I would totally be on Team Shane from the start. First off he got it it took Rick till Season 3 to understand people were worse then the Zombies I blame that on being in a Coma unlike Shane who seen the military shoot civilians and drop Napalm on them in the streets. Shane actually was way ahead of everyone including Darrell it took them a lot longer to realize you had to kill people to protect the others the world had changed. If Shane was alive still today he would be one of the leaders period & hell Lori , Carl and even Andrea might all be alive still.
Rick killed people in season 2 to keep Hershel and Glen safe. Negan kept people alive and he was dominant for a long time and probably would have been if he treated the other communities better.
Why shane? Shane didn't even know how to attract them. Rick told him to follow to pashin of killing them. Shane disagreed bc he thought there was a cure. Rick taught Shane to out a cut in you're hand to make the walkers follow. Shane told Rick he would send walkers after Carl and Rick and the others, he put threats up to them. There for Rick killed him now there blood on his hands..
@@cartmankewl2335 if you listen to one of jon bernthals interviews he explains that shane litterary gave himself up and wanted rick to kill him to see if rick could kill to protect his family ....it was planned to show a scene were rick looks at shanes magazine only to realize shane didnt have any bullets loaded meaning he didnt want to kill rick
I really like that idea but when Rick stabbed Shane, Shane’s gun let off a bullet so he did have a bullet in their. But the writers probably changed it so that the herd would then be drawn to them and I also still think Shane wanted Rick to kill him so he’d prove himself. I also don’t think Shane could live with the fact that he couldn’t have a family the way he wanted to even though Judith was his daughter.
@Jonathan Landeros And in later seasons Rick became the exact same as Shane. When you actually look back at it he did nothing wrong. Even wanting to kill Randal was the right thing to do.
He assaulted Lori and tried to kill his best friend for his wife. It was either his way or the highway, he argued with everyone who disagreed with him.He definitely wasn’t a good person
I really wanted Shane to leave the group as he planned to. Imagine TDog and Andrea going with him and then appearing in season 6 when Negan was introduced. Rick would see that Shane could keep themselves alive for years. That would be the real Shane
Zᴀʙɪx Overall he was a good guy. He just lost it due to the fact that he loved Lori and Carl and they both left him to return to Rick. He was basically alone in the scariest time of his life. I'm SUPER against rape and cheating, but I wouldn't say that incident makes him a bad person. I'm not saying it's entirely justified, and still a horrific act, but that one act doesn't suddenly make him a bad person. I would say all of his mistakes boil down to that--the loss of Lori and Carl. When he pointed his gun at Rick, it was a chance to take Lori and Carl back, same with when he tried to kill Rick. When he shot Otis it was so he could guarantee he was going to live so he could get back to Lori and Carl. Obviously these are all nasty acts, but they're all somewhat justified when you take into account that he's losing his sanity in a post apocalyptic world. Everything else he did was to ensure the safety of the group, and that's what makes him an overall good person.
I hated when Hershel attacked Shane with we haven't even dealt with what you did at the barn! Okay I think personally Shane should of said your right & we haven't dealt with the fact you had our little girl locked in it either!
Jay Bird yeah true but it would still been a good come back ,put everyone in silence and put the audience in a position where people would feel like "yeah.. Shane might be right since the beginning"
Shane all the way I wish he was still in this series. To be honest in the first season he said he could protect Lori better than Rick. Lori did end up dying Shane would have went in there guns blazing to get her out of there. Maybe the show could have had him and Andrea become a couple .
@@Crittttt Otis was a sacrifice for a more important survivor, Sophia was with Rick when she disappeared, and Dale.. Well Shane would've probably killed Dale himself 😂
Rick was delusional in those times , he wanted to adapt to hersel rules that were gonna get everybody killed, sadly Rick had to ALOT of people to realise things, to not take chances with strangers, Shane always saw things right, the fans of walking say that Shane was ahead of his time but no.. they were all late amd almost all of them here is dead because of it
Shane was egoist and too competitive. That's why he lost it. You cant be mean towards your teammates especially heavy ones. Like he should be more positive towards Rick. Cuz he was the key player in the team. Imagine you go lost and the team leader is Shane. You re basically dead. I would choose Rick cuz he will do everything to find me. He is the man that you want as a leader. He will protect you. He won't kill you whenever he got cornered by walkers. Shane definitely will.
Team Shane a hundred percent but Rick needs to be around because without him Shane could never build alliances with other groups Shane needs Rick Rick is the rightful leader but Shane is the right one to protect the group Shane was Rick's right hand man his Yin to his yang ☯️ they need each other Rick is always getting the group into dangerous situations that could've been avoided such as 1) attacking the governor first 2) attacking the satellite station first 3) living with walkers in the barn 4) bringing enemies into the camp If Shane was still around none of this would've happened but the show probably would've sucked The true villain of the first 2 seasons was Lori because she caused everything to go wrong
Team Shane sans hésiter, il est facile de voir que les choix de Shane sont guidés par la seule volonté de protéger tous le monde, il est sincèrement impliqué auprès de tous le monde sans pour autant les mettre en danger, il prend toujours les décision, même les plus difficiles parfois, dans l'intérêt de tous. Rick n'a depuis le départ causé par extension que des pertes inutiles qu'elles soient humaines ou matérielles, bien sur une fois Shane hors jeu, plus le choix. Shane est peut-être dur mais malgré le rejet parfois injuste de tous il a toujours fais les choix qui sauvent des vies pas qui les risquent.
I have to disagree mainly because Shane definitely wasn’t a good person and she tried convincing people that the governor was good and died because of her wrong doings
Rick all the way he doesn't kill strangers for no reason even if Randal shot at him he still provided hasptality shane was only survival of the fittest if Lori never existed shane would be in season 10 so it's safe to say that rick is a good person if someone says he's not then why would he keep Randal he didn't want to kill him he just wanted to exile him and if he wasn't a good person why did he blow up the bridge? He died for his people and saved 3 communities if any says that rick is dumb oh please I would like to see you try
Jay Bird you're right... you're absolutely fucking right... Shane wouldn't have gotten them to the prison... m'ask you something Jay... what happened to the group since arriving to the prison? answer me what happened to Lori, T Dog, Herschel, Andrea what happened man? I thought Rick was the good leader? Shane's a better leader than Rick!
Team rick! Shane was out of control. Shane knew how to think in a apocalypse but he was totally crazy. You couldn’t predict him he could do anything. Team rick 100%
2,916,494 views of course, Rick was delusional in those times , he wanted to adapt to hersel rules that were gonna get everybody killed, sadly Rick had to ALOT of people to realise things, to not take chances with strangers, Shane always saw things right, the fans of walking say that Shane was ahead of his time but no.. they were all late amd almost all of them here is dead because of it
I am pretty sure Rick got almost every killed already but a few people, Shane was leader none were killed till after Rick came back took charge let me say that again no one died under Shane leadership until after Rick woke up! Shane was about keeping the group safe and alive everyone else outside the group don't matter reason simple he didn't trust anyone else because of the military going threw the hospital and shooting civilians. Go back and watch it he left Rick after he thought he was dead he couldn't hear a heart beat and the military was going threw the hospital killing people he hid bye Rick. The man just understood it before everyone else then Daryl, Andrea and Carrol got it even Carrol killed 2 sick people to protect the group seriously that was way worse then Shane shooting Otis and leaving him for bait to save Carl. Otis was a outsider who shot Carl and Carrol killed two of there group to save people. Daryl kills anyone that oppose the group and so does Rick now hell they all do including Maggie who I am 100% sure wishes Shane was there perhaps to stop Negan from bashing in GLEN HEAD!
@@dalelapointe9289 That’s because Shane never left the barn. You can’t say he didn’t get people killed when he hardly did anything except get into arguments with people. Rick was actually out doing things for the group
I would totally be on Team Shane from the start. First off he got it it took Rick till Season 3 to understand people were worse then the Zombies I blame that on being in a Coma unlike Shane who seen the military shoot civilians and drop Napalm on them in the streets. Shane actually was way ahead of everyone including Darrell it took them a lot longer to realize you had to kill people to protect the others the world had changed. If Shane was alive still today he would be one of the leaders period & hell Lori , Carl and even Andrea might all be alive still.
Rick killed people in season 2 to keep Hershel and Glen safe. Negan kept people alive and he was dominant for a long time and probably would have been if he treated the other communities better.
Why shane? Shane didn't even know how to attract them. Rick told him to follow to pashin of killing them. Shane disagreed bc he thought there was a cure. Rick taught Shane to out a cut in you're hand to make the walkers follow. Shane told Rick he would send walkers after Carl and Rick and the others, he put threats up to them. There for Rick killed him now there blood on his hands..
then how come Shane didn't have what it took to kill rick I agree with you but how come he couldnot kill rick
@@cartmankewl2335 if you listen to one of jon bernthals interviews he explains that shane litterary gave himself up and wanted rick to kill him to see if rick could kill to protect his family ....it was planned to show a scene were rick looks at shanes magazine only to realize shane didnt have any bullets loaded meaning he didnt want to kill rick
I really like that idea but when Rick stabbed Shane, Shane’s gun let off a bullet so he did have a bullet in their. But the writers probably changed it so that the herd would then be drawn to them and I also still think Shane wanted Rick to kill him so he’d prove himself. I also don’t think Shane could live with the fact that he couldn’t have a family the way he wanted to even though Judith was his daughter.
Team Shane. Before Rick showed up and when Shane was in charge, nobody had died. Shane had the perfect mindset for the apocalypse
@Jonathan Landeros I don't think so. He evolved really quickly. He probably would've realized at some point they have to move.
@Jonathan Landeros And in later seasons Rick became the exact same as Shane. When you actually look back at it he did nothing wrong. Even wanting to kill Randal was the right thing to do.
Ok nothing wrong ? ... so attempted rape on lori isn’t bad . trying to kill ur bestfriend so u can sleep with his wife isn’t bad ?
@@kali4568 Didn't Rick do the exact same thing when he showed up at Alexandria to Pete?
Ok pete was a woman beater and a drunk . and even tho rick was a bit crazy at that point he still had his reasons .
If Shane was alive - Rick, Glenn, Andrea, T-dog, merle, Abraham, Hershel, Beth, carl and Sasha would have still been alive
Well, rick wouldn't be alive. Rick would of all ready killed him
Shane comeback on season 9
I hope so man, I really really hope so
He's dead
@@tuckerb3259 Or a Vision like they did with Lori, When she died
@@RaaaAuti yeah that would be cool
@@tuckerb3259 Andrew Lincoln/ The Actor for Rick. is planning on leaving the Walking dead, So it would only make sense if he seen Shane one last time.
What saddens me the most is that most of these guys r gone!😢
They're all gone, including Rick
@@thelegacyofgaming2928 Carol's not gone.
Shane isn't the bad guy all he`s trying to do is keep the group alive but half the group thinks he's the bad guy
He assaulted Lori and tried to kill his best friend for his wife. It was either his way or the highway, he argued with everyone who disagreed with him.He definitely wasn’t a good person
@@SmallShowsTv sorry you don't understand shane
@@SmallShowsTv i dont think you understand shane
@@SmallShowsTv You're right, but these people are not very bright
I really wanted Shane to leave the group as he planned to. Imagine TDog and Andrea going with him and then appearing in season 6 when Negan was introduced. Rick would see that Shane could keep themselves alive for years. That would be the real Shane
Much better than Shane dying, Andrea becoming a terrible character, and T-Dog having ZERO lines...
@@thelegacyofgaming2928 you are right man
I miss him.😢He was a good guy
RIP. Shane❤❤❤
TWD Fan Love good guy? Yeah because even though shane almost raped Lori that makes him a good guy yeah your so right 😂
Zᴀʙɪx 👌
Zᴀʙɪx Overall he was a good guy. He just lost it due to the fact that he loved Lori and Carl and they both left him to return to Rick. He was basically alone in the scariest time of his life. I'm SUPER against rape and cheating, but I wouldn't say that incident makes him a bad person. I'm not saying it's entirely justified, and still a horrific act, but that one act doesn't suddenly make him a bad person. I would say all of his mistakes boil down to that--the loss of Lori and Carl. When he pointed his gun at Rick, it was a chance to take Lori and Carl back, same with when he tried to kill Rick. When he shot Otis it was so he could guarantee he was going to live so he could get back to Lori and Carl. Obviously these are all nasty acts, but they're all somewhat justified when you take into account that he's losing his sanity in a post apocalyptic world. Everything else he did was to ensure the safety of the group, and that's what makes him an overall good person.
Deception Wow I don’t really like him though
the wall how do you mean this?
I hated when Hershel attacked Shane with we haven't even dealt with what you did at the barn! Okay I think personally Shane should of said your right & we haven't dealt with the fact you had our little girl locked in it either!
Jay Bird yeah true but it would still been a good come back ,put everyone in silence and put the audience in a position where people would feel like "yeah.. Shane might be right since the beginning"
this made me miss Shane even more, he would have been such a great character
Shane 100%. Rick was a mess, is a mess. Shane was the man, he tried to keep them alive, but nooooo
Shane tried to kill Rick... You're living in fantasy land
Team Shane sempre, saudades!
TEAM SHANE!
-Time to face the facts old man,that your nothing without her.
Negan-🏏
team Shane is better than team Rick. Always
I felt bad for Shane. Dale, Hershel, Patricia, Daryl, Maggie, Glenn, Jimmy, and Beth, all hated him.
Shane all the way I wish he was still in this series. To be honest in the first season he said he could protect Lori better than Rick. Lori did end up dying Shane would have went in there guns blazing to get her out of there. Maybe the show could have had him and Andrea become a couple .
Shane! Even carl is trained by Shane.
TEAM SHANE!!!!
Awesome vid man!
People said Shane was crazy but he was right
Everyone knows shane was a better leader every person that shane had all the survivors safe.
nope
What about Otis or Shopia or Dale
@@Crittttt
Otis was a sacrifice for a more important survivor, Sophia was with Rick when she disappeared, and Dale.. Well Shane would've probably killed Dale himself 😂
@@sebasdurden9274 none of that is even a good argument
@@Crittttt
Dale even says in one of the episodes that Shane sacrificed Otis. And Sophia was definitely with Rick when she got took. So what else?
Team Shane
Rick was delusional in those times , he wanted to adapt to hersel rules that were gonna get everybody killed, sadly Rick had to ALOT of people to realise things, to not take chances with strangers, Shane always saw things right, the fans of walking say that Shane was ahead of his time but no.. they were all late amd almost all of them here is dead because of it
Ever since rick came everyone good died
Best vdo
Shane Walsh lost it after Rick came back but I still liked him
Team shane
#teamrick
I like rick, but Shane was ready for the world and how it was.
Also wanted his best friends wife and to kill him so there's that
Saudade Shane.
Shane was egoist and too competitive. That's why he lost it. You cant be mean towards your teammates especially heavy ones. Like he should be more positive towards Rick. Cuz he was the key player in the team. Imagine you go lost and the team leader is Shane. You re basically dead. I would choose Rick cuz he will do everything to find me. He is the man that you want as a leader. He will protect you. He won't kill you whenever he got cornered by walkers. Shane definitely will.
Shane
Shane not dead
Yes he is Carl shot him
@Nico_Medina SK he’s a soul cause he got shot dead
Team rick 🔥🔥🔥
Team Shane a hundred percent but Rick needs to be around because without him Shane could never build alliances with other groups Shane needs Rick Rick is the rightful leader but Shane is the right one to protect the group
Shane was Rick's right hand man his Yin to his yang ☯️ they need each other Rick is always getting the group into dangerous situations that could've been avoided such as
1) attacking the governor first
2) attacking the satellite station first
3) living with walkers in the barn
4) bringing enemies into the camp
If Shane was still around none of this would've happened but the show probably would've sucked
The true villain of the first 2 seasons was Lori because she caused everything to go wrong
Team Shane sans hésiter, il est facile de voir que les choix de Shane sont guidés par la seule volonté de protéger tous le monde, il est sincèrement impliqué auprès de tous le monde sans pour autant les mettre en danger, il prend toujours les décision, même les plus difficiles parfois, dans l'intérêt de tous. Rick n'a depuis le départ causé par extension que des pertes inutiles qu'elles soient humaines ou matérielles, bien sur une fois Shane hors jeu, plus le choix. Shane est peut-être dur mais malgré le rejet parfois injuste de tous il a toujours fais les choix qui sauvent des vies pas qui les risquent.
Andrea was right about Shane, despite her being a little stupid a lot of the times
😂🤔
I have to disagree mainly because Shane definitely wasn’t a good person and she tried convincing people that the governor was good and died because of her wrong doings
Well, from season 5 to 8 Rick is team shane
no, Shane is a badass, but not so smart like Rick. With Shane the group would be dead in middle of season 3
Rip Shane
TEAM SHAAAANE
Rick all the way he doesn't kill strangers for no reason even if Randal shot at him he still provided hasptality shane was only survival of the fittest if Lori never existed shane would be in season 10 so it's safe to say that rick is a good person if someone says he's not then why would he keep Randal he didn't want to kill him he just wanted to exile him and if he wasn't a good person why did he blow up the bridge? He died for his people and saved 3 communities if any says that rick is dumb oh please I would like to see you try
Cough 8x14
@@idontknowwhattoputformyuse1104 *Cough* his son died so he didn't give a fck at that time
@@idontknowwhattoputformyuse1104 Except those guys had already tried to run back to the Saviors AND had contemplated taking them to Negan, so no.
Team Rick
Jay Bird you're right... you're absolutely fucking right... Shane wouldn't have gotten them to the prison... m'ask you something Jay... what happened to the group since arriving to the prison? answer me what happened to Lori, T Dog, Herschel, Andrea what happened man? I thought Rick was the good leader? Shane's a better leader than Rick!
Jay Bird where's Carl, man?
@kieron spiteri fuck Shane
Why couldnt Rick and Hershell convince Shane for what they tried to do at barn.
Rick was very naive in season 2. Shane in season 2 was what Rick became in season 4/5
Team Shane of course 🥰🥰🥰
#TeamRick
Yes sir
#TeamShane
Team rick! Shane was out of control. Shane knew how to think in a apocalypse but he was totally crazy. You couldn’t predict him he could do anything. Team rick 100%
Exactly. Having someone that hostile and unpredictable is NOT good for leadership
Shane 😥 Rember Him? 😥😥😥
Jay Bird so are the rest of the group that Rick led to the prison
Team Rick!
Always Rick
Up
Shane😓
Shane era foda ...
Iae brasileiro kkkk
Queria que o Shane ficasse vivo, eles poderiam adaptar mais esse personagem
@@Joaozx14 same :(
Rick
#teamshaneforever
I like Shane but I prefer rick
#TeamRick
Youtoo_ _YTB team shane
team rick
Go with team shane 👍
Team rick
Shane was a great man but to far gone cause of lori
Team Rick all the way!
Team Shane rick got everyone killed also dale was annoying I loved Hershel but still team Shane:)
Dale was one of the best characters...He wanted to keep his humanity and not give in to the world they live in...you can't blame him
To fora
Team Shane he wanted everyone to be safe
Except Rick 😂
There’s no way t dog would be on team shane
That’s true
He was with the barn. But overall I'm sure he knew Rick was a better leader
@@thelegacyofgaming2928 daryl and glenn were also with the barn
Team Shane Fur sure!!!!!
2,916,494 views of course, Rick was delusional in those times , he wanted to adapt to hersel rules that were gonna get everybody killed, sadly Rick had to ALOT of people to realise things, to not take chances with strangers, Shane always saw things right, the fans of walking say that Shane was ahead of his time but no.. they were all late amd almost all of them here is dead because of it
Team Shane for early seasons Team rick for the rest bc Shane died lmao
Honestly team Rick Shane is awesome in all but Rick is a better leader if Shane was alive he would have gotten him and the group killed
I am pretty sure Rick got almost every killed already but a few people, Shane was leader none were killed till after Rick came back took charge let me say that again no one died under Shane leadership until after Rick woke up! Shane was about keeping the group safe and alive everyone else outside the group don't matter reason simple he didn't trust anyone else because of the military going threw the hospital and shooting civilians. Go back and watch it he left Rick after he thought he was dead he couldn't hear a heart beat and the military was going threw the hospital killing people he hid bye Rick. The man just understood it before everyone else then Daryl, Andrea and Carrol got it even Carrol killed 2 sick people to protect the group seriously that was way worse then Shane shooting Otis and leaving him for bait to save Carl. Otis was a outsider who shot Carl and Carrol killed two of there group to save people. Daryl kills anyone that oppose the group and so does Rick now hell they all do including Maggie who I am 100% sure wishes Shane was there perhaps to stop Negan from bashing in GLEN HEAD!
@@dalelapointe9289 That’s because Shane never left the barn. You can’t say he didn’t get people killed when he hardly did anything except get into arguments with people. Rick was actually out doing things for the group
TEAM RICK!
I hate Rick he killed hes best friend
He had no choice shane was out of control
TEAM SHANE FOREVER
Team Shane for life
Team Rick! Shane is too overrated
👎
@@Johnwick-yo6hk Rick owns Shane. Cry about it.
@@TheRealRickGrimes 👎
@@Xhanatos 🧂
Team Shane
Team shane
Team shane
Team shane
Team Shane
Team Shane
Team shane
Team shane