Blind Tasting American Macro Lagers

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 25. 10. 2022
  • #59 - The guys go back in time to blind taste the beers of our fathers. Which 100+ year old American lager reigns supreme when they don't know which is which?

Komentáře • 1,1K

  • @jcindestin8611
    @jcindestin8611 Před 29 dny +15

    When in the Marine Corps, we declared Pabst Blue Ribbon, "America's beer." 34 years later, PBR is still my go to beer

  • @ghw7192
    @ghw7192 Před rokem +190

    The best beer I ever had was an icy cold PBR after moving a friend into an upstairs apartment on a 100+ degree day.

  • @Runner-fz5qg
    @Runner-fz5qg Před měsícem +9

    After a long hot day at the mill a coors banquet hits just right for me.

  • @treytison1444
    @treytison1444 Před rokem +120

    I could identify the Yuengling just from the color alone

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +3

      Yeah, it had been quite a while since either of us had a Yuengling and usually straight out of the bottle so we weren't clued in to the color yet. It's definitely different from the rest in color and flavor profile. Thanks for watching! Cheers🍻

    • @saddletramp6935
      @saddletramp6935 Před rokem +1

      You ate right. Some local microbrews are red, but not the major labels.

    • @flatlanderfl
      @flatlanderfl Před rokem +6

      Absolutely. Yuengling is definitely the standout here. Easy to pick out in this group

    • @GB-rv8im
      @GB-rv8im Před 4 měsíci +1

      1st American MICRO Brew LOL

    • @intentionaloffside8934
      @intentionaloffside8934 Před 4 měsíci +4

      Black & Tan is my favorite

  • @rayperry7315
    @rayperry7315 Před rokem +35

    I look at beer the same way my favorite great uncle who was a WW2 vet looked at beer. Whatever is cold and whatever someone else is buying is fine with me.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +2

      Cheers to that 🍻

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před 4 měsíci +1

      Absolutely!

    • @kcstott
      @kcstott Před 4 měsíci +1

      I’m sorry but you’d drink free piss? Is that what you’re saying??
      Sorry I was at a ball game and my tickets included beer. It was coors light.
      I walked around the corner and paid good money for real beer.

  • @bobsoldrecords1503
    @bobsoldrecords1503 Před rokem +71

    Schlitz going back to their original recipe was one of the most exciting things to happen to macros in the last 20 years. In the sixties and early seventies, it was the most popular beer in the United States, leaving Bud at number two.

    • @myleftthumb2294
      @myleftthumb2294 Před rokem +16

      Apparently they had to recreate it since the original recipe was lost. They interviewed old brewmasters.

    • @jpecci1262
      @jpecci1262 Před rokem +12

      We didn't even call it Schlitz. We used to call it beer and it was understood that beer meant Schlitz.

    • @_Peremalfait
      @_Peremalfait Před rokem +15

      I'm glad to see the once mighty Schlitz beer is still going with their original recipe. With Budweiser's recent woes perhaps there's an opening for new Schlitz drinkers to give the brand a boost.

    • @joebauers3746
      @joebauers3746 Před 5 měsíci +8

      Schlitz wins just because it is the most fun to say, especially after 8 of them.

    • @paulpeterson4216
      @paulpeterson4216 Před 4 měsíci +2

      @@joebauers3746 Yes, once you were full of Schlitz

  • @toddlehman928
    @toddlehman928 Před rokem +44

    I couldn't agree more on Miller high Life being a different beer from bottle to can. I too land in the bottle camp

    • @JohnMartin-ys1kn
      @JohnMartin-ys1kn Před 4 měsíci

      You are correct.

    • @Zeus-dw1cx
      @Zeus-dw1cx Před 4 měsíci +1

      Absolutely

    • @caseysmith544
      @caseysmith544 Před 3 měsíci +2

      I am Bottle though a tall 16 oz can is almost a bottle. Of Cheap beers it is my second choice over Coors and third is Rolling Rock.

    • @JohnMartin-ys1kn
      @JohnMartin-ys1kn Před 3 měsíci

      Agree. @@caseysmith544

    • @T-Mo_
      @T-Mo_ Před měsícem +2

      It ended up being his least favorite 😂

  • @eddy67
    @eddy67 Před 2 měsíci +3

    Genesee (Rochester NY) would be a good candidate for this test. Brewery has been around since 1878!

  • @bozojoe197
    @bozojoe197 Před 5 měsíci +67

    Yuengling is by far the best. You can drink it all night long and not get tired of the taste. It also has the best color out of all of the other beers and stands out beautifully.

    • @JimneyCriquet
      @JimneyCriquet Před 5 měsíci +3

      Agree so sad it’s not available everywhere

    • @user-cv8qe9ru8c
      @user-cv8qe9ru8c Před 5 měsíci +1

      No yeungling in my state sadly

    • @smileymalaise
      @smileymalaise Před 4 měsíci

      They caught a worker pissing into the beer recently.

    • @Rich-fg9vj
      @Rich-fg9vj Před 4 měsíci +2

      Where did you find that information?@@smileymalaise

    • @tweezerjam
      @tweezerjam Před 4 měsíci +2

      Grew up on this stuff. Took a break for a decade but recently came back home to lager. 😂

  • @panicrev555
    @panicrev555 Před rokem +31

    You need to be able to cleanse the palette between beers. The previous beer(s) will drastically affect the flavor of subsequent beers tested.

  • @stevenm.6886
    @stevenm.6886 Před rokem +22

    My Dad always drank Hamms, advertised during his beloved Cubs games!

    • @peterniemira9536
      @peterniemira9536 Před 4 měsíci +2

      Hamms is still a good tasting brew. Like all of them chill to the max.

    • @Polack-ml9fh
      @Polack-ml9fh Před 3 měsíci +2

      Can’t beat hamms from a keg.

    • @caseysmith544
      @caseysmith544 Před 3 měsíci +2

      Still in parts of the USA find Hamms.

    • @corysather6640
      @corysather6640 Před 2 měsíci +2

      Hamm's is the Mountain Dew of beers very sweet and very little carbonation

    • @leemehan
      @leemehan Před 2 měsíci +1

      @@corysather6640- Hamm's kind of has a sweet, weird taste to it.

  • @benjaminhawthorne1969
    @benjaminhawthorne1969 Před rokem +15

    Past Blue Ribbon has been my everyday choice for decades. It is clean and fresh tasting, with no odor or aftertaste. It is the beer that I reach for to accompany every meal (except breakfast!😁)
    I buy thirty (30) cans at a time at Wal-mart for less per ounce than I can buy cola!
    When I want a beer that "eats like a meal," I reach for Samuel Adams. Held up to sunlight in a Pilsner glass, it shows its gorgeous rufous color. It also is clean tasting, but filled with about half a-dozen flavors, and as maker Jim Koch says, "a head so thick, you can float a bottle cap on it!"
    A bottle of "Sammy" is always a treat for the senses of every beer lover!

    • @copsarebastards
      @copsarebastards Před 3 měsíci +1

      I'm a brewer at a craft brewery in NY and pbr is my #1 macro lager as well. The price is great, it has some nice hop character, it's not flavorless.

    • @leemehan
      @leemehan Před 2 měsíci +1

      Schlitz is really great too. U want a beer that is miles better than Sam Adams, buy Wernesgruner at Aldi's. Sam Adams is terrible to me and blows it away!

  • @LevisLabOfficial
    @LevisLabOfficial Před rokem +7

    Really great video! Love the vibe of the discussion, feels relaxed yet lively.
    Subscribed!

  • @ShyGuyLoveSongs
    @ShyGuyLoveSongs Před rokem +7

    My buddies Dad worked at Schiltz in Milwaukee back in the day. Glad Pabst brought it back in small batches. Good stuff.

  • @ericruggles4631
    @ericruggles4631 Před rokem +75

    And if you drink enough of them, they all get prettier at closing time.

    • @willhorting5317
      @willhorting5317 Před rokem +2

      🎶 "The girls all get prettier at closing time, cause they all begin to look like movie stars." 🎶

    • @billh.1940
      @billh.1940 Před rokem

      But so do us fat, ugly guy's. Good time is had by all.

    • @billbrasky7540
      @billbrasky7540 Před rokem +3

      Ha I love that song. That was one of my ma's favorites too. When I was still in high school, she's get her boiler maker goin on on the weekends (bc we lived in a dry county at the time), and she had tapes of all the greats, and she'd play em loud while she cooked and danced and would have me drink beers and shots with her and tell me about the good old country music n stuff, SRV, and the golden oldies too, etc... That one ALWAYS got played at the house 🤙🏻

    • @willhorting5317
      @willhorting5317 Před rokem

      @@billbrasky7540 👍

    • @gregthoms5232
      @gregthoms5232 Před rokem

      Coors is great. Don't know what his problem is.

  • @bigfatno
    @bigfatno Před rokem +2

    Fantastic! I love the history of the beers our fathers used to drink. I can still throw back some Bud and Shmidt from time to time, but I'm more of a "fancy" beer drinker now.
    Thanks for sharing.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +1

      Same here. We mostly drink craft but these certainly have their time and place. Cheers and thanks for watching 🍻

  • @joshuafrahm8778
    @joshuafrahm8778 Před 4 měsíci +13

    Out of these I'd have to go Yuengling, but Old Style is my #1

  • @jamesberryman9893
    @jamesberryman9893 Před rokem +4

    Just stumbled onto this video and man I'm so glad I did! You guys are hilarious! My personal all time favorite of these would have to be Miller High Life but after about 5 or 6, it would be pretty hard to decipher which one is which lol.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +1

      Thanks James! Happy to hear you found us and are enjoying it. Keep your eyes peeled for a follow up video in the next week or two 😉🍻

  • @DouglasRosser
    @DouglasRosser Před rokem +7

    My mom was a bartender/cocktail waitress her entire life. I grew up with so much free junk from distributors and about a million of those purple Crown Royal bags. But my prize possession was a wall-mounted Miller High Life sign that subtly lit my bedroom at night.

  • @scotthenkel2833
    @scotthenkel2833 Před rokem +33

    Pabst and Schlitz were popular even into the 1980s before massive advertising and light beers took over.

    • @artistnyc123
      @artistnyc123 Před rokem +1

      Bingo! In the 6o's Pabst and Schlitz, Falstaff, Coors, and Bud, all had the same, price points. Today you pay a premium for Coors, Bud, and Miller due to advertising costs.

  • @vernonmarsh
    @vernonmarsh Před rokem +23

    I live in a college student ghetto and, judging from the empty beer cans that decorate their yards, the youth generation appears to really like Miller Lite, Coors lite, and Keystone Lite.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +8

      Those poor bastards hahahaha. I have a feeling we will do a light beer blind battle at some point.

    • @Mister_Belvidere
      @Mister_Belvidere Před rokem +6

      I drank a lot of Keystone light and Keystone ice in college because a 30 pack was just under $10

    • @LuckyBastardProd
      @LuckyBastardProd Před rokem +1

      Xer here. We drank those as well plus PBR and Lucky Laghard (lager) not just for the irony but they were dirt cheap, too.

    • @michaelmathews295
      @michaelmathews295 Před rokem

      I own some farmland and I clean up litter in the ditches every year and that's what I see also. I think the most exotic beer I ever found was a Corona.

    • @jasoncoates1835
      @jasoncoates1835 Před rokem

      @@LuckyBastardProd Can confirm. Shaeffer's too. (The punk house beer of choice!)

  • @robclark3095
    @robclark3095 Před rokem +5

    Meister Brau!!! That was my high school beer. I also remember my grandmother drinking Olympia beer.

  • @bzwaters
    @bzwaters Před 2 měsíci +2

    A great video and I'm glad Pabst at least placed.
    When my dad was a young man drinking with friends, Pabst was his beer of choice. It was apparently the fuel for many a "colorful tales" of his youth. It holds a special place for me and it's one I always drink in his honor and memory. It is also a favorite of the "cheap beers". I would probably get Schlitz a lot as well except I have a hard time finding in my area.

  • @yokosomike
    @yokosomike Před 5 měsíci +2

    I can remember my dad drinking Schlitts, then Coors and even Michelob. He finally settled on Bud, then Bud light as he got into his 50s. I’m now going to be the same age as my dad when he went to be with our Lord and every year on his birthday I stop and grab a pepperoni pizza and a Bud. Personally, I enjoy craft beer, a good Belgian ale but my favorite beer at the moment since I live in Tokyo is Coedo White and Hitachino Nest, both Japanese craft beers. Seems a long way off but I can still remember my dad cracking open a Coors on a hot day after mowing the lawn in the 70s in Southern California and sharing a drink or two with me. Thanks for the memories.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před 5 měsíci

      Totally agree in that we also mostly drink craft beer. Love Belgians. Glad it brought back some memories though. Thanks for watching, cheers!

  • @roscoe_t
    @roscoe_t Před rokem +19

    Macro beer formulas have changed a lot over the years. Schlitz wrecked itself in the '70s with a formula update; the Schlitz in the test uses a 1960s recipe, so it naturally stands out. The Pabst of today is not the same as the Pabst I drank in the early '70s.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +3

      Yeah, no doubt none of them are the exact same as they started out in terms of ingredients and recipes. I wish I were able to taste how they were back in the day to compare 🍻

    • @csnide6702
      @csnide6702 Před rokem +2

      Pabst was mild back in 1970s -- and a HUGE brand

    • @bklyndg
      @bklyndg Před rokem +1

      Where can you FIND Schlitz with the 1960 recipe?

    • @12babyapes59
      @12babyapes59 Před rokem +1

      @@bklyndg yes where do you find this beer?

    • @SharpsBox
      @SharpsBox Před 5 měsíci

      Weirdly enough, the PBR in China is the original recipe on Pabst equipment. Tastes like mid 90s PBR before the Milwaukee plant closed.

  • @Kutulu369
    @Kutulu369 Před rokem +5

    That Miller High Life sign on the shelf though. I miss seeing that so much from my childhood as it was hanging in the garage. It was mesmerizing.

  • @RJR2222
    @RJR2222 Před rokem +1

    Sterling big mouths and Old Milwaukee were my go too back in the day. Enjoyed the content thanks

  • @austinidol95050
    @austinidol95050 Před 2 měsíci +1

    my grandfather's beer was olympia , wish that beer was still available and part of your list for nostalgia , great topic video guys

  • @user-David-Alan
    @user-David-Alan Před rokem +24

    Yuengling in a bottle is so much better. I guess everybody's tastebuds are different. The only beer with flavor out of the beers you had there was Y.

    • @kentmarsh6442
      @kentmarsh6442 Před rokem +9

      Yuengling is best on tap.

    • @picklerix6162
      @picklerix6162 Před rokem

      It’s good on tap but most beer tastes better on tap.

    • @finnafishfl
      @finnafishfl Před rokem +3

      Cans > bottles

    • @jeffduncan9140
      @jeffduncan9140 Před rokem

      ​@kentmarsh6442 never had it on tap but I do love it in the bottle.

    • @flatlanderfl
      @flatlanderfl Před rokem +1

      Just got back from a week of racing/camping down here in Florida and Yuengling kept us happily hydrated! Very good stuff.

  • @gene1278
    @gene1278 Před rokem +9

    wish someone would bring back Falstaff.

  • @geoffreyclark2805
    @geoffreyclark2805 Před rokem +2

    I'm in my 60's and back in the day I enjoyed Schaefer Beer, unavailable in stores for quite sometime a friend of mine ordered me a case from the liquor store a few years ago and it was okay but not quite what I remembered. Came to find out it's under Pabst umbrella now. Miller High Life is my choice now for American Lager style. Moosehead, Molson Canadian, or LaBatt's Blue I enjoy too.

  • @edfulginiti8798
    @edfulginiti8798 Před rokem +6

    PBRs for me.

  • @tomy.1846
    @tomy.1846 Před 4 měsíci +3

    My best beer? Hands down. When I was about 14 years old, some of my friends and I went up on the roof of a random 5 floor apartment building one summer night. We found a red cooler on the roof with about 6 cans of Bud, in with the coldest possible water. A few few ice cubes were still keeping them frosty. It was a warm night, we were running around the nearby town like usual. Those beers were delicious! Cracklin cold! To this day, I'm 52, those cold beers were the best! It was like the scene in the Shawshank Redemption when they got the beers after tarring the roof! Incredible! 😃🙃🤤😎🤠🤯👆 Miss those days, lol!

  • @HaimTabibi
    @HaimTabibi Před rokem +47

    Take Yuengling to your families and friends out west. They can’t get it out there and LOVE it!

    • @sspaay
      @sspaay Před rokem +2

      The Black and Tan is heaven in a glass.

    • @TheNutzandBoltz
      @TheNutzandBoltz Před rokem +1

      I'm from PA and live in Idaho. Brother'n'law borough out four cases. Fully agree.

    • @Whats-It-To-Ya
      @Whats-It-To-Ya Před rokem +5

      I live 15 miles from the Yuengling brewery and you couldn't pay me to drink that piss

    • @ericmiles6413
      @ericmiles6413 Před rokem +1

      Found this in PA. at race love it since then.

    • @TheNutzandBoltz
      @TheNutzandBoltz Před rokem

      @@Whats-It-To-Ya And the color blue sucks. Thanks for your opinion.

  • @AJ-ln4sm
    @AJ-ln4sm Před 4 měsíci +1

    Good stuff fellas! I'd love to sit down and do this with my dad or my son. Cheers

  • @erinskyes1468
    @erinskyes1468 Před 4 měsíci +2

    As a punk from the West Coast, PBR and Miller High life are my personal favorites and scene favorites. Cheap and good.

  • @joshuarosen465
    @joshuarosen465 Před rokem +11

    I remember that there was always a case of Schlitz in the back stairwell of my grandfather's house. He died in 1962. I don't know if it was a choice or if that was the only beer available in Sheboygan in the 1950s.

    • @wardaddy6595
      @wardaddy6595 Před rokem +1

      My Dad and uncles all drank Schlitz when I was growing up in the 60s and 70s , I'm sure my first sip of beer was a Schlitz .

    • @pjw1016
      @pjw1016 Před rokem +2

      Seems like WW2 photos of GI’s drinking beer were overwhelmingly Schlitz. Growing up in the 50’s and 60’s most of my area taverns had Schlitz or Hamms signs hanging out front.

  • @adamjenks9613
    @adamjenks9613 Před rokem +15

    The ‘E’ in this study, the Narragansett Lager has been a favorite of mine for years! My personal choice for cheap beer. That’s just me, I honestly like it.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +2

      It really is a nice one. I have been ordering it at concerts lately. Cheers! - Craig

    • @skswig1
      @skswig1 Před rokem +1

      They sell that as premium beer where I live

    • @michaelbower85
      @michaelbower85 Před rokem

      Same! I had one with dinner tonight and after work it hits the spot nice

    • @justincovert6943
      @justincovert6943 Před rokem +1

      Still love Narragansett. They make one called Fresh Catch which is delicious

    • @gregggoss2210
      @gregggoss2210 Před rokem +1

      Good cheap beer. Prefer it in bottles. Quint's beer of choice.

  • @billg3356
    @billg3356 Před 6 měsíci +2

    My Nana used to drink 'Gansett tallboys back in the day. I still remember them in the fridge when I was a kid...

  • @MrBushy3000
    @MrBushy3000 Před 4 měsíci +2

    I didn't see this in comments at least near top of them. One of the biggest differences between Schlitz and other American beers is the grain that is used. They brewed with rice because near Milwaukee there were large areas with wild rice and it was cheap and easy to get. They meant to change back to the usuals but people liked it so much they kept it. Just one fun side note the beer factory that Lavern and Shirly worked at was called Shots Beer which was an homage to Schlitz.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před 4 měsíci

      Ha! Very interesting. I know rice is very commonly used today but must have been an interesting change back in the day. Thanks for highlighting that!

  • @marcstevens8576
    @marcstevens8576 Před rokem +23

    I'm a Pabst man, however, I truly miss the Coors Extra Gold. Shame they discontinued it.

    • @Mike-jv4rz
      @Mike-jv4rz Před rokem +5

      PBR and Old Style in bottles are both great to me...
      In the dead heat of summer I like the "miller killers" the 7 oz bottles, 3 chugs and gone - they never get cold lol..

    • @marcstevens8576
      @marcstevens8576 Před rokem +2

      @@Mike-jv4rz It was a lot of fun trying to open those pull-tabs in the Winter as teenagers. "Hey, Shake get us a screwdriver". I remember it very well. Half the time, before Shake returned with the screwdriver, our cans of Schlitz, or Pabst were pretty much frozen. Brings back great memories.

    • @Mike-jv4rz
      @Mike-jv4rz Před rokem +2

      @@marcstevens8576 Pull tabs- lol
      Now that's a blast from the past 👍

    • @FestusBro
      @FestusBro Před rokem +1

      Drank a bunch and forgot about the Extra Gold. From the wayback files.

  • @lcusatis
    @lcusatis Před rokem +16

    I love how the Yuengling stands out so obviously.

    • @JH-pn6zd
      @JH-pn6zd Před rokem +3

      ..and yet they acted like they had NO idea what beee it was!🙄🙄🙄

    • @JH-pn6zd
      @JH-pn6zd Před rokem +1

      **beer

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +2

      Haha, yeah honest ignorance I'm afraid. I don't think either of us had seen a Yuengling outside of the bottle or can, or at least not in a long time. Believe it or not, it got edited out when trimming down the time but I actually thought it could possibly be the Narragansett originally because I hadn't had that one outside of the can either.

    • @lcusatis
      @lcusatis Před rokem

      @@drinkingwithcraigandroger4539 Thanks for the reply, fellas. Enjoy the videos. This one was quite fun.

  • @pecoswild
    @pecoswild Před 3 měsíci +1

    Entertaining and a fun activity. I’ve done that with bourbons. I’m going to copy y’all and do the same with beers! Cheers and greetings from Justin, TX!

  • @justincovert6943
    @justincovert6943 Před rokem +5

    It's important to remember that your grandparents would probably have only drank regional beers. Especially in the 40's and 50's since countywide distribution was a huge thing. Yuengling is still only available in I think 15 states.

    • @porkrind
      @porkrind Před rokem

      Yuengling has recently made a BIG change in distribution and is now available at least as far west as Kansas. By recently I mean last week, it was big news here. It's... okay. I too am a High Life from the bottle kind of guy.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem

      Great point 🍻

  • @DH-.
    @DH-. Před rokem +3

    Miller high life bottles give me nostalgia, those were the best to chug in competition with your buds .. secret trick you get a flexy straw bend around the rim use like a snorkel in a weird way and u can chug the whole thing 3 seconds flat as an amateur drinker 2 seconds with practice

  • @eugeneblum5686
    @eugeneblum5686 Před rokem +6

    Yuengling is currently negotiating with a distributor in Wisconsin. Usually have a few when I'm in Alabama, Georgia and Texas. Although can't beat a Shiner Bock when in Texas. Usually a High Life in the bottle is my go to.

    • @gertifity4868
      @gertifity4868 Před rokem +2

      Shiner Premium is a great lager. (And Texas is a great state!)

    • @JimneyCriquet
      @JimneyCriquet Před 5 měsíci

      Wish I could get some in WA

  • @brownale1000
    @brownale1000 Před 3 měsíci +1

    What a great 👍 video Craig and Roger well done subscribed cheers 🍺🍺

  • @stevea6936
    @stevea6936 Před rokem +3

    I understand that this was a taste test between the largest breweries in the United States of what I called cheap crap beer. I have been a beer connoisseur all my life and I have tried well over 200 brands of beers from around the world and I'm also a former bartender I can tell you straight out the best water makes a huge difference in the best beer and the best water on planet Earth is in Canada. If you're strictly going by large-volume breweries and not microbreweries which are clearly the best ,the best large volume brewery 12 pack hands-down is a 12-pack of Labatt's Blue from Canada and amazingly enough out here in Las Vegas a 12-pack of Labatt's is cheaper or equal in price than any of the above-mentioned beers. If you want really good beer the largest volume microbrewery is still the best in the United States and that's anything from the Sam Adams Brewery out of Boston

  • @PipeMan1958
    @PipeMan1958 Před rokem +63

    I picked Schlitz right at the start, but Hamm's should of been a part of the test, these two beers are great.

    • @theworldwariioldtimeradioc8676
      @theworldwariioldtimeradioc8676 Před rokem +13

      Stroh’s also. Both might be tough to find. I live in an urban area and can find Hamm’s at the mega liquor stores.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +14

      Yeah, Hamm's and Old Style seem to the be two most popular in this style that we can't get in our market here in Atlanta 🍻

    • @leviturner3265
      @leviturner3265 Před rokem +9

      I agree. I find Hamm's to be very nice. Our local liqour store sells Hamm's in 30-packs. I do not know how well they sell, but I make sure to buy two a week so that they continue to stock to them. Currently I have a surplus of about 150 beers because I can not drink them as fast as I buy them.
      Whenever the liqour store does not have Hamm's in stock I buy Miller High Life. If for whatever reason they do not have either, or I am looking to save one dollar, I might buy Busch. Always in 30 packs to save money.

    • @TheMarcopix
      @TheMarcopix Před rokem +5

      @@leviturner3265 We mostly drank Stroh's because that's what the older guys drank and they bought ours so...ok. Hamm's was another that brought back memories.

    • @theworldwariioldtimeradioc8676
      @theworldwariioldtimeradioc8676 Před rokem +2

      @@leviturner3265 You are beer stocked for the apocalypse.

  • @alanarnold2163
    @alanarnold2163 Před rokem +18

    The Narragansett is a contract beer as well. If you look at the can it says brewed in Rochester, NY. So basically you’re drinking a Genesee Beer.

    • @aleks1939
      @aleks1939 Před rokem +4

      Well the brewery may be owned by Genesee, but they're using the Narragansett recipe.

    • @mondoenterprises6710
      @mondoenterprises6710 Před rokem +2

      Speaking of Genessee, where do they place?

    • @csnide6702
      @csnide6702 Před rokem

      FIFCO --- Genesee has been absorbed by them.

    • @billh.1940
      @billh.1940 Před rokem +1

      Ah! Genesee, I remember it well, 10 cent a can. The cream ale was drinkable, but junk. The beer was worse.
      Upstate NY it was were I started drinking, but then the whole town was drunk. Nothing else to do.

    • @markabrams3932
      @markabrams3932 Před rokem +1

      @@billh.1940 Genny Cream Ale was my staple growing up in upstate NY until I was 20. I enlisted and was later stationed in Belgium has had introduction to real beer of the region. I've never gone back!

  • @drew311stylee
    @drew311stylee Před rokem +2

    Fun video. Thanks for posting. It's really hard to side-by-side taste test beer. Even in this video certain beers that you really liked upon first tasting, once you've had a bunch of different cheap beer on your palate you go back to it later and it doesn't taste good to you anymore. I bet you guys could do this 10 times and get 10 different winners.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +3

      You are absolutely right. The temperature and palate fatigue are big factors. It was very difficult haha. Still fun though. Thanks for watching, cheers!

  • @skateboarderw3281
    @skateboarderw3281 Před rokem +7

    Totally enjoyed this....good times, Schlitz rules. Too bad it's not in NC anymore...

    • @arise2945
      @arise2945 Před rokem

      Apparently you can't get it in Kansas any more either.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +1

      Dang. Roger said he couldn't find any when he went around to a few stores in Georgia the other week. So hopefully they haven't stopped distributing here also. Thanks for watching 🍻

  • @stephenrichie4646
    @stephenrichie4646 Před rokem +3

    Wow. Surprised. Gonna have to try Schlitz. My long time fave Yuengling. Can’t abide Bud or PBR.

  • @MichaelLanier-qk8kg
    @MichaelLanier-qk8kg Před 4 měsíci +1

    Schlitz was my favorite beer in the early 70s. They tried to speed up the brewing process and thus gain an economic edge over its competitors, and it backfired on them. One of the great all time blunders in the beer industry.

  • @steveh4114
    @steveh4114 Před 11 měsíci +1

    Good, Fun review. Wish I could get Schlitz in Seattle, WA. 1 of best take-aways is that they are all pretty similar. I tried Schlitz once here (12 pack) and I liked it. It was my father's favorite in the 50's to early '70's. He was from Wisconsin, too. I also enjoy Coors and Miller.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před 11 měsíci +1

      That is certainly a big takeaway. You get a lot more separation as far as good and bad once you get into light beers which we also did a blind tasting video of recently, but in this category it's kind of hard to go wrong if you are in the mood for that type of beer. Thanks for watching! Cheers

  • @shawnlabroix6886
    @shawnlabroix6886 Před rokem +3

    What a superb review, Gents! As a Canadian, I can only get high life at the local beer store. Interesting that Roger noted a difference between the bottle and can versions. In fact, up in Canada, the bottles are imported from Milwaukee and the canned versions are brewed locally by Molson. Both are tasty, but I prefer the bottles. (Plus, the bottles are cheaper). Lastly, On business trips through Michigan , I always grab some Hamms', Strohs', Schlitz or Old Style. Just love these American Macros!!

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem

      Interesting on the cans being brewed locally. That would definitely create a noticeable difference. Thanks for watching! Cheers 🍻

    • @laudanum669
      @laudanum669 Před rokem +1

      I work at a liquor store in Wisconsin we sell a 4 pack of Hamm's Tall Boys for $2:50. So 2 4 packs equals about 11 12 OZ beers for $5. We also sell 30 packs of Hamm's 12 OZ for $13. But our best selling beer is 30 packs of 12 OZ Busch lite for $22. I'm a die hard Hamm's guy myself.

    • @shawnlabroix6886
      @shawnlabroix6886 Před rokem

      @@laudanum669 Just bought a 30 of Hamms in michigan @ 13.99. Solid macro imo. Would really love to try Extra Gold Lager by Coors but tough to find

    • @bucknasty69
      @bucknasty69 Před rokem +1

      That’s nuts you guys can get Hamm’s that cheap up north. I hardly see it around down here in Texas, and the cheapest 30 pack I can get is High Life for $20. I miss Hamm’s, I drank a lot of it in college. Used to get 30 packs for $15 when I went to college up in Kansas.

  • @ronaldtheriot
    @ronaldtheriot Před rokem +12

    Schlitz is my favorite, in this lineup.

  • @DSToNe19and83
    @DSToNe19and83 Před rokem +1

    Hahaha, this should be golden... like the high life! Plus don’t forget this buds for you and the mountains are blue!
    My favorite will be always the original American blue ribbon award winning Americas world’s fair!
    Still my favorite, red white and blue... with a ribbon on top!
    🍻

  • @j.landismartin5397
    @j.landismartin5397 Před rokem +1

    The original Michelob was my beer of choice since high school (I graduated in '83) till it was discontinued. Yuengling has been my go-to since. In fact, I'm enjoying one now. Don't recall ever having a Schlitz but remember my dad and his friends having it around back in the '70's. Think I'll look around for it and pick up a 6-pack for my own taste test.

  • @willcool713
    @willcool713 Před rokem +10

    Just an interesting side note, Coors makes its big money with high-end ceramics for electronics, mostly as a defense contractor. The beer side of things acts mostly as a PR wing, though it's definitely a strong concern in its own right. In the early '90's I worked for a laser scribing firm, and a single Coors ceramic plate, about 4"x4", was about $100, and once it was scribed, punched, and snapped, was worth as much as $50K. Coors had the market cornered, and was the only manufacturer of the specific type of required, military-grade porcelain for certain defense contract circuit boards. The little firm I worked for (seven people) probably went through 200-300 plates per day, five days per week. (It took a lot of time to build up the power in the capacitor banks, and the system could only cut a half dozen or so pieces per cycle.) That's over $100,000/week that Coors got from us alone. (And we made about the same, I believe, after energy, equipment, payroll, and basic overhead. The two owners were raking it in.)
    (The most fun was the excimer laser, which could punch through a half inch of plate steel in under half a second. You'd do a x-ray resistant ceramic stencil first, and put that in the way of the excimer aperture and -- Flash! -- an 8"x8" area of steel plate would be cut into whatever shapes, to tolerances that could only be checked by electron microscope.)

    • @gamemeister27
      @gamemeister27 Před rokem +3

      I honestly had no idea! That's super interesting man

    • @SilverbackGorilla69
      @SilverbackGorilla69 Před rokem +3

      Making a comment so I don't forget this. Never knew, very interesting.

    • @Mike-jv4rz
      @Mike-jv4rz Před rokem +2

      @@gamemeister27 Agreed great info...

    • @fiteboss
      @fiteboss Před rokem +1

      Yeah, CoorsTek makes some really nice precision squares and other metrology equipment too. Big $$

    • @scarhart53
      @scarhart53 Před 4 měsíci +1

      Miller-Coors is owned by Molson out of Canada. All they make is beer.

  • @fixed970
    @fixed970 Před rokem +4

    I’m sitting here with a glass of Hamms, laughing at these guys!

  • @charlesjessie1733
    @charlesjessie1733 Před rokem +2

    Miller high life, unless I can get Miller Genuine Draft. Now that is a dad's beverage. Enough to take off the edge from a long day, but not commit domestic violence.

  • @chuckharst8676
    @chuckharst8676 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Grain Belt still going well in upper Midwest. First thing i do when I visit is buy a 12 pack in bottles. Very very good beer.

  • @brianandrews4716
    @brianandrews4716 Před rokem +4

    Nice video. Out of that line up I'll take the bottled High Life all day.

  • @mondoenterprises6710
    @mondoenterprises6710 Před rokem +11

    Now if they can only bring Stroh's copper kettle fire brewed beer back.

    • @csnide6702
      @csnide6702 Před rokem +1

      and get it back in Detroit

    • @brent69
      @brent69 Před rokem +2

      Old style

    • @mondoenterprises6710
      @mondoenterprises6710 Před rokem +1

      @@csnide6702 If it's good enough for Clem Snide, it's good enough for me.

    • @csnide6702
      @csnide6702 Před rokem +3

      @@brent69 Heileman's Old Style was HUGE in Chicago area - for a long time !

    • @Mike-jv4rz
      @Mike-jv4rz Před rokem

      And Alex ....

  • @beardorocks
    @beardorocks Před měsícem +1

    I rotate between Hamms, PBR, Highlife, Old Style and Coors. After 20 years of mostly craft brew, ive gone back to my roots.

  • @brendamackel6917
    @brendamackel6917 Před 4 měsíci +1

    My dad was a Schlitz drinker when I was a kid. Of the macrobrews you had here it is pretty much the only one I’d drink. I’m a craft brewing fan.

  • @MidNight-ns7is
    @MidNight-ns7is Před 3 měsíci +4

    Miller high Life in the bottle is always my go-to, the original Schlitz recipe is right up there and I'm glad they brought it back. It's just kind of hard to find where I live. Great show! This was a lot of fun. Thanks!

  • @fionnmaccumhaill3257
    @fionnmaccumhaill3257 Před rokem +4

    In beer taste testing, the taste gets better the more you drunk.

  • @wellfleation1
    @wellfleation1 Před 5 měsíci +2

    Out of all those bad beers, I would go PBR all day every day on a hot summer day.

  • @brianhayes7153
    @brianhayes7153 Před rokem +2

    PBR is a good beer and glad to see it still hanging on and doing well. I also like Hamm’s. Wish it would have been part of your test.

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem

      Yeah there are several beloved regionalized beers that just don't seem to make their way down to our market in Georgia so we couldn't get them for this tasting. We will look for some when we travel though. I'd like to try them.

  • @dane5896
    @dane5896 Před rokem +3

    I had not seen or heard of Narragansett, until this year, here in New Jersey. I recently saw Hamm's beer for the first time. 🍻

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem

      Ohhh, Hamm's ey? That's a new one on me. Sounds worth a try.

    • @ryantaylor3945
      @ryantaylor3945 Před rokem +1

      I was wondering where Hamm's was in this lineup bc I thought it was a very old brew as well.

    • @drbobdrake
      @drbobdrake Před 4 měsíci

      Narragansett was a very popular beer in New England and was a major sponsor of the Boston Red Sox out of Cranston, Rhode Island. The brand went out of business but was brought back several years ago with great success. Cans of Narragansett featured in the film Jaws.
      “Hi, neighbor, have a ‘Gansett!”

  • @familytrieserichiltz940
    @familytrieserichiltz940 Před rokem +9

    I’d love to see you do a battle of all of the bud beers including Michelob, Busch, Natural and see what the main differences are.

    • @MichaelWilson-sn1yo
      @MichaelWilson-sn1yo Před rokem +5

      I grew up up in a Budweiser house when I was a kid. Next door neighbor drove a short order truck for Budweiser that wasn't locked up at night until some teenagers got in there and had a party! He knew right away something was wrong when he smelled the residue of cigs and weed in his truck. He locked it up after that!

    • @tomsherwood4650
      @tomsherwood4650 Před rokem +2

      You know why they use horses in their advertising, don't you???

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem +2

      Great idea! We will definitely keep that one in mind 🍻

    • @billybandyk0720
      @billybandyk0720 Před rokem +2

      @@MichaelWilson-sn1yo Kool, Mike. Now THAT'S how u get FREE BEER!!!!! RAID THE BEER TRUCK!!!!! 2 which I say "WINNER, WINNER!!!!!! LIQUID FUCKIN' DINNER!!!!!"

    • @DWilliam1
      @DWilliam1 Před rokem +1

      Michelob was a treat growing up. Can’t find it in NY anymore. Loved that beer

  • @scottbaron121
    @scottbaron121 Před 4 měsíci +2

    Hell...I didn't know they even made Schlitz any more!

    • @jimsonjohnson3761
      @jimsonjohnson3761 Před 3 měsíci

      Pbr brews it along with other old time locality beers. Schlitz is honestly amazing.

  • @iasimov5960
    @iasimov5960 Před rokem +3

    Of those tested, my favorites are Yuengling, Schilz, and Pabst. Do they even make Blatz anymore?

    • @leemehan
      @leemehan Před rokem

      Yes they do! I am from Wisconsin and it is here

  • @ClancyWoodard-yw6tg
    @ClancyWoodard-yw6tg Před 11 měsíci +7

    I'm a coors banquet man You cannot beat a cold Yellow Jacket on a hot summer day And my dad was a Budweiser Drinker I believe he got introduced to it while he was in Vietnam

  • @seekingagreatperhaps6391

    The sheer stress I feel watching videos on any macro beer review is I can actually sense them getting warm as discussion happens and I start wrinkling my nose and then I realize I am on a mote of dust around an obscure star and nothing matters and we are all just cosmic dust in the wind and then I sigh and then I want a beer.

  • @tweezerjam
    @tweezerjam Před 3 měsíci +1

    Yuengling only began brewing their flagship Lager in the 1980s. Their original beer is their Lord Chesterfield Ale, followed by their premium (pilsner) and porter varieties.

  • @barberdoug6930
    @barberdoug6930 Před rokem +12

    Problem is all of the beers have changed formula thru the years

    • @congresssux9766
      @congresssux9766 Před rokem +3

      We the consumers allow it.
      Too many idiots drinking beer for a buzz instead of getting a buzz off an enjoyable drinks.

    • @mike289homebuilt5
      @mike289homebuilt5 Před 2 měsíci

      In the old days, everything was organic, everything felt more upbeat

  • @markreeves9026
    @markreeves9026 Před rokem +4

    I advise to try yuengling black and tan, good stuff.

  • @Tyler-wp3ns
    @Tyler-wp3ns Před rokem +2

    Looks like my beer fridge!Just need Old Style, Hamm’s, Busch, Stag, Grain Belt, Iron City, Molson Canadian, Michelob Golden Draft and Natural Ice.

  • @Old_Sailor85
    @Old_Sailor85 Před rokem +2

    Miller and Coors (since it went nationwide) tastes like soap to me. College it was Buckhorn, Old Milwaukee, or anything else that was less than $5 a case. Old Style if we were splurging or buying "kegs".
    I actually like what people call "skunky" beer. Almost all are in green bottles. Heineken, Moosehead, Grolsch, etc.
    FWIW, I worked at Christian Schmidt Brewing Company for a few years until they closed in 1986. We had 100 labels. We also made Rolling Rock when they were om strike. Rolling Rock's recipe made little CO2 and we had to carbonate the heck out of it. Schmidt's beer actually made excess CO2 that we compressed, liquified, and sold or used for other brews. Schmidt's Classic was my favorite.

    • @fixed970
      @fixed970 Před rokem

      Loved the Schmidt’s wild life cans!

  • @davesmith4757
    @davesmith4757 Před rokem +3

    Dad beer? You mean real beer.

  • @Beadle553
    @Beadle553 Před rokem +5

    I liked Genny Cream Ale in the returnable bottles, it had taste all its own. The older the bottles, the better the taste. When they discontinued the returnable bottles, it lost that taste. Can't drink it from cans.

    • @kgilliagorilla2761
      @kgilliagorilla2761 Před rokem

      I live in Chicago. I get Genny in 12packs for about $8. Would love to try bottles. I switch between High Life and PBR for everyday beer. The Genny is a smooth alternative.

    • @kentmarsh6442
      @kentmarsh6442 Před rokem

      My dad always had a quarter keg of Genny Cream in the Beermiester when I was a kid.

  • @Oddzilla51
    @Oddzilla51 Před 4 měsíci +1

    Years ago, my father-in-law had a taste test between very popular and expensive beers and also threw in Old Milwaukee. Turns out, Old Milwaukee was the most picked as the best in the test.

    • @dukeford
      @dukeford Před 4 měsíci +1

      An underrated beer.

  • @chrisgeo1642
    @chrisgeo1642 Před 9 dny +1

    I refer to these as bowling beers and honestly I hardly ever drink light American lagers. However have done a blind taste of them and miller was my top with colors as my second. The thing about coors is it gets skunky quite easily and my guess is the sample that was used here was skunked for those that don’t know what that is when a beer goes through a few temperature changes warm, cold, warm very cold and then served as it warms up again it gets really weird off flavor. Coors is notorious for getting skunky. Bud was my least favorite filled by pbr and Michelob was my third. I do like Narragansett and live in an area it’s distributed in but it was not part of my blind test.

  • @michaelquintman2228
    @michaelquintman2228 Před rokem +3

    Fun fact: Narragansett is actually brewed at the Genesee brewing company in upstate New York. I recommend the Genesee cream ale!

    • @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539
      @drinkingwithcraigandroger4539  Před rokem

      I’ve had that cream ale before and liked it just fine but it’s been several years since I’ve seen it here in Georgia 🍻

    • @kentmarsh6442
      @kentmarsh6442 Před rokem

      Right now, Genny is making Winter Bock available. I haven't had it in years, but I'm sure it's not the same.

    • @AppalachianTemplar
      @AppalachianTemplar Před rokem +1

      Genny Cream Ale was the college beer of choice, back in my day.

    • @myleftthumb2294
      @myleftthumb2294 Před rokem

      @@AppalachianTemplar Yep, 16 oz Genny pounders.

  • @mrben6573
    @mrben6573 Před rokem +8

    I haven't had beer in years but I might try and pick up some Schlitz. I'm a history buff so I think it's neat that Papst brought back the original recipe.

  • @UncleBlasto
    @UncleBlasto Před 10 měsíci +1

    That animated Miller High Life sign is amazing.

  • @powellmountainmike8853
    @powellmountainmike8853 Před rokem +2

    I generally prefer a rich malt taste without too much hops bitterness. I really like Newcastle Brown Ale the best of the commercially available beers. I also liked A-B's Red Wolf, which is no longer made, and Killian's Red. Of the typical American light lagers I like Narragansett the best. Have drunk many gallons of it in my life since, for more than half a century, I lived in RI. When I was a kid my parents favorite beer was Schlitz, although later on they developed a preference for 'Gansett.

    • @Deetman42
      @Deetman42 Před rokem

      Newcastle used to be my favorite beer. Now it's been bought by Heineken and in the USA the formula is changed and is brewed by Lienenkugel in California and I don't like it anymore. On a cruise this past summer they had Newcastle on the ship and on the bottle it said it was brewed in Tadcaster, North Yorkshire, England. It tasted great, just like I remembered!

  • @CrazyAboutVinylRecords
    @CrazyAboutVinylRecords Před 10 měsíci +9

    Yuengling Traditional Lager is the best of the lot.

  • @RWildekrav66
    @RWildekrav66 Před rokem +3

    Should have had Strohs and Old Style in there.

  • @justincovert6943
    @justincovert6943 Před rokem +1

    Being from long island my grand parents. Didn't drink any of that. It was Rheingold and gin sometimes whiskey. Upstate it turned to Genny Cream Ale.

  • @DickElectric
    @DickElectric Před 3 měsíci +1

    I love how all our memories are of dad or grandpa drinking his favorite brews back in the day....by the way my grandpa drank Old Milwaukee....I always got a sip and the golden retriever got a full one in his dog dish.

  • @leeallsopp5152
    @leeallsopp5152 Před 4 dny

    Fantastic! A lot are hard to get here in England.. not a fan of corrs or bud but I loved PBR when it was here briefly 🍺

  • @adameccleston1926
    @adameccleston1926 Před rokem +3

    you forgot the ultimate Grandpa fixed income beer . . . Hamm's

  • @jweider007
    @jweider007 Před rokem +58

    Yuengling has always been better than the rest.

    • @iggypopisgod9
      @iggypopisgod9 Před rokem +9

      its trash

    • @barkingmonkee
      @barkingmonkee Před rokem +10

      When I want to take a break from craft beers, or when only macro american lager types are available, I go for Yuengling. They make a porter that isn't bad as well.

    • @sneifert1968
      @sneifert1968 Před rokem

      Picked it out right away.

    • @HaimTabibi
      @HaimTabibi Před rokem +4

      My friends and family out west always require me to bring a case of Yuengling on my trips.

    • @loboheeler
      @loboheeler Před rokem +1

      Most everybody drank Yuengling in Pennsylvania, at least when they went out to the local watering hole. It's quite good, but maybe more of a local pride thing. Funny how some of the regional beers had such a following in other places. Look at Coors and Shiner before they became available nationally.

  • @DogSpeak
    @DogSpeak Před 3 měsíci +2

    At the end of the day, you drank more Yuengling than the others

  • @71rcode72
    @71rcode72 Před rokem +1

    I met my wife 26 years ago at a bar in Muenster Texas. I had a can of open Schlitz in each hand at the time. It's magical.

  • @skswig1
    @skswig1 Před rokem +3

    Miller High Life has changed since the 70's. Seems like it has too much foaming agents that stick to the glass.

    • @greybone777
      @greybone777 Před rokem

      Cheaper ingredients. In the 70s I talked to a master brewer and he said that Miller chose only the top quality ingredients. When the started genuine draft they actually started using hops flavoring instead of hops.

    • @skswig1
      @skswig1 Před rokem

      @@greybone777 never cared for the GD for the same reason. I wish I could get Shlitz in northwest florida