@@PhillipHerrera-dd7nl you have to do all the interactions with mickey as arthur and then when you’re in the epilogue with john and you talk to him he’ll tell you that you remind him of a feller he knew back named alan but he’s talking about arthur
They are friends, more brothers. Both were pick up of the streets by Dutch and Hosea at young ages. Arthur joined Dutch van der Linde's gang when he was fourteen and John was 12 when he met Dutch in 1885.
@@badboyofficalgamingI think it’s a bounty hunting mission in the epilogue - you have to let Anthony Foreman go as Arthur in Chapter 4 though. Hope this helps
@@talharoxen I’ve beat it 3 times almost 4, it ain’t about how cool and badass he is it’s about his appearance I can’t find no good clothes without mods
Nah I’d say John takes the title of “boogie man” to other gangs. He took down the Laramie Gang, the Skinners, Micah's gang, the Bollard Twins Gang, the Treasure Hunter Gang, Dutch’s gang, del lobos, Bill's Gang, the bandits at the river crossing, the rebels and the Mexican Army, a fuck ton of pinkertons, a fuck ton of investigation Bureau agents, and basically everyone else who stood in his way.
I’d say Arthur was the Marksman, sure he was one of the strongest but nobody compared to his shooting. Everybody came with an colt and a rifle. Arthur came prepared with two colts/pistols, and two rifles. Brother was the army of the group
@@Whoisthat698 True but was he the one always doing the "dirty" work no not really unlike Arthur, Charles didn't like hurting innocent beings for money ect(Not saying Arthur liked it but he still did it anyways)
@@Lupo32 they were more brutal, and Mac was arguably the best hand to hand fighter the gang has ever had ( you can overhear Uncle saying he once saw Mac beat up FIFTEEN sailors in a fight), but in the wild west being a more skilled gunslinger was far more important, and in that John and Arthur vastly outclassed the Callander brothers.
@@WalterWhite0192 that'd be cool..but it'd also be cool to have a main protagonist that doesn't die at the end of the game, at least once in a trilogy ahah
I remeber back in the day, when rdr fans were sceptical about Arthur Morgan, because everyone grew up with John and didn't wanted an new protagonist, but boy oh boy, did Arthur turned out to be an even more loveable Character.
I can’t tell if this is a joke or not. But if it isn’t then that defies the whole point of this edit as well as the people praising Arthur in the comments. It’d mean that Foreman is just referencing the player’s body weight, and since Arthur meets Foreman In Chapter 2/4, most people wouldn’t really be skinny by then, but in the Epilogue, most people have an underweight John.
only if you’ve never played the first game, idk if rockstar had different devs but they must’ve had something against john, what you see in rd2 is NOT john marston or ANYTHING like how he’s talked about in rd1, there’s dialogue where he mentions or talks about his past and it’s not present even a little bit in the second game. i hate seeing people constantly dick ride arthur just because they chose to play 2 before 1, the reason you don’t like him is because they put zero effort and made him completely one dimensional compared to arthur, where they actually tried. i think it’s about time you figure out the difference between a bad character and a poorly made character, one is genuinely not good/antagonist like and the other is just a flat character because the devs were lazy with them
@@whenitsover3479 Pretty sure they just made him like that to prove a point how John changed during the gang to after it, after all it's like 12 years between rdr2 and rdr1, so let's agree, the John in rdr2 is not in his prime at all, but he's getting there
@@whenitsover3479 imma dick ride arthur till the end he’s more of a unit, fought the biggest guy in town, fastest gunslinger. And never said I didn’t like John he cool and all but Arthur’s just physically tougher, I think he’s more cowboy realistic then John so to speak not wearing an eyepatch and shit
@@whenitsover3479 bro sit down. We’re talking about rockstar games they don’t get lazy. John is the way that he is in red dead 2 because he’s in the process of changing.
No, they don't. They made John the same hight, but he's still much more slender than Arthur and he moves completely different. It's very easy to spot the difference and tell them apart, even if they wear the same clothes.
@@Lxzaa Nah bro it's gonna be mac Callender, hosea , Dutch or our boy Arthur if we see him die like in High honour but in low honour he got shot in the head I guess it only 3 of them but I think we see Arthur in rdr3 because the game is going backwards in timeline
Even at one moment it seemed to me that when he said no, his voice was similar to Arthur’s voice and I thought that Arthur was alive, but then I realized that he was just saying no, but his voice was very similar to Arthur’s voice at that moment.
It's funny how i saw another edit like this (he was bigger) 2 hours ago and wanted to see a better edit then just an hour later one of my favourite video creators made the edit
You are an amazing YT RDR Series Creator. Those edits are as fire as hell man, keep up the good work. That transition with John was unexpected and I love it.
@@mahdybenamara3121 John in most sources is measured as 5'10''. Meanwhile Arthur in half of sources i found he was listed as 6'1'' and the other half as 6'2''. So i suppose he's somewhere in the middle of these 2 recorded heights
Yall I just finished the main game and I couldnt stop crying for like 2 days. Such a heart wrenching story. Even Dutch’s Voice actor said he had a difficult time with the last scene
I’ve always loved that little call back to Arthur.
This game has some of the best small details I swear
is what made this game so damn impressive, like even with mickey the homeless vet when he referred to arthur in the epilogue
@zacs6996, how do we know he's talking about Arthur? I was just wondering bc idk
@@ciccery69and how do u do this mission as john?
@@PhillipHerrera-dd7nlit’s a bounty hunter mission where in chapter 4 you have to spared Freeman if Tilly and Susan tells u to kill him
@@PhillipHerrera-dd7nl you have to do all the interactions with mickey as arthur and then when you’re in the epilogue with john and you talk to him he’ll tell you that you remind him of a feller he knew back named alan but he’s talking about arthur
I like how John and Arthur make conversation with their bounties like they're lifelong best friends.
They are friends, more brothers. Both were pick up of the streets by Dutch and Hosea at young ages. Arthur joined Dutch van der Linde's gang when he was fourteen and John was 12 when he met Dutch in 1885.
@@fsinthechat8577he meant Arthur or John with the bounty
@@fsinthechat8577bro he meant them talking to the bountys
@@fsinthechat8577bro💀
@@fsinthechat8577he meant the bounties
”He was bigger”🥶
What mission is this?
@@badboyofficalgamingI think it’s a bounty hunting mission in the epilogue - you have to let Anthony Foreman go as Arthur in Chapter 4 though. Hope this helps
@@Liam.Johnston_ thanks bro yes it helps:)
@@badboyofficalgaming no worries
a 6'2 210 pound man
Arthur: The Bear
John: The Wolf
arthur ferocious bear
Arther was the lone king
John should watch out for the wolves because they seem to be hanging around the area.
They’re both wolves to me
Wasn't author the crow or fox
I love how every bad person in the game that talked back to Arthur, got a beating
you are everywhere
Istg you here everywhere
MRS ADLER!?
Fr
Dutch ?
“Are you Arthur?”
“No”
“Thank god”
😂😂😂
Aren't you ashamed to have that profile picture? I find it very disrespectful and disgusting
@@a.m11558chill its a game
@@a.m11558whats his pfp karen
@@a.m11558why
bro made the coldest arthur edit
That one dutch edit vs the Braithwaites was the best
No he didn’t
Legit
@@itsnotjakeyYes he did
Song name?
Arthur in the beginning of the game:💪🤠
Arthur at the end of the game : 💪🏻💀
John at the start of the game: 🐺🗻😡
John at the end of the game: 🐀🗻👿
TB fvked up the best character in RDR2
@@amartyapanditTrue reason why you get honor when killing rats.
@@octopus3582Do you actually get honor from that?
@@Banana-Boi yes.
This edit made Arthur 100x more badass looking
A difficult feat for anyone
Fr he looks so much different in the actual game without mods
@@supernova4113 i think u havent played the whole game. if u had then u wouldve known how badass arthur is
@@talharoxen I’ve beat it 3 times almost 4, it ain’t about how cool and badass he is it’s about his appearance I can’t find no good clothes without mods
@@supernova4113 That may be true
the only reason to spare Anthony is so you can get him as a bounty as John for like $85
Yeah, and then you get like 30 grand I always Kill him
@@crowsnest1510you spare him and while he runs away shoot him and you can still have him as a bounty
I always kill him just makes sense, didn’t know about this
I don't kill him. I mean, at the end of the day, it's tilly's call
When u get micahs bounty (i think) u get 30k
He really was the boogie man to the other gangs
He was the john wick of the wild west
@@ndb232ironic cause there was already a John
Nah I’d say John takes the title of “boogie man” to other gangs. He took down the Laramie Gang, the Skinners, Micah's gang, the Bollard Twins Gang, the Treasure Hunter Gang, Dutch’s gang, del lobos, Bill's Gang, the bandits at the river crossing, the rebels and the Mexican Army, a fuck ton of pinkertons, a fuck ton of investigation Bureau agents, and basically everyone else who stood in his way.
@@zoroux2826 forgot Dutch's gang in rdr1
@@WalterWhite0192 yeah them too, totally forgot lmao
John: *The Assassin of the Gang*
Arthur: *The Brute of the Gang*
I'd say the opposite
@@youssefElhdad Arthur was stronger than everybody in the Gang which makes him the Brute
@@xElChilinot Charles
I’d say Arthur was the Marksman, sure he was one of the strongest but nobody compared to his shooting. Everybody came with an colt and a rifle. Arthur came prepared with two colts/pistols, and two rifles. Brother was the army of the group
@@Whoisthat698 True but was he the one always doing the "dirty" work no not really unlike Arthur, Charles didn't like hurting innocent beings for money ect(Not saying Arthur liked it but he still did it anyways)
Dutch used Charles and Arthur as enforcers for a reason 😂
I like to think that mac and davey were worse than arthur and john .
@@Lupo32 they were more brutal, and Mac was arguably the best hand to hand fighter the gang has ever had ( you can overhear Uncle saying he once saw Mac beat up FIFTEEN sailors in a fight), but in the wild west being a more skilled gunslinger was far more important, and in that John and Arthur vastly outclassed the Callander brothers.
@@kuroroluxifer8321Mac prob gonna be the main in rdr3, bro seems to be colder than ice☠️💨
@@WalterWhite0192 that'd be cool..but it'd also be cool to have a main protagonist that doesn't die at the end of the game, at least once in a trilogy ahah
@@kuroroluxifer8321uncle constantly lies tho
If it was Arthur who put him on that horse, Anthony would be screaming for help
Arthur in full black outfits>>
Você sabe como conseguir esta roupa preta com caveira nas costas ?
@@Gustareges É mod
He was bigger indeed
Truly
Indeed
@@Denzo875 probably
Так вроде модели Джона из эпилога и Артура одинаковые по размеру
@@user-eg3cc6ul2d what is blud waffling about 🗣️
Every time you like it, I will come and watch it again. It's amazing.
Arthur was one of the most feared men when he was alive 😅
“Run it’s Aurther Morgan” 🥶🥶🥶
They got the same height which is 6'1 but Arthur was looking bigger and more terrifying. Morgan was different, literally a street boy. Tough.
Same height in 2, in one John is smaller, Because of rockstar disdain
John 6'0 author 6'2 or 6'3 plus he was the strongest in the gang
John is 5'10
@@Dingle_jrNo he wasn't. Charles was.
@@andreakopyan2424arthur was more stronger than Charles.
I love John, but he's right. Arthur was an absolute unit
I remeber back in the day, when rdr fans were sceptical about Arthur Morgan, because everyone grew up with John and didn't wanted an new protagonist, but boy oh boy, did Arthur turned out to be an even more loveable Character.
The saddest mention of Arthur is when you talk to Mickey in the epilogue
Whats the song?
I've never witnessed such awesome editing as this one W
I hate how they changed John's body in the epilogue to just be a copy of Arthur's body
there is difference in their weight , john is very skinny in shirts , he kinda look like bones
Their body model is different, but the hair is the same. His rdr1 outfit is so much worse than rdr1 too
@erase666 the thompson vest and the cashmire shirt?
@@ivanjosipovic2493 dont like his vest and pants
@@rdr.erased oooh the rancher trowsers
Song pure imagination by Freddie dredd
Thank you!!
The saviour we all need.
Thank you
thxs
You are the only god i can worshi
“No he was bigger” gave me chills 🥶
Arthur is the greatest character in video game history.. idc what anyone says
One of my favourite callbacks to Arthur is when the veterans hospital is built in Saint Denis and Arthur’s name is on the wall
Bad ass Arthur Morgan🔥
Funny bc if you have Arthur underweight when you do that mission and have John fat when you capture him it says he was thinner
I can’t tell if this is a joke or not. But if it isn’t then that defies the whole point of this edit as well as the people praising Arthur in the comments. It’d mean that Foreman is just referencing the player’s body weight, and since Arthur meets Foreman In Chapter 2/4, most people wouldn’t really be skinny by then, but in the Epilogue, most people have an underweight John.
He was bigger, meaner, and far more scarier
Maybe Arthur was more intimidating, but john had more bite and more skill.
@@zoroux2826 There is no argument there. But John just doesn't frighten me as much.
@@zoroux2826 ngl i think arthur > john and i mean prime arthur, no tuberculosis
definitley not , arthur has more skill@@zoroux2826
@@megs_beastkingdom76d3 you’ve never played rd1?
Man is the goat
Why?
@@user-hh9ku8jx9u what do you mean why
@@rebeccarussell8428 why men-goat?
@@user-hh9ku8jx9uhe didn't mean men overall are goats, he was talking about arthur
@@prska why Arthur goat?
I gotta say.... I really fucking loved being the enforcer
Arthur was a force of nature for sure.
"Get out here"
-Arthur morgan
No agent milton😂
Let’s admit it Arthur is tougher then John
Not tougher than RDR 1 John though
only if you’ve never played the first game, idk if rockstar had different devs but they must’ve had something against john, what you see in rd2 is NOT john marston or ANYTHING like how he’s talked about in rd1, there’s dialogue where he mentions or talks about his past and it’s not present even a little bit in the second game. i hate seeing people constantly dick ride arthur just because they chose to play 2 before 1, the reason you don’t like him is because they put zero effort and made him completely one dimensional compared to arthur, where they actually tried. i think it’s about time you figure out the difference between a bad character and a poorly made character, one is genuinely not good/antagonist like and the other is just a flat character because the devs were lazy with them
@@whenitsover3479 Pretty sure they just made him like that to prove a point how John changed during the gang to after it, after all it's like 12 years between rdr2 and rdr1, so let's agree, the John in rdr2 is not in his prime at all, but he's getting there
@@whenitsover3479 imma dick ride arthur till the end he’s more of a unit, fought the biggest guy in town, fastest gunslinger. And never said I didn’t like John he cool and all but Arthur’s just physically tougher, I think he’s more cowboy realistic then John so to speak not wearing an eyepatch and shit
@@whenitsover3479 bro sit down. We’re talking about rockstar games they don’t get lazy. John is the way that he is in red dead 2 because he’s in the process of changing.
bro dropped the best rdr edit and thought we wouldn't notice
Arthur is one of those people you would call a terrifying sweetheart.
Arthur Morgan 💀🥶💀
Jack:😎
John:😈
Arthur:🐐
Hopefully, dutch in rdr3:🍷🗿
Author
@@tracysluv1Bro just edit the comment
Couldn't have said it better myself
No arthur 💪🏻🦅🥶☠️
John better tho
He was bigger 🥶
BRO THIS IS SO GOOD
They should’ve used max weight fat Arthur for this edit
"Just one more big game meat"
Coldest drop ever🔥
I love you Arthur rip an American legend
Arthur is like legendary Bear ❤
"No... he was ni-
Say it
Cmon now say it
You started the word your so close now
Cmon I’ll say it with you
You got me itchin…..
@@Vaas3867 nah bluds bouta say ni-
you're my idol and I love your edits so much keep going man!
I'm not even kidding that was probably one of the best red dead redemption edits I've ever seen
Bigger and badass
Arthur Morgan is THE BEST!!❤
That little eye movement for some reason is so fucking cold
I always been emotional when Arthur and the gang have some good time
"He was bigger"
That's what she said :(
Bro is more recognise then his brother
??
No, they don't. They made John the same hight, but he's still much more slender than Arthur and he moves completely different. It's very easy to spot the difference and tell them apart, even if they wear the same clothes.
The blind 10/10 when she realizes im not her boyfriend:
Literally gave me chills. John is amazing, but Arthur is simply Arthur
"he was ni-
Imagine if Arthur faked his death and somehow survived TB 💀
They better do that in rdr3 😭🙏
@@recessionto5537 ONG 😭
@@recessionto5537 rdr3 will not be after arthur and johns death because the cowboys era will be over after that
@@Lxzaa хочу часть про зарождение банды
@@Lxzaa Nah bro it's gonna be mac Callender, hosea , Dutch or our boy Arthur if we see him die like in High honour but in low honour he got shot in the head I guess it only 3 of them but I think we see Arthur in rdr3 because the game is going backwards in timeline
Even at one moment it seemed to me that when he said no, his voice was similar to Arthur’s voice and I thought that Arthur was alive, but then I realized that he was just saying no, but his voice was very similar to Arthur’s voice at that moment.
Even people realize no one could match Arthur's energy. Man was a reL OG outlaw gangster.
bro i want to play low honor arthur because of that edit
Good BOAH/10 edit
Freddie Dredd's music used for an RDR2 edit is fucking FIRE
He didnt mean arthur morgan
meaned the drunk ass in the backround💀
For those wondering about the song, the part used at the very beginning was from Zoro by Freddie Dredd
No ones better then Arthur Morgan
Arthur was a moving train 🤣
Really making Arthur look cooler than he already was with those edits
It's funny how i saw another edit like this (he was bigger) 2 hours ago and wanted to see a better edit then just an hour later one of my favourite video creators made the edit
Bro the same thing for me
Bro made one of the coldest Arthur edits and thought it wouldn’t get noticed in 2024
This is exactly how John should’ve looked in the second game.
"Face me to the west, so I can watch the sunfall and remember all the fine times with ya folks."
-Arthur Morgan
Song- pure imagination by Freddie dredd
Thank you very much, my friend
ty
No it ain’t
@@kendamakingtvthat is the song actually...go search it up
@@kendamakingtv then what is it?
Whats the song??
Zoro but slowed
Лучший эдит, который я когда либо видел
Bro drop the best Arthur edit and went to sleep 💞💞
Imagine if he was talking about Charles☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️
he was darker
@@kuroroluxifer8321 he was ni**a
@@kuroroluxifer8321💀
@@kuroroluxifer8321💀💀💀💀
You are an amazing YT RDR Series Creator. Those edits are as fire as hell man, keep up the good work. That transition with John was unexpected and I love it.
This is one of if not the best edit I’ve seen in a long time 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Everytime I get shitty with rdr2 I take a break watch these clips and then I'm in the mood too play it again.
Music please
something freddie dredd i cant remember what
its zoro/pure imagination by freddie dredd just an edited version
@@thedamnedcat3240 thanks
@@pietrovisk3503 no problem i can send you a link to the version used in this edit if u want
@@thedamnedcat3240 no need, thank you
Well you gotta remember that Arthur is like 6’1 in 1899.
Nah hes like 5’9 he’s shorter than all the other npcs
@@JohnnymarstonNegsarthur what kind of goofy scale did you give Arthur?
@@JohnnymarstonNegsarthur he's taller than everyone 😂😂😂wtf
@@snxdede shorter
@@JohnnymarstonNegsarthur taller
Bro just casually dropped the coldest Arthur edit I’ve ever seen
Foreman just roasted and complimented the player at the same time
John 5'10" around 175 lbs, body type : skinny.
VS
Arthur 6'1.5" around 225 lbs, body type: mascular.
Both are 6'1
@@mahdybenamara3121 John in most sources is measured as 5'10''. Meanwhile Arthur in half of sources i found he was listed as 6'1'' and the other half as 6'2''. So i suppose he's somewhere in the middle of these 2 recorded heights
5”10 175 is not skinny lmao
@@stinnyboy4608what is it then lmao. Tho I agree I don't think he got it right John ain't that skinny in the first
@@stinnyboy4608it's not that big anyway
I'm 5'9 170
“He was bigger” 🤨 📸
🤨
I usually think alot this type of edits the music fucks it up. But this one..This one goes hard asf. Sick
I love how John and Arthur have the same model, but Arthur just *feels* bigger
blud was afraid of Arthur
They have LITERALLY the same body 💀💀 (I hate John Morgan)
Really, John Morgan is the worst R*'s idea... well, after gta triology and rdr1 re-release
A edit of low honor's Arthur.. cold🥶
Yall I just finished the main game and I couldnt stop crying for like 2 days. Such a heart wrenching story. Even Dutch’s Voice actor said he had a difficult time with the last scene
Song name?
Idk
Zoro by Freddie Dredd
I mean considering Abigail stuck with John it really makes you wonder who was actually bigger 😂
Or whose worse at pulling out, and we all know what Arthur did to the other prostitute
@@bigball8468 bigger gun slower draw speed if you know what I mean lol
Arthur never did that with Abigail he was with Mary at the time
@@That1nig yes you were. Rip king
Freddie dredd Zoro (remix)
The only reason I let him live on my 2nd playthrough
anthony foreman: "he was bigger"
john marston: but i am red dead redemption 🥶🥶
Another annoying john fan 😒
@@Noirman8annoying? This comment right here was carefully crafted just for you to call it annoying? John Marston IS the red dead redemption
@@Noirman8Arthur meatriders be like
even tho i agree with your statement, but man that was cringe
@@Noirman8John slams the fucking shit out of Arthur. Keep riding Arthur’s meat all you want it won’t change the facts.