A great poem. Thanks. It says what it has to. Disgusting that so many people were moved to watch this short video and cast a thumbs down. Undoubtedly, those people don't know poetry and justice and only want to protect their ignorance and chauvinism. I am a 76 year old Jew, born into zionism but who left it when I discovered how my people have turned their backs on Justice. I am ashamed of my people. Thank you, Roger Waters, for all the work you have done for Justice.
If only True Semitic Hebrews descendants of The prophet Israel himself wanted to live in the Holy Land with us Muslims and Christians we wouldn't have refused, Alas these European Crypto Jews gog and magog, want everything to themselves, not just the Holy land but the whole Arab world, they have Mecca on their eyes too. We know they will fail like they always did, this God's narrative to this world, the prophecies will come true, and Jesus son of Mary will return to this ugly world and make something beautiful out of what will be left of it.
One of the greatest poems performed by one of the greatest musicians of our time. Some of the comments below are really disgusting and show how ignorant some people can be. Anti zionism, anti occupation and anti apartheid is not anti semitism plus some of you should perhaps read history, if it were not for the Arabs in Spain and throughout history there probably wouldn't be any jews. Bottom line is that whatever you say about Waters will not eclipse his status among millions of his fans and whatever lies you dish out won't change the fact that you are defending an ugly and illegal apartheid system called Israel.
Starts with eloquence..continues with historical inaccuracy and (perhaps mistakenly?)with vilification of Israel (“an ugly and illegal apartheid system called Israel”).So I’m confused , are we to believe that pro Jewish/Israel/Zionist comments qualify for your show of disgust when you write “ Some of the comments below are really disgusting and show how ignorant some people can be” ?
The word Palestine derives from Philistia, the name given by Greek writers to the land of the Philistines, who in the 12th century bce occupied a small pocket of land on the southern coast, between modern Tel Aviv-Yafo and Gaza. The name was revived by the Romans in the 2nd century ce in “Syria Palaestina,” designating the southern portion of the province of Syria, and made its way thence into Arabic, where it has been used to describe the region at least since the early Islamic era. After Roman times the name had no official status until after World War I and the end of rule by the Ottoman Empire, when it was adopted for one of the regions mandated to Great Britain; in addition to an area roughly comprising present-day Israel and the West Bank, the mandate included the territory east of the Jordan River now constituting the Hashimite Kingdom of Jordan, which Britain placed under an administration separate from that of Palestine immediately after receiving the mandate for the territory. If you want to say there is no Palestine, you should also say there is no Jordon, and no Iraq. It's all part of greater Syria, or what was part of the Ottoman Empire. 1918: Population of Palestine from the Jewish Virtual Library: Total Jewish Population : 60,000/ Total Non-Jewish Population : 600,000/ Total Population : 660,000/ % of Jewish Population : 8.1% 1946: Total Jewish Population : 543,000/ Total Non-Jewish Population : 1,267,037/ Total Population : 1,181,037/ % of Jewish Population : 30% 1948: Total Jewish Population : 716,700/ Total Non-Jewish Population : 156,000/ Total Population : 872,700 / % of Jewish Population : 82.1% 1955: Total Jewish Population : 1,590,500/ Total Non-Jewish Population : 198,600/ Total Population 1,789,100 / % of Jewish Population : 88.9% So what happened to the majority Non-Jewish Population? They were run out of their homes, killed or pushed out by the newly created State of Israel. They had their lands , homes and farms taken from them by force. Over 480 towns and villages were destroyed. All of this is documented in archives. The same happened to the Native Americans here in the United States. It just that it happened a long time ago. It was taken bit by bit over time. It's what is still going on in Palestine aka Israel today. Don't forget the State of Israel is only 70 years old.
thank you Le Trio Joubran and thank you Roger Waters, you're a great man. ignore the army of hasbara trolls, with every dislike they drop they get a free Bamba and a Falafel sandwich from netanyahu LOL
so sad that Israel so easily forgot about the tragic past of their nation, about that time when they ware behind the wall and right now they are building the same walls around others... so sad. respect for Mr Waters.
It played only seconds and 2 ADD played their time out! I did not expect an recital of the poem in English translation! A shame that so many gets lost in translation...
Roger Waters you are a great man! You are among the few ones who have the courage to tell the truth! All the others have been either corrupted or brainwashed but you haven't. Respect from Italy
Come on, its about music, not indoctrination. Its a matter of just reading both Quran and Talmud to know what those think of you while you weep for one side or another.
Roger Waters canta junto a Le Trio Joubran, una de las bandas más conocidas de música palestina tradicional, esta pieza titulada "Supremacy" (Supremacía), concebida como una respuesta a Trump, quien decidió reconocer a Jerusalén como capital de Israel y ordenó el traslado de la embajada estadounidense, que estaba en Tel Aviv,. La leyenda del rock y exintegrante de Pink Floyd Roger Waters recita sobre la música de los laúdes árabes versos de Mahmud Darwish,considerado el poeta nacional palestino y fallecido en Texas en 2008. El poema de Darwish, "The Red Indian's Penultimate Speech to the White Man" ("El penúltimo discurso del piel roja al hombre blanco") es el relato de un indígena estadounidense que protesta por los asentamientos que alterarán su tierra para siempre, una queja que tiene claras semejanzas con la ocupación de los territorios palestinos por parte de Israel: "¿Dónde, oh amo blanco, estás llevando a mi gente... y a los tuyos?", recita el roquero británico. "Honramos las luchas de los pueblos indígenas de todo el mundo, y a través de nuestro arte, afirmamos que la relación entre las personas, cultura y su patria sobrevive a la historia", afirma Waters en un comunicado. Música independiente novedades.
A long time must go by before our present becomes history, just like us, we will face the long march, But first, we will defend the trees we wear, we will defend the bell of the night and the hanging moon over our huts, we will defend the leaping deer and the clay of our pots, and our feathers in the wings of the final songs. But soon you will erect your world on our remains, you will pave over the sacred places to open the road to the artificial moon. This is the age of industry. This is the age of minerals, and out of coal the champagne of the strong will dawn... There are dead and settlements, dead and bulldozers, dead and hospitals, dead and radar screens that capture the dead who die more than once in life, screens that capture the dead who live after death, and the dead who breed the beast of civilization as death, and the dead who die to carry the earth after the relics are gone, Where, oh white master, are you taking my people...and yours?”
We admire such a humanist like the great Roger Waters (thank you), who after all, defends a justice cause like our Palestinian's. With your wonderful voice, your personality and notoriety, you showed people what is the importance of being an influent artist on such humanitarian causes. Vivre la liberté, and the music that making people get closer.
Muslim Arabs have the rest of the Middle East and North Africa to talk Arabic, and practice Islam in the majority. But a country the size of Wales for those who want to speak Hebrew and live in a culturally Jewish country is too much for them.
I am not an Arab, I am not a Muslim or a Jew. I am from Colombia, South America, I am Catholic, and I have nothing to do with problems in the Mid East. But I know Jerusalem is not and will not be the capital of any State or religion in the world, it is a historic city that belongs to all humanity, plane and simple. Just for the record, if you call me anti-semite (which is the trend among some people), remember that Jesus was Aramaean, I am his follower. Semite means a Hebrew, Arab or Aramaean speaker, sons and daughters of Sem (Noa's child), thus it would be as stupid as my argument to call me like that.
Israeil is killing kids , women , old poeple , young poeple , innocent people ... why ?? They didn't do any crime to them , they are just wanting their country to return to them ,they just want to live peacefully with their poeple .... is that a crime .. oh palestine my heart is breaking for you 💔 يا رب أعن أهل الفلسطين المظلومين و المسلوبين حقهم و كن لهم خير نصيير يالله و كف عنهم أذى و جور و ظلم الصهاينة أرهم فيهم الذل و الخزي و الهزيمة
I love all the pro Israel comments. Number one fans right there. All Roger stands for is for peace. All he wants for people is to live in harmony. He is no bigot, anti-semite. He has stated multiple times that through his music and the music of Pink Floyd, which is probably why you are here, that the message has always been about people and how we can live together. You may disagree, but I see too much hatred just on this silly little video alone. Spread love not hate. ✌
Palestine is the name of a Roman Province (After they Conquered Judea) learn some history - it was never was an Arab State; mostly jews lived there all the time.
I don't think that this song is about palestinans...jews...etc. Is about humman rights...is about our greed and selfishness...and hypocrisy. We rush for goods, we walk on deaths just for our ideas...we destroy everything that is not feeding our greed...and I think that this song is say this...
Shielding Apartheid Israel from criticism and supporting the Occupier/Apartheid Jewish state no matter what crimes she commits has caused the United States the loss of respect around the world. In addition, Israel has cost American taxpayers more than $520 billion in the past 40 years, not to mention the blood (4500+ soldiers) and treasure ($3.7 trillion, and still counting) to fight the Iraq War for them. Our one-sided unbalanced Middle East policy has created the hatred of tens of millions and the primary cause of terrorism that has landed on our own soil..
Isis, Al Qaeda, the Taliban, and the Palestinians (Hamas) have caused Islam the loss of respect around the world. Only 19% of Americans sympathize with the Palestinians and for the first time in over half a century the right wing are gaining in Europe. Take a guess as to why.
שחר, אני מחזיק בדיעה שלך אבל קללות לא יעזרו, רק ינוצלו כדי להשחיר יותר את פנינו. בייחוד שהתגובה כאן התייחסה לשילוב בין היוצרים ללא הבעת עמדה פוליטית הרבה בריאות
Islamic terror supporters who claim some place that can't be found on a map is real call ISRAEL a fake terrorist nation. That is actually pretty funny.
@@holseyd Well, if Israel stopped committing terrorist acts against Palestine, and stopped making efforts to become a homogenous fascist ethnostate, then it wouldn't be a fake terrorist nation.
TRIO JOUBRAN are Israeli from Nazareth, not from a fiction country called Palestine. Israel is a free democratic country which mean that all there citizens, like the members of TRIO JOUBRAN are free. It's better to learn history by open a book (and not from the media) before you write such thing. Have a nice day from Israel!
Love your anger and attitude towards Jews. I'm not only a Jew lover, I'm a Jew myself. So your love really strengthens us. Thanks buddy,By the way, if you're a Christian than mind you - your savior is a Jew.If you're a Muslim than god(not Allah) help you.And after all is said and done - Roger is still a long gone relic.
Roger Waters is already an old man on the border of the dead, and he knows that the last significant thing he will do in his life will be to boycott Israel ... In Israel anyway, no one wants to hear him
theraven900 Its been 70 years and somehow people still say that... I find it very amusing to read people's comments on things they absolutely have no idea about and just write hateful things.
As I say, we here to stay. and no such a thing plastain. this word is made up by morons like you we are so lucky our enemies are so stupid just like you So go make up some more nations because it's no working with that made-up plastain. And you're stupid
500,000 dead Syrians are waiting for their song. Does Roger Waters gonna write something or is jew-bashing the only way that washed out artist can write a song? In any case he's already 74. Shouldn't be long now.
Oh yeah? Gee whiz I always thought that Assad was a power hungry tyrant being aided by the Russians I guess that was all just fake news. So show us your proof in regards to your claim about Israel arming the rebels mr "cool guy".
Jew bashing? Is pointing out and/or disagreeing with the expansionism and dehumanising policies of the Israeli regime "Jew bashing"? It is impossible to start any sort of dialogue when that is how Israelis treat criticism. "Hey man, you are mistreating these people" Israeli response: "HELP!!! Anti -semitism! I am being oppressed". But that is ofcourse how bullies operate. Schoolyardsychology 101. It is also quite hilariously ironic that an artist who has, all his Life and career, been a fervent opposer of any form of discrimination, injustice and the senseless wars is made out to be an anti-semite by people whose foreign and domestic policies are based upon undeniable racism and exclusion of those who are different than them. Ofcourse, the basic premise of judaism; a people "chosen" by a mythical invisible man in the sky, invites a lot of arrogance and entitlement in the followers of that superstition. Sadly, the existence of Israel is contrary to Judaism, so the true Jew bashers are the ignorant non-believing Israeli expansionists who call themselves Jews but do not follow Judaic scriptures. Israel as a state should only exist after the Mashiah has returned. I have as yet not seen any Mashiah. Chances are none will come, ofcourse...thinking you are chosen by god is a sign of psychosis.
You're not the first Jew hater trying to pass the self off as a human rights advocate dumbasswhirrier or what ever. But even your fellow Jew hating fake social justice warriors aren't going to bother reading your long winded canned anti-Israel propaganda rant.
Yariv Rosenstein: You're either jealous of Roger's genius, or you're just another Zionist troll unhappy with his decent stand on Palestine. And you're clearly ignorant about Pink Floyd. Go f___k yourself.
you don't have to like israel, but let's not pretend that being anti israel is not being on the side of hamas. and if you are on the side of hamas, you just cannot speak about human rights. this hypocresy is at the core of those who are opposed to israel. fools.
Israel is another apartheid state , whining about being misunderstood. We understand perfectly . The abused become abusers; a common psychological development. Do unto others if you want the world to respect you.
"Palestinians" don't live in huts you make civilization sound like it's a bad thing, just because the the Arabs couldn't build one where the Jews did doesn't make it a bad thing.
Lets do a deal when USA will give Independence to the Indians and Russia will release the 200+ Civilizations a free state. we will give the so-called invented Arab Palestinians (now they call themselves Cannians...) a state. fine ? start with them...
When civilization and technical development goes along with authoritarianism, discrimination and cruelty towards the weak, one should criticize, shouldn't they? Oh, and the Arabs are capable enough of creating civilization and progress.. They proved it during the Middle Ages, when the Europeans where doing nothing but killing each other, and dying of cholera due to lack of sewage/hygiene systems.
I'm a Muslim, and I really appreciate Roger and the art he represents to the world, I'm actually a huge fan of Israeli artists too like Orphaned land, maybe you just need to hang out with more Muslims 😁
I have enough Muslim friends. And no one will criticize me if what I wrote is a hate speech. The situation can not be ignored. There is extremism in Islam. Roger Waters further intensifies the hatred. Calling for a boycott of a country that defends its independence is a hate speech.
always .. just fucking ..always ... you gotta shove islam into political discussions like you got no other argument .. pretty much explains why ISIS was created LOL
It's pretty well known throughout the music industry that years of drug abuse has left Roger Waters mentally handicapped (it's even apparent from listening to his speech). At some point his family will have to step in and attempt clearing his name by issuing statements or even possibly through lawsuits against those who have been taking advantage by co-opting Roger's disabilities for their own political goals. Those people are destroying this man's reputation and should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.
"This quite possibly has to be the most ludicrous and laughable nonsense I've ever seen on CZcams. Honestly, the "apple-pen, pineapple-pen" video makes more sense than Roger Waters' dribble."
A great poem. Thanks. It says what it has to. Disgusting that so many people were moved to watch this short video and cast a thumbs down. Undoubtedly, those people don't know poetry and justice and only want to protect their ignorance and chauvinism. I am a 76 year old Jew, born into zionism but who left it when I discovered how my people have turned their backs on Justice. I am ashamed of my people. Thank you, Roger Waters, for all the work you have done for Justice.
In the end they'll still kill you for being jewish and not for liking Roger Waters !
Thanks from Palestine
Thanks
If only True Semitic Hebrews descendants of The prophet Israel himself wanted to live in the Holy Land with us Muslims and Christians we wouldn't have refused, Alas these European Crypto Jews gog and magog, want everything to themselves, not just the Holy land but the whole Arab world, they have Mecca on their eyes too. We know they will fail like they always did, this God's narrative to this world, the prophecies will come true, and Jesus son of Mary will return to this ugly world and make something beautiful out of what will be left of it.
One of the greatest poems performed by one of the greatest musicians of our time. Some of the comments below are really disgusting and show how ignorant some people can be. Anti zionism, anti occupation and anti apartheid is not anti semitism plus some of you should perhaps read history, if it were not for the Arabs in Spain and throughout history there probably wouldn't be any jews. Bottom line is that whatever you say about Waters will not eclipse his status among millions of his fans and whatever lies you dish out won't change the fact that you are defending an ugly and illegal apartheid system called Israel.
Starts with eloquence..continues with historical inaccuracy and (perhaps mistakenly?)with vilification of Israel (“an ugly and illegal apartheid system called Israel”).So I’m confused , are we to believe that pro Jewish/Israel/Zionist comments qualify for your show of disgust when you write “ Some of the comments below are really disgusting and show how ignorant some people can be” ?
i fully agree with everything you said
Precisely..
Just left a feed from someone trying to convince me how the situation between Palestine n Israel is not Apartheid 🤦♀️
The word Palestine derives from Philistia, the name given by Greek writers to the land of the Philistines, who in the 12th century bce occupied a small pocket of land on the southern coast, between modern Tel Aviv-Yafo and Gaza. The name was revived by the Romans in the 2nd century ce in “Syria Palaestina,” designating the southern portion of the province of Syria, and made its way thence into Arabic, where it has been used to describe the region at least since the early Islamic era. After Roman times the name had no official status until after World War I and the end of rule by the Ottoman Empire, when it was adopted for one of the regions mandated to Great Britain; in addition to an area roughly comprising present-day Israel and the West Bank, the mandate included the territory east of the Jordan River now constituting the Hashimite Kingdom of Jordan, which Britain placed under an administration separate from that of Palestine immediately after receiving the mandate for the territory.
If you want to say there is no Palestine, you should also say there is no Jordon, and no Iraq. It's all part of greater Syria, or what was part of the Ottoman Empire.
1918: Population of Palestine from the Jewish Virtual Library:
Total Jewish Population : 60,000/ Total Non-Jewish Population : 600,000/ Total Population : 660,000/ % of Jewish Population : 8.1%
1946: Total Jewish Population : 543,000/ Total Non-Jewish Population : 1,267,037/ Total Population : 1,181,037/
% of Jewish Population : 30%
1948: Total Jewish Population : 716,700/ Total Non-Jewish Population : 156,000/ Total Population : 872,700 /
% of Jewish Population : 82.1%
1955: Total Jewish Population : 1,590,500/ Total Non-Jewish Population : 198,600/ Total Population 1,789,100 /
% of Jewish Population : 88.9%
So what happened to the majority Non-Jewish Population? They were run out of their homes, killed or pushed out by the newly created State of Israel. They had their lands , homes and farms taken from them by force. Over 480 towns and villages were destroyed. All of this is documented in archives.
The same happened to the Native Americans here in the United States. It just that it happened a long time ago. It was taken bit by bit over time. It's what is still going on in Palestine aka Israel today. Don't forget the State of Israel is only 70 years old.
Truly inspirational, thank you Roger for your humanity and kindness.
Bravo and thank you Roger Waters from Moscow!
thank you Le Trio Joubran and thank you Roger Waters, you're a great man. ignore the army of hasbara trolls, with every dislike they drop they get a free Bamba and a Falafel sandwich from netanyahu LOL
Roger Waters & Banksy, two british stars that do more than any arab star for Palestine. They do know what is dignity
so sad that Israel so easily forgot about the tragic past of their nation, about that time when they ware behind the wall and right now they are building the same walls around others...
so sad.
respect for Mr Waters.
This is heart-touching.
the power of art will prevail
Great and strong message. There are hearts that are harder than stone, and even rivers can flow out of stone.
It played only seconds and 2 ADD played their time out! I did not expect an recital of the poem in English translation! A shame that so many gets lost in translation...
Roger Waters you are a great man! You are among the few ones who have the courage to tell the truth! All the others have been either corrupted or brainwashed but you haven't. Respect from Italy
Thanks for this
We need more from this
Free Palestine you cant kill us all
LONG LIVE PALESTINE AND YOU BEAUTIFUL PALESTINIAN PPL
trust you to do it on your own
אביחי יהב 😉
Very powerful message!
Powerful message
رائعة.. ألف مبروك
Roger porta la musica all’interno della coscienza✊🏽🏴
Wow ❤
Trio Joubran and Roger Waters ? More like goosebumps and tears. I am appealingly mesmerized.
Too bad it's used for hatred
is not used for hatred, is the REALITY of a STOLEN LAND named PALESTINE.
czcams.com/video/-evIyrrjTTY/video.html
You should be laughing not crying at this sanctimonious crap.
thanks for teaching me what to feel. that seems totally humble.
AMAZING.
Huge respect
Come on, its about music, not indoctrination. Its a matter of just reading both Quran and Talmud to know what those think of you while you weep for one side or another.
Resisti Roger!!!! Impegnarsi in una lotta non è una strada facile
Lovely!💕🎸Thanks!🌹
Poems everybody! The laddie reckons himself a poet! Absolutely brilliant. I just watched it three times in a row.
Roger should make a song out of this poem
Roger Waters canta junto a Le Trio Joubran, una de las bandas más conocidas de música palestina tradicional, esta pieza titulada "Supremacy" (Supremacía), concebida como una respuesta a Trump, quien decidió reconocer a Jerusalén como capital de Israel y ordenó el traslado de la embajada estadounidense, que estaba en Tel Aviv,. La leyenda del rock y exintegrante de Pink Floyd Roger Waters recita sobre la música de los laúdes árabes versos de Mahmud Darwish,considerado el poeta nacional palestino y fallecido en Texas en 2008.
El poema de Darwish, "The Red Indian's Penultimate Speech to the White Man" ("El penúltimo discurso del piel roja al hombre blanco") es el relato de un indígena estadounidense que protesta por los asentamientos que alterarán su tierra para siempre, una queja que tiene claras semejanzas con la ocupación de los territorios palestinos por parte de Israel: "¿Dónde, oh amo blanco, estás llevando a mi gente... y a los tuyos?", recita el roquero británico.
"Honramos las luchas de los pueblos indígenas de todo el mundo, y a través de nuestro arte, afirmamos que la relación entre las personas, cultura y su patria sobrevive a la historia", afirma Waters en un comunicado.
Música independiente novedades.
Me desgarra el corazon...
Love it! #BDS
Palestine will not be erased.
Already was, over 40 years ago.
Mike Cobretti which prove the bastard entity israel has denied its right to exist
Spexxy19 Palestine is a hoax
A long time must go by before our present becomes history, just like us, we will face the long march,
But first, we will defend the trees we wear, we will defend the bell of the night and the hanging moon over our huts, we will defend the leaping deer and the clay of our pots, and our feathers in the wings of the final songs.
But soon you will erect your world on our remains, you will pave over the sacred places to open the road to the artificial moon. This is the age of industry.
This is the age of minerals, and out of coal the champagne of the strong will dawn...
There are dead and settlements, dead and bulldozers, dead
and hospitals, dead and radar screens that capture the dead
who die more than once in life, screens that capture the dead
who live after death, and the dead who breed the beast of civilization as death,
and the dead who die to carry the earth after the relics are gone,
Where, oh white master, are you taking my people...and yours?”
Loads of appreciations
Fantastic
We admire such a humanist like the great Roger Waters (thank you), who after all, defends a justice cause like our Palestinian's.
With your wonderful voice, your personality and notoriety, you showed people what is the importance of being an influent artist on such humanitarian causes. Vivre la liberté, and the music that making people get closer.
כאשר אלוהים רוצה להעניש מישהו הוא לוקח ממנו את השכל....
Long Live Palestine
Roger, thank you! Really touching poem!
Bravo et merci, Roger Waters !
سَيَمْضي زمانٌ طويلٌ ليصبح حاضرنا ماضيًا مثْلنا
سَنمْضي إلى حتْفنا، أوّلاً، سنُدافع عن شَجرٍ نَرْتَديه
وَعَنْ جَرَس اللّيل، عن قمرٍ، فوق أكواخنا نشْتهيه
وعن طيش غزلاننا سندافع، عن طين فخّارِنا سَندُافعْ
وعن ريشنا في جناح الأغاني الأخيرَةِ. عمّا قَليل
تُقيمون عالمكُمْ فَوْق عالَمِنَا: مِنْ مقابِرِنا تَفْتَحون الطَّرِيق
إلى الْقمر الاصطناعيِّ، هذا زمان الصّناعاتِ. هَذَا
زمانُ المعادن، من قطعةِ الفحْم تبزغُ شمْبانيا الأقْوياء..
هُنالك موْتى ومستوطناتٌ، وموْتى وبولدوزراتٌ، وموْتى
ومستشْفياتٌ، وموتى وشاشاتُ رادار ترْصُدُ مَوْتى
يعيشون بَعْد الممات، وموْتى يُربّونَ وحْش الحضارات مَوْتًا،
وموتى يموتون كيْ يحملوا الأرض فوق الرّفاتْ..
إلى أيْنَ، يا سيّد البيض، تأخُذُ شعْبي.. وشعْبَكْ
إلى أيّ هاويةٍ يأخذُ الأرض هذا الرّوبوتُ المدجّج بالطّائِرَات
We will defend!
Muslim Arabs have the rest of the Middle East and North Africa to talk Arabic, and practice Islam in the majority. But a country the size of Wales for those who want to speak Hebrew and live in a culturally Jewish country is too much for them.
Europeans stole the land . They are good at that, Gentile and Jew alike.
I am not an Arab, I am not a Muslim or a Jew. I am from Colombia, South America, I am Catholic, and I have nothing to do with problems in the Mid East. But I know Jerusalem is not and will not be the capital of any State or religion in the world, it is a historic city that belongs to all humanity, plane and simple.
Just for the record, if you call me anti-semite (which is the trend among some people), remember that Jesus was Aramaean, I am his follower. Semite means a Hebrew, Arab or Aramaean speaker, sons and daughters of Sem (Noa's child), thus it would be as stupid as my argument to call me like that.
Israeil is killing kids , women , old poeple , young poeple , innocent people ... why ?? They didn't do any crime to them , they are just wanting their country to return to them ,they just want to live peacefully with their poeple .... is that a crime .. oh palestine my heart is breaking for you 💔
يا رب أعن أهل الفلسطين المظلومين و المسلوبين حقهم و كن لهم خير نصيير يالله و كف عنهم أذى و جور و ظلم الصهاينة أرهم فيهم الذل و الخزي و الهزيمة
I love all the pro Israel comments. Number one fans right there. All Roger stands for is for peace. All he wants for people is to live in harmony. He is no bigot, anti-semite. He has stated multiple times that through his music and the music of Pink Floyd, which is probably why you are here, that the message has always been about people and how we can live together. You may disagree, but I see too much hatred just on this silly little video alone. Spread love not hate. ✌
Wrong - he has proven himself an anti Semite on numerous occasions. Just look at his flying pig with the Star of David on it.
This flat mind approach will bring more and more terrorism into Europe
He's a MONSTER of DEATH AND VIOLENCE He has become what he says he hates
I’m older than Roger and I know where he was indoctrinated…by his father who was stationed with the British Army in “Palestine” before 1949…
Palestine is the name of a Roman Province (After they Conquered Judea) learn some history - it was never was an Arab State; mostly jews lived there all the time.
I don't think that this song is about palestinans...jews...etc. Is about humman rights...is about our greed and selfishness...and hypocrisy. We rush for goods, we walk on deaths just for our ideas...we destroy everything that is not feeding our greed...and I think that this song is say this...
Bravo.
nice++++
What is the name of the poem?
خطبة الهندي الأحمر
google THE SPEECH OF THE RED INDIAN and you will find a translated version of the poem
Hope there is more of this!
Shielding Apartheid Israel from criticism and supporting the Occupier/Apartheid Jewish state no matter what crimes she commits has caused the United States the loss of respect around the world.
In addition, Israel has cost American taxpayers more than $520 billion in the past 40 years, not to mention the blood (4500+ soldiers) and treasure ($3.7 trillion, and still counting) to fight the Iraq War for them. Our one-sided unbalanced Middle East policy has created the hatred of tens of millions and the primary cause of terrorism that has landed on our own soil..
Isis, Al Qaeda, the Taliban, and the Palestinians (Hamas) have caused Islam the loss of respect around the world. Only 19% of Americans sympathize with the Palestinians and for the first time in over half a century the right wing are gaining in Europe. Take a guess as to why.
✊🏻🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🤲🏻🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺💔🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
all those wonderful things she whispers in his ears at nights, kisses farts and a quiver of hateful darts, poisoning their minds and hearts.
Long Live Palestine 😍
Indeed, LONG LIVE PALESTINE and its BEAUTIFUL PALESTINIAN PPL
Error 404 - Palestine not found
You mean Israel?
Can someone please point out "Palestine" on a map for me? I just can't seem to find one any where that lists that place.
Yes Viva Palestina
❤🖤💚 Free Palestine
That is a great collab. I really love this
שחר,
אני מחזיק בדיעה שלך אבל קללות לא יעזרו, רק ינוצלו כדי להשחיר יותר את פנינו.
בייחוד שהתגובה כאן התייחסה לשילוב בין היוצרים ללא הבעת עמדה פוליטית
הרבה בריאות
Well that's some regressive shit.
Israel is a fake country
AND A TERRORIST ONE AS WELL
*Palestine
Islamic terror supporters who claim some place that can't be found on a map is real call ISRAEL a fake terrorist nation. That is actually pretty funny.
Riad Salemi God bless Israel, the real Palestine...
@@holseyd Well, if Israel stopped committing terrorist acts against Palestine, and stopped making efforts to become a homogenous fascist ethnostate, then it wouldn't be a fake terrorist nation.
Roger lost his voice. Now he lost his mind!
I don't think he's ever had much of a singing voice.
Wars over fairy tails ... Stupid humanity ! Why don't you all live together and move on ?
Is this a song???
BIBLICAL PROPHECY
❤Résistance aux envahisseurs et colonialistes.
27.545
Israel is the light
of HELL
... "the light", to Richard Spencer :-D
1
Listened for 2 minutes & NO punch line :(
The greatest poet of Palestine in the voice of the greatest musician Roger Waters. Makes my heart cry of joy ¡ FREE PALESTINE !
TRIO JOUBRAN are Israeli from Nazareth, not from a fiction country called Palestine. Israel is a free democratic country which mean that all there citizens, like the members of TRIO JOUBRAN are free.
It's better to learn history by open a book (and not from the media) before you write such thing.
Have a nice day from Israel!
You mean terrorstine
You can't free something that never existed...... Free Whatever...
cool guy with the zero history ...
From Nazareth - Israel, And they have Israeli Passport
This Pink Floyd relic is indeed gone. So long Roger
Fuck off JEW lover!!!
Love your anger and attitude towards Jews. I'm not only a Jew lover, I'm a Jew myself. So your love really strengthens us. Thanks buddy,By the way, if you're a Christian than mind you - your savior is a Jew.If you're a Muslim than god(not Allah) help you.And after all is said and done - Roger is still a long gone relic.
Good for you
Roger Waters is already an old man on the border of the dead, and he knows that the last significant thing he will do in his life will be to boycott Israel ... In Israel anyway, no one wants to hear him
Long life to jews. Short for Israel and sionism. Jews without Israel, that's the meaning. Thanks Roger.
Israel is here to stay! And NO such a thing plastain.
As a keen supporter of Palestinian rights, I think theraven900's comment is absolute trash.
theraven900 Its been 70 years and somehow people still say that... I find it very amusing to read people's comments on things they absolutely have no idea about and just write hateful things.
No such a thing. Therefore you can call it pee as well
Bla Bla Bla
Is there anything else you guys know except killing people?
AS I SAID: WE HERE TO STAY!
As I say, we here to stay. and no such a thing plastain. this word is made up by morons like you
we are so lucky our enemies are so stupid just like you
So go make up some more nations because it's no working with that made-up plastain.
And you're stupid
He looks mental lol!
because palestine did nothing wrong!
500,000 dead Syrians are waiting for their song.
Does Roger Waters gonna write something or is jew-bashing the only way that washed out artist can write a song?
In any case he's already 74. Shouldn't be long now.
Well said, bravo to you for underscoring Waters's hypocrisy.
76 Yarich listen to “The Last Refugee”
Oh yeah? Gee whiz I always thought that Assad was a power hungry tyrant being aided by the Russians I guess that was all just fake news. So show us your proof in regards to your claim about Israel arming the rebels mr "cool guy".
Jew bashing? Is pointing out and/or disagreeing with the expansionism and dehumanising policies of the Israeli regime "Jew bashing"?
It is impossible to start any sort of dialogue when that is how Israelis treat criticism.
"Hey man, you are mistreating these people"
Israeli response: "HELP!!! Anti -semitism! I am being oppressed".
But that is ofcourse how bullies operate. Schoolyardsychology 101.
It is also quite hilariously ironic that an artist who has, all his Life and career, been a fervent opposer of any form of discrimination, injustice and the senseless wars
is made out to be an anti-semite by people whose foreign and domestic policies are based upon undeniable racism and exclusion of those who are different than them.
Ofcourse, the basic premise of judaism; a people "chosen" by a mythical invisible man in the sky, invites a lot of arrogance and entitlement in the followers of that superstition.
Sadly, the existence of Israel is contrary to Judaism, so the true Jew bashers are the ignorant non-believing Israeli expansionists who call themselves Jews but do not follow Judaic scriptures.
Israel as a state should only exist after the Mashiah has returned.
I have as yet not seen any Mashiah.
Chances are none will come, ofcourse...thinking you are chosen by god is a sign of psychosis.
You're not the first Jew hater trying to pass the self off as a human rights advocate dumbasswhirrier or what ever. But even your fellow Jew hating fake social justice warriors aren't going to bother reading your long winded canned anti-Israel propaganda rant.
czcams.com/video/s97pAth_yzI/video.html
Long live palestine 🇵🇸
Ever since he was kicked out from pink floyd he is terrible.
Yariv Rosenstein:
You're either jealous of Roger's genius, or you're just another Zionist troll unhappy with his decent stand on Palestine. And you're clearly ignorant about Pink Floyd. Go f___k yourself.
קיש מיר אין טוכעס
fuck you jew!!
Cool Daddio fuck you 2
זויגן מיין פּעניס
you don't have to like israel, but let's not pretend that being anti israel is not being on the side of hamas. and if you are on the side of hamas, you just cannot speak about human rights. this hypocresy is at the core of those who are opposed to israel. fools.
Israel is another apartheid state , whining about being misunderstood. We understand perfectly . The abused become abusers; a common psychological development. Do unto others if you want the world to respect you.
I always preferred Gilmour
no one prefers an ugly jew bag like u
MOTION PASSED!!! JEW BAG IS DONE!!
Fuck you Ammon or in spanish aka "mamon"... take your jew ass somewhere else!!!
"Palestinians" don't live in huts
you make civilization sound like it's a bad thing, just because the the Arabs couldn't build one where the Jews did doesn't make it a bad thing.
It's a poem, you absolute numbskull. The "huts" are an allusion to the American Natives and how their culture was relegated to history.
Talisman so you agree it is an inconsistent comparison
No.
Lets do a deal when USA will give Independence to the Indians and Russia will release the 200+ Civilizations a free state. we will give the so-called invented Arab Palestinians (now they call themselves Cannians...) a state. fine ? start with them...
When civilization and technical development goes along with authoritarianism, discrimination and cruelty towards the weak, one should criticize, shouldn't they?
Oh, and the Arabs are capable enough of creating civilization and progress.. They proved it during the Middle Ages, when the Europeans where doing nothing but killing each other, and dying of cholera due to lack of sewage/hygiene systems.
The face of evil and terror
I don't see Netanyahu here?
♥♥♥♥♥
The story is about an Indian who says these words to the white people who have chased them away from their homeland....
Roger Waters does not understand that Islam will kill him too Too bad from a huge singer
To a person who is not worth spitting
I'm a Muslim, and I really appreciate Roger and the art he represents to the world, I'm actually a huge fan of Israeli artists too like Orphaned land, maybe you just need to hang out with more Muslims 😁
I have enough Muslim friends.
And no one will criticize me if what I wrote is a hate speech.
The situation can not be ignored.
There is extremism in Islam.
Roger Waters further intensifies the hatred.
Calling for a boycott of a country that defends its independence is a hate speech.
there are no christian extremist? what about Jews extremist oh wait its called israel
My family is Muslim, and they all love Roger Waters for his humanity and support for the downtrodden and the occupied. You are a laughable moron.
always .. just fucking ..always ... you gotta shove islam into political discussions like you got no other argument .. pretty much explains why ISIS was created LOL
long live to israel
It's pretty well known throughout the music industry that years of drug abuse has left Roger Waters mentally handicapped (it's even apparent from listening to his speech). At some point his family will have to step in and attempt clearing his name by issuing statements or even possibly through lawsuits against those who have been taking advantage by co-opting Roger's disabilities for their own political goals. Those people are destroying this man's reputation and should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.
Your comments show Zionism is scared of Roger Waters.
This guy doesn't know anything about Israel or what they have to do to defend themselves. He had great music but this is preposterous.
This egomaniac has lost it. Can the sight of Waters dancing naked through the streets of Gaza be far behind?
said the khazarian zionist
haya valentinogaravani please tell me that you are real!!!!
"This quite possibly has to be the most ludicrous and laughable nonsense I've ever seen on CZcams. Honestly, the "apple-pen, pineapple-pen" video makes more sense than Roger Waters' dribble."
Brave words coming from someone with a minion profile pic.
FU Roger the Nazi Waters
ISRAEL 👍🇮🇱❤️
Can't stand Roger, but this is awesome !