Massachusetts - I Started A Joke (Live) The Bee Gee's

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 20. 05. 2012
  • A tribute to the great Robin Gibb
  • Hudba

Komentáře • 800

  • @bonnies4230
    @bonnies4230 Před 2 měsíci +17

    His voice was so emotional and unique. If I could only pick one Bee Gee it would be Robin. He was in a league of his own.

  • @beomsukim3929
    @beomsukim3929 Před 9 měsíci +9

    When Robin died whole world cried

  • @normapenado8612
    @normapenado8612 Před 18 dny +6

    Robin will forever be in my heart miss him so much his voice is amazing. 😢😢😢❤❤❤❤

  • @ApuganRiverside
    @ApuganRiverside Před 4 měsíci +25

    Today is 8 February 2024. I am 83. I still remember these songs and others about 2 or 3 decades old. I wonder the children of today can sing, recall their hits ten years on.

  • @felicitaserni8409
    @felicitaserni8409 Před 2 měsíci +23

    It breaks my heart whenever i hear their songs knowing they're all gone,only Barry still living. How much i missed Robin..😢😢

    • @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853
      @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853 Před 2 měsíci

      Asi es ..se fueron demasiado pronto los tres hermanos..Andy , Mauricio ,y Robinn. Que pena y que perdida tan grande D.EP

    • @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853
      @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853 Před 2 měsíci

      ❤❤❤❤

    • @felicitaserni8409
      @felicitaserni8409 Před 2 měsíci

      @@mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853 transfer to English. Sorry, don't understand your language.🥰🥰

  • @wendydubois3872
    @wendydubois3872 Před rokem +29

    People still to this day, hour, minute, month, are still leaving comment's about Robin. How much he was loved and missed. The world will never forget Robin. R.I.P songbird🐦🎶

  • @delliedeguzman1781
    @delliedeguzman1781 Před 6 měsíci +16

    Today is November 25, 2023. I'll never getvtired listening to Massachusetts and I started a joke. Wow what a beautiful voice. Rest In Peace our dear Robin. Also to Maurice which also has a bass voice. With the twins. They sound perfect plus Barry and so they got the best harmony. God bless Robin, Maurice snd Andy.

  • @singluna888
    @singluna888 Před 9 měsíci +19

    I love Robin Gibb. Beautiful.

  • @rasyhol
    @rasyhol Před 9 měsíci +14

    I'm here 2023 thinking how wonderful it was!

  • @mariajosecaldas3272
    @mariajosecaldas3272 Před rokem +19

    Robin your voice is inforgetable and YOU live on my heart

  • @corneliadalupang9680
    @corneliadalupang9680 Před 7 měsíci +9

    I'm in love in that song. Idol Robin...

  • @careforcaregivers
    @careforcaregivers Před 2 měsíci +22

    As I am recovering from stage 4 stomach cancer I have become hooked on the Bee Gees songs. Most of the time I put Massachusetts on loop. I know for sure that their music is helping my healing.

    • @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853
      @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853 Před 2 měsíci +3

      .Me alegro estes recuperandote .Has escuchado la Cancion de CAMINOS RURALES ES PRECIOSA .MUCHO ANIMO .UN FUERTE ABRAZO DESDE ESPAÑA MURCIA ❤❤❤

    • @MiguelPalacios-sv9dw
      @MiguelPalacios-sv9dw Před dnem +1

      Estas canciones llegan al alma y es buena terapia para el cuerpo ,te deseo pronta recuperación,Dios esta contigo.

    • @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853
      @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853 Před 18 hodinami

      @@MiguelPalacios-sv9dw Muy bonito tu comentario .es cierto tocan el Alma ❤️❤️❤️

    • @gilseialuz624
      @gilseialuz624 Před 7 hodinami

      Deus abençoe você, que recupere logo. Continue ouvindo as músicas dos Bee Gees ,são um balsamo,para o corpo e a alma.
      .Obrigada Bee Gees, por tudo que fizeram por nós. 😊

    • @careforcaregivers
      @careforcaregivers Před 36 minutami

      @@mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853 Thanks. I never heard of the singer before, but I am now listening to a music video that says Caminos Rurales ( MUSIC VIDEO ) Largo

  • @aroda8938
    @aroda8938 Před rokem +30

    I love beegees forever ❤️😍😍

    • @pauloopusculo1682
      @pauloopusculo1682 Před rokem +1

      MEU DEUS QUE LINDO AGORA SEI PORQUE SEUS O LEVOU PARA CANTAR ESCLUSIVAMENTE PARA ELE QUE SORTE PODER TER UM CANTOR ESCLUSIVAMENTE SÓ PRA VOCE

  • @dinahtshabalala8239
    @dinahtshabalala8239 Před dnem +1

    I'm so broken old and grey but when it comes to beegees I go crazy their voices the best I will love u guys foever missing u a lot I wish u were here❤❤❤❤thank u👏👏👏

  • @aishagswellnessinabottle2807

    Robin was perfect here! I have no words, he is just the best!

    • @ingegratz6014
      @ingegratz6014 Před rokem +2

      Zu

    • @fellysaguino3798
      @fellysaguino3798 Před rokem +7

      Yes Robin was perfect here I agree with you.He was healthy and gorgeous.

    • @davidfrye4091
      @davidfrye4091 Před rokem

      : AMEN :

    • @judymeunier6920
      @judymeunier6920 Před rokem +4

      I've listened to them from the 70s . Still love them.

    • @vvvvvvvvv11
      @vvvvvvvvv11 Před rokem +2

      @@judymeunier6920 ive done the same , never get tired of the emotions, warmth, texts and voices

  • @karendehring7245
    @karendehring7245 Před 21 dnem +4

    every single bee gees are outstanding singers

  • @violetaoafer7680
    @violetaoafer7680 Před 3 měsíci +6

    The song touches to the core. I repeated listen to beegees songs before sleeping and when i wake in the morning.

  • @alwayssme
    @alwayssme Před rokem +21

    the most amazing song, i started a joke, robin's voice was angelic i was probably like 12 or so when i first heard this i just turned 66 in july

    • @user-tz6bm9yg4k
      @user-tz6bm9yg4k Před 3 měsíci +1

      Я музыкт , но так только бог дает все могут петь и играть но здесь от бога

    • @hennyvanderkamp2791
      @hennyvanderkamp2791 Před 2 měsíci

      De Bee Gees for ever
      Op t.v. in Nederland.​@@user-tz6bm9yg4k

    • @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853
      @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853 Před 2 měsíci

      Anda..lo mismo pienso...No la conocia , la escuche por primera vez hace cuatro años y me dejo impresionada para siempre ...MARAVILLOSA ❤❤❤

  • @yordanybenitez7247
    @yordanybenitez7247 Před 3 dny +1

    Great songs , great song, they will never die. That music was and will be forever 🇺🇸

  • @bjarnestrands8381
    @bjarnestrands8381 Před rokem +19

    The Voice, performance, all. Robin Gibb was master of Voice

  • @penboyasgod6103
    @penboyasgod6103 Před rokem +13

    _I Started A Joke_ has a very special place in my heart. I so remember this hit from Winter through Spring, 1969.

    • @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853
      @mariaisabelfrutosinsa8853 Před 2 měsíci

      Y tambien en el mio❤ escuche esta cancion por casualidad hace cuatro y me marco para bien., Me gustaria la pusiesen en mi funeral❤❤❤

  • @patriciabrown8016
    @patriciabrown8016 Před rokem +25

    Robin’s voice is unique I never get tired of listening to him sing Maurice he’s beautiful and I love to hear him sing closer than Close and everything else and Barry you’re just wonderful keep
    Keep the Bee Gees going we love you guys your fans will always be with you and Andy

  • @jamesmontgomery9516
    @jamesmontgomery9516 Před rokem +5

    I remember hearing this song for the first time i was only 20

  • @johnsullivan929
    @johnsullivan929 Před 9 měsíci +9

    I always put Bee Gees at top of my groups in music, and here in 2023 no group has ascended to the throne & i am 86 years in music, as Band Leader, Trumpet player , Disc Jockey, etc.

  • @lorrainelevi7872
    @lorrainelevi7872 Před rokem +16

    Robin was my favorite Bee Gee, his voice was so unique.

  • @stellamarislapolla1406
    @stellamarislapolla1406 Před 2 lety +58

    Wonderfull Robin!!!!! Your voice get into my soul. Miss you. ❤❤❤❤

  • @360-Guy
    @360-Guy Před rokem +22

    The brothers Gibb the gift they gave to the world is timeless Robin Gibb such a gift to his brothers and the world all of the Bee Gees are a gift to music history ❤

  • @Cabmaker
    @Cabmaker Před rokem +5

    The Bee Gees were masters at there trade for sure

  • @casimirocarvajal4102
    @casimirocarvajal4102 Před 2 lety +32

    grandioso Robin!!! único,

  • @carolegordon876
    @carolegordon876 Před 11 měsíci +9

    50 years ago dancing in the high school gym ……..that’s where I am again when I just close my eyes and listen. Best time of my life.

  • @DimpleSimple11
    @DimpleSimple11 Před rokem +9

    Oh my..one of my father's favorite song...I miss him now😥😥

  • @davelivermore139
    @davelivermore139 Před rokem +11

    What a group! There will never b another like them

  • @rubyseballe7292
    @rubyseballe7292 Před 10 měsíci +19

    I enjoy listening BeeGees songs. Iam teary eyed as I remember 60s my youth!
    They are all gone now and what I have are their songs that I keepsafe. May they are all at peace now! ❤️🙏

  • @jeanninepowell5211
    @jeanninepowell5211 Před měsícem +3

    Robin what can I say ❤️ he was so talented and I loved his voice they'll never be another ❤️ RIP robin

  • @marleteavelinadeoliveiracu737
    @marleteavelinadeoliveiracu737 Před 11 měsíci +11

    Robin's voice got stuck in my heart...mind! Sth out of this world!

  • @mikeford-branch7859
    @mikeford-branch7859 Před rokem +11

    Yep just sheer Magic in his voice and singing THank you Robin thank you very much

  • @MartinaKelly-wj4ll
    @MartinaKelly-wj4ll Před 8 měsíci +4

    Song brings me back to when I was very young and starting out in life

  • @andyhansen4007
    @andyhansen4007 Před 2 lety +71

    Absolutely brilliant robin
    You’ve left such a beautiful legacy mate , nobody can sing like you did

  • @normapenado8612
    @normapenado8612 Před 18 dny +1

    It breaks my heart ❤️ too. Love them all , especially Robin. ❤️

  • @richardmackay5257
    @richardmackay5257 Před rokem +57

    Started crying 😢 hearing these old GREAT songs knowing these 2 wonderful singers/musicians men are gone...but DEFINITELY NOT FORGOTTEN ❤❤!!

    • @dianeh.4287
      @dianeh.4287 Před rokem +1

      I listen to him often. They are top singers in my book. 💙💙💙💙

    • @dianeh.4287
      @dianeh.4287 Před 11 měsíci

    • @brianseager6388
      @brianseager6388 Před 10 měsíci

      only one has gone barry is very much alive and kicking

    • @rickynaicker7313
      @rickynaicker7313 Před 10 měsíci

      Brilliant to the core, making today's music sound poor

    • @richardmackay5257
      @richardmackay5257 Před 10 měsíci +2

      @@brianseager6388 Yes Barry is alive. Both Maurice and Robin are gone but not forgotten 💕

  • @erikaeike1478
    @erikaeike1478 Před 2 lety +5

    Danke BEEGEES🎻🎻🎻🥀 was seid ihr für Könner 💞🎻🥁🥀

  • @mariondoyle9549
    @mariondoyle9549 Před rokem +3

    There is no who sings like Robin he just one on he own

  • @davidbb4053
    @davidbb4053 Před 10 měsíci +12

    i love robin, his voice is magical.

  • @Nannasrevival
    @Nannasrevival Před 2 lety +169

    Such a pure voice and now out of pain and with his twin Maurice. Both sadly missed but never forgotten. 🌹🌹

  • @guaraciramires9390
    @guaraciramires9390 Před rokem +9

    Beautyful 🇧🇷❤

  • @yueh-lanbaldwin2699
    @yueh-lanbaldwin2699 Před rokem +3

    wow what voice Thank you all

  • @shirinjim5375
    @shirinjim5375 Před rokem +15

    Aww what an incredible voice I love you Robin I play these songs every day RIP robin ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔

  • @californiadave2297
    @californiadave2297 Před rokem +11

    This is real music! Pure & Simple!

  • @jimmiecooper3230
    @jimmiecooper3230 Před 4 měsíci +6

    Now that is music i can listen to all day long !! Just beautiful !!

  • @AntonioTy-ww1tj
    @AntonioTy-ww1tj Před 8 měsíci +11

    Dios mio cuanto daría por tenerlos de nuevo y volver a esa época yoa mis 64 añosos recuerdo como si fuera hoy. Esas canciones q te llegaban al corazón!!! Cuanto daría para volverá verlos juntos a los cuatro. Nunca habrá otros iguales para mi. Ojalá Barry pudiera venir a la Argentina y nos cante y poder decirles cuanto se los extraña. HASTA SIEMPRE ROBIN. MAURICE Y ANDY. 😇😇😇😊 Bety

  • @user-zv5zv8so2o
    @user-zv5zv8so2o Před 9 měsíci +20

    One of the most talented groups of the 20th and 21st Century. The range of songs and written lyrics for other performers are legendary.

  • @elainedemers9394
    @elainedemers9394 Před 7 měsíci +2

    My favorite “I started a joke” with Robin of The Bee Gees.

  • @beckyhayob1557
    @beckyhayob1557 Před 4 měsíci +3

    I love you all. Thank you ❤

  • @geraldnovak5042
    @geraldnovak5042 Před rokem +3

    Just touches ones soul. Simple

  • @mariehelenemoal3816
    @mariehelenemoal3816 Před rokem +3

    Robin , Je t aime ! Tu as la voix la plus belle de tous les temps !!!!!!!!!!!!!😍😍😍🥰😘

  • @claudiamarcelarota235
    @claudiamarcelarota235 Před rokem +6

    Robin, You are unique. I' ll always remember You. Thank You.

  • @elainedemers9394
    @elainedemers9394 Před 7 měsíci +3

    I love listening to Robin.

  • @franciscacollsintes6462
    @franciscacollsintes6462 Před 2 lety +14

    Siempre oyendo tu voz 🇪🇸💕💕

  • @montserratcasanovasroca2102

    Robin Gibb, para siempre en nuestros corazones.

  • @user-zj7rz1ud2i
    @user-zj7rz1ud2i Před 10 měsíci +3

    Robin your a great singer we love you

  • @katewills9969
    @katewills9969 Před 4 měsíci +3

    LOVE, LOVE! Halifax, NS Canada

  • @davyd5629
    @davyd5629 Před 9 měsíci +4

    Never see another group like them again fantastic will be missed

  • @evaortiz7327
    @evaortiz7327 Před rokem +8

    Here I go again...'I Started The Joke' it's a great song, beautiful voice makes me feel nostalgic, sad but I love it, reminds of past feelings, places that I've never been before, kind of weird. Rest in peace!

  • @wendylee1813
    @wendylee1813 Před rokem +4

    This song makes me cry so much,was played at his funeral.

  • @patriciabrown8016
    @patriciabrown8016 Před rokem +4

    I love to hear Robin sing and the Bee Gees his brothers are great too Robin is so cute

  • @jelandineros2423
    @jelandineros2423 Před rokem +192

    Thank you for the music. You are sorely missed Robin. Your hauntingly beautiful voice made a lot of us cry, love and hope. Much love to Bee Gees!

    • @edisonlucas3107
      @edisonlucas3107 Před rokem

      Llm..mmmmmmm...mmmmmm.mmmmmm..mmmmmmm.mmm.mmm.mmmmmmmmmmm.mmmmm.mm
      Lm.mmmmmmm.mm..mmloolmmmmmmmmmmm.mmmmmmmm.mmm.mmmmmmmm...m.mm.mmmmmmmm.mmm....m.m.mmmmmm..m.m..mmmm...mlm.m.mm.mmmmmmmmmm...mm....lm.
      ..o.. Con

    • @edisonlucas3107
      @edisonlucas3107 Před rokem

      Mm...m..m.......m................ ...p......................o......lo....llp......omo..ol........

    • @edisonlucas3107
      @edisonlucas3107 Před rokem

      Ok mm mm mm mm mm o lo m mi mm mm mm mm ommmm mm mm mm mm mm l ll llm mm mm mmm
      L

    • @user-wd2iu1co1q
      @user-wd2iu1co1q Před rokem +5

      我が青春の時、美しい曲を ありがとう……あの時を 今鮮明です

    • @susansantapola
      @susansantapola Před rokem +6

      Oh spot on my friend. They are just fabulous x

  • @marianalins4192
    @marianalins4192 Před 2 lety +31

    Wonderful!! 👏👏👏👏

  • @barbaraforde9213
    @barbaraforde9213 Před rokem +85

    Robin always leaves me in awe when he sings. Gotta love this guy !

  • @bindraeliasm1032
    @bindraeliasm1032 Před 11 měsíci +2

    Robin i wish you were still here... Your voice: stunning

  • @OhFookinELL
    @OhFookinELL Před rokem +32

    What a voice. RIP Robin and Maurice Gibbs.

  • @ElenaBeatrizRistau
    @ElenaBeatrizRistau Před 26 dny +1

    Vozes divinas, perfeitos, são BEE GEES! Sucesso ontem, hoje, amanhã e sempre! Amo BEE GEES.Obrigada!

  • @lawrenceseow7252
    @lawrenceseow7252 Před 11 měsíci +3

    The Brothers Gibb are God's gift to the world 🌎 No formal training
    All natural talent

  • @sueduquemin7119
    @sueduquemin7119 Před rokem +10

    I love Robin singing this song. My sister wanted it played at her funeral so I played it for her. Miss you Anna ❤

  • @barbaraforde9213
    @barbaraforde9213 Před rokem +76

    Robin knocked it out of the park ! I love love love his voice. 💕

  • @tinagarvin6186
    @tinagarvin6186 Před rokem +5

    I love them still 2023 ❤

  • @tenorschofield
    @tenorschofield Před 12 lety +189

    Bravo, he was a true artist and sensitive person. May the Lord bless him and receive his beloved soul between His heavenly choir.We will remember him forever!!!!

    • @abuamindasuki
      @abuamindasuki Před rokem +2

      U u8

    • @tryy8365
      @tryy8365 Před rokem

      J you guys 🙏 you joy

    • @vvvvvvvvv11
      @vvvvvvvvv11 Před rokem +3

      well said John pretty nice for a true ´performer

    • @tenorschofield
      @tenorschofield Před rokem +4

      @@vvvvvvvvv11 🙏😇🎶music is the language of the soul

    • @tenorschofield
      @tenorschofield Před rokem +4

      Yes, is that Divine code God gave us all, in order to comunicate with Him, as well to do so with all his creation🙏🎶

  • @mariondoyle9549
    @mariondoyle9549 Před rokem +4

    Robin gibb u r incredible I just relax when I listen to u u help me though my stress and carm me down

  • @davyd5629
    @davyd5629 Před měsícem +1

    I started a joke is the best song of the bee gees for me rip

  • @user-yy3tr3jp7w
    @user-yy3tr3jp7w Před 2 lety +52

    這二首歌是歌迷們的最愛歡迎程度無以言喻, 自己也是 robin 忠實歌迷者, 畫面上重新連結一起的歌曲再次回到1997 年現場表演的實況, 感受到那種滿足感的氛圍一直不減, 目睹當時 robin 演唱時的神情記憶猶新, 特寫鏡頭微笑面對觀眾以示表達謝意, 第二首歌結束掌聲不斷此起彼落, 要不是他暗示樂隊伴奏繼續歌曲的連續, 熱情的歡呼聲欲罷不能;炙熱的二首曲子它的存在感不受時空影響仍持續著, 執著者會永恒懷念不已。

  • @thomashollinger1418
    @thomashollinger1418 Před rokem +265

    Such talent is rare. As I listen to these songs that I heard in the 60's I realized an age is coming to an end. I am 74 and the Bee Gees are all gone but Barry. Many groups have all gone away. Their only proof of existance are their songs. These are voices that will never create new songs. Thank you for what we have. The memories are awesome.

    • @dianeh.4287
      @dianeh.4287 Před 11 měsíci +16

      Yes I agree..I miss those awesome days of our kind of songs..

    • @JulioHernandez-sg8lf
      @JulioHernandez-sg8lf Před 11 měsíci +3

      Aaaa

    • @dannybreen8653
      @dannybreen8653 Před 11 měsíci +10

      Gone but not forgotten

    • @juliethomas8557
      @juliethomas8557 Před 11 měsíci +13

      BeeGees forever! Period!

    • @johnhart125
      @johnhart125 Před 11 měsíci +16

      We grew in a time never be repeatd,America in its prime, best cars clothes and oh, the music! The best of all in 60s and 70s

  • @user-up2er3fb9p
    @user-up2er3fb9p Před 10 měsíci +11

    One of the best groups ever .will always be in my heart

  • @bethzabepalomino411
    @bethzabepalomino411 Před 8 měsíci +1

    Bee GEES and Robin : The best!

  • @user-tb5fq3qx9g
    @user-tb5fq3qx9g Před rokem +5

    A great song to sing karaoke to.

  • @SylviaPryhitka
    @SylviaPryhitka Před 5 měsíci +1

    So much love to you and your family and Hope you are all all safe ❤❤❤❤❤

  • @musicloverrqmmusiccollection

    I really love all the songs of Bee Gees, Thanks for this uploaded videos

  • @donnaeast4845
    @donnaeast4845 Před rokem +7

    What a classic song.

  • @kylekevin3565
    @kylekevin3565 Před rokem +7

    Vibrato like no one I know, perfect Robin and Bee Gees

  • @shaykatz5648
    @shaykatz5648 Před rokem +10

    I LOVE ❤ YOU BEE GEES. Especially Robin's vocals. Thank you

  • @ellenpearljackson5219
    @ellenpearljackson5219 Před rokem +6

    Rest in peace Beautiful Soul you are now singing with the angels with your brother love forever and forever

  • @janemota2737
    @janemota2737 Před 2 lety +21

    ROBIN GIBB SORRINDO FELIZ RECEBENDO APLAUSOS MERECIDOSVOZDEANJO AMOOOO

  • @jennylim9026
    @jennylim9026 Před rokem +3

    I have always loved the Bee Gees snd all of their songs!!! It's so sad that Barry is the only one left out of the 4 brothers!

  • @rickynaicker7313
    @rickynaicker7313 Před 10 měsíci +6

    How can one not love these sweet melodies. R.I.P Robin, Maurice and Andy. Soldier on Barry, theres nothing more to prove. Love youll forever 💗 💓

  • @johnzoraian155
    @johnzoraian155 Před rokem +4

    Think about it, these guys had two incredible careers in two different era’s. Either one of which anyone would have killed for. No they weren’t the Beatles but they came damn close

  • @marinasepulveda5350
    @marinasepulveda5350 Před rokem +5

    Robin tu voz es única jamaz la olvidaré

  • @cindycorrell8861
    @cindycorrell8861 Před 4 měsíci +4

    Robin is my favorite singer in the group…what a beautiful voice…Wow…but liked Barry & Mo too but Robin had such a unique voice…I am 73 and loved them since I was 17….Jan. 2024

  • @elinakontoyiannis2539
    @elinakontoyiannis2539 Před rokem +12

    Unforgettable always in our hearts!!!

  • @aximusroh6453
    @aximusroh6453 Před rokem +35

    Loved his voice. It carried an eerie sadness which resonated with me. I always wished he sang more solos with the group. Rest Robbin Gibb, rest in peace!

  • @user-qg2jk6kj8l
    @user-qg2jk6kj8l Před 9 měsíci +1

    Songs never be forgotten

  • @mavilgapic7188
    @mavilgapic7188 Před rokem +2

    The Bee Gees Are the best And greatest music group the world has ever produced.

  • @gerryesguerra9371
    @gerryesguerra9371 Před 6 měsíci +2

    Two thumbs up to the singing icon...The Bee Gees