As a fan since 1983, I have to say this is one of the best bands in the world at the top of their game. h has a lot of class and regularly pays tribute to Fish, acknowledging his great lyrics and hard work that he did with the band in the early years. There has only been one Marillion, despite the personnel changes.
A really beautiful thing for him to do. My father got me into Marillion and Fish when I was a teenager. He still won't hear a word from me about how H is now the lead singer of Marillion, and how it's possible to like the two singers. But I do (sorry, Dad) 😁
Seen this band many times, and as a U.S. fan, that is no mean feat. I got on board when FISH was still at the helm, in 1984. Steve Hogarth is a fantastic Singer. Of course he is not FISH, who could be? Steve has been HIMSELF since day 1 in this band, and that alone is worth a round of applause. I love FISH also, and have also seen him any time he's come through these parts as well as buying all his Solo material.
Observad a Steve Hogarth justo al principio de la canción su gesto espectante a sabiendas de que será bien recibida por todo el público. Nunca se librará de ese complejo.
Fish in his prime (MC, CAS, Vigil) was a FEROCIOUS singer. Range, depth, emotion, bite, passion. But the reality is that with Internal Exile his voice began its descent. By the time he got to Suits and Sunsets he no longer possessed the same vocal range and prowess and marillion would have suffered for it. Having H in the band gave them the opportunity to continue to explore infinite musical avenues because H’s range was extraordinary. Another incredibly passionate singer who is second to none as a front man. It was a brilliant choice. So we got two great Marillions with two great singers and two great eras. I’ll take that!
Fish has given up smoking now and he actually surprised himself with how much better his voice sounded 😅 will never be what it used to be but it's nice he's trying his best for the farewell tour 🎉😍
yep. I mean, how could anyone dislike the new singer proposing a toast to the former guy! sportsmanship at it's best! a toast to Hogarth! :-) (okok, it's not the best version of this song)
The way I see it its M1 and M2 and both are icons in there own right and song writing skills. I listen to both on their own merits and stopped comparing years ago. Just enjoy!!!...
Love the song, Love the energy. Sorry to all of you who can't let go of what is now thirty years(!) in the past, but I really prefer the Fish material sung by H.
Balls mate ...he good he made marillion his own ..FISH EVEN SAYS THAT...BUT NEITHER HAS HAD THE SAME FAME .SINCE MISPLACED AN CLUTCHING AT...BOTH HAVE MADE OUTSTANDING ALBUMS SINCE THE SPLIT ...BUT IT WAS NOT THE BEST THING TO HAPPEN ... WAS A SAD TIME AN A LONG WAIT FOR THE TWO NEW ALBUMS AT THE TIME .... JUST MY OPINION MATE...
Fish and Hogarth played together back in 1999 - it's on YT - so there is no animosity whatsoever between the two of them. They both rule. And god knows I'm a die hard Fish-era fan. But fuck me senseless, Hogarth is amazing as well, in a different genre. That's what some people won't understand. Different singer, different music. I like both. Stone me.
Sorry , I like of Marillion only the Fish era . But this is a great performance of Steve . I think he's unique like Fish is . In the last Time I hear many Songs of the Hogarth era . It's really good. Marillion after 1989 has a new Fan !
I saw them at one of the weekends in Montreal where they did Jgsaw, but H didn't sing, it was audience sung and they ended it short, just after the guitar solo.
I certainly can't hear H slurring or disrespecting the song as some below are suggesting. - please point me to the timings of this or I'm calling it BS. This version fairly races along so there's a lot of words to get out - he manages it. The crowd involvement is perfectly standard for a fan-favourite like this. And his toast was a very classy and humble gesture.
Kinda sad to see this when it could have been Fish up there instead of slogging away in 300 capacity venues on his own. Kudos to H though for a nice tribute and for being part of the continuing Marillion story.
That's a belting version of a Classic Song.Mr Rotheray you did not drop even an 8th of a beat there.The only problem Marillion ever suffered from (and I hasten to add,through no fault of their own.)WAS LACK OF T.V. AND RADIO AIR TIME people were normally so vibed up they went to see them live and completely forgot to vote in the radio poles etc,leaving the flood gates open to far ...less talented performers .Aforementioned shysters often repleat with major label contracts ,better Kit than Small businesses (and thats what Marillion are ...dont let the Anglo Scots jocularity fool you they count every Pound Note even if they pretend not too)and dubious "Cultish" attitudes.Viva Vivare...Long Live Marillion.🕊🍓🎱
I can’t find this particular version ANYWHERE! not even on the Brave Live Deluxe. Can someone please help. I’m in the US where my ignorant fellow Americans never bothered to appreciate this band and I need this cut
9L1977 I’ve ripped it , I just really want to buy it if they put it out to support the band and have a hard copy if something ever happens but thank you
I just know that this version is taken from Friday night of the Marillion Weekend Recorded in March 2013 at in Centre Parcs, The Netherlands. I don't know any audio CD with these Friday night extras ( HOOKS IN YOU COVER MY EYES & SLAINTE MHATH ) As far as I know, they are available only on DVD and Blu-ray. There is a double CD version of this Weekend but without these three extras from Friday.
Nope. He turns a song about the anger, resentment and disillusionment of the working class into a ridiculous pantomime about being drunk. A horrible version.
it seems like the usual motives, but alas, the fedot is not the same, only with Fish this composition acquires those painfully native sounds for which you say this is the Marillion group
Тридцать лет ныть за Фишем - особый вид мазохизма его фанатов. Пора бы уже смириться, что это давно уже другая группа, с новым лучшим голосом, с новым звучанием. Хогарт идеально подходит группе, поэтому так долго работают вместе.
Pure genius...falling about the stage, slurring his words, getting the audience to sing half the song and proposing a toast...walks a fine line between affectionate tribute and taking the piss. Was Rothery shaking his head a few times?
I guess you haven't been to the weekends, because if you had you'd know it was an affectionate tribute and no-one is taking the piss. They are celebrating ALL of Marillion's music here.
@@GeeVanderplas You're right, I was one of the many who gave up on Marillion after Fish left. Let's face it, Season's End is not a terrible album but it was a huge disappointment after the masterpiece that is Clutching at Straws. Then someone tied me to a chair and made me listen to Brave - I now have a growing appreciation for Hogarth and his work with the band. Now gigs are happening again, I might make the effort.
Having seen the great man perform this live in Haddington a couple of weeks ago, when it grew wings and became an anthem for Scottish Independence, this version just doesn't cut the mustard.
its great to see that the Band is still on (good for them), but for me the thing died when Fish leaves. Over the years I tryed sometimes to find my way back - but I cannot watch and listen to this guy.....sorry. For shure- Fish couldn´t be in Marillion nowerdays, because of loosing his Voice. so sadly!!! Today I found my cure in Steven Wilson, Blackfield and Porcupine tree. When Steve Hogarth came into Marillion- it was a shock for me, because for me he seems to be a Bank-Manager and not somebodey who should stand on a stage. And his Voice don´t catch or touch.......
I feel bad for you Mike. That was exactly what I felt when Fish left back in 88. However, I did hang in there and Hogarth, despite all the criticism, got the band going. I have to admit I was not very impressed with the first couple of albums with Hogarth but these guys evolved really well over time.There are incredible albums you should at least give them a shot, try Marbles, Brave, This Strange Engine and F.E.A.R. You will not regret.
As a fan since 1983, I have to say this is one of the best bands in the world at the top of their game. h has a lot of class and regularly pays tribute to Fish, acknowledging his great lyrics and hard work that he did with the band in the early years. There has only been one Marillion, despite the personnel changes.
A really beautiful thing for him to do. My father got me into Marillion and Fish when I was a teenager. He still won't hear a word from me about how H is now the lead singer of Marillion, and how it's possible to like the two singers.
But I do (sorry, Dad) 😁
It's his loss, he's missing great music.
@@porkulator Agree
Love this live performance Steve Hogarth did a great job!
I absolutely and totally agree !!! mm
A toast to Fish, a wonderful gesture!
He's a really great performer and after Fish we are lucky to have him
It's called class, a trait that's sadly rapidly vanishing from our societies. Marillion still has it, thank heavens.
Seen this band many times, and as a U.S. fan, that is no mean feat. I got on board when FISH was still at the helm, in 1984. Steve Hogarth is a fantastic Singer. Of course he is not FISH, who could be? Steve has been HIMSELF since day 1 in this band, and that alone is worth a round of applause.
I love FISH also, and have also seen him any time he's come through these parts as well as buying all his Solo material.
Long live fish and marillion
I think the Fish and H differences are behind them and they have a lot of respect for each other as fellow professionals
Observad a Steve Hogarth justo al principio de la canción su gesto espectante a sabiendas de que será bien recibida por todo el público. Nunca se librará de ese complejo.
Thank you Steve, for remembering Fish... our great poet en performer...
Fish in his prime (MC, CAS, Vigil) was a FEROCIOUS singer. Range, depth, emotion, bite, passion. But the reality is that with Internal Exile his voice began its descent. By the time he got to Suits and Sunsets he no longer possessed the same vocal range and prowess and marillion would have suffered for it.
Having H in the band gave them the opportunity to continue to explore infinite musical avenues because H’s range was extraordinary. Another incredibly passionate singer who is second to none as a front man. It was a brilliant choice.
So we got two great Marillions with two great singers and two great eras. I’ll take that!
So, so true.
Fish has given up smoking now and he actually surprised himself with how much better his voice sounded 😅 will never be what it used to be but it's nice he's trying his best for the farewell tour 🎉😍
H class act!...doing the toat for the big guy was grand!,I love H even more!
yep. I mean, how could anyone dislike the new singer proposing a toast to the former guy! sportsmanship at it's best! a toast to Hogarth! :-)
(okok, it's not the best version of this song)
I'm totally and absolutely agree !!! mm
H makes these Fish era songs absolutely fly. Love it :)
Wonderful
I love you Marillion 🔥❤️
I really like that version- Steve does a much better job with it than i would have imagined, Top performance
I saw them live exactly one year ago,Marillion weekend,what amazing 3 day concert.Fantastic,Superb quality, and interaction with the public.
I've been a fan all my life and they are both great frontmen, slainte mhath to Fish and Steve in equal measure
This is Progressive Live, not only Progressive Rock! 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Good Job, Mr. H.!
The way I see it its M1 and M2 and both are icons in there own right and song writing skills. I listen to both on their own merits and stopped comparing years ago. Just enjoy!!!...
The first album only featured Steve R, Pete and Mark
All of us miss Fish,but never forget how lucky we are to have Steve,great performer
A Toast to Fish ..... Great
Humildade e respeito!
Parabéns h
Oh! Marillion Fantastics... God Bless Them
Fucking BRILLIANT!
Class move for "h' toasting Fish...
Ciągle pod nieustannym wrażeniem :) dzięki .........
I saw this Band on December 2018, is was fantastic
Love the song, Love the energy. Sorry to all of you who can't let go of what is now thirty years(!) in the past, but I really prefer the Fish material sung by H.
I’ll never understand it! Why the f*ck do people need to hold such a grudge over something 30 years ago? Children in old men bodies.
Fish in his prime with Marillion was simply Genius.
great job !!
you got me crying H, happy now? darn it....
Two different eras 2 totally different singers. Both are simply the best
H .... The BEST thing to happen to Marillion !!
Along with Steve R, Mark, Pete and Ian, I agree :)
Sorry can't agree, just does'nt have the same presence of lyrical skill
Balls mate ...he good he made marillion his own ..FISH EVEN SAYS THAT...BUT NEITHER HAS HAD THE SAME FAME .SINCE MISPLACED AN CLUTCHING AT...BOTH HAVE MADE OUTSTANDING ALBUMS SINCE THE SPLIT ...BUT IT WAS NOT THE BEST THING TO HAPPEN ... WAS A SAD TIME AN A LONG WAIT FOR THE TWO NEW ALBUMS AT THE TIME .... JUST MY OPINION MATE...
I absolutely and totally agree !!! mm
Haha you are joking of course ... It's like a water without fish...or is it a Fish....
Fish and Hogarth played together back in 1999 - it's on YT - so there is no animosity whatsoever between the two of them.
They both rule. And god knows I'm a die hard Fish-era fan. But fuck me senseless, Hogarth is amazing as well, in a different genre.
That's what some people won't understand. Different singer, different music.
I like both. Stone me.
Beautiful. I've seen Fish in CA and he was drinking and drinking on the stage :)
Sorry , I like of Marillion only the Fish era .
But this is a great performance of Steve . I think he's unique like Fish is .
In the last Time I hear many Songs of the Hogarth era . It's really good.
Marillion after 1989 has a new Fan !
I freaking LOVE the bass-forward mix on this show. I'm watching the while damn thing next.
Share a link please.
Great powerful voice here
Respect
Class
Steve Hogarth is a legend
I absolutely and totally agree !!! mm
Apparently he won't sing any material from Figazi, so I heard. Something about not feeling a connection with the songs.
@richard cooper apparently he won't do any songs from Fugazi
I saw them at one of the weekends in Montreal where they did Jgsaw, but H didn't sing, it was audience sung and they ended it short, just after the guitar solo.
Both H and Fish are legend-(wait for it)-ary
Super cool of H to toast Fish
H, you did this song well
Epic
I certainly can't hear H slurring or disrespecting the song as some below are suggesting. - please point me to the timings of this or I'm calling it BS. This version fairly races along so there's a lot of words to get out - he manages it. The crowd involvement is perfectly standard for a fan-favourite like this. And his toast was a very classy and humble gesture.
un grand groupe de rock
❤
Nice touch by S.H
Awesome track, good job Steve H👍. Fish is obviously the original & the best, really liked the toast, gr8 tribute!!!
Marillion - Slainte Mhath - Lyric
A hand held over a candle in angst-fuelled bravado
A carbon trail scores a moist stretched palm
Trapped in the indecision of another fine menu
And you sit there and ask me to tell you the story so far
This is the story so far
Shuffling your memories dealing your doodles in margins
You scrawl out your poems across a beermat or two
And when you declare the point of grave creation
They turn round and ask you to tell them the story so far
This is the story so far
And you listen with a tear in your eye
To their hopes and betrayals and your only reply
Is slàinte mhath
Princes in exile raising the standard Drambuie
Parading their anecdotes tired from old campaigns
Holding their own last orders commanding attention
We sit here and listen to all of the story so far
This is the story so far
Take it away
Take it away
Take it away
Take me away
Take me away
Take me away
Take me away
Take me away
From the dream on the barbed wire at Flanders and Bilston Glen
From a Clydeside that rusts from the tears of its broken men
From the realisation that all we've been left behind
Is to stand like our fathers before us in the firing line
Waiting on the whistle to blow
We stand here waiting on the whistle to blow
They promised us miracles, and the whistle still blows
Broken promises but the whistle still blows
Waiting on the whistle to blow
We stand here waiting on the whistle to blow.
Written By: Derek William Dick / Ian Mosley / Mark Kelly / Pete Trewavas / Steve Rothery (1987)
"Slàinte Mhath" in: Clutching at Straws [CD]. London: © EMI.
Sin fish no es igual!!!
4:01 Drummer...Amazing! Iam Mosley
Absolutely and totally agree !!! mm
V good
Kinda sad to see this when it could have been Fish up there instead of slogging away in 300 capacity venues on his own. Kudos to H though for a nice tribute and for being part of the continuing Marillion story.
Graham Key except it’s couldn’t be fish anymore vocally. Voice is shot. He can’t sing anything anymore :(
I love Steve Hogarth... but it takes a big man to pay a tribute to the guy who went before him.
Pete Trewavas
Pete is in flames
Thinking that too !
Dude wtf!! I just checked it’s not ok the Brave Live track list!!
That's a belting version of a Classic Song.Mr Rotheray you did not drop even an 8th of a beat there.The only problem Marillion ever suffered from (and I hasten to add,through no fault of their own.)WAS LACK OF T.V. AND RADIO AIR TIME people were normally so vibed up they went to see them live and completely forgot to vote in the radio poles etc,leaving the flood gates open to far ...less talented performers .Aforementioned shysters often repleat with major label contracts ,better Kit than Small businesses (and thats what Marillion are ...dont let the Anglo Scots jocularity fool you they count every Pound Note even if they pretend not too)and dubious "Cultish" attitudes.Viva Vivare...Long Live Marillion.🕊🍓🎱
I can’t find this particular version ANYWHERE! not even on the Brave Live Deluxe. Can someone please help. I’m in the US where my ignorant fellow Americans never bothered to appreciate this band and I need this cut
I can send it to you. Just give me your e-mail, please.
9L1977 I’ve ripped it , I just really want to buy it if they put it out to support the band and have a hard copy if something ever happens but thank you
@@geneawisea2708 This version is from BRAVE LIVE 2013 www.marillion.com/shop/dvd/racket108N.htm
9L1977 thanks I’ll buy the video but I’m looking for the audio specifically. Do you know if that’s on a cd as well?
I just know that this version is taken from Friday night of the Marillion Weekend Recorded in March 2013 at in Centre Parcs, The Netherlands.
I don't know any audio CD with these Friday night extras ( HOOKS IN YOU
COVER MY EYES & SLAINTE MHATH ) As far as I know, they are available only on DVD and Blu-ray. There is a double CD version of this Weekend but without these three extras from Friday.
I'll drink to that
Oui steeve est une légende..... mais n’oubliez pas Fish.... sur cette chanson il envoi du lourd, c’est son registre. Steeve reste avec le tien stp.
quand Hogarth chante c'est quand même autre chose que Fish...
Steve Rothery eso es marillion ,
He sings this better than fish in my opinion
Completely agree
+1!
I'm absolutely and totally agree !!! mm
It's good but the big man is best, sorry
Nope. He turns a song about the anger, resentment and disillusionment of the working class into a ridiculous pantomime about being drunk. A horrible version.
Apologies it’s on the Deluxe
A que se debe el brindis por fish?
Marillion tylko z Fishem !
Is he pissed ??
it seems like the usual motives, but alas, the fedot is not the same, only with Fish this composition acquires those painfully native sounds for which you say this is the Marillion group
Тридцать лет ныть за Фишем - особый вид мазохизма его фанатов. Пора бы уже смириться, что это давно уже другая группа, с новым лучшим голосом, с новым звучанием. Хогарт идеально подходит группе, поэтому так долго работают вместе.
with -üfföh- väv you could have yör öwn -nö- Disscö ^ ^
Fish smokes this dude. Period.
Fish can’t even sing anymore?
@@aj.2004 is that a question?
Great man, great singer. But sadly... he isn't Fish
H could have painted his face up .... ..
Steves voice is a zero hot pate-too.
Pure genius...falling about the stage, slurring his words, getting the audience to sing half the song and proposing a toast...walks a fine line between affectionate tribute and taking the piss. Was Rothery shaking his head a few times?
I guess you haven't been to the weekends, because if you had you'd know it was an affectionate tribute and no-one is taking the piss. They are celebrating ALL of Marillion's music here.
I'll go ahead and say it. That was fucking embarrassing.
Martin Haigh It’s all in the eye of the beholder obviously
Martin Haigh Yawn yawn
@@GeeVanderplas You're right, I was one of the many who gave up on Marillion after Fish left. Let's face it, Season's End is not a terrible album but it was a huge disappointment after the masterpiece that is Clutching at Straws. Then someone tied me to a chair and made me listen to Brave - I now have a growing appreciation for Hogarth and his work with the band. Now gigs are happening again, I might make the effort.
f i s h*
would Rather have Martin jakubski sing this over fish and steve H !!!!
love Hogarth with marillion but he just cant do fish songs.
I'm glad he can't do fish songs because Marillion songs better
paul evans Yes he can here is the proof!
Still not
No I think both do their owns songs better than anyone else could.
Neither can Fish any more sadly. Was a load of fun while it lasted though.
Having seen the great man perform this live in Haddington a couple of weeks ago, when it grew wings and became an anthem for Scottish Independence, this version just doesn't cut the mustard.
And your knowledge is poor
+Billy Pickett lol fish lost his voice a couple of tours ago bro
Billy Pickett omg
its great to see that the Band is still on (good for them), but for me the thing died when Fish leaves. Over the years I tryed sometimes to find my way back - but I cannot watch and listen to this guy.....sorry. For shure- Fish couldn´t be in Marillion nowerdays, because of loosing his Voice. so sadly!!!
Today I found my cure in Steven Wilson, Blackfield and Porcupine tree.
When Steve Hogarth came into Marillion- it was a shock for me, because for me he seems to be a Bank-Manager and not somebodey who should stand on a stage. And his Voice don´t catch or touch.......
your loss Mike !!
I feel bad for you Mike. That was exactly what I felt when Fish left back in 88. However, I did hang in there and Hogarth, despite all the criticism, got the band going. I have to admit I was not very impressed with the first couple of albums with Hogarth but these guys evolved really well over time.There are incredible albums you should at least give them a shot, try Marbles, Brave, This Strange Engine and F.E.A.R. You will not regret.
Mike Kramer he left
Mike Kramer Sorry for what... obviously you’re here writing and listening
No Fish,No Marillion.
I cannot listen to this., The new vocalist has NO clue what this song is all about
Ha, ha, but he sings It better, than Fish.
hogart is no fish fish is awsome
Dennis Dawley Steve Hogarth paid respect to Fish in a fucking cool manner!
And vice versa.
He killed that stone dead,lost a lot without a Scottish accent
Singing this w/o Scottish accent is an insult at best.
Wonderful