Congress is Responsible for the Trauma of The Partition | DU Lit. Fest |
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 05. 2024
- Every Indian is more or less aware of the partition of India, in 1947, for the good or the worse. For some even after multiple generations, it is a wound, that is far from healing, for there is next to no effort has been made to provide any restitution or even any kind of solace. On the contrary copious policies have been made that made the trauma ever-fresh in the memory. And the socio-political situation in India still made the real victims, that is the majority to carry the burden of that trauma.
In this video, we will find an intriguing discussion on the book "1947-1957 India: The Birth of a Republic".
The intricacies of the partition and the nature of independence in 1947 are deliberately being shunned by historians. Did Congress ever make any effort to stop the partition? What does dominion status really mean? What was the nature of the so-called independence in 1947? And why 1947, or even 15th August for that matter? What was the role of Congress in the transfer of population after partition? We will learn about these crucial matters in this session.
About The Speakers:
Chandrachur Ghose: He is an Independent researcher and writer on economics, environment, history, and politics. Author of books that unveil modern India's biggest political mysteries.
Anand Ranganathan: He is a scientist, an author, and a famous face on television debates on Politics, Media, and Science. His columns have appeared in Swarajya, DNA, etc.
Topics Covered:
00:00 Partition of India: Pre-planned by Congress
00:50 Introduction of The Speaker And The Book
02:30 The Bloodshed at The Time of The Independence
04:12 The Method of Our Independence: The Utter Failure of The Gandhi-Nehru Nexus
06:36 What Dominion Status Means
09:50 Partition of India: About Turn by Congress
15:38 15th August: Significance for Choosing The Date
16:22 The Farce of History Writing
19:09 The Collaborators: Burning of Pieces of Evidence
22:27 The Crimes of Congress And The Population Exchange: Horrors of The Partition
33:27 The Legacy of Policy of Congress: Waqf Properties
34:48 Was The Policy of Congress Deliberate?
36:05 The Vision of Shyamaprasad: Misunderstood Through Decades
38:09 Greed of Nehru: Why Congress Accepted The Radcliff Line Unconditionally?
41:36 Boycott of the Crips Mission: Not an Ideological Stand
43:46 Assassination of Gandhi And The Hypocrisy That Follows
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @sangamtalks
Join our CZcams channel to get updated on new video releases:
Hindi : / sangamhindi
English : / sangamtalks
Tamil : / @sangamtamizh
Punjabi : / @sangampunjabi
Bhojpuri : / @sangamtalksbhojpuri
Marathi : / @sangammarathi
Malayalam : / @sangammalayalam
Shorts : / @sangamtalkstv
Bangla : / @sangambangla
For updates you may follow us on:
Facebook : / sangamtalks
Instagram : / sangamtalks
Telegram : t.me/sangamtalks
Twitter : / sangamtalks
Whatsapp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va95...
Linkedin: / sangamtalks
Koo : www.kooapp.com/profile/sangam...
Website : www.sangamtalks.org
Donate : www.sangamtalks.org/donate
Anti-Hindu and Anti-India Gandhi, Nehru, and their Corrupt Congress Party are a Curse for India.
Were ? Is 😢
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
They did what their masters told them to. They are doing the same even today.
I know that's true. But there is a question.I still wonder how and why the true leaders were not strong enough to stop nehrus congress from overtaking india. ? There must be a good answer .I hope.
6:20 see . Something like this. Agar bose democratically jeet gaye they pm ki post toh gandhi ka verdict upar kyu allow kiya gaya. It makes zero sense on part of people who allowed it. Phir kara hi kyu election. Sidha gandhi se puch lete.
@@personaldata1270 Anti-Hindu and Anti-India Gandhi image was made Larger than that of God by Anti-Hindu Congress and Leftists. There was almost no opposition against Gandhi from RSS as its leaders were too weak oppose Gandhi was almost worshipped like a God by ignorant masses. Anti-Hindu and Anti-India Gandhi imposed Anti-Hindu and Anti-India incompetent Nehru as PM of India despite Sardar Patel winning an election for PM position.
My blood boils. Shameless Indian congress
But still some shameless PPL are voting them
Mujra kar.. 😂😂😂😂
@sanathanadharmama no we won't vote for pigs 😂😂😂😂 unfortunately khangress and Khajpai are two pigs
Khangress 🤲☪️🤲
@@KickoutMODI woh tou Sonia Gandhi ka pesha tha Mujra kar ke Rajiv Gandhi 1 Rupaya bhejata hoon Janta ko 15 paisen Milten hai.
Ye nahin bol ki Maine Mujarewali ko laya hai baaki uss par udana padta hai, nahin udaunga tou dusre ke bistar mein cablaah karti hai😂
Gandhi was a Father of Anti-Hindu and Muslim Appeasement Politics in India.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Very Rightly Said ✅✅
I agree with you, 100 percent. Gandhi was the father of Muslim Appeasement politics in INDIA. TRUE
@@TheRaman1962 I guess that's why THEY recognize him as "Mahatma"
Rabindranath Tagore was given NOBEL prize , due to special recommendation by Karamchand Gandhi, and Tagore gave him the title of MAHATMA. It was a deal between two popular men, in those times
I have never called him Father of Nation.. that's a marketed product by the Nehru Pseudo Gandhis and the West. He is one person who is responsible for all the sorrows that India (Bharat) suffered
Father of the Nation...my a$$. Desh ki ma ch0d ke rashtra pita bana...sala tharkee buddha
We are STILL suffering.
As a 2nd generation decendent of Partition, I am glad someone is talking about this. I am sick of hearing the Congress lies and have my blood boil. We need to heal and only by the truth can we heal. Anyways Congress was the reason behind Partition and the geneocide, which my country paid the price for.
I saw the trains of butchered Hindus men women and children and I was a small child at that time and going to rialway station for giving help i was so much hurt that i could not take my food for days as those horendous scenes of blood and amputated men and women and children. These congies are now saying India got freedom without shedding blood they want the Hindus to forget those trains full of dead bodies coming from Pakistan territory and that hatred in congress for Hindus still continues.
Soooooooooo true..we have an intelligent logical thinker, bold speaker echoing our anguish
😢😢😢, it's history& we were made blind to know the real truth of our own motherland.
We have to live with shame, but the coming generation will definitely know the real truth.
Millions of lives were drastically ruined by a couple of congress men who thought that they owned this nation. Millions of lives continue to be affected because of their terrible egos. The huge number of young girls crying helplessly as they are taken away to be converted and married in pakistan is the extremely frightening and sad. Shame on the those responsible for dividing India. Shame on those who appease the violent, despite Indias history painfully displaying what its invaders did to it.
Not to mention so many kids who became orphans. What was there fault and Gandhi went on strike when the hindu refugees came after the atrocities done to them , he say if you don’t give pakistan 50 crier that we promised them I will go on strike . He never cared about those Hindus but his other family.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Anti-Hindu and Anti-India Gandhi image was made Larger than that of God by Anti-Hindu Congress and Leftists. There was almost no opposition against Gandhi from RSS as its leaders were too weak to oppose Gandhi as he was almost worshipped like a God by ignorant masses. Anti-Hindu and Anti-India Gandhi imposed Anti-Hindu and Anti-India incompetent Nehru as PM of India despite Sardar Patel winning an election for PM position.
@@102679nc and after that refugee attempted to murder gandhi for 3 times.
@@102679nc There is no other family. The gandi was Jesuit in his thinking and believing the nonsensical message from Jesus of 'turn other cheek' and 'resist no evil'. Hence gandhi and the partition aftermath due to gandhian decisions due to which Hindus suffered is a testament that christianity is pool of lies, Jesus was a dumb person who believed and wanted the world to end, hence christianity and Jesus should not be rejected by every and any Hindu.
Great to hear from Chandrachurda and Mr Rangnathan about the stories from the day of partition and knowing how our politicians were so greedy, selfish and short sighted
Simply Mind Blowing . Jai Hind 🇮🇳
My head almost exploded listening to this. We should hold something like the Nuremberg trials.
It took a decade for such talks to happen in DU and other campuses . Finally the youth is listening to the other side of the story and they’re wise enough to decide what’s the truth .
The whole world was watching the migration of Hindus moving towards India except Gandhi who never in true sense understood or accepted the criminality of peacefuls.
Gandhi was a criminal. It is much to be said about an entire generation when they decided to put their aspirations in the hands of a mad immoral man.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
when was this event organized? they're wearing sweaters.
Partition was a outcome of a closed room meeting between British labour party, congress,muslim league, communists....U agree disagree it's upto u
@@rockyluvinfrnd8180Mountbatten also. He reportedly declared division even surprising Nehru and Gandhi etc.
An excellent and insightful discussion by both Chandrachur Ghose and Anand Ranganathan.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
All this should be taught in school
Most bharatiyas still do NOT KNOW WAQF!
1940 census Undivided India
Total population 38 crore
Muslims 9.5 cr 25%
Muslims in Pak Punjab & Bengal 6.5 Cr
Muslims left in India after partition 3 Cr (9% of 32 Cr ) and most stayed back.
While in Pak East and West, Non Muslims reduced 50% to 2%
In India Muslims grew from 9% to 20% & now India has biggest Muslim population
this was the actual plan but hindus failed to force them out complete and now this problem is again here so hindus will again ready for another partition now?? and notice how muslims are working on west bengal kerala and j&K to scratch them from india this is how they operate , just keep scratching small small part from big portion
We are going to have an unpleasant surprise after upcoming census.
We should officially remove Minority status of the community.
Great to hear from Dr. Anand Ranganathan Ji and the Chandrachud Ghosh 👏👏👏👌✌️🙏
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Love it! A whole BIG mass of historical facts are coming out from the depths at which they were hidden by INC. Truly, we got freedom from Brown Sahibs in 2014! 22nd Jan 2024, we have established Republic of Ramrajya. A lot of work is to be done to undo the damage done by Midnight Children n Communists.
Dr Ambedkars prophesy that the "problem of Minority Majority can only be solved by total population exchange" must be extensively publicized all over India and even to the world.
What an expose to people like me in such an encapsulated form ❤❤
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
My God....what all happened and we were never allowed to know till now...Cheif Burning Officer....what a shame on Congress
Thank you very much for the hidden Truths. ❤
No thanks are enough to this channel for the insights of the true history. ❤❤❤
Great insightful facts straight from a knowledgeable historian Chandrachud Ghosh. Absolutely sad that 1.4 billion Indian students and people were never told these truths for 75 years. Indian history books have to be updated immediately. India needs a benevolent dictator to correct history and take India to progress n growth.
Thanks sir tell us insight view. 👌
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Congress is as much responsible for the trauma of partition as much Muslim league. Anand Ranganathan is simply great.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Partition was proposed by congress 1942.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Gandhi accepted the partition in 1940 in his essay in the Harijan. In 1943, Gandhi prepared a plan to partition and send it to Jinnah through Rajagopalachari.
Both Gandhi and Jinnah were British agents. British planned Pakistan in 1934 as the area where they would stay if they had to leave India to stop the Soviet Union coming to the Middle East.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Indian partition principle lies in Quran where there is a clear distinction of kaffirs are not eligible to rule muslims so majority muslims voted for partition but Gandhi and Congress asked them to stay so that we may become their loyal votebank,now we muslims are demanding another partision be ready
@@yusofahmed4169 Peaceful Islamic Sharia Society & Sunnah Hadith Islamic Theology are realities of this world.
We r lucky enough to see good progress in kashmir.....hope to see it as a state
On 15 aug 1947, ease dont lower the uniommn jack. And Nehru said yes. INA protested and they were barred to e ter Red Fort
For me it was Dominique LaPierre 's book freedom at midnight which opened my eyes that there was much more to this so called independence ...than was told to the people of India..
Really amazing inside conversation.thanks for sharing these new revelations.
Very happy to see closeness
Jai Shree Ram 🚩
The communists were so ungrateful in dishonoring Netaji and Shyama Prasad Mukherjee.
India is speaking now boldly......
I have witnessed the pangs of post-partition trauma that shattered Bengal. The pain is still haunting.
Partition of sylhet, chittagong hill tracts, was a fraudulent act of nehru, Gopinath Bordoloi and Radcliffe.
Different states of India are STILL suffering in 2024, because of criminal decisions taken against the will of Hindus.
It was a partial Islamic country till 2014.
What about Khulna Jessore
Whatever you know , please document it and tell the next generation to spread and pass on to as many people of coming generations
'The cake waiting in the next room' is Goal Gradient Effect, its a psychological principle. So True.
Why yoounger generation alone even older people have no idea of what had transpired between Congress leaders and British or anything in 1947.
We are able to access some of the Declassified files of those era, we have social & global exposure now, which helps people to spread the truth.
Learnt a great deal. Thank you both for this interesting debate. We should have more of such informative discussions.
It is ironical that congress is having Bharat jodo yatra, when they were the cause of partition...
Totally fascinating discussion. Look forward to reading yr book. Thank you Mr Ghose.
Thank you both 🙏
Loved each and every bit of conversation.
Beautiful discussion. Thanks, both of you !!
Absolutely Crazy !!! everytime we think that congress can not stoop any lower then Lehru ji be like "Hold Edvina's beer"
I'm so happy!
What a Fantastic discussion … how much we don’t know … how much we need to know …
I thank sangam talks to hold this discussion before elections so that people will rout khangress.
That Partition Mentality still prevails in the Congress Party. Latest example Divide North and South India. Jai Hind !
Thanks 😊
Great insights unravelled. True we were taught wrong history. But I was wondering why Mahatma Gandhi who fought for our independence was conspicuously absent in the famous midnight speech in the Parliament by our revered Hon’ble first Prime Minister of Independent India. Now the undeniable truth is out after 2014
Now Indian is happy...
Partition was the Best Policy..Atleast 22% problem has gone/ vanished ❤❤😂😂
People who were watching the whole game from the gallery are blaming those who were playing in the middle of deliberately having lost the game.
One of the extremely important conversations in these times, and much needed to heal the wounds of not-so-distant past which are still plaguing our future.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Partition was so damn incomplete & damn cruel!
When the Chittagong Hill District with 98 percent Buddhists and other non-Muslims tribes went to Pakistan, the leader of the Chakma tribe Santu Larma went to Nehru to object, but Nehru drove him out of his room.
Don't keep on harping on partition Partition was a blessing in disguise My parents came from West Punjab Initially there was some rather lot of suffering but then they got over it gradually came to the view that whatever happened happened for the good
On hindsight it seems that partition was good in the long term. One of the demands of Muslim League was that Muslim personal laws/ Sharia laws would prevail . Would our country made any progress under these conditions? Would Ram Mandir happened?Of course it's another story that Congress leaders wanted to grab power. The whole transfer of power was managed by a clique without any accountability to the people.
Its not just the younger generations not knowing the freedom struggle or the nuisances of the Partition, even the older generations too are not aware of all the secretive details as its not mentioned in any books nor talked about them in open seminars or in any such gatherings....i think only handful of people are holding this knowledge close to their chest....
People who have gone through the trauma during partition know the pain and sufferings.
Mostly Punjabis, Sindhis, etc migrated from now Pakistan.
@@PK-nb7fb & especially us Bengalis😢
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
@@PK-nb7fbthat is not what he means.
The events surrounding partition from a lived trauma perspective could righty be captured by survivor accounts and documentary videos.
But what of the perpetrators, traitors and co British operators within the INC ? As Mr Bose said in this video, the destruction of documents is no big secret, yet our society has given free rein to congress and its scions.
@@PK-nb7fb
You forgot to mention the Bengalis.
Interesting conversation on the partition story.
*Nice Informative Video🙏*
Thought provoking!!
Thanks!
Gandhi, Nehru,the family ruined Bharat thoroughly. Need to disclose their darker side of acts that affected majority people of Bharat.
Fully and totally accept that Congress IS the main cause for India's SLOW development, rampant corruption and many other High Handed things. FACT for sure. But my question now, in 2024. WHAT DID THE GOONS, CALLED THE BJP, HEADED BY A CHAIWALA DO, TO ELEVATE THE LIVING STANDARDS OF THE COMMON MIDDLE CLASS CITIZEN OF INDIA????? Electoral Bonds???? Ache Din???? 15L for everybody, brought back from illegally parked, black money from abroad. All your talk about 1947, had Absolutely No relevance today. We were made to understand that 2014 will be the turning point for India, ache din!!! You are wasting your time, presenting IRRELEVANT nonsense, aimed at MISLEADING innocent, ignorant, unfortunate CITIZENS of India. 🙏🙏🙏
The real indirect war criminals Gandhi and Nehru were responsible for defaming Netaji as a war criminal hiding in Russia under the protection of Stalin. Also, both criminals were involved in dividing India. Jai hind.
👍👍
Youngsters don't really mind...don't want to know...for what reason on earth, should I know past?... Is their question...😮😮
The idea of Purna Swaraj, Complete Independence was first propagated by Sri Aurobindo. It was in 1907 Surat Congress that this resolution was passed. Later this was taken up by Netaji, who in letter to his friend Dilip Kumar Roy wrote, "I have dedicated my life to the ideals of Aurobindo Ghosh."
Shouldn't we try this fellow Nehru, posthumously, for the trick he played . And he was lolling around with Edwina Mountbatten while millions were being massacred during the partition. And then the biggest crime was to inflict on us a traitorous dynasty now bent on dealing away parts of our country by a Pappu and his mother.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Can't agree more with Mr Ghosh on partition
🙏❤️🙏
Brilliant jibe at the end about the sterilisation department working well!
❤
Investigation needs to be done sir/mam
Dada putting interesting spin #perspective 😢
I always doubted this because indipendence is taken by force and violence not by peaceful means
jai hind
100 percent.
This is too painful for words. I cannot reconcile myself to the lack of wisdom of gandhi and nehru. As part of the diaspora I implore Indians to vote with caution.
Chandrachur dada darun bola...💥💥💥🇮🇳
If Gandhi would have started his hunger srikes against the Pakistan proposal in 1940 would there be partition? If Gandhi had accepted the Cabinet Mission Plan in 1946 ignoring the opposition to the plan by Gopinath Bordoloi and the Assam -Congress there would not be any Direct action Days Killings and partition. However, Gandhi even wrote a letter to Clement Attlee to get rid of General Wavell who was against the partition. Lord Mountbatten came as a result to partition India as soon as possible and Gandhi and Nehru were very friendly to Lord Mountbatten, who was responsible to invite Radcliffee, who knew nothing about India, to divide India. If Gandhi would have started his hunger strike even in June or July 1947, the British could not divide India.
Gandhi after the partition started his hunger strike in Calcutta in 16 August 1947 to save the Muslims of Calcutta but for the Hindus he suggested them to be sacrificed but not to do any retaliation. Why could not he do any hunger strike in June 1947 to stop the partition as in that case Muslims would be safe everywhere, even in Punjab ?????.
The younger generations do not know how difficult it was to get freedom? They should be told every single day, make them realise that things were not at all easy for people of Bharat . They should be taught to uphold it at cost in their lives and pass it on to next generations.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
Glad to get opportunities to watch/listen to real history of what actually happened pre & post 'independence(1947) & how our so called leaders of that era played diviously against Bharath's interests & completely anti hindu.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance is spearheaded by Khan-gress Party.
The first Indians flag raced in Singapore by Subash Babu. So that was India at that time but not today's India 🤔
Because of the partation of 1947 and because of Congress even some of us from the new generation are suffering in many places. Specially in NE though we are born in this country we are still called refugees because our grandfather came from West or East Pakistan.
To have freedom in the hands of congress is the worst thing ever happened in free India!
Late freedom without congress could have done wonder to India!
I also love Anand ❤❤😂😂
Absolutely bitterness truths 101%
Gandhi made India his Lab for secularism
Soya huaa Hindu nahi Jag raha hai, Soya huaa Deshbhakt Jaag raha hai.
Listen what Godasay said in court, Godassy did right job
How I hate that Cyril Radcliffe....."Sir"
Rahul Gandhi can never answer a single question from these gentleman man.. he has to hide his face
Dominion status mane nehru raja
Clement atlee raja
No discussion should take place on Partition.
This generation is happy with the Partition ..😅😅😅😅India is not interested to take back the Problem 😅😅😅😅
Dear Mr. Chandrachur Ghosh & Mr. Anand Ranganathan, your contents of discussion about the acheiving Independence from British was first highlighted based on records & documents by Dr. Pankaj Phadnis more than 20 yrs back. You also referred Shashi Tharoor in this regard . Dr Phadnis has furnished details extensively also of domanian status. Its a book (The unfinished story of Indian Freedom Struggle) having about 1900 pages. He has raised this question in court as well. Many of Podcast personalities are not different as they are conviniently avoiding the mention of a common man Dr. Phadnis for obvious reason. I will sincerely appreciate if you are bold enough to refer his findings for which he spent about a decade of reseaech. The other part of your discussion is really worth listening. Such findings must be linked with Dr. Phadnis.
Who is him ? His book is available?
AR: the sterilisation dept works well
me: that was below the 'belt'
Bharat has suffered prior, during and even after independence. Where is republic, when there are different rules and privilege for citizens. That too ,after having given 30% of land and resources to Muslims of India and created another country at the cost of Hindus. More than one million people lost their lives...... What is the cost of one life or one million people 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
If congress appose godse why did they kill all the Brahmins.
39:31 was that cake Edwina Mountbatten by any chance..?
Congress which agreed to divide the country based on religion did not negotiate for the rights of minorities in Pakistan ..Why???.. And why did congress leave Kartapur Sikhi...a very significant place for sikhs and which is just a few kilometers away from the border ....in Pakistan?????
The way the partition happened and all our leaders agreed shows they were public enemy, blood in their hands, they all were British agents. Army were removed and the line of partitition was announced abruptly so that slaughtering can go on . Now we all know our so called father of nation and Nehru, Jinnah ,Patel were all British collaborators. So we are still a 3rd world . Some bussinessmen did drug smuggling, money laundering (hundi) in collaboration with British . They were amply rewarded . Now that is considered as virtue. They are our heros ! God save us.