Rosendo No 5 VS YSL Babycat \\ Dupes? Which is better??

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 25. 02. 2023
  • Hey guys! Today I'll be sharing with you my thoughts on Rosendo No 5 and Babycat from YSL; which is better, are they truly dupes for one another, and do you need both?
    // M E N T I O N E D ♡♡
    Rosendo no 5
    Babycat - mine was purchased from Holt Renfrew in Canada (I live in Canada). Samples are available on ScentSplit (reputable decant company)
    ScentSplit for USA www.scentsplit.com/products/y...
    ♡ I N S T A G R A M S Come follow me on both 🤎
    / thesimplechiclife
    / beigeaesthetic2.0
    // B U S I N E S S E M A I L
    simplechicofficial@hotmail.com
    ~ D I S C O U N T C O D E S & F A V E P L A C E S T O S H O P ~
    So-Avant-Garde - Luxury Perfumes & Samples
    Save 15% with ILYTHIA15
    Twisted Lily - Luxury Perfumes & Samples
    Save 10% with code ILYTHIA10
    www.twistedlily.com
    FragranceBuy; the best place to get fragrances at a DISCOUNT - shipping to US and Canada.
    fragrancebuy.ca/Ilythia
    ♡ A L L M Y L I N K S
    linktr.ee/thesimplechiclife
    ♡ P O S H M A R K
    https:/poshmark.ca/closet/ilythiamarie
    FTC DISCLAIMER:
    Some of the links I provide are affiliate links - when you use my links I may make a small commission with which you help support my channel so I can continue making content for you.
    Where I get my music: CZcams Audio Library & www.epidemicsound.com
    #babycat #perfumes #rosendono5
  • Jak na to + styl

Komentáře • 72

  • @thesimplechiclife
    @thesimplechiclife  Před rokem +5

    Hey guys! I know I'll get questions; I ordered my Babycat from Holt Renfrew in Canada. Also learned it is available on ScentSplit! www.scentsplit.com/products/yves-saint-laurent-babycat-sample-decants?variant=42496193888456

    • @juliettirina6829
      @juliettirina6829 Před rokem +2

      I asked a seller and she said Holt Renfrew ships to US.

  • @arianaperfumes
    @arianaperfumes Před rokem +10

    It’s not discontinued, at least that’s what they told me at the Ysl store. They said eventually they’ll only have 125ml bottles, but right now is very hyped and everyone is buying it and they wait for new stocks to show up. I love it , too. I left the store with the 125 ml. And I have Rosendo 5 too. To me it smells like vanilla ice cream. I get where people are coming from with the rubber, but to me is like scooping with a stainless steel spoon vanilla icecream from this stainless steel container and you almost smell the frozen steel mixed with the ice cream . Not sure if you got your nose yet on Lune Feline. That’s another love for me, incense and vanilla . ❤

    • @Nina_80
      @Nina_80 Před rokem +1

      So you would say it smells metallic?

  • @rmkpilates
    @rmkpilates Před rokem +5

    Love Babycat...an instant love at that. Lasts long and makes me fell beautiful. A life long for me.

  • @bcoral8101
    @bcoral8101 Před rokem +18

    I own both. Luckily, I don’t get any burned rubber/gas from RN5. When I first got Babycat, I was sad because they absolutely smelled so painfully similar. Now that I’ve sat with Babycat, they aren’t alike at all! Babycat is so smooth and fluffy and beautifully vanilla. RN5 is more “aggressive” and bold. The magic is in the drydown for RN5. Whereas Babycat smells magical from the initial spritz to the dry down. I immediately bought a second bottle. I love both but Babycat? I want to live in that bottle.

  • @MilaTorres30
    @MilaTorres30 Před rokem +3

    Yaaaaasssss!!! I’ve been on a hunt for a video comparing those 2! THANK YOU for sharing your opinion ❤

  • @FreshGrey-pm4vw
    @FreshGrey-pm4vw Před rokem +3

    I have DUA's Vanilla Baby - its a dupe for Babycat. Took 30 days to sit and develop and its quite nice.

  • @JaclynGreig-nc1sq
    @JaclynGreig-nc1sq Před rokem +1

    I think the similarity might be saffron? I have both these perfumes (omg how good!) and i smell a likeness in brompton immortals which has saffron too and if smell oud for greatness in the same sitting I get it as well, please try and let me know what you think 😊

  • @JMigUK
    @JMigUK Před rokem +6

    I have both and also don’t find them that similar, just similar vibe, RM5 is a bit more unique thou, both are 💯

  • @kathyjimenez4370
    @kathyjimenez4370 Před rokem +5

    Wow I must’ve gotten a bad decant because I didn’t like Babycat. All I got was a strong incense/leather woody scent with very little vanilla.. but i mixed it with Spirituese Double Vanille and it smelled better. 😊

  • @Blowmeagain
    @Blowmeagain Před rokem +2

    Rosendo 5 smells incredible in the air but not when you smell it up close. It’s a compliment monster for me.

  • @elizabetheverson1320
    @elizabetheverson1320 Před rokem +4

    Have you or anyone tried vanagloria from laboratorio olfattivo? The same perfumer and may be a little easier to get in the US. Have seen some reviews saying similar but haven’t been able to get my nose on either yet. 😢

    • @aaronmilic8940
      @aaronmilic8940 Před rokem +1

      I bought it since I couldn't find Babycat. Babycat is better, I feel like it's the finished product whereas Vanagloria was the first demo. Canadians will know what I mean when I say, it smells like Canadian Tire for the first 30 mins to an hour and then the dry down is similar but not quite the same as Babycat. Babycat is truly remarkable and I'm kicking myself for not ordering it when I could. I have a feeling the next batch, if at all, will either be more expensive or tampered with, either changed or watered down. Hopefully not. But I'm also not willing to spend the $650-$685 some people are asking for right now.

  • @paeb
    @paeb Před rokem +2

    Just ordered it so I don't think it will be discontinued anytime soon... Hopefully I like it because it was blind buy at it's finest 😂

  • @junereid18
    @junereid18 Před rokem +9

    Rosendo Mateu No 5 smells like gasoline or a chemical similar to burnt rubber, in my opinion. Yikes... I'm hoping it will change since I blind bought it. I'm pleased to hear that Babycat is a big hit for you ❣️

  • @deannas1515
    @deannas1515 Před 3 měsíci

    Have you tried Penhaligon's Eau The Audacity? It's supposed to be better than Babycat.

  • @sweetpeace5
    @sweetpeace5 Před rokem +3

    I don’t think they’re the same. I love RM 5 & a GREAT DUPE is Fragrance World Rouge 5. Crazy good & dirt cheap. The burnt rubber goes away & strangely becomes addictive 😝

  • @pattieschulte700
    @pattieschulte700 Před rokem +1

    I want Babycat,even a decant❤️❤️ soo bad. My kitty is" Baby"
    as I have mentioned
    I also like YSL much.

  • @terireyes1127
    @terireyes1127 Před rokem +4

    I was able to get Babycat on Scent Split.

  • @avacat5092
    @avacat5092 Před rokem

    Hey friends perfect mini love ❤️

  • @aidafares9268
    @aidafares9268 Před rokem

    Where I can order it ?

  • @kelaniadetifenike8245
    @kelaniadetifenike8245 Před 8 měsíci

    Have you tried indult tihota

  • @avacat5092
    @avacat5092 Před rokem

    Hello friend’s 🤗 no 5 vs ysl baby cat dupes mini love ❤️

  • @Nina_80
    @Nina_80 Před rokem +1

    I live in the US. If baby cat is available only in Europe, I might pull some strings to get the perfume. If it is discontinued in the us AND eventually Europe, Im not going to get it

    • @thesimplechiclife
      @thesimplechiclife  Před rokem

      Yeah I’m not even sure of the availability in Europe, I just know it’s hard to get in the states:/ I wish it was more available

    • @chaton20
      @chaton20 Před rokem +2

      It isn’t available in Europe either.

    • @thebridewearsblack
      @thebridewearsblack Před rokem

      ​@@chaton20 yesterday I ordered a 75 ml bottle from the Spanish YSL website!

    • @mancuniamancunia9212
      @mancuniamancunia9212 Před 4 měsíci

      @@thesimplechiclifeit’s available here in the UK but not sure if Harvey Nichols ship to the states. I’ve got it in my basket for £162 which I think is cheap.

  • @Nina_80
    @Nina_80 Před rokem

    I heard (from another CZcamsr) baby cat has a metallic smell?

    • @thesimplechiclife
      @thesimplechiclife  Před rokem +2

      Not to me! Rosendo 5 definitely does. Babycat smells smooth and delicious to me 💗

  • @AmbercoolPhotography
    @AmbercoolPhotography Před rokem +1

    Guess now I gotta go to Paris for Babycat.

    • @thesimplechiclife
      @thesimplechiclife  Před rokem +1

      I just learned it is available in the USA on ScentSplit! link in description

    • @AmbercoolPhotography
      @AmbercoolPhotography Před rokem +1

      @@thesimplechiclife Yikes! So expensive though. My sister is going to visit the store in Paris this weekend so I'm going to see if she can get me one.

    • @thesimplechiclife
      @thesimplechiclife  Před rokem

      Yeah crazy how it’s literally twice the price in the states as compared to Canada!

  • @shellyannwilson2234
    @shellyannwilson2234 Před 4 měsíci +1

    I blind bought Rosendo Mateu and it made me sick when I tested it on my hand. There is a note in there that stings you and you get an upset feeling. I would gladly give it away and cut my loses.

    • @jj1106
      @jj1106 Před 16 dny

      I’ll take it! Lol

    • @shellyannwilson2234
      @shellyannwilson2234 Před 15 dny

      @@jj1106 Send me your address. I will mail it to you. Cuz I'm not using it!

  • @veenageorge59
    @veenageorge59 Před rokem +1

    Rosendo mateo smells very Synthetic. Good to know u feel the same. not tried babycat yet 😔

  • @flo16kstro
    @flo16kstro Před rokem +1

    do you enjoy Ani from nishane?

  • @aidafares9268
    @aidafares9268 Před rokem +2

    Where did you get your baby cat ?
    I had rosndu blind buy and I sold it I couldn’t handle it

  • @Mr.Cologne
    @Mr.Cologne Před 3 měsíci

    I think the number 5 that you have is incorrect trust me..

  • @Alisha-hs8xj
    @Alisha-hs8xj Před rokem +2

    To me they are nothing alike at all. I guess they both have vanilla and spices but the balance is completely different.
    I am very sensitive to the sharp, metallic saffron in the Mateu. To me it dominates and basically ruins the fragrance for me.

  • @VANITYISFARE
    @VANITYISFARE Před rokem +2

    RM5 smells like a new paved street with gas on it 🤢