Ishmael or Isaac? Which son was Abraham (pbut) about to sacrifice? | Dr. Shabir Ally answers
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 09. 2024
- Dr. Shabir Ally holds a B.A. in Religious Studies from Laurentian University in Sudbury, Ontario, with a specialization in Biblical Literature, an M.A. in Religious Studies from the University of Toronto with a specialization in Quranic Exegesis and a PhD studies in Quranic Exegesis at the University of Toronto.
Dr. Shabir is the founder of the Islamic Information and Da'wah Centre in Toronto, Canada.
He's the author of the book " Is Jesus God? The Bible Says No ! "
#ShabirAlly #Ishmael #Isaac #SacrificedSon #Sacrifice #ProphetAbraham #ProphetIbrahim #Allah #Mercy #Quran #Islam #Christianity #Bible #NewTestament #OldTestament #Scripture #Commandment #Commandments #AlAdha #EidAlAdha #Torah #Tanakh #Sacrificing #Prophets #Prophet #Eid #Son #Jew #Jews #Talmud #Scriptures #Gospels #Gospel #Philosophy #Theology #Islam @MuslimByChoice
Mashahallah very well explained ❤
وَعَلَيْكُمْا لسَّلاَمُ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ
My dear teacher
The soup 🥣 part gets me every time
if it is not Ismael why we called Ismael Zabiullah ?
Out of our love to God, muslims love all of His prophets equally Ishmael& Isaac PBU them both. But if others insist on denigrating one of Abrahams sons, then Islam challanges all bible believers by correcting the bible edited sacrifice story.
If you believe in bible, this is a challenge for you from bible itself:
Since his parents were promised by God before the birth of Isaac that he shall be multiplied& kings from his off spring according to Genesis 17:17& 17:19, then were is the sacrifice or any test at all in Abraham taking Isaac to the slaughter, when he already knew Isaac shall live to make him grandchildren?
We know you cannot answer this obvious forgery by the scribes in what used to be holy scripture, changing the name of Abrahams only son for 14 yrs as the logical sacrifice son, as per the Torah principle in Gods promise being always with your eldest son even if you hated his mother for those who married 2 wives according to Deut 21:15. The Noble Quran not only corrects that bible corruption, the Noble Quran brings back what was deleted from bible: The belief in the concept of an afterlife- totally eliminated from the Jewish bible (1st five books). May be these people don't want to return to see God!
To know God is to love Him and want to go back to God& meet Him in the afterlife- enter His house- paradise
What's worse for christianity in particular, is that the writer of NT Hebrews 11:17 links the sacrifice of Jesus on the cross to that of his father Isaac, which is a forgery. Hence Jesus was never crucified.
Therefore, read the Book of God, the Noble Quran instead of corrupted books men who don't want to meet God messed with& took out the belief in the afterlife from it, that bible leads not to God but to loss for eternity, sadly
I'm not convinced that God told Abraham that
Dear Sir, I am muslim but this story is still confusing. Does this mean that God ordered Abraham to sacrifice his baby son and then after that Abraham drives Hagar and the baby into the desert after Sarah has Isaac. Wouldn't that be cruel. I really want to understand. AdHa Mubarak
First of all, in both Christianity and Islam, the sacrifice was offered after Hagar left Abraham's house. According to the Bible, the son Isaac was offered to be sacrificed after Hagar was expelled from Abraham's house. In Islam, according to Quran 37:102, the child offered for sacrifice is between the ages of 7-13. As reported in Bukhari 3365, it says that Hagar was a nursing baby when she took her son with her to exile, which means that Ismael migrated to the Arab land when he was a child, and when he was older, he was offered to sacrifice. Therefore, it is clear that the event of sacrifice in Christianity and Islam is after the expulsion of Hagar.
Read Genesis.