How to fix a broken education system ... without any more money | Seema Bansal
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 05. 2024
- Seema Bansal forged a path to public education reform for 15,000 schools in Haryana, India, by setting an ambitious goal: by 2020, 80 percent of children should have grade-level knowledge. She's looking to meet this goal by seeking reforms that will work in every school without additional resources. Bansal and her team have found success using creative, straightforward techniques such as communicating with teachers using SMS group chats, and they have already measurably improved learning and engagement in Haryana's schools.
TEDTalks is a daily video podcast of the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes (or less). Look for talks on Technology, Entertainment and Design -- plus science, business, global issues, the arts and much more.
Find closed captions and translated subtitles in many languages at www.ted.com/translate
Follow TED news on Twitter: / tednews
Like TED on Facebook: / ted
Subscribe to our channel: / tedtalksdirector
its so sad TED shows us how to make the world a better place but it never becomes reality...
Well it's already been implemented. This will most likely be replicated throughout India
it does, its just that our brain is skewed towards negative outcomes, things.
Facebook Mark Zuckerberg donated tons of Cash to Help Public Schools. All the money was mismanaged and lost....
+Shinu Chacko. HOW ?!?!?
Given to friends if friends consultants etc. ..
Another moral of the story, it's amazing just how rotten a system can get when most people in it just don't care, or feel hopeless. And it's great to see how quickly it can change with just one small group that cares.
बेहाल शिक्षा दोषी कौन ?
czcams.com/video/AEXC35k-CAs/video.html
A good point was made by her that the government expects their teachers to do everything but teach children. My mother and my aunts are govt school teachers and they get posted to election duties, board exam duties and what not. Sometimes they have to travel farther from their school locations everyday due to these tasks.
Teachers are capable but the authority and the syllabus restrict the full use of their potential.🙁🙁🙁
From your mouth to G-d's ears, as we say. This is terrific. I work for a public school & your solutions are very good ones. This talk hits the nail right on the head. One thing I will add to your presentation. If teachers have adequate levers, if they create adequate levers or get adequate levers, if they improvise adequate levers that won't fail, they will transform schools & worlds. This is very encouraging.
You fixed a minor problem in an entirely shattered system, not a broken one. Indian education as I know it has been too standardized and killed any hope for creativity in children. 5-7 year olds are far too creative than you and me by nature, instead of cultivating that, education system just shoved standardized curriculum down their throat.
Teachers have soo much power in their hand. Partiality, abuse of power and grades through sycophancy is essence of every classroom... result? No healthy skepticism in students.
Grades, oh mighty grades. You know what happens in most first lectures? "Yeh chapters khas padh lo, exam k lie important hai" (translation: learn these chapters, it's important from examination point of view). Instead of teaching children how math and geometry can applied to real world problems, we give them useless numerical problems. Instead of teaching how historical events teach us the way of living, we force them to remember timeline of events with date/year.
Now let's talk about higher-ed, our universities don't have "major" system, students decide their major too early in life and a lot of them regret their decision. This happens mostly because they didn't have any idea about the degree program they were getting into.
+Dushyant Goel ... and what makes you think I'm criticising her or demeaning her work?
well hey she at least metioned it without her personailty getting in the way.
I think she has not fixed all of the problems, too but the important thing is that they have achieved their goal, for every child to be literate and properly educated. This innovation can open up ideas and opportunities more many other innovation in the future. Fixing a whole education system in 2 and a half years is a wild dream. If it's that easy we wouldn't have had any problem in the first place.
Dirk Gently you couldn't have been more correct. However if everybody understood the nectar of life this world would have become an actual heaven. I can feel your frustration, to a certain extent, about certain systems or people. But parents too play a huge part in inculcating deeper values. They are the biggest opportunity lost for every child. I could excuse the parents from impoverished backgrounds but not the urban educated parents instilling their kids with shallow expectations of money, fame, success, competition etc. A school doesn't drop from the heavens neither are their teachers, nor governments or processes. It's us who does and I mean it.
ps. How about big corporations where successful, highly educated people work but with visions which can't get more myopic. By the way, those people think they are doing a great job and few are, but most ain't with their tick in the box mentality. Parents for starters plz
bilkul sahi mai bhi koshish me laga hua ho apne school ko reform karne ke liye
teachers are so underrated. most teachers are overworked and over-stressed but their salary is low. we need to treat them better like how we treat doctors, lawyers and all that. even being a teacher is not highly regarded in society as doctors, engineers or lawyers do. they directly teach us and our kids, give us the knowledge that we need to know for everyone to be a better person and that is truly admirable. great teachers can help slow learners to be advance learners. so teachers should be treated better, give them high salary and quit bothering them with unnecessary work like admin work, filing, check this and that and let them do what they're good at, teach. also progress to make teachers better too, if the teacher is not performing well, train them, let them go for courses so they can learn more and teach better. and this goes out to any kind of teacher, kindergarten teachers, school teachers, universities teachers, teachers who teach special need children, the work of all teachers are truly admirable.
no we dont they had the choice to be a lawyer a doctor or anything like that but they choose teacher they knew before how its going to be they knew they will be payed less they knew they will be overstressed but they still choose teacher and most teachers dont need a good education so they didnt spend the time to get a bitter job if they even wanted them
Liqid And they still made a noble choice. Unfortunately they are treated like garbage by the district and private companies.
@@ihx7 if every or half of the teachers did that, who will teach the generations ??
Teaching is one of the most important career and should be recognized and not being ignored just because of the flawed educational system
@@ange4933 yes its important but that doesn't mean that it needs to be payed better
The solution(s) aren't going to come from the top, regardless of affiliation. We have seen that now for decades. The solutions will come from the bottom up, meaning EVERYONE in the schools; administrators ( a bad one kills a school, good ones breath life back in), teachers(Ditto), paras, nurses, secretaries, custodians, security officers. It is a collective solution because each interacts with the school itself & the students. It is Emergent Theory.
I am from Haryana and our teachers never do any sort of activity , well this sounds good(your speech) but really there's no solution😒
It's 2020 and I'm really curious to know whether the goal has been achieved.
They actually succeeded now 86% of children in Haryana are of Grade level or Sakhsam.
Agreed, but in America, our low income school systems have a huge behavioral issue. And lack of train of thought. Not enough cognitive research in those school systems. Lifestyle and school share an impact on a child. It has to be a balanced or one can disrupt or one can be exposed to disruption. Js.
m.timesofindia.com/city/gurgaon/80-haryana-declared-saksham-for-achieving-grade-level-competency/amp_articleshow/68205655.cms
Not in America 😩
The book "Bad Biz: Your Guide to Starting a For Profit College" by Corin Devaso is an interesting read. It's satire that shows how some colleges scam.
Very inspiring and commendable how people like her are dedicating so much effort to this cause with all their heart. A good education is definitely one of the fundamental rights of every child and probably the one issue that requires utmost attention in India. I hope more people step up to this cause and are able to transform the broken system. A society cannot get closer to being more equal if its education system is so unequal for different segments of the population.
Yes!! Seema Bansal go for it!! You've got the idea now start implementing it! This is REALLY needed
The problem is that if public schools are to improve, then private schools and tutors won't receive so much money and this part of the economy and the government won't receive money and many will stay unemployed. But improving will have benefits that will improve the economy and many other things. Remember that Finland was poor and was healed economically by their education system. WHAT CAN WE DO TO CHANGE THE EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM???!! Anything!
i wish more people had your sincerity and positivity! starting with myself. inspirational
You have taken some baby steps. But we need a revolution. We need everyone to participate. Education is not just about students and teachers. Its about parents too, its about everyone that student interact. Countries like Finland and Norway don't give homework to their students but what their students learn is far more than what homework can teach them. They interact with society, they understand the importance of art, culture, literature, music. They understand why learning science is important. They even understand what they can do or how they can participate in a smooth functioning of society. Coming back to India, can we really do that here. Imagine what's gonna happen it we stop asking our students to do homework. Well they will end up doing worthless things in social media, they will end up learning what's not right for them to know.
In simple words our country don't have a proper academic ambiance. Education makes a better society, again a good society is a great teacher for it's youth. Coming to the point, we need a revolutionizing force. I believe definition of education should be changed and people should be reeducated. Even adults need education.
She is Director at BCG and IIM Calcutta Graduate.
Great efforts to bring in the improvements. The idea of using materials in immediate surrounding as a teaching aid is simple and effective at the same time. Use of whatsapp group for faster spread of information is an efficient move but what's more important in this case too is that there should be a mechanism to look over the implementation of orders texted are in time and up to the mark.
Great talk. Education reform is crucial and I really hope we do see positive changes in the near future.
The real problem of education are the distractions children have today. Im teaching maths, and i know first hand how much TV the children watch every day. My suggestion first is to get rid of the TV in the house. In mine there is no TV since 2005. We replaced the TV news with newspapers. When the children want to watch a show they can find it online, but they choose instead of watching whatever the TV is feeding them. Without TV the family communication improved by a thousand. And children use their logic and can hold adult interesting conversations. Those are the first steps for a better education. But also requires parents to be thinkers of course and to be at least as intelligence as the children. I agree with improving the education, to spend less for war and more for schools but also at home the environment must be challenging. 11 years without TV and the family life is amazingly better.
Anything can be a distraction, you can't get rid of them all. In old times, people get addicted to Non-Fiction novels now its TV and Facebook. You can't just blame TV or other things, its up to the person and family. If they can control it then its fine.
+patel charvak do you have a TV? Yes or No?
mlazos Yes, I do watch it sometimes but I am pretty good at my academics.I watch TV not more than 1-2 hours a day.
patel charvak
then you dont know life without TV. sorry but you cant compare, I can. It is like a meat eater, discuss about vegetarians. Its like a theist talk about atheism. your opinion is biased. Give up TV for a couple of years, see the effects on children, and then we can talk again. until then, you have no idea what im talking about.
Nice point of view. I agree with you, nonetheless there are more situations/things which stop the improvement of education depending on the country.
I have seen number of TED talks. But this one is an awe-inspiring example of real change only with persistence and ingenuity
बेहाल शिक्षा दोषी कौन ?
czcams.com/video/AEXC35k-CAs/video.html
saw her video on inside iim her speaking skills improved by leaps and bounds
Morale of the story: let teachers teach.
+
a nerdfighter?
Artur Mizuno only way it makes sense
don't let oligarchs hire imbeciles into the government and than tell people it's government's fault it is full of retards and we should establish capitalism in place of schools
Googol I will agree that oligarchical councils not caring of the capabilities of those they hire or their creeds, but I wouldn't say that private schools are the easy perfect solution.
Much of this is covered by Robert Mager's work: Preparing Instructional Objectives, Measuring Instructional Results, Analyzing Performance Problems and Goal Analysis, as applied to the Teachers and their management as well as the students.
India really needs a change in the education/goverment system because in listening to this talk I immediatly though of those solutions before she mentioned them. And what scares me is that my own goverment might be doing the same thing, scratching their heads about problems that a common person might already have a solution.
बेहाल शिक्षा दोषी कौन ?
czcams.com/video/AEXC35k-CAs/video.html
simple:
give the child basics:
language skills
basic math
nature knowledge
and give them good books
.. 2 days a week is enough
That is not an education.
i believe thats homeschool, not public school.
Simple:-
Give thechild basics.
Language skills
basic math
nature knowledge
and give them good books
..2day a week is enough
Come on America teach your student how to be Entrepreneurs, Problem solvers, creative thinkers, Not mindless workers.
this is some great work. only if the heads of education in the US had goals..
what a smile facial gesture .....like she is describing the achievements
This is a very smart woman, speaking of a very smart solution to an intractable problem.
What about the broken education system in the U.S?
lost cause.
Politics + Money > Education
we've got a more broken education system, dont complain :(
Really sad
As long as we still have Republican politicians who still want to teach creationism in all public schools, nothing close to an overhaul in funding and change will ever happen in congress.
I love your passion towards children they are our future a best investment to humanity ❤️
Hope we can cross paths in the future
I loved each and every second of this TED-Talk. Got to learn so much todayy
Education System Filing School’s got Problems, lots of them. A funny-and-sad Video-Essay exploring why was just made by „Some More News“.
Sorry but those blocks at the end of the chapter might only help if anyone sees it. because teacher's in my school never brought in any activity to learn better even though it wasn't a government school. teachers are only after finishing their portion faster, cause then they can go for a longer leave. Sadly Indian education system does require a meaningful change. Cause it's knowledge that counts and not the marks.
Simple solution : stop capitalising education and improve the syllabus
Creating a system to help children learn is so difficult and complex. You need to insentivise children to see value in learning, you need to engage the entire class, you need to promote responsibility of the students to take ownership of their learning, you need to educate teachers to a high enough level of content and teaching skills, you need enough teachers and support staff to prevent overstretched teaching. You need education to be accessible and affordable for all and those who are disadvantaged need free school meals amd resources. Once you've found a way to solve all of these points you then need to consider what's happening outside of school and at home, the societal environment and attitudes. We do know generally that wealth provides higher levels of education and there will always be a ceiling on free education.
All the skill that comes out of India is not because of the education system but despite the education system
Exactly bro........exactly
A good idea to change Indian education system...All d best 🙏🙏
Ppl belive that having an education is enough for a nation its not about having an education system in place it's about how that education system functions if we can change the education system and the way schools are run in general, we can change many issues in the world.
Remember that education is not only the knowledge of subjects but knowledge of truth, society and tolerance
Amazing, thank you very much
We are actually trying to implement in remote areas of kolkata,india through our NGO.
Superb !! Great job *****
Countries such as Hong Kong, South Korea, Japan, etc. are rich. They also have better education.
Children are depressed and stressed though
Please help Brazil. Our education is almost hopeless.
I don't have much idea about Brazil's education apart from what I gathered in R. Feynman's book. Damn, that guy was a great teacher. Do read his point of view on Brazil's education system.
The book "Bad Biz: Your Guide to Starting a For Profit College" by Corin Devaso is an interesting read. It's satire that shows how some colleges scam.
احسنتى انتى وفريق عملك
نحن بمصر نحب الهند جداً ونحب الممثل اميتبات شان وشاروخان
وانتم مجتهدون ورائعون ربنا يوفقكم ، نجوان صادق ، مدربة تنمية بشرية للاطفال
Yes, I agree
The solution presented by the consulting company in this TED talk is so simple. But this speaker makes it seem as if they revolutionized the whole industry with this solution. What I really want to know is how much these consulting firms charged for this solution.
seema bansal is such a good speaker, i want to see more uploads of her
बेहाल शिक्षा दोषी कौन ?
czcams.com/video/AEXC35k-CAs/video.html
Get the Federal out of it...BOOM solved. Bring back curiosity, imagination, and creativity...down with standardized testing
but then you'd have children thinking outside of the box.. and that's a big no no for the fellows up above...
federal funded this reform - without federal only liberal states would fund reform in education
Googol perhaps he's referring specifically to India?
Muda Le nope, he is talking about american Republican party ideology - he thought this video proved that american government should stop paying for free schools
But the states are responsible to providing education..
Great person great job hats off
Sticks, stones, and a text message is all you need to fix an education system. Amazing!
What I don't get is...why doesn't ANYBODY SPEAK UP for the U.S education system....literally after 2 years of high school and then only thing i learned is....how to form 1 sentence in spanish and some simple writing grammar...everything else was just forgotten and that's the issue ( While schools in places like india need more money and technology for kids to learn simple common knowledge, america which has it all ( mostly) implements usless subjects and crap that even teachers say we won't use or remember)
i agree but nothing can be done, unless someone in the UN stands up and addresses the problem.
It is not just school, university system also need a fundamental change. I am a MBA student I can learn alot and focus more about problem solving skills or how to be a great researcher but instead teachers always talk about exam and all I want to do is read for my exams, I mean what is this? We passed alot of exams before in school and bachelors so let me be innovative and learn new things and focus about the things that really matters I don't know I am done with all the stress and this ridiculous systems.
Can we move towards an Ai remote homeschooling system?
Teachers are exhausted, children are being held back from exceeding, or pushed forward before they are ready. Drop out rates are climbing, less students are enrolling in higher education.
I propose a new take on how to make this possible.
Who is it that truly benefits from having week educated people?
Governments, Public services, Private companies, business's.
It's not just the student that benefits from a better structured education, it's our society as a whole. Moving towards the future we need to make education accessible at a personal level of growth.
Currently our schooling system only benefits those with strong memorizational skills and photographic memory.
As we all know, to accel we need to memorize the material for passing grades. Many of our population have difficulties in the area of memorization, a self paced educational system would address this issue resulting in better educated working staff, and higher graduation rates.
To achieve this outcome education shouldn't be a burden of finance to the student, when the ones that benefit from a students success is the whole economic community.
This is why I belive a self paced education should be freely funded through the government paid for by business's tax based on the field and requirements of the positions.
Really should teach public speaking
Whoever is putting annotations in the middle of the video, trying to make us go somewhere else, needs to realize we're trying to watch the damn talk - Place the annotations at the end like most other channels do.
I appreciate the lesson but who else thinks of it more as BCG Promotion Gig?
What about when the teachers skip over activities like that in textbooks?
Edcation and medical should be free.In india we join private school from hefty fee then go to tution or coaching to learn what taught in school .
well done Seema. The world needs more people like you. spread the smiles around.
The problem with American public schools is that many of them cater to the lowest class of the students, the students who do not care to learn. Teachers are stuck bringing up them are caring for them like they are babies, thus halting the rest of the class. Inadvertently, they are trying to bring the subaverage level students up to standard, instead of pushing standard students to reach their full potential. How can that be fixed? Im not sure, but the disruptive students have to find it in themselves. Personal responsibility. Trust me, I see it everyday in my classes in highschool.
Why We are behind compare to other's country in so many sectors so follow my below tips for education
Methods of Education
Agriculter Education -- appoint student's whom's want to learn from that way, Education will be only 1st to 10th std
when will be he/she got certificate from 10th std (Last year) after that appoint them's in Millitery organistaion
for take 2 year's study from Millitery organistation (Child year's Ratio will be 10th class (16 year old) + 2 year's = 18 (Capable to work)
Purpose of Lesson (1st to 10th Std) ----------
1) Our treditional Language like Marathi,hindi,Guj etc
2) English
3)For Aggriculter only
4) mathes with Bumiti
5) Sic with Bhugoal
Genral Education ----(Where are Student's want to learn after 10th class Like Com,Art and Sic also other Digaree coureses)
Purpose of Lesson (1st to 10th Std)
1) Our treditional Language
2) English
3) Mathes with Bhumiti
5) Sic with Bugoal
6) For Decent and Activites classes
no need to teach about History
Arts (BA) ---------- (only for Techer's and Low Student's)
1) Our treditional language
2) English
3) For Decent and Activites
4) History
5) chose our selected language (Book) only for teachers like mathes,sic,Bhugoal etc)
6) Low Releted Book only for Low Student's
Comm (B.com) --------------------- (Business and MBA student's)
1) English
2) BK
3) OC
4) Eco
5)SP or Mathes
Sic (MA)--------------- (Engg and Doctors)
1) English
All Subjects was taken in Right manner like Bio,phis,chemistri,mathes etc so no need to changes
Need to get all above students knowledge from Typewriter and Computer Machines because of it's new jenration purpose of our Speed with Kadam kadam Bhadaye ja …………..jai Hind jai Bharat
jalindar Bagankar You have tried very well to explain an answer in broken English! I'll save this one.
1. No figures were provided.
2. Problem was teacher were doing something else than teaching (5:02), however solution said teaching ideas were shared through whatsapp. If teachers were doing something else at the time they should teach how will they implement Ideas being shared on whatsapp
The whatsapp was the solution to the chain of command problem. The solution for teachers being expected to do everything but teach was solved by having the supervisors care about the students learning.
" supervisors care about the students learning" when was this thing said? I might have missed it.
Praveen Prasad 12:25-12:57
Hello,
I think you missed the point at 5:00 to 5:30 she talks about the problems,
at 5:38 she says what a supervisors checks, teachers were not teaching because they do something else.
at 12:25 onwards she says- now when the supervisor comes to visit school they not only checks toilets they also checks quality of education.
My question is same again, how come just forwarding things in whatsapp group improved the education while teachers were doing something else during day.
Praveen Prasad That was a different issue. That whatsapp is meant to deal with the the administration chain. The problem was changes were implemented by an unreliable chain of command and postage. The whatsapp now allows for direct communication of changes directly between teachers and state level adminisrtation, and allows for crowdsourcing problem solving between teachers.
There were multiple solutions that were implemented for multiple problems.
Its 2021 goal is not achieved yet.
Ig schools of Delhi are really improving but the whole system should get a rework from base
i really think this issue should be taken very seriously because the teacher either of Public or private schools are just for the name sake. Teachers themselves don't have core knowledge about the subjects and concepts which they personally taught to their students in Education Centers. Many trusts and managements wow are least bother about the education quality which is been provided by their school teachers.
An English Teacher is forced to teach the subjects in which he himself is poor and weak. Then how can you expect bright future for our country by giving this poor and Inferior Quality Education.
worst things which I'm have observed is unprofessional-ism in An Education Center. i.e Internal Politics. Personal Attachments why i just don t understand this .........You have sympathy and soft corner for them do it personally not on the basis of our country future.
Seema Bansal and speakers like her who are really working hard in improving quality of Education. I will be very happy to join them. For any further queries and assistance write us on mashrafee.aiqtgradcellmbrkausa@gmail.com
Mueen Ashrafee.
President
Graduate Cell
All India Qaumi Tanzeem.
And now the education system of Haryana is best in india🙏
people like this give hope..*they're a sign* that there is hope
बेहाल शिक्षा दोषी कौन ?
czcams.com/video/AEXC35k-CAs/video.html
ultimate
nice work but it is work only 1% when the supervisor is come to check school (which is already inform to teachers) & all the things are created for one day....
"it spread like Wi-Fire"
*crickets
Can I talk to miss Seema bansal I also have the same plan for the govt schools students so please need to talk.. Tell me how we can get connected...
"The system is not broken this is the system."
-Frank Underwood
Unfortunately
In my school, we take a standardized test that rates how well our school teaches certain subjects, which were English and Math. The average score in the school was below state average, so the school ordered English and Math teachers to give us more homework.
I don't know what made them think that was a good idea. Homework is supposed to be based around things that we learn in class. For me at least, I don't usually learn many new things from the homework at all, it just helps me memorize the things I learned in class.
The only thing that does successfully is make things a bit more stressful...
And how much of this is actually true and how much is marketing ? .. I saw workbooks of BCG monitored program ( Gyan Setu in Jharkhand) and the way they were being used in school and found it pretty sucky. Students couldn't read instructions because it used so much pure Hindi. English workbook introducing alphabet was in purely in English (instructions included) and students were waiting for teachers to write things on board so that they could fill it. And same will be reported later.
So my question again is much of this scalable, cost effective solution is actually working and how much is in plain reports ..
oh
I see one wrinkle in that whole story. The school board knew something was wrong and was willing to change. Many government organisations worldwide do not realize that there is a problem and do not want to change. And getting a large-scale system to change when it is not willing is, at best, very hard.
Still, it is great for that place and I congratulate them on their success and hope it continues to work!
yeah this woman doesn't realize she lives in a liberally minded socialist federation and most of the people outside of India barely know Gandhi by name let alone what he taught about human intelligence
Dushyant Goel
I agree about that but she was only able to affect the changes she did because she was called in by the local educational board or minister or something like that (I would have to watch again to remember which). And small changes that are wide spread basically change the whole large-scale system.
Mac Man not just an educational board but socialist Gandhist educational board - no board in Texas would allow a Gandhist to organize anything
I feel like your right on the money with those superstisions. but then again she was giviing her opinoin on the problem not anything serious like an official appeal.
diegofu1 talk about pot calling the kettle black
I tink tis tings in the fiteen tousand schools should be fixed by twenty-tirty. Let's do it one ting by one ting, starting with the small ting first. Tis is good tinking to do someting good.
I thought of that sticks and stones thing in like 10 seconds 😂
You could abolish affirmative action for a start.
Okay! So I can agree to that she tried but I live in haryana and I know since last 3 years teachers are staying(working,as what is expected from them) outside, supervising 10 times more than ever before. Really appreciate your efforts but you are not familiar with results. Sorry!
She seems so enthusiastic. I am so sorry for her.
She fails to see all shes doing is complaining, not doing anything about the problem.
बेहाल शिक्षा दोषी कौन ?
czcams.com/video/AEXC35k-CAs/video.html
@@diegofu1 she can't do anything..nobody can. in this area government needs to take step not a consultant.
Step one is to get rid of those who broke it.
Niceeee
why was her crowd so doll
Get rid of educational system altogether.
That doesn't sound like a very good idea...
Secret Profile
Some of the most successful people in history were dropouts.
Secret Profile
The biggest mistake schools make is that they force children to learn things they are not interested in. Neil Tyson said that if you wan't your children to become scientists then get out of their way. Passionate interest and experience should be foundation of all education.
DepthOfField those people were smart. Not everyone is. Bad idea. Stupid idea to kill the education system. Rathere there needs to be a change
DepthOfField hey i hv thought about it... i want to start an education revolution... please i need help and support
we can't kill the education system but can force the government to change it from a marks oriented study to knowledge oriented learning...
Ufff
Ways to fix school system: Get rid of Department of Education in the Federal government, decentralize school system, improve neighborhood economic opportunities, find ways to lower crime and fix those areas, more jobs and more business in those areas, allow community based schooling, and decentralize it, push for school choice and allow great schools to move into neighborhoods that are improving and like I said push for community based schooling, and ofc one more Rome, SCHOOL CHOICE! That’s all you need to do to fix the school system, it’s not a money problem.
Learning mathematics should follow the ancient Sanskrit way with intonations. It will be memorized easily.
Correct me if I misinterpreted your thoughts but I really think that math should be primarily about learning the practical application and not memorising it. If a child likes Math he or she would eventually go on learning the pure Math but till then they should be learning what a person will need for the day to day life.
Typical Ted talk, all smiles and big talk, she said they discovered "core issues" without saying what they were and how they discovered it, talked about "teachers using innovative tools " but didn't show what they were, no examples. She didn't illustrate the work at all. Just we did this.. and that that...
+Dushyant Goel Sir you too I are talking like her, when you talk about teachers being "good", please specify how does that relate to the act of teaching? How do they channel their goodness in cultivating the children's curiosity, make the students arrive at conclusions? The problem *I have* with these kind of videos is they hardly talk about the actual execution of the work i.e the teaching itself, the teaching methods, actually showing how the student is being taught and the results of it from his/her perspective, was the student now interested in the subject, did he form the ability to ask good questions to explore the concept further with the help of the teacher? Did he get to experiment with the concept? If yes then show examples of that in the video! Because after all the funding, the good intentions of good people all that matters is the ability of the teacher to teach that can prepare the child to explore the unknown and not only feeding his mind with what we already know
she was actually talking about india education systems right? why all the fuss, if you think about it really doesnt affect you.
Raghav Agrawal agreed its always hype related, nothing ever sustainable or authentic.
Agree with you
A beautiful faces I am listening... But failed to understand what is her problem and what solution she bring to do changes....she need to do more work on school rather her beauty in order to show her success...
Teaching is the only profession that makes other professions
9:00
बेहाल शिक्षा दोषी कौन ?
czcams.com/video/AEXC35k-CAs/video.html
One monitoring schools of there funds
sorry did she say that she wanted to help transform a state the size of peru or canada i really hope she knows how big Canada is
She was talking about population not the area
Love u take care dear
Nothing has changed in Haryana till date, its all hullabaloo. When teachers are using social media how they're teaching at the same time. I am in Haryana now, even Govt. has tied up with DAV Society, a private organisation for education. Reality is bitter.
m.timesofindia.com/city/gurgaon/80-haryana-declared-saksham-for-achieving-grade-level-competency/amp_articleshow/68205655.cms
You want to change the education system in the U.S? Quit the standardization and work with every student individually - considering everyone learns and digests information differently. Critical thinkers are but a minority these days and usually rebel from the thought of higher education because they realize (In the U.S at least) it is nothing but a financial snare. Universities have changed in a major fashion... they are more of a business now... and the product you receive for your payment - a certificate and zero, "real world experience." (In a lot of cases)
I don't see how implementing some simple tasks by teachers is a solution to a 'broken education system'.
बेहाल शिक्षा दोषी कौन ?
czcams.com/video/AEXC35k-CAs/video.html
I am not sure why you need to pay BCG for that. Any ias officer could have done that.
All these strategies sounds nice but how much of it is effective and implemented is another story.
The brazilian government should watch this
people intelligent enough to comprehend this video already came to the same conclusions long time ago - people retarded enough to become oligarchs won't understand this socialist wisdom of Gandhist preacher
a socialist yelling at a brasilian about 'socialist wisdom' we can just look north at venezuela
Hollus Elsfik do you profess that burning the rain forest for profit is better than enduring criminal saudi-american oil price dumping? - look further north at how 50% of americans hate capitalism and want Sanders to instate the socialist order
+Googol more love and peace, m8
Googol
No I never said that.
The reason that the people in Brazil have been burning and tearing down the forest in Brazil is because of corruption, nepotism, and poor property rights. Big government officials bribed by big business fat cats don't stop any of this blatant abuse of PUBLIC property, as in property owned by the government, as in government officials, bribed by the BIG COMPANIES. Poor property rights cause these problems too, because of "Tragedy of the Commons", if the amazon rainforest was divided into parcels of private land, a reliable government enforced rule of law and effective protection of rights and property, tort law, and reliable courts, then resource abuse will stop because people have incentives to protect their property and an incentive to not damage others.
how can I contact you?
In the Middle East all the public and half the private schools are closed