Queendom Puzzle Ep.9 - Review and Ranking
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 08. 2023
- Sorry for how bad this video is, I was rushing since I'm literally going home today and I wanted to be able to upload this. I had a lot of fun at the OEC concert last night, they're so cute!!!!
But honestly, this show is tiring me out... I was so excited going into it and now it's just getting messier and messier. Justice for Cherry Bullet. Justice for weeekly.
If I made any mistakes then that's not my fault and I take no responsibility. I've been running on so little sleep this whole vacation it's amazing how I even got through the concert alive. Anyways. Going home which means I can get back to real editing with actual video resources. See you soon!
(subtitles will be posted tomorrow) - Hudba
![[#퀸덤퍼즐/9회] ♬ i DGA (i DONT GIVE A) - 도화, 엘리, 여름, 예은, 유키, 파이, 휘서 #QUEENDOMPUZZLE | Mnet 230808 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lsb7-gwlmXY/mqdefault.jpg)
The part about Jiwoo feeling like she doesn't belong there and is hogging the space just feels so true it's so depressing.
Exactly she doesn't even need the show
But I hope no one is sending her any hate she has improved a lot and given some great performances and obviously none of mnet’s bs is her fault.
@@phoebep4688 it's so sad because jiwoo's group is doing well and she got enough exposure from the show plus wooyeon has Nana who is crazy popular and will debut regardless, those 2 surviving was such a waste of space it's sad meanwhile jiwon & Bora literally depend on this show
@@hueningbahibitch no I’m definitely sad too and I do feel like Jiwon and Bora really needed this show more than some of the other contestants and I think recognizing that is 100% fine so long as we don’t send hate to any of those other contestants because it’s not their fault and they’re still talented too.
@@phoebep4688 I know but I really don't understand why netizens voted for them, I think jiwoo was genuinely voted for her talent but wooyeon was definitely voted just for visuals which is so annoying..
I was so sad when Bora and Jiwon got eliminated, I was hoping after the interim votes people would panic vote for them and they could make it. But no. The worst part is that Jiwon actually would've been safe if Puzzlin' had won benefit.
Jiwon gives everything and shines while doing it. To see her get eliminated again in these types of shows was truly heartbreaking. It really does feel like a last chance as the future for Cherry Bullet seems so unclear….
Like Jiwon’s audition was the best and my fav from the whole show is Yeeun. Jiwon always did well on all the rounds. I feel like Mnet’s editing is the reason for Jiwon fell so many ranks.
@@vixxexo6855 yeah it’s hard to say. Seeing her on these types of shows she always does amazing at everything she does. Sadly she always falls short 😭
honestly, the wedding concept looked like they were getting married to eachother 😭😭😭
i was fully teary eyed and lowkey crying when jiwon and bora got eliminated, was rly hoping at least one of them would make it to the group but goddamn mnet evil editing… wish ppl recognized it for what it was but oh well, at least yeeun should be top 7 and ellys still in it
I'd also point out that Weki Meki hasn't had a comeback in, oh, 632 days now, so if Elly doesn't dark horse into the final group, she's likely not going to be on a stage after the show anytime soon either.
is it siesta their lastest comeback?
@@rielurtziyup
@@rielurtzisadly, yes 😔
@@rielurtzithis might be elly's last opportunity...
I've been trying to predict fantagio's next moves but, since most members are busy with their own things(college, modeling, acting, solo, survival and variety) , it seems like they can't really make group plans. With Elly in El7zup, would the company even bother getting them together? These girls should be in the studio right now if fanta wanted to use the hype Elly is getting on the show, but they (minus Rina, Lua and college student Lucy) keep getting individual schedules instead. Good for them, but we know how much they love performing as 8 and how their sound is irreplaceable in the kpop scene.
It was extra sad to see Haeyoon supporting her members next to Chaerin and see all of them being eliminated :(
literally teared up when bora was eliminated. i was still in the shock of jiwon being eliminated and then they kicked bora out after few minutes :( Mnet can't do anything right.
I'm concerned about Kei right now. There is a chance she could be out from top 7. I keep seeing people who are saying give more chances to the younger contestants. what the heck? who's gonna sing? we already lost (actually Mnet kicked her out) Bora. Kei is the best vocalist in the entire show we need a main vocalist..
I cried over Bora too:(
Bora and Miru getting eliminated was so heartbreaking to me
I wasn't even a fan of Cherry Bullet before this show, but I was so shocked and horrified and sad when Bora got eliminated. I had been voting for her, and hoping that she could still make it into the group... she deserves it, and her vocals would clearly be an asset to the team. I also loved her friendship with Yuki and wanted to see them in the group together. I hope that Bora is doing okay, and that she knows this wasn't her fault, she did everything she could and performed so well :( But on the other hand, I'm thrilled that Yuki is actually getting recognition! I just wish it weren't in the midst of such a weird show
I completely sobbed during Bora’s speech and I don’t cry at anything. Seeing FNC throw her into survival shows because they don’t know what to do with her is so sad but I really thought this would be her chance before Mnet went and ruined it. It breaks my heart so much. The one nice thing has been seeing all of the Bora fans who are just as furious as I am.
I’m going to keep watching the show because Yuki is my second pick after Bora and Mnet doesn’t seem to want her (next to no screen time) so I’m watching essentially to support her but I’m so mad at Mnet I don’t have words.
I did really enjoy the IDGA stage though especially Yuki! She’s now my top pick in the competition and I’m so proud of her stage presence improvement on this show. You can tell she feels really comfortable performing this song and every time I saw her in the center I just wanted more of her.
Guys we have already lost one main vocal "Bora" now we have to vote for "Kei" so that she can maintain her spot in the Top 7 bcoz the team needs a Main vocalist !!
No im not voting
No I hope Mnet gets the worst possible combinatiob.
@@bashgita fr, I'm praying the group flops
@@hueningbahibitch yall are assholes for just throwing the dreams of the rest of the girls just cuz a girl didnt get enough votes to stay like isnt it so fucking mean to hope for the worst?
@@hueningbahibitch you guys are so childish...
I officially quit the show since chebul got eliminated, i'n so sad because their future as a group is so unclear now and the way jiwon & bora were crying felt like it was their last chance
istg if fnc isn't planning a chebul comeback right now I'll start a riot
Bora and Jiwon never give up. Let's support them in the future 😊
It’s the fact they don’t even show all the songs each episode. They also highlight certain people more. Idk this whole show just felt weird.
Whenever I hear the group name I keep hearing Wadada in my head.
Bora and Jiwon stood out in the beginning and had a lot of casual supporters, but as the show went on, their roles in performances became less impactful and more forgettable (also evil/weird edits, though Yeonhee has the same type of competitive personality but gets angel/underdog edits), their fandom couldn't maintain sadly...
Definitely started from Dance The Night Away, Bora's bubble intro and Seoyeon's march band drum dance part stood out... but not a lot of big moments in the performance
In Wannabe, although many would say Wooyeon, but Jiwon had the less impact even by the audience reaction
In Web, Jiwon definitely stood out but Bora was barely showcased, her and Jihan were background
Also the Puzzle vs Queendom narrative and many "supporting the underdogs" didn't help, especially when Puzzle won all
Puzzlin, I DO, i DGA, voting was opened before any of the performances, so it was a mass i DGA voting before anything happened, and Puzzlin was only 1% away from winning
If I DO won, nothing would have changed (edited/corrected)
If Puzzlin won, and it almost did... Dohwa and Jiwoo would be eliminated, and Miru and Jiwon would remain
Also, Nana, Wooyeon, Jiwon, and Jihan grew close in Queendom and have gone out a few times out of filming schedules... they are also close to H1-Key, you could see Wooyeon getting more and more upset from Riina's announcement to Jiwon... These 4 were in Billionaire together, voting should have opened after performances, maybe things would have been different
Also, Nana fractured her finger during rehearsal, and still did the high five choreography from I DO, and then hardly slept and went to Show Champion for MC, then hardly any sleep again to film for Knowing Bros the next day, not including Queendom finale prep, her finger is still fractured
Completely agree. I'm not at all surprised that Bora gets eliminated. It was the exact same scenario in GP999. First everyone was like; "Wow Bora is such a great singer bla bla bla" (and she is a great singer, no doubt about that). Then the group performances starts and Bora is just gone. You have to pause the program to locate her in any group performance. She just lacks the stage presence and charisma that is so important in shows like these. She will always be passade by all the Hwiseos, Nanas, Dayeons and Hikarus out there. I mean look at Yuki. You hardly notice here off stage. I think she have said like 5 sentences in the whole series. But as soon as she steps up on the stage she just pop's. Every time.
@@davidhakanssonhagmanI also feel like reason people don’t vote for Bora is cause of her visuals as well. If Bora looked more like Irene or Jisoo I bet people would have loved her even if she does not have stage presence.
Without winning Dohwa would have 11th place so she is still in the final
Now I got it that all girls were form I do team, yeah, she would be eliminated
@@angelcwooah6481 she got 60 k for win? Because she had 343 k votes and I thought IDGA team got +30 k
@reyandme
Yeah sorry, my calculations are bad sometimes lol, I will remove that message
Suyun, Wooyeon, Jiwon, and Miru would have pushed ahead of Dohwa's 313k
That means I was wrong about if I DO wins, I guess nothing would change, Zoa would be higher but still eliminated, I will edit lol
Jiwon was the best in this show wtf. Cherry Bullet deserved better 😢. Let's support them in the future
I couldn’t not agree more!! I’m very upset and out Jiwon and Bora.
VOTE for SUYUN guys !!!
This global group looking less and less global. Should have never been eliminations to begin with; instead they should have focused on actually puzzling the girls around cuz some of them have been partnered together since the very beginning (Dohwha with Fye, Yeeun with Yeoreum and Nana with Jihan). Where is the puzzlin around? The way Mnet approached this show was just awful and fell off from the very beginning.
The voting system was also super weird. What do you mean we are supposed to vote when only 1 episode of the show with less than half the contestants have performed? How are we voting for these semi-finalist when there was no performances to base the votes on? Why did you even bring the first set of judges on the first round yet disregard that on the other rounds? What do you mean with all the mistakes Puzzle team did during Bad Blood they still managed to win? What do you mean that the popular performances (Shut Down, Time of our life and Overwater) of the show on CZcams and on music platforms lost? Make it make sense.
The story lines and editing were all wack. For the first elimination Chaerin was the only one who was barely shown and the others at least got something but still. For the semifinals the only storyline Miru got was just make another member be the spotlight (Yeeun) then immediately tried to make a storyline about Wooyeon right after and that was at the beginning of the show. In the end Miru got dust and goes to show how popular she was all things considered, I mean just looks at her fancam views. Then you have the members who Mnet tried to push so bad with good edits but got eliminated regardless (Fye & Soojin), and the evil edit members who got the brunt of everything especially the CB girls (Bora, Jiwon and Riina). All that recap bullshit they kept giving us and the few good interesting clips were all just for CZcams which majority of the people don’t even watch.
The top 7 will remain the same and at the end of the day and had Chaeyeon stayed in the show, instead of Yeonhee or Jihan having a spot in the top 7 it would have been Chaeyeon except she would have been the one with most votes instead of Nana. I do think Mnet was going to do the one pick voting system but then they saw the current top 7 and decided to stick with the 7 pick instead.
Queendom 2 was bizzare and I was mad at the results but Queendom Puzzle just made my blood boil.
Bad Blood full ver has over 300k views, people just don't watch the other version as much, also full cam and dance practice is most viewed of all 4 dance songs... and on music streaming apps, Bad Blood has highest streams and Likes... so no, Overwater isn't more popular
And Nxde and Fighting have more views than Shut Down.... so idk... I think it does "make sense" for the most part, Time of our Life got far more attention after it lost, it wouldn't be as high as it is if it won, many go back to watch it to complain, but even without that, yes, it was most viewed before it lost
Also, there are many occasions where other members like Wooyeon, Nana, Suyun, Kei, Jihan, and some others have more fancam views than Miru (look at Bad Blood fancam views, for example), but not Time of our Life, she is definitely highest there, but Suyun Nxde has over 100k views so... using views is not always the best indication for these things, unless you only look at 1 video and 1 source, look at all videos
And, if Miru has these views and all these supporters, why aren't they voting for her? And if they are, then why can't they make a big enough impact to maintain her spot? Views can be inflated pretty easily by algorithm also, just look at Shorts, always inconsistent
Edit: I only agree with ONE thing you said... yes, the groups should have been more random or more puzzling, not the same people working together numerous times
I completely agree that the puzzleing part could have been given much more space. I do not dislike the voting system. Except that so much was determined by the studio audience. That will allways be a very biased group of people. I swear 75% was old WJSN, Lovelyz or CLC fans. Basically impossible to loose if you have Kei, Yeoreum and Yeeun in your team.
@@angelcwooah6481 awesome! You love the show good for you 🙏🏼
WHAT BORA AND JIWOO GOT ELIMINATED!??? DO NONE OF YOU LEARN???
Ι didn't watch the episode on the day of, and when i saw who got eliminated, I lost composure. Thank you Mnet for ruining my day. I won't be watching the rest of the show.
I deleted the voting app right after 😭
@@jonathangonzalez2733 I didn't even vote, because it's Mnet and I didn't trust their voting systems anyway
Everyone knows Boa is such a sweetheart, MNET gets on my nerves!!! 😡 And now, WakeOne is going to have this group, a new boy group(Right?) and where is that going to leave Kepler??? Bc I honestly feel they are neglecting Kepler!!!
😩😩
Debuting under WakeOne as a gg is a near death sentence 😭
@@into_orbit LMBO RIGHT?!!!!!
And this is why I stopped watching mnet shows. They do the same over and over again. Nothing makes sense. The people sent home don't make sense. The fact that i stan like 65% of the contestants their groups and still choose not to support this says a lot. I don't want them to win. I don't want them to be in this. A lot of them should be focusing on their groups right now instead of survivals.
It's not like most of them can focus on their groups since their companies refuse to let them be active :)
This show will actually help the groups get some popularity and comeback, you notice how all the groups of these girls are now announcing comebacks. Some who hadn't had a cb in a year.
@@Paradoxious I have only seen Purple Kiss and H1-KEY having comebacks announced and they get pretty regular comebacks. If you know of anyone else please let me know.
@@timotejgabris9162
woo!ah! and Lightsum did say they were preparing for comeback Feb-Mar, before Queendom was announced, so these could be coming but nothing announced, we just know of prep
What you said about yeoreum at 3:27 is how I felt about her in every performance. I think her spot in the final should have gone to dohwa instead but WJSN’s popularity is what got her that spot. As for bora I think the reason why she also didn’t get a lot of votes is because we knew bora and kei were not gonna make it together and there was always a sort of unspoken rivalry between them and unfortunately for bora everything kei did was too good especially when they went head to head in “snap”
I'm SO glad that I trusted my gut and didn't let myself get invested in this show. I love survival shows but they're rough emotionally anyway, but I was just done after Queendom 2, and I had a feeling Queendom Puzzle was going to be horrible as well, and hearing these eliminations confirms it. I'll continue watching vids like this to see what has happened, and the performance clips, but that's about it.
I genuinely can't pick what has been a worse experience between GP999, QD2, and now QDPZ...
@@into_orbitGirls planet was the straw that broke the camels back. I was already at my wits end what happened to the last season of produce. Seeing what happened during the show (the mistreatment of C-trainees, character assassinations (Cai Bing), and the lineup. Girls Planet made me stop watching survival idol shows and getting invested.
Also…when was the second seulrene album supposed to happen!?!?!?
Just my speculations but based on the amount of effort SM put into making them part of the Kwangya lore I think they were already working on the second album before Irene's scandal, at least the concept
@@into_orbit seulrene was like my favorite kpop thing ever so when I heard you say that I needed to know lolol. You’re right though that song does have the vibe for them.
I'm so happy that all the Rocket Punch members are still in the show cause I love Rocket Punch! 😊
Yeonhee can't rap and lacks in dancing . She is just there bc the mnet editing
I only got through the first 2 episodes, barely, and found it so odd how mnet evil edited Bora. I watched her on girls planet 999 and the difference is night and day. Couldn’t get through the rest of puzzle since I found it dull but I found it sad bora was being portrayed negatively, perhaps to promote Kei better. I feel sorry for Bora and mnet is just shit as always.
Lol I also ditched the show right after they announced Bora and Jiwon was eliminated. Not going to even watch their MV either, it's a reminder of Mnet's successful brainwashing.
If Mnet never wanted them in the first place then okay, they don't deserve the two girls anyway. I'm now a Chebul fan after this show!
I'm not mad about that since I don't even like her voice that much. She's a good singer but Kei is better. Also, she doesn't have enough skills other than singing and that's probably one of the reasons she always flops at the end of this survival shows. I mean, in GP 999 she was portrayed as an angel and a good team leader by MNET and she flopped the same way. So, let's be real. She's cute and sings well but she doesn't have a "wow" factor and that's why she's constantly outshined by other idols. Her elimination has nothing to do with evil editing, because, as I said before, in GP 999 she was portrayed as a very nice person and still didn't make to the final lineup.
I agree with this. But what about jiwon?
I agree with you here…and it did seem from the start it would be her or Kei in the final spot
@@bellehoney6321 I feel like Jiwon fits in the same situation. She's gorgeous and center material but she's not like Nana, for example. I'm not even a Nana stan but her charisma is undeniable and I feel like Jiwon always gets outshined by other super charismatic idols like Nana, Hwiseo or Jihan. I feel really bad for her because she's my bias and I hate seeing her in this situation.
@@justintournoux7421 Yeah, and also Lovelyz still has a HUGE fanbase in Korea. They are voting hard for her.
@@Akire-vv8nk almost like 80% votes came from koreans
Not surprised with her being 4th without the benefits (kei)
Bora being eliminated was not surprising at all. They doesn't have a strong fandom to begin with and she lacks a lot in other areas besides singing.