If You Detonated a Nuclear Bomb In The Marianas Trench (Just Fantasy, not science!)
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 01. 2018
- I hope everyone understood where science ends and fantasy begins?)
Thank's Armando Sepulveda, Fernando Arroyo, CGSOS LLC & Twize films for "The Big Wave" project (04:03 - 04:08) in this video.
Original footage: vimeo.com/222702871
links to their portfolio: vimeo.com/user2511802 , www.behance.net/arosdaf78a
What would happen if a nuke went off in the Mariana Trench? This is the Tsar Bomba the nuke that Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev promised to show the West during the Cold War 58.6 megatons of sheer unadulterated power with a subsequent blast wave that circled the globe three times. And this
is the Mariana Trench the deepest crack in the Earth's. Surface a canyon almost seven miles or 11 kilometers deep up to three miles or five kilometers wide and completely filled with water.
#eldddir #eldddir_ocean #eldddir_bomb #eldddir_disaster #what_if #whatif #marianatrench #nuclearbomb #nuke - Zábava
“Ferb, I know what we’re gonna do today!”
Um
Best comment ever 😂
Oh no why did I see your name now I’m just sad it’s gone again
Lmaooo
Memento Mori, my friend.
Geologist here, was about to rip this video a new one for having no factual basis, but glad the comment section has done that for me - actually makes me hopeful a lot of people don't fall for this bs
David R this was the funniest video ever. I think he was trolling us. I mean 12 magnitude Earth Quake😂
It's hopeless some dip shit Democrat like Maxine Waters will see this and be talking about it on CNN....and blaming Whites for it.
If you remember back from 1970-1990's the French did their testing of Nuclear bombs at this place, Mambo clothing did a full thing on it, and it's been in recovery ever since
Is it true that the asteroid that took out the dinosaurs created an earthquake of magnitude 13 ?
Nakor Z So that means half life 3 is confirmed ?
That kind of bomb could have little impact on Earth.
Change of orbit, tear apart the planet, are you high?
In reality you’d get a bang, some waves, and a shock you could feel in the ground a few hundred miles away. Maybe coastal people would feel it or people on islands. That’s it.
@@bobbyhill4118 Hahahh , funny
@@bobbyhill4118 would also probably get some radiation in the water that kills some fish, but in reality, doesn't harm the rest of the world at all, because radiation doesn't get affected by evaporation, and there would be no acid rain or nuclear fallout like some people think
@@piggy6801 Bro , whetever the bomb would explode , it would affect many people...
@@marioandrei1799 not directly if it exploded in the trench. The worst and only thing it would do is release shit loads of radiation that would kill fish like that guy above said
People watching this be like:
-Not on fullscreen
-scrolling through the comments
- on your bed or couch
You got them all right lol
the idiot watch
Wrong. I'm shitting right now.
Bro how
3 out of 3.
Me: Mom, can we get Kurzgesagt?
Mom: Honey, we have Kurzgesagt at home. Kurzgesagt at home:
Tous il fois bit à bas idée
Yes lol this channel is so annoying
Very underrated.
Science not fantasy!
What's that
Sounds like a new challenge for mythbusters!
Lol DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME (You probably can't but still)
InstantCake 😂😂😂
TheCrazyPotato teens
Alex Lazy i
Alex Lazy haahaha
It’s impressive how this became “fantasy” in an instant
When i saw the earth explode ... well i know it was another sensationnal bullshit .. like earth, born from hell, could die from a mosquito explosion, tsar bomb or not. i wasted some minutes of life watching this, and , wel, it was fun .
@Nurul Aini ??
@@Charlourson the title says fantasy lol
They state that it's just a fantasy video in the title
@@arknark When he first uploaded the video it did not say it was fantasy and received a lot of backlash for making it seem as if it was fact. It wasn't until Kurzgesagt released a video stating what would actually happen, that Ridddle edited the title of the video.
Kurzgesagt really demolished this man
Yeah
Y’all literally taking this shit too seriously. Especially 3 years later.
@@jbrown7063 Well he shouldn't have made the video then, later he got so ashamed by the negativity that he changed the title, this is a joke channel.
@@jonataspereira1691 First off, the man can make whatever video he wants and you don't know what's in the man's head and he most likely changed the title because you people failed to understand it was a joke. I also don't know if your eyes are working or not but the video has 242k likes to 74k dislikes so I believe a lot of people didn't have a problem with the video, most likely because they knew it WAS A JOKE. When the dude said 400-foot waves that alone was a sign that the video shouldn't be taken seriously. A feel like a lot of people knew it was a joke and you keyboard scientist took it way too seriously. No surprise tho, youtube comments have always been a shit stain.
@@jbrown7063 Dude, if this was a joke it was the worst joke I've seen in my entire life.
And considering his other videos, we can say without doubt that he tried to make a scientific video and ended up making scientific bullshit.
He changed the title a week after the backlash when other youtubers made videos debunking and blowing this channel up.
"Just Fantasy, Not Science"
**laughs in Kurzgesagt**
Luaghs in short?
Laughs*
@@whoeverrespondstomycomment6184 Kurzgesagt is a science channel who also made a video on this
@@notmalk_ HA, y o u a r e n o w g a y
@@RoxAS-RN nice
Kurzgesagt just made a video about what would actually happen, highly recommend that channel over this one
The Jiggler just came to this video because of that
me too. I am ashamed.
This channel probably isn't focused on factual science anyway. Just look at its clickbaity titles. Ridddle's reign of clickbait and false news/science must end.
This is the video that made me not believe a single thing in any of the other video on this channel. It's clear that everything is completely made up
lol
Its a joke
Yea same here
Read the title bafoon
@@Purpleshade29 the title was only changed after kurzgesagt debunked it
My IQ drops in every word this guy says,like "just fantasy,no science" just makes the whole thing
@toeff gaming literally everyone knows what what it means but ridddle only write fantasy not science like not to long ago
and still he get money , for you watching longer then 5 min
@@Sh4ngr1L4 I use AdBlock, and I'm here just to watch how stupid this grifter's claims are
That title change isn't gonna save this video from a dislike.
FrogRay big facts
A male watermelon as a pfp lol
It's about damn time this clickbait lord gets some karma.
What did the original title use to be?
still the same. but no "just fantasy, not science".
Ya, um...no. Surprised they didn't mention Godzilla as a likely side effect.
It did mention the entire destruction of Japan whereas Godzilla was barely able to destroy Tokyo.
Don't worry though, Power Rangers will protect us all.
Yeah, I unsubbed from this drivel.
Yes
ThePunitiveDamages Godzilla would literally be best case scenario with this.
The bomb wouldn't be powerful enough to shift our orbit significantly.
“Just fantasy, not science.”
A lot of that going around in 2021.
Remember when this video didnt have "fantasy" in the title until Kurzgesagt schooled him
Their whole channel is sadly like this :(
@@gormoth-5330 no the water pressure doesn't exist because god said so in my brain.
I'm going to give this video a thumbs up. Just fantasy, not an actual like.
(dislike)
Paul Fenton lol fake like 😂
A like is an actual like. What else would it be? WTF is with these terrible English comments getting lots of likes ?
@@CrusaderDom3 but he didn't give it a like?
@@CrusaderDom3 r/woooosh
Wow Cody and Kurzgesagt completely pulled this video apart. What a "science" video this is.
ScienceWithJames The title says "fantasy not science!" So IMO he gets a pass
Edit:
Title has been changed apparently
THE BLACK DRAGON
No, they changed the title after backlash... And people like you are being fooled.
DerpyBean wait really? Damn my bad!
Don't worry, if it seemed like I was being kind of aggressive that's because I decided to read this comments of this video and saw lots of people denying the title was changed and blindly following Riddle.
A fake science video made by a clickbait lord. Ridddle's reign of clickbait and false news/science must end.
Petition for kurzgesgat to launch a series called "riddle debunked" so that everyone he fooled can have a look at reality
Signed
IKR most of his viewers are equally dumb
@@AK-vj9uu this video is real like the flat earth. The only round thing is your MOM. As you can see i am very angry at you and you should apologize or i will cancel you on Twitter because you offended me.
✅
He has already made #1
This video: **Exists**
Kurzgesagt: *"A great place for our nuclear test!"*
Cool video idea but it's super exaggerated.
Probably the worst bit was the change in the Earth's orbit which is physically impossible according to Newton's laws, unless unbelievable amounts of mass were ejected into space (which didn't happen even when the Tsar Bomba was detonated on the surface). But here's the rest...
The Tsar bomba is 50 million tonnes TNT yield. The earthquake which caused the 2004 Boxing day tsunami (9.1-9.3) was an order of magnitude more powerful (for example you could expect a 9.0 and a 10.0 magnitude earthquake to release a 500 Million and 15 Billion TNT equivalent worth of energy respectively). The wave height for the 2004 tsunami was about 30m or 100ft at its maximum, not quite 400ft.
The effects of a deap sea explosion are minimal due water being incompressible, meaning it absorbs amounts of energy when displaced. Additionally the deep trench the explosion would be located in would likely absorb most of the shockwave energy, probably resulting in storm level waves, hardly "washing away South-East Asia".
The Earths crust weighs (very roughly) 250,000,000,000,000,000,000,000kg, suggesting a relatively small energy release would cause the convergence or divergence of two continental plates is fairly (extremely) bold claim.
Finally suggesting that will result in a chain reaction causing 12.0 Earthquakes is a bit off a piss-take. That's a 15 Trillion tonne TNT energy release per earthquake, about 300,000 times more powerful than your inital explosion per Earthquake. And apparently that will carry on for a month. From a single explosion.
Finally, punching the whole in the crust and causing a magma fountain?! Blowing through a few kilometres of crust is not going to happen anytime soon, sorry.
The earthquake that caused the 2004 tsunami was actually 26.3 Megatons, or a little more than half of the Tsar bomb
Dumb 10 year olds like this channel
I can tell you got an A in science..
haider12ization you're trolling right?
Actually a bad hurricane threw the earth .0001 degree off of its axis so it’s very possible for the planet to change orbit
this video is so absurd i was actually waiting for the guy to say "i'm kidding" at the end.
Yeah, I was checking the date to see if it was posted April 1st, but sadly no.
Yep, seems largely made up to me. Enough directed energy to move an entire planet out of the habitable zone? Enough, energy applied at the surface of a planet, to cause all the material of that planet to overcome a planet's worth of gravity? I'd say he pulled all his factoids out of his arse just to keep the video pipeline going.
It is true that Tsar bombas energy release would be comparable to big earth quake. Like say 8 to 9 richter scale, but in the video it would cause 12:s all over the world. Richter scale is logarithmic scale so it would be like 1000 times stronger, lol :) Also considering those tsunamis: Energy release in earthquakes are mechanical so it is more efficient at producing tsunamis than nuclear bomb, which release a big portion of its energy in heat and radiation, which just steams the water. So its no to all those megaubertsunamis all over the world. Rest of the earths crust puncturing hallucinations are just total b***s**t.
Yep it is.....it was painful to watch.
I was sceptical at best for most of the video but when he claimed a small bomb could push the whole world by any appreciable amount such that we would "fry" or "freeze" is ludicrous.
Imagine getting fact checked by a scientific bird and try to save face by saying it's all fantasy.
Isn’t that kurgegzast
Also, following up the “ Just Fantasy,not science” meme. Kurzgesagt changed there title to “ Actually Science, not fantasy”
I FIND THIS HILARIOUS 😂
dangit whyd u change the title, it was a good troll
Lol
Kurzgesagt debunked them
We do a little trolling
Everyone thought it was serious, so he had to make it clear it was a joke.
@@polaxs_x thats what made it a good joke
Science guys are roasting ridddle
kinda sucks that people eat this shit up. The likes to dislikes ratio is almost 3:1! How does that even happen. Global warming isnt how the world will end, it's if people who watch this unironically keep eating this up. Bummer, man
Kurzgesagt's video has been up for less than a day and already has 2m. It would most likely not reach a fifth of this one, but still.
Seriously, Ridddle and BRIGHT SIDE's reign of clickbait must end. This is where it starts to end.
A well deserved roasting. This guy did zero actual research and has no idea what he's talking about.
AMEN Kenneth B. I despise nothing more than BRIGHT SIDE, the Valnetinc group, and all those other shit clickbait channels blocking out actual content creators in the recommended feed. Change your Fing algorithm youtube! Also, ONLY THE 3% MOST INTELEGENT PEOPLE CAN SEE A "3" -> 769875426178998656789177267899 czcams.com/video/dQw4w9WgXcQ/video.html
Yeah, I don't think the planet would move out of orbit.
agreed the the energy would result in a wobble which the earth already has, but it is no where near the energy needed to move a planet... it is not even close.
To move anything mass has to be thrown in the opposite direction and i have hard to believe that the ocean would blast out in space
Lol
Jarely Jocose no shit
Everything here is just fantasy theories.
0:26 This guy said the trench is in the ocean...then proceeded to say its cOmPLeTeLy fiLlEd wiTh wAtEr
Like where the people in the Bikini Bottom is drinking water underwater
@@BerryWithAcneScar_2000 lol
I caught that too.
@@michaelveralrud5051 like, no shit ehh? Filled with water is it?
That statement made about as much sense as saying, "how much water is leftover in the pool of the Titanic, after it sank"!
"The ending results would result in a giant uranium pancake" I laughed LOL
You got destroyed by Kurzgesagt..
This guy just broke my bullshit meter.
sferrin2 ajahahahahahahahahhah
Yeah, but this still seems worth testing.
Same.. If one strong shake would set the entire system into doomsday
Then shouldn't this have already happened it is the ring of fire, there's constantly powerful earthquakes releasing more energy then a tsar bomba going off and not ending the world.
(By constantly I mean geological time)
Yeah, plenty of nucs have been blown up way out in the ocean, and some did create a surge but tidal waves that will destroy the west coast, Japan etc.? Yeah the bullshit flag has been raised.
Same thing. Even a 68 MT bomb is NOTHING compared to the sheer size of forces the Earth puts up with. The gravitational pull of the moon would have caused greater effects than this if this was such a weak point and/or tidal waves could be so easily effected.
The 2003 tsunami was produced by an earthquake that was estimated to be between 2.5-5 gigatons. That is approximately the global nuclear yield. And it STILL did not produced NEAR the effects described, even though the yield is 50x Tsar Bomba
I like to come back to this every once in a while, just to have a good laugh at the channel and some uncultured dudes defending it
Yeah
Wait.. it’s not a legit channel??? This video is pretty wack but I did like his other video’s.. I thought they were legit 😅
Do people actually defend this video?
@@zaknelthepony7124 well, a lot actually. Im sure you can spot some by just spend a few minutes in the comment section
uncultured dudes defending it? there's only kurzgesagt fans here who don't know what a joke is, it has to be completely exaggerated for them to know its a joke notice how around 20% of the comments are just people promoting kurzgesagt, this channels competitor
Patrolling the mojave almost makes you want to wish for a nuclear winter
1:15
Voice: "the water will reach 110 MegaPascal"
Video maker: That sounds small, lets add 6 zero's to that. 110 000 000 MPa. There.
110 000 000 pascals
@@safinsalt2265 yep, but they wrote MegaPascal
Lets also consider usual car tire pressure is 34 pa.
@@rajendraks593 no it isn't
@@rajendraks593 perhaps you meant psi. Pretty sure the conversion rate is significant between psi and Pa.
get roasted by a bunch of science birds lmaoo
Vinnie i love those birds though ❤
Vinnie They became suicidal
Sinta Sirait same
Ridddle's reign of clickbait must end. Let the dislikes flow.
Clearly this was going to be just a hypothesis i would have expected it
a magnitude 9 earthquake releases 475 megatons of energy, and he says a 50 megaton bomb will cause a magnitude 12 one.
This guys voice can only be associated with all the low quality no effort channels of the era of CZcams. I wonder how much they pay him.
I have a hard time believing the detonation of a Tsar Bomba at the point of the trench could literally blow up the planet.
Ghostwolf Declassified That's because it's an embarrassingly dumb lie
It's like the creator of this video has never heard of gravity.
Lies. No bomb is that suave.
Ghostwolf Declassified same here wtf
This video is fucking stupid. There is NO COMPUTER modelling or real testing to analyze what a Tsar bomba size blast would do in the Marianas Trench. Just youtube graphics and someone talking out their ass............
Kurzgesagt made a science version of your video lol
keep in mind that this video's title never had the "fantasy not science" part until up until just a few hours ago
Cody's lab too lol
Ridddle's reign of fake news/science topped with clickbaity titles must end now.
Damn he said big words, that means he's smart and absolutely not making shit up
Edit: I changed my mind, he said humans are no fools and we all know that's total shit
Talk about jumping to conclusions without watching the full video first
watch the kurzgesagt video about an explosion of the tsar bomb in the mariana trench.
at least they did the math and asked scientists
@@bananenkuchen2164 This is so annoying and I completely understand why CZcamsrs put disclaimers in their descriptions. Any dumbass with two eyes and 1 brain cells can tell through the entire video, it wasn’t meant to be serious. You guys literally just made it serious.
@@jbrown7063 yeah no, he changed all of that shit when he was debunked and called out.
@@jbrown7063 it was your just some 8 year old getting mad at random people
No scientists were harmed (or consulted) in the making of this video.
What would happen if Kurzgesagt detonated a nuclear science bomb on Ridddle?
A comment section full of "lol Kurzgesagt roasted u" on the original vid
We are the fallout
Finally there is the possibility that so powerfull an explosion at the location of an intelligence void will simply tear the channel itself apart! The fate of ridddles channel in that scenario is easy to see...
I would be very satisfied
Dislikes flow in, the likes drop, and the reign of Ridddle's clickbait will begin to end. Dislike now!
Recommendation: Let's recommend this after the Beirut explosion
Ik that was crazy I Sall that
In one of the vids I Sall you can see people and cars just get blown to dust
The Practical Gamers what?! From the Beirut explosion? Have a link?
No I sall on twitter
They said its a TNT but don't you thing it's a nuke or warhead
We had our first open ocean swim over the Marinas trench. Swells were around 10'. That day we learned to respect the power of the ocean. Mother nature can be unforgiving.
“Giant uranium pancake”
I almost spit out my food
"just fantasy not science" wtf was the point of this video then?
To disappoint you or if you like fantasies then this is for you...
To get 19 million clicks and counting.
What was the point of Harry Potter
People are saying they changed the title. Because apparently they weren't clear earlier that this was 100% fantasy based on a real bomb.
It wasn't "fantasy" when I first saw it, they initially tried to pass this off as legitimate science. It was changed to "fantasy" after they started losing subscribers because of the backlash, with people complaining about the grotesque inaccuracies all over. It's one of the reasons I stopped paying attention to this channel. I came here to see what people were saying about the much more scientifically accurate video by Kurzgesagt(which is obviously poking fun at this channel) dealing with this same scenario.
PSA this wasn't the original title. It didn't have "fantasy not science." Not that it matters but this tripe puts all your videos in a skeptical eye....
you caught that addition also huh? riddle is beyond shady.
darkwing dook i bet you're right but too late. He's been exposed.
i also noticed "fantasy not science"
I like boom boom.
I know, They are trying to combat the dislikes, like that will work.
Them nukes mariana trench
.
.
.
Godzilla emerges from the surface
A description of the end of the world accompanied by a delightfully, jaunty tune...
B.S. The Tsar bomb won't do this, Its too small of an explosion for the size of the earth. Its like saying that a firecracker exploded at the basement of the Empire State building will cause fires, roof collapses and mayhem on the top floors of the building.
A single spark from a cigarette or a piece of glass from a broken glass can cause a huge catastrophic forest fire... or achille’s heel.. whatever, i am confued.
Distant Bells that's different for some reason because of causation. It's rare even for the fact of the common amount of this. Lots of people smoke, like, millions, and to that only about a hundred forest fires are caused by that. One tsar bomb means the chances are very unlikely, this paired with the size of the Earth.
The Tsar Bomba also had is yield cut in half due to concerns the pilot wouldn't be able to outrun the bomb so if the full yield (110 Megaton) was used this would be very easy to achieve, even at half its output you are directing an immense amount of force at a strategically weak and fragile area of the earth
That is still incorrect as you are comparimg a general surface impact to a strategically placed impact. Think of the techtonic plates as the weakest spot on earth, somewhere where a decent enough hit can cause a chain reaction an impact on the surface would have to be substantialy larger to have the same efffect as it would have to penetrate 15km downwards whereas on the trench it has to penetrate far less as it is already so far down in comparison.
Man, well.....WTC7 got expl....ahem.....somehow destroyed by "fire" and "flying parts" ....sooooooo
Homie got so scared had to change the title
And also edit the video to say nothing would happen
From who
@@neoarmstrongcyclonejetarms9326 Kurzgesat, he made a video back debunking this one as being completly ridiculous regarding physics and math, so the author of this video seeing how bad the situation turned out to be, changed the title.
Jônatas Pereira oh ok thanks for the explanation
what's the original title ?
"So we decided to blow up the marianas trench"
Yeah
These videos are fun to watch, finally!
I love how confident this guy is like he's tried it over and over.
maybe he has
So a nuke can cause 400 foot tsunamis on the open ocean but a subduction earthquake can't? I don't think so. The effects of this scenario are WAY overestimated. Nukes are powerful to us, but are insignificant when it comes to their possible effects on the oceans or the tectonics of the entire planet.
For me it was a huge bullshit moment when he told us that nearly half of the world will be underwater ..
Even the power to destroy a planet is insignificant compared to the power of the force...
grantsdaman01 d
why do you think it`s insignificant?
energy of explosion is 58MT in TNT, this can be compared to 8.3-8.4(Richter) earthquake.
However, in wiki i found this: "...Using the conventional specific energy of TNT (4.184 MJ/kg), the above formula implies that about 0.5% of the bomb's energy is converted into radiated seismic energy. For real underground nuclear tests, the actual seismic efficiency achieved varies significantly and depends on the site and design parameters of the test"
In that case, seismic energy will be equal to an earthquake with magnitude 6.8-6.9(Richter).
But in video he said about very spesific place with good conditions, so i think effect can be much stronger.
upd: new continents and orbit change are fairy tales, of course
about new continent - not really. If it were to break earth crust, the pressure from within the earth outter layer is quite high, thus shooting out a lot of magma, which when cooled would form... well, not a continent sized island, but something like two madagascars at most
The logic in this 🤣
Sometimes I have no ideas what you’re talking about but I watch anyway cause it’s interesting 😊
I started laughing uncontrollably when he mentioned the entire planet would blow up.
This video is a bigger catastrophe than the Tsar Bomb at the bottom of the ocean.
cefarix I agree
This video made me so mad I’m going to write a novel of a comment proving it wrong
please do it, that shit was so bad it made my head hurt
The best part is the bs about the bomb ripping earth apart... like that must've been a joke that I'm not getting, it's ridiculous...
cefarix Actually I unsubscribed from Ridddle because he made such bullshit videos, but I am interested in the actual science.
This is what it’s like having anxiety. The amount of catastrophizing in this video is out of this world.
I died watching this video, my brain cant handle this much information..
....and then the earth splits completely in half and releases the CRAB PEOPLE. They look like people, but taste like crab.
I knew it!
I'll bring the zatarans for the crab boil. Lol
Scott Aveles mmmm crabs.
Clams got legs!
Thank god for butter and garlic....
Do your Research the deepest part of this Planet is the Space between my Wall and Bed whenever my Phone drops in it
Honestly this is just hilarious and incredibly depressing....And relatable.
Mine is 2nd place then.
This is just pure teenage laziness which is sad and depressing . No wonder older people hate on teens
Clarke Klein I know is a joke but joke like these is what make older people downers
Clarke Klein That Teenagers try to hard to get likes on social media that they'll make fun on themselves that only teenagers and young adults will find funny . While older people will consider it to be sad and pathetic that they just a read a teen making fun of themselves being lazy when is actually sad .
Wow thanks for the good thoughts just before bed lol.
These videos are making out days better
I dont mean to nitpick, but I've always heard a tzar bomba exploding that deep underwater wouldnt do much more than make some bubbles at the surface of the ocean
Yeah, it takes a lot of energy to really displace enough water in the ocean to cause a tsunami. A bomb (even this big) down in water that deep... I dont think it will do that much.
Kill some fishies
they'd be big bubbles though XD
Andrew Wilson extreme overkill fishing
Yep
0:00 - 5:18 Some stupid shit.
5:18 - 7:03 WTF Stupidity overloaded
Couldn't stop laughing
ori amram don't be scared
Nice animations though - who needs credibility?
Holy fk when he says that it could move us closer to the sun, my eyes literally widened.
This shit is so stupid xD
If it did anything it would increase or decrease the earths rotation. It will do nothing to the orbit.
I love your videos
This narrator is the guy in ur school who writes 12 pages of answer for a question of 4 marks
Basic intuition and reasoning tells me that a single nuclear bomb, even if it's the largest nuclear bomb ever tested, is not going to be capable of causing the largest tsunami in recorded human history by orders of magnitude.
We know that the two large tsunamis that happened in the last two decades were caused by earthquakes that released orders of magnitude *more* energy than the tsar bomba. Necessarily the tsar bomba would cause a tsunami orders of magnitude smaller than those tsunamis (if you could even call it a tsunami at that point). This "tsunami" would maybe cause the water to rise a few *inches* at shore (and that's probably still being generous), not hundreds of feet.
We also know that hydrogen bombs that were only about 10 times less powerful than the tsar bomba were tested underwater on multiple occasions. If the tsar bomba would cause a wave crashing on shore across the entire Pacific hundreds of feet high, why wouldn't have these ones caused waves tens of feet high all across the Pacific? They in fact caused no noticeable waves accept on islands that were within tens of miles of the detonation.
TL;DR shits all retarded
Edit: God dammit, I wrote this outraged comment after pausing way too early in the video. Clearly this is a farce. Anyways I gotta go, I have a very strongly worded letter to the editor of The Onion I need to complete.
OK
Exactly. This is nonsense. The pressure at this depth would keep most of it under control.
It should also be noted, we detonated numerous nuclear bombs - while not as large, still very powerful - underwater without so much as any tsunamis whatsoever forming.
MacK Olives except we’ve tested Hydrogen bombs underwater. And water pressure did have an impact. Yes it make a massive spout... but little more. Nothing globally impactful
thank you!
Hey dog ran some basic numbers, biggest underwater nuclear detonation was 30kt ( en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Underwater_explosion#Deep_nuclear_explosions ), but most were under 20kt. Minimum yield of the Tsar was 50Mt with a maximum of 100Mt. At minimum the Tsar was 2500x more powerful and at maximum 5000x more powerful. Even if the wave was only something like 4 inches (.25 feet) at a 20kt blast, thats anywhere from a 625 - 1250 ft wave from the Tsar. Spooky big. Actually just looking up "do deep nuclear explosions create waves" in google yields a bunch of well cited easy reads on it that state that there are, in fact, no waves produced from such a blast, rather just a bunch of hot water left over ( what-if.xkcd.com/15/ ).
Edit - links are now clickable
"I hope everyone can understand where the science ends and the fantasy begins" -the description.
Bruh when DID the science begin?
When the planit moves thousands of miles across space and blows up. Like it was made out of legos and it got dropped
Lol these guys honestly believe that their viewers are idiots
It began from "why"
It didn’t. And by that logic we could assume riddle’s videos are just stuff he makes up.
@@elysannes7133 planet*
The permanent winter sounds like a snowpiercer pilot episode.
Man u have so good vodiče it's so relaxing to watch how u talking about space earth so cool
Dude your giving North Korea a damn instruction manual
Finn McManus They don’t got the same WiFi as us, so no they can’t get the manual.
Finn McManus its ok.. let them do it.. this video probably made to fool kim jon un.. hahaha.. full bs
True
yes they can, they have access on other country such as china so if china send this demo it would be possible for them to make a plan lols
nah don't worry, the bomb they are making is less powerful than the us and russia is created during cold war (around 1 hiroshima sized bombs). and getting out of the orbit by that bomb is very unlikely
I could make a whole series of videos about all the unscientific things said in this video.
I would watch a whole series of videos about all the unscientific things said in this video.
Plz do.
I implore you to make this series!
you were the first person i thought of when i noticed this video is full of untrue and blatantly false info, lol. seems all too similar to the flat eathers
He was talking about a specific isotope when he said Uranium half life, no such thing as a magnitude 12 earthquake, etc, etc
wow that's a great what if sir
This is SO interesting!!!!!!!
I like how you guys change the title when people started debunking this
well people keep bitching so...
@@sarahdrakengard9438 and they pussied out lmao spineless crooks
What was title
@Donnie Pendleton that's about over to top.go vegan
@@1A_B_C1 it used to not include (Just fantasy, not science)
Raise your hand if you're here because of Cody's Lab or Kurzgesagt - In a Nutshell debunking this fool today!
Wait Cody's lab did too, link? ( I tryed to find it)
ItsLasnAz✋ I came from Cody's lab
It's called "Atomic Bomb Deep Under Water?" and was launched this morning.
he got so debunked he changed the title of his video lmao
It's here: czcams.com/video/eyupkrpm1oc/video.html
Oooohhhh, I don't know....it sounds like a cool experiment. I'm in.
Him: Nuclear Winter, Tsar Bomb, Acid Rain, Earthquake, Volcano And Tsunami
The Music In The Back: Its A Wonderful Day
I'm guessing the title was changed.
It was, trying to play it off as if they weren't trying to be factually correct
Wht was the first title?
@@enchangfortes2054 didnt include the (Just Fantasy, not science!) part
@@enchangfortes2054 the first title was "random what if video"
Yes, it was because this video is completely fake.
So kids...don't play with atomic bombs
Laheeb Station more like hydrogen bombs
B-B-BUT MUM
They use the orbital canon in GTA. That's close enough.
Darn
cookie
this is most interesting science fiction video ever seen.million miles away from reality
Sounds like Tsar Bomba is a neutronium bomb instead. If you're trying to validate the overall explosive strength.
You must be high if you think that a nuclear bomb can cause this kind of damage.
As much of a joke of this video is
Still
The Tsar Bomba is no mere nuclear bomb
It completely dwarfs any other nuclear weapon to date
TheWolfy yeah not really. A single trident missile could do much more damage. The tzar is incredibly outdated and dosent really pose a threat compared to modern MIRVS
Memo Supremo I hope so lol. I don't feel safe knowing that the 3 biggest countries in the world hate each other. This bomb Russia has isn't a thing I should be worried about? Even it the us or China had it? I'd still be in danger
And i am pretty stoned right now
Here's the math good sir for why you are incorrect
50 megatons TNT =
154298001628803936 lbs
.
The earth weighs
.
13,170,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 000 lbs
.
The bomb is
.
1.17158695*10^(-10)
.
Or
.
0.000000000117158695% of the earths mass!
.
DO YOU THINK SOMETHING SO RELITAVILY SMALL WOULD MAKE A REAL, noticeable DIFFERENCE???
.
NO!
.
*cough *cough kurzgesagt made a video on it *cough *cough bascically debunked you
Prabhav Sthapit I’m pretty sure this didn’t have to be debunked it’s pretty clear lmfao
Let the dislikes flow through this clickbait lord.
nice idea u make sir
If a nuclear bomb did this much damage, we would be swimming with the fishes, literally.
Friendly reminder that before Kurzgesagt video, this video didn't have "(Just Fantasy, not science!)" in the title, nor " I hope everyone understood where science ends and fantasy begins?)" in the description.
They tried to pass this as legitimate science, and I remember downvoting it months ago.
it was there before but because other small youtubers roasted him
It was there, and science birds mocked it by putting "Science not fantasy"
No the internet/physicist debunked him before other youtubers did
So this is why north korea been droppin bombs in the ocean... oh shit
Their nukes are nothing but just a glorified bottle rocket experiments that can't even reach anything but their own.
L XUSTXN no he's testing the nukes
How?😑
"We'll next be treated to" cracked me up.
This is like when you are getting ready to leave the store and mom sees a friend…
so wrong it's painful (comment was made before uploader got called out and changed the title to look less stupid)
Mart j shut up your not a rocket scientist so what do you think you know about that.!.!.
More than you
LaBorah Crawford What does being a rocket scientist have to due with things you learn in high school?
Well how do you know it's wrong explain?
Here's a pretty good explanation of what would happen from this website "what-if.xkcd.com/15/" Here it is for you lazy people:
"The explosion at the bottom of the Mariana Trench will create a quickly-expanding spherical cavity of hot steam. To figure out how big it gets, we can try a formula from the 1971 paper Evaluation of Various Theoretical Models For Underwater Explosion:
Radius=(34π)13(40%×53 megatons of TNT Mariana Trench pressure+1 ATM)13≈580 meters
The bubble grows to about a kilometer across in a couple of seconds. The water above bulges up, though only slightly, over a large area. Then the pressure from that six miles of water overhead causes it to collapse. Within a dozen or so seconds, the bubble shrinks to a minimum size, then ‘bounces’ back, expanding outward again.
It goes through three or four cycles of this collapse and expansion before disintegrating into, in the words of the 1996 report, “a mass of turbulent warm water and explosion debris.” According to the report, as a result of such a deep-water closed bubble creation and dissipation, “no wave of any consequence will be generated.”
That “turbulent warm water” is actually quite substantial. The rising column of heat creates a hot spot in the ocean-many degrees warmer than the surrounding water-that lingers for some time.
Earlier this year, Severe Tropical Storm Sanvu passed over the Mariana Trench. The column of deep, hot water from our nuke could conceivably have been enough to strengthen it into a typhoon, much as the deep warm waters of the Gulf of Mexico’s Loop Current sometimes cause hurricanes to rapidly intensify. In addition to the heat energy from the water, Sanvu could whip up a spray containing fallout from the blast, and approach Iwo Jima as a radioactive whirlwind.
Of course, that’s getting a little far-fetched. In the absence of an improbable typhoon interaction, the overall effect of the bomb isn’t quite as dramatic as Evin might have imagined..."
It's not April 1st yet.
poorly not, its s***t
Andre Leonhardt shoot?
Damnnnnn
Me: eating breakfast (I’m Filipino by the way)
Government: Launching the bomb
Me: Falling in to the depths of earth because of the hole in the floor
I watched another video about this and it said detonated a nuke would literally do nothing. The pressure down at the bottom is so intense that it negates the explosion seconds after it happens. And the amount of energy needed to cause any tectonic plate movement would be beyond any nuke that we or any country has in its arsenal
Video directed by Michael Bay
Of course
Michael bae
Seems more like his ultimate lucid dream...
Kurzgesagt debunked this video
Let the dislikes flow.
And codys lab
Last pic was really relevant 😂
Nice ending with None-But-The-Un waiting to pull the trigger.