Which Homeowner grade Battery Chainsaw is the best value? Stihl vs Worx...YOU DECIDE!
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 09. 2020
- Which Homeowner grade Battery Chainsaw is the best value? Stihl vs Worx...YOU DECIDE! Today we'll do an honest review and overview of 2 great battery operated chainsaws...see which one is right for you! Hope ya'll enjoy
Worx Saw Link: amzn.to/3iScZBe (stoney ridge amazon affiliate link)
LogOx Forestry Multitool: amzn.to/3mJCgji (affiliate link)
Stihl Saw Link: www.stihlusa.com/products/cha... (not affiliated)
LOOKING FOR TOOLS AND GOODIES USED ON THE FARM CHANNEL..HERE YA GO! www.amazon.com/shop/stoneyrid...
(affiliate link to our Amazon page!)
SUPPORT THE FARM....PICK UP A HAT OR STONEY RIDGE T-SHIRT HERE:
www.stoneyridgefarmer.com
Follow Us on Facebook: / stoneyridgefarmer
Support this Farm as a Channel Member:
/ @stoneyridgefarmer
Chapters:
0:00
0:10 Introduction
1:27 Comparison
10:13 Running the Saws - Zábava
7:35 First time ever I had a CZcams intermission experience
Sorry I wasn't ready with the Popcorn, but will next time 😅
lol...thought I'd add that in for some fun! Thanks buddy
@@wd8545 Hey, No sorry.
For the Price Worx seems to be the way to go.
I personally use an Ego 56volt and paid 249 for it. Love the electric chain saw comparison
I've been pleasantly surprised by worx tools. They put out pretty decent tools for the price and they seem to hold up pretty well.
Based on performance: Worx. It's also way cheaper. It's heavier, but it has a longer bar, and a more powerful motor.
The reason for the responsive and sound difference is the Worx being a brushless has a soft start feature so saw doesn't buck up.
Both saws are brushless and both have soft start switches
I’d choose the worx any day of the week
I also have the 80$ version of that log ox. Mine has a wooden handle.. when it breaks I’ll put metal handle on it. Been using it for about 6months now
You describe me perfectly at 21:48, and since I have several other Worx tools that use the same 20V battery, I just purchased their latest iteration of the saw you tested. They’ve recently re-branded all of their brushless tools as “Nitro“, and I’ve been pleased with the value they represent, going back over 10 years ago when I purchased their first string trimmer. Yes, they are consumer grade, but that’s exactly what I need. Great video. Scott
The worx probably has a "soft start" feature to reduce power consumption and startup torque reaction.
Thanks for your time and effort to demonstrate these two battery powered chainsaws. It’s clear that you favoured the Stihl from the get go until you found the torque of the Worxv just kept it cutting under greater pressure. I was concerned at first that your bias would spoil the comparison. In the end it just emphasised the differences between these two saws. We’ll done.
Anybody else waiting for that tailgate to take a hit? :)
I bought the Stihl when you built the wood fence, great saw! If you let the saw do the work the Stihl is great, it will bog if you push it hard. It did take a little time to learn it's capabilities but I'm extremely happy with it!
DeWalt 60 Volt Max Chainsaw; it is the top rated battery chainsaw for the money. Researched and looked at them all before I bought the DeWalt. Milwaukee and Husqvarna electrics were also very high rated saws, but cost more than the DeWalt. Another reason I bought the DeWalt, I can use the 60 Volt Max batteries in all my 20 volt DeWalt tools. It somehow knows to power down to 20v for the 20v tools, but will last 3 times as long. Very versatile and useful platform. Another plus, the DeWalt has a 16 inch bar. I have cut down and bucked some 12 inch hardwoods with it. Very impressive saw!
so i have been wanting to buy a cordless chainsaw for a while, i just went and got the 14 inch bar with dual 20 v batteries and charger for 109 plus taxes and 11 $ discount i paid total a 105 $ you cant beat that with a stick. thank you for the review. also if my lady asked why i bought it am going to say you made me do it
I bought a 40V Ryobi chain saw with a 14" bar a few months ago and have used it heavily ever since. I even cut a few rounds off of an 18"-20" log just to see if it could do it . I'm very happy with it.
I honestly thought you was going to just be nicer toward the stihl because it was sent to you. But you proved me wrong when you talked about how much more power the worx had and was 100 percent honest. I appreciate an honest review. Keep up the good work.
I paid for the Stihl my brotha....left out spending over $400!! Ugh...it's what I do to keep it real here
He wasn't 100% honest he was just looking stupid to where he had no other choice but to keep it real and say that his little toy Stihl had no work for the Worx saw cause Worx was made and fashion better ! 😄😆🤣
I have all of Worx products and they out perform better on most products!
For consumer saws, I’d have to go with the works for the price point.
I'm really happy with my Milwaukee 18V chain saw. It has a long running life and I like the 16" bar. It is really handy having my drill, impact gun, grinder, etc, all on the same battery platform.
I have used Worx electric tools in the past. I like them for the price point but they don't last as long as say, other electric weed eaters. Use them both for about one year then get back to us.
The Worx uses batteries that can be used in smaller tools. It's part of a family they call 40V Power Share. Each of these tools uses two 20V batteries that also can be used by the tool in the 20V Power Share series. These tools range from drills and impact drivers to lawn movers, a shop vacuum and a couple of different chainsaws.
Note that Worx also have a series called 40V Share Volt and these are not compatible with the Power Share tools. Something to be aware of...
So if you already have some Worx tools it may be a good idea to also get their chainsaw. Same with the Stihl. Already got some other device using the same batteries then getting the Stihl is probably a good idea.
Finally if you have no previous tools then either just look at the saws and get the one that fit your usage profile the best or the one with the compatible tools you are planing to get anyway.
Locking yourself into a product line means you will have to compromise. No one manufacturer has the best tool for everything, so look for a manufacturer that has the best tools for your particular use, and compromise on the less used tools.
I have bought works garden and yard tools in the passed and threw them all away they were junk after a short time I have the stihl that you are using and love it. The works batteries do not last, and won't charge and need replaced. I went to buy a stihl electric pole saw (I only have five acres) The Stihl was 0ver eight hundred dollars so I passed I bought a Dewalt on line for half the price, I have not recieved it yet so I can't rate it but I am happy with my other Dewalt tools.
I would use the works if I haven’t already picked one based on work per price point!
I have not a lot of experience with battery chainsaws, but I just got a 16-inch bar 8,0 Ah 40V max Nitro Worx chainsaw and when I tried it for the first time, I was amazed and speechless at how fast it went through a 6-inch cherry tree log. No more than 5 seconds and totally effortless, like a steel knife through soft butter. I needed about 200 seconds to achieve the same with a small bowsaw. Obviously the chain was very sharp, brand new, and well oiled too. It is noisy but a much less offensive noise than a gas chainsaw. At source noise must be about 90 dbAs meaning that holding it at armslength, we get about 85 dbAs into our unprotected ears, compared to about 105 and 100 dbAs with a typical gas chainsaw.
I think there may be a difference in the chains themselves. The chain on the Stihl may be a finer cut and nit as aggressive in the pitch as the worx. The chains need to be matched to make the test somewhat more fair. Just saying. 👮🏻♂️👍Chip
sherwood gillette
The chain on the Stihl saws is pretty narrow on their little saws. As you see on the video, they tend to bind b/c of that.
I gotta big ole pin oak too close to the front of my house. One of those would come in handy climbing up in there to thin it out, in preparation for bringing it down.
❤ THANK you! Just when I needed one of these videos. I only have 2 acres, but have a whole batch of 5/yr old volunteers I need to get rid of. Decided in the Worx. If my place was just a backyard, I would have gotten the Stihl.
Wow worx really showed off there.. pretty impressive! Good review Josh
Thanks for your review and experience cause ive been wanting to get one I can handle. We have big gas ones and I’m a little intimidated . Take care. Whoo!
I have a little dewalt..it’s fine for little stuff,but the problem I have with them is I don’t treat them like a gas powered saw.I still use the same safety precautions,but I don’t care if I hit dirt ect..it just feels disposable to me..
I enjoyed watching your review. I own the worx but was curious about the Stihl. I'm happy with my purchase and appreciate your concise, honest review.
Thanks for the content brotha! Glad to see you growing the channel!!! Stay safe and God Bless 🙏😎
Very informative! Also, appreciate the honesty with dropping the tree in the driveway 😄
Ah yes Josh, but in the end, they both STIHL WORX! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Good vid. Maybe I missed it, Warranty on unit, Warranty on batteries? Charge time? etc. Huge Stihl fan, but for the average homeowner that uses it once a year for 5 minutes? ..the Worx for sure.
I like both...kinda different applications for each saw
I have really enjoyed the Worx chainsaw. Thanks for sharing!
Great Video. I've got the still had it for several years still going strong battery still good
It seems like they will both do the job. If the battery life is about the same I believe the worx would win because of torque. You buy a chainsaw to cut wood and the worx just cuts better plus you can buy two of them for one stihl. Something you did not cover was how long does it take to charge the respective batteries and of course you have to charge two worx to one stihl.
I'd say the Works has the upper hand, it's economical, has the torque to rip. But it does have a longer bar. The Stihl is better at trimming the branches, and even smaller trees with that burst speed. I grew up running Homelite, and McCullough... And there was nothing light about them Homelites! Never really looked at the Electric chainsaw line up, till now. Neat vid. Tnx.
Need to test this out on some harder wood. That Tulip Poplar is super soft and easy to cut.
I love my Stihl Saw it just feels right! Woooooo
Great content as always
I would go with the Stihl MSA 200C. Enjoyed the video Josh. Thanks 👍👍👍❤️
I think one factor should really be if you have any other tools in a product line. I have the stihl 510v push mower so I would easily pick the stihl saw that took the same battery. But if I had ego or workz or what ever I would go with that saw.
I would lean towards the Worx. Very good comparison.
It's a case of horse's for course's, a Rolls Vs Ford, they both do what they are made for except one is more comfortable to use but both will get the job done. Personally I think value for money will win out, if I had to buy one I'd go for the word. Gary..... England 🇬🇧
exactly
Works is a better chain saw. The still does not have the power of the works.
Both of them have their plusses...I'm pretty happy with both saws...but for the money? Hmm
What you "saw" was a perfect example of horsepower versus torque. The Worx clearly has much more torque.
@@StoneyRidgeFarmer For the money, I'd still take the Stihl. Multiply that lag in the time they go through those logs. At the end of a day, the Stihl's going to save a ton of time and cause the worker less fatigue making it the safer tool too. Yeah...it's worth it in my book.
The Worx goes nice when pressured, but really, who pushes on a chainsaw while working? The saw's supposed to do the work.
I'm A Stihl guy through and through BUT I'm going out and buying the Worx after this comparison video. Great video Josh!
I hope it’s Stihl. My wife’s Grandfather helped first bring Stihl to the American market. We are partial to them.
This had a weird soft start effect which I remember and glad the nitro 16" version released a week after I got this one so returned and purchased.
I think you said it all when you said the worx is good for some one who doesn' t use one every day and the stihl will last a long time. The old adage you get what you pay for.
BINGO!
I used to feel the same way about 'You get what you pay for' and still have that on most purchases. However, with Worx, I feel you are getting a great product. I don't have a chainsaw but I do have their Leaf Blower/Vacuum and it's going strong for over 10 years now with regular use! They make their products really good for the value you are paying! I'll buy the Worx in the future for sure based on price point and overall demo here.
I have also heard from a couple buddies of mine that they have purchased some of the work products and have both continued to sing their praises.
Nice video and Review ... Thanks for taking the time to make this Vid.
I own the Worx 40v Pressure Washer and just recently purchased the Worx 40v chainsaw , I have not owned the Worx brand for a real long time but so far I have no complaints. One nice feature is that you can swap out batteries on all of their 40v series tools..
Also paying for the name!
What a coincidence I bought one this past weekend. I was very impressed with the cobalt 40v
Very cool!
Nice comparison video, Josh. Can definitely tell the difference between the two. I'm liking that gas can in the back of your Kubota, though.Never saw one like that before! Where can I pick one of those up?
The Worx saw is a great price point. Once again thanks for sharing!
For me it seems the Stihl sound runs at a higher speed than the worx. To me that may translate into faster chain revolutions but the worx is slower but has more power. Not having a lot of money I probably would go with the Worx. It may or may not last as long but these are not made to cut a bunch of cords of wood. They are considered trim saws not logging saws.
I think you honestly could cut about 1/2 pickup load of wood with each saw....they're both pretty darn good...we'll see how they both hold up brotha..thanks for the insightful comment
Hi Josh! Great video! Pretty impressed with the Worx. Awful unimpressed with the power of the Stihl, but battery was really good. I’m a husky fan, now you have me looking into battery operated Husqvarna chainsaw 😂. Best wishes!
Might have one of those on the channel soon if I can make it happen...expensive little critters!
Hey Josh thank you for the video I enjoyed it and I think that works chainsaw is a monster if I was going to get myself a electric chainsaw that's the one that I would get and thank you for showing all of us that watch your videos on CZcams this video
you guys are the best i have used the stihl before and it work very good
I don't want to like the works products, but I have been totally impressed by several tools that I have. For many years.
I love my Worx chainsaw and jawsaw. I've never started my cuts with the chain already touching the log, so that half second of response time on the front end isn't important to me. Plus, my batteries are standard worx batteries and are interchangeable.
I'm not sold on an electric chainsaw, but we have an electric pole pruning saw that is a great tool. Usually don't cut larger than 3" or so.
I am going to order the Worx , you can throw it on your side by side and cut trails anywhere.
link down there for ya brotha
For the money, I'd get the Worx.
I like the works for its torque and bigger bar and the price but the sthil is nice also apples to oranges nice video very good info.
The price seems nice on that works saw, and it was rating up wood. For a guy like me that does not use a chainsaw that often the works would be great.
If you do not want to own a larger petrol powered chainsaw then get the Works, especially if you have a limited budget. If you do have a larger chainsaw & have the money, get the Stihl.
I think it’s great there are tools like this. Excellent tools at a reasonable price. I have an Ego Powerplus battery powered chainsaw and it’s a good machine.
I have a couple 40V WORX tools. They're aggressive! BUT, they've discontinued some of their 40V versions and gone back to 20V versions of the same tool. You can buy a double capacity bat., though. My 40V stuff runs a LONG time.
Myself I'd rather buy the WORX, and pick up a couple extra batteries for it. Still have less in it than the Stihl. SURE the Stihl will probably last longer, but I'd rather have a new saw every few yrs anyway.
Great, HONEST, comparison!
Hi there, good review! Wonder if any updated comments on the Worx chainsaw now (late 2023)?
Depends on the applications.....working all day...or frequently up in a basket ...the Stihl as lighter and longer battery life.
But for weekend warrior doing this 3-4 times a year....the Wore looks better
Well price wise I'd go whith the worxs it may have more aggressive cut due to the chain it self .but it didn't stop thru the log .that's a plus .so they both have there ups and downs but the only thing whith the worxs saw is it takes 2batteries not 1like the stile saw but anyways great vid and godbless bud
thanks I was wanting a electric saw
I'd have to choose the Worx. I'm a Stihl guy too.
While I’m kind of liking the works it a depends on how long each saw holds up and witch saw is built better! I’d say try and use both saws and see which saw fails or breaks down beyond repair, also the type of battery in these saws is another issue if the saws hold up past the life of the batteries can you easily get battery replacement for them?
Thanks for the video.I'm interested in a small chainsaw
I got the Ryobi Top Handle kit for $149. I use it for the light stuff. Top handles from every other brand seem pricey.
Great video as always sir.
Hello from Australia 🇦🇺. Great review mate. Thankyou! 👍
Great comparison
Thanks Angie
Great vlog Josh 🇺🇲 I have been looking for a saw like this 🇺🇲🇺🇲💯💯 WOOOOOO! 🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲💯💯💯
Make sure you look at Makita. I've used mine 3yrs and love the convienence and ability.
The smaller saw should be quicker to respond with less chain to move with basically the same colts. The 14 inch bar may be slower to respond but it has more power
I’d use the Stihl to trim the branches because it’s lighter easier to handle then the Worx for the log it just has more torque
Worx would be my choice, $ wise and get the job done. Working with a chain saw with wood on the ground, I think the heaver worx is better. If ya gotta climb the tree for trimming, the lightweight Stihl is the choice. If ya can only afford one, Worx, hands down.
One caveat I’ve found in these kinds of companies is continuity of the product line. I would guess that repair parts will be available from Stihl for a long time whereas the next release in the Worx cordless chainsaws will likely be built from incompatible parts (other than perhaps the battery). Also, what percentage is plastic vs metal. Anyway, thanks for letting us share in the fun. Looked like you were having a blast.
So it craps out buy a new one
@@JimsNBHomestead For less than the price of the Stihl replacement parts.
I have the works and it never fails me I had a skill and I had nothing but problems with it
I'd go with the Worx and save $250 bucks. No brainier.
Hi..... Thank you 🎥👍👍👍
I have the msa140 to carry on my Quad ..its a great saw
Hey Josh, Like to see if a 14 inch bar and chain would make any difference on the sthil.
I have a pair of MS170's and they are bombproof. I also have an old all-steel saw from the 30's that belonged to my grandpappy with an 18" bar, but I hardly use it because it weighs about 50 lbs LOL.
whatever you do don't get a 171! Not the same saw as the 170...I was very disapointed..I still have my 170
The difference in the spool up response is that the worx saw is brushless the brushes provide excitation to the field for a more rapid start so without brushes it is slower
I am a penny pincher so I would go to the works, based off of this review but I would like to see a dewalt and Milwaukee match up as well. A four way matchup?
a four way would be awesome....expensive on my end though
I'd like to see universal batteries, or an adapter for widely available batteries.
Makita has a cordless model.
I heart the makita is a beast!!
From the looks seems like the worx you can drop in Dewalt batteries as replacements
I pick the Sthil saw... cool clip
Try a Milwaukee chainsaw those are really powerful. I'd be curious to see how it holds up vs these saws.
If you did it with the stihl battery msa 220c saw it would win everything hands down if you can get hold of a makita and dewalt battery saw and compare all of them 😉
Excellent comparison. It may come down to which company has best service if you have to return to dealer or manufacturer.
We bought a Worx cordless lawn care kit. The weed Wacker was missing a small, non essential part.
The company sent me a whole new weed Wacker.
Yussss!!! CHAINSAWS BACK ON THE TOOL TUESDAYS!!!! Tis the fire wood cutting season, almost to 450k!!
Wooooo!!!
@@StoneyRidgeFarmer stihl is the winner plus good thing with stihls they have parts at dealers and works hard to get parts woooooo
Works for sure
Mrs Stoney Ridge feeding you too well 😎
David in Somerset England
lol...what a nice way to tell someone he's fat bhahhahaha...I know brotha...I'm working on it..back on the bicycle now!
Worx is winner but wonder about longevity ,have Dewalt pole saw 8 in and happy so far but very limited use...