Bill Gates: Teachers need real feedback
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 05. 2013
- Until recently, many teachers only got one word of feedback a year: "satisfactory." And with no feedback, no coaching, there's just no way to improve. Bill Gates suggests that even great teachers can get better with smart feedback -- and lays out a program from his foundation to bring it to every classroom.
TEDTalks is a daily video podcast of the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes (or less). Look for talks on Technology, Entertainment and Design -- plus science, business, global issues, the arts and much more.
Find closed captions and translated subtitles in many languages at www.ted.com/translate
Follow TED news on Twitter: / tednews
Like TED on Facebook: / ted
Subscribe to our channel: / tedtalksdirector
As a teacher’s kid, I’ve seen how underappreciated, underpaid, disrespected yet overworked teachers have been. The amount of paperwork they get is ridiculous, the school secretaries could do them and leave more time for teachers to really think through and plan their lessons (super important for new teachers).
Personally, I know I could make a damn fine teacher, but having seen how it was like for my mom - no. Unless I’ve got nothing better to do.
We get what we pay for - no wonder education systems in most countries are in shambles.
hi
Which country u from?
Man that's so true..
philippines?
We are in 2019! this is my first year in university. After 3 years I'll be able to become an English teacher, I have the passion to help people to learn and become open-minded, not just in a way that they can learn English but to give them pieces of advice and teach them how to be good citizens and realize their dream. I know that education in Morocco sucks, but sometimes when I take a look at some teachers, they are so great, they helped to change and eleminate my negative thoughts ... unfortunatly they couldn't find a lot of open ears. If I become a teacher I'll try to change my students mentality and let them love studying.
Cool! In 2 years i will be English teacher too)
I wish you the best 💓😆 if u become a teacher. . Then text me here back
Good luck bro
I know your gonna be a Great teacher one day 👍
Great, now is 2020. It's my second year in the university. Please teach me english.. I hope learn english from another people abroad make my english better. Btw i the future i'll be an English Teacher too
@@nadilavivo7836
I can help you
What I noticed is that it shows classrooms of around twenty students when in reality most of the classrooms in public schools the average is forty students per class. Also, with the automatic promotion, there is a wide diversity of skills among the students. The Math textbooks, for example are growing and growing in content that makes key information to stick less and less because it's expected to COVER more and more information in the same amount of time.
Teachers are the real nation builders,their role cannot be overemphasized. Teachers are given feedback here in Edo state Nigeria, the governor has trained learning and development officers who give feedback to different teachers in different schools everyday,and we have seen a steady progress in education since the inception of the program
This video It made me realize that if we were teachers, we had to listen to the opinions of our students because their opinions will help us to develop better and more effective teaching.
The most wonderful thing teachers have is to look at the bright and positive side of every student.
schools change societies
1, schools never change everything since the 1800s, well that's old things.
2, schools has too much homework for a child to bear, and in China, 20 is enough for us. :(
3, schools can make you had loss of creativity, imagination, happiness and freedom and replace those of useless facts, what to think, stress and mental health problems.
There's a difference between maintaining control, and actually teaching for mastery. That difference is trust.
7:06 Rare clip of Bill Gates advertising MacBook Pro.
he actually played on an apple advertise.. Even, Macintosh...
@@omerfarukbykl6097 yeah, I think it was for the ipod launch or something.
The feedback that can most benefit a teacher/coach, is feedback from the learners.
To talk about teachers feedback is easier said than done. There’s enormous number of studies concerning with teacher evaluation but we need to know how to implement such system.
Self-Studying is the best teacher.
I would say it's actually motivation and curiosity. If you want to learn something, there's nothing that's going to stop you.
Thanks a lot man. Really means a lot at this point of time. Having my exams in 60 days.. hope everything goes well..
It means that we need to be independent learners. Teachers, should just play encougaring role to help students draw inspiration in learning process.
No!
@@ProfessorSyndicateFranklai that's right
all the sectors or parts of a school should get a feedback, including the managing office and families
we need to learn more and more every single day,
Teachers NEED TO BE HEARD but the coach system has the unintended consequence of silencing them - too many power tripping coaches! My students made amazing progress WITH ZERO suggestions from the coach. I made all my improvements from seeking fantastic training outside of the classroom. Better ideas than a coach: REDUCE class sizes and see what a difference that makes. GET parents to listen to their children read at home for 20 plus minutes and see what difference that makes. EQUALIZE the ever spreading income gap, so parents have time to spend with their children, and you will be amazed. These things will change our education scores better than any coaching could ever hope to do. We need to address the problem correctly otherwise we are wasting our time here.
💪🤝💪
I could not agree more with your reflection. ❤️❤️❤️
So simplistic and short-sighted. I am a former teacher and know of no teachers who have the time, energy, and resources to video tape themselves or watch extra teaching videos. When you're asking teachers to do more on top of the 60+ hours they already work each week, when they're already balancing second jobs and families, when they are up to their necks in paperwork and admin duties, you are asking too much. I would say that no amount of feedback and reflection is going to really matter until teachers are paid an honest and fair wage for their work, when they're given time to prepare for and do their jobs properly, and when they're allowed to actually teach. Until changes can be made improving time and wages for teachers, feedback won't really matter.
So important for teachers to receive feedback. I've taught English both in a class and in home-tutoring an individual. I've also taught social work students. In all cases, receiving feedback, in the form of supervision + evaluation ws critical to improving my understanding of what I was doing - and students being able to understand + improvie how they performed too.
Teacher are the ideal for human being learning
In the exercice shown, students help each other :-)
I have learned twice as much on my own compared to what teachers tought me. I dont like people talking, i like reading, writing, communicating and doing things. Preferably on my own. Why are teachers so important?
For those who cannot do what you can. Not everyone learns the same way that you do.
Thanks for all the research you put into that conclusion.
Unfortunately this system doesn't work in the college education system. There's no requirement or incentive for a professor to improve when they provide the service of research and bring in revenue that way. After all college is firstly a business, and secondly an education institution.
why Bill Gates is not running for USA presidents candidate?
Why are you not?
K
Possibly because he's a businessman, but also w/ Trump.... so I guess, why not?
Cause, he is intelligent.
Which side would he be on?
I doubt it if the presentation slide on the stage is made with Powerpoint, it's so beautiful!
it's wonderful. Can you share with me its audio ? thank you so much.
The way society is has to do a lot with student success too. In the USA teachers aren't really respected we are constantly being doubted, overworked and undervalued. Teachers are to blame if test scores low or if students aren't performing well. But the issue is more than that! A child's education starts at home with the the parent. Nowadays parents aren't doing that and expect teachers to be the parents! We have to be the parents, the teachers, the nurse, the counselor, the family therapist, the police, etc ... Maybe first talk about parenting in this country and putting a priority on education than scratching the surface of the problem. I would welcome feedback, but let's get real here in why the USA isn't ranked at the top 5.
This man can not stop impressing and inspiring me !
I hope Elon Musk also does
You are easily impressed. He is clueless here.
because he only talks about U.S.. unlike a Global Citizen.. despite being called a Leader..
Badatya, he eradicates malaria and TB in different countries.
that's non-US
Me too...
muchas gracias por compartir !!!
In my college year,we used to have a teacher who never listen to our feed back,he never learn from those of our feed back.
Sir, your voice is give me satisfaction.
Bill, you are searching for a system for feedback for teacher. In your example you show two instruments: video feedback and in Shanghai the learning communication between teachers what they do and can learn from each other. We are proudly to present you that this system of feedback and dialogue already exists in the Netherlands. Thousands of teacher use our digital learning instrument called Mijnbardo. In this environment teacher place good examples (including video registration), they share their experiences and give each other feedback. If you want, we can you a demonstration).
I am very much open to having the classroom camera in my classroom. I wish I could have one so I could always go back to how well I was doing with the teaching-learning process. Is this camera already available? I'm from the Philippines teaching English in a public school. Thanks!
because that's how you both improve and gauge improvement. competition provides standard and standard leads to consistency and development.
I am from Bangladesh but I want to go out country for higher education
This speak is very nice
Wow nice to know Thad am also planning
I am from india 🇨🇮🇨🇮
Hii syed
China welcome you。
@@chinavillage7233 no one is interested thanks 😂😂
this is creativity...to come up with a new and great idea to improve the world....
7:17 That's my teacher! Her name is Mrs. Wessling
Trust must be present for teachers to buy in. Too many administrators look for ways to fire teachers rather than ask, How can we help this teacher who wants to be great, improve their skills? The problem is that the attitude of actualizing potential with respect to students is often not applied to teacher improvement. That is a shame, for we are all learners. Building a trusting and supportive environment for teachers can make all the difference. Also, too many teachers work in silos and refuse to collaborate with their colleagues. The whole culture needs to continue to change, everywhere.
The fact that the teacher and most of students uses Apple and Bill Gates just showed the video is a huge character development for me.
Raise teachers' salaries then! It requires a lot of work. It is not as easy as it seems to be able to perch that camera at the back of the classroom and write reviews and notes while all these admin, grading, attendance tracking, other nitty gritty stuff are waiting to be completed.
Seriously! The real difference between us and the example he gave of Shanghai is the time they gave teachers to work on their practice when they are not teaching. I want to challenge my self to video my lessons this year and reflect on them but as I thought about it I realize that it would take about an extra hour a day. I can't justify that when my schedule is already so busy.
@Kam Y wow nice to know Thad yes am also in Canada for study purpose I can understand
Joshua LaForge ж
İn Azerbaijan teachers make 500 manat ( $250) a month :(
Your salaries are very good but you are not thankful.
Exactly
feedback is the best thing you can give a teacher. people rarely think about the complexities of a teaching role, we just accept it happens.
Great!, and many happy returns of the day. Thanks and best regards.
I am a teacher in Mexico, my classroom has cameras but that does not help much in the education, but rather in the surveillance, and I feel observed all the time
Not everyone gets the vision to be a teacher. I have seen there are plenty of teachers who only became teachers after they failed to get any other job. They are just doing the part-time work being a teacher. In essence, they are destroying the interests of the students. If some people become teachers according to their vision and vocation. They want to do something great for the students. But if we don't give them their required feedback then we destroy their interests to be a teacher. In this way, it is mutually harmful for teachers as well as for students.
If you only employed excellent teachers, where would that leave everyone else? I think that there is enough blame for everyone to have some for themselves.
Ryt dear
You can be a good, professional teacher without it being your calling in life
Many people end up in their current profession by chance, not because they planned it that way. It happens not only in the teaching profession, but across the board
Pakistanio ka kaam hi ghalat baat kurna Hy, kuch pta na ho tu chup rehna chahiya.
In the region (in Norway) where i live we got a school just like that, the kids are in groups with other kids of the same ability, the ages are mixed in each group
Thank you for sharing.
I always thought teachers are too smart & good to receive feedback from students or others.
damn powerpoint does some pretty presentations now
such a entirely different Ted talk from the rest !
his Ideas are inspirational and so is his work PHENOMENAL...
I always thought it was something that every student did, but as I got older I realized it was not. At the end of every year I told my teachers what I liked best about the year (or semester) and what I disliked along with why. It had a wide range of responses from lengthy discussions to them telling me to go away.
very very nice point.
Thank you sir
6:05 is this a classroom or canteen
Lol
give microsoft office for free
actually most colleges DO provide microsoft office for free
lol, just use microsoft toolkit, free activation of windows or office
They did at my school district XD
In my school I have it for free (not the school pays for it)
Actually in my college microsoft provide almost all products for free....
Thanks a lot for insight
I am Having Level of Satisfaction.....I will be Gratitude for what I am Having or Consisting......
quite interestingly we get observed in the UK in that exact fashion! however I noticed that we are know where on that list! observations are horrible and stressful, even when you know you are doing the stuff you mentioned, it puts undo stress on teachers, continually being observed is horrible!
I much rather observe myself as the video did, with the teacher videoing herself, we are our own best critic, however does then then become an infringement in the pupils privacy?
They let you teach? Your grammar is appalling, and it is "nowhere" not "know where." And it is "undue stress" not "undo stress."
Na camera's are illegal in the classrooms at school or it was our schools policy anyway because it is intrusive.
Emulating and learning from the best will make a teacher great. Nit picking at faults just makes a teacher nervous and cautious and at best competent but not great.
Give us more money, more time, and policies that are actually logical, effective, and are developed by actual educators.
Thank you Mr.Bill
I never really understood what we had in common as Twitter followers but
You're a friend in my mind.
"THANK YOU"
(I'm just learning to navigate #MicrosoftLauncher the organizers very helpful)
Great message!
Teachers are one of the builders of the nation and I am not saying that just because I too am a teacher. But I guess the idea of a camera in a class is micromanaging and going to take away the spontaneity of a teacher’s facilitation. An alternative would be to provide teachers with a curriculum that includes everything expected from an ideal lesson. Train the teachers to deliver the content in the manner expected of them. Finally, organise regular assessments of the students and let the results talk.
Teaching shouldn’t be a sting operation but fun for both teachers and students. #SucceedEng
wonderful notion for teachers to tape their classes... except that it can be seen as a violation of FERPA unless you get a signed release from each student
This school year I gave 2 of my teachers feed back cause I beleived the class should be taught better and 1 teacher got replaced by request and the other didn't do anything differently. And now im just disengaged in class cause they truly don't care.
sounds like a similar thing I have on my uni here in Portugal
The best feedbacks for teachers are directly and indirectly given by theirs students. If they’re allowed to give their opinions and participate in the learning process, their contributions are unbelievably valuables and transforms the educational internal system. Specially if the teacher is open to build a close relationship with the students. It’s a magic, productive and extremely pleasurable experience! 🤩😉
Fantastic that Mr Bill Gates used this platform to usher in the much needed change in Quality of Teachers' and their teaching methodology so that USA scores better in PISA test.
The message is not only for USA teachers but for all who are into teaching profession .
Good luck
Thanks
Kasturi G
Teacher retraining is also a great tool. I recommend Cambridge conferences (training) around the world for that. As for the cameras, I'm in for it. Though it may raise a lot of questions (I teach in a private school). For me, I have been using my computer (computer camera) to record the activities during the lessons. I can assure, feedback helps a lot.
Real feedback. What a blessing.
I agree we need more support and feedback. However I am nervous when I hear national comparisons because that seems akin to the standardization we see in our standardized accountability testing with which the pedagogical world has identified so many inequities within. It also makes me nervous to compare teacher salary to the cost of a billionaire's system. Don't pay teachers less to improve their performance. We are already paid less than other professions with similar schooling and experience. That being said, I would also like to see different classroom populations taken into account. Who does a fantastic job teaching a specific concept to individuals with learning disabilities? Who is great at teaching a specific skills to individuals with emotional disturbances? Or other important factors such as ELL or individuals whose family culture differs from the Judeo-Christian norm, individuals who come from poverty, or individuals who have a language disorder. Lastly, I believe that more of a comparison with other countries's educational systems should be done. Korea puts much more focus on the emotional support of their students as opposed to the academic support our own (US) system champions above all else. Perhaps we also need a paradigm shift at the highest levels of education to encompass more than just academic achievement--and in doing so, perhaps our own country's academic achievement will improve.
I love the man.he is very amazing man 💖💖💖
yes i agree that teachers should deserve have more resources and feedback to change their way of teaching
I'm a teacher and started to write this long post on how I love that he is addressing this, but the problems with his solution are enormous. Then I realized it's going to fall on deaf ears and erased it all.
I'm a teacher. I'm listening.
@@kpounders7437 all of the teachers are listening, but it's not the teachers that make the big decisions.
Why does it have so less views ?
the video is on the specific topic. people care and search videos that help just them, a few are interested in someone but themselves)
Hey Bill, that Mac helps
LOL, that teacher was using a Mac.
I noticed that as well.
Dr Maszlee.... Should try this
We need more valid and reliable research on this teacher feedback methodology before concluding that it's recommended for all.
A few things to consider:
1) classroom sizes.
2) teacher's personality in general (e.g. do all teachers feel comfortable being recorded on camera? )
3) students (e.g. do we assume that students behave well when they know that they're being recorded on camera? Or do they have a different set of personalities off camera? )
4) measurement of students' academic performance and motivational levels with this method of feedback. Any correlation between them?
His argument assumes that the feedback provided will be crafted in a way that will encourage teachers to change their instructional methods. However, the evidence of the current system of evaluation, Bill Gate's team has sponsored, is very degrading towards teachers. The teachers are told that the top rank on the evaluation is not even possible to obtain. The phrase is "we visit the exemplary category, but that is not where we live." Imagine if students were told that obtaining an A in this class is not possible. That the students might get a couple As on select assignments, but they will not leave the course with an A. It kills ambition. Teachers, young and old, are leaving the profession and a small number of graduates are moving in to replace them. Personally, I had more passion for teaching while I was a student teacher than when I secured my first teaching position. The only good thing that came out of this program was the mentorship program. I can honestly say that I improved tremendously my first year as a result of the unbiased mentor who was assigned to just help me. This part is good, but the evaluation system destroys.
Erika Tornatore SO TRUE! The difference is, a mentor is someone in-the-trenches, not someone on the outside telling you what your day-to-day performance should be, based on a short snip-it of analysis from someone who is not in the arena. People in favor or Mr. Gates' initiative, should read the fine print.
As a student I have only a glimpse of how the system he espoused works. Could you please explain how it is degrading. Also thank you for being a teacher.
The intention may be good but the result could be worse than expected. Every teacher who are called to help often becomes helpless because the final result lies upon the student. Though feedback is important, in a third world country where am in, there is more to look at what technology can help providing teachers the feedback, and that is, the state of majority of numbers of pupils or students who go to school without meals. That means, no matter how good the teacher can be, when the pupils or students are malnourished, the strategy of teachers won't work with the empty stomach of the kids. Technology advancement where Bill Gates carved his name is one best opportunity for some, but it leaves more numbers of young kids in the third world to be left uncared than what it can carry with it. I am a teacher myself, and my first teaching experience brought to my realization that most students from state colleges and universities are in their survival mode to get the degrees they want, land on the job they dreamed, and earn the money they thought can make their realities better. But they don't mind if they truly learn a thing they can bring on for life as long as they pass the curriculum and move up higher. And the teachers? They can be remembered but their lessons are forgotten.... So I left formal Academies and decided to focus more on self-empowerment and self-development, subjects where majority of formal school teachers are unequipped themselves. (Not all anyway!)
He speaks like a CEO :D
Talked about Shanghai teachers' feedback from colleagues, that reminds me when I was in my elementary school in China. My teacher signed the students different roles before the class "show". We had the rehearsal about the class before the "show" started. Some students even be signed the roles of "wrong " answers. I wonder how many schools have done like this?
Sherry Hu That's maybe happened when the government officer come to the school, or teachers from other school. But for the teachers in the same school, it is different. Most of the time, the senior teachers play a role as mentors, mark the new teachers better.
Self reflection for the next better teaching practice. Thanks Bill.
imagine having a multi-billion dollar worth IT team doing your Powerpoint presentation for you :D
He is awesome. One day I'll be able to present something like that.
I am currently a junior in one of the top ranking public high schools in the nation.Every classroom has fancy electronic whiteboards, every language class has a $20,000 headphone system, and every student is issued a laptop.There seems to be the false perception that more technology equals better education.I do not disagree that technology can definitely help, but teachers are hands down, no argument, a million times more significant that fancy pieces of equipment.We need better trained teachers
Feedback from parents and kids, suggestion from parents, ideas from other teacher, advice from principle, coordinator and academic head does magic
if you really want a solution then watch Sir Ken Robinson's TED talk on escaping education's death valley
Yes, I do recommend it
czcams.com/video/-0UBog-vjuo/video.html
sir ken robinson's ted talk
Bill, this is GREAT for students.
Common Core is BAD for students :(
It's a real shame you don't understand that.
MrVanTeacher Agreed!
Gregg Jones giving tough standards(they think "tough love") is okay for HEALTHY ADULTS. but these are a great variety of healthy and unhealthy CHILDREN. it's a shame that the politically powerful, elite, 'education with profit/choice' CC advocates haven't experienced the lives of the lower 50%, so, I think, they really don't understand the damage they are doing.
MrVanTeacher Another 10 billion for Bill and his "empire". Way to go Big brother! It's only 2% for US government and yet another way for you to "engage" in your "humanitarian" work. So transparent...
Teachers are the backbone of a great country.
not the feedback they need but the feedback they deserve
Be nice to nerds. Chances are you'll end up working for one. :D
Grade: A
Fantastic! Best man, best company in the world, helps in so many ways! Thank you Bill!
An interesting TED talk. I feel that the first qualification of a teacher should be that they are interested in people, then the subject. I can really get excited about teaching chemistry, but when the students do not seem to care I lose interest, Therefore, I am not a successful teacher. Some times the most challenging question to some students deals with home life and other challenges. It is easy to motivate yourself as a teacher when the students begin to show interest.
We get plenty of feedback, what we actually need is a decent paycheck
Sloke1001 X6 preach it !!!!
I as a teacher haven't got my salary for the past several months. Leave alone feedback.
Does anyone know the progress of this device currently in 2017?
It is so great video for me! Thank you :)
It sounds like a business plan =)
His speech was very helpful and inspiring...
But still i expected Bill Gates to talk about something more intresting , as Bill Gates...
Now u realized the value of sons in the ariel ad
There are schools that do just that, magnet schools, schools that teach via the Montessori method, but they aren't nearly common enough or affordable enough. I also think that there's a bit of a stigma placed on them, because they're "special" schools for kids who often have "problems" learning in a conventional school environment.
Walter white is the best teacher ever
Yeah he's a genius
Bill gates is amazing and he is doing things which normal rich people don't do. Sincerely appreciate him.
jaglinuxmint He is not a normal rich guy as well. He is the richest of them all
Yes i agree with you. Maybe it is true
I"ve been a teach for 20+ years and my best feedback - the only feedback I take seriously - is the students themselves. When the teacher is hitting the mark, the students are more animated, they participate in class, creativity flows. Most of the time grades improve as well, but that's not my goal. I don't believe every student fits in the formal education box. If two way communication flows I'm doing my job - end of story
Not only the teachers need feedback, but the students also need to see how they work in the class. Of course the admins should hear the feedback from teachers, students and parents.