Watch again: Rishi Sunak faces Keir Starmer at PMQs as Israel-Hamas conflict continues
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 10. 2023
- Watch again as Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer face off in Prime Minister's Questions in the House of Commons.
The prime minister is expected to answer questions around the UK's role in the Israel-Hamas conflict following Mr Sunak's visit to Israel last week.
Watch more from Independent TV at: www.independent.co.uk/tv/edit...
Click here to subscribe to The Independent: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-Independent
About The Independent:
Making Change Happen. The Independent is the world’s most free-thinking newsbrand, providing global news, commentary and analysis for the independently-minded.
Connect with The Independent:
Check out our full video catalog: / theindependent
Videos, daily editorial and more: www.theindy.com
Click here to get the best of The Independent daily: www.independent.co.uk/newslet...
Like The Independent on Facebook: www. TheIndependentOnline
Follow The Independent on Twitter: / independent
Follow The Independent on Instagram: / the.independent
Download the iOS & Android app: www.independent.co.uk/subscri...
Help to support truly independent journalism. Every dollar you contribute will directly fund additional special reports and investigations from a free-thinking, award-winning newsroom you can trust - www.independent.co.uk/donations
Subscribe to Independent Premium for exclusive content & live events: bit.ly/2MiOONB
Palestine has the right to defend itself.
The Palestine people have right to defend themselves
I dont believe that the PM a person of Asian origin has such a low feeling for fellow humans. He should return back to India to learn Asian value.
Wonder if he has more feeling towards cows?
India is a close ally of Zionist Israel, what do you expect?
You afghanistani turkey Arabic people should learn humbleness and good manner from Indian and British people.
cow> Palestinians@@ardahankonk5275
Not even the Jewish people want this violence and they cannot stand Netanyahu as he is nothing more than a power hungry despot. Power and big love to the Palestinian people to stay strong and don't give up
True fact blood hangry
But he listens his zionist minsters!
People? people don't behead babies etc nor vote fo nor root for beheaders and those who chant from the river to the sea.. meaning forcibly replacing State of Israel with divided Arab groups vying violently for Palestine
NETANYAHU SERVE HIS OWN INTEREST SINCE 1995
IN 1995 HE PUSHED HATES AGAINST YITZHAK RABBIN
Because lovely jewish people are not the zionist terrorists.
But Israel is not defending itself WITHIN INTERNATIONAL LAW...so for goodness sake STOP SAYING IT!!!
Got new argument huh
I think the majority of the country can see what is going on and we are yet again getting involved in War Crimes by siding with Israel
@@thesarasohrabi I don't understand what you mean...
Rishi is curry, what do you expect from him
How do you expect any nation to fight against a terrorist state who don't recognize international law or any other laws and stick by international laws, it's extremely difficult for any country to fight a war without breaking any rules and yes Israel is defending itself but not against another country that also has to stick with international law, it's fighting a terrorist state who is fully supported by palastinians who send their sons to terrorist training camps every year, did you not see how they danced and praised Allah and beat the innocent kids that Hamas kidnapped and drove them through the streets of gaza, I don't feel sorry for terrorist's and terrorist supporters, palastinians are still chanting about the full destruction of isreal and all Jews
MY HEART IS WITH PALESTINE....FREE PALESTINE...🇪🇭❤️🇪🇭
❤🇵🇸❤🇵🇸❤🇵🇸❤🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
''For anybody who changes their principles depending on whom he is dealing, that is not a man who can lead a nation''
Nelson Mandela
@@AA-ls8ww все они моделлы
Perhaps Osama Bin Laden or Sadam Hussain.....lol
It seems UK ran out of intelligent PMs who want to lead its people
But, but… the children, and the environment, and Ukraine, and now Gaza… The people, the economy and the country are not important. Is not like that’s their job, you know?
Mithter Thpeaker! Mithter Thpeakerrrr!
Most of them are USELESS..A waste of tax payers money thats being polite.
They did that many many many moons ago.
Gvery true ,UKhas ran out of pm with integrity and charisma
This sunak is the worst leader he has nothing appealing in him
Arab Peace Initiative (22 % for Palestinians - 78% for Israelis)
Before Hamas came to Gaza, in 2002 the Arab Peace Initiative, was introduced by Saudi Arabia and endorsed by all the Arab countries. It offers Israel full recognition by the 22 members of the Arab League in exchange for an Israeli withdrawal to its pre-1967 borders, thus allowing the Palestinians to create a viable independent state on what is only 22 percent of historic Palestine land.
The Arab Peace Initiative was supported by large numbers of policy makers throughout the world, with favourable comments made by the leaders of over sixty countries including the American President himself.
Israel Ignored it and carried on building more new settlements in the West Bank.
If Israel accepted the peace initiative, then today wouldn’t be Hamas in GAZA and everyone knows this.
✊🏻👏👏👏🦁
Exactly Hamas is composed of the young men that cannot sit still while being oppressed by israel which is cheered by the world.
They will be no peace aslong as zionism exists.. FREE PALASETINE 🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴❤
And wouldn't be Hizbulah too.
I don't think israel wants peace. It wants all that piece of land for itself. Since the dawn of its making it persecuted the PALESTINIANS. bibi netanyahu want them all out. cause he thinks he and his people are of superior race.
Israel has challenged the world asking UN secretary asked to resigned for his opinion.
The most bold and unbelievably threatening statement EVER!
Know Israelis believes international laws are applicable to other nations,
Except their own!
That shocked me more. What the world we live in?!
@1:04 "Israel has the right to defend itself" this statement is just as dumb as saying "Russia has the right to defend itself in Ukraine"
You can't claim "defence" when you're the one invading and occupying the land and have been doing so for 75 years in addition to placing 2.2 million Gazans in an open air prison for 17 years where you control everything that goes in and out including water and electricity. Israel is an expansive state it's been growing on Palestinian lands since 1947, look at the maps from 1947 to 1967 to 1973 to 2000 and 2023. That's not defending yourself, you can't defend yourself by expanding your territory.
That's you saying "of course Israel has the right to continue occupying and terrorising and imprisoning the indigenous people (Palestinians) of the land and expanding it's territory".
Stop using the word "defend" unless you'd use the same for Russian troops in Ukraine.
If you are a Muslim country, you have no right to Defense- according to the Muslim world
According to the Western World***
@mustafa
Israel is a great country that promotes inventions and many greater invetions and facility to world. Palastine supports and promote irans hamas, A terrorist group. Its not good.
The thing is both Israel and Ukraine are under Western protection, it doesnt matter if theyre defending or not they were able to twist the words around if something goes wrong and blame the nearest enemy. Just cut US aid and all of them would go into the black market, Ukraine slowly noticing that those weapons would possibly go elsewhere with these considered biggest protection money and Ukranian economy would collapse even more while Russia is literally still having positive benefits from the sanctions. Israeli government can't DEFEND themselves and knows they were doomed with these new alliance formed against them, offensive forces isnt the same ones sitting around Russo-Ukranian war they can stretch themselves yet Israel already wandering about Iran support as they immediately strike Syria.
👏👏👏✊🏻
İ can only conclude that the pm is clearly executing orders to the letter. He's just repeating the same two sentences exactly like other supporters of massmurder. Shamefull.
They need to. Change prime minister question time to. The Rishi sunak comedy hour …🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭
😂😂😂
Can't stand sunak
A shocking PM
Be gone soon
Worst pm we have ever had
Yes, a total A HOLE
I miss the Liz Truss days thanks to him
Sunak should be Kicked out 😂
Yes...he isnt elected!!!
Seems like these politicians just meet up to share jokes to one another. This government ain’t serious at all
It is like something from a comedy sketch but real people are suffering.. Yes the economy is only working for a selected few and here is where they gather to cover their own backs
They are not setious for real
After work on the weekend they're at the pub having pints of largers together talking BS 9ver this BS in parliament
I thought It was skit sketch shows, it's lively tho, more democratic countries should do this healthy banters on monthly basis
They have no shame
The UK is now a country with poorer people with some rich people running it! So what do you expect from this lot?
They “imported” most of that poor people so they could remain the rich, the powerful and of course, the “savior”.
@tracy1105 The UK has always been that. Every now and again they lull people into believing it's better than that (e.g when the first labour government was elected) but the UK has always been run by rich people for the benefit of rich people.
The parliament room full of India not British, is this England of India state
😂😂😂
@@rahilyas254 For sure, Bradford, Luton, Birmingham, is being re named to Calcutta, and Elephants are going on sale.
Seriously though its interesting im watching these videos most of them are indianamd scottish ..scottish are well represented but i dont see english people
I think Rishi is fooling the world like UN UNICEF does
At what point are political parties going to be honest about the way israel is behaving?
There is a very clear line in law and israel is blurring this line as they did in 2003 when the Int'l Court of Justice (ICJ) rulled against israels claim of "self-defence" for building a wall in Occupied Palestinian Territory (OPT). There are many law principles in Int'l Humanitarian Law (IHL) and in Int'l Human Rights Law (IHRL), the UN Charter also denotes what "self-defence" is in Article 51 of the UN Charter.
I suppose Politicians and public dont read too deeply into these things to understand that israels current behaviour is UNLAWFUL.
The applicable legal regimes before and during armed conflicts are different. Jus ad bellum consists of principles applicable when states “may engage” in an armed conflict or resort to the use of armed force. On the other hand, jus in bello refers to the situation where the applicable law "regulates the conduct" of parties ‘engaging’ in an armed conflict (also known as IHL). Self-defence falls under the jus ad bellum regime. IHL governs rules pertaining to jus in bello. The two regimes should not be merged and israel merges these two principles.
This means that the Geneva Conventions of 1949 and customary international humanitarian law still hold their value when a state acts in self-defense in an armed conflict. In conclusion, an act of self-defence (jus ad bellum) must be consistent with applicable legal instruments. It must not be used to justify IHL violations (jus in bello) owing to the divide between the two regimes.
It is undisputed that self-defence is an exception to the prohibition of the use of force in jus ad bellum. However, when exercising this inherent right, states must pass the 'Caroline test', a customary law principle that lays conditions of _'necessity of self-defence, instant, overwhelming, leaving no choice of means and no movement for deliberation '_ Self-defence must be _'that military action necessary and appropriate to REPEL an attack'_ a state exercising this right must comply with the principles of necessity and proportionality. This requirement is also held by the ICJ in Nicaragua and Nuclear Weapons and it has now been accepted as customary law. Additionally, states exercising the right of self-defense must consider the derogation measures and non-derogable rights mentioned in the applicable human rights treaties. They must ensure that actions taken in self-defense _“must be the least intrusive instrument amongst those which might achieve the desired result.”_ Thus, self-defense cannot justify IHRL violations since it cannot preclude the wrongfulness of conduct.
Like i said Israel blurrs the lines which is not permissible and political parties should know this, the UN knows this and recently called Israel out yet again as they have for decades, but Israel remains protected by vetos held by the UK & USA.
So when Sunak and others say they stand by Israels right to self-defence, what they truely mean is that they are turning a blind eye to IHL, IHRL, UN Charter A51, The ICJ, and the 4th Geneva Convention 1949 on 'the protection of civillians'.
These are well known principles of modern international law and rules of conflict.
There are five _ad bellum_ criteria for a war to be considered just:
▪︎ having just cause,
▪︎ being the only means of last resort,
▪︎ right authority (international law supports the action),
▪︎ having proportionality _( _*_that the war/action does not cause more harm or suffering than the good achieved by a victory_*_ )_
▪︎ reasonable prospect of success.
The UK Government is deliberately being ignorant of these laws, and rules, by sompky repeating the _"right to self-defence"_ because nobody in their right mind would deny that right, however it comes with special rules and those rules are not being observed.
In short, the self-defence line taken by isrsel and parroted by the eestern leaders is a rouse.
No less, it's a lie!
Very true, indeed. The Zionist Israel is the true terrorist, Hamas retaliates..
I didn’t vote Rishi or Liz as my prime minister I voted for Boris! Isn’t democracy such a pantomime 😢
You don’t vote for a person in the UK. You need to go back to where you came from. Which is Africa. Where humanity was born.
Boris is no better, his Brains also gets clouded when he has to deal with Zionists Apartheid Jewish State. They are all Puppet of the American so they take instruction from the Head Quarters in Washington. If you don't comply you will be sidelined. UK is not independent in anyway as it does not represent the people of UK but Washington.
I am so distressed about the children 🧒🏽
A cold house keeps the elderly peoples mind clear, and sit there knitting more wool socks, dear prime minister.
These two parties only bicker with each other about how good they are about making the country better . Why don't both parties just get together and work together and make the country better for the people.
Since borris the bullet dodger ran the circus , it’s got worse . There should be life for failing the country .
he didnt press , infact he veto to the humantarin aid to gaza. Uk is is also accomplish to the Gaza genocide
This is better than Rap Battle 😂😂😂
They’re glad you enjoyed their show. Good you were entertained.
He is an Indian, ofc he will support israel
I do hope the victims bill will be accepted
We should not have dangerous people on the streets, our children must be safe
The Palestinian People are just a mere minutes thought in Britain.
Shameful Parliament.
How could the British vote a pariah as PM???
He isnt elected
True....hindu pariah.....👎👎👎
But 2.5 thousand children have died already. They had nothing to do with Hamas.
This PM is worst
Rishi Sunak doesnt know a thing about humanity.
Rishi Sunak🧒🧒: " I refuse to call on Israel for a 'ceasrfire', i am not a Hamas representative nor a Palestinian PM in British Parliament, I am a PM of UK."
He is taking the revenge of Afghan and Mugul kings who conquered india from Palestine. 😂😂😂
Stop the war if any one does car about people’s life .
No doubt Hamas committed a crime against innocent people but at the same time what IDF is doing in Gaza????
Not true go to Gaza and see Hamas is controlling them stop making things up !
🐯 it's more easy to fool some people but nearly impossible to convince them they’ve been fooled It’s an interesting dynamic but makes a lot of sense if you think about it Not only is the one fooled misguided but willfully so After all the process of being fooled is to convince one’s self to adopt a false narrative A person who is fooled is a willing participant He has jumped on a belief without the proper vetting and so was fooled always look at the bigger picture now that's what I'm talking about we're from the beautiful jungle.🌴😎🍊🐯🎨🎻🧡💚🌳
So true.
Even when you convince them, they bury their head in denial, it doesn't matter how big a fool they are being made, admitting they were fooled isn't on the radar. In 30 years time, you won't find anyone that voted for this crap!
Punctuation would have made all that, sound better. 😉
I must have been fooled 🥴
All I hear Yeeeeaaaah & hahaha!!
While so many people in Gaza are facing starvation and suffering from booming their homes!
What a joke!
Every time I watch this as a comedy yeeeeeeh 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
the more he lie the more his nose getting longer and darker
😂😂😂
And the comedy continues
Yousef's little prime minister is still in charge lol
🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸
Rishi Comes From Money Does Not Have A Clue About The Real World 😅
Free Palestine, Free Syria, Free Iraq, Free Libya
Free your mind ,and the rest will follow.
Would you go there if they’re set free?
@@GnarledSage would you?
No one would. That’s the point
So you made your point.@@GnarledSage
ARE THEY FIGHTING OR WHAT ? AUDIENCE : AEYYYEE
Shame on you Sunak! Shame on you for supporting the genocide.
😂😂😂I can't believe this country ruled a quarter of the world, free Palestine
It did when it was a country of British people
@@GnarledSage thanks for the xenophobic response, I needed that to go with my coffee...for next time though no response from you might be better
Why? Is truth and reality now racists?
@@GnarledSage xenophobic not racist... don't be that person. 🏳🏳🏳 you win
Sunak bow downs to his real master zionist
❤️🇵🇸
why they're making fun of each other rather than discussing solution together...
The British Govt. was responsible for the creation of Israel after the W. W. ll . Therefore the responsibility for the security of Israel to some extent ( very little ) lie with the British people . They should not avoid this and cry for the Hammas to which the Palestinians gave their supports.
Need a ceasefire NOW!!!
Dear UK
You all have to be tough on your foreign policies especially regarding this issues.if you really wanted your street to be safe, keep your eyes & ears open.
Oh my gosh is this the choice available between crooked leaders.
You can tell by the faces next to the leaders they want to be next as they don't seem to be on their side
Need to vote soon
British Councils remind me of the night watch from game of thrones
The leader of Indian 😂, what a disgrace!
Prime minister stop saying Israel has right to defend its self, Israel has no right to kill innocent people these words that you saying is hurting us as human beings
That parliament is true comedy.
Not really, they’re not funny at all.
Add a laugh track - cos some of them are clowns
What a circus with all that shouting. Takes away all seriousness from everything said.
Most there are clowns, so, I guess it’s fitting.
Name things correctly, if Israel had the right , Arabs had the right over the land too, stand up before ending up in a dark corner alone .
Good 👍🙏
#FREEPALESTINE🇵🇸🙏✊
what a rap roast, quite a show.
You guys can say what ever you want to say.but you guys .. need the Muslim Ummah more than anyone in this world....
I wish Nigeria's democracy was like this British democracy.
Excellent 👍 debate.
that ff tall guy with stripe tie in the pms line gets up all the time who d f is he. Is that his job to just raise all the time, he is too tall to keep doing this. Hin knees going to go crazy by the end of his term
🤣
this has a more "comedy show" vibe than anything else. only thing worse is the corrupt/incompetent government across the pond.
Choose wisely and diligently next poll UK.
Malaysia can give Singaporeans a state, Bruneian a state, then why don't Palestinian got thier own state. Free Palestine.
when did malyesia give Singaporeans a state? The malyesians persecuted Singaporeans on the belief that malyesia is for malays while Singaporeans demanded malyesia for all races.
End of that
The anonim of The King is "Crown Flower"
A man goin to hospital to change his barin, when he reach the hospital the Dr ask him there 3 option of brain which one do you want ?
1. Dr Brain $30k
2. Professor Brain $50k
3. Minster/PM Brain $100k
The man so curious n ask the Dr why Minster brain so expensive.
Dr said Minister/PM brain is so rare because not all Minister/PM have brain.......
As far as Both party have to ceasefire , And surrender the hostages.
Do some work for the people of this country, not just making money for themselves and there friends. They care nothing for people.
Children Are Starving
But time will let you know that... and by that time is not possible to the Muslim Ummah to listen to you guys
Making me sick
RS is a weasel ..a snake
The british government should make a constituent assembly under three lagisletive assemblies which are: political, economic and social. Political lagisletive assembly should make political laws which will conduct the constituent assembly. Thus economic and social. It must be noteable that in parliamentary democracy the bill should pass according to the constitution. In republican system there is no power of constitution against the majority vote of parliament.
What a bunch of nonsense
sunak is clown
21:58 dat ed sheeran?
31:27 who this lady?
आसा की किरनो से जो कायदा रहा तो बहारो के लिये खुशी है जानने
तमंना की तरह जो छय्स कलियों का आकार तो आसा की किरनो से बहारो को है पहचानने
समा ने किये सादगी का आकार तो खिलकर आये खुशी के आईने
Your security is ridiculous
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Ang sutsut na iyon hangin ay ingatan nyo.
✨️✨️
O people his say I help the people to put the hand in pocket people is helping them I can be Prime Minister to charge 80% more and I can say is progress wow that is a very good idea
People die and they play their theater, their Affentheater!
Doubling our international aid to people who wish us harm. Unbelievable 😮
Man wearing Ukraine tie critiques others for electoral advantages.
A lot of hit talk by pm
Sunak is a cowered!
Rishi sunak (double standard man) couple of weeks ago you went to Israel and you said there we are always with Israel.
If do u have a guts could you please go there and tell the same or else say the same thing in London itself even.