How Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw treated Pakistani POWs of 1971 war
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 02. 2019
- Field Marshal Sam Hormusji Framji Jamshedji Manekshaw, popularly known as Sam Manekshaw, is credited with India's victory over Pakistan in the 1971 war that led to the creation of Bangladesh. Known for his courage and wit, Field Marshal Manekshaw was extremely popular which went up several notches during the 1971 India-Pakistan war.
The World is One News, WION examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim is to empower people to explore their world.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs as well as personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Google Plus: plus.google.com/+WIONews
This man and Netaji Bose deserves statue in every army academy
Kindly don't equate him with *Netaji Bose.* It is an insult to Netaji Bose. He would not have treated r@pists and murderers with such respect. And definitely would not have let them go scot-free to continue their reign of terror elsewhere. It was the official dictate of the Pakistan Army to "r@pe the Bangladeshi women". This is not something that India/Indians say. It is put on record by Pakistan.
We, Indians, have a habit of elevating characters of dwarven stature to the high heavens. While the real heroes are buried under the layers of dirt created mostly by the left historian.
@@RKB192000 Manekshaw was an army personnel , he was bound by certain rules . It's not upto him to take politically sensitive decisions . If you wanna blame , then blame the then political disposition
@@RKB192000 bro you Speak good English..From where'd you learn it?
Netaji Bose .... he was one of a kind ... he build an army and attacked British even though congress was against him
@@RKB192000 dude I agree with you that we shouldn't have let them just go home, we should have made a deal in exchange of pok, but you can't blame field Marshal Sam Manekshaw for it, he is an army man, his job is to plan and win wars. Indira Gandhi is to blame she just allowed them to go back and didn't speak of Kashmir at all. It was her decision not the field Marshal's.
The brain responsible for a wonderful victory ☺
Not to forget legendary general JRF Jacob .
Brain, bravery, alertness, courage of conviction,sense of humor, above all care and concern for his soldiers.
@@siddhantsingh7606 JFR Jacob*
@@amnamumtaz8774 Well my name says it all 🤷♂️
The name which we most forget is RN kau.. The man behind the plannig of 1971
Always respected the Genral.
His lecture on leadership is magnificent.
Love from Pakistan.
I have saved that lecture.
Precious lessons on leadership
Goodwill from India
Wajahat Alvi well online fighters do not understand how life is tough for Army people. Army men give respect take respect. Simple. Rest are civilians.
well indian armed forces are professional .. my father was from IAF . i know what type of discipline our armed forces maintain even during battle.. in india a soldier is a soldier .. he have no cast no religion.. thatwhy our generals even after retirement stay in india and do jobs for govt and pass his almost 40 years of its original experience to different part of civil life.. sorry to say pakistan general kiyani is now in australia .. musharrf is in dubai and a rajput raheel sharif in saudi arab while there counter parts in india now serve for india only.. thats the main differnce between a soldier always be soldier and others..
Pls tell ur army to show some insaniyt towards prisoner of war of India .....they do very inhumane things
@@ME-tc7fk pow atrocities got committed on both sides . Cant blame one side.
Its sheer fault of both side government to address & expedite in timely manner. Which result in trust deficet.
So the process becomes questionable & delay tactics used which could have been avoided. Hence lifes ruined on both sides by both sides.
Salute sir 🇦🇫🇮🇳🇦🇫
Afghan India bhai bhai❤️❤️
❤️🇮🇳🇦🇫
@@amnamumtaz8774 Arre mulua kitna spam karoge jute khane ka aur man hai😂😂😂😂
@@amnamumtaz8774 true and pakistani army resembles present day taliban ...same jobs...rape,kidnapping,killing weponless people...right
@@amnamumtaz8774 lol 😂😂😂..india won..93k cowards lose 🤡
This is why Indian army is the best in the world. We are capable of showing love to even our enemies.
czcams.com/video/HXAmH3hZgR4/video.html
Emotions statement or fact ?
Superrrrrrb Indian Army 👍,👌
Hain yaar Sahi hai. par kabhi kabhi kuch jayada hi ho jata hai. Apka enemy apse pyar kare na kare Darna jaroor chahiye. Daar jaroori hai pyar nahi. Darr hai to war nahi.
@@arijit020 Don't know about the army but this guy feild Marshal Sam Manekshaw is the best gen known in the Indian army his so down to earth nature simplicity and his respect towards PoW makes him different from other generas (in the world may be )
"LEGEND" is small word for....sir
ICON...no less
WHY is india always jealous of NASA?
@@charlesleroy7291 USA is a developed country while INDIA is developing ...and oppressed by white men country .....and they way INDIA and ISRO progressing ....i dont think so we need to be jeaslous....by 2050 india will be 2nd largest and USA will be 3rd......😄
@@charlesleroy7291 jealous, WTF
NASA is jealous of ISRO
Bcz we are challenging their dominance
Countries like Brazil 🇧🇷 preferring India 🇮🇳 for their lunch in low cost .
ISRO have many world records like most satellite lunch in one time .
One and only country to reach at Mars orbit in it's very 1st attempt
1st country to find water on moon 🌙
And many more
@@charlesleroy7291 ISRO is one of the leading space agency in rank 3-4
Having lowest budget among top 10 .
A soldier deserves respect, even if he is my enemy. The fact that he has put his country before himself is the biggest sacrifice that I can expect from anyone. Jai Hind!
Why is india always jealous of NASA
@@charlesleroy7291 Is this correct? Why should we be jealous of anyone?
@@charlesleroy7291 Tf, we literally have like our own space station named ISRO, why would Indians be jealous of NASA?
Soldiers like the Pakistani army in 1971 who committed innumerable rapes, massacres , executions after asking men to open their lungis DESERVE No respect, no humanity.....nothing.
@@charlesleroy7291 we are jealous??? 😂
Field Marshal 5 star !
5 star
@Arjun Yes, Field Marshal is a 5 star general aka he has 5 stars in his insignia. General of Indian army adores 4 stars on his shoulder not Field Marshal.
Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw, Field Marshal Kariappa and Marshal of the Air Force Arjan Singh are the only 3 ever to get 5 🌟 status in the history of Indian Armed Forces.
@Tanmoy Biswas no there is only Two Field Marshal in India with 5 Star, Cariappa sir and Sam Manekshaw sir. Arjan singh was 4 star Air chief Marshal ❤️
Only
In 1971 not even tea, but even food was fantastic!! 🤣
Haha
Arre bhai bhai savage
Na na na.tareef wo jo dushman karay.apne mou se to sab he tareef krte hain😁😁
@@umairali-il2rx Bhai, Pakistan ke commander ne hi tarif kari thi, hindi mein bola tha "khana bahut acha hai" yani ki "Food is fantastic" hamein pata hai unki English shuru sai hi tang hai 😆😆
🇮🇳🇮🇳💗💗💗fevarete 🔥🔥🔥🔥🐖🐖🐖🐖 fry 🐄🐄beef rost 💗💗
When Sam Manekshaw use to go to SBI bank, employees hand him over there lunch and starts filling his forms
This is a good one :)
Yes govt should privatise it asap
🤣🤣🤣🤣
He died 13 years ago in 2008
@@joydip9044 okk I edited my comment 🙏🙏
General Kariyappa and after Field Marshal Manekshaw was legand military Leader Ever Born in India. Jai Hind
Field Marshal Kariyappa and Field Marshal Manekshaw..... Both are Field Marshal and we'll deserved 5 star rank... The other 5 star ranking officer from India is Arjan Singh.
Sam manekshaw closely resembled in physical shape and behaviour to Iftikhar takkur ( A Pakistani comedian), just Google it you will be surprised.
Salute to you IFTIKHAR TAKKUR sahb😊😊😊
@@amnamumtaz8774 Partly True
They share some similar face cuts
But Irony is
Ek to aap logon ko Hasiyaan baantaa
Aur Dusraa aap ki fauz ko Aasu mein dubaa diyaa
@@samind1604 This reply is pure fire. Loved it ❤️
@@mayankbravo6012 Thanks Brother
Sam Manikshaw..a legend..as a Pakistani soldier i have insane amount of respect for this legend.
You should respect the minority in your country!!!......
@Student of Klaus Schwab Ok?
Being a Pakistani I really appreciate his professionalism. Great General indeed. Love from Pakistan 🇵🇰.
They served one cup of tea for one day and made that much hype we served 93,000 for two months
Kya baat bol di bhidu 👍😎
Remember,abhinandan sir atleast blown up the the f17,but in 1971 those did nothing...
@@Aman-td9nl it was a F-16 fighter jet.
Bhai not 2 month it's more than two years
I am from Pakistan but huge respect for this person. How i wish our generals become professional and loyal to motherland.
This man, I have no words for him. He is such a gallant soldier and possesses such thorough professionalism yet has a ruthless streak to him. It's true that Pakistan Army Generals really did think themselves as Nawabs. Pride had a humiliating fall, as it always does, and we were taught a lesson we will never forget.
😃👍🏻
Ur a gentleman ..salute tp u sir ..
@@rohitramesh3502 you know what hurts me the most. when our Bengali brothers and sisters cheer for Pakistan (now that their team is out) and when our team plays well they appreciate it. bhaijaan I swear at that moment I feel like a piece of trash. look what we did to them, and look how they treat us. man karta hy zameen me aadmi gadh jaey khud se. I mean our Govt has no shame. Imran Khan said GoP should publicly apologize to the Govt and people of Bangladeah for the atrocities our army committed in 1971. but it's been 3 years since he came to power and no apology. shameful isn't it?
@@letsjoinhands what can you expect. I sincerely think an educated human wont vote for him
@@letsjoinhands Bangladesh did not apologize regarding the Bihari genocide they committed
salam/respect from Bangladesh🇧🇩
He is a Bharat Ratna.. and should be awarded the same , albeit posthumously but he really deserves this...
Soldiers are not awarded Bharat Ratna. It is only for civilians
@@blistering2900foolish number 1
As a Bangladeshi i love and respect him so much. He struggled a lot for us❤❤❤❤
Unfortunately most of the Bangladeshis hate India in the influence of " Hojoors'
I will request the channel to upload the full interview of this great man.....He is the inspiration for many 😊😊😊
The full interview is present on CZcams
@@abhirajarora7631 could you provide the link? Would literally pay to watch this interview.
What an alpha male ♂️ country needs more people like Mr. Sam. Legendary stuff.
It can happen, starting with you. All it takes is the will.
Every generation must know about him
We want him in our school textbooks.
Such a legend! He deserves more appreciation, more recognition and respect in our country...
His story should be taught to our children in schools
This is the reason why Indian army is the most professional defence force....
"Were" but not anymore. You can't compare hate filled and politically guided small men like Bipin Rawat to these kind of honourable soldiers.
@@MrKhan-dd7fp but far far better than Pakistani
And everyone can't be like Gandhi , u will find bhagat, Chandrashekhar too
@@sharunchandran3410 India should not be compared to a tiny country like pakistan but a big one like china. But unfortunately India does not compete with powerful Nations. Btw I am not from Pakistan. 🥴
@@MrKhan-dd7fp I don't think china can mess with India...one on one.
Factor are several and few are-
*India is a very strong country ( economic and defence wise)
*India is supported my many developed countries and India's importance in world welfare is known
* China is most hated
That is enough for China to think thrice attacking india.
*
You can't give them proper food and saying indian army is best😂😂
He deserved to be a field marshal. What a gentleman he was❤️
Huge respect
What a leader he was..Sam will always inspire young people
This man wore the dignity of an era gone by. Every little snippet I see of his videos makes me miss him on the behalf of India.
Oh man😂😂 93,000 POW. I wonder what Pakistani text books write about the 1971 war😂😂
They tell us that we were humiliated and forced to sign a treaty with India. Nothing exaggerated
@@muhammadmussawirkhuhro7468 peace to all🤟🤟🤟🤟
@Quartz indian news channels are idiot, pakistani text books are lier
@Quartz yes its true that they dont talk about the massacres and atrocities we did, but they do tell us we were humbled by india
@@muhammadmussawirkhuhro7468 you're very honest.
The first five star general of South Asia- Legendary Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw! Great person with great attitude and character! ❤️🙏🏼
Jai Hind! Jai Bharat! All the love and respect! Salute! 🙏🏼⚔️❤️🇮🇳❤️⚔️🙏🏼
@Student of Klaus Schwab aby he ws parsi.. india have parsi community too
@Student of Klaus Schwab abbe chutiye , he was an indian , india mai parsi nhi ho sakte kya ? ratan tata bhi parsi hai , thats how india treats its minorities ..!
There are men. There are legends. Then there is marshal Sam Manakshaw
💥💥🤩
WELL SAID JONATHAN BROTHER.
Every Indian must know his name.His biography should be included in the school syllabus. Love you sir.
What a character. Sam manekshaw, naam hi kaafi hai. 🇮🇳🇮🇳
I tend to revisit this interview over and over again. The charisma of Gen Sam is just awesome, and this video is certainly a lesson in leadership.
Indeed he was as inspiration to young boys growing up in wellington in the 80s.Miss those days
Same here, I just listen and feel so inspired by him. My dad had the honor of serving under him during 1971.
Any Bangladeshi here
We should thank the legend who save us in 1971 war and give training our Bangladeshi soldier
Thank you for your great kindness the sham bahadur manikshaw 🙏❤️
Very heartfelt story. This is how you treat war prisoners.
Legend ho aap sir
What a great leader... The more I know about him I am in awe of his towering personality...
The officer who goes to field and interact with the riffleman are respected from the heart not because of their position/rank, officers who give orders only from table podium are given salute just because of their rank when he turn back the juniors spit
This legend of our motherland is beyond any praise of any word mentioned in any dictionary of the world . He will inspire not only generations of men in uniform in our country but beyond too , boundless of time . Love you sir . You are as always in our souls forever . JAI HIND 🥰😍♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Their country was carved out on the basis of communal hatred. Just reverse the role and imagine what would’ve happened. But still, their defeat was inevitable.
I want to listen more, give me the link of full video,please.
Me too.
This man has respected an enemy soldier and provided them with best facilities possible
This shows character
Which we commoners lack a lot
This man is love and courage.❤
Our Pride India 🇮🇳 and Indian Army
the man the myth the legend himself
Mein Sam Manekshaw sir ka print t shirt pe laga ke ab friends se cantonment areas me milne jaya karunga hahaha maza ayega unke fathers ke reactions dekh ke.
This man is the definition of badass.
India's evergreen Hero☺🙏🇮🇳
What a legend this man was. Salute. Jai Hind. 🙏
One of the bravest son of India 💜 love and respect sir
WHAT A CHARISMATIC PERSONALITY AND WHAT A MAN SALUTE TO YOU SIR..........HE IS A TRUE GENTLEMAN
Legendary person who taught us a good lesson and adequate culture of Indians..
Legend 🇮🇳
Thats my hero, right there ! ❤️
Such a great personality great human being.. bless his soul
This man had a good future for the nation, he understood the idea of the politicians and wanted to neutralize them but sadly it didn't go in his favor.... Hopefully there is a someone like him in the defence to bring the country to dignity
Sirji was something else.
Swag....grace...chivalry....Love.......Compassion...Valour....Major General SAM MANEKSHAW⚘⚘⚘⚘⚘⚘⚘⚘⚘
What a Beautiful Soul ..Salute to you Manekshaw Saab...
The real heroes of 🇮🇳 India.. Salute tu Field Marshal Manekshaw sir ❤.. JAI HIND 🇮🇳
_Much Love_ ❤️
Nothing but respect for the man
A class of a soul.
RIP honourable man🙏🏽👏🏾
Young generation should learn many things from this general..salute you sir
"THE MAN" this title is enough to describe him. 🙏
Greatest Warrior of all time.
Pure soul,i always wonder about the charisma of last generation.they were the best ,being kind is difficult in these days.
What a true gentleman n genius he is.. 👌🏻😊❤️✨
Respect you ! 🧡
The translation was delayed and was not full.
But still It's a Gold.
One needs to be strong but at the same time show humanity to your enemies. In this case, even your enemies will show respect to you. Then we truly know, *I have no enemies* quote.
No words for him. He was a legend that's all.
Legend!
This man is army legend , GOAT 🐐 .
Amazing Personality 🙏🙏 These types of personality are sent by the divine to help others 🙏🙏
See how well India treated Prisoners of War from Pakistan. We can never expect this from Pakistan.
Love from India to Pakistan peace offering
He will always have a special place in the hearts of India and its people . He was an officer and a gentleman. We proud of him and the Indian Army's Professionalism. The incident is just a fine example of how an Army and its leader should be . The tradition has been kept alive till date and will remain the same for years to come. Jai Hind
They don't make such men anymore..!
A true warrior and gem.
Sam Manekshaw - 'A Man of his words' 🇮🇳
Sam Manekshaw: how's the tea? Surrendered shamless Pakistani General: the tea was fantastic..
😆❤️
Legend 🙏
One of the real gems of our beloved country ❤❤ lots of respect sir!!
राष्ट्र आपका हमेशा ऋणी रहेगा मानेकशॉ साब। 🙏
We returned 90000 soldiers, they had our 1300 soldiers , which they never returned, they were tortured to death
Thanks to Indira Gandu... The gandu family has always been disastrous..
No doubt he was a great soldier and leader, but remember folks what happened to Prithvi Raj Chouhan, giving forgiveness to wicked enemy will give Indian army the treatment given to Raman Kalia, his mutilated body was delivered back to Indian army.
Sam Bahadur and his team never gave mercy in war. When enemy is captured and defeated its a gentle man army even in Pakistan our many pow they treated well and return. Our amry is great with values.
KARTIKEYA SIR,
THERE ARE MANY YOUNG INDIAN POW'S STILL IN PAKISTANI CUSTODY.
This is the leadership quality....For him (Maneksha) every one is equal...
From Grassroot to Heaven....
India is Proud to have you , sir🙏
Legend 🙏❤️🙏
मेरे जुड़वा भाई।
Lekin jihadiyon ko Allah ka hukum phle he mil chuka hai Quran se unko ye sab batein palle nhi padhegi.Mujhe yakeen hai .
Yes, keval hinduon ka rape or hatya karni h in rakshason ko
🤣🤣
Aur sangi atankwadi b nhi samjelge.. Unko gita ka gyan mila h
@@burhanibnbashir waah Europe main ghar rent pr nhi deta koi America airport pr nanga krta h Russia bomb marta h china masjid ko toilet bnata h fir bhi bhaunkna h tumhe 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@burhanibnbashir apni ghatiya jubaan se geeta ka name v mat le jihadi. Geeta tu padh lega to kya pta jihad chor de tu.
Inka bolne ka tareeka kitna pyara hai. Sach me Sam Sir aap kamal hai aur hamesha rahenge
SAM, WAS A OFFICER AND GENTLEMAN OF THE OLD WORLD.
CHARMING AND DASHING, IT WAS A GREAT HONOUR FOR INDIAN ARMY TO BE LED BY HIM.
Hero.
His biography has been aptly titled "Soldiering with Dignity". Please read, to know a lot more about him
Thanks for your comment. I'll definitely read this book. 😊
Ye superhero hain India k....love u sir great respect to you and our armed forces
That's what a real human being ❤
This is our Army 😎😎😎😎😮
I am Pakistani and I respect Marshall Sam maneshaw ji because he has humanity. And he was legend.
But I think that Indians you should also respect our Pak Army because when they captured your pilot #abhinandan so they also treated him like manekshaw ji treated with their enemies. Our army show their humanity Because we Pakistanis have humanity. If you don't believe me so you can ask your pilot abhinandan.
But yeah you should Don,t listen to your stupid and lier Indian media. You Indians also know that your Indian media is a biggest lier in this world.
@@Believer104 🖕🖕
@@Believer104 I am talking a bit late but it was your people who made fun of our pilot
Tea was fantastic
we have not made fun of your pilot qureshi in 1971 war who later became air chief of paf.
Dont just blame us you made fun and thats the reality.
😠😠😠😠😠
This is the reason why we love Indian Army!
Man of Great Calibre.🙌❣️
great man .
All we need is peace and harmony.