One of my favorite CZcams videos. Indescribably wonderful to hear so many intimate details about Utd Thirakwa Khan saheb. Also great that Pt Nayan ji imbibed so much from him.
I have watched this video so many times and still feel warm and fuzzy feelings from listening to these stories! However ... I would like to mention one thing. I believe that the assertion that Thirakwa-saheb had “not taught anyone” may be taken with a grain of salt. He seems to have had a number of disciples in both Bombay as well as Lucknow. These include Bapu Patwardhan, Narayan Joshi, Prem Vallabh, Sudhir Verma and others. It may be that he had a reputation as a very strict and demanding teacher who did not have much patience with students, most students did not last long, hence he may have developed a reputation as not having taught many students. But I do not think it is completely true that he did not teach anyone. The below video may be of interest where Prof Sudhir Verma has shared his memories of Thirakwa-saheb and has touched on some of these points: czcams.com/video/LPGVQCTMVls/video.html
Pt. Nayan Ghosh said @ 12.11 that his father had no clear idea on Benaras and Punjab Gharana. And @ 4.15 when he named best tabla maestros who were contemporaries of his father Pt. Nikhil Ghosh, he unconsciously selected 5 out of 9 maestros, who belonged to those two lesser-known gharanas!!! Benaras and Punjab Baaj are relatively new and based on power and they can dominate any other gharana any day. Ustad Ahmedjan Thirkawa is the Mount Everest of tabla. But the other maestros are not grass eater by the way.
One of my favorite CZcams videos. Indescribably wonderful to hear so many intimate details about Utd Thirakwa Khan saheb. Also great that Pt Nayan ji imbibed so much from him.
Nayan Uncle is such a learned Artist and so warm and encouraging personality... Hats off to you sir!! So happy i came across this video...
Fantastic. 🙏🙏
Great post, very interesting. Thanks.
Very nice information.thanks
God bless you for posting this video my friend. Much much appreciated !!
yes
Ustad ahmad jaan thirkawa ke teen bete Number one son nabijaan khan in Delhi number two mhemoodjaan khan lucknow number three Alijaan khan in bhopal
I have watched this video so many times and still feel warm and fuzzy feelings from listening to these stories!
However ... I would like to mention one thing. I believe that the assertion that Thirakwa-saheb had “not taught anyone” may be taken with a grain of salt. He seems to have had a number of disciples in both Bombay as well as Lucknow. These include Bapu Patwardhan, Narayan Joshi, Prem Vallabh, Sudhir Verma and others. It may be that he had a reputation as a very strict and demanding teacher who did not have much patience with students, most students did not last long, hence he may have developed a reputation as not having taught many students. But I do not think it is completely true that he did not teach anyone.
The below video may be of interest where Prof Sudhir Verma has shared his memories of Thirakwa-saheb and has touched on some of these points:
czcams.com/video/LPGVQCTMVls/video.html
Bhai hindi main tranalate krdo.mesns nichod
Pt. Nayan Ghosh said @ 12.11 that his father had no clear idea on Benaras and Punjab Gharana. And @ 4.15 when he named best tabla maestros who were contemporaries of his father Pt. Nikhil Ghosh, he unconsciously selected 5 out of 9 maestros, who belonged to those two lesser-known gharanas!!! Benaras and Punjab Baaj are relatively new and based on power and they can dominate any other gharana any day. Ustad Ahmedjan Thirkawa is the Mount Everest of tabla. But the other maestros are not grass eater by the way.