@hugjass6585it aged very well lmfao most blackgaze copies it

  • @Progger11
    @Progger11 Před rokem +22

    My personal fave of 2001 is Tool's Lateralus, but the Microphones album is a close second. I also really liked Behind The Music from that same year, my personal favorite Soundtrack of Our Lives record.

    • @joeyb4766
      @joeyb4766 Před rokem +3

      Solid choice. Blackwater Park for me!

    • @Journeyman2585
      @Journeyman2585 Před rokem +3

      ​@@joeyb4766Damn, I forgot that also came out in '01. What a good year for music.

  • @bronzeageperfumer5494
    @bronzeageperfumer5494 Před 11 měsíci +1

    That Arcade Fire is great and I can see why it’s their pick but I feel like the 2004 AOTY is From A Basement On The Hill

  • @oogi14
    @oogi14 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Was fun hearing pitch forks anime of the year!

  • @unhelpfulrevelations7989

    Always fun to hear Anthony talk about music from prior to his reviewing days

  • @ItsSomeDeadGuy
    @ItsSomeDeadGuy Před rokem +60

    Shitting on Funeral is a trendy take these days but I think it's deeply moving and wonderfully constructed. The fact that it's "aged poorly" in relation to the zeitgeist is more of an indictment of the zeitgeist than on the record itself lol

    • @_moonmoth
      @_moonmoth Před rokem +6

      It pretty much defined the sound of that era. So many bands and songs that were basically following in its footsteps

    • @BigOwl51
      @BigOwl51 Před rokem +3

      @@_moonmoth influential≠good

    • @ginahaney7365
      @ginahaney7365 Před rokem +1

      Am I weird for liking suburbs more

    • @TheZenomeProject
      @TheZenomeProject Před rokem +3

      The hate will die out eventually, I think. Also, Fantano still praises this record and the other two big ones, Neon Bible and The Suburbs, to this day. I don't think that's changed.

    • @Jezzascmezza
      @Jezzascmezza Před rokem +4

      I don't understand the claims of it aging poorly. I think it still sounds amazing, and the backlash is probably just because Arcade Fire have fallen off in more recent years (I still love Reflektor, but their two most recent albums are definitely their two worst).

  • @tameimpala37
    @tameimpala37 Před rokem

    It has taken a bit of time but I am following Anthony more and more.

  • @EricRodriguezJ
    @EricRodriguezJ Před rokem +1

    I really enjoy these videos. Keep it up Anthony

  • @garrettmckellar
    @garrettmckellar Před rokem +59

    Funeral is almost solely responsible for the decade long trend of whoa-oh indie rock choruses.

    • @jorgekech
      @jorgekech Před rokem +4

      nah Kid A was responsible

    • @biglmaowski6509
      @biglmaowski6509 Před rokem +11

      nah Kid B was responsible

    • @vegamode8706
      @vegamode8706 Před rokem

      @@jorgekech ... huh?

    • @jorgekech
      @jorgekech Před rokem +3

      @@vegamode8706 Kid A was the most important album of 2000s ..

    • @vegamode8706
      @vegamode8706 Před rokem +5

      @@jorgekech Right, I just don't think it had any influence at all on the whoa-oh indie rock chorus trend. Radiohead never used that. I agree with the original comment which is that Arcade Fire started that trend. Particularly with "Wake Up"

  • @Poetic9
    @Poetic9 Před rokem +94

    Illinoise = 10! Would love to see a Sufjan worst to best, Anthony.

    • @kvothe9933
      @kvothe9933 Před rokem

      Although I do prefer suburbs that feeling of listening to the overwhelming opening of funerals is unbeatable

    • @bothquickanddead
      @bothquickanddead Před rokem

      ​@@kvothe9933 I also love their live energy at this time - with some members literally putting on helmets during songs like "Laika" to play percussion on everything on-stage, including each others' said helmets

  • @Santiago.--
    @Santiago.-- Před rokem +82

    ILLINOIS BEST ALBUM OAT

  • @ciaranwright4361
    @ciaranwright4361 Před rokem +42

    Persons Pitch hate is nuts

    • @ciaranwright4361
      @ciaranwright4361 Před rokem +4

      Agree better 2007 albums but its still a masterpiece imo

    • @llucsimon418
      @llucsimon418 Před rokem +11

      It's not a bad album but it is utterly ridiculous to put it as AOTY when it's not even the best album by Panda Bear THAT YEAR lol, and it's not close. To me, Strawberry Jam is one of the best albums of the century so far, while Person Pitch is maybe top 10 that year.

    • @ciaranwright4361
      @ciaranwright4361 Před rokem

      @@llucsimon418 agreed strawberry jam is obviously the better album, but persons pitch is probably by 3rd fav anco album

    • @ciaranwright4361
      @ciaranwright4361 Před rokem

      @@llucsimon418 also sound of silver would probably be my 2007 pick

    • @cheeez9438
      @cheeez9438 Před rokem +2

      I think his take is completely disrespectful. It’s a unique record that fills me like a thicc drug. I absolutely love Person Pitch.

  • @oweb7754
    @oweb7754 Před rokem +18

    that person pitch opinion is criminal

  • @dinkusoninkus
    @dinkusoninkus Před rokem +155

    I’d love a ranking of animal collective albums

  • @salvatoresultana4058
    @salvatoresultana4058 Před měsícem

    I would love for Fantano to do his own album of the year series.

  • @slestertv6185
    @slestertv6185 Před rokem

    I actually guessed you would do that.

  • @ldjkfg
    @ldjkfg Před rokem +13

    Even though I'm a fan of 90% of the albums you pointed out from 2007 I still think person pitch is the best that year and actually the best animal collective album. Guess it's just the dub and sunshine pop fan in me.

    • @deangoranites2609
      @deangoranites2609 Před rokem +5

      Hearing him grill it like that was killing me inside lol

  • @petermahler853
    @petermahler853 Před rokem +28

    Here’s mine:
    2000: Lift your skinny fists
    2001: Discovery
    2002: Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
    2003: Give Up
    2004: Madvillainy
    2005: Illinois
    2006: Donuts
    2007: In Rainbows
    2008: Deathconcsiousness
    2009: Merriweather Post Pavilion

    • @billymessenger3982
      @billymessenger3982 Před rokem

      That's a good one!!

    • @becklanda.3642
      @becklanda.3642 Před rokem +1

      who hurt you

    • @archieglover5481
      @archieglover5481 Před rokem +1

      2000: since I left you

    • @vb2388
      @vb2388 Před rokem +6

      My List
      2000: KID A (Radiohead)
      2001: Vespertine (Björk)
      2002: Geogaddi (BoC)
      2003: Elephant (White Stripes)
      2004: Madvillany (Madvillain)
      2005: Illinois (Sufjan Stevens)
      2006: 10,000 Days (TOOL)
      2007: In Rainbows (Radiohead)
      2008: Dragging A Dead Deer.. (Grouper)
      2009: Merriweather Post.. (AnCo)

    • @Jacob-hv7jz
      @Jacob-hv7jz Před 11 měsíci

      W skinny fists

  • @kidrenegade8525
    @kidrenegade8525 Před 7 měsíci

    14:14 holy shot he’s right, in 2007 you had
    Neon Bible, FWN, Oracular Spectacular, HFAYTD? Ga Ga Ga Ga, Wincing the Night away, Graduation

  • @blinddig7525
    @blinddig7525 Před 3 měsíci

    i discovered illinois because of this video and it's album art
    changed something inside of me

  • @max-beckett
    @max-beckett Před rokem +123

    Anthony *finally* talking at length about Illinois has made this a wonderful start to the day 🥰

    • @max-beckett
      @max-beckett Před rokem +4

      (There was that video on another channel he’d recorded talking about it, but that was deleted years ago so this is all I’ve got xxx)

    • @MichaelTurner856
      @MichaelTurner856 Před rokem

      ​@@max-beckett yay!

    • @CaldoV1
      @CaldoV1 Před rokem +9

      This is the closest we're getting to a classic review 😔

    • @max-beckett
      @max-beckett Před rokem +1

      @@CaldoV1 agreed 😭

    • @Price_of_Fame
      @Price_of_Fame Před rokem +5

      I keep requesting it for a patreon review but it gets ignored even when it got the most upvotes one time ;_;

  • @WiloPolis03
    @WiloPolis03 Před rokem +38

    Fantano dunking on Person Pitch, finally another opinion I can put excessive and copious amounts of energy into hating!

    • @BrofUJu
      @BrofUJu Před rokem

      Dude I just checked this out, wtf is the production on this album? Just sounds absolutely awful.

  • @eeeeeeeeeddddd
    @eeeeeeeeeddddd Před 7 měsíci +2

    KID A IS S TIER STOP UNDERRATING PERFECT ALBUMS

  • @iceyroo
    @iceyroo Před rokem +58

    Kid A isn’t a S-tier album Melon?!?!

    • @joaocardoso6697
      @joaocardoso6697 Před rokem +33

      It’s right there in the name, kid A, not kid S

    • @gremlin1634
      @gremlin1634 Před rokem +2

      i just wonder what other 2000 album he would’ve chose as album of the year ngl

    • @angelothorpe15
      @angelothorpe15 Před rokem +8

      @@gremlin1634probably lift your skinny fists

    • @iceyroo
      @iceyroo Před rokem +2

      No Strokes but Interpol? Nah….

    • @jorgekech
      @jorgekech Před rokem +1

      @@joaocardoso6697 nah Kid A is a S

  • @alydanilo4229
    @alydanilo4229 Před 5 měsíci +4

    The Glow Pt. 2 is an dreadful beautiful album.
    Everybody would have to listening to it. It is too incredible.

  • @tameimpala37
    @tameimpala37 Před rokem +4

    TotBL is a devastating record.

  • @pf887
    @pf887 Před 10 měsíci

    OH MY GOD I CANT BELIEVE YOU SAID THAT ABOUT PERSON PITCH MELON. JESUS. THIS IS GONNA TAKE SOME TIME TO GET OVER.

  • @kamjamtv
    @kamjamtv Před rokem +1

    Thanks for the video Fredthony Kruegtano!

  • @damiankarras
    @damiankarras Před 10 měsíci +3

    Fleet Foxes is a masterpiece

  • @Andlovethebomb
    @Andlovethebomb Před rokem +4

    “And I’m a freaking Blood Brothers fan”

  • @wqnd
    @wqnd Před rokem +1

    your shirt is fire btw

  • @hamzarana4783
    @hamzarana4783 Před rokem +2

    Please do this with all the other decades of Pitchfork's AOTYs!!

  • @Felldohswrath
    @Felldohswrath Před rokem +44

    Illinois is one of my all time favorite records of all time. I've been listening to it since I was 14 and it's music has evolved with me and my experiences, and I credit that album to why I am so into experimental and avant-garde music nowadays (well, that and Mr. Bungle as well lol).

    • @GoodByeSkyHarborLive
      @GoodByeSkyHarborLive Před rokem +1

      is it really an experimental album?

    • @Felldohswrath
      @Felldohswrath Před rokem

      @@GoodByeSkyHarborLive Oh absolutely, just listen to track 3 or track 2, they are absolutely experimental

  • @tashmitkhan2853
    @tashmitkhan2853 Před rokem +14

    Sonic Youth tier list when

  • @noahboss9618
    @noahboss9618 Před rokem +1

    The Glow pt. 2 for 2001 when Vespertine came out that year tho ??

  • @kylev8926
    @kylev8926 Před rokem +1

    Man, I can understand where you're coming from with some of your takes. Interpol's album, while having strong songwriting and good productions, is incredibly derivate of its influences. And there's certainly an argument to be made for Funeral not aging well, if only because indie music shifted away from that overproduction in the 2010s and the band themselves releasing some uninspired music in the past decade.
    Where you've lost me is your opinion on Person Pitch. I adore that album, the repetition, the hypnotic acid-trip effect of it. Different strokes for different folks I guess but the repetitious beats are part of what draws me into its hazy drug-induced atmosphere.

    • @BrofUJu
      @BrofUJu Před rokem

      I checked it out and get what they're going for, but the production is just so out there and distracting. I get going for hazy and lots of reverb etc but..... don't get it

    • @SwitchbIade
      @SwitchbIade Před 10 měsíci +1

      Doesnt matter that TOTBL is derivative , it literally improves on all fronts compared to their influences.

    • @kylev8926
      @kylev8926 Před 10 měsíci

      @@SwitchbIade not even close

  • @epicjake354
    @epicjake354 Před rokem +37

    Turn on the bright lights has been growing on me immensely recently. I love the way the guitar playing sounds across the thing with how atmospheric it is

    • @ehvyn3661
      @ehvyn3661 Před rokem +4

      Absolutely agree! PDA's ending where it continuesly plays a b over and over with reverb feels cold as hell, but as they add in more instruments and fill the space it becomes such a warm yet atmospheric track. In my honest opinion it's the best track on the album!

    • @epicjake354
      @epicjake354 Před rokem

      @@ehvyn3661 PDA is one of my favorites but I think my top 3 are Say Hello to the Angels, Leif Erikson and Untitled, although I also really love Obstacle 1 and NYC

  • @sammo2560
    @sammo2560 Před rokem +11

    Wild that they gave Echoes AOTY over either of Ben Gibbards projects from 2003

    • @TectonicImprov
      @TectonicImprov Před rokem +4

      Between Transatlanticism, Give Up, and even the Home EP, dude was absolutely on fucking fire in 03.

  • @limpusshrimpus9810
    @limpusshrimpus9810 Před rokem +1

    Always gotta watch my boy fantano on 2x speed
    It only makes sense

  • @grandaddy0807
    @grandaddy0807 Před rokem +2

    I agree with the list. I missed The Microphones so going to check that out. Only thing I'd maybe change is swap Kid A and Illinoise. As a major Interpol fan I was also surprised they got AOTY, was a strong year of music.

  • @biddleeewho4181
    @biddleeewho4181 Před rokem +60

    Putting Funeral in B tier hurt me way more than it should have

    • @jb.3820
      @jb.3820 Před rokem +5

      I shed a tear. Or two! Fuck I love that album still.

    • @KayButtonJay
      @KayButtonJay Před rokem +2

      If only it was a good album :x

    • @sothis8900
      @sothis8900 Před rokem +2

      FR IK

    • @sothis8900
      @sothis8900 Před rokem +2

      @@KayButtonJay it is though LOL

    • @thefuturist8864
      @thefuturist8864 Před 10 měsíci +1

      It belongs there. AF have at least three better albums (Neon Bible, The Suburbs and Reflektor). There are those who still prefer Funeral and that’s fine, but it’s become far too fashionable to pretend Funeral was their best.

  • @michaelluciano1980
    @michaelluciano1980 Před rokem +66

    Room on Fire a much better album for the 2003 pick.
    Also, good news for people who love bad news is a great pick for 2004. Float on was on the radio constantly and beloved by everybody.

    • @SIDEKICKDUSTY
      @SIDEKICKDUSTY Před rokem +1

      Those are both definitely standouts for those years for me, too.
      I was surprised at the absence of mentions for Joanna Newsom (I vaguelly recalled her not being aoty on pitchfork, but Ys is a strong contender for album of the decade for me) and Jens Lekman, whose most celebrated output was during the 00s and I thought I remembered pitchfork being a big booster for (Night Falls Over Kortedala was the big one for me, but iirc You're So Silent, Jens was super popular)

    • @valeruano1636
      @valeruano1636 Před rokem +3

      good news is so sleeped on. i know that they went into a more mainstream route with the record, but is still incredibly solid and good times is such a killer closer

    • @michaelluciano1980
      @michaelluciano1980 Před rokem +2

      The rapture definitely has some Bangerz - house of jealous lovers is a great track. But if I had to choose between that or Reptilia? You already know.

    • @ciaranwright4361
      @ciaranwright4361 Před rokem

      Pitchfork at the time far to hipster to choose the modest mouse album, kind of agree with them though, deep cuts are kind of annoying on that album

    • @echosmyron1278
      @echosmyron1278 Před rokem

      Yuck, Modest Mouse really started their creative downfall with that album.

  • @vincentbatten4686
    @vincentbatten4686 Před 11 měsíci +2

    I found out about Radiohead because I confused them for the talking heads and bought OK Computer and Kid A. Best mistake of my life.

    • @kruggyy
      @kruggyy Před 11 měsíci +1

      Too many heads in music

  • @j.roseee
    @j.roseee Před dnem

    2000 - lysflath
    2001 - discovery
    2002 - songs for the deaf
    2003 - velocity comfort design
    2004 - madvilliany
    2005 - illinois
    2006 - the black parade
    2007 - in rainbows
    2008 - deathconsciousness
    2009 - mpp

  • @Driver8takeabreak
    @Driver8takeabreak Před rokem +7

    If Fleet Foxes has included "Mykonos" on Fleet Foxes album would that bump it up to S or A? Great album already, but Mykonos is one of the favorites from them.

    • @CL2-
      @CL2- Před měsícem

      The pitchfork review said their 2008 album of the year was the combo of Sun Giant/Fleet Foxes, so Mykonos should technically be included in their pick. Although I don't know if Fantano realized that.

  • @zachcaton8064
    @zachcaton8064 Před rokem +38

    How is there no mention for Vespertine or Discovery in 2001?? I really like The Glow, pt 2 but idk how it could possibly be an S tier when those two albums absolutely sweep it

    • @blargghkip
      @blargghkip Před rokem +12

      He has a huge The Glow bias (I get it tbh), watch his classics review. Tbh he probably saw the name and stopped thinking about other albums from that year

    • @lrba5524
      @lrba5524 Před rokem +1

      i don't think the point of this video was to name every great album that came out that year. i think if he agrees that an album was aoty, there's no where to put it besides S.

    • @jorgeortega6806
      @jorgeortega6806 Před 11 měsíci +2

      'absolutely sweep it' is an exaggeration, c'mon

    • @SwitchbIade
      @SwitchbIade Před 10 měsíci

      Glow Pt.2 is better than everything björk put out.

    • @samindumadusanka3149
      @samindumadusanka3149 Před 9 měsíci +1

      ​@@SwitchbIadeNo

  • @lukeizabelle2131
    @lukeizabelle2131 Před 4 měsíci +2

    I don't agree that today 20 years after, Funeral by Arcade Fire sounds dated. I've listened to it lately which I haven't done for many years and I was suprised how much I liked it more than I used to do in the past. For me it is a modern classic and the music is timeless

    • @drcider5255
      @drcider5255 Před 2 měsíci

      I agree. I hadn't listened to it ever until yesterday and even if the mixing on the vocals was a bit spotty and the lyrics weren't exactly mind blowing, the hugely varied, and grand sonic palette more than made up for in my opinion. As much as Madvillainy calls into question the "album of the year" title, Funeral is worthy of at least A tier I think.

  • @JapanoiseBreakfast
    @JapanoiseBreakfast Před měsícem

    15:34 - Finally for 2009 as we finish off the decade, we have the meme album, the cover. Yep, Merzbow - Pulse demon.

  • @GentlemanJunkie95
    @GentlemanJunkie95 Před rokem +15

    00 Kid A - Radiohead
    01 Lateralus - Tool
    02 Songs Fort The Deaf - Queens of the Stone Age
    03 The War in Errorism - Nofx (yes, really)
    04 Miss Machine - Dillinger Escape Plan
    05 Demon Days - Gorillaz
    06 Back to Black - Amy Winehouse
    07 Fear of a blank Planet - Porcupine Tree
    08 Third - Portishead
    09 Crack the Skye - Mastodon

  • @NickyStikes
    @NickyStikes Před rokem +38

    I used to think Arcade Fire’s “Funeral” sounded like an Indy Celine Deon album, I still do, but I used to too.

    • @jeremyc9593
      @jeremyc9593 Před rokem

      Okay, Mitch

    • @billhicks8
      @billhicks8 Před 11 měsíci +1

      is because Celine Deon = dramatic? because I can't see it going any deeper than that

  • @standardbrah
    @standardbrah Před rokem +2

    2004 should go to MCR's three cheers (my favorite by them) or kanye

  • @augenmaugen
    @augenmaugen Před rokem

    Pitchfork and reviewer Ryan Kearney still owe Cave In and the rest of the world a massage for their mindless treatment of the phenomenal album Jupiter. I wonder if Ryan has been able to enjoy the taste of ice cream ever since writing it.

  • @aschemusicreations
    @aschemusicreations Před rokem +37

    It's a shame Panda Bear gets shit on so much for the production style, because the ideas behind his music and the craft of what he does is incredible.
    If he were produced by Dre he'd be a household name.

    • @joaquin5929
      @joaquin5929 Před rokem +13

      As if animal collective aren’t like the most popular “indie alternative” band on the internet.

  • @DanDhaniels
    @DanDhaniels Před 11 měsíci +5

    Kid A and MPP = both exceed the S tier 😛

  • @coffee_mouth
    @coffee_mouth Před rokem

    Idea: Your top 5 songs/albums to form your very own Anthinity Gauntlet.

  • @ego3162
    @ego3162 Před 10 měsíci

    "You called me cerebral, I didn't know what that meant"
    - The Knife, probably