Atif Aslam On His Fight With Goher Mumtaz | Best Of Rewind With Samina Peerzada |

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 11. 2019
  • Atif Aslam On His Fight With Goher Mumtaz | Best Of Rewind With Samina Peerzada |
    Fair&Lovely Presents Rewind With Samina Peerzada
    Subscribe to our channel to get latest updates and win surprise gifts bit.ly/RewindSubscribe
    Pakistan’s first ever digital talk show featuring untold stories of today’s heartthrobs and legends of the past. A roller coaster ride of emotions, as we relive the past and discover the secrets and struggles of the great names of today!
    The Show is hosted by Pakistan’s most beloved Film and Drama actress, Samina Peerzada.
    Like Us on Facebook bit.ly/SYHFB
    Follow Us on Instagram bit.ly/SpeakyourheartOfficialI...
    Log on to our Website speakyourheart.a
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 260

  • @EntertainmentDailyOfficial

    Whenever you do something, always a good idea to remember God, but how do we teach kids that? This video will help them fall in love with Bismillah: bit.ly/BismillahOmarandHana

  • @harramsalman111
    @harramsalman111 Před rokem +5

    He was honest, loyal and upright that's why he's at this position MashaAllah

  • @joinobbintejahan1674
    @joinobbintejahan1674 Před 3 lety +174

    money is the main culprits to break relationship in everywhere

  • @hasaansaeed9162
    @hasaansaeed9162 Před 3 lety +75

    Having said that, Gohar did have the better music sense just not the voice

  • @fatemakhatunnandiny2414
    @fatemakhatunnandiny2414 Před 9 měsíci +5

    Atif is honest and hardworking. He is never insecure.
    I feel Gohar is always jealous and insecure. There’s a video where Farhaan and Gohar were cursing Atif where Atif never cursed them.

  • @dreamland552
    @dreamland552 Před 3 lety +52

    Jab dil saaf ho tou you always win at the end. Story of Atif's life.

    • @burnbaltimore3901
      @burnbaltimore3901 Před 2 lety +1

      Only hustlers and thugs win in this world. History is evident either it’s Steve Bill story or Atif Gohar

  • @menaceasif
    @menaceasif Před 3 lety +26

    My god.... Listening him speak is a bliss... Calm composed honest perfect vocabulary ❤️

  • @koushiksarkar3776
    @koushiksarkar3776 Před 3 lety +38

    Miss you JAL.... From INDIA

  • @mr.lastchance
    @mr.lastchance Před 3 lety +89

    If they had been together then we would've gotten so many hits.

    • @nostalgicgammingwithshykh9781
      @nostalgicgammingwithshykh9781 Před 3 lety +2

      So True

    • @Smokester6669
      @Smokester6669 Před 3 lety +9

      Don't think Gohar wasn't talented as a singer. Jealousy got to him.

    • @vp98215
      @vp98215 Před 2 lety +6

      If they stayed together then farhan saeed would have never gotten the chance.

    • @poatan6304
      @poatan6304 Před 2 lety +2

      @@Smokester6669 he was a talented writer n Atif a talented singer. It was a great pair productivity wise

  • @Kazimpasha_
    @Kazimpasha_ Před 2 lety +13

    He knew he was right from heart
    He knew he's going places

  • @ZubairKhan-nb1tp
    @ZubairKhan-nb1tp Před 3 lety +9

    when he said kuch iss tarah ka silsala howa(2:24) mjhy kuch iss tarah song yad agaya

  • @ryanwalter482
    @ryanwalter482 Před 3 lety +31

    Samina Peerzada Queen of "Curiosity"

    • @umerjaved6315
      @umerjaved6315 Před rokem

      Hahahahahahah

    • @asifmahdi1987
      @asifmahdi1987 Před rokem

      She was a good actress during her Ptv days. Private v logging and hosting doesn't suit her.

  • @kjibinmohammad4848
    @kjibinmohammad4848 Před 3 lety +35

    he got some guts to speak so honestly about his relationship with goher.

    • @awais2585
      @awais2585 Před 3 lety +4

      A honest man would always have the courage to say the most difficult things without any fear. Especially in his case, his standing in the world of music compared to Gohar is clear to everyone so what’s to be afraid of.

  • @darsurriayaaiimsdehli4271

    Love u Aatif sir..... My favourite singer forever

  • @bilalraza4751
    @bilalraza4751 Před 2 lety +17

    Gohar wrote something similar on his website of Jal, way back in 2005 or 2007 when the song came. He wrote Atif went alone for concert, leaving me behind. I once went to attend Goher's concert. He was with Farhan. His band came late and did not perform as they had fight with school administration

    • @talhaejax8589
      @talhaejax8589 Před 2 lety

      He lied plenty of times

    • @dabeerahmed254
      @dabeerahmed254 Před měsícem

      this is the greed of money and fame i think when Atif became more famous in the band bcz of his unique voice and in general vocalist of the song get fame usually so the band members were jealous of him and this is where the fight begins starting frol Goher then Farhan and others, in the end if someone is getting more fame than you be humble and patient your time will come but respect that person first

  • @afreenkhan1470
    @afreenkhan1470 Před 2 lety +19

    I just want to say that the words were Gohar’s and the voice was Atif’s
    According to intellectual property the songs were Gohar’s. Chahe koi bhi ga le. Likha usi ney tha.

  • @mirha2513
    @mirha2513 Před 3 lety +56

    Can see the honesty in his words through his eyes ❤

    • @musawermukhtiar
      @musawermukhtiar Před 3 lety +2

      ❤️❤️❤️

    • @TheShrey88
      @TheShrey88 Před 3 lety +3

      Seems true

    • @musawermukhtiar
      @musawermukhtiar Před 3 lety +4

      @@TheShrey88 Atif is Legend he is always true, that's why he is most successful Artist today, beshak Allah jissy chahay izzat de ❤️

    • @mirha2513
      @mirha2513 Před 3 lety +3

      @@musawermukhtiar true that. Atif has fame and respect, both ❤

    • @KirtiSharma-gt2ms
      @KirtiSharma-gt2ms Před 3 lety +2

      @ Hina yes he is a legend ❤

  • @salmanahmedofficial122
    @salmanahmedofficial122 Před 3 lety +26

    Dono milke ak song banaw yrr I love addat I'm from India

  • @musicprogramfree8778
    @musicprogramfree8778 Před 3 lety +2

    Thanks for this interview

  • @myworldofdarkness4118
    @myworldofdarkness4118 Před 3 lety +7

    Atif 😍😘

  • @haseenariaz9670
    @haseenariaz9670 Před 4 lety +16

    I love you so much atif my life my world 😍💋😘😘😘

  • @TaqweemMirza1
    @TaqweemMirza1 Před 3 lety +6

    True Legend he is

  • @hamzathaheem3150
    @hamzathaheem3150 Před 3 lety +30

    Atif is so famous now, he is a superstar. But his humbleness, and yet he has forgiven them all and he has power to talk about them being guilty. But gohar didn't spoke much about Jal.

  • @harshtanoli7570
    @harshtanoli7570 Před 3 lety +3

    Legend singer jis nay all world may name kamaya

  • @ms_nawaid847
    @ms_nawaid847 Před 3 lety +22

    Gohar ko koun jaanta h but Atif ko puri duniya jaanti h ❤️

  • @syedabuhuraira9022
    @syedabuhuraira9022 Před 11 měsíci +1

    Atif Aslam ❤❤❤

  • @ms_nawaid847
    @ms_nawaid847 Před 3 lety +2

    I love him ❤️

  • @businesselves6332
    @businesselves6332 Před 2 lety +6

    Where there is greatness, there's always jealousy. But it is good, because it rids the great from the ugly. Harsh words, but this is how it works.

  • @mussawirulmohsin2141
    @mussawirulmohsin2141 Před 3 lety +3

    I love you atif aslam

  • @toywithtech
    @toywithtech Před 3 lety +39

    Well judging from his success, Atif was obviously in the right 😂

    • @killa3929
      @killa3929 Před rokem

      Bro it's kaliyuga even politicians are richer and get whatever they want while simple people are struggling for 1 time meal. 😅

  • @elphavlogs4958
    @elphavlogs4958 Před 3 lety +10

    Thats what i proud ov u atif sr

  • @iamBisma
    @iamBisma Před 3 lety +10

    Watch it in 1.75×

  • @sajidarbi7793
    @sajidarbi7793 Před 3 lety +7

    What ever it was, it’s called (naseeb) if u all believe in this..

  • @raeesahmad9692
    @raeesahmad9692 Před rokem +2

    I think we all make mistakes and we all learn from our mistakes butt the main thing is forgiveness ♥️

  • @TheMunta88
    @TheMunta88 Před 3 lety +25

    Gohar regretted it because he knew he could have been a big thing as big as atif if he was still part of the band, but he fought for little money and ruined his journey. I remember Gohar, Farhan, and Haroon were once abusing Atif for no reason.

    • @PageNo70
      @PageNo70 Před 3 lety +7

      That was a dubbed video, not real one. Atif himself knows that it was a fake.

    • @muzandyou
      @muzandyou Před 2 lety +1

      @@PageNo70 Abe jaaa Dubbing ke bachy galiyon ke saath gande gande saare bh kr rhe thy wo us video me

    • @gotahgemini6415
      @gotahgemini6415 Před 2 lety +5

      that video was definitly NOT dubbed - Gohar showed his true colors in that one. Full on insecure.

    • @Richasinghrajput23
      @Richasinghrajput23 Před 2 lety

      Can i get the link of that video plese

    • @simranvirmani3379
      @simranvirmani3379 Před rokem +1

      @@PageNo70 any proof or source,i m a huge fan of farhan but taht vid just broke my heart

  • @mr.lastchance
    @mr.lastchance Před 3 lety +4

    jo bhi hua bhool jau, sab piche chhodke sath hojau, we want the jal from 2006.

  • @danialtahir974
    @danialtahir974 Před 3 lety +55

    Man, as soon as Goher Comes first and says he regret it. He came bigger than Atif. A warm heart person

  • @mohammadfaizanmalik5572
    @mohammadfaizanmalik5572 Před 3 lety +16

    Atif is good singer and also a good person.

  • @asikulalam7043
    @asikulalam7043 Před 3 lety +1

    Atif aslam

  • @sim4cs
    @sim4cs Před 3 lety +4

    Showbiz folks have got only 2-brain cells:
    1. Fame
    2. Money
    For them to reclaim their humanity back and regrow rest of their brain cells, they need to sacrifice one of the above.

  • @mirha2513
    @mirha2513 Před 3 lety +13

    We love you Atif ❤

  • @muhammedalyy5536
    @muhammedalyy5536 Před 2 lety

    Good job

  • @asifiqbal9680
    @asifiqbal9680 Před 3 lety +4

    Atif Aslam is a legend and equally a wonderful, kind and Humble Human being.

  • @033waleed9
    @033waleed9 Před 3 lety +4

    Love you Atif Aslam 😘😘😘

  • @musawermukhtiar
    @musawermukhtiar Před 3 lety +10

    Atif is Always Right

  • @CARSANDCARS.1
    @CARSANDCARS.1 Před 4 měsíci

    Atif is now a legend nd gohar people might not know him he must be new to some people Atif is superstar bcz he was loyal to his passion ❤

  • @khadijarauf2197
    @khadijarauf2197 Před 3 lety +4

    Bachpn sy janna chah rhy thy k in dono ka kya msla h finally

  • @EntertainmentDailyOfficial

    This Ramzan we bring to you kids Islamic rhymes - watch Alhamdulillah (الحمدللہ) now, we know your kids will love it: bit.ly/AlhamdulilahOmarandHana

  • @MuhammadAmjad-ei2ou
    @MuhammadAmjad-ei2ou Před 3 lety

    Kismat hay sir

  • @adnanhaind
    @adnanhaind Před 3 lety

    Atif Aslam ✌️

  • @hifsaasghar1827
    @hifsaasghar1827 Před 3 lety +18

    Kindly u both make a video together and clear the situation

  • @tube4625
    @tube4625 Před 3 lety +5

    rangeen mizaaj log nachnay gaanay waalon main bohot interest laytay hain🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸

    • @b4real89
      @b4real89 Před 2 lety

      What is rangeen mizaaj even mean?

  • @ahmad3303
    @ahmad3303 Před 3 lety +18

    hamara kam music su na ha na k 2 singers ki ladai k peechay dono ho hate dena.....stop it

    • @alee13786
      @alee13786 Před 3 lety

      @@Farhanraja01 usny sahi baat ki hy jahil admi

  • @yasirraza3503
    @yasirraza3503 Před 3 lety +1

    yar sirf paison ki khatir itna bara music brand tabaha ho gaya ........alacccc

  • @RD-vu4yx
    @RD-vu4yx Před 3 lety +10

    💜i believe him, he have pure soul🤍atifff🤍🤍

  • @myworldofdarkness4118
    @myworldofdarkness4118 Před 3 lety +15

    Gohar mumtaj 😍

  • @EntertainmentDailyOfficial

    For the first time in Pakistan, Islamic content that your kids really need to see - Omar and Hana now in Urdu! Watch Promo now: bit.ly/OmarandHanaUrdu

  • @tanveerkhattak2498
    @tanveerkhattak2498 Před 3 lety +17

    Atif was the soul of JAL ,without him the band was never there ,Gohar became greedy and he lost it .

    • @areebhusain9505
      @areebhusain9505 Před 2 lety

      Ayyyy ayyyyy ayyyyyyy shut up Goher is better than him and Jal is better than Atif

    • @asifinet79
      @asifinet79 Před 2 lety

      It is ethically wrong

    • @QueenFlowers-ht8uk
      @QueenFlowers-ht8uk Před 2 dny +1

      Yess. Atif is better without those people. Look. He is a superstar now.

  • @arsalzaidi7346
    @arsalzaidi7346 Před 2 lety +2

    Or phir Atif ne apni pehchn bana Lee agr ye band sath hota tw hum Atif k supperhits songs se mehroom reh jate 😍😘🤩

  • @jabirahmed5182
    @jabirahmed5182 Před 3 lety +3

    I inspire you Atif Sir (from ) MiZZi Bro

  • @abrarahmed458
    @abrarahmed458 Před 3 lety +7

    Has she asked you ‘ MohObbat hui??' Yet??😂

    • @usmanarif24
      @usmanarif24 Před 2 lety

      Muhabbat hui is much better than if she asks "khatney hue??" .... she can go a little tooooo private while asking questions lol

  • @fayyazkhan3529
    @fayyazkhan3529 Před 2 lety

    Achha banda hai yeh

  • @gamesandtech8305
    @gamesandtech8305 Před 3 lety +28

    atif voice need gohar music and gohar music need atif voice
    u both are incomplete
    addat best song u guys did it together will alwayz be the best song
    i hope u guys will come together again

    • @manbro1610
      @manbro1610 Před 2 lety +1

      atif has conquered the world without Goher

    • @nokitoki9823
      @nokitoki9823 Před rokem +1

      atif needs noone kid hes the king

    • @zzz2005
      @zzz2005 Před rokem

      Agreed. They both needed each other. Atif didn’t do anything significant after Gohar and him went separate ways. Atif sang songs for movies and other composers but nothing for and by himself..

  • @asikulalam7043
    @asikulalam7043 Před 3 lety +2

    World best handsome boy

  • @hasanshahriardiptodipto5179

    Goher Mumtaj is the founder of jal. Goher
    created Jal, all songs of Jal. And gave Atif this platform.

  • @uyfhfhykgjfjkjgjfjdhg4816

    yasir ali atif aslam songs

  • @mannmadrosiya750
    @mannmadrosiya750 Před 3 lety +1

    Ok but ye video is channel ka nahi he phir bhi itne advertise kyu.. so plz kisi ke channel ke views mat khao yrr or khao to free ad rakho ok!

  • @ghanchiidrish7934
    @ghanchiidrish7934 Před 2 lety +2

    Actually u should require again together for once again and alive #Jaltheband... actually it needed ❤️❤️

  • @syedfaiqali1
    @syedfaiqali1 Před 3 lety +6

    Breaking of band is always good for industry. We have several examples, one direction, NSync, fifth harmony, vital signs...

  • @SmartTechCAMP
    @SmartTechCAMP Před 3 lety +2

    He look lile imad waseem, or vise versa

  • @naimmalik1867
    @naimmalik1867 Před 4 lety +9

    Watching from UK 🇬🇧 London 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧 sad story if it’s true tho.

  • @Talkashu1
    @Talkashu1 Před 3 lety +66

    Goher is the actual writer and creator. Atif basically took his songs away

  • @obaidkniazi
    @obaidkniazi Před 3 lety +17

    Fame and money are double edge swords, "mazza Aye ga" element keeps friends together until money isn't involved and you had a marketing boy involved so you were clearly not doing it for fun itself you knew well how to guard your interests.. you were either too naive/immature if you thought otherwise or straight up lying a.s.a.t.
    Its that situation when you know you have a great voice and only need one chance or have a rich guy as friend who funds everything until you have a hit and bam you are off. You could be a great businessman too, or you are nvm!

  • @cinephile13admirer
    @cinephile13admirer Před 3 lety +6

    Atif ke chehre pe aur uske bolne ke andaaz sai pata chal rha hai ke kahi nah kahi yeh miss karta hai apne band ko
    Aur ke yeh Sach bol rha hai

  • @motivational6061
    @motivational6061 Před 3 lety +3

    Heeran kahtoon 😂
    Samina khatoon😲😮😲😮

  • @somaiyarahman5424
    @somaiyarahman5424 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Gohar ke ego ki wajase atif aur uska jhagra hua aur bich me farhan fas geya 🙂

  • @muhammad5550
    @muhammad5550 Před 3 lety +36

    I watch both interview (Atif and gohar) my conclusion is Atif is guilty and playing game, %100000

    • @uzairut914
      @uzairut914 Před 3 lety +5

      @Ali Dar Ap wahan Cake kaat rahy thy ya candles ko phoonk marahy thy?? Bhai agar serious hy tou proove it

    • @hotnews3283
      @hotnews3283 Před 3 lety +2

      @@uzairut914 prove tu atif b nai kar paya 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @saqibzia197
      @saqibzia197 Před rokem +1

      Atif is not guilty...ghoar is cheater

  • @PageNo70
    @PageNo70 Před 3 lety +28

    Whenever I see Atif's interviews He seems so insecure of his position. It's fishy, Why? Goher seems confident with what He has achieved but seems bitter. Only Farhan Saeed seems confident, content, satisfied and more sensible than both Goher and Atif.

    • @umerjavednisar
      @umerjavednisar Před 3 lety +1

      Farhan came when Atif left

    • @PageNo70
      @PageNo70 Před 3 lety +11

      @@umerjavednisar I know that Farhan was introduced to Goher by Call band members when Atif left for India. That is not what I am saying I am saying that Atif wanted a big break and he got that when he went to India, he doesn't need to be insecure, he should be the most confident one but he is not confident, he is insecure(as if his status can be lost).
      See on the other hand Goher is confident but bitter(rightfully so cause Atif did steal is compositions and lyrics).
      Then there is Farhan Saeed the most confident, carefree and satisfied of the 3. If you think it through Farhan suffered the most in these 3, was dragged into a fight that wasn't his in the first place, was hated by Atif fans unjustly(that he himself methodically converted into love for him by being better), he continuously had to prove himself. Yet that man(Farhan Saeed) channels most secure attitude out of these 3.

    • @faizanzahid553
      @faizanzahid553 Před 3 lety +2

      @@PageNo70 the accusations ur pointing on atif of stealing composition then u should watch there interviews in which gohar himself said that atif and him made the composition of adat
      So regarding compositions they both worked on it its not right to say that that belongs to only gohar or atif
      The fact is that the public choosed atif more due to his iconic adat voice and india exposure and his versions got massive hit

    • @umerjavednisar
      @umerjavednisar Před 3 lety +4

      @@faizanzahid553 jal has a unique style. I can tell if a song is written by Jal just by listening to it even if I have not heard it before. Its not the case with Atif. Gohar has magic in his hands. Atif has a great voice. They are both good at what they do.

    • @gotahgemini6415
      @gotahgemini6415 Před 2 lety

      Not at all, where are you reading any insecurity? To me he came across as confident and clear. If you look at one of Gohars uploaded videos from the early days he was so insecure after splitting with Atif that he was cussing, and raising the middle finger, and saying ugly things to Atif. Gohar was just being a bully, which insecure ppl do. It's pitiful. Atif on the other hand, has never stooped so low.

  • @firstvideo6339
    @firstvideo6339 Před 3 lety +14

    @4:30 , hikmat kehti hai k dono taraf k reasons sun kar hi fesla dena chaie, mene atif ki bat suni gohar k bare main, but gohar ki abhi tak nahi suni, but kehna to nahi chaie lekin gohar shakal se or body language se bazahir bht jealous or ajeeb sa banda lagta hai. But this is only my point of view. Haqeeqat Allah janta hai.

    • @Talha_Sardar
      @Talha_Sardar Před 3 lety +7

      Shakal aur huliye se kisi insan k bare mn apni raye qaim krna sb se bro jahalat h..🙄

    • @firstvideo6339
      @firstvideo6339 Před 3 lety +2

      @@Talha_Sardar No shakal, no hulya... I said "body language"!!!

    • @izzahnadeem4791
      @izzahnadeem4791 Před 3 lety +2

      never judge a book by its cover , we should listen both sides

    • @lightofeyezz
      @lightofeyezz Před 2 lety

      You're soo right about listening to both sides.

    • @adibutt1171
      @adibutt1171 Před rokem

      Ap aesa kro Junaid Akram ki podcast Aya hay gohar k Sath us may gohar ne apni side se story bhi btai hay wo Suno must phr yahan reply kro apko Kya Laga..

  • @khawajanabeel6703
    @khawajanabeel6703 Před 2 lety +2

    V shameful Atif u should no say that about your colleague if u r speaking truth

  • @iamBisma
    @iamBisma Před 3 lety +12

    Gohar was clearly insecure , It is very much evdient from this conversation..Because Atif's vocals , looks and overall personality used to stand out while they were a band, hence overshadowing the other two.

    • @sarat8577
      @sarat8577 Před 2 lety +1

      But let’s give credit where it is due. Gohar wrote and composed adat. These guys were kids at the time and not mature. They have come a long way.

    • @talhaejax8589
      @talhaejax8589 Před 2 lety

      @@sarat8577 give it's not enough for him now

    • @QueenFlowers-ht8uk
      @QueenFlowers-ht8uk Před 2 dny +1

      ​@@sarat8577Atif has contributed to the lyrics of aadat and Woh lamhe

  • @yebataodanish
    @yebataodanish Před 3 lety +7

    Best part 8:30

  • @sajidhussainmemon2520
    @sajidhussainmemon2520 Před 3 lety +8

    I think gohar is inocent

    • @atifmunawarhussain8245
      @atifmunawarhussain8245 Před 3 lety

      Think Farhan did all this

    • @PageNo70
      @PageNo70 Před 3 lety +3

      @@atifmunawarhussain8245 Dude Farhan joined Jal 3-4 months after Atif left Jal and went to India, Farhan had never met Atif in person until 2015/1016. Farhan didn't even know anything about the rift between Goher/Atif, He got to all this when Jal's and Atif's album had same songs. Farhan was dragged into their fight without having any part in it. This thing is even vouched by most of the bands from that time specially Call band who were mostly Farhan's seniors form his university, even Goher admits that Farhan was the innocent victim of his Atif rivilary.

  • @potatofiesgaming4576
    @potatofiesgaming4576 Před 3 lety +1

    Hamesha ek side ki bat sun k faisla ni krna chahiye

  • @_plastikman
    @_plastikman Před 3 lety +1

    basically Goher is very greedy person no wonder his band is not around anymore

  • @smashrafulislam729
    @smashrafulislam729 Před 3 lety +3

    Jal =Atif/Goher?
    Jal=Goher. ...

  • @kidscorner8009
    @kidscorner8009 Před 2 lety +1

    But Jal had us😪

  • @thetegan808
    @thetegan808 Před 2 lety +20

    It's hard to believe him. This side of story is not at all convincing.

  • @Abdulrazzaq-nu6ti
    @Abdulrazzaq-nu6ti Před 2 lety

    Ye kia host hai

  • @hassanwali9947
    @hassanwali9947 Před 3 lety +12

    the thing is
    " you still can't hate goher" He is love

  • @LA-tf2gp
    @LA-tf2gp Před 3 lety +4

    issko urdu bholl ghai ? sawal in urdu jawab in english...

  • @fahadjavaid7336
    @fahadjavaid7336 Před 3 lety +1

    Aatif kibqismat mai tha behter aur mukhtalif musicians ke saath kaam karna.

  • @smashrafulislam729
    @smashrafulislam729 Před 3 lety +19

    I think Goher Momtaj is the real hero of the jal band...
    So Atif Aslam is really wrong...

  • @Mageroth
    @Mageroth Před 3 lety +7

    Gohar was and is Multi-Talented at Singing/Composing/Guitarist and furthermost he has humbleness also he produces new stuff...
    Atif.. is a one trick Pony, however great that trick that may be (his Voice and Maybe Aadat on Guitar) which i agree is better than Farhan and Gohar, but that is his limit, that is why you only first saw him running to India for Bollywood gigs, but when Pak-India relations went sour he started making money by playing old songs at Coke studios... basically no new stuff.
    In my personal Opinion.. Atif wanted to cash in foreign gigs when they were not well groomed, and Gohar realized it and was waiting for the right time.. but Atif wanted the cash quick!

    • @hrishikesh07m
      @hrishikesh07m Před 3 lety +3

      baat aisa nehi hai. pyar hum india waale Gohar se bhi karte hai. infact Jal band was a huge hit and a cult following back then. school parties mein table bajake humlog jal hi gaate the. aatif to bad mein aaya. movies ke trhough.

    • @PageNo70
      @PageNo70 Před 3 lety +4

      I agree with you on most points except one Aadat was sung better by Farhan(it was musically accurate, proper sur, proper rythm proper flow), Atif only plus there is that he sang it first and sold it to India.
      As for Goher Vs Atif, you are right Atif wanted quick cash and quick fame. In those time every band in Pakistan was against what Atif did, 1st because it tarnished Pakistan music scene in the eyes of whole world and 2nd because it was unethical to sell someone else's hardwork with his own name. Some bands even helped Goher start his band again by introducing Farhan Saeed as a vocalist to him, which to me speaks volumes in Goher's favor because no one would bring an innocent kid of 18(Farhan Saeed at that time) into such a huge mess if Goher was in the wrong.

    • @usmanarif24
      @usmanarif24 Před 2 lety

      @@PageNo70 very well analyzed...

  • @mussawirulmohsin2141
    @mussawirulmohsin2141 Před 3 lety +11

    Gohar ko sharam aani chaye itnii badi baat keh di l hate gohar

  • @1989kratoz
    @1989kratoz Před 3 lety +6

    Only Gohar.... never cared about Atif..

  • @imranmbp
    @imranmbp Před 3 lety +4

    He is hiding the truth

  • @sherryghouri1997
    @sherryghouri1997 Před 3 lety +8

    Atif’s expressions says it all, he’s lieng, seems guilty. On the other hand Goher sounds genuine. ☝🏽

  • @kayzeefuzee1373
    @kayzeefuzee1373 Před 3 lety +50

    His body language says that he is guilty.

    • @1989kratoz
      @1989kratoz Před 3 lety +10

      Exaclty...

    • @PageNo70
      @PageNo70 Před 3 lety +10

      He is, but He can't escape what he himself started, so he has to lie again and again or else his whole career might crumble.I have always noticed him being insecure in his place.

    • @legendofnothing1
      @legendofnothing1 Před 3 lety +2

      if he was Gohar would have immediately responded. And this is not the first time this story came out. There is no counter version ever presented by Gohar.

    • @PageNo70
      @PageNo70 Před 3 lety +4

      @@legendofnothing1 A lie has to be repeated again and again. Goher gave a counter and true explanation once and that was enough for Goher to say it once. And Atif here is making accusations while Goher just gave an account of what happened without accusing anyone. When you are right you don't have to accuse others.

    • @legendofnothing1
      @legendofnothing1 Před 3 lety +4

      @@PageNo70 oh come on, unless you are Gohar himself or a Jal member, you can't be sure either. My gut feeling goes with Atif's version, but Allah knows the best.

  • @samadshaikh3395
    @samadshaikh3395 Před 3 lety +1

    #atifaslam 😘😘😘 mein agar sach par khada hu. To mera jo kaam h wo bolenga😘