PART 2: Seymour Hersh's New Book Disputes U.S. Account of Bin Laden Killing
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 04. 2016
- democracynow.org - Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Seymour Hersh discusses the reporting he did for his new book, The Killing of Osama bin Laden in part two of an extended interview. Next week marks the fifth anniversary of the assassination of bin Laden.
Democracy Now! is an independent global news hour that airs weekdays on nearly 1,400 TV and radio stations Monday through Friday. Watch our livestream 8-9AM ET: democracynow.org
Please consider supporting independent media by making a donation to Democracy Now! today: democracynow.org/donate
FOLLOW DEMOCRACY NOW! ONLINE:
Facebook: / democracynow
Twitter: / democracynow
CZcams: / democracynow
SoundCloud: / democracynow
Daily Email: democracynow.org/subscribe
Google+: plus.google.com/+DemocracyNow
Instagram: / democracynow
Tumblr: / democracynow
Pinterest: / democracynow
iTunes: itunes.apple.com/podcast/demo...
TuneIn: tunein.com/radio/Democracy-Now...
Stitcher Radio: www.stitcher.com/podcast/democ...
![Global Empire - The World According to Seymour Hersh [Part One]](/img/n.gif)
When the CIA says ( every sentence was wrong ) well this book must be accurate .
No. It's just the other half of the fake story to keep you confused.
It all has the "Ring of TRUTH" ! I believe Hersh !!!
Dude the guy just keeps rambling.
Why you believed it true,what you base on,i challenges that this journalist to investigate the Fsb of Rusia ,what they did intil now,i dare him if he í e real man braves
I was scrolling down and I for a moment I thought I saw your username (before I focused), as Ronald Dump (don't be offended, it's a typical play on Donald Trump, whom I voted for twice. I believe this guy also (a real journalist), whether he's right or wrong (and I know for a fact he's wrong in rare instances), he seems honest and truthful, and like the last bastion of real and actual Investigative Journalists. He does his due diligence research. We are really going to be screwed when these people are gone (unless people like him continue to inspire new and real actual Investigative journalists, rather than simple "News Readers" on TV, reading a prepared edited script (many times false narrative).
@@kietv.7189 You can't challenge shite when your ability to write a sentence is akin to a 5 year olds 🤦🏻♂️🤣
This is the reason this is the definitive definition of and for the freedom of the press this guy should get the Nobel prize in truth
@@TheRealCheckmate in a perfect world ironic isn't it ?
Nobel prize is dead!
This guy is incredible, a wealth of information.
His mind is messier than a 13 year olds room.
@@seltonk5136 Could listen to the rambling for hours haha
12:58 Amy tries to get Seymour back on track LOL, who can blame him for rambling a bit he knows so much interesting shit. I love this guy.
Right? He reminds me so much of myself when I get extremely excited to tell someone something that I've been holding onto for awhile. Except his news is a lot more interesting lol. This is fascinating stuff.
You love a guy who missed Washington’s involvement in 9/11? even a kindergartener can see thru Washington’s bullshit. If this guy isn’t a spook then my uncle is Lois Lane
I could listen to him for hours
When he talks about My Lia is amazing
You would HAVE to listen for hours in order to get the whole story.
Lot of people taking shots at Sy's presentation here. The thing you have to remember is; Sy is telling the truth and he knows a LOT of it. So there's a lot of stuff going through his head. It ISN'T simple. Its complicated. Most people you see on TV are just spitting out talking points, propaganda and sound bytes that are rehearsed and designed to sell you something. This is what truth sounds like folks.
Spot on 👍, most stuff from western media is complete bullshit
Those Are The Same People That Couldn't Pick Any Of These Countries On A Map Nor There Own City On *The AMERICAN Map* & Aslo *Small Note:* They've Also At Best Maybe just Possibly Read more than 1or2 Books in There Hole Lives📚
@@patmax9005 not reading books would leave a hole in my life
reading books inspire would be holers
to live a whole life
Bullshit.
Lots of Indians want Pakistan to be blamed.
Hersh seems to be in really good shape for an 85-year-old man. Good on him.
He's 85?! Wow! I assumed he was in his sixties.
@@littlestone1541 this was 6 years ago, he was 79. Still impressively sharp
Whenever the establishment says you're wrong that's the indication you're RIGHT 👀
Sy is one of thee greats and it’s this kind of real journalism that’s been lost, we need it back.
It's sad; we have very few real journalists left. The majority are pundits and glorified bloggers. Investigative journalists are a dying breed.
So true
All but extinct these days.
Hersh isn't a 'real journalist' either.
Amy please do like a 2 hour version of this! I could have listened to this rant for ages! really insightful hearing these details falingout of Sy's mouth!
It's interesting how brilliant writers aren't always the best orators. I am a much better writer than speaker, too. I often trip over my words but can communicate clearly on paper. Seymour Hersh is one intelligent guy and he's recounting a very complicated story so there's alot going on in his head. You have to listen closely to get the gist. I really like Mr. Hersh, a guy with integrity.
I'm not a writer but same here. My mind keeps racing from stuff to stuff with many visual images thrown in. It's a serious mental exercise to construct the sentences prior to speaking so that I don't risk sounding stupid. Always a challenge when giving presentations and talking during meetings.
He is well over 80 years old (late 70s at the time?) Some cognitive skills will be effected regardless of intelligence.
Is this guy still out there??? He is axwralth of info!!!
@@Alsatiagent very true, well he's doing just slightly better than Biden at a similar age anyway 🤣🤦🏻♂️
@@Alsatiagent A family friend of ours works for the WW2 Museum. His job is to edit the interviews for veterans. The Museum interviews 90 year old vets whose minds are still sharp, and they can recollect memory from the 1940's , heck even growing up in the 20's and 30's. It depends on each person.
Well if the former deputy secretary of the CIA Mike Morrell knows that "every sentence is wrong" then he might want to tell us which sentences and WHY.
@YTCensors and the Warren Commission.
@YTCensors I disagree. It was absolutely TERRIBLE fiction. Hard to read, full of evasions and obfuscation, of impossible fantasies, and a barrier to truth. JRR Tolkien wrote great fiction.
@YTCensors We are in agreement. If you have a study that decides what outcome they want before the study starts, what kind of outcome will result? Both commissions were only in place to reinforce the fabricated "official" story.
I remember reading in 2002 about him dying going up the mountain on a horse on a portable dialysis machine 😊
And then South Africa border control said he had entered South Africa, I was at a KZN Casino when a man dressed and looking like bin laden was leaning on my machine and the young man with him said, there you go the jackpot is yours, phone the Americans. I just laughed, but the Durban mosque is huge and they had recently put in a dialysis machine , it was a donation from the Givers. So did he live out his days in Durban?
The American West and its media are NO STRANGERS FOR FALSE FLAGS OPERATION THROUGHOUT THE WHOLE WORLD.... so no surprises what their side of the narrative is,,,OBVIOUSLY BLATANT LIES. They THRIVE on it to survive like COWARDS , Dont have the courage to face unarmed nomads face to face..but throw bombs on innocent civilians from drones n fighter jets and call it collalateral damage. SHAME ON YOU AMERICAN PIGS AND EUROPEAN ALLIES....
You DONT have the BALLS to go invade RUSSIA ,but use your WHORE UKRAINE to do your bidding.
OSAMA BIN LADEN, the COURAGEOUS AND SOLDIER OF ALLAH swt died peacefully in the mountains AND NOT HOW THE ROGUE BARACK OBAMA & CRONIES WANT THE WORLD TO BELIEVE....
SHAME ON YOU PIG AMERICA!!!
Sure a great man, thank you for having him on.
I understand his "rambling", as many hear are calling it lol. This is a lot of info, and due to the complexities and the connected stories to those complexities...first off, hats off to his memory, yes, it sounds like rambling. But this story is huge, very complex and I'd like to see anyone try to share all this with the time he was given, any better then he presented here.
Exactly, most journalists and reporters are given shallow stories, often lies with nothing to back them and so have little to talk about.
here, not hear
Mr. Hersh, if you look up Senator Benazir Bhutto interviews. She openly talks about how Bin Ladin died many, many years earlier from something like Kidney disease. The reporter didn’t blink or question it like “what? Omg!!” Nothing. It’s funny because that interview, most of them now have her words changed and dubbed. You can see her lips saying something else. If you dig, you can find the original. Overseas they know the truth.
2002 to be exact. He was in the American Hospital in Dubai for treatment (Dialysis and other serious medical care) and almost died at that point. The entire story and event of 9/11 and OBLs death is an interrelated Conspiracy (and nonsense). We know who perpetrated 9/11 and it was the Zionist Deep State/ PNAC/ the Bush Administration. I like this guy, and feel he's sometimes correct, but a lot of what he says is false.
Flat Earther moment
That was an interview with David Frost, in which she actually referred a man who she alleged killed bin Laden in IIRC December 2001.
The kidney disease storey is another third hand account of a CIA operative meeting with bin Laden in a gulf state hospital where bin Laden was allegedly receiving dialysis treatment.
You appear to have conflated two different accounts.
What we know for certain is that ALL the official UBL narratives are false.
In order to understand all the ‘War on Terror’ narratives, it is necessary to start long before 9-11; before the Alfred P Murrah Building operation in OKC that was the real reason why the Patriot Act was written; long before the first Gulf War; before the CIA took over from the British SIS operation to overthrow Mossadegh in Iran in 1954; before the British and US intelligence agencies were involved in the formation of Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt; before Sykes Picot, the Balfour Declaration and Lawrence; before Churchill purchased Anglo Persian Oil on behalf of the UK government; indeed right back to true origins of WW1 - on the battlefields of the Boer Wars.
💯 % true. She said she saw live feed from SAS. 3 years before Obama. He used it as a way to prop up polls that weren’t doing well around his election time.
Bin Laden’s tapes were originally authenticated by our govt using voice analysis. In 2004 the audio on the tapes started being encrypted to prevent voice analysis. Bin Laden had no reason to disguise his voice. That’s clearly the point at which he was replaced.
His appearance seemed to have changed as well.
Shame you didn't let him talk about 9/11.
Nothing about this on mainstream news.
People questioning his memory because of age are missing the point that he is a journalist , he keeps notes , writes everything down , checks his sources and documents them . He doesn't rely on memory
Mr Hersh may be a better writer (I hope!) than an interviewee. Almost every sentence he starts to express begins a sequence of parenthetical remarks, qualifiers, to the point that I find his oral presentation difficult to parse. One really needs a transcript, or his book. That is a clever way of selling his book. Presumably, he had an editor who helped him organize his thoughts.
@@TheRealCheckmate You'll have to settle for 'Zero Dark Thirty'. The official, approved story
USA is sooooo weird in every sence
"Sense"
Thank you so much❤
Will Seymour Hersh investigate the really big 'story' - Who planned and who carried out all the various actions (and action failures) that occurred on the morning of 11th September 2001 - and who coordinated the cover-ups and miss-direction afterwards. Who for example ordered the site of the Twin Towers cleared of the remains of the buildings before forensic examination had taken place? - and that is just a detail.
Who ensured the ground to air missiles protecting the Pentagon would not operate? Any aircraft that gets within three miles of the Pentagon is supposed to be shot down automatically if those flying it do not provide the correct code response when asked to do so.
How was Building 7 demolished - no steel frame building, before or since, has collapsed into its own 'footprint' as that building did, supposedly as a result of a furniture fire, in fact the steel-work in such buildings remains generally intact even after much more intense and longer burning fires, burning furniture does not get hot enough to effect the heavy steel framing of a building such as that of WTC Building 7.
What happened to the passengers from the fourth hijacked aircraft, the one that was not crashed into a building? Where are the hijackers of that plane?
There are many many more such questions, but no credible answers. My view is that Bin Laden was involved, but in the same way that Lee Harvey Oswald was involved in the murder of JFK, he was set up as a patsy - and he got nowhere as near to the major incidents - the aircraft hits - as Oswald did to the shooting of Kennedy. Oswald was after all in the book repository from which others may have fired distraction shots, he probably heard those shots. Where was Osama Bin Laden on the morning of 11th September 2001 and what was he doing at the time? What was his motive for committing this crime?
He probably won't go there bc the tribe would be implicated. After the tower, we got a new Federal agency DHS that Israel basically controls. Where is Chertoff now? Pollard living the life of a hero in Israel. 9/11 was a pretext for the neocons to put the US military in the ME and neutralize Israel's enemies. The first thing we did with Iraq was put in a central bank Any Christian man or woman that joins the military now is stupid. We are not fighting for the UA. We are dying for Israel.
@@margaretnorvell9555 Yes true. MSM certainly won't touch it. They have even gone deaf and dumb on the act of war against Germany, even in Germany - although I understand the German people are waking up and protesting about what has happened and what is happening to their country at the behest of America.
Compare the reaction to the attack on the the World Trade Center and the Pentagon with that to the destruction of the Nordstream pipelines (which is likely to eventually kill at least as many people at the 9/11 attacks did). The real difference ? Not cost of replacement, but who did it and who suffered because of it.
@@ZigZagHockey There are many more obvious answers than questions about Nord Stream. This article was sitting there just waiting to be written and I believe if any source wanted to tell his/her story but stay anonymous, Hersh would be a trustworthy contact.
@@fredgarvinMP I agree, the main culprit was obvious. even from the threats and promises made long ago by Biden and Nuland - they are actually proud to have committed this crime. The involvement of Norway was a surprise to me, even if more logical than that of Britain, which I strongly suspected - given that Liz Truss was PM at the time.
@@ZigZagHockey is the destruction of the Nord stream pipeline an impeachable offense?
thanks for finishing this interview
Hersh is telling the Truth
Why you knowed?
Back When *DomocracyNow* Was Creditable, *_Sadly & Pathetically_* They Sold All The Way Out🙊🙈🙉
Yup. State run tv all the way.
@@optimal8155 sadly good people go bad rationalizing that if they disappear truth will die . so they acquiesce and they poison it with little lies. better to quit than both -side-ism. we need an underground
where is part 1?
+Jakka Makka
watch?v=itGou9qCUnY
What a kind of channel is this? There's NO MENTION/link of the Part 1 anywhere! Who's going to watch a Part 2 of nothing? Still AMATEURISH after all those years...
I thought from the time
the news came out
"why was he killed instead of captured?"
The answer was he knew too much,that is,
there were a lot of stuff that would come out
that would be not just embarrassing but criminal
once exposed.
And his body dumped in sea.. I knew it was all bull
He was not killed by the PIGS AMERICANS ....DONT COME OUT WITH ABSURD EXCUSES TO FEED THE NARRATIVES. He die peacefully in the mountains and there is proof of his funeral with videos and pictures ....PERIOD!!!
Let's all hope that all what he knew as you claim will all comes out, for nothing under the Sun that stay secret in the dark.
@@acerrome9672 One argument against suppositions of government
cover-ups is that people can't keep a secret year after year after year....
but why not? It's obvious Roosevelt lured the Japanese into attacking the
US territories in the Pacific in 1941, there was a conspiracy, but who didn't
keep the secret conversations with him undisclosed until their deaths? Same with JFK,
that book is very nearly closed, and everyone has kept their mouth shut.
@@stangaboywhere ??
9-11 full of lies..😂😂
Osama Bin Laden was in an American hospital in Dubai having kidney dialysis and he was transferred to a Pakistan hospital where he died.
Bullshit
My dog died in the hand of vet
i m crying, the others Dog died,good for the bad dog's, no pity,one less not barking in the cave
Eminently unlikely.
@@kietv.7189
com certeza deves pertencer a uma raça de câes malhados ...
I suspect that was a ploy to hide him as he was still being paid by the CIA. Later they decided to kill him after framing him for 9/11
Please add subtitles
Anybody with a brain that saw clips of OBL knew something was sus. A clip of him firing an AR with his left, then another clip he's righthanded. His beard would change colour as would the shape of his ears and nose. His voice was often turned low and a translator would speak over him, even then his voice would be heard to be different. And often the translation was not even correct. The MSM would have us beleive that this man with a failing kidney needing medical treatment armed with a mobile phone hiding in a cave in Afghanistan somehow pulled of the 911 (the number used to call the police and fire service in the US) attack. LMAO is all I can say.
👍 what he said makes a lot of sense .. and yes, it's complicated.
One of my contentions was that 'they' knew where Bin Laden was almost from day one .. or very close to it.
However, 'looking for him' gave them licence to dig everywhere .. even places where they were not officially supposed / allowed to. Once then, he had outlived his usefulness, he was 'found' and terminated .. inter alia, a political coup for the Obama administration.
1
You don’t cut a man like this off, Ms. Goodman.
I voted for Obama, but am open minded enough yo see the irony that his press secretary Josh Earnest is a liar.
A great guy but hard to listen to you need to play it twice and you will understand what he is saying.
FRANCIS GARY POWERS
LEE HARVEY OSWALD.
YASUGI
DISCUSS.
Love it when $#!+ hits the fan.
That is some special forces stuff right there, let me picture this two helicopters pact with 24 operators and their equipment go to 🇵🇰 air space, nobody knows, few miles to their White House, have a shot out kill bin Ladin,1 helicopter goes away, now Timmy how did they get 24 men with their equipment +treasure chest of computers and intelligence + the body of bin Ladin= bu!!sh!t😂🤣🤪
The account of why there was no body to show is about as convincing as Joseph Smith's account as why there were no golden tablets with the ten commandments to show.
👏💯🌹to Mr. Hersh on .."The TRUTHS hadn't been in 1/2 a decades..." or longer.. 🤣😂..
Interesting
Thanks 😊 Amy for your brilliant 👏 presentation keep up the good job posting real News!
Does Seymour Hersh have any thoughts about the crash and death of Seal Team 6 soon after the raid on Bin Laden?
The guy just jumps all over the place. Seems to know something. Hopefully the book is more organized.
SEAL TEAM
SIX SIX SIX
ALL DEAD.
This interview was done in 2016. The White House used the same techniques of abstract denial (no facts provided - just plain denial) then as it has recently used with Hersh's piece on the US/Norway destruction of the Nord Stream natural gas pipelines. They (the servile media) are now claiming that half a dozen "unknown" individuals on a 50 foot sailing yacht called Andromeda blew up the pipelines last September. That's a story truly worthy of the Coen brothers in a sequel to The Big Lebowski. These techniques of denial go all the way back to Hersh's story on My Lai. The principle? When the truth does not fit your immediate, short term agenda... lie. As Goebbels noted... the bigger the lie, the better.
Lies are the enemy of freedom and democracy, not their friend. What is the role of the majority of corporate media (whether it's FOX News or the New York Times) in the present world? Chomsky coined a phrase. He called it "manufactured consent". That's the promotion of lies, half-truths, and, in short, deceptive propaganda reflecting the retrograde agenda of the privileged few against the interests of the majority. People wind up agreeing out of ignorance - not knowledge. Unfortunately critical thinking skills are not seriously encouraged in our schools today and... it works. At the cost of untold human suffering around the world.
Esta entrevista se realizó en 2016. La Casa Blanca usó las mismas técnicas de negación abstracta (no se proporcionaron hechos, simplemente negación) que usó recientemente con el artículo de Hersh sobre la destrucción de los gasoductos de gas natural Nord Stream por parte de EE. UU. y Noruega. Ellos (los medios serviles) ahora afirman que media docena de personas "desconocidas" en un yate de vela de 50 pies llamado Andrómeda volaron las tuberías en septiembre pasado. Esa es una historia digna de los hermanos Coen en una secuela de The Big Lebowski. Estas técnicas de negación se remontan a la historia de Hersh en My Lai. ¿El principio? Cuando la verdad no se ajusta a su agenda inmediata a corto plazo... mienta. Como señaló Goebbels... cuanto más grande sea la mentira, mejor.
Las mentiras son enemigas de la libertad y la democracia, no sus amigas. ¿Cuál es el papel de la mayoría de los medios corporativos (ya sea FOX News o el New York Times) en el mundo actual? Chomsky acuñó una frase. Lo llamó "consentimiento fabricado". Eso es la promoción de mentiras, medias verdades y, en definitiva, propaganda engañosa que refleja la agenda retrógrada de unos pocos privilegiados en contra de los intereses de la mayoría. La gente termina aceptando por ignorancia, no por conocimiento. Desafortunadamente, las habilidades de pensamiento crítico no se fomentan seriamente en nuestras escuelas hoy en día y... funciona. A costa de un sufrimiento humano incalculable en todo el mundo.
Dear Mr SEYMOUR you maybe a great writer & you may have put yourself at great risk in writing your books & articles I thank you for that, it takes a brave person to speak the truth in today's times but only if you could go further & write the full truth in its entirety!
In sha Allah (if Allah swt wills it)
Real journalist.
This tarnishing the shing on dear leader
Why was the body buried at sea? Huh? Wha?
Bingo
Anytime YT gives a “context bar”, you can reasonably be assured there is a good degree of truth to the claims made in the video.
And the sad thing is you really believe that don't you 😐❓️.
One of a kind investigative journalist with obviously lots of information in his racing mind, and you can see that when he talks and goes on a dozen different tangents before getting to the point, if ever. lol
You really have to concentrate on what he's saying.
Ok
Word
He is all but comprehensible.
Hersh is terrible at telling a story
The fact that the body was dumped in the ocean, which by they way is not an Islamic mood of burial like the media says raises eyebrows.
Funny how the google algorithm has actually picked this one back up again - looks like it started 4 days ago and accelerated a day ago. I remember watching this interview at the time. How far Democracy Now has fallen since this was aired - very unfortunate. No matter how bad it gets though, Amy deserves a lot of credit for DN managed to acheive even if her team has lost their sense of objectivity and perspective in the Trump years. Hard to blame them as most people went a bit loopy over Trump. Will be interesting to see how much they make of Seymour Hersh's most recent revelation. It's one that deserves even more attention than the Bin Laden story, the documentation of an act of war against our most important EU ally. Lets see what DN and Amy make of it.
I said the same thing , She eve took money from the Bill Gates foundation during covid and so has never said a bad word about him nor has she spoken about the vaccine injured
No it’s not “hard to blame them” over their loopy coverage during the Trump era. They lost a lot of credibility and all objectivity during that time and it has bled into present. As far as I’m concerned, they are liberal run state tv.
I agree, Democracy now has definitely fallen really far then what they used to be.
@@funkyfissIt's considered more as Democratic Tyranny.
@@J.M.254 Well the tyranny part is correct.
Why is the volume level so low? I wanted to listen while washing dishes, but couldn't hear it well enough. Maybe you should pay the sound engineer at least minimum wage.
After a few years then the fumbling stories come out.
I really wish I could follow any train of thought that this man comes up with....
I wish he would stay on topic for just two minutes....
@@TheRealCheckmate No he doesn't, I don't think he said a single lie. LOL.
"I can only speculate." -- Seymour Hersh
I'll believe this Pulitzer Prize winning journalist over the rest put together any day. Investigative journalism is a dying art in our country that has been replaced with tv pundits and bloggers.
He did his part to destroy America.
I assume his writing is easier to follow than this interview. Very disjointed. There should have been more questions, not all the rambling, to keep things focused.
Well that depends really . If you have been following war on terror , and listened to what WH was doing all these things he says make sense . People don't reall follow anything through . So when govern ment does something they have to explain from the beginning.
Now , listen again and check the info he's giving . Just google it and than you will get what he is talking about .
One thing more wiki is not the most reliable source but for a first general picture is ok .
Sometimes thing it should be called the Black House , considering the amount of killing and destruction sanctioned from there . Look from Vietnam onwards and ongoing relentlessly .
Killing it was bloody murder.
A lot of Muslims know for many years in the Middle East and South East Asia that he died in the bombings in Afghanistan years before the supposed killing in Abbottabad, Pakistan.
Fascination with nitpicking everything under the sun .
Why can’t he just answer the question instead of a scrambled egg with a history lesson and assumptions about how the SEALS came in. It’s called jamming electronic/radar jamming.
I'm skeptical.of his claims !
For the White House spokesman….calling this gentleman a liar….As Mandy Rice Davies once said….well he would wouldn’t he….
I don't think I'll be reading a book by a writer who can't get to the point in an interview. We knew about OBL and the Mujahideen; we knew about the money channelled via the Pakistani ISI, which got diverted into Muslim schools called madrasahs, which primarily bred the Taliban, and a chunk of those millions, which got into the hands of Lashkar-e-Taiba. And we saw first hand interviews with residents of Abbottabad at the time who totally disputed the US version of the event. Like I'm real excited about US investigative journalists; they haven't even figured out who shot Kennedy yet!
I am disappointed
What I want to know why no picture of the 'body'!
Another innocent killed or a dummy 'buried' 😅 or dumped in the sea and the crew blackmailed muted as was the case for the USS Liberty in 1967!
We’re all looking at Seymour Hersh now because of his Nordstream piece but seriously he’s just rambling. His story keeps going left and right.
He has a lot of info to talk about, if you knew that much you'd find it difficult to just stick to one liners. Most journalists are paid to stick to strict narratives.
Whatever the real truth is you can be sure that a context bubble from the Ministry of Truth means that this account is closer to the truth than what’s in that bubble lol
was he there
Of course its lies, have you ever known these insane psychopaths to be honest, better yet to be expecting an intelligent outcome! Not any thing right has come from wrongness and deliberate lies, agreed?
Interesting man. I just wish he would go to the point without so much useless bla bla.
Does any other species care, or go on about the dead as much as humans ?
I think it's very likely that the Pakistani authorities had foreknowledge of the raid and gave their permission for it on the condition that the Americans deny that there had been any cooperation because of the way that would play out politically in Pakistan, but Hersh's argumentation is all over the place. The bit at 8:10 about kids being able to monitor the choppers coming in from Google Earth is ridiculous. Google Earth doesn't have real-time updates of satellite images any more than a paper atlas does.
Yes it does😂
@@Desmondbrown73 No, it doesn't
@@Desmondbrown73 proof?
@@dragomatinov2720 Google earth live
The Radars on Pakistan’s western frontier were designed and made by the US for Pakistan when Afghanistan was occupied by the USSR. The CIA and Pakistan’s ISI were running a resistence movement against the soviets in Afghanistan at that time. They used to train the fighters in training camps inside Pakistan and shift them over the western border into Afghanistan to fight the Soviets.
Several times, advanced Soviet jets crossed over the border into Pakistan to attack the training sites of the resistance fighters. So, in order to shoot down the Soviet jets and improve Pakistan’s air defense system, the US made the Radar system for Pakistan. This Radar system was the most sophisticated one-u could think of it as if the US was making a Radar system for New York. It was so advanced that after it started operating, Pakistan did shoot down soviet jets.
That’s the Radar system Sy is referring to. It is impossible to cross over the Western border of Pakistn without them knowing. Also, no pilot or heli on eath can fly as low as is being projected and told by the US over the Hindukush mountains between Pakistan and Afghanistan. There are narrow gorges, where flying at day time is hard to do. Anyways, just to be specific, the guy that had walked into the US embassy in Islamabad was Col. Iqbal Saeed, who is now living a lavish life in the US at the moment. They gave him the head money for OBL. Most of the Pakistanis know about that. Therefore, sorry to break it to u, but Zero Dark Thirty was a lie😅
I concur with the previous writer. Mr Hersh certainly does not sound like someone whose job it is to tell a story.
He still a life
Osama lives in the garden house of the Bush family. Both families have a long history of friendship. ;-) :P
I guess you’ve gotta read the book. He mumbles and jumps around so much that he and I loose track of his gist.
this isn't Sy Hersh
Pls can you give more details? !
Was it true that one of the BIn Laden family was a member of the Halliburton group? And that they were in New York the day of 911. And the private jet he flew out of the next day was the only airplane allowed to leave US airspace?
At 5:20 I was losing interest.
As an authority to cast doubt on the book the White House cites the former deputy director of the CIA. lol
Rambling and incoherent.
What true in the story is not new..and what’s new in story is not true
Funny that I wrote( myself ) a similar quotation 50 years ago
If you believe what the government says I have the Golden Gate bridge for sale in my back yard
And a Warren Report and the rock&roll8 reportof the 9/11 Omission.
I hope this guy writes better than he speaks.
Don’t josh me, Earnest
He is downright incoherent...
It is frustrating to listen to this guy. I wanted some answers but I give up. Guess I'll find them from someone who can speak for him
Counter-terrorism and NOT counter-insurgency!
How about we send "RAMBO" next Time!